I remember back when this dropped, we had MTVU in my dining hall in college. After like 6 months straight of Steve Aoki they randomly played this video. You could see everyone in there look up from their phones at the TV, like a spell had been broken. Thank you St Vincent.
There've been a lot of comments with this same template: "I can't believe ________ invented ______, iconic [or 'what an icon']" And I haven't seen a single fucking one that's older than a year and a half I think you started a trend.
I’m only just discovered St.Vincent in the last few weeks and may I say OMFG!!! You My Dear are a huge breath of fresh air!! Outstanding!! Finally someone new AND original!!!
Totally agree, I actually didn't like this song much when I first listened to it, but something always made me come back & loved it a little more each time. And now I can't stop listening to it.
hunger993 do you know what the song is about? Social media and technology creating dissatisfaction and numbness in its user’s lives. It seems the message went over your head.
I saw her in concert, I was very close to the stage and I touched her hand. She's absolutely stunning -I'm not even kidding. Best show I've ever seen. What an amazing experience.
I'm very thankful for my music junkie friends introducing me to St. Vincent~ The sound is refreshing, and the guitar work is a personal favorite. Love Love Love 🎶
Ladies and gentlemen this video was made before the advent of mass consumption of cell phones, listen, hear, and adhere to the message. Most of you have children and to give them that tree of knowledge (cell phone), use your best desecration on how to proceed, her song is on sound mind and body! The commercials are targeting their thoughts.
Love this. It's like modernized 80's music. Not saying it's unoriginal at all, because it's totally awesome and unique. There's just some influences that shine though like The Talking Heads which is cool.
+Rolman80 80 Bro, she's saying you hate this song, then ironically list all the qualities of this song as things you like in 80's music, then repeat that you hate this song.
Yeah man, I saw her in austin and dallas this week, and goddamn, I don't think anyone will ever be able to top those two shows, or any of her shows, ever.
What's with the haters? I like this, she doesn't just keep putting out the same thing over and over, she does something new and different with each album.
I was channel surfing tonight and stumbled into Austin City Limits tonight and I am seeing St. Vincent for the first time. Holy crap!!! What a unique sound and talent in this group. And a beautiful, talented front woman💪💪💪Reminds me of the first time I saw Grace Potter and the Nocturnals randomly on Austin City Limits. I was so blown away by Grace Potter that night. Grace and the band was so great sounding. I am truly impressed by what I'm watching right now. You can't beat Austin City Limits for finding a unique sounding band that SOMEHOW you have never heard of.
Saw St. Vincent in concert opening for the Black Keys this past month. Hadn't heard very much of her before then, but hot damn, I'm a fan now. Lots of great guitar work. This song is so damn catchy, too.
St. Vincent is a true artist, wether you want it or not, she writes beautiful and meaningful lyrics. Those texts tied to a creative and crazy production make incredible songs like this one and most of her discography.
Eno is the ever-present wisdomly grandfather who Annie has the closest bond with, and Steve Albini is the weird uncle with an abstract mind who she never connected with until adolescence and gave her her first guitar.
I remember when this came out , it was during the big internet fascination with people who live streamed their entire lives min by min. Its sad how this song still resonates today.
Well it's definitely not POP, nor rock either. "Alternative", maybe, but alternative to what? It also sounds a little like "new wave" (which is "new" since 1978). Well, I can tell you one thing for sure, it's jolly good fucking MUSIC
The people complaining that they don't understand what the song is about, is who the song is actually about. I love Annie Clark, I wish there were more artists like her.
Also.. I always like the criticism of "selling out." One can sell out and still be artistic -- just depends on how much they're willing to bend. All I know is that I'd sell out as soon as I could. God forbid, I make money doing what I enjoy.
Very true. Annie made a fan of me with her older material because I liked the sincerity (especially if you watch her older stuff live, like the DUMBO sessions), but with each album, she changed her sound and evolved, so I re-listen to them often. Each one satisfies a mood for me. This new album is pretty different, and I like it. It satisfies a different mood. It's fiercer, more experimental, and there's plenty more guitar (which Annie seemed to want to get back to). She's one of the few artists choosing to explore their style, and partially why she's my favorite artist. I'm excited for what she comes up with next.
