Let’s Play Commander With TheOdd1sOut, Arin Hanson, and Amy! | Shuffle Up & Play 59 | Magic Gameplay
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ก.พ. 2025
- James Rallison (TheOdd1sOut) sit down to Shuffle Up & Play his first Commander game on camera! Can Arin Hanson (Game Grumps) show him how it's done? And will he ever return after Amy show him her Starscream Commander fan fiction? Let's play!
▶Are you looking to Shuffle Up & Play games of Magic: The Gathering over webcam? The "Looking For Game" section of our Patron Discord is 100% free and open to everyone: / discord
#magicthegathering #mtgcommander #commander
►Check out my guests' channels!
TheOdd1sOut: / theodd1sout
Arin Hanson: / @gamegrumps
Amy The Amazonian: / amazonian
►Deck Lists
The Professor: archidekt.com/...
Arin: archidekt.com/...
James: archidekt.com/...
Amy: archidekt.com/...
►Credits
Lead Editor | Director: Kevyn Wallace
Editor: Theo Nguyen
Assistant Editor: Brian Sirk
Music / SFX: Def Cat @defcatofficial
Intro VFX: Kyle Sullivan, Kevyn Wallace
►Special Thanks
Josh-TheProxyGuy
Andre Garcia
Jebari Dean
►This episode is brought to you thanks to our wonderful Patreon community. Join to support the show, or just Shuffle Up & Play with other awesome people on our Patron Discord by going to / tolariancommunitycollege
►This show is made in part due to Card Kingdom. You can help us out by visiting our affiliate link at www.CardKingdo...
#MagicTheGathering #MTG #commander
►Not A Sponsor But We Love Them!
Infinitokens Rewritable Dry Erase Tokens: www.infinitoke...
Be sure to also watch Yu-Gi-Oh Players Try Magic: The Gathering! (feat Team APS) on Shuffle Up & Play 51 here: th-cam.com/video/exV3pXeNcwE/w-d-xo.html
for real though this one's criminally underrated, go watch it.
For the record. Galvatron actually said was, coronation starscream? This is bad comedy
You gotta get CGB on now with Amy 👀👀
47:34 posty callback 😂
LETS PLAY! ☝🤓 (thanks for having me on! My very first time playing Magic for a video was a blast!)
Please come back and also have a second time playing Commander on camera!!!!!!!
It was so fun to get to play with you!
I'll take "something you don't want to hear at your proctologist visit" for 400, Alex😆. LETS PLAY☝
You have great energy on camera and looking forward to seeing more games with you in it whereever you may pop up!
Wow
"It's okay to gaslight adults" - The Professor
🤣🤣🤣
Them not bleeping the professor was comedy gold
I never thought it would make me laugh but it admittedly got me 😂
It got me but also imagine if they had gone through with the reverse censorship when he said "when you say Urza we replace it with a swear". (now i do Need the patron-exclusive SUP where prof plays tron lands but they're each reverse-bleeped differently.)
It would've been if it wasn't spoiled before the video started.
14:26 The editors left him hanging again too
It was so unexpected xD I'm still waiting for someone to say "Urza" to see if they actually replaced it with a swear :')
The false start counterspell battle over Koma into actual counterspell battle over removing Koma is the greatest sequence of the show. Magnificent.
If I remember correctly, it’s still a valid target for counterspell, it just doesn’t work, so an “um, acshually 🤓 “ moment would be to just have the spell fizzle.
I could be wrong though.
@@Brianlikescars 100% correct. If this was a more serious game then they'd play it exactly like that.
@@dinklebob1 oh thank God. I figured it just wasn’t good content so the judge stepped in so we didn’t miss out on shenanigans, and we GOT them. lol
@@Brianlikescars Yeah rewinding in EDH can be pretty common, especially for something like this where decisions were made on a misunderstanding by multiple players.
Technically the spells wouldn't even fizzle. The Arcane Denial would fail to counter Kona, but the draw effects would still happen. And then countering the Arcane Denial to deny those draw effects would be a valid (if questionable) decision you could make.
The editors were COOKING this episode. Thank you for letting me play my self-insert Transformers Fanfiction deck.
Always a good video when you're in it Amy!
