I was in the market, took both bikes out for an extensive ride, that KTM engine! Anyway, when all was said and done, I walked out of a KTM Dealership with the KTM 1290 Super Adventure with factory panniers for $16499, the equally equipped BMW GSA with panniers was $26,000 and my local BMW would not budge off that price. My decision was easy!
I had a very similar experience. Ktm for me, and I'm glad for it. The motor is just so so good. One of, if not the very best motors in motorcycling. 1290 SA
Going to my KTM dealer this week, this is going to be the deciding factor for me as well, who can I get the best deal from on end of season 2018's... BMW or KTM?
Great review MSDF but yes what tacjam 1 said. BMW is nearly $10,000 more than the KTM . Which leaves alot of spending money for upgrades and Trip expenses.
Absolutely incredible review!!! I was literally in between these two bikes as I am doing research for a long tour...not quite sure where yet. Thank you for the information and I can't wait to check out the rest of your channel!
The KTM would be like the gal you want to party and have fun all night long, the BMW would be the gal you want to settle down with. Another really nice and interesting review sir! Cheers!
Actually if you like off-roading a bit the KTM will make you feel a lot like a Dakar racer (see: suspension) vs an SUV driver that can get there (but not always). P.S. I owned both bikes (or variants).
Hi, I’m getting very interested in motorcycling quite late in life. I would like to complement you on the way you present your articles. I’ll keep watching thank you.
Excellent detailed comparison. However, I wish bike reviewers would begin to address the largest concern for every rider in the UK - security! Can you fit a big chain through the frame or swing arm? What does the bike come with stock to prevent theft? These adventure bikes are HUGE targets for theives.
MUNRO MUSIC I have just bought the new GS Rallye version. It came with alarm, immobilizer and yes, you can get a BIG chain through the frame at various positions.
@munro. Have look at the Pragmasis site for their anti-pinch pin. This goes through the hollow swing arm on bikes like the bmw, with a 19mm chain either side to ground anchor (or other immovable object if parking up when out and about ) and squire lock. You can also option an alarm with the bmw.
Mr Flyer, great review as always. But in all fairness, your GS (as good as it is) is a 2014 model. That's not fair. The new GS: the gearbox is much better, the shifter/blipper is much better, & the TFT is probably the best screen in the world at the moment. The fact that it doesn't have issues with glare or sun like others. Also, the KTM would be more suited up against the GSA. The big thing that gets me with all riders that say the KTM has more power, & the BMW should get more, is ridiculous. Think about it gentleman. You don't want a motor that eggs you on to blast it when your selecting a touring/cruising bike. For example like the Super Duke, Ducati Monster, & all super-sport bikes. Im a '16 S1000RR rider, and unless your in the 6k, 7k, or 8k zone and up, your not enjoying the bike. This is what their made for, to blast like a bat out of hell. Sport bikes are boring when cruising. So with my "Sports-bike/power on tap" mentality, I was disappointed when I jumped on the GS for a test ride. The "Docile" style motor, the boxer, was not up to it (like the KTM riders say)......Until the penny dropped!!!! I realised the motor wasn't egging me on to blast it all the time. Hence the ride was much more sophisticated, smooth and enjoyable. Then I opened it up, due to a possible emergency situation, (as a moron was about to pull out) and ALAS!!!! She pulled me forward like a sports bike. I then learnt a big lesson gentleman! You want the bike to do what it was made to do, but always have that "power blast" on tap. This is when I realised the "Docile" boxer motor, was a peach. No V-Twin can give you that smooth "Rolls Royce" feeling when cruising. Yes it will have loads of torque & power, but at a sacrifice to sophistication. Although, they are getting better and better in todays fantastic motorcycle industry. So if you want a touring/cruising/off road bike, you cannot beat the GS. If you want that thrill of the motor, then buy a V-Twin-torque blaster like a Monster R, or the Super Duke. And if you can only afford just one bike... then you've got your work cut out for you. But much easier these days with all the technology on tap. Yes its each to their own on selection of bike. But try your best to think of the style of riding you will be wanting to do. The decision might be much easier than you think. And on that note, the GS doesn't need more power. It just needs to be lighter, which in return, will make it faster. Cheers Mr Flyer.....keep groovin' like you have been ;-)
Wayne B, I guess you are right Wayne, but my point was that the GS has been tweaked every year by BMW. eg: the quickshifter/blipper was retro fitted to Mr Flyer's bike as it didnt come out until later on. Also gearbox & suspension settings have changed dramatically as well. My mate has the 2014 GS, and another buddy has the 2017. When you ride both, the 17 just feels that much more refined than the 14, in all aspects, much smoother. So it would only be fair if the exact same years were put up against each other, as the BMW is a far better bike in 2017 than 2014. Still though, all in all, it was nice to see the comparison through Mr Flyer's eyes. The input from others always gives you a bit more to look out for when testing yourself. But picking between the two is a real shame as both are such sweet bikes. Cheers groover ;-)
Just tried the Super A for size at Motorcycle Live - Found it a lot taller than my standard chassis low seat GS. I could only just brush the floor with tip toes. I'm also 5'8" but have shorter 29" legs.
Have you tried the more sensible 1090 engine? Another factor for me is dealer support, BMW supply spares next day and the coffee is, usually, free. I have never seen a KTM dealer not based in farm buildings, except in Bayreuth where I was visiting last week....
mine is tucked away on an industrial estate , they also sell mowers and chain saws, i did like the ktm engine but the finish of the bike was like the dealer left a bit to be desired,
Great review. I have tried the BWM GS Adventure but for my height and the want to be off road sometimes meant that I went with KTM 1290 Adventure R purely based on the quality of the bikes and the type of riding like to do. Even if not off road sometimes, cisyt wise i would still go with the KTM. not sure the BMWs are worth the price difference.
i would like to ask about why you didnt talk about telelever and paralever (bmw certified and copyrighted suspension technology) and the other most important thing is boxer engine which has less consumption and alive with low revolution(torque). and all of these two units we must add the center of the gravity of these two motorcycles which is lower with bmw. best regards ;)
you actually mentioned boxer engine but i couldnt hear about telelever-paralever and center of gravity. but look at the bright side; there is a new topic for a new video for you man ;)
Great comparison. I think the GS with the TFT option is pretty unbeatable and as a bike offers more all round use. It makes a great commuter as well brilliant for touring however commuting on the KTM...hmmm not convinced.
Both fantastic bikes, but I got the KTM simply because of the motor. 170hp and a bucket load of torque. Much like a sports bike that doubles as an adventure tourer or vice versa.
The 1200 GS was and is a great motorcycle but I love the KTM. Does just about everything a little better - even though it is not really about that in the end. It needed a better windscreen (I have the Givi) and the powerparts (softer) seat. I have had it for 17k km now and I would not trade back ;-)
You'd buy a GSA, unless you bought ......an RT. I watched your 5 things I hate about the GS, and reckoned every issue would be solved by the RT. Maybe another comparison ....I've just got my RT after 37yrs and find it a very easy machine to handle, keeps the weather off too,many people nod at me ;-)
Have tried both, and agree both brilliant. The KTM wins with things I don't really need, like better engine and gearbox and great looks, but the BMW wins on things I do need, like comfort, low speed handling, luggage space and easy to push around in the garage and into the back entrance to the hotel-ness. Still don't like the new models enough to spend all that money on a new model though. (That KTM gearbox is very smooth, but will it last as long, and anyone who has taken a GS clutch apart will tell you there's nothing to match it). All right I give in. If you gave me anything else, I'd still buy a GS.
The GS gearbox is junk! maybe better on 2018 models, but on my 2016, it came straight out of a 1950 Deutz tractor. Even old Guzzi's are better. And don't have me talking about the absurd drive-line lash of my bike after 20.000 kms of just stupid commuting
Great review. One thing I have to criticise; kTm has "Favourites" you can "customise" for quick access to your favourite settings. So I can't let you away with that the BMW has the more user friendly controls. 😂 However. If done a similar comparison for myself and for me there is only one winner. Don't get me wrong. The other is a fantastic bike but after riding it all day I can only say "Yes, I rode a motorcycle today" while after getting on an after the second turn I have a massive grin on my face with the winning bike and getting off at night I can only say "that was awesome!". So for me the kTm is the winner and always will be. Even with the looks, as the Beamer looks like the built in flush buttons on my toilet. Which raises for me the question if it was there where the Germans got their inspiration for the design of the BMW? 😂 But I agree. Those two bikes are so damn close, for somone new to adventure bikes, it will be a decision made by the gut. So here I am looking forward to the banter and slagging matches between me and my kTm riding friends and the Beamer riding friends in years to come. 😂😂😂
Coming from a ZX1400 I think the KTM would appeal to me more (more power= more better) but I have a 32 inch inseam just like you so I'm still in a quandary, off to a test drive for both I suppose
I had a 2014 KTM Adventure R, I loved that gearbox and engine but it was just too tall for me to live with and I spent most of my time on the blacktop, I now have a 2017 R1200GS Rallye, fantastic bike, amazing suspension, super comfortable goes really well and like he says that wiz wheel for the electronics is brilliant, the engine is clunky and noisy as is the gearbox and I find the bike has no "fizz". I am considering going to the KTM Adventure S and getting the seat rebuilt to make it more comfortable because I really miss that V-twin engine and gearbox package, it just grunts out of corners, no shortage of fizz!
