Judge frustrated with family attorney in 'Take Care of Maya' trial
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ต.ค. 2023
- Judge Hunter Carroll expressed his frustration with the family attorney for the Kowalskis in the 'Take Care of Maya' trial on Wednesday.
More: www.fox13news.com/news/take-c...
FOX 13 Tampa Bay brings you the important videos like breaking news, Tampa Bay weather, and local stories. But also plenty of fun stuff, like 'We Live Here' tips, the best of our archives, and all those 'only-in-Florida' stories.
Subscribe to FOX 13 News: th-cam.com/users/FOX13TampaBay...
Watch more FOX 13 News video: fox13news.com/
Watch FOX 13 News live: fox13news.com/live
Download our app: fox13news.onelink.me/Sd7G?pid...
Get our newsletter: www.fox13news.com/email
![[ไฮไลต์] ฟุตบอลชาย ฝรั่งเศส vs อเมริกา รอบแบ่งกลุ่ม | โอลิมปิก 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oZ9aSS0NEEg/mqdefault.jpg)
Had they not made the documentary I doubt it would have ever gone to trial. This whole case trying to be delayed and looked over is disgusting in itself
The documentary had zero effect on this case getting to trial. It takes years for a normal civil case to reach a jury, let alone one as complex as this.
I agree 💯
Nope, this trial was planned for September 2023 before the special released. Its common for cases to take years
@@rescuedogtrailrides6352well you’re wrong so
Incorrect. It stated at the end of the doco when the trial date was set for.
The documentary however did bring a lot more eyes onto this case in terms of the general public. Disgusting behaviour by the system. And also very common all around the world. Glad the family got some justice
The doctors at the hospital mocking Beata's death as well as mocking Maya's condition was one of the most unprofessional and disgusting things I've ever witnessed from health "professionals". They don't care about the families, the patients, the pain, the sleepless nights. All they care about is the money they get from insurance and going on their little vacations. May this life and the next become their worst nightmare.
it's something I have noticed with medical staff everywhere in the world. they deal on a daily basis with a lot, not to mention that some are working extreme overtime hours, and they reach to a point where they simply are desensitized. Patients are objects to them. Unfortunately, this sort of treatment was given to my poor grandma... there are very few doctors and nurses who don't lose their human touch so to speak
As a doctor I was also as disgusted, as you. I treat every patient with the care I would expect mine to receive.
@Rosispergia My grandmother's passing was also a result of the hospital staff's negligence. Though becoming desensitized is common in such work environments where death is almost a daily occurrence, that's no reason to mock or consider a human being under your care to be of no importance, much less when such human's life depends on your duty as either a nurse of doctor. I've met/know people who have been (and still are) exposed to human death on an almost "normal" basis (doctor and military), and yet their empathy is intact. Not once do they speak of the ill nor the dead as if their life wasn't worth saving.
@@myrkvdr well said I treat each Patient as I would expect my loved ones to be treated most Drs I know think the same
@@myrkvdr I know many doctors as I come from a family where all my siblings are doctors and it is very common to hear nurses and doctors and consultants not really care for their patients. It feels like a conveyer belt at certain hospitals as well, patient in and then out and then the next one. This isn't an excuse but this doesn't happen out of thin air, these people in these positions are given too much work and sure they are paid for it but it kills their empathy and kindness, not all of them but there is quite a few in every hospital.
When he left maya dry from sharing the letter she wrote in the Netflix film… BROKE MY HEART. He is so heartless
In that incident the judge appeared to be taking direct orders from his masters (the ultra wealthy’s attorneys). The Johns Hopkins lawyers was talking to the judge as if he was his boss & the judge immediately put his head down, toed the line & followed orders from his master. And the sad part, when Johns Hopkins appeals this settlement, there’s going to be hordes of judges eager to help Johns Hopkins scr3w this family even more than they already have. In the end, the family will only receive a tiny fraction of what the jury awarded.
With these huge settlements it happens every single freakin’ time with the ultra wealthy and their bootlick!ng cronies wearing robes (aka “judges”). Always undermining the jury’s decision to protect the most vile, disgusting rich people in America.
