I know, all the damage calcs and the free summon hurt as I made the same mistake. The guy who helped build my first decent deck drilled that into me... black white annointed procession zombie horde... still my fav deck
@@davidkindle7944grave titan and lord of the undead are zombies in 2005 lords and lord effects were given their creature type they boost and commander 2014 confirmed grave titan is a zombie giant
@@robnorman5183 nah that one has since been updated and is a zombie; however Grave Titan definitely is not, and it would've made a lot of difference this game unfortunately.
@@AraAraAraAraAraAraAraAraAra I think grave Titan only attacked on the last swing and not sure if that power mattered to kill the professor. But yea the whole rooftop storm for grave Titan is the biggest misplay that would’ve changed the outcome of the game lol
Not that it was egregious either, but Matt was doing Lightfoot Rogue wrong as well. You only add the single box that your die roll falls in, not every single box before it as well.
I love the goofy editing mixed with the kinda scuffed gameplay cuz it makes it feel more like I’m hanging with the bois playing magic than some other shows. I also love shuffle up and play so this collaboration was perfect.
Really nice job with the edit, especially leaving the cards on the screen that the previous players played, incredibly useful. And no other commander channel really does that
I’ve been teaching a friend how to play mtg the past couple of months. Watching people relatively new to the game fall in love with it is something that will truly never get old 😊
I really like that they keep the recently played cards on screen. I'm pretty new, so being able to read the cards without having to pause every 3 seconds is great!
38:57, this is actually incorrect, but the reasoning the judge makes aligns with what we've been doing for all the other similar effects in the game. Sefris must be on the battlefield for the "when one or more creature cards [...]" to trigger, and if Sefris is destroyed with all other creatures, it does *not* trigger (because it looks for cards not creatures). This is noted in the Rulings section on Oracle.
Ive been watching commander videos for years. And finally finding more channels that play at least a little competitive is such a great watch. It teaches how to use the stack properly and how some cards work in ways you haven't thought of. And Prof will always be one of my favorites
Part of what I like about watching you guys play is catching the misplays. Wish I could get out and play commander with a chill group of friends like this.
Congratulations, you are the 1.000.000th player that thinks Grave Titan is a Zombie. You win sass from a commentor on TH-cam. 🥳 What really cracked me up was the close up on the card image and even the editor didn't realize. 😂
Charlie has reached the ultimate game. I'm so, so glad he is in this space now. We just need Posty to come back for the ultimate game's ultimate collaboration.
Saw Charlie was on TCC the other day, was hoping he would come visit the guys here too. And great to see Professor a bit more relaxed. Great video boys.
Another rule mishap that I didn't see mentioned yet: @38:43 Sefris asks for creature cards being put into the graveyard from anywhere, this is different from a leaves-the-battlefield ability. Because of this, she needs to be on the board when other creature cards hit the graveyard, it won't trigger when she leaves the battlefield at the same time as other creatures.
25:38 bit of advice for people you can swords to plowshare at the beginning of combat before attackers are declared but after the first main phase is exited so people can't reequip their equipments.
By default, that is what happens if a player says they are going to combat. Unless the player casting the spell explicitly states they are casting it during the main phase, it is assumed it is being cast at the beginning of combat, which would prevent the player from continuing their main phase. But it's nice that it's also legal to let him stay in the main phase, to give him a break. Even if he knew he could prevent Matt from equipping, I think he was happy to let him re-equip, to soften the blow of losing his commander.
I love seeing the prof all over my TH-cam feed. It’s so weird that I only found out about prof when him and Rudy were playing with some vintage magic decks like forever ago.
Been following for a long, long time and I absolutely love the recent surge of passion for Magic from the gang and I'd love to find myself slinging cards one day at an event!
6:50 So I like how he says it doesn't matter. Because spindowns have the same odds, it doesn't matter what order they're in. Of all the takes MTG players have this is the only one that bugs me because it's ignoring basic math. I've been a DM for a while now. I truly don't care which one you use, because they both have the same odds.
Casting that [[Grave Titan]] at 19:16 for zero mana kind of warped the game, but overall that was a fun game. Also liked the chill vibes a lot compared to some other EDH content creators that are faster paced with non-stop hysterical chatter back and forth, will definitely watch more of your games if they're as relaxed as this one!
