So thankful to you, for sharing these precious art works of a legend, Sir R.Waters. for those like me and many lovers of Pink Floyd, that have no chance to participate in any concerts of these honorable men. Again Thanks.✨🌀✨
I saw the Paris concert and I left a different man that day, out of all the events i've been through during my life , nothing can be compared to that day
Attending this concert was a dream come true! I feel incredibly lucky to have been there. Words can't express how amazing the experience was. Forever grateful!
In 2003 my father showed to me The Dark Side of The Moon for the first time, and in 2023 i took him and my wife to see this show here in Brazil. That was a dream coming true to me!
Cette version de comfortably numb est sublime. j'étais au pied de la scène le 3 mai à Paris et c'était fabuleux . je revois cette vidéo avec beaucoup d'émotion. Merci pour ce partage
I have to add....Comfortably Numb IS my favorite some in my over 60 years of being a musician and audiophile. This rendition caused me to write the below comment....this redition LACKS all of the substance of the original, created by ALL of PINK FLOYD....not just Rodger Waters....no matter what HE thinks.
David is in the bar i respect roger He still a rocker at heart nothing changed If I were the moon I'd be cool If I were a ruleI would bend If I were a good man I'd understand the spaces between friends
Hola muchos saludos buen día dulce pequeña mujer oye muy feliz día hoy y siempre dulce pequeña frágil mujer 🤟👍🐟🎸🎶🎵🎶👉🌛🌹🎼🌌🌞☁️☁️🌦️🌦️🤟🤗😇🤟👍🐟🌹🎼🎶🤟👌🎸The pink floyd the wall
I am sorry folks....I love Pink Floyd for all of their beauty, diversity and harmonic musical prowness. Rodger Waters IS NOT Pink Floyd!!! Rodger is a very ANGRY MAN, who HAS BEEN the majority of his life!!! Music should express the vast gambit of human emotion, not just "ONES" preclusion for all that is wrong with the world. Rodger makes interesting MUSIC, but has LOST the need to present the BEAUTIFUL side of this existance. Where is the BEAUTY of sweeping keyboards, guitars, flutes and harps expressing this beauty and LOVE. If I want to hear a well programed PRERECORDING of mostely ANGER, I am quite content to hear it in the perfection of my home listening room, with the ability to ALSO enjoy the BEAUTIFUL....I don't want to pay over $100 to hear precorded tapes and one mans pervisons....mostly PRERECORDED!!!! COMMON all you SHEEP out there....REQUIRE something BETTER out of HIM!!! He IS capable of doing so, but the POOR GUY has lost all of his EQUALLY talented mates and co-musicians that ARE, or were PINK FLOYD.
too many times a gun speaks where a human being should . in our history it has been our problem for far too long. Roger has many good things to say . in context , they are good. but, he does not address the issues that cause the strife in the region. I wonder how many people roger has met that have a blue tattoo on their arm that is just numbers. i have. When you lose someone you love, there are only 2 emotions left anger and sadness. Roger has a journey yet. I hope he gets there safely.
He wrote the thing. As an artist,.he is free to do what he feels right for it. This version might miss the classic thing we love, but this take is equally good. It is a much more haunting song now ;)
the guitar is absent from this revisited version, but Dave Kilminster, the lead guitarist on this tour is very good, certainly not at David's level, it's a shame but it's been like that for 30 years...
it's a totally different version, without guitar to make up for David's guitar, but I nevertheless find this version interesting, with a much slower tempo, very different arrangements
So thankful to you, for sharing these precious art works of a legend, Sir R.Waters. for those like me and many lovers of Pink Floyd, that have no chance to participate in any concerts of these honorable men. Again Thanks.✨🌀✨
I saw the Paris concert and I left a different man that day, out of all the events i've been through during my life , nothing can be compared to that day
Omg.....
The voice of that woman!!!
Powerfull
Attending this concert was a dream come true! I feel incredibly lucky to have been there. Words can't express how amazing the experience was. Forever grateful!
In 2003 my father showed to me The Dark Side of The Moon for the first time, and in 2023 i took him and my wife to see this show here in Brazil. That was a dream coming true to me!
