Magic5 Pro Vs Galaxy S23 Ultra Vs iPhone 14 Pro Camera Comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 มิ.ย. 2024
- HONOR Magic5 Pro Vs Galaxy S23 Ultra Vs iPhone 14 Pro Camera Comparison. See my full Magic 5 Pro review here: • HONOR Magic5 Pro Revie... S23U review: • I Dumped My iPhone 14 ...
00:00 - Front cameras 4k30
01:13 - Rear main cameras 4k30
02:05 - Ultrawide caemras 4k30
03:04 - Zoom cameras
03:47 - Main cameras 4k60 video
04:24 - Low light video 4k30]
05:39 - Stills, selfies, portrait, zoom, ultrawide and low light
12:19 - Recap with my findings - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![[TH] VCT Masters Shanghai Playoffs DAY 5 // 100T vs PRX | FUT vs TH](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/q75pv359eP4/mqdefault.jpg)
See my full Magic 5 Pro review here: th-cam.com/video/8wv9Fu7Hfy4/w-d-xo.html S23U review: th-cam.com/video/mbfcTmKqMso/w-d-xo.html
00:00 - Front cameras 4k30
01:13 - Rear main cameras 4k30
02:05 - Ultrawide caemras 4k30
03:04 - Zoom cameras
03:47 - Main cameras 4k60 video
04:24 - Low light video 4k30]
05:39 - Stills, selfies, portrait, zoom, ultrawide and low light
12:19 - Recap with my findings
Hi, saw some other reviews mentioning that the Honor Magic 5 pro can't record 4k video using the ultrawide, is it true?
It actually yes
It can record 4k but only at 30 fps not 60
In my opinion, apart from the video stabilization and microphone quaality, the Magic 5 Pro was the clear winner in this comparison. Good job honor 👍
lol blind fanboy
LOL
Stabilization is very necessary
What are you talking about? The mic and stabilizer works wonders on Magic. I wanted to ask what is going on with the iphone's mic???
obviously, the magic 5 pro has much more advanced hardware, bigger sensors, better tele etc.
honor gets the color right most of the time, better than the other two.
I personally thought most of the Honor ones were better.
Hopefully the next couple of updates will put that right.
@honor
Sorry. That was me agreeing buddy.
Enjoy mate.
Its surprisingly good performance from Honor. Being able to put up a good fight for the camera which they are not really well known for
The undisputed king of comparisons
Thank you for this great comparison ❤
Thanks for watching!!!
Better accurate colors and realistic natural shots from the Magic Pro.
Details are also better. Sound is ok.
As for the Samsung and iPhone from your shots here the S23 Ultra overall pulls ahead. That was fun.
Another excellent comparison. Agreed with you here.
The S23U does pull ahead in videography for having better mic outputs, zoom etc whereas quality itself is still better on the iPhone but not by huge margin.
For photography, I straight up preferred the Magic 5 Pro in most instances.
Thx a lot m8!
I like those darker night shots from the Honor, the other two are too bright to my mind, they are kinda unrealistic.
Honor did very well in this comparison.
And the portrait shot of your daughter is kinda
green on the S23 Ultra to my mind.
Here indoors the S23 Ultra fails when I try to catch my two boys (2,5 and 5 years old) running around, they are totally blurred.
Honor M5P did a good job against these 2 giants expensive phones! The camera quality nothing felt really far behind. Being the cheapest here, quite a bargain for those looking for an excellent Android camera phone if can't afford the S23U.
How on earth is 1100-1200 euros for the Honor a bargain?? S23U is 1200 euro, but it has better cameras, much better software features, a longer and faster software support, and a stylus.
@@s-plus wake up fanboy. Samdung just gets an extra year of updates at the moment and possibly faster updates. Samdung doesn't have a REAL 3D face unlock like Honor, WAY slower charging, Honor cameras are better than what Samsung offers except perhaps selfies. Samsung has a worse display in the S23U versus the Honor, the S23 series has a worse design (in my opinion), I'm sure Honor's design is more premium as well, for less than £1000 . The same price as the BASE S23, which let's be honest, doesn't come close to the Honor Magic5 Pro.