Your make up was straight 🔥 queen 👑👉👈🥹
How do I put you in contact with my Transformers obsessed and terminally on AO3 wife? Y'all seem like you might have similar interests
@@nerfinatorrr9981 I wanted to look villainous like a true Decepticon!
@@captainflapjax7240 My email is on my page - or she can stop by my twitch chat :D
Professor: These cards have too many words!
Also Professor: These cards need more words!
I am many things if not a being of contradiction.
Wait you’re telling me james is NOT a vagely humanoid white blob in real life?! Next you’re gonna tell me the professor has won a commander game…
I have video proof of it!
@@TolarianCommunityCollege It must be AI-generated then
@@TolarianCommunityCollege *Edited video proof. Basically didn't happen since it wasn't in one continuous shot.
@@TolarianCommunityCollege That he's not a humanoid blob? not sure i believe that.
He's also (allegedly) not a furry
1:07:02 "No I would never be a dick to a student" he says after telling a story of how he gaslit his entire class.
"We bleep it, watch this" these edits that your team does is fantastic
My absolute favorite mtg dynamic: _Three siblings and their dad play a hostile game of Magic after Tuesday pizza night_
"Watch this! Fuck"
It's OK, we can have up to 1 f-bomb. No wait, those are for movies
An absolute jump scare. I wasn't ready.
HE SAID A CUSS.
I feel so unclean....
-The Professor, 2024
Being a fan of TheOdd1sOut for ages, since finding out he played magic I've always wanted to see him play and see his decks. Perfect Episode!
Me, a grown adult: "Oh my god, he said FUCK."
You can't fucking say that!
You can't say the "fuck" word on the internet, naughty prof
I couldn't believe it, I had to rewind 4 times to comprehend what had happened
I wonder if Professor has been hanging out with Post Malone again.
Apparently you are morally gaslight-able too
GALVATRON: "CORONATION STARSCREAM? THIS IS BAD COMEDY."
STARSCREAM: "MEGATRON?! IS THAT YOU?!"
GALVATRON: "HERE'S A HINT."
Literally shouting it at the screen during that segment.
thank you! Its one of my favorite lines from the movie and I was sad that they all didnt know it by heart :P
Brother. The fact that the professor just says, "see, watch... F***!" and it isn't bleeped made me laugh so hard.
LOL "ITS OK TO GASLIGHT ADULTS"..
What an episode. Thank you so much for this one.
I'm pretty sure they actually added in a "fuck" in post lol
Arin brings such a lovely chaotic awkward energy that is so unique and charming. IT also bleeds into the rest of the chaotic energy from the rest of the colorful cast.
Truly a magical episode with great guest chemistry. I look forward to the return of these wonderful friends!
I feel like he mirrors My approach to the game. He is first and foremost there to have fun and winning isn't the objective. He will play optimally and try to win but the experience is what matters
1:47
Prof: "You're allowed to swear. We bleep it. Watch. 🤗Fuck"
Priceless 😂
I was dying seeing this happen 😭
@@DaClaptainimagine complaining about people having fun on the internet. Is your favorite color eggshell?
@@DaClaptain Are you getting enough vegetables in your diet? I've heard some folks get irritable if they don't eat enough veggies, and you seem pretty cranky.
@@DaClaptain Imagine judging someone for succeeding without losing their childlike innocence. Are you broken?
@@DaClaptainaww it’s a 4 year old ITS so cuteeee🥹
Such a fun episode! All of Arin and the Prof interactions cracked me up
You asked Arnold "I don't animate anymore" Hansen if he wanted to animate. The look on his face when he said "no" was the look of someone who has been asked that too many times.
Arin disassociated into a reddit-based PTSD flashback hilariously fast when the Prof asked him about animating
The music cutting off at 1:00:33 is a small, but hilarious detail. The editors did an amazing job this episode.
“Yes daddy” was hilarious 🤣🤣🤣
In this episode of Shuffle Up and Play, The Professor gets *relentlessly* bullied lmao.
What's new?
New series description
@@Hoologramek him winning
isn't that every episode?
Do you have any idea how little that narrows it down.
