"So casually cruel in the name of being honest" is one of the best lyrics from any song, from any genre, ever. And its just one tiny line that passes by in a 10 minute masterpiece.
I’ve always thought that that was the line that really solidified her ability as a lyricist. But I’ve also always thought this was her best song and the extra length only adds to that
@@MrUssy101 you must be a very lonely person and horrible person if you think the way that he treated her was in any way correct. I feel truly bad for you. Please get help
@@MrUssy101 the door is open for you to walk out, why listen when you just wanna comment such bad things Abt her, dude it ain't worth it I'm telling you.
Her short film playing in the background makes this performance magical, her past is literally behind her as she remembers on it wow. You can hear how real it is for her
@@Mac-dt3iz she never mentioned him by name, and shes just re recording a song so she actually owns it again. what do u want her to do, not re record one of the best songs from the album and let shamrock holdings own it?
Taylor is my inspiration!! My mom said that if I got 5k LIKES on my new song!! She definitely buy me a professional mic!! Begging you GUYS!! Please...I LOVE YOU! I'M NOT LYING! PLS!.
@Jack W. Oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh You need to calm down (you need to calm down) You're being too loud (you're being too loud) And I'm just like oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh You need to just stop (can you stop?) Like, can you just not step on our gowns? You need to calm down
With all of those efforts but still got few views when compared to Easy on Me live on NRJ. Let's not forget that her vocals sounded so awful in this performance.
I’m still having trouble processing the fact that she’s giving a live performance of the full version of this song almost a decade after it was released. what a time to be a swiftie
I'm a 67 year old man, I've been in a lot of relationships and this song had me crying for 8 minutes of it, been on both side of the story. I am amazed by her.
@@TheMark60172why are you watching a Taylor “swizzle” performance if you don’t even like her, and looks like you scroll through the comments!! Ur a true Swizzle fan 😉
@daemurua3511 sad life you say, will that make you cry also? Hopefully not 8 min. Im not a Taylor Swift song, but dude please try to Shake it off. I mean, dont hold a grudge until August and leave yourself with a Blank Space. If you dont stop crying, its gonna be a cruel summer for you man! In closing, stop feeling sad, go out to a bar and make the whole room shimmer and be Nice!
Please dont get me wrong...not laughing at you cause your 67 and crying...just you commenting is bad enough, but for a 67 year old man to say he cried over a swift song for 8 min is absolutely hilarious. Please put out a video of you with a box of tissues, curtains down, dark room, and Lover is playing while you sip some Cabarnet and ball your eyes out. Ill pay a grand as a starting bid to see that live!
This 10 minute version has been wanted for so long and she’s giving all of her. It’s such a masterpiece, just like we thought it would be. RED IS A MASTERPIECE.
Taylor is truly an excellent songwriter. I've never had a boyfriend but when I listen to the song, I feel like I lived it myself. She reflects her emotions and feelings very well in her songs.
I think Taylor Swift may have a possible future as a budding filmaker too or film writer I'm not a Taylor Swift fan but the way she created the story, and how the highs and lows of the relationship were shown felt very realistic and of course can't forget credit to the actors themselves Sadie and Dylan had great chemistry together. I was definitely feeling very emotional and melancholy after it. Well done to Taylor
I barely memorize 3 minutes song. 😂 Taylor is a genius plus, dont you need a break after a 3 mins song? How she continue for 10 mins. Even during the music solo, she still need to put her energy playing the guitar😂
Same! When I very first listened to this, I'll admit I wasn't as impressed. I guess I was expecting different lyrics. But, I watched the short film and ever since then, I can't stop listening to this version. It's almost like I can't listen to the 5 minute one, knowing how much added depth the 10 minute holds. There was so much left unsaid when it came out in 2012, and the 10 minute version somehow makes the song ten times more mature, and showcases more of what went on behind the scenes. I don't think I've ever heard a song so tangible. The tone of the song, and the way she sings it lets you actually FEEL the story and you can feel what she's feeling. And sadly, that tells me just how much worse the relationship was than we all thought before with the original version of the song.
This song is a love letter to every person who feels like that they feel too much, think too hard, and remember the details that most seldom do. Those are the people with the softest hearts, the greatest minds, the most giving of hands. Taylor Swift captured that simple truth in this song, and I cannot possibly thank her enough for it.
I just spent the night with my ex and we talked. It was freeing. Cause I am one of those people who feels everything. I pick up on small details. They simply weren't weren't realizing how much the little things, that they didn't care about were the ones that actually mattered the most.
probably the reason why the 10 minute version isn’t boring to listen to and to watch the performance is that the song has a story to follow, it’s like taylor’s telling a story in a way that she’s just singing it out. not to mention the fact that the lyrics are damn painful and relatable.
It also doesn’t have a repeated chorus, it’s different each time and keeps you engaged. I was never a swift fan until I saw this and I’m blown away each time
It's a refreshing song while we're in the midst of famous main pop songs that aren't... as meaningful. Most songs rn are famous because of its beat (I'm not saying that this is wrong but that's just making this stand out more. Not to mention, this is a literal lyrical masterpiece).
They’ve been together with Taylor like 9-10 years ago. Some of Taylor’s band members are still with her since the first time she started her music career. Taylor must loves them so much and so they are 🤧
I love that her back-up singers are the same women we've seen by her side for years. It's a testament to her character that they're still by her side, smiling, and full of joy performing for and with her.
It also shows how she treat them, cause I mean if she wasn't caring and such they will talk against her, but no. They did not and can not, it is because she was and is still grateful to all of them and I love that about her.
I believe these are the vocalists she's had since Red first came out. In fact, her band has been pretty much the same since Fearless, and the few that have left she's still in touch with. Her old vocalist Liz Huett even makes a few appearances on Red TV.
Her lyrics and storytelling is everything. The story of the naive girl who fell in love with an older man who cannot commit and take her seriously as she did is truly heartbreaking. I just cant.
That reminds me of her “i am the man” music video where there is a younger woman who is marrying an older guy and it seems like she is a gold digger bc of a GIANT diamond on her finger. I think it points to how when a younger guy dates an older woman he is never seen as a gold digger, but when it’s a younger woman dating an older man she’s is almost always seen as a gold digger
People say she’s being dramatic cause she wrote a 10min song about a short relationship but it’s not about how long or short a relationship is. It’s about what that person made you feel during those times. She fell hard fast and there’s nothing wrong with that. She was young. I can write a 10 page essay about a relationship I didn’t even have 🤣🤣🤣
I actually think it’s easier to write a song about a short relationship because you can focus on those moments because those moments are so brief they have more meaning attached to them. It actually makes it easier to make those moments even more dramatic. Not that that’s a bad thing🤷🏼♂️
As an adult male, I never really understood the Taylor phenomenon. Until I watched her sing this song at the Grammys. Then I found this. The young lady is incredibly talented. She played piano at Grammy’s and guitar on SNL. I have to believe her best attribute is writing after hearing these lyrics. I believe she writes her own music. The lyrics in this song are mind blowing. I love the up tempo and down tempo. Especially when they get to the first snow. That was so cool. Great song. Great performances. Kudos to her insanely talented backup singers.
@@stardolphin783 Im thinking the same thing. Also they're the type of song that can be really repeated a number of times cos they have so much in them, and the switch of tone.
"I'm a soldier who's returning half her weight" - such a beautiful way to describe the toll a relationship like this takes on you - from eating disorders to loosing your other half..
No words. It's really difficult to keep a listener's attention for ten minutes with the same song and have them want to revisit it, too. Taylor was meant to do exactly what she's doing now.
SNL really went all out with this performance. They gave her a 10 minute time slot when most people get 2 3 minute time slots, they put leaves on the ground for the autumn aesthetic, they gave her a screen to show her short film, and they made it snow.