I got fed up with the press saying how good they were - Too tall for me and an old man's bike.....I then got overtaken by one on a trackday at Cadwell Park so took one out for a test ride to see what the fuss was about and was shocked how it well it handled, the grunt out of corners and that I could reach the ground. I've now had mine for nearly 3 years.
This must be a UK thing. I don't see too many BMWs at all. When I do, my first thought is that that guy probably knows more about bikes than the average bear. In the US it's all Harleys all the time. When I see them, I have the opposite thought. I still wave to them all. Something we can do here where we drive on the correct side of the road ;)
Correct side of the road? Hmmm, let me see. If i was in Europe/USA, and stopped on the right hand side of the road and placed my bike stand down, the bike would be leaning into the lane. Then, I would get off the bike (on the left hand side) and step into the lane of on coming vehicles. Hmmm, but hang on a second !!! If I were in the UK/AUS, I would stop on the left hand side of the road. I would put my stand down, and the bike would lean away from the traffic in the lane, and I would get off the bike (left hand side) and I would be on the curb/footpath safely out of the way. WOW!!! That's amazing!!! ;-) Keep on groovin' on.....
For touring I’d choose the GS adventure bigger tank, drive shaft (no chain lubing). Currently have the KTM 1290 Adventure R as I do more off road riding here in South Africa.
Great comparison. I've got an older GSA (2010) and a new 1290 Super Advanture S, so while I can't make the exact same comparison, I do have reasonable experience of both. I'm not a fan of the quick shifter on the KTM and from what you say I will ask the dealer to check mine! The one thing you leave out entirely is the heat on the KTM. I get loads of heat off the rear cylinder once the whole bike is warm. And I don't mean while sitting in traffic, I mean when running down the motorway, doing normal motorway speeds!! The dealer has tried a few things to improve it but for me its a real problem. By the way, the KTM dealer is good and is definitely not based in an old farm building, plus offers free tea!!
One category you missed that I am looking for is second hand on these two. Which one lasts the test of time. For 10 odd grand now you seem to get more for your money with KTM but do they last as well as BMW? Reliability could be part of this new category too.
thanks pard! i went with the {bmw} because of comfort, drivetrain, ending easy for me to work on ( valve adjust,maintnence) down fall $$$$ dealership shop price etc......both great machines....
I believe the comparison between the GS (not the GSA!) is much more relevant,, when comparing it to its Austrian rival. Personnally sold my 2016 GS to buy the 1190 adventure, which I love much, much more. But i'm not 35 yet...I'm just as happy about my (older) KTM panniers as I was from my Vario panniers (which are excruciatingly expensive). engine on my KTM is much more fun, "accelerates like a rocket" indeed, makes a much nicer noise (certainly with Wings exhaust), has a little less torque low down but more than makes up for it. The only thing where the GS has the KTM, is suspension polyvalence (and much less dive on braking) and yes, the road handling is fantastic and the engine has way sufficient power and low end grunt. I'd also say my long legs (i'm 1.90m) were also a bit better on the GS. Weather protection: get a Vario screen on the KTM and it's much better than the standard GS (which as standard, does get better protection indeed). I'm sick and tired of people buyin' GS's just because of credentials and BMW badge. However, when I tested the new 1290 Superadv S, it had the well known fork clunking (fork cartridge faulty?), which I hated. But my story goes to show you can have shitty GS's and very nice KTM's. He's right about the user-friendlyness of the switchgear, however, my GS switches got sticky after cleaning a few times, which I don't have on my 1190. Fact is, I have been disappointed by the GS. If I was to do it again (well actually, no I just love my 1190 and really don't wanna get rid of it, for once), I'd seriously look at the 1290 or even the 1090 (which I rode and was also great fun, but no match for an 1190). Absurd thing is that, when I got it as a replacement vehicle during maintenance of my LC GS, I just loved the LC RT (noice, performance, comfort)
I´m moving from a suzuki Bking to a GS. Specifically because I want comfort and cruising pleasure and not the insane power of the BKING. Don´t get me wrong, riding the GS felt a bit dull and tractorlike compared to my beast, but that´s what I am looking for. The wind protection, lack of any vibes at any speed and relaxed riding position, is what I want these days.
Another one of your excellent comparison reviews. My only nitpick would be that you're comparing a modern 2018 transmission on the KTM vs the 4 year old transmission on your GS. I'm not talking about the maintenance of the transmission, it's just that I've read quite a bit that BMW has updated lots of the mechanicals of GS for 2017 and 2018. Maybe you've adjusted for that. One more thing. Girls in the USA love BMW bikes, partially because they think you're rich. Maybe the GS and RT are considered to be "old man's bikes," but I haven't experienced that. Of course, I'm old.
Rich=old. In belgium the GS has just the same "cocks drive GS's image (see old top gear for audi's)" image. The GS gearbox was shite and actually unacceptable for this kind of price range. You realize that once you've owned an 1190/1290 adventure KTM
-In comfort the BMW is better; -The Windshield, i think is very subjective; -The seat on the KTM has 2 positions! But yes, it's higher (but lighter than the GS and the GSA); -The KTM has more equipment (standard, no extras); -The shaft doesn't need the maintenance as the chain, but is heavier and if has problems, is much more expensive; -Regarding the fun factor, i think that the KTM is not probably the winner; it's undoubtedly the winner; -The panniers, i don't know because never used any of the original, but it's also subjective due to the options we have on the market; -The TFT from the BMW (Bosch, as the one equipped on the KTM), i think it's better; they waited one more year to "develop" better the system; -The KTM will have navigation too; -The TFT comes standard with the KTM but on the BMW is an extra... -KTM has offroad mode standard; BOTH are great bikes! It's a matter of taste, and money of course. The important is Thanks
Both great bikes. For me the GS wins because it has a shaft drive and the KTM loses because it is chain drive. Chains are a pain...too much PT, mess and fuss (esp when removing the rear wheel...getting greasy and having to retension the chain again). It is a deal-breaker for me.
At my GS's last service (20k km) they remove the rubber boot at the joint to check for corrosion because there is ANOTHER flaw in the new GS and water leaks in there and causes corrosion. So maybe the drive shaft is not as attractive anymore...
My finger was hovering over the unsubscribe button but fortunately the Beemer didn't get trashed. Okay only kidding, if I could afford it I'd have both in my garage. Unfortunately, rego in Australia is more expensive than a gambling addiction, not to mention the service cost on my GS. Well executed comparison, thanks.
Fuel efficiency? And you didn't mention the KTM has illuminated switchgear for night riding which is a big big plus imho. The whizz wheel on the BMW is a much better system for controlling the modes, etc. Servicing? A lack of seat height adjustment on the KTM is a serious oversight making it best suited to taller riders. If BMW upped the power output of the GS to near the KTM and introduced illuminated switchgear then it would be unbeatable. Otherwise it is just lagging behind. They will have to at some point. Why delay?
Having owned and ridden both KTM and BMW i can honestly say the BMW is far more comfortable, found my buttocks went numb with 30 minutes of riding my KTM, made it impossible for long rides, might just be me.
Did you try a PP Ergo seat? Massively better, they should fit them as standard. At least they are not too pricey and also have a heated option which is fabulous. :)
When doing a trip for five days in Austria and riding at least 400km's a day this Autumn, I noticed my butt got used to the treatment and adapted to the 1190's relatively harsh standard seat. But yeah, the GS' triple black's seat is unquestionably more comfortable. And by the way, no need for a heated seat. All KTM V-twins come as standard with heated (in summer = baked) arse/thigh option :D
A Kali everyone on forums is complaining about the harsh KTM seats. After a while though you get used to it. It's not a goldwing for sure but it's decent. Our butts need to get used to some harshness
The GS wins for me, it's so iconic. I'm biased simply because I'm on the lookout for a used one as I write this! I'm sure the KTM is fabulous, but I just can't get past the looks.