@@s-plus hi, & I'm talking regarding the camera capabilities. Of course I think the overall package Samsung would be better for most people. And you referring to Europe's pricing. In Malaysia M5p 12+512gb is priced at less than 900 euro & S23U 512gb is more than 1200 euro (after conversion) & still need to fork more money for fast charger 😬. My wife is using S23U now & I already pre-ordered M5P as I think the overall package suits me better.
@@s-plus depends where you buy. S23u is either £1400-£1200. H5P is £950-£850. The H5P isn't the outright winner. but cost/quality it's a good deal.
H5P will probably be my next phone.
@@LordAngelus Samdung what are you 5 sad kunt
Wow. All those comparison made me realise how lazy apple has gotten 😅
Good job honor 👍
I know, right? 😅
Apple has been lazy for several iterations. It's been awhile since they had the best cameras. So many years that I don't remember when.
@@sflxn the best for video. I have a note 20 ultra and used iphone 12 pro and iphone 13 pro as the iphone 14 plus and all are way worst as photos quality , details and night mode. Only the videos are better without discussing it.
Apple not lazy but its already perfect
Great comparison as always. It really seems like Honor has made one of the only phones on the market that can truly compete at the top end across the board with apple and Samsung on cameras without any obvious shortcomings. Actually seeing 4K on a front camera from a Chinese manufacturer is a major result to start with. Love the way the low light shots retain detail but aren't artificially exposed. This was the camera system Oppo and Xiaomi should have made. If only Honor could refine magic OS so its on par visually and functionality wise with the likes of ColourOS and miui.
You're saying magic os is even worse than MIUI? No way... This phone is £950+ in the UK right now what a joke
@@ulysses4989 nah i said miui and colour OS have more features and look better visually. Optimization and performance is another matter. Honor pricing for their flag ship is high but still cheaper compared to their competition, like s23 ultra, iphone 14 pro max, Xiaomi 13 pro, Oppo x6 pro all over a £1000.
This time xiaomi 14 😂
Honor Magic 5 Pro is the allround winner for me
😂
The Ultra is the all around winner. It was as professional quality as you can get in a phone. The iPhone while good did not fare that well against the Magic
Honor video Stabilization= bad, honor photo night= bad, and the daytime photos are all the same.
@@orlandoBcrpStabilisation looks good to me on the Honor
Night mode? 😂😂
It's been years since I've watched any camera comparison videos as in depth as this, and I have to say, I'm impressed at how good all of these are, although there is obviously still room for improvement
Always room for improvement. Thanks for watching!!!
Photo/video on a smartphone is always going to be a compromise across different media. Again, I think the S23 Ultra does the best job overall. But I don't see, still, any pressing need to upgrade my 3 year old S20+. Smartphones have seen camera improvements, in terms of image and video quality, plateau in recent years, even though they trumpet new hardware.
Watching from my S23Ultra and feeling so much proud 😅
Proud ? 😂😂😂😂 proud on what? Are you Samsung CEO? Weww
@amarmacanovic proud because he paid 1200$+ on the right phone
@@Amamm888 about his choice to buy s23 ultra
How is the S23 Ultra? Are you happy with it?I have the A73 5g.
The same feels here!
Thanks for the comprehensive info I am looking for a successor and I was thinking about 14Max, Magic 5 Pro and Magic wins.
wow the magic5 pro is beast, the only not so good area is that it does not have that 10x optical zoom... aside from that, its amazing and will be swapping my s23 ultra for it.
The best flagship offering all rounder for that price.
and not good selfie camera also..
@@dzonib9595 It's good enough!
So after watching so many comparisons here till this date I can clearly assume.
Xiaomi - Day Photography
Oppo X6 Pro - Night Photography
Samsung S23Ultra - Videography + Zoom
Honor - Bit of meh in each category.
The struggle is real.
Thanks for the 📸 comparison. A Q though: Does the s23U has the last frw update in this one?!
Yes it does. April update the "camera update" all phones have the latest firmware always before I start a camera comparison.
Hello sir I need some help 1 year back u tell the robo vacuum cleaner I need side breshes any buy link please
You gotta be my fav TH-camr great footage and comparison
Thanks Chris Second comparison video from you I watched today. Honor won my appreciation. Magic 5 pro did a really good job (just night video aren't so good) . The colors in each image looked very beautiful to my eyes.
