2020 Porsche 911 Carrera S MANUAL vs 2010 Porsche 911 Carrera S // The $100K Divide
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ส.ค. 2020
- This is the new 2020 911 Carrera S, and today it meets its elder, the 2010 997 911 Carrera S which costs less and offers naturally aspirated thrills. Both have a flat-six engine, a manual gearbox, and take the shape of an icon. Equipped with turbos, the new one does 0-60 in 4.2 seconds with the manual, and 3.7 seconds with the PDK. So can the old one stack up? Is the new one worth the massive premium? James and Thomas jump behind the wheel of both to experience them and discuss them inside and out. Watch and enjoy!
Thanks to the legendary Muneesh for allowing us to use his 997 AND his wonderful 993.
And thanks to Porsche True North for putting us in touch!
/ porschetruenorth
Big Thanks to Car Crib Canada! www.carcrib.ca/
Ontario's premier car storage facility! James and Thomas store their cars there in the winter in their heated, locked, and secure storage facility.
SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE THROTTLE HOUSE
/ @throttlehouse
Instagram!
/ thethrottlehouse
Post-production by the man, the myth, the legend: Karston Chong
Oh and also Thomas Holland
Facebook!
/ thomashollandproductions
Music from Epidemicsound.com
#Porsche #CarreraS #Manual - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Reviewing high end cars and comparing them to their more financially accessible counterparts is a good way to go. You give us the best of both worlds, the cutting edge of today and the hidden treasures on the secondary market.
Everyone of those cars was amazing, and you showed appreciation for them all.
Well done.
J S it’s fascinating to see how far cars have come but also highlight some of the reasons why enthusiasts like older cars, e.g. for their hydraulic steering or mechanical simplicity
@@neelparmar6690 I went on a rant the other day about older cars. Not so much that they are better than the technological wonders of today, because they aren't, but because they made us better drivers. There's more to driving than just getting from A to B on the highway fast.
These days, lane keep assist is ubiquitous, adaptive cruise has made is to you don't even need to touch the pedals, and you can parallel park by touching a button. I know people who have never been behind the wheel of anything older than a 2005 Ford F-150. They don't know how to drive with no power steering. They don't know about life without being able to hook up their phones to the stereo. It's funny, how so many drivers cry over the looming loss of manual transmissions, when they never really drive on their own anyway.
Those old cars made us part of the drive. The immediacy of driving them was not unlike riding a motorcycle. We were part of the road and the world around us in a way we can't be in modern cars. The connection to the road was direct, and there was less safety gear to separate us from the experience.
This is why it's great to see the side by side between the modern and the old. It shows how far we have come and what we used to consider state of the art. And Thomas and James did a wonderful job of describing the sensations of old compared to the sleek new experience.
Thanks for taking the time to contribute on the way things were.
J S wonderfully put
@@JS-hw8ve I agree with you. My first manual "sporty" car was a 1985 VW GTI which I purchased new. It was featured in Motor Trend's , "Car of the Year", that year and 2 years later I traded in for a 1987 16V GTI which was the 3rd car in my life up until then that I modified. That thing did not have power steering and didn't need it. It was standard and handled amazingly well and was fast even by today's standards....for a hot hatch. I loved driving it and I lived in Toronto where the roads were amazing compared to Montreal where I moved back to in 1987.
@@xorbitman Good on you, bud. I didn't know what a "hot hatch" was until much later. Where I am from, the sports car guys and muscle car guys had less friendly names for that type of car.
My own opinion on a person's car is a lot more welcoming, and comes from understanding where they come from, and what the use of them would be.
Asia and Europe are tighter, more compact, with narrower roads, so handling and maneuverability were important.
North America has lots of space and vast distances to cross, so power was at a premium, as well as comfort for long, long rides.
Then there's taxes and other issues to contend with.
