absolutely agree on lavish living habit. we are the country who do not tax the rich and instead we spend hard earned dollars to fund their lavish life by allowing them to import cars worth of hundreds of thousands dollars, packed food items, and lavish home amentias used during construction and so on. We should ban all these foolish imports for 10 years atleast if we want to survive anymore. this is madness.
But at the end of the day, Indians fell for the jingoistic nationalism of Modi in 2013. What people of India did to congress is ruthless, I mean how can you people forget the efforts of Manmohan both as a PM and an FM? India stands where it stands today is bcz of the reforms Manmohan brought during the 90s. Now India is slowly becoming an intolerant society bcz of Modi's politics of hate. This would not end up great.
@@shapackgaming4629 What India did to Cong in 2014 is why India is real Democratic nation. We rewarded them with another term in 2009 with increased majority but their term from 09 to 14 was absolutely pathetic with lot of corruption & policy paralysis. India is country of 140 Cr. We reward regime when they good & throw them out mercilessly when they don't perform. India is not jagir of any political party. We chose govt to serve us no need to be loyal slave to any govt. We currently have govt which is doing decent job. So they will get 3rd term in 24 but if they don't perform then make no mistake even they will be thrown out but if they perform we will give them more terms. India today is like this due to effort of successive govt not just 1 man. We are here due to these people 1) Narasimha Rao & Manmohan Singh - For opening Indian economy and bringing out of economic instability. They were amply supported by statesman like Vajpayee in opposition who didn't trouble govt despite being in minority. Manmohan in his UPA1 era too did some good work like cutting down subsidy on LPG, Civil Nuclear deal etc. 2) Vajapayee - Who gave a stable govt & then focussed on rapid road infrastructure & education, He steered India away from economic sanctions & led country during turbulent time of Kargil war. Tried to bring peace with neighborhood (though was betrayed by Mushraff). 3) Current Modi regime - They cut down the red tapism & fast tracked infrastructure development, electricity connectivity & rapid digitization. Modi govt led India effectively in really hard time of Covid and still leading it decently during hard time of Russian war.
@@ganeshshenoy1175 Then you must also know that know that 2 main parties of Pakistan (PPP&PMLN) both served for 4 and 3 terms respectively but none of them served for 2 consecutive terms. Anti-incumbency is at another level in Pakistan 😂. Even Imran Khan's party was going to loose badly in the upcoming election by the looks of it till the last year but fortunately for him, the two traditional party took over and made the situation worse for themselves and for the country. Imran Khan is currently in a very strong position to win the upcoming elections and he might break the tradition.
@@shapackgaming4629 are you stupid or what if tomorrow manmohan Singh comes again people will again vote for him but he was not an independent leader he was just a puppet of congress party and now congress party want that Rahul gandhi to prime minister of India lol You only tell is there any comparison between Rahul gandhi pm modi
I’m from India and I must say that you have put in a lot of research and time for this video. Absolutely brilliant, have subscribed to your channel for more content.
wrong. Don't equate their religion with our Dharma. If we become ''religious" or more Dharmic, we will become better, not worse. Educate yourself on a subject before yelping on SM. What do you know about their religion and our Dharma to create this false equivalence?
Asim Rasmalai sex racket in Pakistani army and bureaucracy is handler of Aimen Nadeem FSP 43rd CTP and behind Syeda Fatimee FSP rape and murder along husband at China border
he was comparing Pakistan with Argentina, Srilanka which is unfortunate. Argentina is running trade surplus. Sri lanka has tourism and tea exports which puts them in course correction and their current account balance is not really out of shape. Their only issue was getting loans from china. the apt comparison will be Lebanon where the currency has depreciated by 95% which has similarities like fragmented society, no exports
Why do you think that society is fragmented in Pakistan? As a Pakistani, I can say that the economic crisis in Pakistan has nothing to do with its society. Why should the society be blamed if there aren't enough opportunities for the youth, why should the society be blamed if the crime rate is surging due to unemployment, why should the society be blamed if people are homeless and are starving due to the recent floods? This is my take on the situation.