Hi Andy can you tell I'm looking at buying the r1200gs with all the comments on your older videos 🤣 I know you haven't got access to all the bikes but I know you have ridden the XR,, so do you think the KTM is more suited to pitching against that now you have tried them all? I've tried a GS and I really like the relaxed leg position now my knees are shot, but how do they all compare in leg position? I'm the same height as you but a bit more Roly poly 🤣
This could lead to an endless discussion! For me the BMW wins, if only because I am no longer wanting to do daft things on a bike. Comfort and useability for me. Boring!
Agreed...long touring and ease of use make it a nice bike to ride on long trips...I rather look at the scenery then fus with cleaning the chain, getting fuel all the time, and changing the suspension all the time..My GSA has me spoiled and even if the KTM is more exciting..I like a smooth uneventful ride with the cruise control on when I cover long miles. Much like you...Boring!
Great video got to the crux of a topic many bikers want to know, many of us aspire to one or the other, must be great to have both in the garage 👍 fyi in general manouverability is key for me cos of limited space, i have to get in and out of my back gate, you are one of the only vloggers who cover this, for instance the new BMWR18 wouldnt fit in my bike store, beautiful bike but only for those with a large drive/garage. Those of us living in more economy properties appreciate your manouverability comments 👍
Cloggsy Goodwin The sheer fear displayed by the KTM representatives that they’re bikes would be put through that level of punishment was very revealing at the time.
Great video and i agree with your summary. Have you tried the KTM 1090 Adv R, i would be interested in your thoughts. I am sure Jason will loan you one and a ladder !!
Although, I completely agree with all the points you give to the KTM, I feel that some of them are irrelevant advantages for someone on the market for these big adventure bikes. For example, the nuclear engine the KTM has. Is that really that important for someone who wants a "one bike to do it all", or someone who prioritises touring? The way I see it, the GS wins points where it matters most. For me it's the winner. But with the KTM being an equally excellent bike.
TheMissendenFlyer Yes of course. I didn't mean to say that I disagree with your verdict or your process of comparing the two. Just taking the discussion further
As a GS owner who will likely get a 1290R for his next bike (that doubles as my car) the deciding factor for me is the motor. I love the GS motor, but there is something exceptional about the motor in the 1290 that I can't seem to shake.
Hi. Interesting comparison. Thanks for that. Don't forget that the 17 GS has a much improved gearbox, as good as anything I've ever used, plus the auto suspension which is fantastic. Still a very close call though. Guess we're lucky to have two superb bikes to choose from.
Resale value,seat height and shaft driven ,plus sat nav feature do it for me BMW then , plus older I guess ktm younger man wheels , but love them both for there great presences
For me, there are several compelling features that have influenced my decision to purchase BMW's over the years: 1: 3-year unlimited mileage warranty with 24/7 Roadside-Assist (bear in mind I am reporting from Canada), 2: Alarm/immobilizer/key-less ride (not sure if KTM is key-less yet?) 3: Resale value - BMW's seem to hold a higher resale value. And then there is the chain issue......! Thanks for another great review - you continue to describe and report well the real-World experience which generally differs from professional journalists. Keep up the good work.
I question the value of BMW shaft drive advantage, my 2015 had to rebuild the final drive at 15,000 miles because BMW claimed stored on the side stand damaged the bearings cost $1,500 to overhaul, total rubbish bearings, not side stand issue, new final drives are a whopping $3,000 US and not rebuildable. I like the lower maintenance value of the shaft drive over messy chain drive, but at $3,000 plus labor, I'll take KTM chain drive any day. BMW Legendary durability is a total myth, I've owned 3 BMW R1200 GSA Hex head and 1 Water boxer. On the other hand KTM really needs to get its act together regarding comfort, seats are horrible, we laugh saying the reason KTM has such great suspension because it's too painful to sit down, you have to stand after the first hour. The new KTM 790 sets a whole new standard in brick hard seats, with zero attempt to fake comfort.
It's quite easy to get your seat to any level of padding you want. Not more than a 100-150 Euros in my country. I second the final drive/shaft drive issue. I had the same issue on a 2006 (bought from new) BMW GSA 1200 at just 22000 kms (bearings again). Moreover, the same bike managed to get a valve through a piston at 20.000kms and sput it out from the exhaust! (last month within guaranty - thankfully covered by BMW). Neddless to say that after the shaft drive issue that came second I traded her for a brand new 2009 KTM 990 adventure with R suspension. Great bike that last one! P.S. I also owned a regular BMW 2005 GS1200 that had terrible (dangerous) ABS and needed oil (from new) like a Greek salad. More than 500ml every 1000kms! That's the bike I traded for the GSA. I didn't pamper that GSA in break-in period and it didn't burn any oil at all. I think it was running lean though with the Akra exhaust - hence the catastrophic disintegration.
We nod because we ride on the other side of the road, and to wave we would have to take our right hand off the throttle. Nothing to do with being "snooty".lol.
I think when the pavement ends your choice would be more clear. I have owned both and when I took the GSA off road I truly felt like a fish out of water with no confidence. Now to be clear it was the GSA not the GS. I also find that all KTM's have a fun factor that the BMW's I have owned did not have. Both bikes are great but an adventure bike is a purpose built machine so a true all around comparison would be great to see. Wait till you give that 1290 a true off road test, it is actually remarkable of how well a 500lb bike does.....I think Chris Birch vids say it all. Great review as always.
the "GS rider is not a REAL rider" thing is nonsense... I'll be at the NEC show from London no doubt in the freezing rain..when a lot of the "REAL riders" will have tucked up their sports/naked/retro bikes for the winter and will have their bike covers glued to their bikes!
TheMissendenFlyer certainly a better way to ensure fonder memories of motorcycles... All said I see you are warming up to the more scaffold orientated GSA. I would like to get a Gsa myself with the vario cases and would value your opinion on such a pick and mix ))
This was the most awesome very detailed comparison between these two incredible motorcycles. At age 71, I lean more towards comfort. I rode a very comfortable Harley Davidson Fatboy for several years and I guess that spoiled me. Twenty years ago it would have been KTM all the way. In Maui, Hawaii, I owned a Honda Superhawk with the 996 motor and I couldn't throttle it out on the island as much as I tried...136 on Haleakala Highway's 7 mile straight stretch was the best I could get. For me, the BMW would be my choice. At 5'7" on a KTM I don't think my heels would ever touch the ground at stops unless I lean the bike heavily to one side.
The qualifiers “edges out” and “by far” matter in this review; the nuisances sure add up! What I’d also like to know is cost of ownership. I gave up Beemers a few years ago because of the cost of ownership - wondering if it was just my experience or an across the board reality. Also, spent half of my 50 years riding shaft bikes, the other half were chain drive. In my opinion, contemporary chains/sprockets (add a tooth, drop a tooth) are the way to go . . . “by far.” Thanks for another great review.
Great vid, I own both bikes as well. I made the mistake of watching Long Way Round too many times, fellin love with the concept then test driving a BMW GSA . Purchased a new one the following week, within a few months it felt slow and the speed shifting didnt work. Then I test drove the KTM 1290 SAR and man WOW, this thing is a beast. I prefer much more than the GSA , I am keeping both because I have too much money into the GSA to loose and I have the room. For all those out there, definitely test drive a 1290 before buying a GS!
will M Weird comment. I'm 40 and I think the BMW R nine T range are beautiful. And it's not a badge stigma, they are genuinely good bikes. See TMFs reviews
Great review as always! I rented a 2008 GS in australia that had about 150000km on it (and a rental so it had been dropped in all ways possible). It felt like a new bike, engine, brakes everything performed like new I was surprised considering how beat up it looked! My only grip is that it could lose 50lbs...otherwise super comfortable and pleasant to ride.
Tough choice. Definitely like the looks/headlight of the BMW more than this particular KTM. I'd probably go with the KTM though, it's a bit different than your usual GS and the taller seat height is a plus for me. Anyway, not for at least another 20 year will I be looking for a big adventure bike.
Hi TMF. I think your comparison is valid. The old KTM adventure T was the GSA equivalent. But moving on you made two ommisions. No mention of fuel consumption and on to tank range/gauge accuracy. Lastly doesn't anyone else ride in the dark? What's the head light like on dip, full beam etc. Otherwise a very slick beautifully edited video. You are easy to listen to unlike Capitan Ram.....
I find it rather amusing when people say the GS is an old mans bike. That’s probably because we’ve had all the other bikes and now realise that the GS does everything well. It tours two up, is great for commuting, can go off road, and in the hands of a good rider will stay with all but the fastest sports bike- on the twisty roads. However, having owned 8 of them, I will say that the reliability should be better for the price. The switch gear fails and the and Alloy corrodes badly of not treated very carefully (acf 50) & cleaned with the right cleaner. For £15k-£20k these bikes should be better. Period.