As long as your car does what you need it to do, safely, then you have a damn fine car. And I do so love me a good Golf. The platform is far more comfortable than the last Jetta I was in. Was looking at buying one of the 2020 Golf Rs back in Nov.
1980s: Automatic gearboxes are a luxury
2020s: Manual gearboxes are a luxury
😤
Not in europe lmao, everything is a manual here. Trust me id take an automatic everyday, and you feel free to take a 1.2 3 cylinder 70 hp manual petrol for daily driving..
Americans: 90% of cars sold on our market for the past 50 years were automatics and almost nobody can drive a manual here.
Also americans: wHy dOnT wE gEt moRe MaNuALs??!?
No, manual gearboxes aren't a luxury in 2020. They're standard in pretty much all cars pretty much everywhere in the world outside of NA.
@Frank cassidy you can make a lot more money trading on forex and crypto or investing on the stock market and probably owning the Carrera
I actually invest both on stock and crypto but lately crypto is far better than stock
"1996 wasn't that long ago..."
Me, born in 1996, "thank you for making me feel a little less old."
86 here buddy.. You have no idea what kinda feels are coming! :D
I was driving an air cooled Porsche in96.
Okay, Volkswagen , but driving!
You look a lot older!
@@TheSteinbitt well, I'm not tho
@@asadrahman_ar just joking, you’re far too young to even be having such thoughts!
Daily drive a 997.1 and it never fails to put a smile on my face. I recommend every driving enthusiast try a 911 at least once.
My 997.1 sleeps during the winter, and I don't take it to work. Both other than that I drive it as much as I can. 16 years and the car still feels fantastic.
I was given a Cayenne loaner when I took it into for service. The interior is light years ahead of my car. But when I'm driving it, I really don't feel I'm missing too much.
And yes, every driving enthusiast should try a 911 at some point. Even if it is the dreaded 996. One that has been taken care of is still a fantastic car to drive.
Bought a 997.1 2 years ago to, I also leave it in the garage for winter but 8 months a year it puts a smile on my face everytime I drive the thing! One thing I changed on mine wich is an absolute must is I changed the steering wheel into a 991.2 generation one, I recommend it I really do
Bought a 997.1 2CS because of your comment
@@hobear637 what colour? How you liking it?
@@grivoc loving it! Arctic silver, flies under the radar. What are you driving these days?
The intro alone is worth a million subs
Agreed
I can see his light sabers reflection from the hood of the 911.
just commenting here because yours is the top comment and to reach more people
it’s por-SCHE, not por-sha/po-shuh like they said in the review th-cam.com/video/Im2eYuGdmfY/w-d-xo.html
Ifkr
@@dr-ok3sn You dont have to say every car brand in the exact accent of the original language. 99% of English speakers have never said Honda or Subaru correctly even once. Stop being elitist lmao
The cinematography after the intro isn't less than that of a show with a multi million dollar budget, great job guys 👏. You guys are under rated even at 800k subs.
Holy crap! 800k+ subs! I've been watching since 100k+! So exciting to see my favorite automotive YT channel doing so well!
Agreed.
I kept thinking Top Gear (late May/Clarkson/Hamster). Beautifully done.
Gears & gasoline are way better and way more underrated
I often wonder how Doug has as many subs as he does.. this is just so much more entertaining and informative. Doug just goes "...steering is so precise!" or not, and that's about as deep as it gets.
That $60k S is now sitting at $75-80k a year later.
In Australia they’re $160,000-$200,000.
@@SkyKasha what??? 997.2 carrera S for that price? in NZ they're average around 70-90k for a manual and lot less for an auto.
@@unluggylounge674 yeah aus is nuts, I’ve moved here from London and they’re about 5x the price 🤣
I hope prices go down soon -__- I can afford a 60K car not a 80K one
Back down to $60k now! I'm looking for one now!
"When it came out... it was the PDK... and it was that little nub." *Microsoft error sound*
It's shit like this that makes me love you guys just that much more.
This.
