As some of you have pointed out - we misplayed the Curses a bit. The player who cast the curse should get the benefit every time the target player is attacked by any player. Many apologies. This is upsetting to me, mostly because I could have had so much more Gold! -JLK
Is anyone else giddy by the fact that the way Mel won was by having Edgar lay down his sword after combat and go start a farm in the countryside, which caused Shawn to just kinda...keel over and die?
@@mellowwookiee7533 even better: our 8 player free for all had taken too long so we decided to go around once and determine the winner by lifepoints. I was the last and at the end i tried to path my own commander, gaining 6 life and get no top, but someone COUNTERED MY REMOVAL ON MY OWN GUY! so I came second...
It would have been awesome to have her play the cat deck, but most guests on the show (including Shawn and Melissa), already live in the LA area. I don't really think they have a budget for travel. :)
I'm revisiting this video because I've pull out my Ur-dragon, Edgar, and Arahbo decks and started putting new cards in them. This is the video that got me into commander and got me to buy those decks.
Wow, so what I saw there was... Cats: Strong early game, but like many aggro decks it needs to take people out fast to get there...which just isn't easy to do in Commander. I'm much more interested in going wide and using equipment in that deck, I prefer the other two commanders. Can't wait to add Amoncats to it too. Dragons: Exactly what I expected, crazy splashy plays made possible by seriously sweet ramp - seemed like Josh had the perfect opening hand. Shame about all the missed gold. The Utvara Hellkite play was awesome, I am SO happy that card is in the deck. Wizards: I knew it was a slower deck, but I don't think we really got to see any of its potential here, because everyone else was so aggro so fast with those curses... the others having great ramp into their aggro really didn't help. Vampires: Surprisingly effective, Sanguine Bond is such a powerful include, and sweet tech with Blind Obedience, insane with that kicker spell. Never seen Swords to Plowshares used as a finisher before :P
I feel like dragons will be consistently stronger, but that does rely on getting a decent opening, with enough ramp and colour fixing. It's probably one of the better decks at catching up if it does fall behind, too. Vampires does have the potential to be explosive though, if it casts like 3 vampires in a turn, say... But I could imagine it being quite a bit harder for that deck to catch up if it falls behind.
Perhaps, but I think those decks were designed to be stronger. They were the best of what those colour combos could offer. These are designed to be great tribal decks, and for the most part they are, but unless you're playing something like goblins or elves, tribal is just not as competitive a deck. These are designed to be more casual. And after last year's price spikes, that's probably a good thing.
Shawn: plays mirror of the forebears Josh: I don't know how this card will work, I guess i have to wait and see. Josh 5 seconds later: I play mirror of the forebears
It's funny to think that a boardwipe that slows down EVERYONE in the game is the same thing as slowing down your opponents. It's a very narrow view of the game.
I feel like theres an argument to be made in favor of mel's view here. Yes I hate stax, stax are in no way fun to play against. do I run trivial stax pieces, yes everyone has at least one stax piece in one way or another in any deck, be it major or minor. They SLOW the game down. On board wraths and stuff that PREVENT you from playing anything are worse. With stuff like blind obedience, im gonna be mad, but im still gonna get to cast my janky artifacts and creatures, but larry niven's disk says, no one gets to play anything until im gone bc itll be gone when I decide to fuck everything up. TLDR Stax is stupid, but ill take slow down a turn over prevent until its gone any day
I love the little touches you guys put into your videos. The animations, the little snap shots and the reality show-esque side interviews all make for a really quality show. Great content guys!
At the end there mel, when you cast edgar he was supposed to get 2 +1+1 counters from opal palace. Glad it didn't mess up the game though. Brava to your win madam.
serenade yep she even said "seven mana" even though it should be 8 (for some reason a lot of people mistake Edgar markov for a 5 drop apparently, already saw that happen 3 times in reviews and stuff) but it's not like it would have mattered she still had 2 lands open.
I enjoyed this video, one: I saw how much everyone honestly enjoyed playing these decks, and two: this is one of the first videos of watching others play and you get to actually see the mechanics play out, you take the time to explain how the cards work as you play them, and because of that I enjoyed watching this match unfold. You definitely got a subscriber
41:35: Opal Palace -> The “number of times it’s been cast from the command zone” includes the most recent time. For example, the first time you cast your commander from the command zone in a game, if you spent mana from Opal Palace’s last ability to do so, it will enter the battlefield with a +1/+1 counter.
The cards from the wizard deck are actually bonkers strong if built around them. The main commander just has almost no support from the deck. It's badly prebuilt but the 2 side commanders are sweet.