Both bikes are excellent. BMW is like German Volksmusik, the KTM is Rock and Roll. I buy the KTM last year. I am 1/4 Welsh and 3/4German by the way :-)
Thanks for the reviews ,personally the fun factor has always been the biggest reason for my bike choice so the Ktm wins for me .If you ever get the chance try a buell uylsees you would really be surprised can and did easily all of what those 2 machines can do even off road . To some a bit agricultural ,others it's charioteer .
Surprised you said running costs are the same when in your previous review of the KTM you found the insurance very expensive for a mature rider like yourself. Also what is the price difference for the panniers?
Having owned two BMW GS's in the past (just out of warranty) and voted them both in my top 5 best bikes of all time for overall riding, sadly the build quality, electrical issues, reliability and BMW customer care (non-existent) prevents me from buying another. I took the KTM 1290S and both the 950 and 1200 Multistradas out last year and did some serious miles around Wales in both wet and dry conditions and all three bikes I found to be awesome machines and without doubt the best performance and handling in this class so a justifiable 9/10, for me however the bikes having a chain drive instead of shaft, plus a high price (if you want all the extras) and too much plastic let them all down, so this year when if I decide to trade in my Explorer 1200 I am seriously considering .....another Explorer 1200, mine is 5 years old now, and still looks and rides and handles like new. Please note this is just my opinion which I am still entitled to. Please BMW owners do not get upset with my experience of GS's both the bikes were low mileage used machines and were just over 2 years old when I bought them, Not new bikes.
Thank you for this I’ve been in between on a decision on these two bikes I live in Temecula Southern California we have many areas to ride on and off road I think I’m gonna go with the KTM because the engine will give me what I want out it. I plan to rent one first there places I can rent here in SoCal thanks mate!
An aspect that doesn't seem to get pointed out very often in reviews is the amount of heat that gets directed toward the rider. I have ridden both bikes and can say that on a warm summer day with the KTM, it's like hugging a log burner.
Nope - I've had it booked in three times and told the parts aren't yet available, then the dealer said they'd call me when they were....still waiting.....(since August).....
TheMissendenFlyer Wow! I had to wait a while for the parts to come in also but not for that long. Hope you get it handled soon. All the best to you sir.
I filmed this before riding the 2018 GSA - the 2018 GSA is currently the best adventure bike on the market in my opinion (but it's close and is only my opinion....)
I think I may be of assistance. I had been pondering for a while your comments regarding the GS screen’s shortcomings as I own one and find it the best screen I’ve ever had. I recently fitted the Touratech handguard extenders, and then found my head being rattled around in the wind, I too come from an aircraft background (RAF) so looked at the shape from an airflow perspective. It looks like the original handguards are shaped to direct the flow away from the rider’s head, where the extensions fill the outflow gap and direct it at your head. I notice you have them fitted too, and wonder if that’s where your issue is derived? Cheers Gordon Blackley
Yes interesting - could well be although I don't have an issue on my GS now I have that MRA Vario Screen fitted (the aerofoil at the top smooths out any turbulent flow a treat...)..
Your killing me Mr Flyer...I will be buying a adventure bike in the spring and was hoping there would be a overwhelming winner...Appreciate your honesty...Keep it up.
i do not have an adventure bike yet (important that i state this) i had heard from several sources online that ktm is doing much of its manufacturing in china i would not support that so for me i would go with the german bruiser even though motor is down on the fun factor
Hei TMF, thank you for the detailed review and comparison I am checking the seat height and at least the ktm 2019 model mentions a ajustable seat 860 mm or 875 mm, was not availeble in the year your reviewd? How tall is the seat of your GS?
enjoyed the comparison, how does the fuel consumption compare, i use my GS everyday and it is frugal, also when shelling out a big lump of cash what will it be worth in the future? does the Gs have a better residual? me thinks it does but i am biased
I was in the market, took both bikes out for an extensive ride, that KTM engine! Anyway, when all was said and done, I walked out of a KTM Dealership with the KTM 1290 Super Adventure with factory panniers for $16499, the equally equipped BMW GSA with panniers was $26,000 and my local BMW would not budge off that price. My decision was easy!
tacjam1 damn, that's a lot of money for about the same experience, i would take it in consideration as well.
strange, they are exactly expensive here in EU. No price advantange for KTM whatsoever. Must be some tax or intentional price dumping involved.
I had a very similar experience. Ktm for me, and I'm glad for it. The motor is just so so good. One of, if not the very best motors in motorcycling. 1290 SA
Going to my KTM dealer this week, this is going to be the deciding factor for me as well, who can I get the best deal from on end of season 2018's... BMW or KTM?
Great review MSDF but yes what tacjam 1 said. BMW is nearly $10,000 more than the KTM . Which leaves alot of spending money for upgrades and Trip expenses.
Great video but you missed 2 important points... range / mpg
and price...
Absolutely incredible review!!! I was literally in between these two bikes as I am doing research for a long tour...not quite sure where yet. Thank you for the information and I can't wait to check out the rest of your channel!
Good stuff! Welcome along.....
The KTM would be like the gal you want to party and have fun all night long, the BMW would be the gal you want to settle down with. Another really nice and interesting review sir! Cheers!
Nice comparison and I totally agree - except I'd be with the Super Duke R on party night.....
Well--I guess I'll follow my usual program and date the party girl until we fall out.lol
Actually if you like off-roading a bit the KTM will make you feel a lot like a Dakar racer (see: suspension) vs an SUV driver that can get there (but not always). P.S. I owned both bikes (or variants).
You should enter the items to add points, the reliability, guarantee and prices of the services by the brand
Hi,
I’m getting very interested in motorcycling quite late in life. I would like to complement you on the way you present your articles. I’ll keep watching thank you.
when i see pannier reviews, no one ever asks to me the most important question..will it hold a full face helmet?
Well done. I would choose the same. Bmw does it for me with regards to comfort/power. I use it almost daily. I look forward to every ride!!
Excellent detailed comparison. However, I wish bike reviewers would begin to address the largest concern for every rider in the UK - security! Can you fit a big chain through the frame or swing arm? What does the bike come with stock to prevent theft? These adventure bikes are HUGE targets for theives.
MUNRO MUSIC I have just bought the new GS Rallye version. It came with alarm, immobilizer and yes, you can get a BIG chain through the frame at various positions.
Trackers should be fitted as standard on these bikes.
You have a good point Munro. Perhaps TMF should consider having that as a point in reviews.
A very good question
@munro. Have look at the Pragmasis site for their anti-pinch pin. This goes through the hollow swing arm on bikes like the bmw, with a 19mm chain either side to ground anchor (or other immovable object if parking up when out and about ) and squire lock. You can also option an alarm with the bmw.
First class motorcycle journalism as per usual. Thank you. Your opinion is highly valued.
Thank you Keith.....
TheMissendenFlyer . . The pleasure is entirely mine.
Mr Flyer, great review as always. But in all fairness, your GS (as good as it is) is a 2014 model. That's not fair. The new GS: the gearbox is much better, the shifter/blipper is much better, & the TFT is probably the best screen in the world at the moment. The fact that it doesn't have issues with glare or sun like others. Also, the KTM would be more suited up against the GSA.
The big thing that gets me with all riders that say the KTM has more power, & the BMW should get more, is ridiculous. Think about it gentleman. You don't want a motor that eggs you on to blast it when your selecting a touring/cruising bike. For example like the Super Duke, Ducati Monster, & all super-sport bikes. Im a '16 S1000RR rider, and unless your in the 6k, 7k, or 8k zone and up, your not enjoying the bike. This is what their made for, to blast like a bat out of hell. Sport bikes are boring when cruising. So with my "Sports-bike/power on tap" mentality, I was disappointed when I jumped on the GS for a test ride. The "Docile" style motor, the boxer, was not up to it (like the KTM riders say)......Until the penny dropped!!!!
