It won't be beneficial because if I talk about northern part of western mumbai if will see too much crowd to cover this much crowd they will require more than 200 machines at single station and also they will have to make seperate way to put those machines .Here surrounding space is not much to let everyone to go .
Sir metro is also used by middle class people, and they have no issue with using the automated ticket checking system. So, I don't think their would be an issue. The largest issue is the opposition from the Railway union, which needs to be ignored. The IR needs to go ahead with the process of automation.
Right, we can't stop the progress of our country just because someone's "upari kamayi" will get disturbed. We should move toward massive automation and privatisation. Similar people were pressuring the govt during the era when Computers were getting introduced. Change is part of life and everyone must be ready for it.
Metro Maximum Ticket Price is 60 RS and currently run in TIER-1 and 2 cities only while Railway average price is 800-1000 and run in whole india . Literacy and Finance of those area where metro run is average much better than compare to Railway covered area.
@sahilbhardwaz4852 A similar issue was raised for UPI. It is a completely failed reason. The same will happen in the case of railways. UPI has been implemented with complete success in India. So, why can't IR implement digital systems successfully.
Every Weekend I come to home from Delhi by Mewar Express-12963. Local Passengers (general or no ticket) from ballabhgarh highjack the full train till Kosi Kalan. Reserved Passengers are forced to give up their seats. And railway official are nowhere seen.
We need to build full transport eco system with strict rules and regulations. Building high class train only won't help india to be superpower we need both technological as well cultural changes for reaching pencal .🙃
My India in 1835Read Carefully "I have travelled across the length and breadth of India and I have not seen one person who is a beggar, who is a thief such wealth I have seen in this country, such high moral values, people of such caliber, that I do not think we would ever conquer this country, unless we break the very backbone of this nation, which is her spiritual and cultural heritage and therefore, I propose that we replace her old and ancient education system, her culture, for if the Indians think that all that is foreign and English is good and greater than their own, they will lose their self esteem, their native culture and they will become what we want them, a truly dominated nation." Lord Macaulay's Address to the British Parliament on 2nd Feb. 1835 *We must at present do our best to form a class who may be interpreters between us and the millions whom we govern; a class of persons, Indian in blood and colour, but English in taste, in opinions, in morals, and in intellect. To that class we may leave it to refine the vernacular dialects of the country, to enrich those dialects with terms of science borrowed from the Western nomenclature, and to render them by degrees fit vehicles for conveying knowledge to the great mass of the population. - macaulay *Commenting on the objective of colonial education in Africa, Nelson Mandela remarked thus36: The educated Englishman was our model; what we aspired to be were 'black Englishmen'. We were taught and believed- that the best ideas were English ideas, the best government was English government, and the best men were Englishmen.
People sleeping on platform floors and obstructing passenger commute is the thing which isn't seen in any developed nation. Even our tier 1 city railway stations have this issue so imagine the first impressions of our country from a tourist's PoV
There is no problem with people sleeping on platform many people even sleep on airports You only need to create designated place like waiting area form them to sleep
@@adarARYANSINGHRANA Bro let me tell you the whole story On airport there are so much chair to sit but on station there re not enough chairs and this is due to 2 reason corrupted system and people don't hesitate to sit on floor on station but have you ever seen someone putting there sleepers and sitting on them on ground No that is why it is too obvious to sit on ground and sleep to as on airport people will sleep on chair rather on the floor and also the train is late mostly so people have no other option and people also don't prefer waiting room I have seen empty waiting rooms and people sitting outside in summer
This has been in my mind for a long time.. i wish to see this change in Indian railways. It's definitely doable. We should first barricade the entire area of major stations.. second, train doors should be opened/closed at respective stations only so that even in case of chain pulling, no unauthorised person can entry/exit from a train. We need more and more vande Bharat trains to help this entire system. It may take years but in return, Indian railways well be very profitable.
True even I've experienced once such scenario when I was travelling in 1st AC class and at Patna station some random guys entered in First AC. They had no tickets; they gave money to tc and that's it. I booked ticket for Rs.6000 and they got seated for some 100rs. And one of those was saying I work at railways so what I paid Rs.6000 for tickets and they are asking me to give space to seat pathetic. Ticket checking machine is must atleast at platform for those who are travelling if not at entrance so those who came to drop their friend, relative at station can come.
This can be done in at least Delhi where the 4 major railway stations , new Delhi , old Delhi, Nizamuddin , and anand vihar are all well connected by metro. Delhi metro has really made a difference in the culture of this city. However the railway itself needs to be developed and expanded . The freight corridor will help in separating the freight trains , so passenger capacity can increase. Big cities also need dedicated suburban train lines instead of the hotchpotch we get, where daily commuters often hijack long distance trains. Delhi suburban train system is desperate for an upgrade because the network is there, coverage is there , but the the trains aren't run with enough frequency , there's even a local train station close to Delhi Airport
It's a crime to assume lower middle class people can't use the simplest automated systems if they are implemented in all Railway stations. Such myths are excuses for corruption to continue and unions to arm-twist. Public demand for better experiences will shut these unions down soon. Fortunately, Modi ji and his team are great visionaries & nationalists, to make Bharat a global Super Power. 🙏
It might be offensive😂 to some, but it is ABSOLUTELY NOT a crime. Also no, those stereotypes are not why corruption exists, it would exist without it. If you improve the infra, the unions and corrupt tts will automatically wont have the opportunity to cheat and take graft. Also, don't underestimate the unions, I expect the infra, the people and the culture to change before the corrupt unions to change.
If the ticket checking machine are executed it shouldn't take the jobs of TC's. This can be achieved by doing the following things 1. Excess no of TC's can be shifted to other work like collecting fine from people who spit on the station (this can generate huge revenue as their are crores of Ajay Devgn fans in India, bolo jubaan kesari 😂😂) 2. It will also saves litres of water and cost required for cleaning
I always had this question from my childhood why does Indian railway not have ticket checking system at the entrance of the station itself mainly for Mumbai locals because Japan like countries do have. Thanks. ❤
After the freight corridor , indian railway must focus on increasing suburban railway between cities. This will really be helpful for people . Dedicated suburban train lines connecting small towns with big cities. They can be run like metro where the particular platform is for the local train only. That will surely fix a lot of things for Indian railway
In Foreign Countries, the entry into Railway Platform is restricted only to travellers with valid travel tickets like what we have in Metro Stations. The stalls, restaurants etc. are available only in the concourse areas only and not on platforms. Hence the concourse areas are heavily crowded and railway platforms are less crowded. Most of the long distance trains have restaurant cars and hence there is no need to have stalls on railway platforms. This system also reduces ticketless travel on trains. We are still in the Colonial Era and lack the will to come out of our past.