Thanks for sharing
But its still more expensive than an iphone. At least in Germany
Die Video- Tonqualität ist sehr schlecht beim Honor Magic 5Pro.. Gibt es eine Möglichkeit die Rauschunterdrückung/Windfilter in der Kameraeinstellung zu deaktivieren ? Grüße 👍😉
It's all personal in the end... we all know that. However moving personal aside and taking the unit price in consideration! - Honor is a very good phone. You get most of what other phones offer for quite a bit less and it ain't a joke, considering that Magic comes with 12 ROM and 500 GB of internal storage! and a very capable battery as well. Big YES to Honor!!!
Great video most of reviewers are scared to tell that S23U video os better than iPhone
I really love a camera to have natural colours and in that aspect the Honor 5 pro wins.
Samsung really improved video a lot
Sure has!
@@Techtablets SO IN TERMSN OF VIDEO QUALITY IS THE S23 ULTRA BEHIND THE IPHONE 14 PRO MAX OR IS IT EVEN BEHIND THE IPHONE 13 PRO MAX I AM TALKING JUST ABOUT THE PICTURE QUALITY NOT STABILIZATION AND AUDIO.
S23U has better ultrawide video (EIS) than the iPhone 14 Pro and 13 Pro. Main video the iphone is very detailed and 4k60 is still it's strength. However! The S23U audio is far superior to all the iphones and its zoom camera.
@@Techtablets no my question was what ever you said does it even apply to iPhone 13 pro Max meaning is the 13 still better then s23u at 4k 60 picture quality from rear camera
@@debojitmandal8670 The IPhone 14PM video quality deserves better hardware. It has been surpassed in flexibility and efficiency by the S23 Ultra. Apple can't live in the past like many of it's devotees, and must set new standards with the 15PM. The whining has to stop now. Let's pull ahead again.
*Huawei/Honor actually has a great imaging pipeline.* They just need to focus on the video aspect. Apple's low light videos are the best but Samsung takes the crown in rest of areas.
Woow.!!
M5P not far behind actually and some scnario still looks better, what a GREAT REVIEW and deserve two thumbs up.!!
Keep it up mate.!❤🎉👍👍
Hey, thanks for the video, great stuff. It would be really interesting to see the comparison of the photo raw files - what can you get out of each system if you are really trying to squeeze it out to the max. Do you think this is what people would find worth watching? Have a good day.
I don't think so and the issue is people will think I edited one better than the other etc. I cast a vote twitter.com/TechTabletscom/status/1645017614719041536 recently and 5% of people use RAW.
Dude, thanks for that great effort you put in. Very helpful and detailed Video. Considered switching from iPhone 13 Pro to Honor. But maybe Samsung? Big phones..
Glad I could help!
Hi, I have an S23 Ultra, but on mine, the video portrait mode has notable worst stabilization than the auto video mode. Is it happens also to your S23 Ultra? Thank you!
Yes as it seems portrait video at 4k doesn't use stabilization or very little of it.
Very Honest review thanks, i agree with your choices based on the image quality etc.
Thanks for watching!
S23ULTRA do have April updates?
What a difference a clean lens makes!!! It allows us to have an unbiased conclusion of the S23u being the best among the 3, however the Magic 5 is also very good.
Congratulations my friend, I don't miss your videos... and if I could make you a request I'd like to see the S23u with Oppo and Magic together, or maybe Vivo instead of Magic, even to do justice to a comparison with clean lenses and not hasty conclusions, because there was a comparison that unfortunately happened... but I want to make it clear that you are one of the best and most impartial and I am with you here in Brazil, following everything and recommending your channel.
Hug!
Thanks for your support. I'll see these videos take 2-3 days to make so if it gets good views and there is the demand I'll do it. But my last two camera comparisons don't have much interest in them.
Chris, I've recently ordered the Honor, however, I've recently come across a S23U for about 200€ more, would you take the S23U for that price difference? I still can cancel the Honor order
If this y plan to shit a lot of video yes the S23 Ultra us worth it.
great video again. Thanks a lot.
You're the best, man. Keep it up.
Thanks, will do!
To my eye Honor look the best thanks for the review
Thanks for watching.
Thanks bro. U talk real things about phones ❤
S23 ultra is a legit beast after April update
What has changed?