The fact that she originally thought no one wanted to hear this version because it’s 10 minutes…an absolute masterpiece. I truly hope she submits for the Grammy’s because this deserves so much.
I hope she submitted All Too Well (10 Minute Version) in next year’s Grammys cuz this song needs a Grammy for the most rare written song we ever heard in 10 minutes
Count me another fan. I've never paid 30 seconds of attention to her until the last couple of weeks but I've watched a bunch of interviews and YT videos, just started listening to some songs in the last few days. I'm stunned at her creativity, humor, authenticity, compassion, strength, courage, and the way she is turning her love of life into an incredibly powerful inspiration of a life for so many, including me, a 66 year old guy. Brings levels of hope I wouldn't have thought possible from someone I had always written off as a teeny-bopper bubble-gum pop star. I've never disliked her, just simply never knew who she really is. I'm deeply impressed with her now and wish her (and everyone she touches) many blessings onward.
I don't know if re-recorded albums are eligible for grammys but this song definitely deserves one. So compelling, you can actually feel the pain from all those years ago. Way to go Taylor
People are simply comparing to their own taste in musical artists, humans like to argue by stating extremes. I'm not Swift fan, I think she's got some incredibly catchy songs that stick in your year. I was actually brought here by some comments about how no one but Swift could make a 10 minute song because no one matches her talent (insane claim, tons of 10, 20, 30 minute songs out there). Is she talented? Of course, no denying it. Is she the most talented musician ever? Of course not. Isn't the most successful musician of all time at this point? That seems like it should be enough for her fans to dismiss people saying she has "no" talent.
I have one, and I'm suffering and loving a lot, he is bi-closeted, with a girlfriend. And I feel so so bad because of that. But this feeling is like...is something I believed couldn't be feel.
The fact that she made a 10 minute song that you don’t get bored of listening to halfway through just shows how incredibly talented she is. She’s just pure musical genius and has been since day one. So proud of her🥲
This is the ONLY ten minute song I've ever been willing and excited to listen to. I can't even listen to Stariway to Heaven all the way through (no offense, Led Zeppelin)
Lol bruh it’s a song for women who have relationship problems. It’s the one chord that she is playing over and over I found it incredibly boring??? Ok ??
People love to hate on her but you can’t deny her staying power. She’s 15 years into her career and still breaking records left and right. Every album she puts out, even ones from a decade ago, go number 1 and a 10 minute song originally from a decade ago went number 1. She’s just as relevant now after 15 years as other new artists in their prime.
Well I mean she is still quite young... So by normal Hollywood standards she is still in her prime and would remain so for quite a few years, especially if she keeps putting out masterpieces like this one
Even with the imperfections that would have been edited out in a studio version, this is the best to watch. The break added in the middle is perfect, as is the a cappella ending. Her acknowledging the background singers is another mark of Taylor's charm. Taylor always knows where the camera is.
@carlos non-ya Fearless had already won Album of the Year, it didn’t make any sense to submit it and it competing against evermore. If she submits Red it would be for the 2023 Grammys, and given that is was snubbed before, I definitely think she will give it the second chance it deserves at winning a Grammy
the fact that other celebs attended on this performance is the next level of excitement (JoeJonas,SophieTurner,CaraDelevigne,AnyaTaylorJoy,SelenaGomez,RyanReynolds,BlakeLively)
What makes this song so iconic and relatable is the fact that almost all of us have experienced a scenario of being gaslit in a relationship and being told that “it” wasn’t real, wasn’t a big deal, didn’t mean much, etc. when you know it WAS something special, something different. It is such a unique and horrific pain to have those feelings invalidated by another and Taylor completely captures that emotion with her lyrics.
GAGAGAGAGAGA! I will now count to 3 and then I am still the unprettiest TH-camr of all time. 1...2...3. GAGAGAGAGAGA!!! Thank you for your attention, dear tom
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 The fact that you made that comment. she regularly stands on stage for three hours at a time putting on a show. Do you think she can handle one10 minutes on? It doesn’t require vocal stamina it’s a very simple song to sing. It’s not like she’s hitting Mariah Carey whistle notes for 10 minutes😂😂
I usually don't say that everything happens for a reason, but in this case I believe it did. Because if it wasn't for her dispute with her previous label, this version most likely would have never seen the light of day, the songs from the vault wouldn't have been released either, not to mention All Too Well perhaps wouldn't have got a short film. But instead all of her albums are getting even more appreciation and recognition than they did (meaning more people discover her music). It really worked out so well for her.
Red as album and all too well got attention that it deserved to get at the first place. Cause now it's no longer just fan favourite song or album but literally every one is liking it.. thanks to folklore and evermore which opened eyes of many that Taylor was and is best songwriter but jealous media and people elbowed her down!
@@JenniferJiang2013 how can it be a secret session when the album was already released and the event wasn't even secret? 😂 It was all too well short film premiere where she performed the all too well 10 minute version for the first time.
@@venlalehtinen5766 because it wasn’t live streamed and wasn’t an open event. everyone who attended was chosen. It was an intimate performance. So it doesn’t count
@@jaceplaysgames5031 Well, I'm kinda old. Guns N' Roses, Iron Maiden, Led Zeppelin, Tool, Pink Floyd, The Doors, Jimmy Hendrix all had songs longer than 10 minutes so...I'm just saying, it's not like a record. Plus, if an artist can do an hour+ concert, I'm sure a 10 minute song is not that big of an achievement for them. js
This performance is huge. The lighting how it goes back and forth from reddish tones to bluish tones is symbolic. Same as the video. You’ll see the tones change. When the love is magical and intense it’s red…. when it’s painful and falling apart it’s blue. It’s interesting seeing the different tones pass over her face. No doubt she directed this performance.
...I mean, these are completely fine, but they aren't even close to a bunch of other vocalists 🤷♀️ don't over romanticism people. Her songwriting is absolutely top shelf.
Correction: Her vocals are nice. There are a bunch of other singers who have way better voices than her. Her songwriting skills are the one that is a masterpiece.
A masterpiece. The only reason I don’t want a 20 minute version is because I’d never want Taylor Swift to go through that. An outstanding performance and from the heart 💯
The fact that she can write a ten minute song using the same four chords the entire time and somehow keep it entirely engaging and exciting through her lyrics and melodies is truly a testament to her particular style of genius.
Unpopular opinion, but I wish she had switched it up more musically. She’s a genius lyrically but the song felt monotonous to me. Especially when there was so much potential to use the music to support her lyrics.
“The idea you had of me, who was she?” Just hits me. It reminds me of my toxic ex and how I pretended to be someone I wasn’t just to please him. I’d love to know who he thought I was or who he thought he could mold me into.
Hey guys I’m a 21 year old pop singer-songwriter based in New York who just uploaded a new single and video called "Rude Awakening" that is available now on all streaming platforms. If you take the time to listen I think you may be pleasantly surprised and find the chorus stuck in your head- check it out!
Why Taylor the attention seeker songs are always about relationship problems?? Redhead 🧑🦰 in this mv was portrayed as typical drama queen Taylor making a scene out of nothing, blaming the poor guy ??? WHY ??????
The fact that she loves her fans so much to do all this for us. We've asked for almost a decade for the full version and she did it because she knew what it would mean to us - I'm crying. She deserves everything she has and more. What a rare and beautiful person
Her lyrics are so timeless and sad. I think anyone can relate to her in different ways. I’m 29 yo and happily married now, but this song reminds me of the way I felt at 17 when the boy I liked broke my heart,
I'm literally in the same situation. Happily married. But at 17 when your heart is broken for the first time, it's a pain you think you won't get over. You feel everything so deeply. She grasped that feeling in this song. I can go back to that time if I just close my eyes and listen.