Defining Arrival and Exit points are not required, just install the scanner at all the points. First scan can be entry and second scan is exit, simple.
At least someone spoken on this topics. This is very big issue that railway should improve. People must change their mindset that you can't go unnecessarily to railway or create Chaos. There should be restrictions, rules , discipline, a system with well defined planning. Yes it will take time but somewhere we have to start this. People will understand the things. And In few years people become habitual of this just like UPI. So I support this . 🙏 Jai Hind 🇮🇳
If tickets are checked as in Metro, people will revolt for compulsory seat allocation or availability and making the train be on time, will be the biggest issue.
True, train tickets are booked well in advance. Let's say there is a family emergency in my village and I have to get there by end of the week, what would I do if I do not find tickets. In the existing state, I will slip into the general coach and face hardship but somehow reach my destination on time. At some point, people need to have a chance to slide.
I regularly travel by long distance train. I seriously feel IR should implement this automated ticekting gate. This will significantly reduce the load on the station, it will be easy to manage, eventually service experience will improve.
The Indian government is re-developing 500 something railway stations which will help in implementing these kinds of machines in tickets checking... It will take some time tho
Glad To See It Became The Point Of Discussion. Its The Need Of The Hour, Very Important To Be Implemented In Railways Of Bharat. Please Share This Informative Video To "Railway Ministry".
It is not that difficult of a task. Instead of revamping the whole stations, we can make these tickets only accessible doors in the coaches themselves. Only valid tickets will ensure entry in the coaches.
The stoppage at some stations is pretty less and it can cause issues as many people deboard the train at stations to buy food or water and people deboard at stations too so it will be a huge bottleneck if they are made at coaches.
We have to do every state and station on make this this system which entering station metro ticket checking machine need 😊😊 these system allready in China and many other countries and it makes also give profit for railways and they give good service and trains
Problem is Express, Superfast, Local etc have different rates and came in the same platform. How to check If one take general ticket and board Superfast or Rajdhani trains?
This is where TC can stay relevant. Make sure everyone has a ticket inside the train, allot seats to people with RAC tickets, etc. Basically, they'll stay employed even after the introduction of these machines. Increased revenue for railways, no protests from Railway union either.
@@satyammalik6770 Then, Railway needs more manpower. Currently, vacancies are so high that one employee has to do the duty of 2-3 employees. This is the cause of so many frequent accidents. Need manpower, need recruitment.
@@manikck7229 While true, that's a separate issue altogether. Railways won't need to recruit additional TC to keep track of who's travelling in which class with which ticket, which was your original question.
It is achievable and we should do the following things considering good for all the people 1. Make big walls at the end of platforms and walls on side of first and last platforms at all railway stations in country and recruit rpf to do patrolling at both ends of all the platforms 24X7 so that no person enters through the tracks. 2. Make designated entry doors like airports and exit doors where RPF/TC checks the ticket as well as the ID as this will ensure that there is no opposition of the unions. 3. To address the issue of general tickets they shouldn't be sold above a limit ie there are 180 seats in a general coach so max tickets sold per coach shouldn't be more than 200 considering few people can stand or adjust and the sale of tickets should happen outside the railway station not inside. 4. There should be TCs inside every class of the train to ensure that no one travels in the wrong class
Great info. But i feel all of the developmental activities will take place only after the completion of dedicated freight corridor because without an efficient transport system imposing restrictions is not a wise decision. Once dedicated freight corridor gets operational we can see efficiency of trains increasing and there by having a chance of implementing the above stated developmental works.
Pahla bat to ye hai ki train me itne log Bina ticket k ghum Raha hai wo agar Kam ho jaye toh hi ye solve ho payega ...nd no of trains should increase ...nahito kabhi bhi possible nahi hoga aisa system sustain karne k liye ...90 seat me 150 log travel karega toh kaise rokoge Khali ek proper entry bana k... Metro jaise every 5-10-15 minutes pe ata hai waise agar local trains chalega toh maybe it vl become practical in coming years ...Bihar me toh patri chori ho jata hai ...it's just not easy ...but junction ya terminal station pe platform me blockade lagwaya ja sakta hai as a pilot project ...nd also there are places without proper platform...train platform se bahar nikla rehta hai ..infra sudharna padega ...maybe then ...aise bhi bohot bar train ruka rehta hai outside station ...too many reforms needed to implement it practically
Bro, 1. Local trains and express trains ke platforms ko segregate karna padega. 2. Express trains ke platform ke liye tucket mandatory karna padega. 3. Waiting khatam karni padegi. 4. Reservation system ko bhot hi jyada overhaul karna padega. Filhall ye 4 hi main mudde hai...inse Quality of Service mein behad improvement nazar ayega. Aur ye logo ke confidence ko boost karega.
But my question is If we only implement ticket checking system at the entrance how will that be effective actual coaches like if someone has borrowed ticket of sleeper class they can enter ac coaches if we do not have manual ticket checkkers.. so this is a big issue why Indian railways cannot implement automated system for ticket checking at the entrance.. infact in metro we have that entrance ticket checking system because metro has only 1 type of coach for all ticket holders and passengers
Sir only railway is not only for passengers, but think about the parcels, there are so many people working in third party workers, need to issue a proper id card for them to scan and loading and unloading should be done at some other location not the platform, then every station there will be two Stops one for passengers and other for parcel If it was done it will be gud let's hope it will implement in coming years Jaihind
As a TTE. , it's a good idea , metros are in some cities like majorly developed one , and railway have many station like a small one to , it's connected all over India and in mumbai , manu station have unauthorized authorities entry so how many they should apply gates and checking machine , and local crowd in mumbai is peak , whenever a train leaves it leaves high bunch of crowd and people are like animals jump over 😂😂
The major issue is crowd. Many person reach on station just at time or the big lines to scan ticket is very time taking for a passenger and it may lead to departure of the train before we reach in.