@@SnipingDragoit’s a replacement cost, it’s 0 instead of 4 and 2 black so he doesn’t have to pay any black. If it was legal that is, cause grave titan isn’t a zombie lol
I love seeing charlie in the magic community, as someone who used to play very lightly and just played casually now he makes me want to get reintroduced and find people to play seriously with like this!
TBH ive NEVER played Magic: The Gathering, ive heard about it, and have some friends play it sometimes, this were really interesting stuff to watch, looks really fun, to bad that im bad at math, and i have an IQ of 78 probably, i would love to see more of this :) much love from Sweden
Adding block constructed cards to a correlating deck usually makes it more fun. Hence the haha. But it works better with cards from that block. Lots of room for fun interactions. Especially with immovable rod.
New subscriber here: Things the Skill Check guys need to work on? Triggers. Remembering them and sometimes the timing. Things the Skill Check guys DON'T need to work on? Being fun personalities that I loved watching play Magic 😊❤
Good game! A suggestion for Charlie: try to cast instants and abilities as late as possible on your opponent's turns instead of your own, especially if you can't do anything meaningful that turn anyway. Not only can this surprise them, but also protect you against discard/removal etc. It's also always better to act when you have more information.
Love seeing two esper decks being piloted at the same time. Literally have both of them built not to mention Kamiz and the eminence knight deck. Aaaaaaand esper urza lol
![[#2024MAMA] ROSÉ (로제), Bruno Mars - APT. | Mnet 241122 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dgGqD28J6aQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Hearing Prof actually swear is weird
Urza
Elesh Norn
IT'S SO *emrakul*
Marith Lage
Yawgmoth
"Thrun, Breaker of Silence - get fucked" I've always wanted this from Prof.
The Thrunderdome is back
was like a magic spell lmao
timestamp?
@@kyleolsen3305 1:29
Now we just need to hear him say it uncensored about Lord of Atlantis.
Prof being nice watching all the misplays and not saying anything but definitely screaming in his head "READING THE CARD EXPLAINS THE CARD"
I'll agree to that. Why be a party pooper and ruin the fun. I've definitely been on the other end, just killing vibes lol
@@MrMADMADHATTER1because then when later you realise you only won because of a mistake you feel like you didn’t deserve the win
@@timdadwagan wins in commander dont really mean to much anyway. if you want that gratification of actually winning a fair game commander aint it
The proffessor just stared at that grave titan knowing it was a giant.
I know, all the damage calcs and the free summon hurt as I made the same mistake. The guy who helped build my first decent deck drilled that into me... black white annointed procession zombie horde... still my fav deck
props to prof for not coming in with the, respectfully, "Um, actually" when calcing the damage on the final hit. he just rolled with it.
maybe you need a professor so you can spell shit right
Charlie is such an addition to the commander content community. As are the rest of you. Welcome and thank you for bringing more players to the game.
Before anyone says anything I’m not talking about the professor lol
@@MFobesprofessors name is Brian anyway
Charlie casting a free giant
Charlie immediately breaking the rules not paying life xd
Charlie casually using Rooftop Storm to cast a giant
We all know that Grave Titan is a Zombie. So yeah More Shock collars!!
He also casted lord of the undead with it too lmao bring back out the collars, these misplays getting out of hand
@@davidkindle7944 Lord of the Undead is a Zombie Lord, and has been since 9th Edition from 2005.
It's rules text was updated a long time ago.
He’s still learning 😅
@@davidkindle7944grave titan and lord of the undead are zombies in 2005 lords and lord effects were given their creature type they boost and commander 2014 confirmed grave titan is a zombie giant
Charlie not losing the 2 from the tutor
And casting a giant for free off of Rooftop Storm
@@T1nyFr0gg BRING BACK THY SHOCK COLLARS 😂
@@T1nyFr0gg Giant zombie?
