Nawaz Sharif, Imran Khan, 9th May, TTP and Afghan Refugees - Syed Muzammil Shah -
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 พ.ค. 2024
- Anchor, Journalist and Thinker, Syed Muzammil Shah, comes back on The Pakistan Experience to discuss the return of Nawaz Sharif and what it means for politics in Pakistan, on this episode we discuss Muzammil's experience at Bol TV, the Pressures on Mainstream Journalists, Imran Riaz Khan, 9th May, PTI's Miscalculation, the future of PML-N, Civilian Supremacy, PTM, Afghan Refugees, TTP and Syed Muzammil Shah answers all your questions.
• Nawaz Sharif, Imran Kh...
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
1:00 Experience at BOL TV and Pressures of Mainstream Media
5:30 Thoughts on PTI people now going against PTI
8:00 The Economy of Journalism and TH-camrs supporting Political Parties
17:00 How bad is the censorship and political repression
20:00 9th May and PTI’s miscalculation
30:00 PTI is Pakistan Tehreek e Imran
35:00 IPP, PPP and Nawaz Sharif
40:00 I can never vote for PML-N
43:00 Anwar Kakkar and Caretaker Set up
45:00 Has Nawaz Sharif been selected?
50:00 Decline of Civilian Supremacy from 2017
57:00 Economic Degradation and Civil War
59:00 Intersectionality, PTM, Baloch and TTP
1:11:00 Afghan Regugees and Afghan History
1:23:40 is TTP back in the North of Pakistan?
1:28:50 Audience Questions - บันเทิง
My STRENGTH upon these ULMA is to be here in PAKISTAN. I will never LEAVE my country PAKISTAN. In-shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! Excellent & Logical Analysis. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! TRUTH Lovers ko SALAM ! ! !
Thank you sir
@@ThePakistanExperience ₩
The best soul I have found on social media. May he be safe from the wrath of the state and extremists.
🙌
I am afghan living in the states. Came from Pakistan when I was 4. Love Pakistani people. Gov everywhere is corrupt but people are great. Peace
Good to know masood,, thanks for such words.. Only Being abroad we can understand how things are reall.
corruption is every where but not as much propaganda floted every where about corruption that is too high so u believe in it...u prove it or stop barking
We love each other as a human as a Pakistani as cultural as neibours
I know you are not afghan you are punjabi...
@@user-nh6wn3ln8hbelieve people if they tell the truth. He lived in Pakistan for a long time so naturally he can speak Pakistani languages.
First time in my life I have seen two pakistani having a fair and sensible talk....👏👏
Best wishes to everyone watching. On a side note; if I get abducted after this, the onus is on Shehzad. 😅
At least one random Indian will remember you if that happens 😅
Saath uthaye jaye gai 😅😅
Thank you, Muzammil, for offering a fresh perspective on the Afghan situation. Your insights have significantly altered my view, and I am now reevaluating my stance on the removal of Afghans from Pakistan. I appreciate your enlightening discussion on this matter.
@@Babasasa111 ghoo kha le
@@amankharb2401there are many 😁
I may not agree with muzzamil on some issues but I love to listen to him always….he’s achieved so much at such a young age. He’s one of those few rare journalists who have great intellect and are well read
Absolutely true.He is an inspiration to the whole of South Asia
Syed is really good. All the Best to him.
This guy is amazing ❤
Love from India 🇮🇳
bhai lay jao isko
Sayed Muzammal sahib tuhanu salam 🙏 from Punjab India 🇮🇳
Muzzammil is intellectual. I am Indian live in California always listen him
Muzzamil is the GOAT. Only Pakistani guy i agree with on almost everything.
Absolutely Loved the PC. Again 2 favourites. I just binge watched it 🧡
❤
You don't have any idea shehzad how desperate I was for this one, gonna watch it over and over again.
❤
Same. Gotta say i may have skipped through most of the last 2
Bhai itni mushkil baat tuo nahi kr rahay k bar bar dekh na hai
Muzzamil and Sandeep Dwivedi is among the best journalist of our time.
If you watch the early interviews of the people in swat and other agencies their stance was totally in favour of Taliban and against military operations but once the military operations started the local people faced use of force by army for info against Taliban
This is also true that those locals who were affiliated with government in any case faced problems and difficulties from Taliban
Thank u Syed Muzamil.....your admirer from India
Finally , 👑 Arrived.
He kill with LOGIC.....my fav quote from him is 'agar mulk ka mazhab hoga to phir firka bhi hoga'
🙌
He's trying his own political party probably funded by ISI. The bottom line is Paindoo army has been ruling this country for over 50 years. No PM can do anything without ISI's approval. . Courts and media is shit scared of Army etc etc. The system is corrupt blah blah but we want Imran Khan as a face of Pakistan. In other words Pakistan's brand ambassador can't be unparh paindoo PM' period.