If tickets are checked properly then it will be much more convinet for the passengers and also generate more revenue then now. People without tickets pack AC 3 tier, SL and general we people who have tickets suffer as we get compact in hot and tight space.
My brother had to travel urgently from Mumbai to Surat due to hospitality emergency. He travelled without ticket. He reached Surat easily without ticket. No one came to check the ticket.
Please make a special video on touts and scammers in major tourist places. Those scumbags are not tarnishing Image of India but also discouraging the tourists to come to India. Strict actions like sedition/UAPA should be taken against them for decreasing the foreign revenue from tourism.
To an extent, travelling without ticket and giving TC some money to get an un-assigned/missing passenger seat is necessary. There are so many instances I know where it has saved people's lives/hleped in some very needing times. But if the TC forcefully adds extra passenger on the same seat then that's an issue.
Even if we get automated ticket checking at the entry, how will we ensure the passenger is only taking the train they paid for and not a more expensive train? How will we we make sure people don't move from general compartment to sleeper or AC compartment if there is no manual checking inside the train?
Station ticket ko aasani se koi bhi le sake any upi app se ya kisi bhi finteck app se with bar code Aisa krna chiye Sathh hi station ticket ke liye alag se dedicated counter hona chiye entry exit gate pr Or plateform ticket ko aniwarya kr dena chahiye
I think there is a simple solution Automate the Entry-Exit, but keep the TC for in-train checking, to ensure people aren't "voluntarily" upgrading themselves to higher class. This will not take away any work from the TCs, but will make the travel process easy. But the only issue I see with Railways is the Coolie issue, if we prevent free entry-exit. They're charging grossly high prices these days, like ~1000 Rupees, or more for just 1-2 bags. Usually all the relatives come to assist in the baggage handling lol. So platform ticket should be very readily available through QR, like in Hyderabad/Delhi Metro tickets. Or..... Make railway stations accessible, with multiple lifts, escalators, travellators, and better platform surfaces which won't break the suitcase wheels, if we're dragging.
Acc to my opinion This work should be done by phases Like in 1st Phase all TIER-1 city stations should implement Automate TC system Then Tier-2 After some year then 3 and finally Rural . Cause just like you told Discipline , Literacy and Finance are the biggest obstacles then Its ultimate solution and Parallel at the same time too Cause in Tier-1 Cities Peoples Literacy , Discipline and Finance are average better than others ,, and same apply 2 ,,, 3 ,,, RURAL. What about that idea ??
#Askpt or video topic Can we fill the creeks around mumbai with sand , so that mumbai wil be attached with mainland completely. Then all the problem of space will resolved as horizontal expansion can be done
Not just Platforms but the train doors should also have QR scanners and should only allow people who have a QR on the ticket to open the door. The trains can have a local computer which would have the database of all the valid travelers and railways employees who are authorized to travel.
After 26/11 it should have been implemented. Just imagine if airport type of or even a lesser security system would have been there then the outcome at CST nightmare would be different for so many life's
1.keep railway stations of Tier 1, Tier2, Tier3 cities outside the city and run an MMTS service within the city which solves the problem of travelling more people. 2. remove the sleeper trains which travels in morning and replace with Seating trains and trains should not travel more than 12hrs from one destination to other destination. 3.Bring the punctuality in trains and implement the QR scanning and don't let public to enter into stations before 30min of departure. 4. Tickets should not be released before 1 week of travel and keep the tatkal system open for 7days so that there will not be flooding of people on sites. 5. don't operate a trains without proper ticketing as it is leading to robbery, safety of passengers and improve the train signaling system. 6. seal the unofficial Entry, Exits of railway stations and install the automatic gates closures so that people cant enter in public places other than Railway stations.
Because metros, and airports are closed, like an indoor, one cannot reach to metro stations, or airports through any other way, other than entrance. While railways are like outdoor, any one can come through the tracks to the railway station.
There are like 50 different ways to enter a station if not the main entrance, boundary walls are short or u can just come from the end of the station and a lot more
Same happen metro cities they implemented well, people travel and learn so first it should be develop in bigger and main station so that people would learn and accept them in their cities
I don’t think the automated ticket checking should be used in station as it’s very crowded and not feasible and people could take general tickets and get in AC coach which defeats the purpose. But rather keep automated ticket checking machines beside the doors of coaches and automated doors which only opens if the ticket is validated.
Ticket collectors or ticket checkers will soon be a part of history as indian railway is not recruiting new loco pilots and others group candidates for sure it willl bring profit but as also have loss of jobs. .
During college days I saw my rich friends don't use ticket. Said I will give fine once. I will save money lifetime by not buying tickets. This is mentality of some people. Govt sab kar dega. Ham desh ke liye kuch nahi karenge.
Yes absolutely, Indians doesn't deserve development. Because basic civic sense is absent. Even if people can afford ticket for 1st class they won't even take general ticket.
Please dont underestimate the people from lower and middle class. Some agency should be prepared such as airport authorities of India to Run the railway station.
In my opinion the biggest issue for development any new things in india is to change the behaviour of people by forcing strictly action without thinking vote bank, believe 70 percent problems solved related to every aspect, now sleeper looks general now a days specially in those travelling to up Bihar
Mera paper thaa par ticket nahi milli toh maine binna ticket ke travel Kara . Agar ticket checking machines lag jaaeyegi toh aisa nahi kar paaeyega koi .😮❤😮❤😮😢😢
बहुत अच्छा बताया ,धन्यवाद !! भाई थोड़ा अवैध औटोवालों, टैक्सीवालों , कूली आदि की चर्चा भी कर देते ,क्योंकि वे भी बहुत परेशान कराते हैं। खासकर दिल्ली जैसी जगहों पर ।
Then why not impliment automated ticket checking system in train coaches directly. Scan your ticket and move in. It will also reduce black marketing as well.