@@natebeal18 Grave Titan is just a giant
I WAS THINKING THE SAME LMAO
I always love seeing Prof on other commander channels where he can swear it's always fun hearing him say "fuck"
Urza
It’s like seeing a teacher out of school and learning they swear a lot
I felt like Walter White screaming to Hank when Charlie played Grave Titan for 0 off of Rooftop Storm when it isn't a Zombie Creature.
Lord of undead as well. Lord, not a zombie
@@robnorman5183 nah that one has since been updated and is a zombie; however Grave Titan definitely is not, and it would've made a lot of difference this game unfortunately.
@@AraAraAraAraAraAraAraAraAra I think grave Titan only attacked on the last swing and not sure if that power mattered to kill the professor. But yea the whole rooftop storm for grave Titan is the biggest misplay that would’ve changed the outcome of the game lol
@@TofuofLight It did create zombies on ETB that attacked for quite a bit of damage so it definitely mattered.
Not that it was egregious either, but Matt was doing Lightfoot Rogue wrong as well. You only add the single box that your die roll falls in, not every single box before it as well.
I love the goofy editing mixed with the kinda scuffed gameplay cuz it makes it feel more like I’m hanging with the bois playing magic than some other shows. I also love shuffle up and play so this collaboration was perfect.
I like big production magic but, this is a good time as well. still has good production value but, it's not sanitised so much.
Matt: "Does anybody have a problem with me cheating?"
Charlie getting ready to summon a giant using Rooftop Storm:
And play vampiric tutor and not lose life
casting grave titan for free is how zombie decks work. BRING THE SHOCK COLLARS
We want shock collars back!
Round 2 baybeeeee
Really nice job with the edit, especially leaving the cards on the screen that the previous players played, incredibly useful. And no other commander channel really does that
Prof without censoring is wonderful
Charlie playing West Tek Tyrant as if it was a zombie. Bring out the shock collar.
Love hearing Prof curse. It's like learning that your teacher is a real person and not just a robot they unplug at the end of the day
When I was teaching I once got scolded for saying damn. I was like “for real? Damnnnn”
Gotta love how wholesome the Prof is at the end shouting out some of the other channels he works with to get them some views!
@7:51 Charlie should be at 34. Lose 2 life from Vamp Tutor, 2 life for Godless Shrine, and lose another 2 for using Ancient Tomb.
Lmao
it's okay man lmao
he posted about it😭
I’ve been teaching a friend how to play mtg the past couple of months. Watching people relatively new to the game fall in love with it is something that will truly never get old 😊
Prof of all people being one of the first Magic content creators to play with someone as big as Charlie makes me so happy.
Prof using his time to plug other creators was top notch.
Hearing the Professor curse and it not be Emrakul'd was fun. :)
Also, a class act giving shout outs to basically everyone but himself.
I really like that they keep the recently played cards on screen. I'm pretty new, so being able to read the cards without having to pause every 3 seconds is great!
38:57, this is actually incorrect, but the reasoning the judge makes aligns with what we've been doing for all the other similar effects in the game. Sefris must be on the battlefield for the "when one or more creature cards [...]" to trigger, and if Sefris is destroyed with all other creatures, it does *not* trigger (because it looks for cards not creatures). This is noted in the Rulings section on Oracle.
Love seeing the prof and Charlie in two back to back guest features
Ive been watching commander videos for years. And finally finding more channels that play at least a little competitive is such a great watch. It teaches how to use the stack properly and how some cards work in ways you haven't thought of. And Prof will always be one of my favorites
Charlie and prof commander game was fire this game should be good as well
Prof and Charlie are an awesome combo. Gib more pls.
First Charlie on SUP, and now The Professor on Skill Check. W
This was recommended to me after that one. 😅 Idk this channel, though. Lol
I can see why you made a shock collar episode, and I would like more of it. There were so many misplays happened but still a fun game to watch!
Part of what I like about watching you guys play is catching the misplays. Wish I could get out and play commander with a chill group of friends like this.
Grave Titan is a giant not a zombie so charlie couldn’t have played it for 0 :(
Congratulations, you are the 1.000.000th player that thinks Grave Titan is a Zombie. You win sass from a commentor on TH-cam. 🥳
What really cracked me up was the close up on the card image and even the editor didn't realize. 😂
youve got my sub! never heard of this channel until now after seeing the game with Charlie on TCC
Charlie has reached the ultimate game. I'm so, so glad he is in this space now. We just need Posty to come back for the ultimate game's ultimate collaboration.