@@KingKong-lb3vh tu pen ki BAAT krta hai, logo nai apny dam par 1-2 billion dollar e-commerce economy bana di hai Bina kisi government support Kai. Pakistan Sab Kuch bana skta hai agr government Kuch krey to.
@@shapackgaming4629 after zia ul haq pakistan society islamized and became violent extremist before that pakistani people were like Turkish people who were secular in nature and had persian and Indian influence. And also developed karachi and lahore even Europeans used to buy flats in Pakistan
@@shapackgaming4629 jenaab aise toh Phir hamare padosy mulk Afghanistan wahan toh sirf jahalat hai aur deshatgardy hai lekin uske bawajood Afghanistan Ki dollar rates Pakistan se acche hai
Keep this content of awareness, and reach out the public, as everyone can know the basic issues of the country in order to be careful in next time, while electing their representatives.
Sir India k pass Dr man mohan Singh shb thy luckily. Or hmare pass tareen chacha, hafeez uncle & ishaq disaster shb hai unluckily. I admire and want Pakistan to learn from India in many fields because for us India is not an enemy that's the other thing India wants to become our enemy. But thing is things never stand still or constant things will change and become better doesn't matter we want to or not.
The actual problem is tunnel vision Neutral Nuts, whose meddling in politics & shallow mindedness has consequently imposed these IMF agents & narrow minded politicians like Nawaz, Zardari, Fazzlo, Chuadhry bros & others like them. US cannot accept any independent minded & reform bound statesman, like IK, in Pak. Therefore, they pull the strings of the colonial era mercenary Catalan company aka Establishment & get rid of him through coup. Pakistan is just like a stoner, who will be paid for weed, if he contract kill anyone.
Atif Main is one of the Greatest Economists in the world. Said he is willing to serve Pakistan in any capacity he is called on. Want to guess why he isn't being called on?
Pakistan faces a serious balance of payment crisis. Two things have mainly contributed to the crisis. First, the imports of foreign-made luxury goods for lavish lifestyle of the rich and super rich classes. Second, the lack of investment in domestic manufacturing sector and exports of Pakistani products. Sadly, the lion's share of cash investment goes into non-productive sector like real estate which does not generate any foreign exchange. In a nutshell, a flawed economic policy is formulated by an extremely incompetent bureaucracy and political leadership in Islamabad. Unfortunately, Pakistan is a stubborn country where it is considered taboo to even mention the Indian model and lessons we may be able to learn from the successful economic policies of our neighbor. No wonder Pakistan is doomed in international credit market. Our government bonds are junk quality which no one wants to touch with a ten foot pole.
Thanks for praising Bharat Sir correcting a bit Bharat is not sitting at 600 BILLION DOLLAR FOREX RESERVE AND 5500 TONNE GOLD AND WE ARE ONE AND A HALF BILLION PEOPLE SIR WE ARE THE RICHEST NATION ON PLANET PLEASE LET US KNOW ANY OTHER NATION WHO GOT FREEDOM ONLY SEVENTY FIVE YEARS AGO AND HAS ONE AND A HALF BILLION PEOPLE ACTUAL BHARAT GOT FREEDOM ONLY IN YEAR 2014. Jai Hind
hamare politician hume chod ke nahi vage on that time and remember the hard time makes tax reform public shows there nationalism.But I don't think u came from here because ur politician have dual citizenship and citizen have no nationalism.....sob corrupted and lot mar ke chal rahe hai .Thanks for realistic analysis sir.Hope god will help u similar to us.
Pakistan is not a republic country. Infact occupied a equiped but organized Gangster, which called Pak Army. If it is republic, then beurocracy and Judiciary work. But Pak Army do not let to do any political function.
Correct Analysis !! But problem is people are not in a position to deal with these Gangsters. It is really a grim situation from the citizen point of view. Also no outsider can help.
The current forex holding of 7 times below the gold reserves holding of Indian temple padmanabhan Swamy The curent GDP of Pakistan is Less than GDP of Mahrastra. Country that invested only on weapons is reaping it's fruits . With enemies in North in form of TTP enemies in South in form of BLA enemies in East in form of India and enemies in west inform of Taliban pakistan is doomed .