Back when I first heard this song I thought it was ridiculous and awkward but I couldn't stop watching this video. Then something clicked. It's completely genius.
The first time I listened to this, I was like "Uh. What. No........." I listened to it a second time. Okay, maybe. Went and listened to a lot of her other songs, came back... AND YAAAAASSSS SLAAAAY
yeah this is true me with her in general. a year ago i had 2 songs from her on my computer, that i kinda liked. then i bought an album and another..and then the new one. i love basically every track. tho i had to pass on the album with david byrne..not really my speed
I am so lucky to've been born in a time where I get to watch you progress as an artist. Can't wait for the years and years to come. You are a great artist with an amazing vision. Thank you Annie, and everyone else involved.
True. Still the most viewed vid on the official channel tho, and one of the most plays on Spotify. Los Ageless always comes up as her most popular song (and while it’s brilliant and worthy of the claim) it’s datas a little obscured by it being featured in tv soundtracks. Think it’s safe say Digital Witness still gets the attention it deserves
I can't believe I found this video! Saw this years ago waiting in line at a theme park somewhere, but I couldn't hear the audio. All I remembered about it was a lady singing while looking up and to the side and people marching with the camera pretty far away. I found it really captivating and wanted to watch the full thing, but I couldn't find it. Of course it would be St. Vincent making such a cool video!
All you haters for this vid: did you actually listen to the lyrics cause she's right on the money with all this technology. I liked the way she avoids looking into the camera.
I was listening to this album 9 years ago and the tune has been stuck in my had ever since (And I couldn't remember the name) I'm glad I've got the video now!!!
Must admit the more I listen to this the more it sounds like she uncovered some unrecorded Talking Heads song and decided to record it herself. Which isn't a bad thing in the slightest.
Or, both her and the Talking Heads channeled the same muse... She simply channeled it for a song or two, whereas they channeled much more, quantity-wise, from the same.
The comments are like "i don't like this song, I don't like her music, i don't understand this" like ok??????? Don't watch it? I don't understand why you feel the need to add that comment in the first place, especially when there's already 1000+ comments saying the same thing. St. Vincent is quite popular, so obviously people do still like her music. No need for negativity.
The guitar part at 2:27 is STRAIGHT out of "Kiss." I saw her perform a couple weeks ago in Minneapolis and she gave a shoutout to Prince before performing "Sugarboy." My heart was warmed.
I love you, Annie! The originality in this video speaks to me on so many levels. Educating our society and showing us that we have become slaves to the technology of this generation!
What some of these negative commentators may not know is that Annie Clark is a virtuosic guitarist and an impeccable singer. If you ever get a chance to see her live, you'll realize just how jaw-droppingly talented she is.
She's been making music like this since 2009. Why are people just now coming to the realization that it's "weird" and criticizing her for it? This is actually pretty accessible in comparison to some of her other stuff, all of which i love. Can't wait for the new album!
Ten years ago I was studying in a community college and I needed a break. I decided to click on a random link based on the imagery to watch new art. I have been a huge fan since.
It is. You know normally I am one of those "Not everything needs a deep meaning." type people. I can listen to some pretty bad music as long as I can bob my head with the beat. But with her I feel like it is deeper. I think people assume that because it is 'pop' music it can't have a deep message. But that is just it, It can. Something can be simple and also complex. Everything is not black and white.
This really hits different! 🤯🤯🤯 I'm hooked, listening to it at least 10 times a day - being a digital witness on my own... If only I knew what the windows look like...? 🤔🤷🏼
Sometimes you're really late to a party. Just discovering St. Vincent. This is a brilliant composition.
I discovered her on SNL on the work tv on shift. I stopped dead to watch it. Maybe 2013?
about a decade
same here!
Ah hell yeah dude. Welcome! I come back here often. Been here for a decade. Austin, TX native.
Please check out The Hood Internets Digital Humpty.