A btw for anyone learning, the sequence at 57:40 is actually completely legal
You can always target a spell that can't be countered with counter spells. Just nothing will happen with regards to actually countering the spell. If Odd1sout wanted to be mean, he could actually let Arcane Denial resolve, and since the drawing cards aspect is not tied to the spell being countered or not, he would get to draw 2 cards during his next upkeep and Arin would draw a card during his next upkeep.
Presumably the people off-screen are freaking out because, while it is all legal, it is a waste of resources and less entertaining for people at home.
Well, also because in almost any casual table, people will let you take that back. Same with with ward costs.
@@marcup1584 well yeah, but there are some scenarios where it is useful. Some counterspells have additional effects that don't rely on the spell being countered (like arcane denial or absorb) and sometimes, you can use fizzled counterspells as fodder to get card types in the graveyard for delerium, or to fuel delve spells or to hit threshold.
So while it is usually not great to counter uncounterable spells, there are reasons to do it, and it's important to know that uncounterable doesn't mean hexproof while on the stack. So you can still bounce spells with cards that do that before it resolves.
I would love it if the Professor responded to "you heard it here first, it's okay to gaslight adults" with "I never said that" or something similar.
He invited them all in and they just sit there and insult him for an hour. I love this channel
I NEVER though I would ever heard the words "Trasformers Vore Fanfiction" used in the same sentence..... ESPECIALLY before saying "it wasn't bad".....
Oh I'm excited for this episode now XD
@@raimundopilotto2675 ever since Transformers: the Movie… Vore has been Canon in the Transformers Universe. Any Fanfic is ADDITIONAL vore content.
I hate that my brain is super curious about it
Tell me you don't watch amys streams without telling me
@@Littlewh0 true enought
The music cutting out when Prof just said “I want to be daddy!” is just
Chef’s kiss
Didn't expect Daddies and Vore to feature so heavily this episode
Arin's here- there will be daddies
@@LoonerFlightI was just gonna say this
1:48 time stamp best prof moment ever
I really was not expecting that lol
Can we PLEASE thank the animators and editors for such a good job overall,but on 45:41 going above and beyond❤❤❤
Absolute gold.
"Coronation, Starscream? This is bad comedy." Also, I'm so happy that Arin's 'daddy' fixation has carried over from Game Grumps.
That exact moment when the prof draws a card like a yugioh player and Arin is just staring at it only to suddenly have that "oh shit im not supposed to see that" look on his face and hard recoil was beautiful 😂
OMGGGG, Did not think I was going to be watching one of my fav MTG youtube channels and see one of our shirts on there! Thank you James for the support! ToT
😮 JAMES?! JAMES IS HERE?! YOU GOT JAMES?! AND HE'S NOT ANIMATED?! WHAT IS THIS SORCERY?! EXPLORE?!
It's a face-up trigger that has reveal!
James is a morph irl
Arin and the Prof's antagonism is always a delight.
The energy of everyone at the table right off the jump is phenomenal. You just know it's going to be a good game
Look, the guests were fantastic this episode, but we all know the real MVPs here were the editors. Amazing work, folks.
My appreciation for Amy has reached new heights, and the quote Arin was looking for was "Coronation Starscream? That's bad comedy."
This is* bad comedy but close enough lol unlike Arin unfortunately. He got the "Here's a hint!" part right tho!
lol Arin always looking at the Prof’s draw/hand every turn 👀😂
Ikr.. it was really bugging me...
If I ever make it onto this show I’m playing Urza just so y’all can replace every time I say Urza with “fuck.”
Fucking saga
"I'm going to cast my commander, 'Fuck, Lord High Artificer'"
then the other players need to play Yawgmoth and Lim-Dûl
9:16. “THE GAME HAS STARTED” 😂😂😂
The episode with spice and rhystic with the riddles in the dark USED to be my favorite episode, but I think it's this one, not even 8 minutes in and I'm trying not to spit my coffee out
"Coronation, Starscream? This is bad comedy!"
Amy's "will not shut up about Transformers if anyone shows an interest" is the neurodivergent infodump vibe, and I'm here for it!
My hyperfixations are varied, but Transformers is certainly one of them.
Glad to hear that's not just me. For me it's halo, I could deliver a 4 hour speech on Halo lore
@Amazonian have you read any of the new Image comics?! They're SOO GOOOOOD
0:17 OHMIGOD STARSCREAM’S CROWN????