Last option is to gather money from elite class so we can pay our debt... All of us know that elite class is much richer than govt... This would be greatest ever help and favor from elite class to Pakistan and its citizens...
India progress was through multiple phases. First it was basic opening from manmohan Singh. next set of reforms was from yashwant Sinha. Then from Chidambaram. Then last set of banking reforms from Raghu ram rajan was even more beneficial. Unfortunately Pakistan has not crossed the first stage. Basic set of opening up reforms. We need to speak a lot on opening up reforms. Pakistan has a open economy only on paper. reality is productivity and competitiveness. India first set of reforms was competitiveness. license raj was put to an end. Even speaking proudly of india, Even India has got a long way to go in terms of reforms. labor, land, bureaucracy
Opening the economic was imf's condition along with cutting lpg subsidy and raising taxes Japan was the the first to invest 300$ million in indian automotive sector at that time learn how licence raj bought about bankruptcy in the country
Sir u r comparing indian situation 1991 they take Loan from iMF. Is india that time under heavy returns same today pakistan have return back billions of dollars to imf and other countries ?.
Seems Pakistani cannot survive without constant bailout...always begging and borrowing....how and when will they start repaying all this borrowed money. ?????
You said that Pakistan had option to say to the countries from which Pakistan received debts that Pakistan is not able to return their debts anymore but it actually means default means Pakistan will default. Default actually means that then how are u saying that Pakistan say to the countries from which has received the debts
Islam ki hukumat chorke ye anti islamic political parties cane to rule against islamic law. Pakistan was sleeping so this is the fruit of your stubbones to abandant the deen and follolw unislamic practises.
بد قسمتی سے کوئ بھی حکومت جب آتی ہے تو ایمانداری اور بہادری سے فیصلہ نہیں کرتے اس لئے کہ وہ ڈرتے ہیں سیاسی ناکامی سے کہ ووٹ بینک کم ہوگا لوگ ناراض ہوںگے۔ ہمیں صرف بہادر اور آزاد حکومت اور ایک اچھا ٹیم ورک چاہئے باقی پاکستان کرسکتا ہے۔
@@SHAROOZBASHIR fair enough I was wrong I thought as a Islamic nation it would not take money from kafirs . But then I guess only kafirs are the ones giving your nation aid all These years . But your right money is money and we’ll done to securing the loans . The army guys all buying big houses in uk and Canada now
absolutely agree on lavish living habit. we are the country who do not tax the rich and instead we spend hard earned dollars to fund their lavish life by allowing them to import cars worth of hundreds of thousands dollars, packed food items, and lavish home amentias used during construction and so on. We should ban all these foolish imports for 10 years atleast if we want to survive anymore. this is madness.
Bharat does not have gernails living off the fat of the land. Narasimha Rao and Manmohan took us through that phase.
But at the end of the day, Indians fell for the jingoistic nationalism of Modi in 2013. What people of India did to congress is ruthless, I mean how can you people forget the efforts of Manmohan both as a PM and an FM? India stands where it stands today is bcz of the reforms Manmohan brought during the 90s. Now India is slowly becoming an intolerant society bcz of Modi's politics of hate. This would not end up great.
@@shapackgaming4629 What India did to Cong in 2014 is why India is real Democratic nation. We rewarded them with another term in 2009 with increased majority but their term from 09 to 14 was absolutely pathetic with lot of corruption & policy paralysis. India is country of 140 Cr. We reward regime when they good & throw them out mercilessly when they don't perform. India is not jagir of any political party. We chose govt to serve us no need to be loyal slave to any govt. We currently have govt which is doing decent job. So they will get 3rd term in 24 but if they don't perform then make no mistake even they will be thrown out but if they perform we will give them more terms. India today is like this due to effort of successive govt not just 1 man. We are here due to these people
1) Narasimha Rao & Manmohan Singh - For opening Indian economy and bringing out of economic instability. They were amply supported by statesman like Vajpayee in opposition who didn't trouble govt despite being in minority. Manmohan in his UPA1 era too did some good work like cutting down subsidy on LPG, Civil Nuclear deal etc.
2) Vajapayee - Who gave a stable govt & then focussed on rapid road infrastructure & education, He steered India away from economic sanctions & led country during turbulent time of Kargil war. Tried to bring peace with neighborhood (though was betrayed by Mushraff).