What is firka ? 🤔
@@whysoserious5594 It's like casts and stuff in Hinduism but not official in islam, created by third parties.
ohk same as castes like they were also created not official now i get it thx .
Muzammil is a Gem of a Mind.
🙌
Best podcast after a while ❤🎉.
Long live Muzammil.. I enjoy his talks so much. Corruption is mainstay of Indian subcontinent. Genes to sabka ek hai.
In india we have NOTA option None of the Above" (or NOTA) has been provided as an option to the voters of India in most elections since 2009.
No need to ell about our things.There could be any ISI agent s
@@apurvabhide2860😂
Qaiser raja's currently planning to cut an out of context clip and then review on it😂
lmfao that right wing ka kutta always has something to bark about 😂😂
Bilkul sahi kaha😂, wo bnda bhooj kar dosron ko ghalat light me hmesha paish krne ki Koshish krta hai😂
Great podcast
Was waiting for it🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
🙌🙌
Thanks for inviting This man.
Finally finally wait is over now my both mentors sitting and I'm just listening both of you ❤
🙌❤❤❤
Thank you so much, Shehzad. This was much needed. Can listen to you guys for hours.
🙌❤
Lovely presentation of views and information by both, the host and the guest, kudos👍
🙌
What a shameful history we have - with Afghanistan- it’s heartbreaking to see little kids being thrown out of Pakistan right now -
while tens of milions are below poverty line in sindh and uonjab and TTP murders punjabi muslims, you heart bleeds for afghans. shameless animals you aghans after Pakistan helped you
Never clicked faster on a video. The conversations from these two some of the most enjoyable podcasts on all of TH-cam.
muzammil chootia hay... who listens to this fool
@@ThePakistanExperienceThankfully your audio is good on this episode.
Syed bhai is always so logical. Ye banda transcends borders. Very logical always
🙌
Very well cited. Thanks for sharing your log & thoughts
I can listen to muzamil for my whole life
So sad that a man so well read has little to none knowledge on Dalits in India or even about the varna system in Hindu dharma. Which is totally fine but then why make statements on things you don’t know… lost respect and actually sad about it
pakistani hai wo. jahil koom hai.ya tumari problem hai. jo tum pakistani se umid kar raha ho.
They are leftist in nature so hate Modi. But Modi is a socialist's dream. He has given free rations to poor, subsidized cylinders, focused on girl education, promoted cleanliness and toilets, health insurance.
The biggest innovation UPI is still free and there no merchant fees either
It's ok to admire someone who doesn't understand our system. Agree to disagree. And that is how we are different from them. 75 years has created that difference. They can't fully understand how complex India is.
Shezad's reply to "And he pulled out" was epic 👍😂
😅
You both are critically thinkers ❤
The best line for me in this podcast was "بولنے سے پہلے پڑھیں"
My all time favorite Muzmal, I advise my students to listen to him..
🙌
Sounds like double agents to me.
ادھر بھی اور اودھر بھی۔
Their job is not to confront but dilute PTI.
Oo 😂😂😂
@@user-du5gn9ng6mPti wali tab hi har gayi thi Jab wo foj ka kutta bani thi
@2:06:30 this is what we need in this country on a very big level i.e learn to live with conflict. sirf samnay walay ko tabey kerney ka thekka nai lein. have reasons to agree or disagree then at least you'd be proud of ur decisions.
Yes, I still watch Doctor Israr for different topics
One of my favourite:) can’t wait to meet him in person
Dont understand why isnt this channel getting the love n likes it deserves
Same :(
Because its always about two patwaris hating IK
koi bataye ga state=?
that salary thing is 100% true, I personally know, a close relative who faces this salary issue, 2-3 months is a normal thing and no card, so tough time for them.
Can you share the timestamp of this part?
This is a huge problem across the media
The prospective Sayeed gives is actually eye opening. This type of podcasts really raise the quality of discussion in society.❤
❤
Credit to the host as well, the flow to closing the discussion is great
@@MHussain-es2qd 🙌
Agreed
Sir now you are speaking very factually and truthfully I like you and hope you will continue to speak the truth like this you will go far.
Syed Muzammil Shah Thanks for Amazing information
Like Rohit Sharma said at the toss that, “Gill is Back” , and there was a loud roar. Similarly here I would like to say, “ Legend is back”.
🙌
Muzammil Shah and Shehzad Ghias- only wish there were more voices like you .
Regardless of your opinions you are very well read on history , pakistan politics and its people.