This song hits straight to my heart because the exact same thing happened to me. We fell in love and we were 9.5 years apart, 22 and 31. We were together for 3 months non stop and something (he said it was age as well) happened where he started to pull away. He finally did the no call/no show thing and we broke up. Then for two years he was in and out of my life until I finally said I couldn’t take it anymore. He is the love of my life but it didn’t work out. Every person he has ever been with since then has characteristics that are like me, almost like he is trying to recreate what we had. It has truly changed who I am as a person over the last 15 years and I wish I could go back every single day to who I was before I met him because the heartache is enormous. I think there are some things in life that you never get over and they hurt just as much at 100 years old as they did at 22 years old. ❤
I felt this. Same thing. I was 22. He was 31 and I was just so in shock that HE would want me that I was so submissive and would let him blame me for stuff that just didn’t make sense but he must’ve been right. We did the back and forth thing for 5 years. I forgave a lot of shit from him cause I just wanted him while he threw things in my face every chance he got. Tried to get me to turn on friendships he said weren’t real (still friends at 33) and just would shatter my soul. One thing about aging is that I realize I needed those lessons to know I will never make myself dim or small for anyone or not stick up for myself and speak up and not accept the gaslighting.
Ok so why Taylor's outfit is similar to one of her 1989 concert? Like, on one of her out of the woods person she worn the similar outfit. Can it be some hint?
@@strawberry2559 there are soooooo many 1989 references in the Short Film it’s insane. I think buzzfeed compiled them into a list of you want to read it.
@@strawberry2559 it is like the suit she use in Grammy's Award when she sing Out of the woods. Though it is just similar not the same, that one had some blings on it.
@@strawberry2559 she's been giving many hints on 1989 for a long time.............. People were expecting 1989 to come out but instead she released red
@@ShorsBones "Taylor Swift just sang a 10 minute song on “Saturday Night Live”. It was wonderful and set a record for the longest single performance in the history of the show."
Well I'm 74 and I've just "found" her. I always knew she existed but thought she was a teen phenomenon. Now I realise she's got far too much talent and ability to be limited to one age group. Very proud to be a Swiftie.
I'm 69 years old and have yet to make it thru this song without crying. It just keeps bringing back memories of a guy I dated when I was 23. She is the most amazing storyteller.
The fact that she's smiling while singing this makes my heart move. Edit: If I can be Joe even just for a day, I would tell her how she means the world to me and give her a forehead kiss. ❤️
Taylor is my inspiration!! My mom said that if I got 5k LIKES on my new song!! She definitely buy me a professional mic!! Begging you GUYS!! Please...I LOVE YOU! I'M NOT LYING! PLS!.
I was never really a Taylor fan before - not against her, just not super into her style of music - but I am now. This song is a masterpiece. The whole album is. No doubt she’s ridiculously talented
Sometimes the music that’s released now doesn’t relate to you until years later 😁😁 glad you like her now. I love her and Selena because they’re so graceful and classy.
What an artistic triumph! I can guarantee that I'm older than any of the stated ages here and I only discovered this lyrical genius recently. First time hearing this song. I haven't been so moved by a songwriter since listening to her namesake, James Taylor over fifty years ago. A once-in-a-generation talent. Amazing.
72 year old here loves the song and attended Eras, Sydney. Totally mesmerising performance from an amazing talent and apparently she paints as well. Her g’mothee was an opera singer
I think the live version has more emotions, but that’s to be expected. Any song holds more emotion when you preform it live as it’s not the person in a studio singing it dozens of times. It is also more impactful when you can see their face and body.
I really do not care much about celebrities and singers, but Taylor Swift has my full support. She is one classy, smart, big-hearted lady. She has amazing music and I admire her for sharing her stories about love. She is special. Happy thanksgiving
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 91 | คู่เอก "คมอาวุธ vs อเล็กเซย์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/V0RkEfYFsgM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[FINALE] 💸ที่แท้พ่อเป็นผู้ถือหุ้นบริษัทพันล้าน เขากลับใจตอนนี้ก็สายไปแล้ว🙇🏻♂️#ละครคุณธรรม #short](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yFwgjTFISUI/mqdefault.jpg)
The fact that this song doesn’t feel like ten minutes is a sign of a great performance.
the greatest of all time .... taylor
I know right? Every time I listen to it, like one second later- it’s the end and I’m like: “What??? Over already??”
yesss
I was thinking the same thing
Exactly! Like she is so awesome!
"So casually cruel in the name of being honest" is one of the best lyrics from any song, from any genre, ever. And its just one tiny line that passes by in a 10 minute masterpiece.
I suspect we might all find our special tiny line...I know I did!
@@rebeccamilward4758 the thing is that it became part of pop culture at this point
Yes I totally agree and I also love “and you call me up again just to break me like a promise” another tiny line with great meaning
that was what got me since i heard this song for the first time
I’ve always thought that that was the line that really solidified her ability as a lyricist. But I’ve also always thought this was her best song and the extra length only adds to that
It’s unhealthy how many times I listen to this daily
Here I am again
Hey y’all what’s new
Me too … its Like daily dose to listen to her ♥️🧣
and here we are again (on that little town street)
Same.
"You told me 'bout your past thinking your future was me"
So painfully relatable!!
U2
600th like!!!!!!!!
Her smile, the glow-up that matters the most.
so common this guy
@@MrUssy101 you must be a very lonely person and horrible person if you think the way that he treated her was in any way correct. I feel truly bad for you. Please get help
@@MrUssy101 do us a favour & stop copying and pasting your own comment
@@MrUssy101 keep crying
@@MrUssy101 the door is open for you to walk out, why listen when you just wanna comment such bad things Abt her, dude it ain't worth it I'm telling you.
Her short film playing in the background makes this performance magical, her past is literally behind her as she remembers on it wow. You can hear how real it is for her
is it tho? she's getting people to hate on Jake Gyllenhaal for a 3 month relationship from 10 years ago
@@Mac-dt3iz I'm genuinely curious, did she say it's about Jake or are these just speculations?
@@anoushkapandey5744 Idts
@@Mac-dt3iz she’s re-recording music for herself not to shit on him 🥴
@@Mac-dt3iz she never mentioned him by name, and shes just re recording a song so she actually owns it again. what do u want her to do, not re record one of the best songs from the album and let shamrock holdings own it?
10 mins and at the end you still want more.She is a musical genius.
Ikr
She is genius.. gifted ,talented.
Fr
on constant repeat
And still crying, she is so real and honest.
‘So casually cruel, in the name of being honest.’ One of the greatest lines ever written!
And “I’m a crumbled up piece of paper, just lying here” That just crushed me 😢
And truly, how many of us can relate to that EXACT feeling😢
You need to listen to more songs
Yes
“You kept me like a secret but I kept you like an oath”.
This song is so captivating, it doesn't even feel like 10 minutes..
Yeah! I kinda wish it was longer haha
I feel like she’s venting to me 😌
@@Sadistic_Samurai I feel like it lasts 2 minutes
Thiss
Yeah I wish it was longer😂 I’m like tell is more
Literally "all too well" is everywhere currently. Taylor is planet .
Taylor Swift is tra$h, my music is better
@@robinskull yeah right
and we're just living in it
@@robinskull actually its the reverse for both taylor and you.
It’s getting the recognition it deserves 😩✨
"maybe this thing was a masterpiece" this song is, indeed, a masterpiece
To who ever is reading this comment
You are awesome 🌟
My goal is to hit 30k any help would be epic🙌
Taylor is my inspiration!! My mom said that if I got 5k LIKES on my new song!! She definitely buy me a professional mic!! Begging you GUYS!! Please...I LOVE YOU! I'M NOT LYING! PLS!.
@Jack W. ????? lmao embarrassing
@Jack W. That’s an opinion not a fact.
@Jack W. Oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh
You need to calm down (you need to calm down)
You're being too loud (you're being too loud)
And I'm just like oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh
You need to just stop (can you stop?)