3) Current Modi regime - They cut down the red tapism & fast tracked infrastructure development, electricity connectivity & rapid digitization. Modi govt led India effectively in really hard time of Covid and still leading it decently during hard time of Russian war.
@@ganeshshenoy1175 Then you must also know that know that 2 main parties of Pakistan (PPP&PMLN) both served for 4 and 3 terms respectively but none of them served for 2 consecutive terms. Anti-incumbency is at another level in Pakistan 😂. Even Imran Khan's party was going to loose badly in the upcoming election by the looks of it till the last year but fortunately for him, the two traditional party took over and made the situation worse for themselves and for the country. Imran Khan is currently in a very strong position to win the upcoming elections and he might break the tradition.
@@shapackgaming4629 are you stupid or what if tomorrow manmohan Singh comes again people will again vote for him but he was not an independent leader he was just a puppet of congress party and now congress party want that Rahul gandhi to prime minister of India lol
You only tell is there any comparison between Rahul gandhi pm modi
I’m from India and I must say that you have put in a lot of research and time for this video. Absolutely brilliant, have subscribed to your channel for more content.
Same here bro. Glad that we are indians
Glad we have modi
@@yajatsen2657 both are resource rich nations. Only difference is, they have a bad leadership and their media is obsessed with India
Very eloquent. I wish Pakistan can find peace and love. Inshallah.
Ameen thanks bro ❤️
Don't expect peace and love from Islamic ideologies
Under the plan and protection of Pak Army, the PDM and Isaq Dar delibrately fallen this country in this crises.
Very sensible person and to the point
The difference in India is we chose economy over religious politics in 1991
wrong. Don't equate their religion with our Dharma. If we become ''religious" or more Dharmic, we will become better, not worse. Educate yourself on a subject before yelping on SM. What do you know about their religion and our Dharma to create this false equivalence?
Asim Rasmalai sex racket in Pakistani army and bureaucracy is handler of Aimen Nadeem FSP 43rd CTP and behind Syeda Fatimee FSP rape and murder along husband at China border
he was comparing Pakistan with Argentina, Srilanka which is unfortunate. Argentina is running trade surplus. Sri lanka has tourism and tea exports which puts them in course correction and their current account balance is not really out of shape. Their only issue was getting loans from china. the apt comparison will be Lebanon where the currency has depreciated by 95% which has similarities like fragmented society, no exports
Why do you think that society is fragmented in Pakistan? As a Pakistani, I can say that the economic crisis in Pakistan has nothing to do with its society. Why should the society be blamed if there aren't enough opportunities for the youth, why should the society be blamed if the crime rate is surging due to unemployment, why should the society be blamed if people are homeless and are starving due to the recent floods? This is my take on the situation.
As Hasan Nisar said, "Pakistan ek pen bhi nahi bana sake"...........total wasteland of a nation full of sheikhchillis
@@KingKong-lb3vh tu pen ki BAAT krta hai, logo nai apny dam par 1-2 billion dollar e-commerce economy bana di hai Bina kisi government support Kai. Pakistan Sab Kuch bana skta hai agr government Kuch krey to.
@@shapackgaming4629 after zia ul haq pakistan society islamized and became violent extremist before that pakistani people were like Turkish people who were secular in nature and had persian and Indian influence. And also developed karachi and lahore even Europeans used to buy flats in Pakistan
@@shapackgaming4629 jenaab aise toh Phir hamare padosy mulk Afghanistan wahan toh sirf jahalat hai aur deshatgardy hai lekin uske bawajood Afghanistan Ki dollar rates Pakistan se acche hai
Keep this content of awareness, and reach out the public, as everyone can know the basic issues of the country in order to be careful in next time, while electing their representatives.
Sir India k pass Dr man mohan Singh shb thy luckily.
Or hmare pass tareen chacha, hafeez uncle & ishaq disaster shb hai unluckily.
I admire and want Pakistan to learn from India in many fields because for us India is not an enemy that's the other thing India wants to become our enemy.
But thing is things never stand still or constant things will change and become better doesn't matter we want to or not.