James: "Ah, 911 day!"
Thomas: (nervously starts pulling at his collar)
Ha!
James did 911
idk why i’m watching this as a 15 year old with $43.62 cents to his name but here i am
because u can dream better than anyone and before you are 18, if you start imagining now, you can have whatever car you want, but you gotta want it without compromise
Put down the games, focus on school, and you'll have a porche before you know It!
@@J.Wolf90 School ? What school does teach about money ? Nothing ! Study Bob Proctor
William Wilson yes sir! that 911 won’t pay for itself
You are starting at the right place. You can have anything you can dream, got get it!
The 997.2 is my favorite generation of the 911.
"911 day"
"Is a good day"
I'd bet.
5:25 “One of the only issues that I have with this car, is that two things.”
Yup, makes sense Thomas.😂👍🏽
Each gauge is its own issue I guess 🤣
Haha
Oh my God you're so smart your mom and daddy must be proud of you
Intro is just 😂
I love how they can talk for 22mins about how the car feels. Keep it up guys! Best channel out there
Awesome review guys, I love these new and old comparisons of these iconic cars. A Boxster and/or Cayman version with this format would be awesome also.
When I saw the thumbnail and title: I wish they can review an aircooled 911
When I saw the 993: YEEES, LOVE YOU GUYS
When I saw the thumbnail I couldn't help but think about those porche SUVs and wonder what's next? A Lamborghini minivan? A Ferrari station wagon?
J. Wolf oh come on, those would be badass
It's too bad they didn't get in the 993 though. I was waiting for them to do that since they introduced it in the feature.
@@J.Wolf90 There kind of already is a Ferrari station wagon. The FF/GTC4 Lusso
The 997 was so sleek ! Especially the early ones, and without ginormous wheels introduced with 991. Love it.
Alain best looking post 993 911 in my opinion
By far the best (looking) modern 911. Still fast by today's standards, and all variations could be sold with a manual transmission. What's not to like?
@Collidiscope you can buy a NA 991.1 manual
Unpopular opinion: I feel like the 991.1/.2 chassis doesn't get enough love...
To me, that gen also feels pretty lively and engaging, while balancing both digital and analogue, which the analogue part does take over for the MOST part of the car, not entirely. Yeah, it misses the Hydraulic steering, but still has a very confident EPAS rack. Though, it would be wonderful to see Porsche returning to Hydraulic power assist racks.
@@rahulmandala4930 unpopular opinion? Mate, if anything, the 996 gets no love.
James and Thomas, keep up the the production (video, planning, sound, sound, etc.) it shows. Your approach is SPOT ON and it isn't chosen by folks like me only for the subject, but because of the delivery. Well done. One of your best deliveries ever.
I really love when you guys do the new vs old comparisons!! So informative!
6:10 "it's like if you played beethoven night symphony in one second. Ehh" too funny lol 🤣😂
Foreal tho🤣🤣🤣
9th* yeah that was hilarious
Congrats on the 840,000 subs fellas. Been watching since it was just Thomas doing his solo thing on the channel and it was great then, now it's another level of great with the addition of James. Continued success fellas, and i can't wait for you guys to hit the 1,000,000 mark.
2Milly+ now pretty incredible!
Seeing the way the intro was made was hilarious. I think we speak for all of us when I say, we love you guys. Thanks for your hard work and dedication and keep up the amazing work! 👍🏾👍🏾
Just stumbled on your channel and specifically this vid. Simply fantastic! Love the production quality and chemistry between you all. Keep up the great work!!!!!
Starting to get some serious Top Gear / Grand Tour vibes on that intro...
10:36 "Do it a different way... First time!" I caught that 😂
The 997.2 is the stuff of legend. It still retains the visceral experience and refine enough to make it a daily driver. It will go down in history as a highly sought after car and has shot up in value.