I remember back when this dropped, we had MTVU in my dining hall in college. After like 6 months straight of Steve Aoki they randomly played this video. You could see everyone in there look up from their phones at the TV, like a spell had been broken. Thank you St Vincent.
just one of the crimes that steve aoki must pay for
When she says "ya" i really felt that
or "whaaats the point"
Ya
Ya?
Type O Negative 💚
I just recently saw her and the way the whole band said “ya” was so funny. She actually started laughing after one.
i can't believe st vincent invented music... iconic...
This a good comment
Did Mike's Mic write this comment ?
There've been a lot of comments with this same template: "I can't believe ________ invented ______, iconic [or 'what an icon']"
And I haven't seen a single fucking one that's older than a year and a half
I think you started a trend.
@@iwantaoctosteponmyneckbut3545 Are you Ben Shapiro?
@@lasseheller9863 lmao 😭
This is true ArtPop
People need to be disturbed by music more often. Thank you St. Vincent.
Agreed
Exactly. If I wanted to be comforted id wrap myself up in a blanket and take a nap. id rather be challenged. feel all the emotions.
What's disturbing is the truth found in the lyrics.
disturbing is Animal Collective - Peacebone
This is more of a film score than a song though. It’s too weird and just not catchy or memorable…it’s definitely interesting, just not a good song.
If St. Vincent was a Pokemon Gym Leader, she'd be an electric type gym-leader; no question.
fails
Absolutely
I’m only just discovered St.Vincent in the last few weeks and may I say OMFG!!! You My Dear are a huge breath of fresh air!! Outstanding!! Finally someone new AND original!!!
this song really grows on you.
I've listened so much since I've heard it this week.
Totally agree, I actually didn't like this song much when I first listened to it, but something always made me come back & loved it a little more each time. And now I can't stop listening to it.
Annie will always be a huge musical influence for me, everything she does is just so stellar
I love that every album she puts out is completely different in genre and vibe to anything else, and yet they're always recognisably St Vincent.
The most brilliant artist to fly over everyones heads.
Bullshit. Art is about communicating an idea.
@@hunger993 if that's not what this video and song is doing than what is it to you?
hunger993 do you know what the song is about? Social media and technology creating dissatisfaction and numbness in its user’s lives. It seems the message went over your head.
@@aniimusic1 This
Just discovered it, it's okay, not bad at all, just very pop-y, but that's the vibe
I saw her in concert, I was very close to the stage and I touched her hand. She's absolutely stunning -I'm not even kidding. Best show I've ever seen. What an amazing experience.
Yeah. Well. Did you touch her (fishnetted) legs, bro?
S'wat it's really all about, you know.
you havent been to any good concerts then..
agreeed
@@BostonianBroker You're from Boston - you're fairly fucking clueless on just about everything.
Wow sweeeeet !
She is proof that there are still artist out there making good music and artist. I love her.
I'm very thankful for my music junkie friends introducing me to St. Vincent~ The sound is refreshing, and the guitar work is a personal favorite. Love Love Love 🎶
LOVE LOVE LOVE YES
yes yes yes
Boontarika honey love love love love love
Ladies and gentlemen this video was made before the advent of mass consumption of cell phones, listen, hear, and adhere to the message. Most of you have children and to give them that tree of knowledge (cell phone), use your best desecration on how to proceed, her song is on sound mind and body! The commercials are targeting their thoughts.
Love this. It's like modernized 80's music. Not saying it's unoriginal at all, because it's totally awesome and unique. There's just some influences that shine though like The Talking Heads which is cool.
Unique?!?! Laurie Anderson was doing this same pretentious shit 30 years ago.
Teenage Hermit I hear some Kate Bush in this. :)
Teenage Hermit She works with David Byrne of Talking Heads frequently.
+Rolman80 80 lmfao
you're like:
"things i hate
1 negativity
2 lists
3 irony"
+Rolman80 80 Bro, she's saying you hate this song, then ironically list all the qualities of this song as things you like in 80's music, then repeat that you hate this song.
my friend’s mom played this song in the car when i was 12 and i forever thank her for letting me find this artist
yoooooooo my dad played st. vincent's performance of the song on the bbc and I've never been the same since.