@@mikeappleget482 Agreed. Its like what else do these Judges doing? The way people wait for a hearing to start then zip thru cases. Do they even work at least 4hrs a day. I doubt they work anything over 6.
@mikeappleget482 man that's so bloody sad I have no idea how the American justice system works 😢 I'm sure for every cent given they would absolutely give it all up to have their mother back
The judge has shown several times his bias in favor of John's Hopkins Children's Hospital.
Maybe they should move the case to another jurisdiction due to conflict of interest
This isn't a bias. John Hopkins' attorneys are ENTITLED to know these things. This is dirty tactics and can result in a mistrial and/or sanctions if a judge thinks it's getting to be too much. As much as I want the Kowalskis to win, the judge has every right to be mad and tell the attorney off here.
@@teemyoutube2066actually they aren’t entitled. He has a witness list and they are to assume he can call anyone on that list at any time but doesn’t have to call any of them. They aren’t entitled to know more than that
@@teemyoutube2066yes - this is a bunch of gold diggers. Extremely unethical plaintiffs counsel. They have to rely on tricks to try to win.
Well even the judge couldn't stop justice being served in this case, thankfully.
This judge needs to get off the bench. It's clearly obvious he's in the pockets of the hospital.
Why don’t you show the clips of the judge getting frustrated with the defense attorney who tried to keep relevant evidence from the jury and exclude a qualified witness?
Because $$$$ hello?
The treatment of this family is disgusting and vile.
Start protecting itself
Yeah I agree this is really shocking to say the very least.
It’s not just the lawyer. Judge Carol is the judge that made the decision over 5 years ago to delay the case.
the judge is definitely paid by the John Hopkins hospital pray the Jury’s are honest
Say it ain't so
@@democracysdoomsday7905 I saw the court hearing 5 years ago and it was the same one. I will try and find it.
Judge Carroll was not involved in this case 5 years ago….at all.
@@MamaBear0417yes he was he’s on the Netflix show
What a drama queen of a judge!
They’ve all been dealing with each other for years, I think patience is wearing thin lol
I can't stand that judge. Just the fact he doesn't shaves off those tiny bits of hair in the middle of his head screams mid life crisis. No matter how many cases are coming down the pike ,the Present case shouldn't have to cut corners and leave things out. It's that whole treating people like cattle. I'm so happy she won
Yes of course the judge needs a shave
I couldn’t stop staring at his hair.
@@notbroku9528 ...........Yeah, he needs to go ahead and shave it off. no use in holding on to it.
The hair completely dismisses him professionally. He needs a toupee.
JHC didn’t believe her but the hospital still billed the Insurance Company with her disease!!
How do you think our Godless 5 billion in fruad fines medical system became a leader in fruad and iatrogenic death? (see: the Johns Hopkins [low-ball] iatrogenic study claiming "medicine" only kills 250,000 annually or only 684.9 a day!) Don't you know, "Death is the wages of sin, vs the gift of God is everlasting life through Jesus Christ our lord."?
Corruption in the medical field isn't new.
Yes! Over 500k worth of bills!
@MIAreturned How many people who can think, would agree with you & JHACH?
This is crazy. The hospital has so much power and so many political connections and probably board members that are so rich that they could buy anything and they’re torturing this family. When does it end. What they did was wrong…what they did was disgusting and they did it to so many other families too. Shame on them, I hope karma comes around sooner than later.
🙏 Amen
Just finished the documentary and it killed me,they deserve every single penny of that $220 million PLUS...
Same and 100% Agree!! 👏🏾
You guys didn't show the GOOD STUFF!😂 Maya's attorney called a witness that PROVED SHE WAS TREATED LIKE A PRISIONER AT JOHN HOPKINS! DAMN!
The hospital is quilty as sin!
The judge was a lot angrier with the defence lawyers the next day when they tried to squash Dr. Corcoran’s testimony.
Amazing how the system works against good people.
This judge needs to clean up . Looks like a drunk for days and just rolled out of bed 🤔 …
That is very unkind. He is doing a good job of administering a fair trial. Very hard work.