Just find you guys today. watched already about 10 video's on your channel today, just love how you both work together and interact with each other. Keep up the great work. BTW, Porsche 911 is my favourite car, but sadly can't afford these beautyful cars.
I was 20 when the 993 came out and remember it being the coolest 911 I’d ever seen. Especially the Turbo. A classic for sure.
Okay James, that was a REAL bad try on Doppelkupplungsgetriebe, but I'll give you a pass for being nice to the Porsche :)
Dopplküpplungsgötriebe
xD I had a good laugh. Einen Personenkraftwagen mit Doppelkupplungsgetriebe und Frontscheibenheizung bitte^^
Doppel[geffif?]götriebe?
Minimal MO am besten noch mit:
Abgaskrümmer Abgasturbolader Anhängerkupplung Anlasser Antriebswelle Autobatterie Bremsbelag Bremskraftregler Bremssattel Bremsscheiben Einspritzpumpe Einspritzventile Glühkerze Kältemittelkondensator Katalysator Keilriemen Klimaanlage Klimakompressor Klimatrockner Kraftstofffilter Kraftstoffpumpe Kühler Kupplung Kupplungsscheibe Kurbelwelle Ladeluftkühler Lambdasonde Lenkgetriebe Lichtmaschine Luftfilter Luftmassenmesser Nockenwelle Ölfilter Ölwanne Partikelfilter Servopumpe reparieren Stoßdämpfer Trommelbremse Ventile Wasserpumpe-Kühlmittelpumpe Zündkerze Zündspule Zylinderkopf Zylinderkopfdichtung
@@2tp223 schön alphabetisch geordnet
This is one of the best car channels out there. I just now found it and wish I knew about you many moons ago. Keep up the great work!!!
Man if I had the money I would buy any of those Porsches tomorrow. This channel is brilliant, guys you deserve all the respect for your passion and work 🙏
I really really love this series of old vs new! Please please keep them coming! And I really really hope you guys hit 1M soon!!!
That intro was amazing. I fell in love with my dream car all over again. You guys killed it with this video🔥
Guys, this video is insane qualitiy, I enjoyed every second (as usual) 👌🏼
You guys GET IT ! Congratulations on perfectly describing the feel of driving these two cars !
That was an amazing video! You guys should do another like this with the F8, 458, and F355
Nah, Ben they should stick to real sports cars, not tourist hot rod's!
That intro scene...sooooo good!
Thank you guys !!! I am 911 addicted (driving 997.1c2) and was feeling all your words and symphony 🤪. Great moments always with you !! Thanks
Awesome review guys! I have a 2012 911 997.2 and love it! I find myself watching this video over and over!
You guys have really stepped up the production value. Love it ! Reminds me a lot of top gear UK.
I had to pause the video 10 seconds in so I could get more comfortable so I could enjoy the vid to its highest potential
did you have one off the wrist as well? same here mate.
That intro is the culmination of the best of classic and present youtube... that clip should be on trending & triple your subscriber count quite literally
This channel deserves way more subs than it currently has... Great production, and entertaining as fook...
These guys need 1 million subs. At the very least. So much hard work!
Loved this comparison. I just bought a 997.1 C2 sight unseen and haven't even driven it yet. This video makes me look forward to that day even more.
Even at almost 1 million subs, you guys are underrated. Keep up the great work, and DON'T CHANGE A THING!
Guys, that intro (after the behind-the-scenes, of course) was AMAZING! Great work!! Wish I could afford a 997.2 but at a tad over $30k USD I got a 997.1 Carrera S instead, and it's still phenomenal!
how the f come german car is cheaper in us than in europe this is so fking unfair ! 😢
😍
I'm thinking about buying a 997.1 S. What are your thoughts on the car?
@@iluvcakes19 brilliant cars! I've had two now for about two years with each. The only thing that sucks about them is the fear (mostly overblown) surrounding the IMS bearing and cylinder bore scoring. Generally speaking, if the car is regularly driven, it's probably fine.