Metros are underground and some are through flyover. Railways go through cities. So if you want to go from east to west you won't be buying a ticket to do that right you will be using the same bridge. Railways have cheap tickets compared to metros and I think once you stay in Mumbai you will understand that's not possible railway are like roadway where you have to welcome everyone else moving through city will require additional bridges undergrounds
Like metro trains system , a similar system should be implemented in indian railways as well. Ticket counters should be present before entering the platforms.
The stoppage at some stations is pretty less and it can cause issues as many people deboard the train at stations to buy food or water and people deboard at stations too so it will be a huge bottleneck if they are made at coaches.
So its the fault of public not railway authorities. Why they buy food when the train is going to start?? After automation people will not buy food when the train is going to start@@pritishposwal2590
For updating machines station will require to be elevated because without tickets a passenger can enter jumping of the walls or ending point of platforms!!! Which is not possible according to current scenario..
Now Government is working on it, the main issue is infrastructure. Now government is changing structural function and modernizing some important stations and there almost control by digitally. In just 10 years it will completely changed as a developed country.
middle class and lower middle class ....kabi kabi waiting list ki wajha se without ticket travel krna padta ha aur aapke ye suggestion ke chakkar mai ye sab logo ki life par impact padega ....
If automatic ticket checking machine are installed lot of ticket checker jobs will get scrapped. Rather than that develop system where man and machine can work together to ensure nobody without valid ticket gets entry.
In a city like mumbai for local trains it has to be implemented and for those who can't afford they can provide free passes. This will avoid thefts and crowding
Bhai Ranchi junction pento ab bina ticket ke entry nhi lene dete. Atleast platform ticket to lena hi pdta hai😊. Last month mujhe khud entry nhi diya tha
Sir ji aapne end me sabse bada reason bataya hai politically aur humanity ke liye Bharat me.yah kaafi important reason hai jisse railway itna jyada strict nahin hai.
Railway stations are open from all sides, if you install a ticket checking system at station then people without ticket will cross railway track from opposite side to get on platform.
Now imagine you entered the platform 15 mins earlier before train after you entered you found that train is only 30 mins and 8hours late now you exit the platform and now your ticket is invalid and you have used it
Lower class people sleep on platforms and students giving exams are sleeping in platform this is the biggest help by railways tum video to bana dete ho logo ko majburi nhi samjti
Rather than having ticket verifying machines at the gates of the railway station , we can not put it at the doors of the train. It will come with its own sets of challenges like maintenance and delays in boarding time resulting in train delays (which I guess is solvable over a period of time if citizens are to inculcate more civic sense) , but it will not require an infrastructure overhaul for all the railway stations in the country . What are your thoughts ?
![[🔴LIVE] งานประกาศรางวัล MAYA TV AWARDS 2024 : มายามหาชน](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nwmWYXXVwBY/mqdefault.jpg)
It can be first implemented in Tier 1 cities followed by state capitals and Tier 2 cities.
I like this👍
Very well said 👍
Especially those railway stations which are in the process of redevelopment/renovation
It can also be implemented at Railway Division Stations
delhi me ndls me jane ke lie fixed entry exit gates h, aur bag checking etc, bas ye ticket checking nahi h.
There should be automatic ticket checking gates in every station for crowd management and safety.
It Will Help Railway To Arrest People The Without Tickets
U r absolutely ryt saying 👍
@@carsvelozindia4775😊
It won't be beneficial because if I talk about northern part of western mumbai if will see too much crowd to cover this much crowd they will require more than 200 machines at single station and also they will have to make seperate way to put those machines .Here surrounding space is not much to let everyone to go .
They'll install it and then they'll switch it off just like the scanners in most railway stations
Sir metro is also used by middle class people, and they have no issue with using the automated ticket checking system. So, I don't think their would be an issue. The largest issue is the opposition from the Railway union, which needs to be ignored. The IR needs to go ahead with the process of automation.
Right, we can't stop the progress of our country just because someone's "upari kamayi" will get disturbed. We should move toward massive automation and privatisation. Similar people were pressuring the govt during the era when Computers were getting introduced. Change is part of life and everyone must be ready for it.
U r absolutely ryt saying 👍
Metro Maximum Ticket Price is 60 RS and currently run in TIER-1 and 2 cities only while Railway average price is 800-1000 and run in whole india .
Literacy and Finance of those area where metro run is average much better than compare to Railway covered area.
@sahilbhardwaz4852 A similar issue was raised for UPI. It is a completely failed reason. The same will happen in the case of railways. UPI has been implemented with complete success in India. So, why can't IR implement digital systems successfully.
Wahan unki majboori hai isliye 😂karte unko koi rasta mila toh woh nhi follow karenge
Every Weekend I come to home from Delhi by Mewar Express-12963. Local Passengers (general or no ticket) from ballabhgarh highjack the full train till Kosi Kalan. Reserved Passengers are forced to give up their seats. And railway official are nowhere seen.
Right daily passenger aisi hi gundagardi karte h
I had to give up my reserved Sleeper class seat also at Jaipur station while returning home to Howrah
@@BikerBoyArunava but why, why to give up on your seat that you paid for
@@umamahmad8366
Can you oppose 5-6 people who are just there to take seat?
@@AdityaKantKushwahaGovernment should add more or euqal general coaches than Ac and Sleeper coaches so this problem will
be rectified 😊
We need to build full transport eco system with strict rules and regulations. Building high class train only won't help india to be superpower we need both technological as well cultural changes for reaching pencal .🙃
👍
My India in 1835Read Carefully
"I have travelled across the length and breadth of India and I have not seen one person who is a beggar, who is a thief such wealth I have seen in this country, such high moral values, people of such caliber, that I do not think we would ever conquer this country, unless we break the very backbone of this nation, which is her spiritual and cultural heritage and therefore, I propose that we replace her old and ancient education system, her culture, for if the Indians think that all that is foreign and English is good and greater than their own, they will lose their self esteem, their native culture and they will become what we want them, a truly dominated nation."
Lord Macaulay's Address to the British Parliament on 2nd Feb. 1835
*We must at present do our best to form a class who may be interpreters between us and the millions whom we govern; a class of persons, Indian in blood and colour, but English in taste, in opinions, in morals, and in intellect. To that class we may leave it to refine the vernacular dialects of the country, to enrich those dialects with terms of science borrowed from the Western nomenclature, and to render them by degrees fit vehicles for conveying knowledge to the great mass of the population. - macaulay
*Commenting on the objective of colonial education in Africa, Nelson Mandela remarked thus36:
The educated Englishman was our model; what we aspired to be were 'black Englishmen'. We were taught and believed- that the best ideas were English ideas, the best government was English government, and the best men were Englishmen.
