@shamwikkis1551 Basically, "I bought a haunted cartridge at a garage sale" is one of the cheapest, most unoriginal creepypasta beginnings you can come up with.
@@SirAsdfyeah, but Ben Drowned was the first story to use that setup. Also, that’s not what he’s referring to. He’s referring to the fact that the creepypasta is only the first part of a huge ARG
18:01 I dont know about the oldest zelda games but fairys are used to revive link when he runs out of health. It probably represents the kids passing by becoming the zelda equivalent of an angel, but it could also imply a loop back to the first video. Especially the part with the distorted fairy fountain music.
I played the first Zelda and the fairies do the same thing as the other Zelda games, however they did reuse the sprites for over-world fairies and great fairies.
The Macabre Experiment one kinda irritated me because of its presentation. With analog horror the main reason why people like it is because of nostalgia. It takes something like a news clip, cartoon, or tv show and corrupts it in a way that is somewhat believable for its time. I don't get that same impression from Macabre Experiment, it just looks like they added VHS effects and distortions to media that wouldn't have been on VHS. This would've been better if they took inspiration from digital analog horror that replicates 2000s internet crustiness rather than VHS analog horror.
agreed u cant just slap on some effects and maybe tweak with the clips and call it ur own u have to bring something to the table that is unique but the 2nd one is pretty cool and unique tho
Jesus, I don't think I've had an experience with analog horror that kept me up at night since my first watch of the Walten Files. Nowadays I'm so desensitized to AH stuff that I mostly just watch it for the lore/ARG elements, because mystery is fun to puzzle out. But... that scene with presumably Jack being beaten to death by his father, even with the censoring, was just... brutal. Horrific. Way further than most AH series are willing to go. The pleading, the text getting more jumbled as though spoken through sobs or grievous wounds, each horrifyingly pitiable phrase being punctuated with another terrible crunch... Props to Maple Riot. Serious props. Some of the worst shit I've ever seen, in the best possible way.
In LOZ we get more insight with captions on basement I accidentally had captions of and it said some stuff that you wont hear in the video. If this is present in other videos, I don’t know I’m to lazy to see but I just wanted to point that out hopefully you’ll see this.
I have a theory of what maybe happening with the LOZ series, I think what happened was that the young boy Jack accidentally came across his father killing someone maybe his siblings which drove his dad into a rage. And which had caused the chase that lead to being brutally killed in the basement. Cause as he was attacked he said he wouldn't tell his mom what he saw, and that makes me think he either found the dead bodies of his siblings or some other kids or something else dark that Jack's father was keeping a secret and he had to kill Jack to keep.
Stuffy Studios made a new analog horror video called “Enola’s Minigames” and it’s pretty terrifying. I would like to see a video explaining the lore or something, would be cool :)
Awesome! I highly recommend checking out stuffys other work as well, like the two chapters of malediction (its an interactive TH-cam game with a pretty unique story) i wouldnt call it a straight up horror series, but it definitely leans into the genre a bit I think it’s REALLY underrated as well 😂
Thank you for knowing how to pronounce Macabre I watched someone else cover the series a while back, and they kept pronouncing it like McCabber. Drove me nuts
@@isabelortiz1230 if you imagine it it's still a rendition of a child being bludgeoned to death by a sledgehammer, didn't give me chills but more of a semi uneasy feeling
on a completely unrelated note: 7:44 sometimes when its dark and i close my eyes i see those almost exact two eyes staring back at me but their green. They're even unlevel like that. Weird.
No joke, I was watching a video a bit ago, and then this appeared. When I read the words "I just want to be freed," my mind went to the commercial (song idk if it's a parody) that goes "I want to break free" and it's like, a laundry commercial of sorts I think. Been a while since I last heard it 😂
12:29 At the top where it says enter your name the word your gets replaced with the word me for a second, 13:16 it also says elimination mode at the bottom but that might be a part of the og game but idk.