@@coreykononchuk dope! Great summation. I saw a really inexpensive 2005 recently that got me thinking. I really don't need the car but basically it's cheaper than buying a new or used 86/FR-S, so I could essentially use it as a fun beater. Only thing is consumables and maintenance don't make sense in that capacity. Again, I really don't need the car but damn I low-key want it (also, rather, in comparison, I'm putting the 911 against a 2001 RT/10 which would be a completely different and rad experience).
Great video, guys!! Love all three of these 911s, and hope to be able to afford one someday.
Nice. Really nice guys. Excellent choice of 911's to compare. Your cinematography is excellent, way beyond most on TH-cam. My son is a DP so I've learned how to appreciate the amount of work it takes to get it all just right. Enjoyed listening to your banter which was P car on point. Who in the heck can say the PDK word correct in the USA anyway. I just had to subscribe.
You guys upped your game with the camera angles. It looks a lot more like a Top Gear episode now vs a TH-cam channel production. And that's a good thing. Impressive!
Just to add, the Porsche 997.2 Carrera S does 0-62mph in 4.5 seconds (so 0-60mph in 4.3 seconds) and not a “hair over 5 seconds” as stated in the video. 😎 Love the video; great to see a MANUAL 992! The throw of the gait when changing looks so tight and precise!
Yes I noticed he got that wrong.
"1996 wasn't that long ago" Thanks for making feel better about my age, James! :)
The review of various era 911's is awesome, what a treat. Thank you
I was picking up my car from a body shop one time and they had an old 70's 911 there that the owner had turned into a rally car. I was obsessed with opening the door and closing it, lol. The popping sound the handle made and the satisfying clicking sound of the door closing. I can totally relate, haha. Great video.
The fact that well maintained, low mileage 997’s are now keeping pace price-wise with the newer 991s should tell you what enthusiasts think is the better car. 😉
it tells which one is still in production and not much else. to reach the conclusion you did, you have to come back to the newer ones in 12 years.
991s aren't/weren't in production at the time of OP's writing. They're comparing the 997 to 992.
I think the 997s are the prettiest. That was peak 911 in terms of looks. They've gone downhill a bit since then.
@@joels7605 Agree that 997s are pretty cars but for me the 964s were peak 911 design.
@@thedudeabides1443interesting. For me it's either a 993 or a long nose 911S
That intro reminds me of that old Top Gear episode of the original Lambo Aventador! Awesome! 👍
Made my day guys, i am 61 i had a 1995 993 and a 2007 997 C4 i cry every time i think of the day i sold the 993. Great job, love watching your show !
Right after the intro the quality was hollywood level you guys are insane congrats on now having 2.51 million subs
The AeroKit really improves the 992's look - breaks up the bigness.
It's UGGs
Yupp, that's a good intro 👍🏻👍🏻.
Really awesome videos with beautiful and iconic cars! Even though Doppelkupplungsgetriebe sounds different it was a good try. Love you guys
You guys are the Canadian version of Top Gear... entertaining and informative. Love it!
Oh what 1 year can do in terms of pricing. Good luck trying to find a 997.2 S manual for $60k in 2021.
It'll be under $40k in 12 months. 😊
My favourite automotive channel. Now topgear comes 2nd for me.
J M you should check out carwow Mat Watson is funny af. That being said, these guys are absolutely awesome.
Tom Robinson carwow is great and the straight pipes is also great but throttle house... it’s just better
@@tomrobinson9388 yeah they're good too, matt and yannie just rock
@@ethancaine1646 true
@@tomrobinson9388 carwow and mat are great but throttle house goated rn
This has become my favorite car channel. Cheers from Argentina
I seriously LOVE these comparison videos.
You guys clearly deserve millions of subscribers
I'm trying! I tell everyone about these guys.
Me too😅
Best introductions on TH-cam!!!
Hey there! First time to watch your video. Subscriber after 5 minutes... brilliant!! So much fun to watch! Go ahead!