I realised the motor wasn't egging me on to blast it all the time. Hence the ride was much more sophisticated, smooth and enjoyable. Then I opened it up, due to a possible emergency situation, (as a moron was about to pull out) and ALAS!!!! She pulled me forward like a sports bike. I then learnt a big lesson gentleman! You want the bike to do what it was made to do, but always have that "power blast" on tap. This is when I realised the "Docile" boxer motor, was a peach. No V-Twin can give you that smooth "Rolls Royce" feeling when cruising. Yes it will have loads of torque & power, but at a sacrifice to sophistication. Although, they are getting better and better in todays fantastic motorcycle industry. So if you want a touring/cruising/off road bike, you cannot beat the GS. If you want that thrill of the motor, then buy a V-Twin-torque blaster like a Monster R, or the Super Duke. And if you can only afford just one bike... then you've got your work cut out for you. But much easier these days with all the technology on tap. Yes its each to their own on selection of bike. But try your best to think of the style of riding you will be wanting to do. The decision might be much easier than you think. And on that note, the GS doesn't need more power. It just needs to be lighter, which in return, will make it faster. Cheers Mr Flyer.....keep groovin' like you have been ;-)
Thanks for watching and for stopping buy! All the best - TMF
the groove... thats like a blind date sum up!!!
The Groover A
This KTM is the street version (alloy wheels) so is the right bike to go up against the GS. The R version is the bike to put against the GSA.
Wayne B, I guess you are right Wayne, but my point was that the GS has been tweaked every year by BMW. eg: the quickshifter/blipper was retro fitted to Mr Flyer's bike as it didnt come out until later on. Also gearbox & suspension settings have changed dramatically as well. My mate has the 2014 GS, and another buddy has the 2017. When you ride both, the 17 just feels that much more refined than the 14, in all aspects, much smoother. So it would only be fair if the exact same years were put up against each other, as the BMW is a far better bike in 2017 than 2014. Still though, all in all, it was nice to see the comparison through Mr Flyer's eyes. The input from others always gives you a bit more to look out for when testing yourself. But picking between the two is a real shame as both are such sweet bikes. Cheers groover ;-)
Just tried the Super A for size at Motorcycle Live - Found it a lot taller than my standard chassis low seat GS. I could only just brush the floor with tip toes. I'm also 5'8" but have shorter 29" legs.
32 might be the outside seam.
Have you tried the more sensible 1090 engine?
Another factor for me is dealer support, BMW supply spares next day and the coffee is, usually, free. I have never seen a KTM dealer not based in farm buildings, except in Bayreuth where I was visiting last week....
Mine is based in modern offices with free coffee ... they are also a Honda dealer/distributor, maybe that has something to do with it? ;)
My local KTM dealer (the KTM Centre in Hemel) is a pretty impressive place - certainly not farm buildings!
mine is tucked away on an industrial estate , they also sell mowers and chain saws, i did like the ktm engine but the finish of the bike was like the dealer left a bit to be desired,
My local KTM dealer is on an industrial estate in Loughborough. Take your sunglasses through, It's the most orange place you've ever seen!
Great review. I have tried the BWM GS Adventure but for my height and the want to be off road sometimes meant that I went with KTM 1290 Adventure R purely based on the quality of the bikes and the type of riding like to do. Even if not off road sometimes, cisyt wise i would still go with the KTM. not sure the BMWs are worth the price difference.
i would like to ask about why you didnt talk about telelever and paralever (bmw certified and copyrighted suspension technology) and the other most important thing is boxer engine which has less consumption and alive with low revolution(torque). and all of these two units we must add the center of the gravity of these two motorcycles which is lower with bmw. best regards ;)
Err, I forgot??
TheMissendenFlyer ops. Did I miss that part? :/
No, I genuinely forgot....
you actually mentioned boxer engine but i couldnt hear about telelever-paralever and center of gravity. but look at the bright side; there is a new topic for a new video for you man ;)
Dostum senin eline su dökemezler zaten :D Canavarları araziye bile sokmamış. Hani ADVENTURE? :D
Great comparison. I think the GS with the TFT option is pretty unbeatable and as a bike offers more all round use. It makes a great commuter as well brilliant for touring however commuting on the KTM...hmmm not convinced.
Both fantastic bikes, but I got the KTM simply because of the motor. 170hp and a bucket load of torque. Much like a sports bike that doubles as an adventure tourer or vice versa.
Thank you for your great review. I made the switch from a 2016 BMW R 1200 GS to the KTM 1290 super adventure s in January 2018.
...and what do you make of it?
The 1200 GS was and is a great motorcycle but I love the KTM. Does just about everything a little better - even though it is not really about that in the end. It needed a better windscreen (I have the Givi) and the powerparts (softer) seat. I have had it for 17k km now and I would not trade back ;-)
You'd buy a GSA, unless you bought ......an RT. I watched your 5 things I hate about the GS, and reckoned every issue would be solved by the RT. Maybe another comparison ....I've just got my RT after 37yrs and find it a very easy machine to handle, keeps the weather off too,many people nod at me ;-)
Have tried both, and agree both brilliant. The KTM wins with things I don't really need, like better engine and gearbox and great looks, but the BMW wins on things I do need, like comfort, low speed handling, luggage space and easy to push around in the garage and into the back entrance to the hotel-ness. Still don't like the new models enough to spend all that money on a new model though. (That KTM gearbox is very smooth, but will it last as long, and anyone who has taken a GS clutch apart will tell you there's nothing to match it). All right I give in. If you gave me anything else, I'd still buy a GS.
Glad we agree!
The GS gearbox is junk! maybe better on 2018 models, but on my 2016, it came straight out of a 1950 Deutz tractor. Even old Guzzi's are better. And don't have me talking about the absurd drive-line lash of my bike after 20.000 kms of just stupid commuting
Great review. One thing I have to criticise; kTm has "Favourites" you can "customise" for quick access to your favourite settings. So I can't let you away with that the BMW has the more user friendly controls. 😂
However. If done a similar comparison for myself and for me there is only one winner. Don't get me wrong. The other is a fantastic bike but after riding it all day I can only say "Yes, I rode a motorcycle today" while after getting on an after the second turn I have a massive grin on my face with the winning bike and getting off at night I can only say "that was awesome!". So for me the kTm is the winner and always will be.
Even with the looks, as the Beamer looks like the built in flush buttons on my toilet. Which raises for me the question if it was there where the Germans got their inspiration for the design of the BMW? 😂
But I agree. Those two bikes are so damn close, for somone new to adventure bikes, it will be a decision made by the gut. So here I am looking forward to the banter and slagging matches between me and my kTm riding friends and the Beamer riding friends in years to come. 😂😂😂
Cheers for the clarification Marc - all the best - TMF
Coming from a ZX1400 I think the KTM would appeal to me more (more power= more better) but I have a 32 inch inseam just like you so I'm still in a quandary, off to a test drive for both I suppose
Thank you! Going to BMW dealer to get GS 2018!
proslava
Lucky bugger!!
get it bought, I have 2018 rallye, its superb 4 th gs since 2004 its like a Rolls Royce Ferrari.
I had a 2014 KTM Adventure R, I loved that gearbox and engine but it was just too tall for me to live with and I spent most of my time on the blacktop, I now have a 2017 R1200GS Rallye, fantastic bike, amazing suspension, super comfortable goes really well and like he says that wiz wheel for the electronics is brilliant, the engine is clunky and noisy as is the gearbox and I find the bike has no "fizz". I am considering going to the KTM Adventure S and getting the seat rebuilt to make it more comfortable because I really miss that V-twin engine and gearbox package, it just grunts out of corners, no shortage of fizz!
If they think a gs is boring obviously they haven't ridden one and see what it can do.
I got fed up with the press saying how good they were - Too tall for me and an old man's bike.....I then got overtaken by one on a trackday at Cadwell Park so took one out for a test ride to see what the fuss was about and was shocked how it well it handled, the grunt out of corners and that I could reach the ground. I've now had mine for nearly 3 years.
This must be a UK thing. I don't see too many BMWs at all. When I do, my first thought is that that guy probably knows more about bikes than the average bear. In the US it's all Harleys all the time. When I see them, I have the opposite thought. I still wave to them all. Something we can do here where we drive on the correct side of the road ;)
Correct side of the road? Hmmm, let me see. If i was in Europe/USA, and stopped on the right hand side of the road and placed my bike stand down, the bike would be leaning into the lane. Then, I would get off the bike (on the left hand side) and step into the lane of on coming vehicles. Hmmm, but hang on a second !!! If I were in the UK/AUS, I would stop on the left hand side of the road. I would put my stand down, and the bike would lean away from the traffic in the lane, and I would get off the bike (left hand side) and I would be on the curb/footpath safely out of the way. WOW!!! That's amazing!!! ;-) Keep on groovin' on.....
In the US, there's always a McDonalds to stop and pee within two miles. They have spacious parking lots ;)
LOL!!! Well said. I must admit, I thought Australia had one every few miles, until I went to the US! Cheers groover :-)
For touring I’d choose the GS adventure bigger tank, drive shaft (no chain lubing). Currently have the KTM 1290 Adventure R as I do more off road riding here in South Africa.