MageKirby it's every other izzet Grixis combo deck. Looks harmless and durdely until without warning it draws a billion cards and cast a billion spells and wins out of nowhere.
As if I needed any more convincing to buy the Vampires deck...that game was full of SO MUCH COOL STUFF. Winning with Swords to Plowshares + Sanguine Bond?! Accidental boardwipe by cloning Butcher of Malakir?! Massive vampire flavor wins?! TOO MANY DRAGONS?! I have NEVER been this hype about Commander before!
@Scythic If you put it on yourself, it still triggers anytime any opponent attacks the cursed player, which is you. Instead of it only conferring a bonus to the attacking player, you both get the bonus and your opponent leaves themselves open to a counter swing after you have had the opportunity to kill some of their creatures with blocks. Its great as a deterrent because if they ignore it they just end up feeding into you.
I just love the production and editing of your Game Knights series. You all are very entertaining and I'm glad this series has continued and improved along the way. Great job!
This is great. You guys are really doing something right since I don't know how to even play magic and I've been watching you're videos. Love the interviews. You're able to captivate an audience other then the one you intended. Good job.
TY for this episode! After all the spoilers, to see these decks in action is amazing. I couldn't agree more that play-wise, I've never been this excited for a commander release. The plays in this episode were insane and Mel had some awesome tricks.
I love these gameplays! And Mel makes for an awesome villain! Loved her in your Nicol Bolas gameplay, and I loved her behind the Edgar Markov deck. Please invite her to more of these. XD
I really enjoyed watching this video. As this is the first video I've watched all the way through, I'm left wondering how they do the player commentary. Do they do it as the game goes, off to the side? They kind of talk about their own plans, so it would be a little odd just doing it right at the table (plus, I don't see cameras everywhere)... Or are they really good actors, and either note the commentary during the game that they want to say for editing later, or someone writes it for them, or do they just remember and say it later? Really good stuff, game seemed really realistic and casual and reminded me of the reason why I got into Commander in the first place. Good job, guys. I dunno if you ever respond to comments, but I'm actually really curious how you coordinate the commentary in a way that makes it seem like it's happening in the moment.
We play the game as normal but we pause at various points for everyone to take notes. Plus, we have a judge on site who is keeping track of every card and move made in the game. Then - after the game is over - we interview each player going slowly through each play of the game (and consulting our notes, etc) and getting their perspective on it. This is also a time when we begin to notice patterns or common themes and we do a small amount of staging or scripting. For example, we came up with the idea of Jimmy doing parodies of famous political speeches during the interview because we knew that the political argument was an interesting moment we were likely to highlight.
Cool! Have we ever seen this judge in a video before, i.e. "Hey, I'm Mark, and you never see me but my job is really important!" I really enjoy how you combine Magic playing and, for lack of a better word, theatre, to make a really interesting video. I don't normally watch gameplay videos, but the work you put into these episodes is evident, and I'm sure I'll be spending more time watching future videos of yours. With the knowledge of how you do the commentary, I'm left surprised at the amount of enthusiasm you guys give a play that happened half an hour ago. As an actor, I can appreciate just how difficult it is to recreate authentic emotion to something that you've already done, let alone having played thousands of previous commander games with the same people. You guys clearly enjoy the game, and you know what you're doing. Have a nice day! Throughly impressed. Edit: I also appreciate the editing that goes into the extra stuff, like the popups of the cards and tokens, making the power and toughness bigger when you pump a creature, the bounty counters making the creature "Wanted"... Clearly you have an editor that enjoys their work, if not more than that.
To piggy back on Snaky Dragon, I agree with everything he said about your gameplay videos format, and I love the sound design and editing. The use of colorful sound effects to underline pumping and other game events is really compelling
33:20 The moment ive been waiting for all episode. I discovered Vela a few months ago, so September 2019, and she is amazing. In my opinion a very underrated commander. Yes she's a 6 drop but if you can time board wipes correctly it will hurt everybody way more than it hurts you.