Okay, I’mma watch this episode!!!! I really hope someone’s running Screamer and that’s the Monarch crown!!!
😊
Everybody deserves someone who looks at them the way Amy looks at that crown on Arin's head
Real Starscream behavior
Arin is always a treat.
I would love to see Rhystic Studies, Spice8rack, and Egoraptor all on one episode. It would be interesting to see how they'd interact.
shame about him and the oneyboys
@@Radicalbeast I’m not upset about it.
@@Radicalbeast ?
@tiptaphooves Chris O'Neil who goes by oneyng. they had a falling out when they used to be cool.
@@Rudepetsclub justice for dingdong
That "may ability, it's August" joke was perfection
man I cant believe they got theodd1sout on game knights!
It's prof not game knights
He's the only one I have no clue who he is.
@@dinoman8229 bro's never heard a joke before
Oh my gosh, you're so dumb, this is clearly Commander at Home
I thought this was commander at home, Or maybe game knights.
Nice to see Arin sitting next to his dad. But why did they not kiss?
I was thinking this is my favourite table so far.
Then I saw the sting for next time.
You're proliferating your poggers Professor, as I believe the youths say 🤔
every time i see a special guest on shuffle up and play, i realize that magic is actually more popular than i believed it was
I met Amy at MagicCon Chicago. It was at the end of the con and she didn't have any games left in her, but she was super nice and signed a random card from one of my decks. Great guests and awesome game, like usual.
Didn't think I'd see TheOdd1sOut on this channel. It's a welcoming surprise for sure. In fact, I think I learnt about MTG from one of James' animation videos about board games.
24:36 FUN FACT FOR RULES! I have a Yasova Dragonclaw deck, and Yasova Dragonclaw has this little interesting aspect of her that many would call, *the big stupid.* So much so Gavin Verhey did a video on why this cycle of effects were bad and unintuitive.
ANYWAY, the fun thing is, You must *always* name a target for Yasova if there is a legal target to be named. But it gets worse. You don't pay the cost until the ability has resolved. So an opponent must choose to play any protection prior to you paying the cost to do Yasova's effect, "wasting" their protection since you now save 3 mana.
Surely, the way the card is worded, the ability only goes on the stack if you pay the cost though
@@cathalmolloy2002 Nope. "At the beginning of your combat on your turn" is the trigger for the ability, meaning the ability "You may pay 1{U/R}{U/R}. If you do..." goes on the stack at the Beginning of Combat phase regardless.
@@cathalmolloy2002 Nowadays, they would format this as "At the beginning of combat on your turn, you may pay [cost]. WHEN you do, [effect]."
This makes it a reflexive trigger, which means you don't choose a target unless you pay the cost, and the opponent gets a chance to respond after they know it's happening.
But as it's worded, Demonaru is correct.
18:47 I love the subtle reference with the censor being Tezzeret with Starscream being described as a schemer just moments before lol
Everytime i see Arin playing Magic, he is wearing the COMFIEST looking clothes ive ever seen! Iconic. I want his fashion
Starsceam died, and then came back from the dead!
STARSCREAM'S GHOST! its just like in the comics!
love that Decepticon Crown, Amy.... super deluxe.
YES. Someone else caught on that I said he'll come back as a ghost.
@@Amazonian Never forget the cosmic powered Starsceam.
He'll be back, in Wassssspinatorrrr's body!
Omg Amy's big Grumps fan, i can only imagine how much fun they had recording this
This might be one of the best episode of Shuffle Up and Play, the video was great and the editing was incredible. Great job team!
That uncensored fuck broke me 🤣
I stopped breathing when the editors didn't bleep the professor
A+ editing 👌👌👌
Dude, oh my god James (Odd1sOut) being in the thumbnail and being fully animated flashbanged me so hard
great chemistry between all of ya'll, lost my mind when Amy whipped out the crown.
very excited to see wubby on the show, keep it up Prof!
Animators doing Shuffle Up and Play?!
Count me In for this game, Professor!
Why is this quickly turning into the best magic show on the internet for me? 😂
Crazy lineup!
Quite an animated group of guests!
