Bo Allan needs to be one of those picks , his speed from stoppage, defensive game is exactly what Stkilda needs. Little bit iffy by foot on occasions but his run with the ball creates opportunities inside 50 .
If we trade our picks 7, 8, and a future first for picks 2, 15, and 16, I’d love to see us grab Draper for speed, Hynes as our big-bodied midfielder, and Shanahan (a Saints supporter)
STOP THE REID NARRATIVE TO STK! Murphy Reid = Hunter Clark They play exactly the same (even down to the head band) Hunter was a better prospect at the same age, given he's a bigger body & a better kick. We don't need 2 of them! Lindsay & Hotton/Travaglia (given Lalor, Tauru etc gone)
FKN PREACH BRO!!! I"m sick and tired of us being linked to Murphy Reid... it's the biggest giveaway that these "experts" don't know a single thing about our midfield makeup and biggest needs. Thank god Dylan put that first guy in his place! Reid and Armstrong with our top 10 picks?!??? Is he high?!?!?
Watch out for Lindsey at one of those’s picks ? If they don’t? We at Richmond could get him at 10 or 11 he would be one of about 5 players looked at in those’s selections. From what hear Lindsey is be looked at to go early than most expect ? And St Kilda , Melbourne and Richmond are fans! A lot Clubs are Fans in the teens but he may not get past pick 15 ? The good thing is there are a lot of good players around that mark in different positions so Clubs would be hoping Lindsay may get through to them ? But St Kilda will be thinking than can get before others at those’s selections ?
Any inside info on St Kilda’s interest in drafting a key fwd at 8? Almost every Saints fan I know, me included, would prefer to take 2 mids at 7 & 8. Think Reid and Travaglia suits our needs better
@@superclasico8757 na no inside info! I’m definitely in the two mids camp also. My preference would be pace at one of those picks, that’s why I think saints will either split to go up or down, If it’s up they’d look at FOS and if it’s down I think Hotton
You lost me at “Max King drops the ball and then offers nothing”. What a load of bollocks. King has kicked as many goals from ground balls as marks. He’s elite at second efforts below his knees.
@@Chuckakhan Rowell and Anderson were better kicks to forwards at under 16 level than Seb Ross, Crouch and Steele ever were. Ben also had Levi beside him as a foil - Max at best had Membrey who’s a high HF
If saints need that speed, game breaking midfield. Should do 7+8 (3200) for roos 2 and f2 (~3200). Can get their man and would put roos in a great position to get Tauru and Armstrong
If I was St kilda, I would like the recruiters to trade pick 7 and one of their lower picks for pick 6. This should get Smilie done and then we still have pick 8 and their lower pick that they can use for a ruck. so 2 Mids and 1 Ruck. Would this make sense Dylan?
Saints will be trying to trade 8 and F1 for pick 2, or 8 for 15 and 16. Maybe they're trying to get both of those deals done using both 7, 8 and F1. I'd love to see us pick up FOS or Lalor, Lindsay and a KPF/Ruck.
I'm not sure if Hotton would like to go to St.kilda since they delisted his brother. I know they don't get a choice where they go but blood is thicker than water. I think they are in awkward spot. Do you know how many senior/rookie spots they have now they have delisted Crouch and going to rookie him? I'm assuming they will upgrade Sharman at least to a senior spot.
You're looking at academy picks the wrong way. St kilda have pick 32 for example. Lombard, Kako, Ashcroft, are all getting early bids ok, whatever picks the Matching teams use, Brisbane, Gold Coast, Essendon, that are in FRONT of Pick 32, so 25, 28, 30 for example, those picks are used up, so St Kildas Pick 32 could actually move UP by the time they take that Pick. The same for any Pick later in the draft. 4 academy picks before Pick 32, essentially makes that Pick 36, then subtract the draft picks used up BEFORE Pick 36 for academy bids. That's the real Number of your draft pick.
I would love it if Saints managed to trade 8 and F1 for pick 2. Then we bid on Levi at 2, Leo at 8 and Kako at 9. Forces a high price for all and brings our picks in as much as possible!
@scottdoncon9647 dude, I honestly think that us the best scenario. I'd be happy if the saints gave up pick 8 AND a future first for pick 2, even the saints and North trade future firsts and the saints give up 7 and 8, and if they can wrangle a later first round of this year's draft in a trade, then go for it.
if I was the saints I would trade that 7 and 8 up for 2, then trade a future first into this year for one of Richmond's 10 or 11, don't worry about next year's draft, they could pick up a draper at 2 and a shanahan or another tall forward at that 10 or 11. I think Gerreyn might be someone who is a bolter into the first round
Murphy reid and Harry Armstrong dont seem suitable. Need a midfielder that spreads and can get the ball to the outside players wingers/Half backs/Half Forwards. Saints also need a player that can win clean clearances and break the lines; think Dustin Martin type midfielder (Strike Mid) Saints also need small forwards as a priority and a mature aged ruck. Also need Key Position Defenders but the NGAs in Cole and Hoffman will cover this and i would expect to be drafted at picks after 32. Saints first 3 picks should be best available but ideally best available would be 2 midfielders and 1 small forward. ,4th pick to be a mature aged ruck. with 5th and 6th picks used on NGA Players in Cole and Hoffman. Saints will still have 2 available list spots by that point to be used at the rookie draft.