People sleeping on platform floors and obstructing passenger commute is the thing which isn't seen in any developed nation. Even our tier 1 city railway stations have this issue so imagine the first impressions of our country from a tourist's PoV
it is true but they are forced, mazboor
There is no problem with people sleeping on platform many people even sleep on airports
You only need to create designated place like waiting area form them to sleep
@@adarARYANSINGHRANA On station there are but people do not use those
@@harshagrawal3441 there area is really small
People use them but due to overcrowding they have to sleep on platforms
@@adarARYANSINGHRANA Bro let me tell you the whole story On airport there are so much chair to sit but on station there re not enough chairs and this is due to 2 reason corrupted system and people don't hesitate to sit on floor on station but have you ever seen someone putting there sleepers and sitting on them on ground No that is why it is too obvious to sit on ground and sleep to as on airport people will sleep on chair rather on the floor and also the train is late mostly so people have no other option and people also don't prefer waiting room I have seen empty waiting rooms and people sitting outside in summer
I have seen many passangers don't have train tickets when they travel in general coaches and other local trains
This has been in my mind for a long time.. i wish to see this change in Indian railways. It's definitely doable. We should first barricade the entire area of major stations.. second, train doors should be opened/closed at respective stations only so that even in case of chain pulling, no unauthorised person can entry/exit from a train. We need more and more vande Bharat trains to help this entire system. It may take years but in return, Indian railways well be very profitable.
What about crossing??log vag nhi jayenge??metro underground he so log kahin see bhii vag nhi sakte...
First we need more tracks. That will solve most of the problems with railway
True even I've experienced once such scenario when I was travelling in 1st AC class and at Patna station some random guys entered in First AC. They had no tickets; they gave money to tc and that's it. I booked ticket for Rs.6000 and they got seated for some 100rs. And one of those was saying I work at railways so what I paid Rs.6000 for tickets and they are asking me to give space to seat pathetic. Ticket checking machine is must atleast at platform for those who are travelling if not at entrance so those who came to drop their friend, relative at station can come.
How did you get a tatkal ticket of first AC?
@@SaileshAgrawal railway counter
@@imankitsingh09 i don't think tatkal option is available for 1st ac. That must be through general booking or current availability.
@@SaileshAgrawal yeah ur right not for 1st ac. Regular booking I had. Thanks for making me realise my mistake. But those guys without ticket entered.
@@imankitsingh09 Why didn't you complain about it in RailMadad? That too when you had a first AC ticket. I would have called the RPF 😆
This systems can be easily implemented in Mumbai suburban railway station
This can be done in at least Delhi where the 4 major railway stations , new Delhi , old Delhi, Nizamuddin , and anand vihar are all well connected by metro.
Delhi metro has really made a difference in the culture of this city.
However the railway itself needs to be developed and expanded .
The freight corridor will help in separating the freight trains , so passenger capacity can increase.
Big cities also need dedicated suburban train lines instead of the hotchpotch we get, where daily commuters often hijack long distance trains.
Delhi suburban train system is desperate for an upgrade because the network is there, coverage is there , but the the trains aren't run with enough frequency , there's even a local train station close to Delhi Airport
Delhi-Meerut Rrts jab ban jaayega tab Aur Accha ho jaayega
Power train आप देश के हर एक पहलू पर गहरा चिंतन रखते हों।आपके इस एपिसोड में रेलवे के रखी बाते बहुत ही सुन्दर और प्रगति को ले जाने वाली है।
It's a crime to assume lower middle class people can't use the simplest automated systems if they are implemented in all Railway stations. Such myths are excuses for corruption to continue and unions to arm-twist. Public demand for better experiences will shut these unions down soon. Fortunately, Modi ji and his team are great visionaries & nationalists, to make Bharat a global Super Power. 🙏
Mudi ji will listen to you definitely
can u expect a 4th paas to be visionary he depends on civil servants for inputs. otherwise badlo k upar se plane udalo radar se bachne k liye
@@Shekhru121 4 th pass out I don't think so but 70-year experienced person with 40 years in governments. sure he can be visionery
It might be offensive😂 to some, but it is ABSOLUTELY NOT a crime.
Also no, those stereotypes are not why corruption exists, it would exist without it. If you improve the infra, the unions and corrupt tts will automatically wont have the opportunity to cheat and take graft. Also, don't underestimate the unions, I expect the infra, the people and the culture to change before the corrupt unions to change.
@@Shekhru121 why cant a 4th pass be a visonary? Is getting a degree the only way to have visions. Such a stupid comment.
If the ticket checking machine are executed it shouldn't take the jobs of TC's. This can be achieved by doing the following things
1. Excess no of TC's can be shifted to other work like collecting fine from people who spit on the station (this can generate huge revenue as their are crores of Ajay Devgn fans in India, bolo jubaan kesari 😂😂)
2. It will also saves litres of water and cost required for cleaning
Bro pls tweet this man!
'" Ajan Devgn fan "😂😂😂
Kindly make a video on legalized corruption🙏. That will be interesting.
Thats called Lobbying by West
@@arpanabinaswar1811mafia*
@@arpanabinaswar1811does lobbying happen as much in India?
@@S1S2S3S4 ha
I always had this question from my childhood why does Indian railway not have ticket checking system at the entrance of the station itself mainly for Mumbai locals because Japan like countries do have. Thanks. ❤
This way overcrowding on trains would also be stopped
After the freight corridor , indian railway must focus on increasing suburban railway between cities.
This will really be helpful for people .
Dedicated suburban train lines connecting small towns with big cities.
They can be run like metro where the particular platform is for the local train only.