@@Julian-Willemsen nothing 😂
@@nunosantos2015 isheep🎉
I'm currently using the magic 5 pro from s23 ultra. Night mode doesn't seem to work. It's so dark. But every single picture has so much better details n less noise than the s23 ultra.
Your review is the only one where I like the honor 😅
Your daughter is adorable 😊
Since the night mode of thr honor isn't good. How about sunsets? I don't shoot night pictures at all but a lot of sunsets which is really important for me. My huawei p20 takes good sunset shots. Nice warm colours 😊
Esperaba más del honor, en su presentación alardearon demasiado sobre sus capacidades en fotos y videos pero parece ser lo mismo de siempre quedandose detrás en varios apartados, sin ser lo que prometia
I bought the Magic 5 PRO and the photo quality has blown me away. For video, iPhone is better, but for photos, I like more the images from Honor.
Hi sir which one will u say take the best still pictures?Is Goggle Pixel the best?
Pixel 7, Mate 50 Pro and Vivo X 90 Pro+ my top 3 for now, not in this order.
@@Techtablets thank you sir, meaning there isn't a best of the best for still picture. I don't really care about videos, I am surprised Samsung S23 or Oppo Find X6 pro isn't in your list. Phone is very expensive from where I come from, so for me to invest in one I am looking for the best. If you are like me, and you can only pick one for the best picture quality which will you purchase sir. I am sorry to trouble you.
When do we get the oneplus 11 review? BTW great reviews as always
My unit bricked so I sent it back.
@@Techtablets 😯😯 haha
It is very simple to see which has the best camera, go to 8:17 and read on the warning board in the upper right corner. The rest is subjective and it's up to the software. In this case the winner is the cheapest
S23 ultra is goated for the front camera, didn't expect it
in the photo of the cat 6:50, is really focused? is so bad the s23u with the animals hair?
I tapped the same point on all 3, my cats nose. The shutter was slow...
The Samsung S23 Ultra video is basically a small micro-step behind of the iPhone, while the Honor is a few steps behind. For HDR, Honor has a good handle on it while Samsung and Apple, as usual, overdo the HDR.
My Rankings for overall this video:
1. Samsung S23 Ultra ( by the slimest of margins)
2. Honor(video is somewhat weak)
3.Apple iPhone 14pro max( not a bad overall camera, just that most Androids have caught up with it)
Thks for your videos 👏
Overall, I prefer the Magic5 pro and that's the one I'm gonna get 😅😁🤪
Good choice!
I dont get why s23 ultra is exposing video that much, that's the one thing iPhone for me got right. But from what Ive seen you can still get iPhones more contrasty and more real exposed image with a pro mode. Otherwise it seems like noisy mess in low light that you can clearly see on 14 inch display, let alone 55 inch 4K TVs
great!! review❤
Thanks for watching
Thanks for your video. Just bought the honor. I got the honor pad 8 tablet for free. I paid 840 Euro. Best price. I love the dual mode video in honor. Best feature.
Amazing price with the the Honor Pad 8 included!
how is it now
@@omarsalim9562very good. I am happy 😊
To be fair I expect Honor to be much worst than those 2 buuut , I was surprised.
For me personally still 1. iPhone 14 Pro 2. Galaxy S23 Ultra and 3. Honor Magic 5 Pro for the camera comparison.
I really don't like how Samsung making their own colors in almost every picture, Samsung night photo looks like it's not night outside but it's sunset time, too much light that ruin the atmosphere , but I need to agree that video and sound quality in Galaxy it's really good, zoom is nice but I don't understand who need that zoom and for what, anyway the quality after zooming it's bad . But overall I think iPhone is more universal, you get amazing video quality, good pictures quality , natural colors .
Now, about Honor, if on the pictures quality he can easy compete and in some scenarios smesh those 2 , in video no chance, for the video, Honor is 1 step behind , video sound, stabilisation, white balance, ( 15min 4k, no 8k( I don't need it but still, it's better to have it)) .
But, iPhone is already more than half year on sale, S23 Ultra 2 months , they get a lot of updates with soft and camera improvements , they fixed the main problems and overall they show their maximum level, while Honor isn't still available for pre-orders in almost all countries and I think their engineers working hard to improve the software and camera quality. I think if we gonna do the same comparison somewhere in July 23 , Honor would show even better results, because that sensor have a lot of potential , but looks like now soft it's still a little bit raw .