Just discovered your channel and I'm veeery happy that you guys keep the (sorry) ''fake'' excitement to a m-i-n-i-m-u-m! Very smooth to watch, not many cringe moments. THANK YOU ❤
Oh I love this channel so much!!!
I’ll be so pleased for you guys when you hit a million subs. You really deserve it 👍🏼
This comment aged like fine wine
@@pressstart1490 I am now so pleased
Nice video guys, great entertainment, as usual. My daily is a Civic Type R, and despite how much I love my car (and the fact that my mountain bike fits neatly in the back of it)....having a (manual) 911 sitting next to it in the driveway is still something I dream about, regardless if it is a 2020 or a 2010 model.
my 997S still puts a smile on my face 10 years later.
That Intro though🔥🔥🔥🔥
This vid gets it. And, if you want the most incredible Porsche, get into a '14-16 Cayman 6mt. It is the zenith of Porsche that is affordable for normal humans.
Almost. Second gen 997/987s.
Pinnacle. After that, beautiful cars; less Porsche looking and steering. Just my opinion. Carefully friends
Word. I have a 981 S so I am a bit biased...
Actually, the 993 series was the last of the real Porsches. I have a 991.1 GTS but also a 993. If I had to sell one of them and I don't, the 991.1 would have to go. Both of them are manuals.
Your vids are getting better and better, great episode guys
The more I’m watching TH, the more I feeling that ‘THIS CHANNEL DESERVES MORE SUBSCRIBERS’.
Keep doing these good works, Thomas and James. 🎉
Couldn’t see outer gauges in 993 either... just sayin’ lol
Great review! Do you guys really have more next week??
Great video as always guys. 997 is my choice too for that sweet naturally aspirated flat 6 sound.
The 996 and 997 are the perfect years for Porsche. Like freedom in Canada and America, I miss those models.
the intro is very Top Gear level, which I love, amazing review guys.
I'd take both...But Love the 2010, 911 naturally aspirated engine !!
That intro gave me top gear vibes man 😭😭
Yeah, love the intro and obviously LOVE THE MANUAL! Truly a jewel! Just put in the same wing almost blending with the car and take off the rear roundness.
the vibes of your videos are very reminiscent of that UK motoring show.... keep it up boys, love the content.
Who's here mainly for the "and I'm James" line?
I would take the 997.2 over the 992 every day. The 997 is one of my favorite 911, there is just the 993 on the same level, but way more expensive.
You guys are flawless! Thanks for what you do.
I love your reviews but it is always the intro for me . LOVE THE INTRO!
I’ve always thought Porsche were great cars but didn’t really LIKE them... I think this video changed my mind.
I dont like their pricing, especially 911, panamera and other stuff is actually pretty affordable, but with 911 you pay like 20% tax for it's name
Haha the intro scenes are TopGear-esque.
Intros like that is why you guys deserve over a million subs!
Thank you 😭 this is exactly the video I’ve been looking for
Throttle House >>> The Straight Pipes, Doug Demuro, Redline Reviews.
Fight me.
For me, the 'gold standard' is Harry's Garage. Also, Jay Leno's Garage, when he is reviewing his *own* cars.
Vipul Singh yes! Leno's garage is the Original TH-cam car show. I love when he does his own cars.
How could you forget Hoovie? PREPOSTEROUS
"1996 wasnt that long ago"
Literally 24 years
Essentially a quarter of a century 😁
It's going to be 2100 before people stop thinking that the 19 hundreds was yesterday lol
@@markweisgram155 Thanks for making me feel old lol
Good golly gosh. The quality of this introduction slots somewhere in-between "The Grand Tour" and UK's "Top Gear" by every discernable measure. Stunning. The sky's the limit fellas!
Great review! I love my 997.2. It puts a smile on my face every time I drive her.
It just worked bro😂🔥🔥🔥