Great comparison. I've got an older GSA (2010) and a new 1290 Super Advanture S, so while I can't make the exact same comparison, I do have reasonable experience of both. I'm not a fan of the quick shifter on the KTM and from what you say I will ask the dealer to check mine! The one thing you leave out entirely is the heat on the KTM. I get loads of heat off the rear cylinder once the whole bike is warm. And I don't mean while sitting in traffic, I mean when running down the motorway, doing normal motorway speeds!! The dealer has tried a few things to improve it but for me its a real problem. By the way, the KTM dealer is good and is definitely not based in an old farm building, plus offers free tea!!
...interesting, a few people have mentioned the heat, I had no issue at all on the bike I borrowed (mind you I'm used to riding a Panigale!)....
Great video! Planning a 2024 update for these 2?
Thank you, now I made my choice...KTM for sure
One category you missed that I am looking for is second hand on these two. Which one lasts the test of time. For 10 odd grand now you seem to get more for your money with KTM but do they last as well as BMW? Reliability could be part of this new category too.
Have to say the KTM would had found the way to my garage...but in the 1090 form..
What do you have on your garage floor?
Great video
Err, flooring?
TheMissendenFlyer
Yes the black thing😁
It's from Costco....
thanks pard! i went with the {bmw} because of comfort, drivetrain, ending easy for me to work on ( valve adjust,maintnence) down fall $$$$ dealership shop price etc......both great machines....
I believe the comparison between the GS (not the GSA!) is much more relevant,, when comparing it to its Austrian rival. Personnally sold my 2016 GS to buy the 1190 adventure, which I love much, much more. But i'm not 35 yet...I'm just as happy about my (older) KTM panniers as I was from my Vario panniers (which are excruciatingly expensive). engine on my KTM is much more fun, "accelerates like a rocket" indeed, makes a much nicer noise (certainly with Wings exhaust), has a little less torque low down but more than makes up for it. The only thing where the GS has the KTM, is suspension polyvalence (and much less dive on braking) and yes, the road handling is fantastic and the engine has way sufficient power and low end grunt. I'd also say my long legs (i'm 1.90m) were also a bit better on the GS. Weather protection: get a Vario screen on the KTM and it's much better than the standard GS (which as standard, does get better protection indeed). I'm sick and tired of people buyin' GS's just because of credentials and BMW badge. However, when I tested the new 1290 Superadv S, it had the well known fork clunking (fork cartridge faulty?), which I hated. But my story goes to show you can have shitty GS's and very nice KTM's. He's right about the user-friendlyness of the switchgear, however, my GS switches got sticky after cleaning a few times, which I don't have on my 1190. Fact is, I have been disappointed by the GS. If I was to do it again (well actually, no I just love my 1190 and really don't wanna get rid of it, for once), I'd seriously look at the 1290 or even the 1090 (which I rode and was also great fun, but no match for an 1190). Absurd thing is that, when I got it as a replacement vehicle during maintenance of my LC GS, I just loved the LC RT (noice, performance, comfort)
...I'm going to have to look that up....
I´m moving from a suzuki Bking to a GS. Specifically because I want comfort and cruising pleasure and not the insane power of the BKING. Don´t get me wrong, riding the GS felt a bit dull and tractorlike compared to my beast, but that´s what I am looking for. The wind protection, lack of any vibes at any speed and relaxed riding position, is what I want these days.
Another one of your excellent comparison reviews. My only nitpick would be that you're comparing a modern 2018 transmission on the KTM vs the 4 year old transmission on your GS. I'm not talking about the maintenance of the transmission, it's just that I've read quite a bit that BMW has updated lots of the mechanicals of GS for 2017 and 2018. Maybe you've adjusted for that.
One more thing. Girls in the USA love BMW bikes, partially because they think you're rich. Maybe the GS and RT are considered to be "old man's bikes," but I haven't experienced that. Of course, I'm old.
Rich=old. In belgium the GS has just the same "cocks drive GS's image (see old top gear for audi's)" image. The GS gearbox was shite and actually unacceptable for this kind of price range. You realize that once you've owned an 1190/1290 adventure KTM
-In comfort the BMW is better;
-The Windshield, i think is very subjective;
-The seat on the KTM has 2 positions! But yes, it's higher (but lighter than the GS and the GSA);
-The KTM has more equipment (standard, no extras);
-The shaft doesn't need the maintenance as the chain, but is heavier and if has problems, is much more expensive;
-Regarding the fun factor, i think that the KTM is not probably the winner; it's undoubtedly the winner;
-The panniers, i don't know because never used any of the original, but it's also subjective due to the options we have on the market;
-The TFT from the BMW (Bosch, as the one equipped on the KTM), i think it's better; they waited one more year to "develop" better the system;
-The KTM will have navigation too;
-The TFT comes standard with the KTM but on the BMW is an extra...
-KTM has offroad mode standard;
BOTH are great bikes! It's a matter of taste, and money of course. The important is
Thanks
Both great bikes. For me the GS wins because it has a shaft drive and the KTM loses because it is chain drive. Chains are a pain...too much PT, mess and fuss (esp when removing the rear wheel...getting greasy and having to retension the chain again). It is a deal-breaker for me.
Thanks for watching and for stopping buy! All the best - TMF
At my GS's last service (20k km) they remove the rubber boot at the joint to check for corrosion because there is ANOTHER flaw in the new GS and water leaks in there and causes corrosion. So maybe the drive shaft is not as attractive anymore...
That was worth hitting the 'like button' for the 'Mini-me' impression thumbnail alone.
My finger was hovering over the unsubscribe button but fortunately the Beemer didn't get trashed. Okay only kidding, if I could afford it I'd have both in my garage. Unfortunately, rego in Australia is more expensive than a gambling addiction, not to mention the service cost on my GS. Well executed comparison, thanks.
Thanks for watching and for stopping buy! All the best - TMF
Fuel efficiency? And you didn't mention the KTM has illuminated switchgear for night riding which is a big big plus imho. The whizz wheel on the BMW is a much better system for controlling the modes, etc.
Servicing?
A lack of seat height adjustment on the KTM is a serious oversight making it best suited to taller riders.
If BMW upped the power output of the GS to near the KTM and introduced illuminated switchgear then it would be unbeatable. Otherwise it is just lagging behind. They will have to at some point. Why delay?
Having owned and ridden both KTM and BMW i can honestly say the BMW is far more comfortable, found my buttocks went numb with 30 minutes of riding my KTM, made it impossible for long rides, might just be me.
Did you try a PP Ergo seat? Massively better, they should fit them as standard. At least they are not too pricey and also have a heated option which is fabulous. :)
When doing a trip for five days in Austria and riding at least 400km's a day this Autumn, I noticed my butt got used to the treatment and adapted to the 1190's relatively harsh standard seat. But yeah, the GS' triple black's seat is unquestionably more comfortable. And by the way, no need for a heated seat. All KTM V-twins come as standard with heated (in summer = baked) arse/thigh option :D
My gs seat is horrible after a few hundred miles, upgraded and it is a bit better. All bikes need a seat upgrade or shoudl I say most.
A Kali everyone on forums is complaining about the harsh KTM seats. After a while though you get used to it. It's not a goldwing for sure but it's decent. Our butts need to get used to some harshness
Compare your bike seat to your bicycle's and you'll know what I mean
Did you Take Mrs fly on the back I’d be interested to know what the KTM is like from a pillion
The GS wins for me, it's so iconic. I'm biased simply because I'm on the lookout for a used one as I write this! I'm sure the KTM is fabulous, but I just can't get past the looks.
There is something very special about how that boxer engine looks.
Yep, that headlight looks too much like an insect..
Hi Andy can you tell I'm looking at buying the r1200gs with all the comments on your older videos 🤣
I know you haven't got access to all the bikes but I know you have ridden the XR,, so do you think the KTM is more suited to pitching against that now you have tried them all? I've tried a GS and I really like the relaxed leg position now my knees are shot, but how do they all compare in leg position? I'm the same height as you but a bit more Roly poly 🤣
This could lead to an endless discussion! For me the BMW wins, if only because I am no longer wanting to do daft things on a bike. Comfort and useability for me. Boring!
Agreed...long touring and ease of use make it a nice bike to ride on long trips...I rather look at the scenery then fus with cleaning the chain, getting fuel all the time, and changing the suspension all the time..My GSA has me spoiled and even if the KTM is more exciting..I like a smooth uneventful ride with the cruise control on when I cover long miles. Much like you...Boring!