Anyway, overall for the price/quality Honor Magic 5 Pro is one of the best on the market right now , I'm waiting for 19 April to pre-order it and after 4 awesome years with my amazing 1+7Pro , I'll finally change it . Thank you for the video!
Honor is doing very well, it needs to work on video, because there (for me) iPhone is the best. If we talk about photography, more or less everyone is on par, but Honor does a very good job
Vuelvo a opinar que en cámaras premium donde se dirime la batalla es en las situaciones complicadas ya que en buenas condiciones las diferencias son mínimas. Las cámaras delanteras ninguna es gran cosa, para variar, aunque quizá Apple ahí se porte mejor. En las traseras sigo pensando que está un punto por encima el honor. Y más teniendo en cuenta que por lo que he leído ni siquiera es su software definitivo. Así que entiendo que irá mejorado.
Keep doing Your work 💪
Thank you, I will if these videos do okay more will follow.
Great video!!
Thanks!
I really like the video and photo quality of honor magic 5 pro,, stunning and very adorable compare to this 23u and 14pm, almost half of the price
The S23 sound quality is just unreal. The competition isn't even close.
Yes the mics and overall quality is just so good.
Actually when you listen with some decent equipment, you can hear that its completely processed and frequency response is off with some strong peeks in the treable (I would say 7.5 khz where naturally should be a dip, listening with Etymotic ER2SE). Picks up the voice really nicely but its enough to listen to his voice in the video and compare to the sound from the phones, iPhone is maby correct and more realistic sounding although doesn't really adjust to the situation... Quite impressive from samsung yes
@@lukabosnjak3829 I've read that it records sound at up to 900 kbps... is it not so?
WoW. This is definitely the best comparison I've seen so far for these phones. I was tired of biased youtubers.
Thanks 👍
I have the s23 ultra and the iPhone 14 PM, the ultra camera very often produces awful unrealistic photos .
Samsung is another level❤
Video audio yes defiantly!
@@Techtablets Do you think Google Pixel 7 Pro is better in photos and videos?
Samsung ha fatto un ottimo lavoro in tutti gli scenari,nel controluce al sole ha un maggiore controllo del sole,anche con la u Wide si comporta bene,con i 4k a 60 FPS sulla bicicletta è il più stabile,sul mare ha la stessa tonalità colore di iPhone,al buio è dove mostra rumore.. Ps senza brand ottiche Zaiss,Leica , Hasselblad ecc .bella comparazione 👍🏻
Good job to Honor! They made cameras on par with the other giant phone companies.
They did a fantastic job.
S23 mic is at another level. Wow.
What is a judder?
It is very noticable now that Samsung uses AI to "enhance" their photos, especially in the night shots. Those "details" are generated, the image looks exactly like a noisy, blurry mess which was thrown into an AI upscaler. Very unnatural, it's just bad.
Such a stupid comment. Every company uses AI for nightmode. Would you rather it look like a blotchy barely recognizable mess that the iPhone produced? You can barely discern anything in the photo.
IPhone wins in ultra low light video by a decent bit. Samsung really improved their low light conditions video as well which is nice to see. But once the light really drops to poor conditions, iPhone looks decently sharp, with less noise. Day light video I love the honors contrast, exposure smoothness and color, really pop. Samsung has amazing stabilization, zoom, great overall system. Only weakness bring really really low light
Samsung has certainly improved it's low light video, but it needs to take a leaf out of the IPhone's book and simply not try too hard to brighten things too much in very low light resulting in noisier video. This isn't Samsung's way though at the moment. Very impressed with the S23 Ultra's video overall I must say. It now makes a more flexible videography device than the IPhone. And let's not forget it is a new device awaiting software improvements that will surely follow.
@@neilmcguinness4422 very true!
call me old fashioned but the best way to take pictures at night is when you turn on the flash lol my pictures come out better than night mode. but that's just me
Honor 5 for the win really, some better quality pictures and when you compare the price of these 3 phones
Again apple proved that more than enough detail of video and photos aren't the thing.. what you want is a beautiful and close to natural images and videos .. and in low light conditions apples do a fantastic job .. also the image stabilisation is very high..