9:49 now everything goes back to the Mandela catalogue? I THINK NOT, Ben Drowned as one of the first ORIGINAL analogue horrors/ creepy pasta, it’s sad to see almost everyone in the anolouge horror conk follow the same script of: New species or scary thing discovered, mimics, people die.
The original Ben Drowned story is really good and I’d like to see more people cover it. The ARG and story ended a few years ago and was really fun to witness in real time
If i were to die and posses a video game, it be pokemon emerald, or ORAS. I'd be the chillest ghost ever lol. Sometimes challenge the player to a battle with my own team, and if the player say no to the battle, i'd be "cool ok, see you next gym battle, peace" the only way i'd force the player to a fight, it be after the champion, kinda like the steven fight or after the delta episode. Heck, i want to kinda fight competitive and i think the player would like to have a "real" fight
I wouldn't say LOZ is a horror, its just one hit after another, its interesting to look at but not at all scary, kinda predictable BUT its pretty and high effort.
Something that has irked me on nearly every analog horror series i've seen (especially back when the shovelware piracy screens were big) and it really tries to kill my immersion every time, but, say it with me, hardware limitations. I'm getting so tired of people doing analog horror, an artform predicated on recreating the nostalgic feeling of something from years of yore, and just not doing their homework/paying attention to detail. Example: say we're watching a super mario all stars analogue horror. It's starting to freak out, at the crescendo we get a GBA crash sound. Now, you dont need to be a nerd to know the SNES's sound chip isnt quite as powerful as a GBA's.
I'm gonna be honest, this is a bit.. cliche. The "analog horror" style is very overplayed, plus the original Ben Drowned has way more effort put into it, since it's an entire mod of the game, while this ARG is just a bunch of photoshopped images and VHS filter. Although the 2nd part is a bit more interesting
If you watched the macabre experiment beyond that episode, you would realize that that's kinda the point. The whole series is about what if all these famous creepypastas where experiments done by someone and it actually has an over arching story to do with all the creepypastas that are featured in the videos and what the experiments even are
So my personal interpretation of Macrabre Experiment 3 is that it's actually a criticism of people who just try throwing well known internet horror icons into their stories in an attempt to make it seem good... Ben is just sick of being thrown into your fanfics and x reader fics.... He just wants to rest in peace outside of the empty shell of the link statue.... It's a stretch but I quite like it
both of these kind of suck really bad, imo. one is a clout chasing retread of stuff from the mid 2000s that saps the tension with dumb "OOO SPOOKY FACE" horror while the other is just grainy gameplay with bad visual effects and no depth
i like how my parents whipped out the nintendo 64 a few days ago and it had OoT on it and i wanted to play majora's mask as a used copy but i dont think i want to do that anymore... (btw my name is really oliver)
Ben do be drowning
and "JACK" do be "JACK"
Fax
Benjamin is indeed losing his ability to breathe underwater
Something something it's drowning time and drowned everywhere? Idk 🗿
@@calebd3947rip Benjamin Franklin
Ben drown was the pioneer of analog horror, is sad that almost everyone got stuck on the first step of the story
Agreed
wym?
@shamwikkis1551 Basically, "I bought a haunted cartridge at a garage sale" is one of the cheapest, most unoriginal creepypasta beginnings you can come up with.
@@SirAsdf ohh
@@SirAsdfyeah, but Ben Drowned was the first story to use that setup. Also, that’s not what he’s referring to. He’s referring to the fact that the creepypasta is only the first part of a huge ARG
18:01
I dont know about the oldest zelda games but fairys are used to revive link when he runs out of health.
It probably represents the kids passing by becoming the zelda equivalent of an angel, but it could also imply a loop back to the first video. Especially the part with the distorted fairy fountain music.
I played the first Zelda and the fairies do the same thing as the other Zelda games, however they did reuse the sprites for over-world fairies and great fairies.
In LOZ: the basement if you turn on captions it will say "he's home early" and "i'm serious i didn't see anything"
The dad died after that
6:51 Holy shit, that's a mix of Link statue with The Maze Game screamer. Finally someone made imagery using it lol, that face scared me for years.