Vampires seems like a well rounded deck, and due to Edgar's eminence ability can rebuild quickly. Cats has staying power with all the equipments, though we didn't really see any that game. Dragons is kinda clunky due to a weak mana-base, but if you can stabilize I would think it would be easy to run away with the game. Wizards is the weakest deck out of the box, but with some modifications it would probably be very easy to win out of nowhere. If I had to get 3 friends and play against them, straight out of the box, I would go for the vampire deck. I'm slightly biased, as vampires are my favorite tribe along with sphinx, but I feel that the go-wide strategy of the vampire deck, coupled with the quick rebuilding time can take down games. Edgar's lord ability certainly doesn't hurt either, and if you add things like Bloodline Keeper/Lord of Lineage, you can win, albeit after a bit of a build up. I found that with a few additions, the vampire deck can knock someone out by turn fiour, if it gets lucky. To do this, you must have one mountain, one plains, two swamp, a one-drop vampire, a three-drop vampire, Bloodline Keeper, and a Sol Ring. For math reasons, the one-drop used in this example shall be a Falkenrath Gorger, and the three-drop Vampire Nighthawk Turn 1: Mountain, Sol Ring Turn 2: Swamp, three-drop vampire and one-drop vampire, make two friends off of eminence Turn 3: Swamp, Bloodline Keeper, make a friend, swing with the one drop, the three drop and two friends. 5 damage. Turn 4. Plains, Cast Edgar from the command zone, use the one black to flip the Bloodline Keeper into Lord of Lineage. Move to combat. Send everything at one player. You have 3 4/4s, due to the +2/+2 from the Lord, and Edgar's +1/+1 counters. Then Lord of Lineage becomes a 6/6, and Edgar becomes a 7/7. The one-drop (Falkenrath Gorger) becomes a 5/4, and the three-drop (Kheru) becomes a 5/6. That comes out to a total of 4+4+4+6+7+5+4= 35 total damage.
but at least wait to play the white zenit right..? It's an instant. That way you could monstrosity in case of a board wipe or surprise block with your cats or whatever.. Did I miss something? Anyways, great games and content nonetheless
Watched it again here in 2023 just to see some OG wholesome commander . These commanders definitely made their mark over the years . I still have an Ur Dragon and Edgar deck , and Arahbo in my Rinn and Seri , but I think I'm gonna go back and build the other two now for nostalgia. Think it'll be a blast .
Wizards just looked so weak because it got pounded the whole game. Grixis isn't one of the faster decks and if it gets taken out or beaten on early, there isn't much to come back from (except you actually play with good cards like Cyclonic Rift).
Does anyone have an idea who the guy is on the new curse cards because he is very unfortunate? He is on every curse card. Would Mel have any insight on this?
My very first game of magic was actually with these exact decks. I had no idea what was happening, but they explained the mechanics as we went. Favorite moment was when I asked “hey, what’s a fate token?” and everyone else freaked out. That was a good boardwipe
Shouldn't JLK get Gold when Jimmy attacked Mage guy? EDIT: Just read the text. Yes, the Curser gets the bonus when other people attack. So JLK would get Gold each time Jimmy/Mel attacked, and Mel would've got Zombies likewise.
I really really enjoy these Game Knights and thanks to you guys i'm hoping to get one of the commanders myself to try out! Would buy the set myself but money is a little time for the time being but I made sure that my friends who did purchase the sets did so through your link! Thanks guys
I am just getting to watch Command Zone Game Knights. These videos are all great. I notice the rules sometimes are not caught, and that happens in games like this that require a lot of focus. I love that Game Knights will post about things missed in the comments to clarify. I see that the 2nd time Mel cast Edgar (and used Opal palace this time), it was only brought in with 1 counter, she still won, but it should have been 2 counters as this was the second time that Edgar was cast. Keep up the great show! It is great content to binge during this stay at home order!
At 14:34 regarding The Ur-Dragons ability. You may "put" a permanent on the battlefield is different from "playing" a permanent which means you don't have to pay its mana cost? That's awesome
As some of you have pointed out - we misplayed the Curses a bit. The player who cast the curse should get the benefit every time the target player is attacked by any player. Many apologies. This is upsetting to me, mostly because I could have had so much more Gold! -JLK
The Command Zone it's ok man as long as it stayed consistent everyone makes mistakes :)
I had to read each of the curses 3 times before I understood it, too, so I'm glad I'm not the only one that thinks they are confusing.
You see mister powers. I LOVE GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOLLLLLLLLLDDDD!
The Command Zone will you still take them all out of your decks with that extra effect in mind?
Came here to say this.
You know whats great? rewatching this series in 2020 because I can't remember who wins any of the matches :D
What’s even better is watching what cards are in a certain commander deck and working them into your own lol
Are you me?
Same tho
I do this all the time! The commander cube episode is epic
This is exactly what I’ve been doing. I watched these over a year and a half ago, and now I can watch them again as if it’s new.