That will surely fix a lot of things for Indian railway
In Foreign Countries, the entry into Railway Platform is restricted only to travellers with valid travel tickets like what we have in Metro Stations. The stalls, restaurants etc. are available only in the concourse areas only and not on platforms. Hence the concourse areas are heavily crowded and railway platforms are less crowded. Most of the long distance trains have restaurant cars and hence there is no need to have stalls on railway platforms. This system also reduces ticketless travel on trains. We are still in the Colonial Era and lack the will to come out of our past.
the best video ever, perfectly confessed my thoughts on railways
Defining Arrival and Exit points are not required, just install the scanner at all the points. First scan can be entry and second scan is exit, simple.
There are multiple entries and exits
Do you know what a deadlock is? What if (and this will always happen) there are big lines on both sides of the scanner?
At least someone spoken on this topics. This is very big issue that railway should improve. People must change their mindset that you can't go unnecessarily to railway or create Chaos. There should be restrictions, rules , discipline, a system with well defined planning. Yes it will take time but somewhere we have to start this. People will understand the things. And In few years people become habitual of this just like UPI. So I support this . 🙏 Jai Hind 🇮🇳
This is the first channel I have seen which talks about all the topics in so much detail. Keep up the good work!
If tickets are checked as in Metro, people will revolt for compulsory seat allocation or availability and making the train be on time, will be the biggest issue.
Then train should not stop in middle like metro 😂 it's not possible because it's india
True, train tickets are booked well in advance. Let's say there is a family emergency in my village and I have to get there by end of the week, what would I do if I do not find tickets. In the existing state, I will slip into the general coach and face hardship but somehow reach my destination on time. At some point, people need to have a chance to slide.
I regularly travel by long distance train. I seriously feel IR should implement this automated ticekting gate. This will significantly reduce the load on the station, it will be easy to manage, eventually service experience will improve.
The Indian government is re-developing 500 something railway stations which will help in implementing these kinds of machines in tickets checking... It will take some time tho
Problem and solution in one place @Power Train 😊
Yes definitely the Indian railway stations entry must be strictly restricted to ticket holders only.
Glad To See It Became The Point Of Discussion. Its The Need Of The Hour, Very Important To Be Implemented In Railways Of Bharat. Please Share This Informative Video To "Railway Ministry".
We have strong tell these railway union to we need ticket checking machine for develop railways
It is not that difficult of a task. Instead of revamping the whole stations, we can make these tickets only accessible doors in the coaches themselves. Only valid tickets will ensure entry in the coaches.
The stoppage at some stations is pretty less and it can cause issues as many people deboard the train at stations to buy food or water and people deboard at stations too so it will be a huge bottleneck if they are made at coaches.
TC 300-500 me seat bech dete hain, bina official process follow kiye
Nhi bhai 200-300 maximum
@@parthjain1496 kaha bhai, 500-1500 lete hai wo
@@connoisseur670 depends on sl, ac, 1st ac etc
We have to do every state and station on make this this system which entering station metro ticket checking machine need 😊😊 these system allready in China and many other countries and it makes also give profit for railways and they give good service and trains
Problem is Express, Superfast, Local etc have different rates and came in the same platform.
How to check If one take general ticket and board Superfast or Rajdhani trains?
This is where TC can stay relevant. Make sure everyone has a ticket inside the train, allot seats to people with RAC tickets, etc. Basically, they'll stay employed even after the introduction of these machines. Increased revenue for railways, no protests from Railway union either.
@@satyammalik6770 Then, Railway needs more manpower.
Currently, vacancies are so high that one employee has to do the duty of 2-3 employees. This is the cause of so many frequent accidents.
Need manpower, need recruitment.
@@manikck7229 While true, that's a separate issue altogether. Railways won't need to recruit additional TC to keep track of who's travelling in which class with which ticket, which was your original question.
It is achievable and we should do the following things considering good for all the people
1. Make big walls at the end of platforms and walls on side of first and last platforms at all railway stations in country and recruit rpf to do patrolling at both ends of all the platforms 24X7 so that no person enters through the tracks.
2. Make designated entry doors like airports and exit doors where RPF/TC checks the ticket as well as the ID as this will ensure that there is no opposition of the unions.
3. To address the issue of general tickets they shouldn't be sold above a limit ie there are 180 seats in a general coach so max tickets sold per coach shouldn't be more than 200 considering few people can stand or adjust and the sale of tickets should happen outside the railway station not inside.
4. There should be TCs inside every class of the train to ensure that no one travels in the wrong class
Great info. But i feel all of the developmental activities will take place only after the completion of dedicated freight corridor because without an efficient transport system imposing restrictions is not a wise decision. Once dedicated freight corridor gets operational we can see efficiency of trains increasing and there by having a chance of implementing the above stated developmental works.
Pahla bat to ye hai ki train me itne log Bina ticket k ghum Raha hai wo agar Kam ho jaye toh hi ye solve ho payega ...nd no of trains should increase ...nahito kabhi bhi possible nahi hoga aisa system sustain karne k liye ...90 seat me 150 log travel karega toh kaise rokoge Khali ek proper entry bana k... Metro jaise every 5-10-15 minutes pe ata hai waise agar local trains chalega toh maybe it vl become practical in coming years ...Bihar me toh patri chori ho jata hai ...it's just not easy ...but junction ya terminal station pe platform me blockade lagwaya ja sakta hai as a pilot project ...nd also there are places without proper platform...train platform se bahar nikla rehta hai ..infra sudharna padega ...maybe then ...aise bhi bohot bar train ruka rehta hai outside station ...too many reforms needed to implement it practically
Tc should be in each compartment as in foreign trains. They are care taker og coaches. But here only 2 tc for full train
Bro,
1. Local trains and express trains ke platforms ko segregate karna padega.
2. Express trains ke platform ke liye tucket mandatory karna padega.
3. Waiting khatam karni padegi.
4. Reservation system ko bhot hi jyada overhaul karna padega.
Filhall ye 4 hi main mudde hai...inse Quality of Service mein behad improvement nazar ayega. Aur ye logo ke confidence ko boost karega.