Ganondorf got so much drip, it got ben drownin'
I LOVE the Macabre Experiments by Stuffy Studios! Thanks for mentioning it, Sunflower. You never fail to impress/amuse me💕🌻
The Macabre Experiment one kinda irritated me because of its presentation. With analog horror the main reason why people like it is because of nostalgia. It takes something like a news clip, cartoon, or tv show and corrupts it in a way that is somewhat believable for its time. I don't get that same impression from Macabre Experiment, it just looks like they added VHS effects and distortions to media that wouldn't have been on VHS. This would've been better if they took inspiration from digital analog horror that replicates 2000s internet crustiness rather than VHS analog horror.
agreed u cant just slap on some effects and maybe tweak with the clips and call it ur own u have to bring something to the table that is unique
but the 2nd one is pretty cool and unique tho
it also would've been better if they had a single original idea lmao
@@CybenX_yt yeparooni
That analogue horror
You do realize that Majora's Mask was released like 5 years before VHSs were phased out right?
That “without him” scared me so fucking bad that jumpscare killed me 💀
NO SWEARING
2nd amendment
I don't blame you this is horrifying
7:29 fun fact that shadow dude (I call him Mandela catalog dude) appears in EVERYSINGLE video in the Macabre experiment
Your video on the splatoon analog horror was great, i got chills from it in some instances, this will be a good one for sure as well
Jesus, I don't think I've had an experience with analog horror that kept me up at night since my first watch of the Walten Files. Nowadays I'm so desensitized to AH stuff that I mostly just watch it for the lore/ARG elements, because mystery is fun to puzzle out. But... that scene with presumably Jack being beaten to death by his father, even with the censoring, was just... brutal. Horrific. Way further than most AH series are willing to go. The pleading, the text getting more jumbled as though spoken through sobs or grievous wounds, each horrifyingly pitiable phrase being punctuated with another terrible crunch...
Props to Maple Riot. Serious props. Some of the worst shit I've ever seen, in the best possible way.
You know it's good when it leaves me cravin' for *MORE.*
I didn't know Ben got that Walten Files DLC
He really had to censor that pixelated child even more lol
In LOZ we get more insight with captions on basement I accidentally had captions of and it said some stuff that you wont hear in the video. If this is present in other videos, I don’t know I’m to lazy to see but I just wanted to point that out hopefully you’ll see this.
I have a theory of what maybe happening with the LOZ series, I think what happened was that the young boy Jack accidentally came across his father killing someone maybe his siblings which drove his dad into a rage. And which had caused the chase that lead to being brutally killed in the basement. Cause as he was attacked he said he wouldn't tell his mom what he saw, and that makes me think he either found the dead bodies of his siblings or some other kids or something else dark that Jack's father was keeping a secret and he had to kill Jack to keep.
Stuffy Studios made a new analog horror video called “Enola’s Minigames” and it’s pretty terrifying.
I would like to see a video explaining the lore or something, would be cool :)
Awesome! I highly recommend checking out stuffys other work as well, like the two chapters of malediction (its an interactive TH-cam game with a pretty unique story) i wouldnt call it a straight up horror series, but it definitely leans into the genre a bit
I think it’s REALLY underrated as well 😂
Ben: (playing Minecraft)
Drowned: *exists*
[[This information has been stricken from the record and cannot be viewed.]]
The moment after you said "Things appear to be normal." Then link started burning to death i audibly said "Ope there it is!"
The skull kid laugh still makes me uneasy to this day
Congrats on 50K!!!
Hey thanks a bunch!
Thank you for knowing how to pronounce Macabre
I watched someone else cover the series a while back, and they kept pronouncing it like McCabber. Drove me nuts
Can I just say, i'm glad you censored *that* scene as graphic content really makes me uncomfortable
It wasn't that graphic
@@isabelortiz1230 if you imagine it it's still a rendition of a child being bludgeoned to death by a sledgehammer, didn't give me chills but more of a semi uneasy feeling
Imagine repeatedly getting hit by a sledgehammer
Could never be me lmao 💀
on a completely unrelated note: 7:44 sometimes when its dark and i close my eyes i see those almost exact two eyes staring back at me but their green. They're even unlevel like that. Weird.