Like, can you just not step on our gowns?
You need to calm down
I LOVE HOW SHE IS ONE OF THE SINGERS WHO SING EXACTLY HOW THEY'RE FEELING WITH EXACT EMOTIONS
Fr swiftie forever ❤
do you not realize she copies and paste the same formula over and over? lol
@@testing7802 what formula?
Because she wrote those exact words to express the exact feeling she experienced - love it!
Taylor wearing that revenge red lipstick!! 💄
@Sir Monster gurl no.
Fly with Stella - That's a thing?
🇰🇷🇧🇷
Rigghht
And i got that red lips classic thing that you like
The stage production of autumn slowly turning to winter matches the lyrics exactly. She captures a full season’s turning in ten minutes
Uaoooo...you re very very nice ♥️♥️♥️
And the turn to the red lights for that last coda starting with the joke line…whew!!!
Do like india
With all of those efforts but still got few views when compared to Easy on Me live on NRJ. Let's not forget that her vocals sounded so awful in this performance.
@@ferdinandbundac9856 is this jake gyllenhaal on burner account lmfao
I’m still having trouble processing the fact that she’s giving a live performance of the full version of this song almost a decade after it was released. what a time to be a swiftie
@Jack W. Tf are you laughing at? The only joke here is you, Jack.
Usha I feel like they’re a bot or something lol
@Jack W. You're hilarious 🤣
@Jack W. then why are u here 😭
@Jack W. jake stop we know its you
I'm a 67 year old man, I've been in a lot of relationships and this song had me crying for 8 minutes of it, been on both side of the story. I am amazed by her.
I totally agree; she's amazing. I recently started "really listening " to her songs. I haven't cried at one yet lol! but time will tell.
You sure you're a man? Jesus christ...67 crying to a t swizzle song?
@@TheMark60172why are you watching a Taylor “swizzle” performance if you don’t even like her, and looks like you scroll through the comments!! Ur a true Swizzle fan 😉
@daemurua3511 sad life you say, will that make you cry also? Hopefully not 8 min. Im not a Taylor Swift song, but dude please try to Shake it off. I mean, dont hold a grudge until August and leave yourself with a Blank Space. If you dont stop crying, its gonna be a cruel summer for you man! In closing, stop feeling sad, go out to a bar and make the whole room shimmer and be Nice!
Please dont get me wrong...not laughing at you cause your 67 and crying...just you commenting is bad enough, but for a 67 year old man to say he cried over a swift song for 8 min is absolutely hilarious. Please put out a video of you with a box of tissues, curtains down, dark room, and Lover is playing while you sip some Cabarnet and ball your eyes out. Ill pay a grand as a starting bid to see that live!
This 10 minute version has been wanted for so long and she’s giving all of her. It’s such a masterpiece, just like we thought it would be. RED IS A MASTERPIECE.
@Jack W. You commented this ….3 times..?
@Jack W. tat's y u hv to come on TH-cam to be heard unlike Taylor. Keep Crying
igaisu he’s spam commenting this on every comment, I think it might be a bot or something
@Jack W. YOU MEAN EVERYTHING YOU SAY IS BS.
@Jack W. ok…?
*Lord, please grant me Taylor Swift’s level of productivity.*
5 albums, 1 pandemic....
It’s how we know she truly loves what she’s doing
AMEN
when you don't love what you're doing, you can't have it xD if ykyk
@@karissaly9616 can you please tell me all the albums she released 😭😭😭 I can only count 4.
Taylor is truly an excellent songwriter. I've never had a boyfriend but when I listen to the song, I feel like I lived it myself. She reflects her emotions and feelings very well in her songs.
Taylor Swift is tra$h, my music is better
@@robinskull you’re never gonna get anywhere with tearing other people down :)
@@robinskull that's why she has 44.4 million subs : ) FOOL!!
Same
I think Taylor Swift may have a possible future as a budding filmaker too or film writer I'm not a Taylor Swift fan but the way she created the story, and how the highs and lows of the relationship were shown felt very realistic and of course can't forget credit to the actors themselves Sadie and Dylan had great chemistry together. I was definitely feeling very emotional and melancholy after it. Well done to Taylor
I am fully convinced if taylor wasnt a singer she'd be a terrific best selling Author
That's coming I'm sure. She's insanely talented
Each album is a book. Every song is a chapter. I could see it.
Shes a poet. She's absolutely capable of writing a book. I hope she does
Movies
The fact that this song is literally TEN MINUTES LONG and yet every time I'm like "oh is it over already??" like it never gets old.
SAME
I barely memorize 3 minutes song. 😂 Taylor is a genius plus, dont you need a break after a 3 mins song? How she continue for 10 mins. Even during the music solo, she still need to put her energy playing the guitar😂
it keeps me on my toes even after listening so many times 😫 also hey! I sang a cover of “All Too Well”, mind giving it a listen?
Progressive metal/rock artists: "Allow us to introduce ourselves."
Same! When I very first listened to this, I'll admit I wasn't as impressed. I guess I was expecting different lyrics. But, I watched the short film and ever since then, I can't stop listening to this version. It's almost like I can't listen to the 5 minute one, knowing how much added depth the 10 minute holds. There was so much left unsaid when it came out in 2012, and the 10 minute version somehow makes the song ten times more mature, and showcases more of what went on behind the scenes. I don't think I've ever heard a song so tangible. The tone of the song, and the way she sings it lets you actually FEEL the story and you can feel what she's feeling. And sadly, that tells me just how much worse the relationship was than we all thought before with the original version of the song.
This song is a love letter to every person who feels like that they feel too much, think too hard, and remember the details that most seldom do. Those are the people with the softest hearts, the greatest minds, the most giving of hands. Taylor Swift captured that simple truth in this song, and I cannot possibly thank her enough for it.
🧡
😭
this comment needs more likes
I needed this. Thank you 😭
I just spent the night with my ex and we talked. It was freeing. Cause I am one of those people who feels everything. I pick up on small details. They simply weren't weren't realizing how much the little things, that they didn't care about were the ones that actually mattered the most.
probably the reason why the 10 minute version isn’t boring to listen to and to watch the performance is that the song has a story to follow, it’s like taylor’s telling a story in a way that she’s just singing it out. not to mention the fact that the lyrics are damn painful and relatable.
It also doesn’t have a repeated chorus, it’s different each time and keeps you engaged. I was never a swift fan until I saw this and I’m blown away each time
@@sonicbl00m yeah agree w u
It's a refreshing song while we're in the midst of famous main pop songs that aren't... as meaningful. Most songs rn are famous because of its beat (I'm not saying that this is wrong but that's just making this stand out more. Not to mention, this is a literal lyrical masterpiece).
so true... and every song by Taylor is a story being told 😊 in a beautiful way that makes your mind paint a picture of it 😊
@@sonicbl00m welcome welcome i suggest you watch the live performance of dear john
dude it’s crazy how much her voice has improved in only the past 3 years
Can we also appreciate her backup vocals? They added volumes to the song. They're equally awesome.
They’ve been together with Taylor like 9-10 years ago. Some of Taylor’s band members are still with her since the first time she started her music career. Taylor must loves them so much and so they are 🤧
Yes, those women are amazing! They've been her singers and toured with her for years.
@@shelly7185 and we as fans love them, too ❤️
they have been by her side for ages and rightfully so
Shut up Steve
This song doesn’t feel 10 minutes at all. Taylor is truly a master of her craft.
I was thinking that! This is the fastest ten minutes ever!
I would say I enter the song not just listen to it😅
👏👏
I was thinking the same
I love that her back-up singers are the same women we've seen by her side for years. It's a testament to her character that they're still by her side, smiling, and full of joy performing for and with her.
Exactly. She still with her band until now which is awesome. She is really a keeper. The love she has for the people around her is really genuine.