Duuude.
Prof, Charlie, Posty, and Maldhound (Olivia would be fire too)
This videos editing instantly made me like this show, its so good and funny as hell
5:37 crazy Isshin animation replay button
Many magic the gathering players have asked themselves the question “alright, that’s about it, see ya.”
Many magic the gathering players have asked the question “why couldn’t I be 6 foot, dad?”
Great to see the prof on the show. Looking forward to a lot more guests from the great magic YT community. Well, provided they dare to come to Florida
Saw Charlie was on TCC the other day, was hoping he would come visit the guys here too. And great to see Professor a bit more relaxed. Great video boys.
Another rule mishap that I didn't see mentioned yet: @38:43 Sefris asks for creature cards being put into the graveyard from anywhere, this is different from a leaves-the-battlefield ability. Because of this, she needs to be on the board when other creature cards hit the graveyard, it won't trigger when she leaves the battlefield at the same time as other creatures.
Was just about to write this haha
Uncensored Professor is actually gold.
25:38 bit of advice for people you can swords to plowshare at the beginning of combat before attackers are declared but after the first main phase is exited so people can't reequip their equipments.
Real
By default, that is what happens if a player says they are going to combat. Unless the player casting the spell explicitly states they are casting it during the main phase, it is assumed it is being cast at the beginning of combat, which would prevent the player from continuing their main phase.
But it's nice that it's also legal to let him stay in the main phase, to give him a break. Even if he knew he could prevent Matt from equipping, I think he was happy to let him re-equip, to soften the blow of losing his commander.
I always announce phase changes for that reason. Some people just speed run through steps, not giving anyone time to react
I love seeing the prof all over my TH-cam feed. It’s so weird that I only found out about prof when him and Rudy were playing with some vintage magic decks like forever ago.
All this dope collaborations in mtg, this is the brightest timeline
Embarrassment resolves- feel like i'm at my lgs rn ,love the commander content y'all have been doing also hearing the Prof be able to swear is S tier
Edits on this are great tbh, game was easy to follow and funny to watch
Been following for a long, long time and I absolutely love the recent surge of passion for Magic from the gang and I'd love to find myself slinging cards one day at an event!
What an awesome collab. Certainly not one I ever thought I'd see
That went from father and son to lovers really quickly! Wild.
i love the chemistry on the table, and i love the professor. The crossover i did not know i needed
6:50 So I like how he says it doesn't matter. Because spindowns have the same odds, it doesn't matter what order they're in. Of all the takes MTG players have this is the only one that bugs me because it's ignoring basic math. I've been a DM for a while now. I truly don't care which one you use, because they both have the same odds.
Love hearing Prof curse 😆
Urza
Emrakul
I fricking love the Prof and Charlie duo, it's awesome to see them inviting each other to their shows!
Prof gives off Big Deck Enrgy😫
Lol that's the name of my mono green historic deck in Arena
I haven't played MTG in 25 years, but I love these videos. Especially with Charlie and Prof
Love seeing Prof on other shows where he can be more of a degen lol
New Idea. Instead of shock collars you have to eat the hottest peppers known to man if you make a misplay.
Charlie, it makes me so happy to see two content creators i followed independently cross over like this.
I haven’t even started the video yet, but I’m definitely excited to see the big deck energy the prof gives off
“Errrm Charlie, the Gravetitan is a Giant, not a Zombie! You’d have to pay the 6 for him” 👆🏼🤓
This feels like a game you would play at a lgs and I love it.
I really loved the TCC/Skill Check collabs... I feel like this is a fever dream hearing Prof among the crass crew here.
Ohh damn, I thought this was a reupload of the video from prof's channel, but its actually a whole new game?!! Yes please!
I always love seeing Prof on other channels so I can hear him say things like 'accord' and 'game actions'.
Casting that [[Grave Titan]] at 19:16 for zero mana kind of warped the game, but overall that was a fun game. Also liked the chill vibes a lot compared to some other EDH content creators that are faster paced with non-stop hysterical chatter back and forth, will definitely watch more of your games if they're as relaxed as this one!