Its crazy that 4 years later, edgar markov and ur-dragon are 2 of the best commanders
So Mel is the lead for creating the most broken mechanic in commander. Props to her.. 🙄
the ur dragon precon is like $300… im so glad i bought the kaleidoscope killers secret lair that copy is like $95
Yeah, Eminence really is disgusting lol
I love it!
Just bought the ur-dragon precon in 2024 to finally live my dream of playing this busted commander
That guy has super-villain wizard eyebrows. Very fitting deck choice.
😂😂😂😂
2:06 "be the sneaky one" and then proceeds to get cursed and destroyed by the rest of the players.
Is anyone else giddy by the fact that the way Mel won was by having Edgar lay down his sword after combat and go start a farm in the countryside, which caused Shawn to just kinda...keel over and die?
I agree. One of my favorite game finishes yet. That Mel. She has style.
best ending :)
I'm pretty sure that was the first time anyone has swords-to-plowshares their own creature to win the game.
@@mellowwookiee7533 even better: our 8 player free for all had taken too long so we decided to go around once and determine the winner by lifepoints. I was the last and at the end i tried to path my own commander, gaining 6 life and get no top, but someone COUNTERED MY REMOVAL ON MY OWN GUY! so I came second...
@@jayp4687 Damn... That's gotta suck.
"I dont have artifact removal, but I have player removal"😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@Nightwizard I mean, it was a really good line
Spoken like a true black player
The line became a meme in the show, been backtracking to find the original source, glad to rewatch and find it!
The American way /j
😁"I will equip the Lightning Greaves"
☝️
😨"I-I'll go to equip..."
My man's eyebrows on point
emphasis on "point"
Evil Otto Jr. Productions crYING LMFAO
We've got a motherfucking Kemal Ataturk here.
He may or may not look like a cartoon villain
For real
Mel is so much fun! Charming, outgoing, competitive and with a hint of malice. Invite her more often!!
Somewhere out there in the world, there is a seething Kathleen DeVere who is upset that she didn't get invited to play the Cat Deck.
so true.
Gavin Li Ehh... LRR will stream their own Commander game with these decks soon enough, after their move. She'll get her shot then.
It would have been awesome to have her play the cat deck, but most guests on the show (including Shawn and Melissa), already live in the LA area. I don't really think they have a budget for travel. :)
Vampires. Kat is crazy about vamps.
just wait for the Friday nights for commander 2017 I'm sure there will be one
the editing on this is amazing. Love how quick it is, turns what could be an hour and half video into 45 minutes of entertainment!
I'm revisiting this video because I've pull out my Ur-dragon, Edgar, and Arahbo decks and started putting new cards in them. This is the video that got me into commander and got me to buy those decks.
Mel's play at the end was extremely sick 👌
Are the cat ears from ultra-pro too?
yep, you can buy them on cardkingdom as well.
Lol
@@sweetkicksvideos7566 you lie.. not in cardkingdom.
@@genmasaotome3503 calm down, its a joke.
Genma Saotome r/whoooooosh
Wow, so what I saw there was...
Cats: Strong early game, but like many aggro decks it needs to take people out fast to get there...which just isn't easy to do in Commander. I'm much more interested in going wide and using equipment in that deck, I prefer the other two commanders. Can't wait to add Amoncats to it too.
Dragons: Exactly what I expected, crazy splashy plays made possible by seriously sweet ramp - seemed like Josh had the perfect opening hand. Shame about all the missed gold. The Utvara Hellkite play was awesome, I am SO happy that card is in the deck.
Wizards: I knew it was a slower deck, but I don't think we really got to see any of its potential here, because everyone else was so aggro so fast with those curses... the others having great ramp into their aggro really didn't help.
Vampires: Surprisingly effective, Sanguine Bond is such a powerful include, and sweet tech with Blind Obedience, insane with that kicker spell. Never seen Swords to Plowshares used as a finisher before :P
what do you think is the strongest dragon or vampire?
I feel like dragons will be consistently stronger, but that does rely on getting a decent opening, with enough ramp and colour fixing. It's probably one of the better decks at catching up if it does fall behind, too.
Vampires does have the potential to be explosive though, if it casts like 3 vampires in a turn, say... But I could imagine it being quite a bit harder for that deck to catch up if it falls behind.
good to know, but I still think these precon decks are severely underpowered compared to the previous 2016 ones
Perhaps, but I think those decks were designed to be stronger. They were the best of what those colour combos could offer. These are designed to be great tribal decks, and for the most part they are, but unless you're playing something like goblins or elves, tribal is just not as competitive a deck. These are designed to be more casual. And after last year's price spikes, that's probably a good thing.