She truly does keep people around. Just like the dancer in the lover video
She is a beautiful person
She’s a keeper.. ☺️
It also shows how she treat them, cause I mean if she wasn't caring and such they will talk against her, but no. They did not and can not, it is because she was and is still grateful to all of them and I love that about her.
I believe these are the vocalists she's had since Red first came out. In fact, her band has been pretty much the same since Fearless, and the few that have left she's still in touch with. Her old vocalist Liz Huett even makes a few appearances on Red TV.
Denial. Anger. Bargining. Depression. Acceptance. All in one song without ever outright saying it.
Did u just predict ttpd
Her lyrics and storytelling is everything. The story of the naive girl who fell in love with an older man who cannot commit and take her seriously as she did is truly heartbreaking. I just cant.
I was once that naive girl the fact i could relate is devastating i wish no one to experience the same :,(
WARNING I am the unprettiest human YTer worldwide. Take the hint, dear kate
and sad that it continues to happen today
Borahae
That reminds me of her “i am the man” music video where there is a younger woman who is marrying an older guy and it seems like she is a gold digger bc of a GIANT diamond on her finger. I think it points to how when a younger guy dates an older woman he is never seen as a gold digger, but when it’s a younger woman dating an older man she’s is almost always seen as a gold digger
People say she’s being dramatic cause she wrote a 10min song about a short relationship but it’s not about how long or short a relationship is. It’s about what that person made you feel during those times. She fell hard fast and there’s nothing wrong with that. She was young. I can write a 10 page essay about a relationship I didn’t even have 🤣🤣🤣
Genius… totally agree
7 pages for a situationship i had too, 😄😂
besides, it takes a whole lot of skill and talent to make a 10 min song...they should appreciate the music
Exactly !!!!!
I actually think it’s easier to write a song about a short relationship because you can focus on those moments because those moments are so brief they have more meaning attached to them. It actually makes it easier to make those moments even more dramatic. Not that that’s a bad thing🤷🏼♂️
Taylor's relationship with her people reflects so much as I noticed that the back up singers are the same people that sang with her back then.
Amos her bass player has been with her since 2007 too!
@Jack W. Literally nobody cares about your channel 😂
@Jack W. get out, get out now.
@Jack W. Won't even bother checking your channel with that kind of baiting. Try being nice, it may get you more views than this tactic. Best of luck!
@Jack W. i would check out your channel but i am not bored enough.
Maybe when i am as big of a sad sack as you then i will check it out.
As an adult male, I never really understood the Taylor phenomenon. Until I watched her sing this song at the Grammys. Then I found this. The young lady is incredibly talented. She played piano at Grammy’s and guitar on SNL. I have to believe her best attribute is writing after hearing these lyrics. I believe she writes her own music. The lyrics in this song are mind blowing. I love the up tempo and down tempo. Especially when they get to the first snow. That was so cool. Great song. Great performances. Kudos to her insanely talented backup singers.
The eye contact with the camera like she's speaking to him after all these years. I love the power this woman holds. Love you Taylor!
Her face when she said “you never called it what it was” ahhh
Who is that “him”?
@@estefaniaaguilera873 jake gyllenhaal
yess i was gonna say that!!
🇧🇷🇰🇷
This feels so much more like an angry song now, rather than just a sad one--amazing!
I was thinking the same thing!💕
I love both versions, but they really are completely different stories.
The edited one reminds me a LITTLE of billies happier than ever, ur sad but ur trying to cover the anger, and this one is just the raging other half
I feel it's more story telling than angry
@@stardolphin783 Im thinking the same thing. Also they're the type of song that can be really repeated a number of times cos they have so much in them, and the switch of tone.
Honestly, I still need the 10 minutes version of Back to December
And Dear John!!
I need a 10 minute version of every taylor song!!!
How am I just finding out there's more 10 minute versions😭
I need enchanted one-hour version
Getaway Car 10 mins version pls :D
It’s not just a song. She wrote & directed a short film based on the song. She owns it all. I find that very impressive! Love it!
Yes, they played the film behind her as she sang. But it’s also on TH-cam. It’s so well done.
Thank u
I remember it all too well
there’s a very “F you for making younger me feel this way” energy to this performance. I love it.
2:37 her eyes are saying exactly that
@@gigirodrigues8 7:30 as well 😩
💯💯💯❤❤❤
The way she’s looking at the camera frequently. I caught that too
And the way she looks in the camera at him
"I'm a soldier who's returning half her weight" - such a beautiful way to describe the toll a relationship like this takes on you - from eating disorders to loosing your other half..
Yes the two were one and now not so much.
So she had eating disorders after that? 🥺
@@a.a.2573 yeah... its heartbreaking
When I first processed that line I went “OH SHIT!” because it reminded me of her ED…
really thought it was "..half her wage."
No words. It's really difficult to keep a listener's attention for ten minutes with the same song and have them want to revisit it, too. Taylor was meant to do exactly what she's doing now.
Laughs in Prog
@@Greasonn jealous!
TooL
Taylor Swift doing a Dream Theater song we love to see it
lol i dont even like taylor swift i think this is the best 10 min song ever
The way that 10 years later her pain is still palpable when she sings this song 😢❤
I noticed this as well. It hurts to see her hurting.
Powerful.
It will always be painful when you remember your younger self being hurt.
Sorry for my english.
"So casually cruel in the name of being honest"
Is still such a slick line.
Taylor Swift is tra$h, my music is better
my fav too :((((
Yes
Casually cruel
Mr everything involves around you
@@robinskull what-
SNL really went all out with this performance. They gave her a 10 minute time slot when most people get 2 3 minute time slots, they put leaves on the ground for the autumn aesthetic, they gave her a screen to show her short film, and they made it snow.
she is very famous and they know it
exactly!! this will definitely go down as one of the best SNL performances of all time
Well.. she is a big draw. Audiences matter on tv.
Well, she’s Taylor Swift.
As she deserves it
The fact that she originally thought no one wanted to hear this version because it’s 10 minutes…an absolute masterpiece. I truly hope she submits for the Grammy’s because this deserves so much.
she tells a whole story through this songs and it's BEAUTIFUL
Yeah, if you plan to listen to the song on repeat anyway, it doesn't matter if it's 3 or 10 minutes of repeating themes.
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
it’s a work of art, literally. Anyways hello :) I sang Taylor’s new song, check it out!
I hope she submitted All Too Well (10 Minute Version) in next year’s Grammys cuz this song needs a Grammy for the most rare written song we ever heard in 10 minutes
Count me another fan. I've never paid 30 seconds of attention to her until the last couple of weeks but I've watched a bunch of interviews and YT videos, just started listening to some songs in the last few days. I'm stunned at her creativity, humor, authenticity, compassion, strength, courage, and the way she is turning her love of life into an incredibly powerful inspiration of a life for so many, including me, a 66 year old guy. Brings levels of hope I wouldn't have thought possible from someone I had always written off as a teeny-bopper bubble-gum pop star. I've never disliked her, just simply never knew who she really is. I'm deeply impressed with her now and wish her (and everyone she touches) many blessings onward.
My boyfriend too (he's 56)... I introduced him to Tay, the real stuff, and he now says, "how did I never know about her? She's a goddess!"
You need to watch the Eras Tour. It is well worth the money! You will become a fan all over again!
@@angieboreman2921 would love to!
welcome!!
I don't know if re-recorded albums are eligible for grammys but this song definitely deserves one. So compelling, you can actually feel the pain from all those years ago. Way to go Taylor
They are eligible. But she doesn't want to submit the rerecordings, like Fearless TV, as the main point of this was ownership.