@@TolarianCommunityCollege, I'd love to see more animators for Shuffle Up and Play!
45:45 the "daddy is a good boy" here had me in stitches.
1:28 that transition though, seamless
He transformed like the cover of an Animorph book
@@momomochi3757 omg he did
I cant tell if this was the best magic vid for being so unhinged… or simply the most unhinged magic vid
Amy's Starscream crown is EVERYTHING
:D I made it myself
new kink unlocked
@@Amazonian 10/10. I have a monarch deck and I too strive to be as ostentatious and unbearably regal as possible.
"Coronation Starscream? This is bad comedy "
The secret message was delightful!
Prof your editing team has been absolutely killing it. Best edited EDH gameplay around. Thank you for giving them creative freedom.
1:50 my favorite moment
Editing game is so on point with this one, mad props to whomever did it.
The "Transformers WHAT?" made me laugh so hard I immediately felt better from my cold. So healing.
45:21 I can't believe none of them said "Dark Snails". XD
I've been a fan of Arin for as long as i can freaking remember, love seeing him on your show professor. my sides are split and i am still laughing on the floor
This episode got super meta towards the end and I loved it lol
The jump to James' reaction to "not bad Transformers vore fanfic" was absolutely perfect
"Watch this, FUCK" was so funny hahahahh
Absolutely love the energy that Arin brings to any video he’s ever in.
"thats what starscream is right? the little back stabbing [[TEZZERET]]"
lore accurate censor bleep got me lauging
She committed to the Starscream deck and I salute her for it.
"WHO DISRUPTS MY CORONATION?!?!?!"
"Coronation, Starscream? This is bad comedy"
"Megatron, is that you?"
"Here's a hint" *transforms into a space cannon and shoots Starscream*
"Will anyone else attempt to fill his shoes?"
"euhhh what'd he say his name was?"
Arin, you're my favorite. Everybody makes a little goof or gaff every once in a while, and it doesn't really matter because you still came out on top! Good win, good approach.
As I'm sat here wearing my "Be Excellent To Each Other" t-shirt, I would like to say I approve of Prof channelling Bill and Ted
This episode was AMAZING!!! One of my faves. The quote Arin wanted at 25:59 is "Coronation, Starscream? This is bad comedy!" Which I waited the whole game for someone to say to Amy, so close! I ADORED Amy's TF theme deck & crown setup the extra mile! The entire Dark Souls bit at 45:19 was immaculate, editors went extra hard this episode.
“I would never be a dick to a student”
> tells a story about how he gaslit an entire classroom.
Love you prof❤
This was hilarious! 😂 The chemistry between everyone is just so fun to watch. Also, Shoutout to Arin for trying to teach James, that's gotta be tricky! I can’t believe Amy brought her fan fiction into it, that’s some next level commitment! 🤖✨
The students that were in his class are gonna be watching this, screaming “I KNEW IT!!”
The overwhelming chaos of this episode. Transformers Vore, Daddy energy, and super doodles.
Arin Handsome and TheBest1sOut together? This season is FIRE
The editors are becoming main characters on the channel in their own right. Fantastic job all around, great banter. I hope all your mispronunciations become playtest cards for next year's convention
"Oh attacks" ah, feels so familiar
One of best group chemistry’s I’ve seen on the channel!!!
Arin Looks like he's slowly turning into the Prof
THIS IS CRAZY, i remember interviewing theodd1sout back in like 2017 for a kids newspaper in tucson, i remember being so excited when he responded to my email as a kid. Anyways thanks for coming to my ted talk
I enjoyed Prof being low-key jealous whenever Arin's bad puns got laughs
MANY Magic the Gathering players ask the question: "How is Arin so lovable?"
The editor becoming reaction to James movies his mat was so good !
guess you could say James got two Optimus Primals to go ham on Starscream XD
also missed opportunity to say "now I, Starscream, am The Professor of Tolarian Community College!"
Poor Wasssspinatorrr got his ass beat just cause he was possessed by Starscream again huh lol
this whole episode was gold, but the arcane denial on the koma and the counterspell after and then the immediate use of it on upkeep just to get arcane denialed was hilarious, he was so confident after playing it 🤣🤣🤣