I feel like shaving that island of hair... Is that illegal?🤔
@kevinhornbuckle um he is the one who tried to keep it out of court all these years and dismissed maya and her family over and over. He is bought by the system, he is awful
@kevinhornbuckle I believe he's being fair and impartial also!
Agreed. He treats this whole case like he's doing amateur night at the comedy club. Telling jokes. Trying to tell jokes. Failing hard at telling jokes. This isn't funny, it's a damn shame!!
I'm so glad they made a documentary and Beata was so brave! I stand behind this family and the other families that's been wrongly accused and poor children snatched out of their mom and dads God given right to parent!
This judge needs sleep. Clearly he is mentally unstable.
Coming back from the whole trial
I’m highly concern with the attitude and the professionalism of this judge
Well its really frustrating to see the victim getting victimize by justice system
this judge is mad at them everyday and has been from the jump to be fair
I hate this judge too!! He delayed the trial..
As trial now over, it's interesting to compare the judge's response to JHACH knowingly giving false testimony and not turning over related docs on their license and accreditation review (occurred during last few days of trial). And it was an accident that it came out. It appeared this was one of many discovery violations, and very serious as it was definitely withheld on purpose. Yet, judge didn't hold lawyers or JHACH in contempt, much less raise voice at them.
That poor mom and her child, what they went through and poor Maya losing her mom thanks to the cruel kidnapping of the child. So horrible. Massive wrongdoing of the authorities in taking that poor child. Maya deserved better from the hospital and social worker. She lost her mom that she loved all because of a horrific power struggle of an insane worker...
Bring back street justice 🪓
Bc the judge is bought by the hospital
Yes the judge is not for this case ….
The judge is so biased!!!! When will someone treat this family with compassion? They did nothing wrong yet the court and hospital treat the remaining members of the family like criminals
This judge was chosen by the hospital
This is another injustice to the Kowalski family! This is not helping their mental/emotional health and not helping the case!!! Shame on their lawyer! I SUPPORT MAYA KOWALSKI
I stand with you on this. I can't believe the amount of boot lickers backing these giant corporations who would do the same exact thing to them.
@@jhodson10 Maya was a faker and is currently a liar.
Sorry but you don’t “fake” that level of severe chronic pain. Where’s your evidence?? Are you a licensed doctor??Clearly you have never experienced a disability like this (and I hope you never do bc it’s not fun)I’d also like to add that now just because Maya is now walking this does NOT mean that the disability ever goes away it’s managed with treatment (which I might add was diagnosed by a doctor)Many times even after finally finding a plan that works you will still have flare ups & bad days and though we learn to deal with our symptoms becoming very good at seeming “ok” the struggle with our pain is still there. This is something that you will NEVER understand till you experience it yourself and trust me it takes its toll never mind on top of everything Maya physically experienced there was the severe emotional distress that she went through being taken away from her family & as a result losing her mother.
@@shannondominguez9725 I agree 💯 how could a ten year old possibly hold her feet in that long keeping them positioned and why would a ten year old tell her uncle Bob to help her out of the pool, leaving all the other kids..defense is off their rocker
@@sherryscarabino255 Yes!! There is absolutely zero logic in what the defense is trying to push through its beyond ridiculous!! With the way her feet were contorted there’s no way Maya would’ve been able to get in/out of the pool by herself without screaming in pain never mind actually swimming. My heart broke listening to this sweetheart cry out begging for someone to take away her pain there was several times where I was in that same situation wanting my mom to help me & she couldn’t even though I know if she could have she would have done anything to ease it. Our diagnosis are different but I understand & what truly made me see red is the “doctors” telling a little girl that HER feelings/pain weren’t real that she was a liar,instead of listening to her & Beata they tried convincing her that her mom was a horrible person and that everything she was experiencing with her body was all in her head,which I too have personally been told by a therapist(and even a close family member who I love dearly)who bc of his fancy doctorate degree felt he knew better than me & what I live with every day;I get it but personally nobody will know it better than the one living in the body that doesn’t cooperate so it really ticks me off when there’s these keyboard warriors over here hiding behind a screen who haven’t a CLUE about what it’s actually like living with a chronic illness come be in my shoes for awhile you’ll get humbled REAL quick.😅🫶
So let me get this straight...