@@karlpatrickmartirez2111 we don't know about Red TV. She only spoke about Fearless TV
@@karlpatrickmartirez2111 she already won a Grammy for fearless. But she might submit Red seeing it was nominated back then but didn't win
I hope she submits Red this time. And we'll prove it deserved a grammy.
they are if Taylor submits them for the Academy's consideration.
it's just gratifying to see Taylor's evolution emotionally singing this song, what was once sad has now become a fan-bonding song.
the fact that she was able to sneak in words like “self effacing” and “refrigerator” is completely mind blowing
Say it louder for the haters who say she only gets credited as a great songwriter for using big words. Refrigerator is such a mundane word.
@@wgrodrig5651 the audacity of those people. dont they think she helped them in terms of vocabulary.
The words like "maim" and "glistened" are new to me.. Her vocabulary is superb. How does she do that?
@@crystalmaureensantillan6406 You should listen to the albums folklore and evermore. She does it even more in those albums.
Also "twin sized bed"
It blows my mind that people say she has no talent. Her song writing and performance is incredible
Incredible how no talent is currently on the most successful tour ever in history. 😂
People are simply comparing to their own taste in musical artists, humans like to argue by stating extremes. I'm not Swift fan, I think she's got some incredibly catchy songs that stick in your year. I was actually brought here by some comments about how no one but Swift could make a 10 minute song because no one matches her talent (insane claim, tons of 10, 20, 30 minute songs out there). Is she talented? Of course, no denying it. Is she the most talented musician ever? Of course not. Isn't the most successful musician of all time at this point? That seems like it should be enough for her fans to dismiss people saying she has "no" talent.
They’re jealous. Plain and simply jealous.
This song makes everyone cry from a relationship that we even didn't have
Til you do, and you know what she’s talking about. It hurts even more to hear it, really.
exactly, im too young for this to happen to me but it still makes me cry every time
absolutely!
I have one, and I'm suffering and loving a lot, he is bi-closeted, with a girlfriend. And I feel so so bad because of that. But this feeling is like...is something I believed couldn't be feel.
I knooow 😭
SNL giving her 10 minutes to do this is wild. True Queen
And they put up a screen for the short film, had leaves on the floor, and made it snow. SNL really went all out for her performance.
How is it wild.. artists usually perform 2 songs. She just combined her two time slots.
@@annah8496 you're commenting on a 2 year old comment tryna debate 😂 seek help
@@briano9397people tend to comment on things as they see them. You okay?
@@katiematthews4021 seek help aswell
The fact that she made a 10 minute song that you don’t get bored of listening to halfway through just shows how incredibly talented she is. She’s just pure musical genius and has been since day one. So proud of her🥲
I'm surprised a pop star could even do that considering that most songs over 10 min. are progressive metal/rock songs that are never boring.
This isn't the only 10 minute song in the world, jfc
I won’t complain if she makes longer songs like these ❤️ also hi! I sang “All Too Well”, would you mind taking a listen?
This is the ONLY ten minute song I've ever been willing and excited to listen to. I can't even listen to Stariway to Heaven all the way through (no offense, Led Zeppelin)
I only made it to a minute
Modern pop masterpiece.10 minutes and not a single second wasted.
..and does the other Grammy winner play the guitar?
The power Taylor holds is incredible. NBC literally allowed her to be on air for 10 minutes straight. Iconic, if I may add.
only the music industry herself could accomplish such a feat
true
tay is a legend
Incluso si ella exigiera estar allí durante 20 minutos, le darían permiso ... ella es sin duda una leyenda.
How frequent are commercial breaks at NBC? I’m not from the US.
I genuinely can’t stop listening to this song😍
Lol bruh it’s a song for women who have relationship problems. It’s the one chord that she is playing over and over I found it incredibly boring??? Ok ??
@@MrUssy101 Tell me u got bullied at primary school without telling me
@@MrUssy101 ok but who asked?
Samee!!
BTW
Hello fellow amitian
And this post helped me to find you, in now subscribed to your channel,,
People love to hate on her but you can’t deny her staying power. She’s 15 years into her career and still breaking records left and right. Every album she puts out, even ones from a decade ago, go number 1 and a 10 minute song originally from a decade ago went number 1. She’s just as relevant now after 15 years as other new artists in their prime.
Well I mean she is still quite young... So by normal Hollywood standards she is still in her prime and would remain so for quite a few years, especially if she keeps putting out masterpieces like this one
I don't get the Hate on her, it doesn't make sense. They're jealous of this gorgeous multi-talented hard-working artist.
THIS!!!!🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
Adele and Ed Sheeran has released new music, yet Taylor Swift is No1.
That’s why we love TayTay 💜
Swiftie for life ✌🏼
Even with the imperfections that would have been edited out in a studio version, this is the best to watch. The break added in the middle is perfect, as is the a cappella ending. Her acknowledging the background singers is another mark of Taylor's charm. Taylor always knows where the camera is.
She literally sang a whole 10 minutes song which has literally no brakes. That's some serious vocal stamina 😌
And makes it seem short
Every fan can sing this 10min song with totally no brakes too 😅
@@jeranjed You’re so true. I won’t even notice the duration if she didn’t put 10 Minutes in the song title.
@@johnpauloenriquez8553 no.
Yea it is darlings
all too well is definitely winning song of the year at the grammys.
If she didn't submit Fearless TV, I don't think she's try for this album either
BUT IT DESERVES IT😭
@carlos non-ya Fearless had already won Album of the Year, it didn’t make any sense to submit it and it competing against evermore. If she submits Red it would be for the 2023 Grammys, and given that is was snubbed before, I definitely think she will give it the second chance it deserves at winning a Grammy
if not that than defintely a oscar for the short film
@@gabep5096 yeah i think sadie deserves something for her performance in it, and also taylor for directing
the fact that other celebs attended on this performance is the next level of excitement (JoeJonas,SophieTurner,CaraDelevigne,AnyaTaylorJoy,SelenaGomez,RyanReynolds,BlakeLively)
What?! How you know that??
wait really??
Yea saw so many of them coming in on Twitter. Also joe Biden was there lol it’s actually true maybe !!!
Sadie sink was there as well
It was all her friends!!
What makes this song so iconic and relatable is the fact that almost all of us have experienced a scenario of being gaslit in a relationship and being told that “it” wasn’t real, wasn’t a big deal, didn’t mean much, etc. when you know it WAS something special, something different. It is such a unique and horrific pain to have those feelings invalidated by another and Taylor completely captures that emotion with her lyrics.
Fun fact: Taylor doesn’t have a bad song. She didn’t just deliver, she SERVED.
So true
Stay stay stay
GAGAGAGAGAGA! I will now count to 3 and then I am still the unprettiest TH-camr of all time. 1...2...3. GAGAGAGAGAGA!!! Thank you for your attention, dear tom
@@Angelchavezxo i was about to say that lmaoo
what about ME!? lol
the fact that she sang this 10 minute version live without any breaks, dang taylor really has a lot of vocal stamina i'm so prouddd
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 The fact that you made that comment. she regularly stands on stage for three hours at a time putting on a show. Do you think she can handle one10 minutes on? It doesn’t require vocal stamina it’s a very simple song to sing. It’s not like she’s hitting Mariah Carey whistle notes for 10 minutes😂😂
@@elijahcambry3319 but most a lists cant sing live AT ALL
Literally have you heard of opera singers 😂
There is a break part..
@@elijahcambry3319 Can you chill, it ain't even that deep
I usually don't say that everything happens for a reason, but in this case I believe it did. Because if it wasn't for her dispute with her previous label, this version most likely would have never seen the light of day, the songs from the vault wouldn't have been released either, not to mention All Too Well perhaps wouldn't have got a short film. But instead all of her albums are getting even more appreciation and recognition than they did (meaning more people discover her music). It really worked out so well for her.
exactly! queen of making the best out of a bad situation. and not just for herself, but for all her loyal and supportive fans !!
omg yes!!!
and still being better than the stolen version,and still at the top
Red as album and all too well got attention that it deserved to get at the first place. Cause now it's no longer just fan favourite song or album but literally every one is liking it.. thanks to folklore and evermore which opened eyes of many that Taylor was and is best songwriter but jealous media and people elbowed her down!