Can’t believe it’s been almost 10 years since I found this song
I'm shocked too
St. Vincent opened for Roxy Music on their 50th anniversary tour last week. "Digital Witness" was her opener. It was SO AMAZING live.
Yeah man, I saw her in austin and dallas this week, and goddamn, I don't think anyone will ever be able to top those two shows, or any of her shows, ever.
You are so lucky to have enjoyed that!!!!
This woman is a genius. Just got home from a St. Vincent show. Mind blown.
What's with the haters? I like this, she doesn't just keep putting out the same thing over and over, she does something new and different with each album.
I was channel surfing tonight and stumbled into Austin City Limits tonight and I am seeing St. Vincent for the first time. Holy crap!!! What a unique sound and talent in this group. And a beautiful, talented front woman💪💪💪Reminds me of the first time I saw Grace Potter and the Nocturnals randomly on Austin City Limits. I was so blown away by Grace Potter that night. Grace and the band was so great sounding. I am truly impressed by what I'm watching right now. You can't beat Austin City Limits for finding a unique sounding band that SOMEHOW you have never heard of.
Crazy how a person with her impeccable facial aesthetics also turns out to be a brilliant musician & songwriter.
1174 people think their TVs actually are windows.
This song has the dopest beat, and mad clever lyrics.
New St. Vincent fan right here...
Saw St. Vincent in concert opening for the Black Keys this past month. Hadn't heard very much of her before then, but hot damn, I'm a fan now. Lots of great guitar work. This song is so damn catchy, too.
I bet she put on a better show than the Black Keys, she jams live.
I saw her in Austin with the Black Keys and was really sad when she left the stage :(
I envy her facial bone structure. She's absolutely beautiful and extremely talented.
Absolutely agree! Stunningly beautiful (and incredibly talented)
@@darkfate666 you just did
I love St Vincent's work especially this song. So catchy
I'm obsessed with this song...
Me too I've always loved it
Margaret Atwood is a woman of many talents.
LOLLL
i dont get it
+Joe Mama I know where to get it if you want it. ;o)
And the Eagle Eye award goes to...
10/10
St. Vincent is a true artist, wether you want it or not, she writes beautiful and meaningful lyrics. Those texts tied to a creative and crazy production make incredible songs like this one and most of her discography.
It's like Prince and Bowie had a baby...and David Bryne was the nanny.
Hell yes
Wrong
VERY Byrne-ish
So that is why I felt appealed from the first sound.
Eno is the ever-present wisdomly grandfather who Annie has the closest bond with, and Steve Albini is the weird uncle with an abstract mind who she never connected with until adolescence and gave her her first guitar.
At first I thought this song was super weird, but the more I listened to it, she's speaking the truth. Great song, and the beat is killer
Can't believe I'm just finding this now. This is brilliant
This video and song need to be the national anthem. The fact that this was released in 2015 is remarkable.
It was out before then. I remember this playing in some resturants i was in in 2012, so it's older than 2015
I remember when this came out , it was during the big internet fascination with people who live streamed their entire lives min by min. Its sad how this song still resonates today.
The other day...my workmate told me about St. Vincent. "Really intelligent POP music" he said....Yaaah!!
Well it's definitely not POP, nor rock either. "Alternative", maybe, but alternative to what? It also sounds a little like "new wave" (which is "new" since 1978). Well, I can tell you one thing for sure, it's jolly good fucking MUSIC
Martín Zuccari Its pop. Don't make pop a dirty word.
Martín Zuccari Indie or Alt Pop.
Sandrin Fernando or just pop because there is nothing wrong with pop.
certainly there is not. There's someting wrong with some so called "pop" artist, that's it.
The people complaining that they don't understand what the song is about, is who the song is actually about. I love Annie Clark, I wish there were more artists like her.
This song helps reaffirm my desire to document my entire life on social media. Thanks, Annie!
I think the point was to make you question that desire. Unless you're being sarcastic and I missed it?
@@teodorasavoiu4664 I was being cheeky. I love Annie and this song is amazing... and eerily accurate.
The little guitar riff at 1:29 brings me much joy
0:55 that Moogy- sounding bass - TASTY!