8:06 "i just want to be free"
*a few seconds pass*
"God damn my back is killing me"
banger video!!
great vid sunflower!
Whats old is new again. THE DAY OF ALL THE BLOOD! AND THEN A SKELETON POPPED OUT!
You could do a video covering the rest of the macabre experiment series. That would be interesting
Finally a version of ben drowned that isn’t made by a cryptobro
Was the original made by a crypto bro? And does that end up influencing the OG series?
Same question, what happened to the original?
@@Mauripsu he decided to sell the original videos as nft’s
@@davindean6780 Scummy and stupid ngl
@@davindean6780HE WHAT
No joke, I was watching a video a bit ago, and then this appeared. When I read the words "I just want to be freed," my mind went to the commercial (song idk if it's a parody) that goes "I want to break free" and it's like, a laundry commercial of sorts I think. Been a while since I last heard it 😂
Correction: Majora's Mask is the emperor of dark Zelda games, not even close.
Your channel is pretty good man! Keep it up! :D
19:00 ok but like you should definetly cover TMK if you havent already. the story goes deeper than the SM64 and BD videos.
I've seen a few people now recommend covering it so I'll have to look into it more 👀
@@Sunflower41XD WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
You should do a full video on the Kirby one
No way is Benjamin creepypasta drowning
Man my friends are lacking they love Analog Horror and never showed me the LOZ one?!
12:48 "Register my name" nah im good
I know the sinking stomach feeling, Jesus it's a weird feeling
Benjamin inhales too much water with a lack of oxygen In which Benjamin looses his life due to suffocation
Oh cool
hey stuffy
16:24 this you?
Creepypastas vs deleting the save file (it deletes the ghost too)
Haunted cartridges vs hydraulic press
12:29 At the top where it says enter your name the word your gets replaced with the word me for a second, 13:16 it also says elimination mode at the bottom but that might be a part of the og game but idk.
Wow Ben drowned again.
But for real tho, I love these creepy pasta reimaginings. They are groovy.
i saw the first loz video and went: "this is a story about an abusive dad!" and i was right.
Me resisting the urge to rewrite Ben Drowned to have an ending where Ben is freed and laid to rest
13:05 To me, it looks like the sprite of Link, I mean Jack, looking up at you, the viewer, instead of looking forward like in normal gameplay.
i accidentally read "i just want to be bread"
They'll make an analog horror vid on anything, huh?
Yes, and I am grateful for that
9:49 now everything goes back to the Mandela catalogue? I THINK NOT, Ben Drowned as one of the first ORIGINAL analogue horrors/ creepy pasta, it’s sad to see almost everyone in the anolouge horror conk follow the same script of: New species or scary thing discovered, mimics, people die.
The original Ben Drowned story is really good and I’d like to see more people cover it. The ARG and story ended a few years ago and was really fun to witness in real time
16:20 Back on my soapbox about hardware accuracy: the NES would not produce that reverb.
13:10 the other save files could represent jack's siblings
Maple riot has a great Kirby series too. He just has a bad habit of not finishing anything
Oh my god! They killed kenny... I mean jack!
you bastards
Damn there was a cult? I need to reread Ben Drowned. I only remember parts of the story but it's been freaking years
and it's NOT a rehash of Ben Drowned? LET'S GO
Mofos literally spooked by jerma faces.
I can’t believe Ben got FNAF’d into Majora’s Mask that’s so freaking cool
i said "No, fuck off" and flipped off ben when he said he wanted to rest peacefully, and he jumpscared me as revenge >:(
I think the distorted picture is funny partly because the eyes appear to be looking in opposite directions, which is almost always funny.
For the first one, that smiley face goofball is theorized to be Ethan Macabre, the founder of the lab these experiments take place in.
If I died and had to haunt a game it wouldn't be Zelda it would be de blob 2 on Wii the greatest game of all time
What about… LOZ: the basement..?