The family's attorney isn't telling John's Hopkins attorneys all the information they're ENTITLED to hear/see???
Kind of like how Maya's parents were NOT given all the information they DESERVED to receive while Maya was in their care?
Hmmmmmm....
I truly hope Maya & her family win!
❤️🙏🏻❤️
PS- yes, I know that counsel is supposed to communicate with each other. I just find it ironic. Maybe JHACH will understand juhhhhhhhst a tiny bit of what Maya's parents were going through, not knowing important information.
Great point!! 👍👍👍
When has he NOT been frustrated over this trial?
I hope he gets it together does the right thing.
This whole thing has been tragic in so many ways.
Let's hope that people and those that work in the medical profession will learn about RSD/CRPS and not just beginning stages but what it can present like years and years on.
hes been fantastic actually
i'm sorry but this case is SO sus
Well maybe the hospital are getting back a bit of their own!! They never informed the parents what they were doing with their child.
And the parents didn't care to ask?
Yes there are multiple recorded calls of the parents asking. @@rhondennis979
@@rhondennis979you obviously haven't watched this trial. Go back to the beginning, then come back and return to the conversation.
@@rhondennis979this ain’t a serious question right?
Some people aren't interested in facts.
That judges hair though😶
I hope they get every penny. Poor baby
Hope dr Smith will lose her license
I hope John Hopkins pays out the nose to this family! Dr sally smiith and Cathy should pay personally for what they did to this family and all the others!
Does this judge not have access to a shower and a razor? He looks like he was out partying at the midnight hour when the attorney was receiving documents! This is not even stylish grunge or Covid isolation reaction--just sheer laziness! Does he have on sweat pants or pajamas under his robe?
You all criticizing the appearance of the judge is so lame. When the trial day ends, do you think he is the bar lounge? His work is not done at the end of a trial day. He has lots to do behind the scenes at the end of the day to prepare for the next day and take care of things that may have come up. He probably spends hours reading stuff that he has to decide on before it goes in front of court and jury. Stop being so judgemental about his appearance. He is not there to look beautiful for you. How many of you tell your children not to judge by appearance at school? Jeez be adults...
No judge what’s wrong is her mother is dead and she was taken away over their screw up
Has anyone ever thought that no one wanted this case it’s taken 5 years to get here JHC has at least 5 attorneys in court not counting the ones behind the scenes against 2 this not about money but yes they do have leans against them from the insurance company and hospitals so if they get money good for them hospitals have to take responsibility for who they hire and be held accountable for their actions just like any other BIG BUSINESS which is all a hospital is
2 months until she is 18 and social services has no say in her medical treatment......
I don't think that is driving this. Her mother was taken away from her. Beatas' death is a result of the whole ordeal. They're trying to get justice for her mom
@@kennedy4257 THAT IS NOT THE POINT...try thinking....i read there is an injunction and she can't get the treatment...until she is 18....its just another part of the story of the ONGOING ABUSE she is being subjected to by the system...so it is relevant...
@@kennedy4257 The hospital killed her?
@OmEvul1415 they tortured the whole family on some nit wit's strange assessment of Maya. Grooming that child is what she did! The hospital was hoping to traffick Maya into foster care or state custody of some kind. Sally Smith had sick and nefarious intentions with Maya. It's amazing what you learn when you actually watch the whole trial and not some quick bit.
I am with you Maya,this disgusting hospital put this family through all sorts of emotional hell and are still continuing to do so, My heart breaks for Maya and her family.
I feel they need a new judge. He seems shady
And we are so tired of you Judge baldy!
50 THOUSAND FREAKING PAGES?!? Omg that’s insane. I don’t even know how to review that many pages.
1:35 if the judge is tired of attorney abuse, then grow a pair of balls and punish the attorneys who are obviously abusing the process and get them disbarred.
This judge seems
like he is not well . I feel he is a 'functional drinker ' /personal issues.
🙏🤞Justice for Maya
Why would you make an accusation defaming this judge?
They didn't "defame" him. They voiced their opinion, and thoughts on the judges behavior. They didn't say "he IS a drinker", they said "I FEEL he's a functional drinker..".