Great video got to the crux of a topic many bikers want to know, many of us aspire to one or the other, must be great to have both in the garage 👍 fyi in general manouverability is key for me cos of limited space, i have to get in and out of my back gate, you are one of the only vloggers who cover this, for instance the new BMWR18 wouldnt fit in my bike store, beautiful bike but only for those with a large drive/garage. Those of us living in more economy properties appreciate your manouverability comments 👍
Nice to hear that - thank you…
Remember when KTM pulled their support for the Long Way Round, and BMW stepped into the breach?...
Ian Fitzharris that was a master stroke for bmw
That was 13 years ago!
Marek Kwietniewski 😮 Time flies eh? 😖
Cloggsy Goodwin The sheer fear displayed by the KTM representatives that they’re bikes would be put through that level of punishment was very revealing at the time.
Tins on Tour Couldn’t buy that publicity!
Great video and i agree with your summary. Have you tried the KTM 1090 Adv R, i would be interested in your thoughts. I am sure Jason will loan you one and a ladder !!
I have reviewed the 1090 but I can't recall without looking if it was the R - great machine though....
In 12 out of 10 cases i'll take juicy orange juice over soy latte from starcucks ;
You may not be a motoring journalist but this is one of the best comparison reviews on yt.
Thank you very much - appreciate the kind words....
Although, I completely agree with all the points you give to the KTM, I feel that some of them are irrelevant advantages for someone on the market for these big adventure bikes. For example, the nuclear engine the KTM has. Is that really that important for someone who wants a "one bike to do it all", or someone who prioritises touring? The way I see it, the GS wins points where it matters most. For me it's the winner. But with the KTM being an equally excellent bike.
Fair do's - I did say I thought the BMW was better overall.....
TheMissendenFlyer Yes of course. I didn't mean to say that I disagree with your verdict or your process of comparing the two. Just taking the discussion further
As a GS owner who will likely get a 1290R for his next bike (that doubles as my car) the deciding factor for me is the motor. I love the GS motor, but there is something exceptional about the motor in the 1290 that I can't seem to shake.
Great video. Would be fantastic if you could do a comparison between the new 1250GS and KTM...
Ktm every day
An twice on a Sunday
Hi. Interesting comparison. Thanks for that. Don't forget that the 17 GS has a much improved gearbox, as good as anything I've ever used, plus the auto suspension which is fantastic. Still a very close call though. Guess we're lucky to have two superb bikes to choose from.
Not another improved gearbox, they've been doing that for the last 30 years! How bad were they?
Trevor Ford . A bit clunky and noisy plus finding neutral was a bit of an up and down affair. All sorted now..
I'll definitely settle for the KTM 1290 SUPER ADVENTURE R
Resale value,seat height and shaft driven ,plus sat nav feature do it for me BMW then , plus older I guess ktm younger man wheels , but love them both for there great presences
I dont even need to watch the video to no the answer to the question. Obviously the best is......the Triumph Tiger 800 XC hands down.
For me, there are several compelling features that have influenced my decision to purchase BMW's over the years: 1: 3-year unlimited mileage warranty with 24/7 Roadside-Assist (bear in mind I am reporting from Canada), 2: Alarm/immobilizer/key-less ride (not sure if KTM is key-less yet?) 3: Resale value - BMW's seem to hold a higher resale value. And then there is the chain issue......! Thanks for another great review - you continue to describe and report well the real-World experience which generally differs from professional journalists. Keep up the good work.
Thank you Chris - and yes the KTM does have keyless - that's what make s the insurance premiums so high!
I question the value of BMW shaft drive advantage, my 2015 had to rebuild the final drive at 15,000 miles because BMW claimed stored on the side stand damaged the bearings cost $1,500 to overhaul, total rubbish bearings, not side stand issue, new final drives are a whopping $3,000 US and not rebuildable. I like the lower maintenance value of the shaft drive over messy chain drive, but at $3,000 plus labor, I'll take KTM chain drive any day. BMW Legendary durability is a total myth, I've owned 3 BMW R1200 GSA Hex head and 1 Water boxer. On the other hand KTM really needs to get its act together regarding comfort, seats are horrible, we laugh saying the reason KTM has such great suspension because it's too painful to sit down, you have to stand after the first hour. The new KTM 790 sets a whole new standard in brick hard seats, with zero attempt to fake comfort.
It's quite easy to get your seat to any level of padding you want. Not more than a 100-150 Euros in my country. I second the final drive/shaft drive issue. I had the same issue on a 2006 (bought from new) BMW GSA 1200 at just 22000 kms (bearings again). Moreover, the same bike managed to get a valve through a piston at 20.000kms and sput it out from the exhaust! (last month within guaranty - thankfully covered by BMW). Neddless to say that after the shaft drive issue that came second I traded her for a brand new 2009 KTM 990 adventure with R suspension. Great bike that last one! P.S. I also owned a regular BMW 2005 GS1200 that had terrible (dangerous) ABS and needed oil (from new) like a Greek salad. More than 500ml every 1000kms! That's the bike I traded for the GSA. I didn't pamper that GSA in break-in period and it didn't burn any oil at all. I think it was running lean though with the Akra exhaust - hence the catastrophic disintegration.
Well done. How might they compare on Reliability?
Dunno - would have to run each for a few years to know that - I know my BMW has been trouble free for the last nearly 4 years...
Oh, and another thing, I'll nod at you! This seems to be a British snooty trait, in "Europe " all bikers appear to acknowledge...
Nick Laskaris I live in Holland and we wave at everyone. Here, it seems as if it's only Harley riders who think they're better than the rest of us.
We nod because we ride on the other side of the road, and to wave we would have to take our right hand off the throttle. Nothing to do with being "snooty".lol.
We snooty BMW riders normally have cruise control !
honestbob45 remind me why you keep using wrong side of the road? ;)
Can't riders wave with a left hand? Everyone in the 70's and 80's waved. Nobody nodded. When did that creep in, I can't remember?
The BMW XR is going to be my next bike, wonder If the nods will dry up?.
No, you'll be OK on that....
I am a ktm fan boi 😎
I think when the pavement ends your choice would be more clear. I have owned both and when I took the GSA off road I truly felt like a fish out of water with no confidence. Now to be clear it was the GSA not the GS. I also find that all KTM's have a fun factor that the BMW's I have owned did not have. Both bikes are great but an adventure bike is a purpose built machine so a true all around comparison would be great to see. Wait till you give that 1290 a true off road test, it is actually remarkable of how well a 500lb bike does.....I think Chris Birch vids say it all. Great review as always.
the "GS rider is not a REAL rider" thing is nonsense... I'll be at the NEC show from London no doubt in the freezing rain..when a lot of the "REAL riders" will have tucked up their sports/naked/retro bikes for the winter and will have their bike covers glued to their bikes!
hehe, I was there today - I drove there in a warm Mercedes E class ;0)
TheMissendenFlyer certainly a better way to ensure fonder memories of motorcycles... All said I see you are warming up to the more scaffold orientated GSA. I would like to get a Gsa myself with the vario cases and would value your opinion on such a pick and mix ))
Hahahaha the fair weather rider is the clever rider
The only response for sad haters
This was the most awesome very detailed comparison between these two incredible motorcycles. At age 71, I lean more towards comfort. I rode a very comfortable Harley Davidson Fatboy for several years and I guess that spoiled me. Twenty years ago it would have been KTM all the way. In Maui, Hawaii, I owned a Honda Superhawk with the 996 motor and I couldn't throttle it out on the island as much as I tried...136 on Haleakala Highway's 7 mile straight stretch was the best I could get. For me, the BMW would be my choice. At 5'7" on a KTM I don't think my heels would ever touch the ground at stops unless I lean the bike heavily to one side.
Thanks for watching and for stopping by Alex....
One comment: while you will always be able to see old GSs models on the road, the KTMs seem to disappear...they vanish! KTMs do not stand time.
They last better than Ducati's anyway ... the newer ones seem to have a very good build quality.
because there are so mant gs in first place ! due to long way round!
I have the answer for you: leasing loan by BMW. That is why you see more GS than any other brands on the roads/streets.
KTM's are very unreliable.....best be a mechanic and carry tools if you ride them.....
I disagree, I see plenty of old 950s and 990s on the road, in fact I see more of them than BMW 1100s or 1150s.
The qualifiers “edges out” and “by far” matter in this review; the nuisances sure add up! What I’d also like to know is cost of ownership. I gave up Beemers a few years ago because of the cost of ownership - wondering if it was just my experience or an across the board reality. Also, spent half of my 50 years riding shaft bikes, the other half were chain drive. In my opinion, contemporary chains/sprockets (add a tooth, drop a tooth) are the way to go . . . “by far.” Thanks for another great review.