The actual problem is tunnel vision Neutral Nuts, whose meddling in politics & shallow mindedness has consequently imposed these IMF agents & narrow minded politicians like Nawaz, Zardari, Fazzlo, Chuadhry bros & others like them. US cannot accept any independent minded & reform bound statesman, like IK, in Pak. Therefore, they pull the strings of the colonial era mercenary Catalan company aka Establishment & get rid of him through coup. Pakistan is just like a stoner, who will be paid for weed, if he contract kill anyone.
Ek economic adviser apka Ahmediya nikla and u guys chased him out.
Atif Main is one of the Greatest Economists in the world. Said he is willing to serve Pakistan in any capacity he is called on.
Want to guess why he isn't being called on?
Enmity is ensued when the other entity is either equal or superior. Enough said.
You just ignored to mention the non-developmental & huge military expenditures.
An amazing enjoyable discussion ☺️....
Very distinct analysis, but no one from govt will take any action in regards because they are also foreigners
Pakistan faces a serious balance of payment crisis. Two things have mainly contributed to the crisis. First, the imports of foreign-made luxury goods for lavish lifestyle of the rich and super rich classes. Second, the lack of investment in domestic manufacturing sector and exports of Pakistani products. Sadly, the lion's share of cash investment goes into non-productive sector like real estate which does not generate any foreign exchange.
In a nutshell, a flawed economic policy is formulated by an extremely incompetent bureaucracy and political leadership in Islamabad. Unfortunately, Pakistan is a stubborn country where it is considered taboo to even mention the Indian model and lessons we may be able to learn from the successful economic policies of our neighbor. No wonder Pakistan is doomed in international credit market. Our government bonds are junk quality which no one wants to touch with a ten foot pole.
Saqib Sherani sb, indeed, is a great research analyst.
oh boy My head hurts already 🤕🤕
Thanks for praising Bharat
Sir correcting a bit
Bharat is not sitting at 600 BILLION DOLLAR FOREX RESERVE AND 5500 TONNE GOLD
AND WE ARE ONE AND A HALF BILLION PEOPLE SIR
WE ARE THE RICHEST NATION ON PLANET
PLEASE LET US KNOW ANY OTHER NATION WHO GOT FREEDOM ONLY SEVENTY FIVE YEARS AGO
AND HAS ONE AND A HALF BILLION PEOPLE
ACTUAL BHARAT GOT FREEDOM ONLY IN YEAR 2014.
Jai Hind
hamare politician hume chod ke nahi vage on that time and remember the hard time makes tax reform public shows there nationalism.But I don't think u came from here because ur politician have dual citizenship and citizen have no nationalism.....sob corrupted and lot mar ke chal rahe hai .Thanks for realistic analysis sir.Hope god will help u similar to us.
افسوس
Begairat behaya ghasti mughaliya ki hira Mandi me hue halala l najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool porki 😂😂😂
@@meerjahangir7807 why sorry
fully agreed mr Narismarao opened the markets to others world
Very clear analysis sir 👌
One joke one of my friends told me today at office..
I told him that pak giving aid ⛑️ to turkey...he told how by not asking loan from them..😂😂😂😂
Any source for claiming Pakistan's monthly imports are 4B USD?
Pakistan is not a republic country. Infact occupied a equiped but organized Gangster, which called Pak Army. If it is republic, then beurocracy and Judiciary work. But Pak Army do not let to do any political function.
Correct Analysis !! But problem is people are not in a position to deal with these Gangsters. It is really a grim situation from the citizen point of view. Also no outsider can help.
The current forex holding of 7 times below the gold reserves holding of Indian temple padmanabhan Swamy
The curent GDP of Pakistan is Less than GDP of Mahrastra.
Country that invested only on weapons is reaping it's fruits . With enemies in North in form of TTP enemies in South in form of BLA enemies in East in form of India and enemies in west inform of Taliban pakistan is doomed .
aaj se hi bachche paida karna bilkul zero kar do, band kar do. bahut paise bachenge.
True
@@mominaali2700 i know you pain 🥲🥲🥲
@@theexposer5303 😒😒😒😶😑😐
Can you stop music in background its hard to concentrate
Conservative fiscal spending may help, cut down terrorist education expenditure for a start.