Well said, sir.
Shawn: plays mirror of the forebears
Josh: I don't know how this card will work, I guess i have to wait and see.
Josh 5 seconds later: I play mirror of the forebears
" You know what sucks ? Chump blocking with a dragon... "
I`ll never get over this xD
Mel is fucking amazing being the lead design of my favorite set of magic.
AND SHE PLAYED EDGAR MY FAV COMMANDER OF THE SET!!!!
It's a shame Wizards lost her to Riot Games.
Don't cuss
@@MadShike lmao idk if ur serious
Well Yes I Am Be Civilized Dear Gentleman And Wear Monocles as Well As Top Hats Dear sir Thank You Gentle Moron
Mel: "on board board wipes are such a draaaaag"
Also mel: "bLiNd oBeDiEnCe iS oNe oF mY fAvOriTe cArdS"
Sorry, new player here. Is there a common board wipe combo with blind obedience or something?
@@DODUCKA blind obedience also makes the game drag.
It's funny to think that a boardwipe that slows down EVERYONE in the game is the same thing as slowing down your opponents. It's a very narrow view of the game.
@@DODUCKA blind obedience makes everything you do slower and harder, it's essentially a stax piece, if you know what that is.
I feel like theres an argument to be made in favor of mel's view here. Yes I hate stax, stax are in no way fun to play against. do I run trivial stax pieces, yes everyone has at least one stax piece in one way or another in any deck, be it major or minor. They SLOW the game down. On board wraths and stuff that PREVENT you from playing anything are worse. With stuff like blind obedience, im gonna be mad, but im still gonna get to cast my janky artifacts and creatures, but larry niven's disk says, no one gets to play anything until im gone bc itll be gone when I decide to fuck everything up.
TLDR Stax is stupid, but ill take slow down a turn over prevent until its gone any day
dude, that playmat rollout. *chef finger kiss*
Got it on the first take too!
Ayy, I like your Podcast Commanderin'! (sneaky advertisement is sneaky)
I have to say, the more I watch this video, the more I appreciate Shawn's presence.
Shawn brought appropriate eyebrows for a wizard deck.
on theme
6:09 43 to 36 6 damage...
yeah, i caught that too lol
She corrects to 37
You noticed that too!
I noticed thay
I saw that
I love the little touches you guys put into your videos. The animations, the little snap shots and the reality show-esque side interviews all make for a really quality show. Great content guys!
Best mtg series on TH-cam period!!!
The "Wanted Card Frame" transition was really a nice creative choice when the "Bounty Counter" was played. Bravo.
At the end there mel, when you cast edgar he was supposed to get 2 +1+1 counters from opal palace. Glad it didn't mess up the game though. Brava to your win madam.
I think she also only paid 1 mana for commander tax instead of two.
serenade yep she even said "seven mana" even though it should be 8 (for some reason a lot of people mistake Edgar markov for a 5 drop apparently, already saw that happen 3 times in reviews and stuff) but it's not like it would have mattered she still had 2 lands open.
This is when the show made a huge difference in production and editing. Glad I got to see it.
I enjoyed this video, one: I saw how much everyone honestly enjoyed playing these decks, and two: this is one of the first videos of watching others play and you get to actually see the mechanics play out, you take the time to explain how the cards work as you play them, and because of that I enjoyed watching this match unfold. You definitely got a subscriber
27:30 that moment when you take a quick peak at what your opponent draw
*quick stare
Seriously gents, the production is getting better and better as these continue to roll out. Congrats on the success and continuous leveling up! :)
The vampires deck is definitely the one I'm most excited for. So I'm glad it performed well. I'm gonna try to pick up the wizards deck as well.
41:35:
Opal Palace ->
The “number of times it’s been cast from the command zone” includes the most recent time. For example, the first time you cast your commander from the command zone in a game, if you spent mana from Opal Palace’s last ability to do so, it will enter the battlefield with a +1/+1 counter.
The cat deck would be ridiculous with Ajani, Caller of the Pride
or any ajani in that fact
Sam Wise yeah I bought s box that had like I think three in it so
Metalsnake I think it has an ajani
It doesn't come with any Ajani Planeswalkers, if that is what you are saying.
Midnight Magic No, but his dead brother is in it.
Wait so what does the wizard deck do lol
MageKirby It's supposed to combo off but it's very janky compared with the other decks.
The cards from the wizard deck are actually bonkers strong if built around them. The main commander just has almost no support from the deck. It's badly prebuilt but the 2 side commanders are sweet.