Cheers Walter - check out my stand alone reviews for details on cost of ownership....
They are so big, bike in that size remind me of a big horse. Why cant they make adventure bikes that are small and light...
Try a CCM GP450 ,its a light adventure bike
Great vid, I own both bikes as well. I made the mistake of watching Long Way Round too many times, fellin love with the concept then test driving a BMW GSA . Purchased a new one the following week, within a few months it felt slow and the speed shifting didnt work. Then I test drove the KTM 1290 SAR and man WOW, this thing is a beast. I prefer much more than the GSA , I am keeping both because I have too much money into the GSA to loose and I have the room. For all those out there, definitely test drive a 1290 before buying a GS!
Thanks for the feedback!
i was riding bmw but when i seat on ktm i never again go back to bmw ktm is beast of a motorcycle
I am interested in buying these two bikes and really valued your review. I agree with all of your positions, and incredible it's a draw!
BMW: riders 35+ years old.
KTM: riders between 17 and 35 years old.
Same here, Will. I'm 42.
I can't see too many 17-35 year old's affording either.
I'm 51 have ridden the BMW but the KTM is more fun.
will M
Weird comment. I'm 40 and I think the BMW R nine T range are beautiful. And it's not a badge stigma, they are genuinely good bikes. See TMFs reviews
Gregory, NineT is not an adv bike. C'monnnnn!!!!
Great comparison, new GS gearbox is far better than the older one. Only point would be which holds its money better?
Yes good question - I suspect the BMW but I don't actually know...
Great review as always! I rented a 2008 GS in australia that had about 150000km on it (and a rental so it had been dropped in all ways possible). It felt like a new bike, engine, brakes everything performed like new I was surprised considering how beat up it looked! My only grip is that it could lose 50lbs...otherwise super comfortable and pleasant to ride.
Tough choice. Definitely like the looks/headlight of the BMW more than this particular KTM. I'd probably go with the KTM though, it's a bit different than your usual GS and the taller seat height is a plus for me.
Anyway, not for at least another 20 year will I be looking for a big adventure bike.
This was a super review, just more interesting details and points. Where other reviews is like they just read the brochure for comments.... Good Job
Thank you!
Hi TMF. I think your comparison is valid. The old KTM adventure T was the GSA equivalent. But moving on you made two ommisions. No mention of fuel consumption and on to tank range/gauge accuracy. Lastly doesn't anyone else ride in the dark? What's the head light like on dip, full beam etc.
Otherwise a very slick beautifully edited video. You are easy to listen to unlike Capitan Ram.....
Thank you Rog - good points and thanks for the kind words...all the best - TMF
I find it rather amusing when people say the GS is an old mans bike. That’s probably because we’ve had all the other bikes and now realise that the GS does everything well. It tours two up, is great for commuting, can go off road, and in the hands of a good rider will stay with all but the fastest sports bike- on the twisty roads. However, having owned 8 of them, I will say that the reliability should be better for the price. The switch gear fails and the and Alloy corrodes badly of not treated very carefully (acf 50) & cleaned with the right cleaner. For £15k-£20k these bikes should be better. Period.
Yes I agree on all fronts - great bikes but not 100% perfect...
Both bikes are excellent. BMW is like German Volksmusik, the KTM is Rock and Roll.
I buy the KTM last year. I am 1/4 Welsh and 3/4German by the way :-)
Thanks for the reviews ,personally the fun factor has always been the biggest reason for my bike choice so the Ktm wins for me .If you ever get the chance try a buell uylsees you would really be surprised can and did easily all of what those 2 machines can do even off road . To some a bit agricultural ,others it's charioteer .
Lovely comparison. Love your work, mate.
Thank you!
Surprised you said running costs are the same when in your previous review of the KTM you found the insurance very expensive for a mature rider like yourself. Also what is the price difference for the panniers?
Well costs are largely the same - but agree the insurance is super salty on the KTM according to my quote. Dunno about the cost of panniers....
Insurance for a brand new 1290 adventure S is $54 USD a month for me with full coverage...
You're a lucky boy to have access to such bikes. Nice comparison.
Having owned two BMW GS's in the past (just out of warranty) and voted them both in my top 5 best bikes of all time for overall riding, sadly the build quality, electrical issues, reliability and BMW customer care (non-existent) prevents me from buying another.
I took the KTM 1290S and both the 950 and 1200 Multistradas out last year and did some serious miles around Wales in both wet and dry conditions and all three bikes I found to be awesome machines and without doubt the best performance and handling in this class so a justifiable 9/10, for me however the bikes having a chain drive instead of shaft, plus a high price (if you want all the extras) and too much plastic let them all down, so this year when if I decide to trade in my Explorer 1200 I am seriously considering .....another Explorer 1200, mine is 5 years old now, and still looks and rides and handles like new. Please note this is just my opinion which I am still entitled to.
Please BMW owners do not get upset with my experience of GS's both the bikes were low mileage used machines and were just over 2 years old when I bought them, Not new bikes.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts Tee...
Thank you for this I’ve been in between on a decision on these two bikes I live in Temecula Southern California we have many areas to ride on and off road I think I’m gonna go with the KTM because the engine will give me what I want out it. I plan to rent one first there places I can rent here in SoCal thanks mate!
I'd love to buy a KTM but the dealer network has passed Northamptonshire by, that also has a big input into my buying habits!
Hi, I had a GS which I loved but with the luggage I always suffered with gusty winds, especially side winds. What’s your experience? Thanks
Yes can act as a bit of a sail....
An aspect that doesn't seem to get pointed out very often in reviews is the amount of heat that gets directed toward the rider. I have ridden both bikes and can say that on a warm summer day with the KTM, it's like hugging a log burner.
KTM are on a great run these last 3 years definitely becoming a big contender BMW for market best in each type of bike.
Thanks for the comment and I completely agree! All the best - TMF
Mr Flyer, have you taken care of the latest recall items on your GS yet? As in, fork bushings and reflectors for your Vario cases.
Nope - I've had it booked in three times and told the parts aren't yet available, then the dealer said they'd call me when they were....still waiting.....(since August).....
TheMissendenFlyer Wow! I had to wait a while for the parts to come in also but not for that long. Hope you get it handled soon. All the best to you sir.
Excellent as always but since your ride on the gsa 2018 rallye would you have same thoughts with your comments in that review best bike ever ridden ?
I filmed this before riding the 2018 GSA - the 2018 GSA is currently the best adventure bike on the market in my opinion (but it's close and is only my opinion....)
I think I may be of assistance. I had been pondering for a while your comments regarding the GS screen’s shortcomings as I own one and find it the best screen I’ve ever had.
I recently fitted the Touratech handguard extenders, and then found my head being rattled around in the wind, I too come from an aircraft background (RAF) so looked at the shape from an airflow perspective. It looks like the original handguards are shaped to direct the flow away from the rider’s head, where the extensions fill the outflow gap and direct it at your head.
I notice you have them fitted too, and wonder if that’s where your issue is derived?
Cheers
Gordon Blackley
Yes interesting - could well be although I don't have an issue on my GS now I have that MRA Vario Screen fitted (the aerofoil at the top smooths out any turbulent flow a treat...)..
Have you done any reviews on the Yamaha Super Ten?
Yes I have....
Your killing me Mr Flyer...I will be buying a adventure bike in the spring and was hoping there would be a overwhelming winner...Appreciate your honesty...Keep it up.
Well I'd take the BMW, but it is close and only my personal opinion.....you'd be very happy with either bike. Enjoy!
$27,000 US plus $500 a yr. to insure for a GSA...Not sure I can justify that amount...lol :/
i do not have an adventure bike yet (important that i state this) i had heard from several sources online that ktm is doing much of its manufacturing in china i would not support that so for me i would go with the german bruiser even though motor is down on the fun factor
nope - these bikes are made in Austria.
Great review !! I have both 2008 GS Adventure and a 2016 1290 Adventure. Both great bikes and your spot on when you said you buy with your heart.
Glad we concur
Yes, I'd go with your preferences. Did I miss fuel consumption. As a guess.....the BM,
+Ronald White Mmm good point...
Hei TMF, thank you for the detailed review and comparison
I am checking the seat height and at least the ktm 2019 model mentions a ajustable seat 860 mm or 875 mm, was not availeble in the year your reviewd?
How tall is the seat of your GS?
Dunno - I have the low seat so a little less....
enjoyed the comparison, how does the fuel consumption compare, i use my GS everyday and it is frugal, also when shelling out a big lump of cash what will it be worth in the future? does the Gs have a better residual? me thinks it does but i am biased