The defense has been reckless in objecting to facts and appears to know the hospital staff was OCD and zealous about abuse that did not exist. The jury gets it. The defense lost the jury days ago.
Justice for Maya ❤
They should put people in jail and they should get the money
That judge should be disbarred..."not telling the other side information ".... uhmm he's doing exactly what the hospital did. Criticizing one narrative that matches the narrative of what they ultimately were fighting to expose.....man oh man the united states is like an adolescent child that needs guidance to learn how to grow up in so many areas...smh
Don’t bitch about it, fine them or warn them if it continues it will be considered as contempt of court and jail them.
This pissy judge needs to be replaced. 🤷♂
They need to push this case above this court and bring it to a court that will actually do something
Did he say he’s tired of them not telling the OTHER side information ????? What a clown.
I don't like her attorney's techniques. He keeps doing things he knows he isn't allowed to, saying things he has been directly told not to say, and not giving information as they are required by law to do. He comes off as disorganized and trying to pull something on the court. It almost feels like he is trying to get a mistrial (which he may well be since they tried to get SA added to the allegations but the trial had already started). This moment by the judge came after many warnings to them. He is frustrated, and rightly so, by their insistence in doing things they are not allowed to do. He is only hurting his client.
Shouldn't the "prosecution" already have all the information? oh wait... Civil ...but took the child away from the mother? wth!
So the judge is mad at the attorney of the family where the professionals messed up in every way possible. He proves that the professionals are any thing but professional
I think they need total transparency on both sides !
This judge seems to be paid well
Who else noticed the Alienware gaming laptop and thought someone was playing some video games 😂
Well, this didn't age well...as Judge leaves the courtroom to avoid an angry outburst at Hunter, the most BSing of all lawyers.
Another reason why I'll never live in Florida......xD
People need to go to jail for this not just paying money.
How did they pick this lawyer? He seems ill prepared to handle a case like this.
Agreed. First time I heard him in court, I was surprised at how sort of bumbling and mumbling he came across. It also appears sometimes that he doesn't understand the rules of evidence. I'm not sure if it's just an act that he thinks will get the jury on his side (being the good-old-guy and trying not to appear too slick) or if he's actually not an experienced litigator.
Be patient and keep watching- he’s not as ill prepared as we think. The way he asks questions is often not a matter of getting the witness to answer it, but to get the JURY to answer it for themselves … he gets to rephrase (re-ask) important questions after multiple objections, and the jury begins to formulate their own conclusions. It’s kind of like the Pink Panther approach Lol. Stumbling on to the truth by “accident” and leaving a mess in his wake. The defense is aware but can’t do anything else but continue to object. I hope we’ll see his true measure when the defense puts on their case. Fingers crossed for Maya and her family.
@@deaniemack
Yes, the wolf knows exactly how to pull his con.
He knows exactly what he is doing and to hell with the judge.
I thought that at the very beginning, but not so anymore. He is very sharp, knows exactly what he is doing and with Mr. Whitney by his side is doing great. Look how he crushed the defence this week. Granted the defence is coming up and next week will be harder but the only thing the defence can do is try and poke holes in the truth.
I saw their documentary on netflix, and it was the most sad documentary I ever seen. Mainly their mother who couldn't take the pain of being away from her baby and took her own life😔😞
he is heartless and almost hairless
I feel this lawyer was not prepared she needs a better lawyer
Horrible judge!
This judge belongs in jail.
I wonder what would happen if we paid a Government run agency for our health care insurance rates and had them retain and regulate care in our interest. These For-Profit "health care" companies would disappear over night and we would do much better. Same with drugs, don't release them to private companies and their private rich families after we've paid for all the research.
As a medical specialist myself, I am so ashamed of people like this with zero comprehension, understanding, compassion, empathy and above all, medical KNOWLEDGE to do the right thing. She needs to be DISBARRED from ever practising medicine , in my option. Also that awful social worker, Bede. Evil monsters the pair of them. JHACH is incomprehensibly evil.