It wants to be stormy but fails
MageKirby it's every other izzet Grixis combo deck. Looks harmless and durdely until without warning it draws a billion cards and cast a billion spells and wins out of nowhere.
Alex Dattel the wizard deck is borderline awful. i don't hate it but im not going to buy it.
As if I needed any more convincing to buy the Vampires deck...that game was full of SO MUCH COOL STUFF. Winning with Swords to Plowshares + Sanguine Bond?! Accidental boardwipe by cloning Butcher of Malakir?! Massive vampire flavor wins?! TOO MANY DRAGONS?! I have NEVER been this hype about Commander before!
I agree! But, the Butcher of Malakir clone/board wipe thing was not an accident - just sayin :-P
Yall only got one thing truly wrong: these curses are for casting on *_yourself._*
But why?
Cast untap one on yourself, and you'll always have blockers lol. (bad idea but interesting)
@Scythic
If you put it on yourself, it still triggers anytime any opponent attacks the cursed player, which is you. Instead of it only conferring a bonus to the attacking player, you both get the bonus and your opponent leaves themselves open to a counter swing after you have had the opportunity to kill some of their creatures with blocks.
Its great as a deterrent because if they ignore it they just end up feeding into you.
Sean's eyebrows are straight out a cartoon.
You could say the cats are not kitten around.
Nice pun 👍
It's such a shame Shawn never got to do much at all. When Mel took over the game it just became obvious noone would ever be able to stop her.
A Cat, a Wizard, a Dragon, and a Vampire. Is this Magic or a Skyrim play-through?
YES! A NEW EPISODE OF GAME KNIGHTS! It's like Christmas During summer...
I just love the production and editing of your Game Knights series. You all are very entertaining and I'm glad this series has continued and improved along the way. Great job!
This is great. You guys are really doing something right since I don't know how to even play magic and I've been watching you're videos. Love the interviews. You're able to captivate an audience other then the one you intended. Good job.
Rofl, make sure everyone stays to the end, that was amazing Josh!
Glad you liked :-)
38:24 This is absolutely my favorite line of the whole video XD
Jimmy was right. lol. I was thinking that Josh was going to ice them one by one before he pointed it out.
Josh LK that was the dopest board wipe ever 😄 I am truly impressed, sir @ 36:00 min +/- "non-coventional" board wipe 👍
TY for this episode! After all the spoilers, to see these decks in action is amazing. I couldn't agree more that play-wise, I've never been this excited for a commander release. The plays in this episode were insane and Mel had some awesome tricks.
this game is so good every five minutes you think one player is going to win, then its the other and everyone seems to have fun!
Josh's outro just brought my respect for him to a whole new level
I still get so much joy out of the fact Mel secured the win by having Edgar lay down his arms
love the game play as always! Great job and keep up the phenomenal work! You guys provide the best commander content by far.
I love these gameplays! And Mel makes for an awesome villain! Loved her in your Nicol Bolas gameplay, and I loved her behind the Edgar Markov deck. Please invite her to more of these. XD
Can't wait to get my hands on one of these. I'm leaning towards wizards, hoping I can make it work better than what was shown in this episode.
I was waiting so long for this episode.
just wanna say that my friends and I just got more into magic because of these episodes, so thanks 👍👍👍🤘
We absolutely love hearing that!
This is the only best magic channel to watch.
Most entertaining commander content on youtube. Please don't stop the Game Knights.
Shawn Main makes me think of what a Henson muppet would be like if it were a real person. Great guy.
I really enjoyed watching this video. As this is the first video I've watched all the way through, I'm left wondering how they do the player commentary. Do they do it as the game goes, off to the side? They kind of talk about their own plans, so it would be a little odd just doing it right at the table (plus, I don't see cameras everywhere)... Or are they really good actors, and either note the commentary during the game that they want to say for editing later, or someone writes it for them, or do they just remember and say it later? Really good stuff, game seemed really realistic and casual and reminded me of the reason why I got into Commander in the first place.
Good job, guys. I dunno if you ever respond to comments, but I'm actually really curious how you coordinate the commentary in a way that makes it seem like it's happening in the moment.
We play the game as normal but we pause at various points for everyone to take notes. Plus, we have a judge on site who is keeping track of every card and move made in the game. Then - after the game is over - we interview each player going slowly through each play of the game (and consulting our notes, etc) and getting their perspective on it.
This is also a time when we begin to notice patterns or common themes and we do a small amount of staging or scripting. For example, we came up with the idea of Jimmy doing parodies of famous political speeches during the interview because we knew that the political argument was an interesting moment we were likely to highlight.