Thoroughly enjoyed your discussions and looking forward for many more . Love from India ❤
❤❤❤
One of the finest v logs .. Classy content and excellent questions and answers ... Just excellent
🙌
He gets a dimple when he smiles, he probably fears unwanted attention from all over the world which in turn may trivialize his meaningful discussions....I.guess.😊
Two living Legends ❤❤
❤❤
HA HA HA. What type of low-cost junkie do you use?
You both are my favourite young intellectuals of Pakistan. I always go through the programs of both of you.
All the best bro.
🙌
Me too from India watching 😊
What a great journalist. Very informative. Great journalist.
Another amazing podcast. Listening to this as a nervous Indian fan before the final!
🙌
Rohit Sharma nay aatay hee nerves settle kardiye aap kay. Two fours against Hazlewood!
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢@@ThePakistanExperience
Itne acche insaan bhi h Pakistan m😮?
Syedd muzamil sir is gem 💎
❤
Your analysis is correct. Conversations can be held with people from around the world, but there is still one question: What is the solution? These discussions are conducted by high school graduates at a tea stall daily.
Solutions are hard sir
Confusion hi confusion hai
Solution kuch pata nahin
Solution jo mila to saala
Question kya tha pata nahin
Shehzad Ghias. very solid work! You are doing some very important work and putting the right narrative.
🙌
Don’t know the anchor but I am really impressed with his maturity
I am so excited to make this comment Shehzad. I am coming to Pakistan to attend the SDPI conference in Islamabad. Tickets are done. Bas visa mil jaye ab. Do tell me some recommendations for me to see around in Islamabad. And sorry for the completely unrelated comment on your video. I had no other way of communicating to a Pakistani person. Super excited !!!!
Welcome ❤❤❤
We have that none of above option during elections in India called NOTA,there is debate going on in SC that all candidates should be suspended for 8 years if NOTA gets more votes🥲
Punjabis are fundamentally religious minded , thats why they backed every religious entity around Pakistan.
Nahi bhai both of you are very ❤CUTE❤
I must say cuteness is no only shakal, it is the art of conversation which attracts and convince the listener.
Versatile Intellectual person who seamlessly combines philosophy, history, and having a strong command on current affairs. Sir Muzammil profound insights span across centuries with a sharp understanding. Such illuminating discussions that bridge the past and present offering unique perspectives on our politics.
THANK YOU For the GEM Shehzad Sir ❤
❤
Imagine lot of people from India waits for his videos.I am his hardcore follower from India
Shehzad iam enjoying your talk shows. Being a south indian i don't understand urdu but still understanding to some extent. I ask, you and Mr. Shah to add english subtitles for your videos, so that people like me can understand Pakistan better.
why the hell is a south Indian concerned with Pakistan? Go back to your business
Because Pakistan is our entertainment
India ko to smj liya na tune??
@@harsha9128then we can also say why the hell should a North Indian care about India…Pakistan is our padosi mulk hai bai we should care about what is happening in our neighbours..now let me go back to my business bro.
@@jithinpoliyedathmohanan7237 North Indians cannot help expose their inanity. Hats off to your patience in responding to this northie troll
I am from india ...After nistish rajput I love him so much
Very interesting discussions...
❤from 🇮🇳
Legend is back 😢
@@ThePakistanExperience 🙏
It’s great thought provoking discourse content wise up to the mark - Syed Muzzamal Shah - widely read the greats likes Nietzsche - one can see and feel from his approach/ views - a hard and long struggle to teach at this level -that too at such a young age -he is already way ahead from majority of the so called pseudo intellectuals who we can’t tolerate even to listen to for short while -- hope he ll keep it up - and the Pakistani Experience ll keep inviting such great/ beautiful minds in future too- gratitude and appreciation --!!
❤❤
Very informative and true analysis. Thank you Muzammil sab 🙏
🙌
Imran is better than others.... Insha Allah he will come back and will not repeat his mistakes.
There must be 1 podcast in a week between you two. Please ❤❤
❤❤
Something like TalkShock
true
+1
🏏🏏❤️🏏🏏❤️🏏🏏
These two have more chemistry than me and my wife ever had …..
😂
😅
🤣
😂
Please could you also do a detailed video on Pakistan's relationship with it's western neighbor Afghanistan from pre Soviet era to 9/11 to current day deportations. Is it possible to get two guests one pro and one anti deportations...or maybe viewpoint of an Afghani-now Pakistani national? My great grandparents were from Afghanistan n while I understand deportation of illegal people in any country my heart feels uneasy n upset looking at women n children especially going to a wartorn country which limits life n opportunities for women. A video on this would do great to educate us all and hopefully dispel unnecessary hatreds. Thank u.