Indeed!
I don’t know how anyone can say she isn’t talented? Do you hear this song writing? It’s gorgeous
the fact that she used to cry with this song and now she looks so happy and proud of herself, I love u blondie
Cuándo lloró
🇰🇷🇧🇷
Honestly this might be one of the best SNL performances of all time. I listen to this at least once per day
agree.
Hahaha me too.
same!
Same brother, same
It’s up there with Billie Eilish
Even thought this is the first time she performed the whole ten minutes. SHE SMASHED IT !
Queen.
didn't she also perform it at the films premiere?
@@thisuserisdelululu Yes. That was a secret session though so this is technically the first public performance.
@@JenniferJiang2013 how can it be a secret session when the album was already released and the event wasn't even secret? 😂 It was all too well short film premiere where she performed the all too well 10 minute version for the first time.
@@venlalehtinen5766 because it wasn’t live streamed and wasn’t an open event. everyone who attended was chosen. It was an intimate performance. So it doesn’t count
The fact that she sung this 1 month after she wrote "Your Losing Me" is so telling. The emotion in her voice and just raw vocals. She's a genius
And she was 20
The fact that she did a ten-minute performance in itself is amazing. The song itself is just the icing on the cake…
Um...have you ever been to a concert? Typically they are much longer than 10 minutes. lol
@@stivaro well 1 song isn't 10 minutes is it? Well Taylor had concerts much longer, but for a song, 10m is impressive
@@jaceplaysgames5031 it's the equivalent of 2 songs.
@@northsource7215 most songs are about 3 minutes so it’s the equivalent of a bit more than 3 songs
@@jaceplaysgames5031 Well, I'm kinda old. Guns N' Roses, Iron Maiden, Led Zeppelin, Tool, Pink Floyd, The Doors, Jimmy Hendrix all had songs longer than 10 minutes so...I'm just saying, it's not like a record. Plus, if an artist can do an hour+ concert, I'm sure a 10 minute song is not that big of an achievement for them. js
How can anyone hate Taylor Swift? She, herself, is really a masterpiece.
Cause she can’t sing. Her voice is like a dying cat
@@gregdelisle6751 you yes, her not. Jealous
@@acecolorsred6543 « Jealous »… of what? Nice try
@@gregdelisle6751 of her money, her fame and her talent. And she doesn’t even know you exist so stay pressed
@@nyamkhishignyamaa6282 hahahahaha AS IF you knew me 😘
we are crying because of nostalgia and she is smiling because of us. WE WON AFTER ALL THESE DAYS!!!!
This performance is huge. The lighting how it goes back and forth from reddish tones to bluish tones is symbolic. Same as the video. You’ll see the tones change. When the love is magical and intense it’s red…. when it’s painful and falling apart it’s blue. It’s interesting seeing the different tones pass over her face. No doubt she directed this performance.
She's a damn extremely talented genius ❤
she sang for a straight 10 minutes
and she does it for 2 hours straight during tour... this is nothing to her...
(the power she has omg)
@@KevinMAbraham there’s usually breaks during concerts , in this song there isn’t , so it’t just shows how much power she has in her vocals
She performed for 10 minutes as well
@BIBLE DEFENDER 144 Oh hush.
@BIBLE DEFENDER 144 hopefully x
She was right. She rewriting these songs and fans like us are reliving those precious memories that we experienced when all too well first dropped
with different light, we grow up with her. this re-recording idea is genius
It's the best thing she could have done tbh
Reminds me of my 21st, where I wished my ex would remember my birthday
True fact : Taylor’s vocals are no joke. Her vocals are a masterpiece
Love from a TH-camr
...I mean, these are completely fine, but they aren't even close to a bunch of other vocalists 🤷♀️ don't over romanticism people. Her songwriting is absolutely top shelf.
love her, but she’s actually pretty flat throughout this performance. I don’t know. She likes when her fans are honest, I think haha
Correction: Her vocals are nice. There are a bunch of other singers who have way better voices than her. Her songwriting skills are the one that is a masterpiece.
@@riddhisingh5466 pretty much every time she holds “wellllllll”
@@riddhisingh5466 3:52
A masterpiece.
The only reason I don’t want a 20 minute version is because I’d never want Taylor Swift to go through that.
An outstanding performance and from the heart 💯
Ha yeah. It's an emotional rollercoaster coaster. Imagine how difficult it is to rip the scab off and bleed out for 10 minutes strait.
I heard the original version she wrote was 24 minutes long, so she'd be very okay with that, actually (I think).
The fact that she can write a ten minute song using the same four chords the entire time and somehow keep it entirely engaging and exciting through her lyrics and melodies is truly a testament to her particular style of genius.
Plus being able to play essentially the same part for 10 minutes....... damn. My arm's ready to fall of after playing an open E note for 3.
@@sridharraju7588 well she didn't play for the whole 10 minutes - not even close. Still amazing performance tho
@@bishop8550 She did not. Ah well.
@@sridharraju7588 practice builds endurance.
Unpopular opinion, but I wish she had switched it up more musically. She’s a genius lyrically but the song felt monotonous to me. Especially when there was so much potential to use the music to support her lyrics.
“The idea you had of me, who was she?” Just hits me. It reminds me of my toxic ex and how I pretended to be someone I wasn’t just to please him. I’d love to know who he thought I was or who he thought he could mold me into.
So sorry you had to go through it all
Sameee, I relate to that specific line so damn much. I'm sorry you have to go through it.
Same..Especially when she says “so casually cruel in the name of being honest”
Yes I love rhetorical questions
U should always behave like urself u r u no one else u r special in some way never change for someone who is a controlling freak
I cannot listen to the original now without being ready to belt, "AND YOU WERE TOSSING ME THE CAR KEYS-"
Hey guys I’m a 21 year old pop singer-songwriter based in New York who just uploaded a new single and video called "Rude Awakening" that is available now on all streaming platforms. If you take the time to listen I think you may be pleasantly surprised and find the chorus stuck in your head- check it out!
me too haha
me to bestie me too😭❤
Same lol
I love the crowd at the end!
"You kept me like a secret, but i kept you like an oath" Is the most iconic line she's ever written
Taylor has glow up so much over the years mane happy for her
Taylor Swift is tra$h, my music is better
Why Taylor the attention seeker songs are always about relationship problems?? Redhead 🧑🦰 in this mv was portrayed as typical drama queen Taylor making a scene out of nothing, blaming the poor guy ???
WHY ??????
@@robinskull so do you have 11 grammys?? pathetic.
@@MrUssy101 bro what did you watch the short film or are you so biased you’ll ignore it all
@@MrUssy101 whats ur problem, she’s just writing songs about her own life🐍
The fact that she loves her fans so much to do all this for us. We've asked for almost a decade for the full version and she did it because she knew what it would mean to us - I'm crying. She deserves everything she has and more. What a rare and beautiful person
Taylor Swift Music pure tr@sh mine better
@@tatiyavichoomusic LMFAOOOO
@@tatiyavichoomusic bestie, where are your grammys?
@@tatiyavichoomusic youre a flop
@@tatiyavichoomusic We even don't know you, man
Her lyrics are so timeless and sad. I think anyone can relate to her in different ways. I’m 29 yo and happily married now, but this song reminds me of the way I felt at 17 when the boy I liked broke my heart,
I'm literally in the same situation. Happily married. But at 17 when your heart is broken for the first time, it's a pain you think you won't get over. You feel everything so deeply. She grasped that feeling in this song. I can go back to that time if I just close my eyes and listen.