But my question is
If we only implement ticket checking system at the entrance how will that be effective actual coaches like if someone has borrowed ticket of sleeper class they can enter ac coaches if we do not have manual ticket checkkers.. so this is a big issue why Indian railways cannot implement automated system for ticket checking at the entrance.. infact in metro we have that entrance ticket checking system because metro has only 1 type of coach for all ticket holders and passengers
It Can Be Done Just Check RRTS Security System😊😊
Sir only railway is not only for passengers, but think about the parcels, there are so many people working in third party workers, need to issue a proper id card for them to scan and loading and unloading should be done at some other location not the platform, then every station there will be two Stops one for passengers and other for parcel
If it was done it will be gud let's hope it will implement in coming years
Jaihind
As a TTE. , it's a good idea , metros are in some cities like majorly developed one , and railway have many station like a small one to , it's connected all over India and in mumbai , manu station have unauthorized authorities entry so how many they should apply gates and checking machine , and local crowd in mumbai is peak , whenever a train leaves it leaves high bunch of crowd and people are like animals jump over 😂😂
The major issue is crowd. Many person reach on station just at time or the big lines to scan ticket is very time taking for a passenger and it may lead to departure of the train before we reach in.
Nice video and good points....we could go with phased implementation
Indian railway station mein bhi airport and metro railway station station jaisa entrance gate hona chahiye woh bhi compulsory aur important Hai.
If tickets are checked properly then it will be much more convinet for the passengers and also generate more revenue then now. People without tickets pack AC 3 tier, SL and general we people who have tickets suffer as we get compact in hot and tight space.
Can use QR code in tickets at entry or exits of trains.
Or those metro type tokens, with rfid.
Ur sugesstion is perfect👌👌
How about a family of 4 or 5 members ?? How can they scan the single ticket....???
@@nikhiln5986 haven't you travelled in trains? is there separate ticket for every family member?
@@ms.550 It seems you haven't understand my question. Im asking how with one ticket whole family acknowledges entry/exit ??
@@nikhiln5986 what's wrong with that, have you booked on BookMyShow?
My brother had to travel urgently from Mumbai to Surat due to hospitality emergency. He travelled without ticket. He reached Surat easily without ticket. No one came to check the ticket.
Please make a special video on touts and scammers in major tourist places. Those scumbags are not tarnishing Image of India but also discouraging the tourists to come to India. Strict actions like sedition/UAPA should be taken against them for decreasing the foreign revenue from tourism.
Even our temples are full of those
It is shameful to witness
have you ever seen the lines outside metro stations in Delhi during rush hours imagine that 24/7 at railway stations
Impossible to implement in stations except the bigger ones.
For eg. koi bhi patri ke raaste enter kar jaiga🤣
And smaller stations are open anyways
To an extent, travelling without ticket and giving TC some money to get an un-assigned/missing passenger seat is necessary.
There are so many instances I know where it has saved people's lives/hleped in some very needing times.
But if the TC forcefully adds extra passenger on the same seat then that's an issue.
Bhai bohot kam logo ke kaam ata h ye chiz... because of this lot of people struggle because of overcrowd
Even if we get automated ticket checking at the entry, how will we ensure the passenger is only taking the train they paid for and not a more expensive train? How will we we make sure people don't move from general compartment to sleeper or AC compartment if there is no manual checking inside the train?
That's why both gates and tte r required
the way it happens in japan and other countries, simple
Station ticket ko aasani se koi bhi le sake any upi app se ya kisi bhi finteck app se with bar code
Aisa krna chiye
Sathh hi station ticket ke liye alag se dedicated counter hona chiye entry exit gate pr
Or plateform ticket ko aniwarya kr dena chahiye
IR must implement this... will boost railway infrastructure, security perspective, revenue etc..
I think there is a simple solution
Automate the Entry-Exit, but keep the TC for in-train checking, to ensure people aren't "voluntarily" upgrading themselves to higher class.
This will not take away any work from the TCs, but will make the travel process easy.
But the only issue I see with Railways is the Coolie issue, if we prevent free entry-exit.
They're charging grossly high prices these days, like ~1000 Rupees, or more for just 1-2 bags. Usually all the relatives come to assist in the baggage handling lol.
So platform ticket should be very readily available through QR, like in Hyderabad/Delhi Metro tickets.
Or..... Make railway stations accessible, with multiple lifts, escalators, travellators, and better platform surfaces which won't break the suitcase wheels, if we're dragging.
Acc to my opinion This work should be done by phases Like in 1st Phase all TIER-1 city stations should implement Automate TC system Then Tier-2 After some year then 3 and finally Rural .
Cause just like you told Discipline , Literacy and Finance are the biggest obstacles then Its ultimate solution and Parallel at the same time too Cause in Tier-1 Cities Peoples Literacy , Discipline and Finance are average better than others ,, and same apply 2 ,,, 3 ,,, RURAL.
What about that idea ??
Perfect. Should be implemented. At least in the new stations that are being redeveloped.
#Askpt or video topic
Can we fill the creeks around mumbai with sand , so that mumbai wil be attached with mainland completely.
Then all the problem of space will resolved as horizontal expansion can be done
Platform टिकट को mandatory कर दिया जाना चाहिए जिसे scan करके हि अंदर जाया जा सके
Not just Platforms but the train doors should also have QR scanners and should only allow people who have a QR on the ticket to open the door. The trains can have a local computer which would have the database of all the valid travelers and railways employees who are authorized to travel.
😂
After 26/11 it should have been implemented. Just imagine if airport type of or even a lesser security system would have been there then the outcome at CST nightmare would be different for so many life's
इंडियन रेलबे को सारी जिलों को बुलेट ट्रेन से जोड़ देना चाहिए छे सौ किलोमीटर प्रति घंटा कि हिसाब से चाहे बीस साल क्यों नहीं लगे
Chup ho ja pagal
Fir to hyperloop lagan chahiye seedha chahe 50 saal kyun n lage
1.keep railway stations of Tier 1, Tier2, Tier3 cities outside the city and run an MMTS service within the city which solves the problem of travelling more people.
2. remove the sleeper trains which travels in morning and replace with Seating trains and trains should not travel more than 12hrs from one destination to other destination.
3.Bring the punctuality in trains and implement the QR scanning and don't let public to enter into stations before 30min of departure.
4. Tickets should not be released before 1 week of travel and keep the tatkal system open for 7days so that there will not be flooding of people on sites.
5. don't operate a trains without proper ticketing as it is leading to robbery, safety of passengers and improve the train signaling system.