I appreciate artists who aren't afraid to evolve their sound. If you aren't trying something different every once in awhile, why make anything at all?
hunter kreuer Or as the art world knows it and routinely refers to it - deconstruction.
hunter kreuer That doesn't even make sense to suggest.
Also.. I always like the criticism of "selling out." One can sell out and still be artistic -- just depends on how much they're willing to bend.
All I know is that I'd sell out as soon as I could. God forbid, I make money doing what I enjoy.
I agree wholeheartedly. However, as Brian Eno says, "Have we not evolved beyond the Talking Heads?"
Very true. Annie made a fan of me with her older material because I liked the sincerity (especially if you watch her older stuff live, like the DUMBO sessions), but with each album, she changed her sound and evolved, so I re-listen to them often. Each one satisfies a mood for me. This new album is pretty different, and I like it. It satisfies a different mood. It's fiercer, more experimental, and there's plenty more guitar (which Annie seemed to want to get back to). She's one of the few artists choosing to explore their style, and partially why she's my favorite artist. I'm excited for what she comes up with next.
Back when I first heard this song I thought it was ridiculous and awkward but I couldn't stop watching this video. Then something clicked. It's completely genius.
I forget when I first saw this. But I'm kinda shocked that it's going on 10 years old now.
The first time I listened to this, I was like "Uh. What. No........."
I listened to it a second time. Okay, maybe.
Went and listened to a lot of her other songs, came back... AND YAAAAASSSS SLAAAAY
Exactly the same response for me :)
yeah this is true me with her in general. a year ago i had 2 songs from her on my computer, that i kinda liked. then i bought an album and another..and then the new one. i love basically every track. tho i had to pass on the album with david byrne..not really my speed
Literally me xD
Same
same😂 actually scare me first
Loving discovering this amazing material.
Why people say this is pretentious? It's just good music, and just fuckin listen to it
Them joints are ready. Nice rolling kids
My new favorite singer. Annie Clark is awesome.
I Luv St. Vincent
She is such a beauty!
Was kind of weird listening to this the first time but after a while I started to love this song
I love the synth in the chorus near the end. This song is a grower. Took me a couple listens to enjoy.
I am so lucky to've been born in a time where I get to watch you progress as an artist. Can't wait for the years and years to come. You are a great artist with an amazing vision. Thank you Annie, and everyone else involved.
this gem is sadly a bit forgotten today ;c
True. Still the most viewed vid on the official channel tho, and one of the most plays on Spotify. Los Ageless always comes up as her most popular song (and while it’s brilliant and worthy of the claim) it’s datas a little obscured by it being featured in tv soundtracks. Think it’s safe say Digital Witness still gets the attention it deserves
When God wants to say something, HE speaks through people like YOU
Easily one of the most inventive musicians I have ever had the pleasure to listen to. 👍🏼
This song is a bop
I can't believe I found this video! Saw this years ago waiting in line at a theme park somewhere, but I couldn't hear the audio. All I remembered about it was a lady singing while looking up and to the side and people marching with the camera pretty far away. I found it really captivating and wanted to watch the full thing, but I couldn't find it. Of course it would be St. Vincent making such a cool video!
Great music and the video is grand.
I honestly never get sick of this song. It's fantastic. St. Vincent is fantastic.
NO NO NO
All you haters for this vid: did you actually listen to the lyrics cause she's right on the money with all this technology. I liked the way she avoids looking into the camera.
Annie is a musical genius.
Those joints are ready
I was listening to this album 9 years ago and the tune has been stuck in my had ever since (And I couldn't remember the name) I'm glad I've got the video now!!!
It's a good song
that guitar in the chorus, wow
St. Vincent is so commanding and beautiful.
The hair style of the st. vincent era was cool as fuck
St. Vincent is amazing
Must admit the more I listen to this the more it sounds like she uncovered some unrecorded Talking Heads song and decided to record it herself. Which isn't a bad thing in the slightest.
100% YES 😀
Or, both her and the Talking Heads channeled the same muse... She simply channeled it for a song or two, whereas they channeled much more, quantity-wise, from the same.