Agree
40 and married here and feel the same. Great song writing can transport me back to that angst teen / early adult that is still within me.
Omg yes. This comment. This brings me back to those toxic relationships when I was 17/18/19 so naive back then. Happily engaged now 🥰
Yes..
This song hits straight to my heart because the exact same thing happened to me. We fell in love and we were 9.5 years apart, 22 and 31. We were together for 3 months non stop and something (he said it was age as well) happened where he started to pull away. He finally did the no call/no show thing and we broke up. Then for two years he was in and out of my life until I finally said I couldn’t take it anymore. He is the love of my life but it didn’t work out. Every person he has ever been with since then has characteristics that are like me, almost like he is trying to recreate what we had. It has truly changed who I am as a person over the last 15 years and I wish I could go back every single day to who I was before I met him because the heartache is enormous. I think there are some things in life that you never get over and they hurt just as much at 100 years old as they did at 22 years old. ❤
🥺❤
I felt this. Same thing. I was 22. He was 31 and I was just so in shock that HE would want me that I was so submissive and would let him blame me for stuff that just didn’t make sense but he must’ve been right. We did the back and forth thing for 5 years. I forgave a lot of shit from him cause I just wanted him while he threw things in my face every chance he got. Tried to get me to turn on friendships he said weren’t real (still friends at 33) and just would shatter my soul. One thing about aging is that I realize I needed those lessons to know I will never make myself dim or small for anyone or not stick up for myself and speak up and not accept the gaslighting.
Lesson learned: don't hurt a genius songwriter, they can make a masterpieces.
Writer in the dark vibes
Ok so why Taylor's outfit is similar to one of her 1989 concert? Like, on one of her out of the woods person she worn the similar outfit. Can it be some hint?
@@strawberry2559 there are soooooo many 1989 references in the Short Film it’s insane. I think buzzfeed compiled them into a list of you want to read it.
@@strawberry2559 it is like the suit she use in Grammy's Award when she sing Out of the woods. Though it is just similar not the same, that one had some blings on it.
@@strawberry2559 she's been giving many hints on 1989 for a long time.............. People were expecting 1989 to come out but instead she released red
Why is no one talking about the acapella part at the end, it sounded HEAVENLY
Yeahhhh 😭
that is my FAVORITE part of this ten minute version!!!
YES
it was the perfect ending 😫 anyways hi! I made a cover of “All Too Well”, check it out?
that's my most favourite part
pretty sure she is the only artist who performed a song for 10 minutes in snl history. what a legend.
wrong
@@ShorsBones who is the other person then? (I genuinely wanna know)
@@ShorsBones "Taylor Swift just sang a 10 minute song on “Saturday Night Live”. It was wonderful and set a record for the longest single performance in the history of the show."
@@ShorsBones not wrong, her performance is the longest in SNL history.
@@ShorsBones Lmaoooo what are you ??? Why u here?
Taylor can make a 10 hour long song and i would listen to it non stop
I’m a 57 yr old man. Not exactly Taylor’s demographic. This performance is one I watch over and over. Her last two albums were terrific too.
This is my favorite thing about Swifties. There's 0 discrimination. Welcome to the club
i'm almost 25 and i listen to this over and over. the agelessness of music is a beautiful thing. :)
Well I'm 74 and I've just "found" her. I always knew she existed but thought she was a teen phenomenon. Now I realise she's got far too much talent and ability to be limited to one age group. Very proud to be a Swiftie.
Yep, right up my alley, mid forties but wow I sing a swiftie song louder than my daughters, love it.
you’re welcome to the fandom anytime!
Fact that everyone agrees: Every swiftie's dream is to shout " Hey you call me up again just to break me like a promise" in a Swift's concert
Like real :(
It’s the best feeling EVER
Its what I live for ;(
“Your sweet disposition, and my wide-eyed *gays”
So casually cruel in the name of being honest - too lol. I really dream about it.
I'm 69 years old and have yet to make it thru this song without crying. It just keeps bringing back memories of a guy I dated when I was 23. She is the most amazing storyteller.
Beautiful
I’m 62 very new to Taylor and yes, it takes us back to youth so achingly…but applies to any age, it’s a timeless beauty
I could cry reading this 🥹
We have all been there. 62 now, and still remember feeling all of this with my first love.
Me too! 69! I miss those days!
when the lights turned RED (Taylor’s Version) and she became angryyyyy >>>
To who ever is reading this comment
You are awesome 🔥
My goal is to hit 30k any help would be epic😁
Yessss
Time stamp?
@@Josh-bu1kr around minute 7
People say humans can't be perfect
But she's the only living proof to prove that line wrong 🥺😙👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
The fact that she's smiling while singing this makes my heart move.
Edit: If I can be Joe even just for a day, I would tell her how she means the world to me and give her a forehead kiss. ❤️
People say humans can't be perfect
But she's the only living proof to prove that line wrong 🥺😙👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Idk what to say but Taylor Swift bringing back the PERFECT All Too Well to life makes me crying like heaven😭😭❤
Taylor is my inspiration!! My mom said that if I got 5k LIKES on my new song!! She definitely buy me a professional mic!! Begging you GUYS!! Please...I LOVE YOU! I'M NOT LYING! PLS!.
She has a few million reasons to smile everytime she sings it 😬
I was never really a Taylor fan before - not against her, just not super into her style of music - but I am now. This song is a masterpiece. The whole album is. No doubt she’s ridiculously talented
hope youve listened to folklore
Welcome😁
@elle I am the same, and now I am listening to all of her album lol
Sometimes the music that’s released now doesn’t relate to you until years later 😁😁 glad you like her now. I love her and Selena because they’re so graceful and classy.
Same. It was folklore that got me into her music and now her version of the red soundtrack.
What an artistic triumph!
I can guarantee that I'm older than any of the stated ages here and I only discovered this lyrical genius recently. First time hearing this song. I haven't been so moved by a songwriter since listening to her namesake, James Taylor over fifty years ago. A once-in-a-generation talent. Amazing.
Same same
72 year old here loves the song and attended Eras, Sydney. Totally mesmerising performance from an amazing talent and apparently she paints as well. Her g’mothee was an opera singer
The fact that the recorded version and the live version sounds identical just shows how amazing she is!
Honestly I don't think they sound that similar... the live version actually sounds even better!
Or entirely manufactured or canned.
yeah no i don't agree. live version gives more emotions
And not mention the fact that she performed for 10 mins straight which is a pretty long time
I think the live version has more emotions, but that’s to be expected. Any song holds more emotion when you preform it live as it’s not the person in a studio singing it dozens of times. It is also more impactful when you can see their face and body.
I really do not care much about celebrities and singers, but Taylor Swift has my full support. She is one classy, smart, big-hearted lady. She has amazing music and I admire her for sharing her stories about love. She is special. Happy thanksgiving
Taylor Swift is my role model!
Agreed to the fullest. Class act, ultra creative, super productive. Happy TnxGvng for those involved.
She's so unreal
Love taylor swift but i hate her fans
Agreed..Taylor Swift the most productive celebrity with her loyal fans & I fullest Respect her forever & always 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏❤❤❤
The “sacred prayer, I was there, I was there…” part at the end is absolutely HEAVENLY. Gives me chills every time!! ❤️
My 3x to cheers me up! Thanks Taylor
I like 7:13 part. 🌬
I cry every time watching the last part. It’s so raw. And emotional.
.i agree so much
Yes ❤
She's a true musical artist. What a phenomenal woman.
From "Hey Joe I'm doing real well" to Joe supporting her in crowd, she grew and we too :')
where is joe???
@@Mariana-oy2mq he along with Sophie, Cara, Anya, Sadie, Blake , Ryan all were in crowd...
i think joe wasn't there coz of his schedule
but his mom were there
@@Mariana-oy2mq joe jonas