I like both versions although the macabre version is just the 1st chapter.
Ben really said "i want to break free"
Bruh I would think a Metroid analog horror series would a hit
its not “oh no samus is possessed by a child” it follows the story of metroid from samus’s view
@@Odindoesstuffreal I meant like about the space pirates
The second one hit different because my name is Jack and I love The Legend Of Zelda series 🥶
Good job
Ben when he drowns
The Ben Drowned ARG was much better than this Analog Horror attempt
If i were to die and posses a video game, it be pokemon emerald, or ORAS. I'd be the chillest ghost ever lol. Sometimes challenge the player to a battle with my own team, and if the player say no to the battle, i'd be "cool ok, see you next gym battle, peace" the only way i'd force the player to a fight, it be after the champion, kinda like the steven fight or after the delta episode. Heck, i want to kinda fight competitive and i think the player would like to have a "real" fight
For LOZ the mom is the thing that comes after jack
Is that the imposter? Seems like it as it shows link not Zelda!
I wouldn't say LOZ is a horror, its just one hit after another, its interesting to look at but not at all scary, kinda predictable BUT its pretty and high effort.
There was some very creepy pasta :( 🍝🍝🍝
To analyze this properly you have to include the entire Macabre series
Did somebody mention the door to darkness.
Something that has irked me on nearly every analog horror series i've seen (especially back when the shovelware piracy screens were big) and it really tries to kill my immersion every time, but, say it with me, hardware limitations. I'm getting so tired of people doing analog horror, an artform predicated on recreating the nostalgic feeling of something from years of yore, and just not doing their homework/paying attention to detail.
Example: say we're watching a super mario all stars analogue horror. It's starting to freak out, at the crescendo we get a GBA crash sound. Now, you dont need to be a nerd to know the SNES's sound chip isnt quite as powerful as a GBA's.
I'm gonna be honest, this is a bit.. cliche. The "analog horror" style is very overplayed, plus the original Ben Drowned has way more effort put into it, since it's an entire mod of the game, while this ARG is just a bunch of photoshopped images and VHS filter. Although the 2nd part is a bit more interesting
If you watched the macabre experiment beyond that episode, you would realize that that's kinda the point. The whole series is about what if all these famous creepypastas where experiments done by someone and it actually has an over arching story to do with all the creepypastas that are featured in the videos and what the experiments even are
@@jeremypool6888 exactly , one of my favorite analog horrors
It’s an internet story bro, I think your overthinking it.
@@le_idiot5442 Él tiene razón, la historia es muy cliché.
I love this so much
So my personal interpretation of Macrabre Experiment 3 is that it's actually a criticism of people who just try throwing well known internet horror icons into their stories in an attempt to make it seem good...
Ben is just sick of being thrown into your fanfics and x reader fics.... He just wants to rest in peace outside of the empty shell of the link statue....
It's a stretch but I quite like it
5:37 looks like he has a goatee
oh fuck yeah i was obsessed with ben drowned as a teenager
Thumbnail goofy asl 💀💀
You 💀
Or maybe ben Father help from the evil energy, How to cheat death.
Benjamin really did drown fr
Den browned
Oh my god finally
The scariest part of LOZ is that he doesn't go for the sword like dude get the sword
Edit: Nevermind its the bludgeoning
O LORD
GIVE
ICEBERG
both of these kind of suck really bad, imo. one is a clout chasing retread of stuff from the mid 2000s that saps the tension with dumb "OOO SPOOKY FACE" horror while the other is just grainy gameplay with bad visual effects and no depth
First Needle mouse now we got
broo my dad just got me majoras mask guys! it looks pretty weird should i play it 🤔
Yep TOTALLY safe
niceeeeeee, new vid.
i like how my parents whipped out the nintendo 64 a few days ago and it had OoT on it and i wanted to play majora's mask as a used copy but i dont think i want to do that anymore... (btw my name is really oliver)
stuffy commented lol
i see you hiding in the comments i see you