@@JasonBunting Reminds me of early Tori Amos.
it looks like one of the black mirror episodes for me
hah my first thought too :)
Which one?
Yeah. St. Vincent's world was like an alpha version of San Junipero.
St. Vincent is such an icon and this video is genius.
The comments are like "i don't like this song, I don't like her music, i don't understand this" like ok??????? Don't watch it? I don't understand why you feel the need to add that comment in the first place, especially when there's already 1000+ comments saying the same thing. St. Vincent is quite popular, so obviously people do still like her music. No need for negativity.
Well they came here to listen and commented their opinion. Stop acting like this is new.
Wrong
nice, this is the first song i heard by this artist
I like St. Vincent.
If you don't sleep, you won't show ir never. Thank you st. Vincent!!!!!!!
The guitar part at 2:27 is STRAIGHT out of "Kiss." I saw her perform a couple weeks ago in Minneapolis and she gave a shoutout to Prince before performing "Sugarboy." My heart was warmed.
I hear it I love it
OMG, this music video is amazing!!!!!!!
I love you, Annie! The originality in this video speaks to me on so many levels. Educating our society and showing us that we have become slaves to the technology of this generation!
The quality if the video is amazing, it looks like a real place. Those outside scenes
This is mostly just unbelievably good.
I’ve never found “Yah” so catchy!!
What some of these negative commentators may not know is that Annie Clark is a virtuosic guitarist and an impeccable singer. If you ever get a chance to see her live, you'll realize just how jaw-droppingly talented she is.
She's a good guitarist. She's not remotely close to being a virtuoso. And who cares, what she actually does in the song is what matters.
SpookyApparition
Fair enough, and I happen to like the song quite a lot.
This is an almost magical undertaking . The first time I saw this it felt like a revelation. I love this still 10 years later.
might as well call this 'The David Byrne Effect'
I love it #StVincent
She's a great artist! why there's so many dislikes? unbelievable
She's been making music like this since 2009. Why are people just now coming to the realization that it's "weird" and criticizing her for it? This is actually pretty accessible in comparison to some of her other stuff, all of which i love. Can't wait for the new album!
Ten years ago I was studying in a community college and I needed a break. I decided to click on a random link based on the imagery to watch new art. I have been a huge fan since.
Rock and Roll is dead, but at least there's St. Vincent!
I don't understand all the thumbs down votes for this video. I'm just going to continue on liking this song and ignore it.
But am I though?
Sort of ironic comment in and of itself, but okay. Peace.
what's with all the dislikes? I freaking love this video and this song!
its because its on ads, and most people don't like ads, even if they are good.
lol just skip the add then I know I do when it pops up
1ab23c4d5e6f
For whatever reason, I've yet to see an ad when watching this video, and I've seen it more than a few times in the last week.
***** im not the hater, im saying that is their logic.
***** This video IS an ad. That's what he/she was saying.
Incredible video. Like an Edward Hopper painting.
I first heard her on rock n roll hall of fame covering lithium with Dave and Krist, I've only fallen more in love with her music ever since
Besides being incredibly talented and unique, she has the most beautiful sexy neck I've ever seen.
wtf
YEEEEEESSSSS SHE DOOOOO
Damn vampires.
Yes
🧄🧄🧄🧄🧄
Clearly guys, the people who don't get the message are the ones the song is about.
It is. You know normally I am one of those "Not everything needs a deep meaning." type people. I can listen to some pretty bad music as long as I can bob my head with the beat. But with her I feel like it is deeper. I think people assume that because it is 'pop' music it can't have a deep message. But that is just it, It can. Something can be simple and also complex. Everything is not black and white.
Agreed.
I keep rewinding to that eye roll at 2:25. I don't know why but I can't stop watching it.
OMGG LOVE THE MEANIG AND THE SOOOOONNNNNNNNNGGG
I never knew her music could be this incredible; it's truly timeless. I swear, more people need to discover Annie's work!!!
This lyrics has a incredible criticism. Annie is modern genius.
This really hits different! 🤯🤯🤯
I'm hooked, listening to it at least 10 times a day - being a digital witness on my own...
If only I knew what the windows look like...? 🤔🤷🏼