Last option is to gather money from elite class so we can pay our debt... All of us know that elite class is much richer than govt... This would be greatest ever help and favor from elite class to Pakistan and its citizens...
Very informative
One joke one of my friends told me today at office..
I told him that pak giving aid ⛑️ to turkey...he told how by not asking loan from them..😂😂😂😂
India progress was through multiple phases. First it was basic opening from manmohan Singh. next set of reforms was from yashwant Sinha. Then from Chidambaram. Then last set of banking reforms from Raghu ram rajan was even more beneficial. Unfortunately Pakistan has not crossed the first stage. Basic set of opening up reforms. We need to speak a lot on opening up reforms. Pakistan has a open economy only on paper. reality is productivity and competitiveness. India first set of reforms was competitiveness. license raj was put to an end. Even speaking proudly of india, Even India has got a long way to go in terms of reforms. labor, land, bureaucracy
Opening the economic was imf's condition along with cutting lpg subsidy and raising taxes Japan was the the first to invest 300$ million in indian automotive sector at that time learn how licence raj bought about bankruptcy in the country
Army jaan chore is mulk ki to hi mulk aage barhe.
I think video is the date 6 two day late🤔
Video k doran music khtm kro plz
Economist is Sherani
Means default confirm hy.
Sir u r comparing indian situation 1991 they take Loan from iMF. Is india that time under heavy returns same today pakistan have return back billions of dollars to imf and other countries ?.
🤲
Seems Pakistani cannot survive without constant bailout...always begging and borrowing....how and when will they start repaying all this borrowed money. ?????
You said that Pakistan had option to say to the countries from which Pakistan received debts that Pakistan is not able to return their debts anymore but it actually means default means Pakistan will default. Default actually means that then how are u saying that Pakistan say to the countries from which has received the debts
This guy is unbelievable. Pakistan imported thousands of luxury vehicles in the last month or so. Where is the cost cutting or import stopping?
Turkey can be another example.
Islam ki hukumat chorke ye anti islamic political parties cane to rule against islamic law. Pakistan was sleeping so this is the fruit of your stubbones to abandant the deen and follolw unislamic practises.
بد قسمتی سے کوئ بھی حکومت جب آتی ہے تو ایمانداری اور بہادری سے فیصلہ نہیں کرتے اس لئے کہ وہ ڈرتے ہیں سیاسی ناکامی سے کہ ووٹ بینک کم ہوگا لوگ ناراض ہوںگے۔ ہمیں صرف بہادر اور آزاد حکومت اور ایک اچھا ٹیم ورک چاہئے باقی پاکستان کرسکتا ہے۔
Default Hona cheye Pakistan ko
Ye janwaron ka rawar esi qabil hy.
Bangladesh has higher GDP than Pakistan.
Going to imf asking kafir money ? What is going on ?
Money is money! And IMF is International Monetary Fund not Indian Monetary Fund.
@@SHAROOZBASHIR IMF toh Ihudi logo ka paisa hai.
@@SHAROOZBASHIR but interest is haram.. So why accept high interest loans?
Han bhik mangte time wo nahi dekhna chahiye
@@SHAROOZBASHIR fair enough I was wrong I thought as a Islamic nation it would not take money from kafirs . But then I guess only kafirs are the ones giving your nation aid all These years .
But your right money is money and we’ll done to securing the loans . The army guys all buying big houses in uk and Canada now
Jajwa 🤣🤣
Aff
im pakistani and i got surprised?? the electricity didnt go out and the currency is dropping little by little
Are bhai tum Afghanistan me game khelte ho, koi tumhare saath game khelta hai. Rona kis baat ka?
Reunification of india and pakistan is need of the hour now to make Pakistan economically rich
Lol. So you won't do anything on your own but you just want the wealth created by kafirs and mushriks.
No thanks!
Gilgit Baltistan dedo..baaki nahi chahiye...humne aage badna hai
Indians from day 1 struggling to kill Pakistan but there is Allah the Saviour
@@zeesmart6540 was your allah on vacation in 71?
islam choro, pakistan theek hojaye gaa