Watching and listening your conversation from abroad. Very interesting. 🙏🙏
🙌
Was waiting for this for a long time !! love from India 😊😊
❤
Wonderful ❤❤
❤❤
Best leader for Pakistan is Prime Minister Imran Khan he is HONEST RELIABLE LOYAL and cares for the poor people of Pakistan
I like this new style of conversation wow 👌 👏 what ever you guys do, Alhumdullah Allah is with those who are honest, and now whole world knows who is honest.
Ap ktni bhe camouflage kar k critics kar lo but notting will happen.
2:05:31 No Qaiser Raja was hurt during this video 😂
😂😂😂
@@saleha.99 😂
Shehzad this is so freaking timely. Syed Muzammil has outdone himself with well researched points and analysis, as per always. Your insights are always helpful. The hypocrisy of so-called Islamic nations is so stark; it is unable to look away from them. I remember being part of a meeting where a major Gulf nation was crying foul for "Muslim lives" in a certain nation where conflict brew between the nation and armed groups. An American counterpart leaned over and said, "those groups couldn't afford to commit atrocities without this Gulf nation's funding". The West knows (actually anyone who can read and comprehend knows) what is what. That is why the selective outrage and activism the world over falls on deaf ears. Well done both of you.
❤
God bless Great Khan
The greatest leader in Pakistan history
It is always soo nice to listen you and muzamil love uh brooo.. Very nice conversation ❤😂
❤
The real voice of reason in the whole of South Asia. Sir Muzzamil is the living legend 🎉
🙌
Pagal Pandit.. He is average
@@Rabindra_who is great then ? Arnab ? Or sudharshan news ?
@@bharatkapoor4062 Tufail Chaturvedi
Very informative.Keep it up.
The GOAT (GREATEST OF ALL TIME) 🐐 IS BACK! 🇵🇰
Absolutely true 💯
🙌
Perfect Podcast.....U both deserve Respect....❤❤❤
❤❤
I can listen muzamil for hours and hours
The two most beautiful and intelligent people in pakistan...God bless you both and protect you from evil eyes❤️
❤
Mera manna ye hai ke
Imran khan ko atleast 5 saal de dena chahiye the
Uske baad public khud decide kerti apne vote se
Dalits are not safe under Modi's India 😢.....who himself is OBC guy.... means other backward cast😂..... it's really joke.....btw I liked muzammil's stance for afgani refusees❤....I saw some pictures of these refusee going back today..... visuals are really disturbing 😢....I hope remaining people will be treated with humanity 😊
Rone do bechare ko hmesa ye hi mindset hai isliye ye hal hai aj 😂
Sab accha hai mgr Modi ko bolo to galat 😂😂 waha
@@jyoti_goswaamiaap ki mindset wahi hone wali hai jo government ki saari baat mano cahe manipur jaale
@@Hararyoukoz3106As Syed said to read and do unbiased analysis and not just to media news, can you do the same for Modi.
India was 10th largest economy in 2014 and now its 5th largest, so something must be happening right
@@Hararyoukoz3106not at all 😂...you are taking it wrong bro😊...I admit that media is more biased under Modi government therefore Manipur issue did not get enough coverage in media.... which is absolutely wrong 😢....but if you are saying that a guy who himself has lived a life like dalit in his childhood and is an OBC guy suppresses dalits....then it's obviously wrong 😮
I think these podcasters should do complete research before making any statement 😊
And for your kind information my whole family votes Congress in elections just becoz in our Rajasthan there is not a proper cm face from BJP party but it doesn't mean that Modi is not a good pm.... India's growth in past years reflexes everything 😅
So nice to watch and listen your smart guest.
پوری قوم اپنے کپتان کے ساتھ کھڑی ہے اب اس دور کو بھول جاؤ جو ماضی میں ہوا اب انشاللہ پاکستانی قوم ووٹ کی طاقت کے ساتھ اپنے ملک کی تقدیر بدلیں گے
Patwari ism is thriving in every field. And the boss approve it. That is why we have this mess.
My two most favourite commentators, you guys are slayin it! Need more collabs like this from you two!
❤❤❤
Very iNFormative Programe +
Best AnaLysis
Muzammal represent educated honest pakistan youth that is y he is loved in india alot well done
Bro dropped the hardest podcast with Syed Muzzamil and thought we wouldn't notice
🙌❤
The guy's name is in defence of savarkar I guess our Gandhi boi didnot notice..
You guys rock with your intellect, comprehension & knowledge. Surprisingly for us, moderates in a land of neo mullahs and zealots. Keep going!
🙌
People of Pakistan please stand firm with your greatest leader PRIME MINISTER IMRAN KHAN, because he is an HONEST MAN
Why this podcasts' voice is low bhai