Great comparison magic is not far in terms of the quality..😊
Very true! Not far off at all.
I'm samsung user, after see this video.. I must admit that the honor more better and i will try to have one. Thanks for make this comparisson video ❤
Glad to help.
Just amazed how Samsung remove sun reflection in main camera video best camera amazed by Samsung ❤
Congratulations for the video. S23 ultra in the video part in some moments it seems to go jerky and it's better iphone. In photography they are equivalent.
Yes it does 4k60 iPhone had it with video quality but then the EIS with the S23U was smoother than the iPhone 14 Pro.
@@Techtablets Samsung lover
How can you ride a bike and film at the same time? U got some talent XD
I have an S21 Ultra and I can't decide which of these three to replace it with. Years of Huawei ownership have left me disappointed with the Samsung's camera over the last 2 years, but with no GMS or 5G the P60 Pro isn't an option.
Magic 5 Pro then is your phone!
magic 5 pro actually records good audio when no wind. i like the wide angle selfie of magic 5 pro.
Yes and it has a very good wide angel camera one of the best around!
in dxo mark samsung is way behind but looking at this video shows that samsung is way ahead ... they probably dont pay dxomark any money
You should make the comparison with the Google Pixel 7 Pro or Pixel 6Pro
Sure I'll just go buy them.
@@Techtablets😂
Next video may be honor vs oppo as highest ranked phones in dx0mark. What do you think? Thank you!
Here you go just for you: th-cam.com/video/fspzM6Y3iUM/w-d-xo.html
I love the sound in the Samsung Galaxy s23 ultra is very clear
Well done S23 Ultra..all balancing foto & video..relax eye to see
Finally someone spotted oversharpened pictures on yt 📸
Wow 5 Pro is a Awsom
Is there any android phone capable of shooting 4K 60FPS without getting judder when panning?
I liked the daylight photo on honor
Yes good colors and quality.
According to DXOMARK (an independent professional smartphones, cameras & lens evaluation & testing company) to-date Huawei P60 Pro has the best camera performance, slightly higher rating than iPhone 15 Pro Max & Samsung S23 Ultra.
Huawei latest release Mate 60 Pro+ is yet to be evaluated & tested. If evaluated & tested, probably the camera quality is at least equal or better than their earlier released P60 Pro.
Even I own the S23U I wont fanboy it~ The chinese phone do really come on par
camera wise slight better, but on video stability not really~ Iphone still the best on stabilization~
But Im ok with my phone~ Just a small complaint on charging speed~
S23U is like a Jack of all-treat phone~ Good display currently nothing can topped it, camera not top tier but consider quite good, good video quality, audio is great but not as loud as ROG phone, good battery life (whoever use previous samsung wil know how shet the battery is), and the 90% in the socket S-Pen (It useful when I need to sign my E-Doc).
So it my pick of this year. So kudos for other company too, keep making great phone and whack on Samsung~ I want Sammy to fear and get something better next year if not they will start slacking when they think their current is the best~ Thanks
Yes Samsung needs that competition to push them more!
@RuWen Zhang of course...
Honor.👍👌
Why is it like it cyan on samsung the bright sky in almost all review iv watched its always that color😅 nice review now i don't know what to get but ill pass on samsung and apple..maybe other phone i want to be different😂
Yes I hate the cyan or purple sky as they just over do it with the night modes. I prefer what Oppo, Huawei and Honor do leaving the sky black!
Wow the magic 5 pro is a mess on video. The microphone sounds terrible, dark video not good and stabilization is poor. I had high hopes for Honor. Was surprised how well the Samsung performed overall.
Why does the Honor's microphone start to sound like you're drowning, when you start zooming in?
Because it applies audio zoom
@TechTablets Well that would be cool if it could tell where a bluetooth microphone attached to it would be, but other than that, does it really make sense?
I hoped that the Honor brand would give better results for the night shoot.
La vidéo avec caméra avant du magic 5 pro prouve une stabilité complète,
I wish a better mic on the iphone... voice sound so bad on iphone...
Samsung S23U is the perfect smartphone of decades
Is AI disabled during the test?
Yes it was.