I don’t even wanna hear how the judge feels, the family has suffered far longer, and will continue to suffer from the loss of wife/mother. And it angers me that he did not allow Maya to read her statement because of the other judge that John Hopkins all hospital, didn’t think it was appropriate. This whole story is sick and sad and it’s happening to families all around there needs to be a stop to it.
So many reasons for a mistrial so many reasons
Some judges have really short fuse, they know they can throw their temper because no one is above them in the court room. Everyone has to tip toe around them. See this type of power trip in Psychiatrists at Psych wards too. Its an abuse of their power.
Apparently, also in the hospitals too.
Are you saying he has a short fuse? That has not been what I've seen. He has, in fact, been tolerant , professional, and even tempered. Not sure we are watching same trial.
But I need to highlight the professionalism of the judge , when he came back after his time off and you could not imagine he was this angry before .
@@AdvocacyZonelol where u get that from 😂
@@Shynestarlight2013 Just look at him classic alcoholic look.
This should be open and closed....F that judge
Because Plaintiff is dragging this out due to the nonsensical behaviour of Plaintiff's lawyers
Oh my, British spelling. See you down the pub mate. Jokes aside, the case is more full of poo than a septic tank. Munchausen by proxy - period. Crazy Mom offs herself.
Each side has an allotted amount of time to present their case in chief and cross X. This case is as complex as any you’ll ever see tried, primarily due to the chapter 39 protections interwoven through the whole fact set.
The plaintiff? The judge dragged this out for 5 years! Plaintiff hasn’t even used their allotted time yet
the judge sadly has lost control of this courtroom. The jurors are biased as daddy is sitting there smiling and showboating w the jury. THey also had a doc on netflix that was very biased. AND there is no way this is not a biased jury. THIS is showboating plain and simple. He needs to set thejury straight about there bullying witnesses etc.
The mafia got caught
Bias judge
Kowalski's counsel has basically cheated by slipping in exhibits the court had already forbidden and not letting defense counsel know about their evidence until it was too late for them to even review it. In my 40 years as a lawyer this guy was about the sleaziest and unethical that I've seen.
You also think the family are just “gold diggers” so it’s seems you are jaded and have a chip on your shoulder to me.
🙄please.
What’s up with the tiny patch of hair on the judges head 😆
The Kowalski lawsuit went to trial in late September 2023. Jack Kowalski - on behalf of himself, Maya, Kyle, and the estate of Beata - sued Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital for $220 million: $55 million in compensatory damages and $165 million in punitive damages. On November 9, 2023, after two days of deliberations, a six-person jury found in favor of the Kowalski family, awarding $261 million in total compensatory and punitive damages.
This judge is the worst he’s extremely bias! And if you notice he sides with the hospital and stretches out time! Instead of solutions
Um the judge was much more frustrated with defence attorney this case is over Maya wins they accidently put the timeline in the risk mngment file lol
Justice! GUILTY on every count! Pay up JH... 211 million.
My gut feeling on this judge is NOT good
I'm just not sure the hospital is responsible for the mothers passing. She should of held on, for Maya 😢 it's all very heartbreaking
The mom wrote a suicide note stating in order to get Maya home, she needed to end her life. Guess what? As soon as Baeda was deceased they released Maya back to her father.
They did release her asap
The hospital was found guilty in actually making it personal to the mother.
Um frustrated with the hospital attys more
Don't mess it up ffs.... They must win!
Make America Florida ?? No thanks ...
This is probably a dumb question but did the hospital bill the family for Maya’s “care”?
Yes
Carroll recused himself from a human rights case out of pure self interest (click my bio), in complete contempt for law (yes, stranger than fiction). It caused an instant lack of confidence in his mental capacity (intantly categorized as being of 'diminished mental capacity'). "I am so tired of how you're not telling the other side... information. It's just wrong." Better judges are everywhere to be found, God willing (my case is in Appellate Court subsequent to the equally diminished hack who replaced Carroll).
This judge is over both sides in this trial. I can see why.
We are tired of you "judge".
Lol Already starting with the propaganda in support of the hospital. Are we going to do a news story about how the Defense completely ignored the judges order and did something that could have resulted in an immediate mistrial? Probably not. Good Ole Fox News. 😂