Yeah I was gonna say the same thing, he still had to pay the two black mana.
@@SnipingDrago Not true actually. Grave Titan isn't a zombie, so it doesn't get any discount from Rooftop Storm.
@@SnipingDragoit’s a replacement cost, it’s 0 instead of 4 and 2 black so he doesn’t have to pay any black. If it was legal that is, cause grave titan isn’t a zombie lol
Free scofflaw Grave Titan absolutely tipped it because it was also having huge attack bonuses and death touch illegally applied to it.
I love seeing charlie in the magic community, as someone who used to play very lightly and just played casually now he makes me want to get reintroduced and find people to play seriously with like this!
More like lovers, Drew and Ryan say. Extremely funny after watching Prof's Shuffle Up and Play with Charlie.
Sefris is my favorite deck ive been playing. Rod of absorption and immovable rod are some of my favorites
It's great to see Charlie featuring small time creators like The Professor on his channel.
Thank you so much for giving me my fix after the Tolarian vid, godbless you
Prof on big deck energy? My first video, already subbed. Nice
TBH ive NEVER played Magic: The Gathering, ive heard about it, and have some friends play it sometimes,
this were really interesting stuff to watch, looks really fun, to bad that im bad at math, and i have an IQ of 78 probably, i would love to see more of this :) much love from Sweden
No one catching Charlie not taking his 2 life for that tutor is the real play of the game 😂
casting a giant for free off rooftop storm was way more outrgeous
@@beliffywu5804he's a giant. Who's gonna tell him that he can't come out for free, really? He'd stomp on a fool.
IT’S THE COLLAB OF ALL COLLABS
Played Grave titan for free?? It’s a giant, not a zombie. Did I miss something?
Nah they just read the card name and looked at it and felt like it was a zombie, but it is in fact, not a zombie
I love that 2 of my favorite content creators are playing together my new head cannon is that charlie and prof are besties
Adding block constructed cards to a correlating deck usually makes it more fun. Hence the haha. But it works better with cards from that block. Lots of room for fun interactions. Especially with immovable rod.
I need Prof + Charlie on a weekly basis.
They were nicer to prof gameplay wise than anyone has ever been on Shuffle Up 😆
I love zombie decks. That's how i started playing magic 12 years ago
New subscriber here:
Things the Skill Check guys need to work on? Triggers. Remembering them and sometimes the timing.
Things the Skill Check guys DON'T need to work on? Being fun personalities that I loved watching play Magic 😊❤
Everyone hating on charlie for some mistakes even as veteran players we make careless plays just let him have fun with his friends
This game was so intense imo, loved every moment of it! Can't wait for more MTG and DnD coming into the channel!
I never thought anything with the Prof in it would be unwatchable. And yet!
I love this skill check channel . Im so ready for the booster box battles .
Good game! A suggestion for Charlie: try to cast instants and abilities as late as possible on your opponent's turns instead of your own, especially if you can't do anything meaningful that turn anyway. Not only can this surprise them, but also protect you against discard/removal etc. It's also always better to act when you have more information.
Idk how I've missed this channel, but im here now. Lol. These 3 are great! So was that grave titan. 😉😅
Low energy prof is pretty awesome actually:) hes just vibing with everyone and chilling haha i think he doesnt feel the pressure to host
Collab of the century
As a member of the undead… I can I fact, confirm… we DO honor our words 30:20
At 38:00 ish. Am I wrong In saying you decide what order to block in? So he could block with that creature last?
I'm on minute 2 and Matt is playing the most complex trigger commander AGAIN hahahah that's so funny
Love seeing two esper decks being piloted at the same time. Literally have both of them built not to mention Kamiz and the eminence knight deck. Aaaaaaand esper urza lol
Was not expecting the Drinkin' Outta Cups Lizard at 5:36.
Episode might as well be sponsored by Honda with all these Accords.
i hope prof had fun i would love to see more content with them all together
27:54 I wonder what Matt was saying . All I hear is flick flick flick flick of Two cards over and over and over , DREW.....