6. seal the unofficial Entry, Exits of railway stations and install the automatic gates closures so that people cant enter in public places other than Railway stations.
Because metros, and airports are closed, like an indoor, one cannot reach to metro stations, or airports through any other way, other than entrance. While railways are like outdoor, any one can come through the tracks to the railway station.
There are like 50 different ways to enter a station if not the main entrance, boundary walls are short or u can just come from the end of the station and a lot more
Same happen metro cities they implemented well, people travel and learn so first it should be develop in bigger and main station so that people would learn and accept them in their cities
Genuine topic brother, info based on fact...
Jo log plateform pe sote rehte he uska solution nikalna padega
I don’t think the automated ticket checking should be used in station as it’s very crowded and not feasible and people could take general tickets and get in AC coach which defeats the purpose. But rather keep automated ticket checking machines beside the doors of coaches and automated doors which only opens if the ticket is validated.
Ticket collectors or ticket checkers will soon be a part of history as indian railway is not recruiting new loco pilots and others group candidates for sure it willl bring profit but as also have loss of jobs. .
एक पूरी पीढ़ी इस सोच के साथ बड़ी हुई है कि सरकारें बेरोजगारी को सिर्फ एक ही तरह से दूर कर सकते हैं कि हर महीने 50 हजार क्लर्क की भर्ती निकाली जाए
I had searched for platform ticket at New delhi Railway Station and was told it was not being sold anymore . So I am surprised to see your video.
During college days I saw my rich friends don't use ticket. Said I will give fine once. I will save money lifetime by not buying tickets. This is mentality of some people. Govt sab kar dega. Ham desh ke liye kuch nahi karenge.
Yes absolutely, Indians doesn't deserve development. Because basic civic sense is absent. Even if people can afford ticket for 1st class they won't even take general ticket.
Please dont underestimate the people from lower and middle class. Some agency should be prepared such as airport authorities of India to Run the railway station.
In my opinion the biggest issue for development any new things in india is to change the behaviour of people by forcing strictly action without thinking vote bank, believe 70 percent problems solved related to every aspect, now sleeper looks general now a days specially in those travelling to up Bihar
Mera paper thaa par ticket nahi milli toh maine binna ticket ke travel Kara .
Agar ticket checking machines lag jaaeyegi toh aisa nahi kar paaeyega koi .😮❤😮❤😮😢😢
बहुत अच्छा बताया ,धन्यवाद !! भाई थोड़ा अवैध औटोवालों, टैक्सीवालों , कूली आदि की चर्चा भी कर देते ,क्योंकि वे भी बहुत परेशान कराते हैं। खासकर दिल्ली जैसी जगहों पर ।
Then why not impliment automated ticket checking system in train coaches directly. Scan your ticket and move in. It will also reduce black marketing as well.
There is no need of TTE in Railways, system should be automate like metro
Metros are underground and some are through flyover. Railways go through cities. So if you want to go from east to west you won't be buying a ticket to do that right you will be using the same bridge.
Railways have cheap tickets compared to metros and I think once you stay in Mumbai you will understand that's not possible railway are like roadway where you have to welcome everyone else moving through city will require additional bridges undergrounds
Like metro trains system , a similar system should be implemented in indian railways as well. Ticket counters should be present before entering the platforms.
Also railways can also implement automated doors on the train itself allowing only the one with tickets to enter in the train at the first place
The stoppage at some stations is pretty less and it can cause issues as many people deboard the train at stations to buy food or water and people deboard at stations too so it will be a huge bottleneck if they are made at coaches.
So its the fault of public not railway authorities. Why they buy food when the train is going to start?? After automation people will not buy food when the train is going to start@@pritishposwal2590
Bro I am from middle class family
But I am use IRCTC app very well
And I am traveling with reservation ticket
For updating machines station will require to be elevated because without tickets a passenger can enter jumping of the walls or ending point of platforms!!! Which is not possible according to current scenario..
Atleast AC / Reservation train coaches pe QR entry h tho bahoot pyara... Bahoot bhadiya...
Now Government is working on it, the main issue is infrastructure. Now government is changing structural function and modernizing some important stations and there almost control by digitally. In just 10 years it will completely changed as a developed country.
middle class and lower middle class ....kabi kabi waiting list ki wajha se without ticket travel krna padta ha aur aapke ye suggestion ke chakkar mai ye sab logo ki life par impact padega ....
If automatic ticket checking machine are installed lot of ticket checker jobs will get scrapped. Rather than that develop system where man and machine can work together to ensure nobody without valid ticket gets entry.
The tc will switch off the machines just like the baggage scanners
A lot of people depends on railways for income, "unofficially "
Railways knows this better than youtubers
In a city like mumbai for local trains it has to be implemented and for those who can't afford they can provide free passes. This will avoid thefts and crowding
Bhai Ranchi junction pento ab bina ticket ke entry nhi lene dete. Atleast platform ticket to lena hi pdta hai😊. Last month mujhe khud entry nhi diya tha
Ticket Checker can be deployed as helper at automatic gate systems and their job will be safe.
It's time we should start doing this. It's good for the betterment of ambience of the stations
Sir ji aapne end me sabse bada reason bataya hai politically aur humanity ke liye Bharat me.yah kaafi important reason hai jisse railway itna jyada strict nahin hai.
Long distance k base par seat allot karke railway ka revenue badhana chahiye
Railway stations are open from all sides, if you install a ticket checking system at station then people without ticket will cross railway track from opposite side to get on platform.
Now imagine you entered the platform 15 mins earlier before train after you entered you found that train is only 30 mins and 8hours late now you exit the platform and now your ticket is invalid and you have used it
Lol mumbai local mai to 10-20% log without travel karte hai😂😂😂
First they should close unofficial entrances and exits , otherwise we know what will happen ......
Lower class people sleep on platforms and students giving exams are sleeping in platform this is the biggest help by railways tum video to bana dete ho logo ko majburi nhi samjti
Rather than having ticket verifying machines at the gates of the railway station , we can not put it at the doors of the train. It will come with its own sets of challenges like maintenance and delays in boarding time resulting in train delays (which I guess is solvable over a period of time if citizens are to inculcate more civic sense) , but it will not require an infrastructure overhaul for all the railway stations in the country . What are your thoughts ?