Cool! Have we ever seen this judge in a video before, i.e. "Hey, I'm Mark, and you never see me but my job is really important!" I really enjoy how you combine Magic playing and, for lack of a better word, theatre, to make a really interesting video. I don't normally watch gameplay videos, but the work you put into these episodes is evident, and I'm sure I'll be spending more time watching future videos of yours.
With the knowledge of how you do the commentary, I'm left surprised at the amount of enthusiasm you guys give a play that happened half an hour ago. As an actor, I can appreciate just how difficult it is to recreate authentic emotion to something that you've already done, let alone having played thousands of previous commander games with the same people. You guys clearly enjoy the game, and you know what you're doing.
Have a nice day! Throughly impressed.
Edit: I also appreciate the editing that goes into the extra stuff, like the popups of the cards and tokens, making the power and toughness bigger when you pump a creature, the bounty counters making the creature "Wanted"... Clearly you have an editor that enjoys their work, if not more than that.
To piggy back on Snaky Dragon, I agree with everything he said about your gameplay videos format, and I love the sound design and editing. The use of colorful sound effects to underline pumping and other game events is really compelling
Neither the judge nor the guys who worked for Wizards bothered to say "Those Curses are being played wrong?"
Snaky Dragon they do the game the sword and then they do the interviews they have a guy there typing everything down so they can react to it
Does anyone else want to see them play previous precons out of the box?
As usual these are such a joy to watch, also Josh works insanely to put it all together, but it turns out so seamless!
33:20 The moment ive been waiting for all episode. I discovered Vela a few months ago, so September 2019, and she is amazing. In my opinion a very underrated commander. Yes she's a 6 drop but if you can time board wipes correctly it will hurt everybody way more than it hurts you.
Watching this while I wait for my decks to be delivered. So far so good!
It seems like the wizard deck was a little under-powered. I felt like each deck was in control of the game except the wizard. Poor cursed wizards.
what do you think is the strongest deck?
Vampires seems like a well rounded deck, and due to Edgar's eminence ability can rebuild quickly. Cats has staying power with all the equipments, though we didn't really see any that game. Dragons is kinda clunky due to a weak mana-base, but if you can stabilize I would think it would be easy to run away with the game. Wizards is the weakest deck out of the box, but with some modifications it would probably be very easy to win out of nowhere. If I had to get 3 friends and play against them, straight out of the box, I would go for the vampire deck. I'm slightly biased, as vampires are my favorite tribe along with sphinx, but I feel that the go-wide strategy of the vampire deck, coupled with the quick rebuilding time can take down games. Edgar's lord ability certainly doesn't hurt either, and if you add things like Bloodline Keeper/Lord of Lineage, you can win, albeit after a bit of a build up. I found that with a few additions, the vampire deck can knock someone out by turn fiour, if it gets lucky. To do this, you must have one mountain, one plains, two swamp, a one-drop vampire, a three-drop vampire, Bloodline Keeper, and a Sol Ring. For math reasons, the one-drop used in this example shall be a Falkenrath Gorger, and the three-drop Vampire Nighthawk
Turn 1: Mountain, Sol Ring
Turn 2: Swamp, three-drop vampire and one-drop vampire, make two friends off of eminence
Turn 3: Swamp, Bloodline Keeper, make a friend, swing with the one drop, the three drop and two friends. 5 damage.
Turn 4. Plains, Cast Edgar from the command zone, use the one black to flip the Bloodline Keeper into Lord of Lineage. Move to combat. Send everything at one player. You have 3 4/4s, due to the +2/+2 from the Lord, and Edgar's +1/+1 counters. Then Lord of Lineage becomes a 6/6, and Edgar becomes a 7/7. The one-drop (Falkenrath Gorger) becomes a 5/4, and the three-drop (Kheru) becomes a 5/6. That comes out to a total of 4+4+4+6+7+5+4= 35 total damage.
To be fair he also got smashed by everyone, so he never really stood a chance
That guy has the most villainous eyebrows I've ever seen.
I LOVE THIS SHOW!!! This is the third episode I watched and I am well and truly hooked. Game Knights rule!!
As soon as I saw Edgar Markov was a commander, I knew he would bring home the win.. So powerful !
Battles of the MELISSAS with de tora vs mel
Did anyone noticed that Shawn main has a T-shirt of the ice king from adventure time?
Why did you not activate the monstrous ability Jimmy? It would have lasted through everything.