The saints have a ton of speed the problem is it's the wingers and Half forwards and half backs that have the speed. The problem is the current midfield can't get the ball to them.
I get from the outset it seems this way but here are St Kilda’s 24 and under players (that I rate): - Max King - Michito - Wanganeen-Milera - Liam Henry - Phillipou - Darcy Wilson Here are Essendons: - Martin - Durham - Caddy
@@HarryLiptak I suspect Saints have reset to eventually move forward. Hopefully the management has patience, but some of the leaders dont have the best reputations.
@dylan id like to hear you speak more about the saints it seems you have something in mind that wasnt detailed out in this video.
Bo Allan needs to be one of those picks , his speed from stoppage, defensive game is exactly what Stkilda needs. Little bit iffy by foot on occasions but his run with the ball creates opportunities inside 50 .
I like him too. I’m always nervous to pick an interstate player.
@
I’m definitely the same , I guess there is Toby Travaglia but I reckon he’s more of a halfback than midfield. Glad I’m not making the decision.
Nice one, Saints need to reverse the misses of the 2017 draft
@@BigGameFish loved their drafting in recent years!
If we trade our picks 7, 8, and a future first for picks 2, 15, and 16, I’d love to see us grab Draper for speed, Hynes as our big-bodied midfielder, and Shanahan (a Saints supporter)
@@G-tw4wp that is a quintessential Norf deal, this draft is strong because of the depth not because of any one pick.
STOP THE REID NARRATIVE TO STK!
Murphy Reid = Hunter Clark
They play exactly the same (even down to the head band) Hunter was a better prospect at the same age, given he's a bigger body & a better kick. We don't need 2 of them!
Lindsay & Hotton/Travaglia (given Lalor, Tauru etc gone)
@Delroy-z1g Exactly. Please St Kilda, do not draft another Half- Back, we NEED centre bounce midfielders.
FKN PREACH BRO!!! I"m sick and tired of us being linked to Murphy Reid... it's the biggest giveaway that these "experts" don't know a single thing about our midfield makeup and biggest needs. Thank god Dylan put that first guy in his place! Reid and Armstrong with our top 10 picks?!??? Is he high?!?!?
@@Delroy-z1g nahhhhhh Murphy Reid to shit kilda it is know
AMEN! AVOID REID LIKE THE PLAGUE. GIVES ME PTSD FOR CLARK
Watch out for Lindsey at one of those’s picks ? If they don’t? We at Richmond could get him at 10 or 11 he would be one of about 5 players looked at in those’s selections. From what hear Lindsey is be looked at to go early than most expect ? And St Kilda , Melbourne and Richmond are fans! A lot Clubs are Fans in the teens but he may not get past pick 15 ? The good thing is there are a lot of good players around that mark in different positions so Clubs would be hoping Lindsay may get through to them ? But St Kilda will be thinking than can get before others at those’s selections ?
Lindsay is a decent one. I just can’t seperate him and Hotton. Hotton is probably better but comes in with a bad knee injury.
Any inside info on St Kilda’s interest in drafting a key fwd at 8? Almost every Saints fan I know, me included, would prefer to take 2 mids at 7 & 8. Think Reid and Travaglia suits our needs better
@@superclasico8757 na no inside info! I’m definitely in the two mids camp also. My preference would be pace at one of those picks, that’s why I think saints will either split to go up or down, If it’s up they’d look at FOS and if it’s down I think Hotton
You lost me at “Max King drops the ball and then offers nothing”. What a load of bollocks. King has kicked as many goals from ground balls as marks. He’s elite at second efforts below his knees.
@@mattswannie6651 that why his twin has kicked more goals than him?
@@Chuckakhan Ben’s always had an elite midfield in front of him lacing him out. Max has had B Grade plonkers who can barely hit the side of a barn
@ except he hasn’t. He was drafted 2018 when Witt’s and Miller were there, then they got Rowell and Anderson who took a couple years to develop.