Not Butcher of Malakir. Also a Monstrous Fleecemane Lion does not block a 10/10 flying dragon - I needed to develop my board. - jimmy
but at least wait to play the white zenit right..? It's an instant. That way you could monstrosity in case of a board wipe or surprise block with your cats or whatever.. Did I miss something?
Anyways, great games and content nonetheless
LedPESRule precisely. he played it like it was a sorcery. too bad.
Watched it again here in 2023 just to see some OG wholesome commander . These commanders definitely made their mark over the years . I still have an Ur Dragon and Edgar deck , and Arahbo in my Rinn and Seri , but I think I'm gonna go back and build the other two now for nostalgia. Think it'll be a blast .
Omg thank you for this. I really wanted to see a play by play like this. Not enough of these.
Why invite Sean if you're just going to bully him?
He got 2nd place...
He only got 2nd because noone saw him as a thread after everyone got him beaten down :(
Scythic exactly
Already preordered the wining deck! Love that tribe.
Zach Harris same here bro, love the cards they put in it lots of them I have wanting for ages
Zach Harris you are awesome I like how u didn't spoil it for ppl reading the comments like me, thanks
Tempted to get all 4.. But Wizards looks so weak.. (But has the coolest side commanders..)
Sheriff K buy the singles on tcg if that's your only pro for buying it
Wizards just looked so weak because it got pounded the whole game. Grixis isn't one of the faster decks and if it gets taken out or beaten on early, there isn't much to come back from (except you actually play with good cards like Cyclonic Rift).
Does anyone have an idea who the guy is on the new curse cards because he is very unfortunate? He is on every curse card. Would Mel have any insight on this?
Jimmy's face when Mel asked the table who angered her the most. Cracks me up every time.
My very first game of magic was actually with these exact decks. I had no idea what was happening, but they explained the mechanics as we went. Favorite moment was when I asked “hey, what’s a fate token?” and everyone else freaked out. That was a good boardwipe
Ive been waiting for so long!!!
6:28 shouldnt mel be at 47 life?
37 life my mistake
He mispoke and said she had 43 but she actually only had 42 so -6 is 36.
Therrion ' no she gained 3 from the lands and they fixed it
She gained two from her first land and 1 from her second, putting her at 43. Losing 6 puts her at 37.
Andrew Velazquez 37
does anyone else think mel has a really soothing voice?
lol Mel's so funny. "what is that, a cat?" "it's a vampire." XD
You know what’s funny? Seeing Ur-Dragon and Edgar Markov have become more expensive than the entire precon deck 5 years later
Mel's final play was so much fun to watch
Fist of sun's= infinity gauntlet
This is true
Shouldn't JLK get Gold when Jimmy attacked Mage guy?
EDIT: Just read the text. Yes, the Curser gets the bonus when other people attack. So JLK would get Gold each time Jimmy/Mel attacked, and Mel would've got Zombies likewise.
Yes he should.
But the wording on the card is really wierd so I am not suprised that they did miss it.
I really really enjoy these Game Knights and thanks to you guys i'm hoping to get one of the commanders myself to try out! Would buy the set myself but money is a little time for the time being but I made sure that my friends who did purchase the sets did so through your link! Thanks guys
Cant tell you how many times I've watched both game knights and extra turns.....love these give me ideas for decks
21:08 how was Josh able to Target ur dragon when it had starld
that ice king shirt was dope
¿Only one game?
We would want to see like in the original chapters, at least two to see more variety...
I am just getting to watch Command Zone Game Knights. These videos are all great. I notice the rules sometimes are not caught, and that happens in games like this that require a lot of focus. I love that Game Knights will post about things missed in the comments to clarify. I see that the 2nd time Mel cast Edgar (and used Opal palace this time), it was only brought in with 1 counter, she still won, but it should have been 2 counters as this was the second time that Edgar was cast.
Keep up the great show! It is great content to binge during this stay at home order!
My favorite thing about this show is watching josh watch people make plays
Wizards was slow rolled. Wizards should have won... Yes, I did pre-order the wizards deck. ;)
I wish Shawn would come back with his Wizard eyebrows
Dragons or vampires? Now I can't decide
christopher acea same problem :(
Get all 4, best decision.
christopher acea Dragons cuz Dragons are cooler than gay vampires
Gay vampires yes...but what about STRAIGHT vampires...hmm...
Brought to you by ultra pro. Joking asides, great production value! I love the side commentaries!
At 14:34 regarding The Ur-Dragons ability. You may "put" a permanent on the battlefield is different from "playing" a permanent which means you don't have to pay its mana cost? That's awesome
Can I just say
Fleecemanne Lion is an insane cat card