@@Chuckakhan Rowell and Anderson were better kicks to forwards at under 16 level than Seb Ross, Crouch and Steele ever were. Ben also had Levi beside him as a foil - Max at best had Membrey who’s a high HF
If saints need that speed, game breaking midfield. Should do 7+8 (3200) for roos 2 and f2 (~3200). Can get their man and would put roos in a great position to get Tauru and Armstrong
If I was St kilda, I would like the recruiters to trade pick 7 and one of their lower picks for pick 6. This should get Smilie done and then we still have pick 8 and their lower pick that they can use for a ruck. so 2 Mids and 1 Ruck. Would this make sense Dylan?
Saints might look at Lachlan Blakiston at pick 32. A mature aged ruckman that Geelong were looking into as well.
I think they should look at splitting pick 8 with Richmond.
If Tauru is there they will take him and one of Smillie/reid/lindsey or Travaglia otherwise will go for 2 of the mids
Saints will be trying to trade 8 and F1 for pick 2, or 8 for 15 and 16. Maybe they're trying to get both of those deals done using both 7, 8 and F1. I'd love to see us pick up FOS or Lalor, Lindsay and a KPF/Ruck.
I'm not sure if Hotton would like to go to St.kilda since they delisted his brother. I know they don't get a choice where they go but blood is thicker than water. I think they are in awkward spot. Do you know how many senior/rookie spots they have now they have delisted Crouch and going to rookie him? I'm assuming they will upgrade Sharman at least to a senior spot.
@@bluedogbluey6742 yeah but that’s a very dangerous game to play. I also think 7 and 8 are too high to take Hotton
Saints have 8 open list spots. That is assuming Crouch is picked in the rookie draft
@@StMaanco thank you. It’s be interesting to see what happens.
You're looking at academy picks the wrong way. St kilda have pick 32 for example. Lombard, Kako, Ashcroft, are all getting early bids ok, whatever picks the Matching teams use, Brisbane, Gold Coast, Essendon, that are in FRONT of Pick 32, so 25, 28, 30 for example, those picks are used up, so St Kildas Pick 32 could actually move UP by the time they take that Pick. The same for any Pick later in the draft. 4 academy picks before Pick 32, essentially makes that Pick 36, then subtract the draft picks used up BEFORE Pick 36 for academy bids. That's the real Number of your draft pick.
Thankyou. Pick 32 remains at 32 And 47 comes in to pick 41 ish
I would love it if Saints managed to trade 8 and F1 for pick 2. Then we bid on Levi at 2, Leo at 8 and Kako at 9. Forces a high price for all and brings our picks in as much as possible!
@scottdoncon9647 dude, I honestly think that us the best scenario. I'd be happy if the saints gave up pick 8 AND a future first for pick 2, even the saints and North trade future firsts and the saints give up 7 and 8, and if they can wrangle a later first round of this year's draft in a trade, then go for it.
if I was the saints I would trade that 7 and 8 up for 2, then trade a future first into this year for one of Richmond's 10 or 11, don't worry about next year's draft, they could pick up a draper at 2 and a shanahan or another tall forward at that 10 or 11. I think Gerreyn might be someone who is a bolter into the first round
@@anappropriatehandle yeah I like it! Weirdly I think 7 and 8 are bit in no man’s land for their needs.
No chance that trade comes off.
@DylanAlexanderFollowsDraft yeah the moving back wouldn't hurt them much, also a lot of talls they could pick at later, like 32
@@Chuckakhan but if it does they are laughing
@anappropriatehandle agree!
Murphy reid and Harry Armstrong dont seem suitable.
Need a midfielder that spreads and can get the ball to the outside players wingers/Half backs/Half Forwards.
Saints also need a player that can win clean clearances and break the lines; think Dustin Martin type midfielder (Strike Mid)
Saints also need small forwards as a priority and a mature aged ruck.
Also need Key Position Defenders but the NGAs in Cole and Hoffman will cover this and i would expect to be drafted at picks after 32.
Saints first 3 picks should be best available but ideally best available would be 2 midfielders and 1 small forward. ,4th pick to be a mature aged ruck. with 5th and 6th picks used on NGA Players in Cole and Hoffman.
Saints will still have 2 available list spots by that point to be used at the rookie draft.
The saints have a ton of speed the problem is it's the wingers and Half forwards and half backs that have the speed.
The problem is the current midfield can't get the ball to them.
Saints seem to be treading water. They remind me of Essendon. The question is whether they've wisely moved backward and in the rebuilding phase.
I get from the outset it seems this way but here are St Kilda’s 24 and under players (that I rate):
- Max King
- Michito
- Wanganeen-Milera
- Liam Henry
- Phillipou
- Darcy Wilson
Here are Essendons:
- Martin
- Durham
- Caddy
@@HarryLiptak I suspect Saints have reset to eventually move forward. Hopefully the management has patience, but some of the leaders dont have the best reputations.
Just pick the best available
1st rule in drafting
You do not address need in the draft. Draftees are there for twelve plus years - not two!
Not with Ross in the coaches box