Cette version de comfortably numb est sublime. j'étais au pied de la scène le 3 mai à Paris et c'était fabuleux . je revois cette vidéo avec beaucoup d'émotion. Merci pour ce partage
Omg..I love PINK FLOYD!!😘😘 I lost my dad when I was young the only song I listened to was
"Wish you were here" ❤❤❤
Yes! Thank you!
Llore en él concierto a más no poder thanks Roger 🫶🏻
A VERY GOOD ROGER WATERS
Gracias desde Uruguay!!!!
Умение воздействовать на массы людей у Роджера - это талант ! ❤
Я полностью с вами согласен!
Superb........
Bealtiful músic!
saw it at madrid, was lucky to get a 50 euro ticket at the back, really enjoyed it. it hink its the closest i will ever get to seeing pink floyd live.
super chanson de the WALL Roger Walters presque 80 ans, je lui tire mon chapeau il est l'âme des pink floyd👍👍
Thanks for film....Greetings for Pink Floyd's Fans
Real PF fans watch David, Rick and Nick! Just watched Waters butcher Comfortably Numb! Gilmour at Pulse concert nails it!
@@detroitlady7201 -WHY you saw this version, anyway???????? :(
04 de Novembro de 2023..Curitiba..Brasil...eu estarei lá....pela 4° vez curtindo o mega show dessa lenda do rock mundial...vida longa Waters...🤟😬🎼
Vou para a 5ª vez, dessa vez em Curitiba também!
Eu também estarei lá, só que pela primeira vez 🙏🏽🥹 que felicidade dividir o mesmo espaço que esse ícone.
I saw this in Denver 2022, awesome as always!!
Oh, I loved the Intro so much 😂
GRACIAS POR COMPARTIR, ESPERANDO EL.26 DE NOVIEMBRE 2023 AQUI EN CHILE. FALTA MUCHOOOOO
Te va a encantar brother. Yo estuve en este de Paris y fue algo de otro mundo.
Brillant !
You now, all those old guys from the old rock days, are telling us all too relax.
Can we try…..???….❤
Tres Bien. I saw him Birmingham, UK 21.5.23. Same seat position as this. Superb.
I love you guys so much ❤
Roger the greatest man in the world!
Si grande come il suo ego!😂
I have to add....Comfortably Numb IS my favorite some in my over 60 years of being a musician and audiophile. This rendition caused me to write the below comment....this redition LACKS all of the substance of the original, created by ALL of PINK FLOYD....not just Rodger Waters....no matter what HE thinks.
Greetings. Roger Waters ❤️🇭🇳
I saw him last sunday in Antwerp. It was awesome good. Chapeau to Roger. Money Well spent. Greetings Dirk Belgium 😊
OmG Eu estava no Allianz Parque em 11/11/2023
David is in the bar
i respect roger
He still a rocker at heart nothing changed
If I were the moon I'd be cool If I were a ruleI would bend
If I were a good man I'd understand the spaces between friends
Un genioooooo
I saw it in munich
I saw the original wall 1980 concert at Nassau Coliseum.They only did 4 in the world.
Roger waters is a genius
Это грандиозно!!!! Fuck off to the bar! Ты гений, вошедший в энциклопедии при жизни!
A banda que mais amo no mundo.
A distant ship in the horizon
Paryz pozdrawia Kraków!
Muchos saludos the pink floyd the wall buena tarde 👍🐟🎸🎼🎶🎵🎶👉🌛🌹🎼☁️🌦️☁️🌦️☁️🌦️🤟😇🤗🤟👍🐟🌹🎼🎸🤟👌
Hola muchos saludos buen día dulce pequeña mujer oye muy feliz día hoy y siempre dulce pequeña frágil mujer 🤟👍🐟🎸🎶🎵🎶👉🌛🌹🎼🌌🌞☁️☁️🌦️🌦️🤟🤗😇🤟👍🐟🌹🎼🎶🤟👌🎸The pink floyd the wall
Capolavoro
Nobody Does it Quite Same as Roger
Yeah, I would hope David Gilmour doesn't do Comfortably Numb the same as Roger in this
Not a drill any more, i feel to collapse, nod if you can hear
I am producing a retrospective film on Roger Waters.could I please ask permission to maybe use a clip of this video?
Kind regards
Barry
I have a love hate relationship with Roger Waters. I saw "This is not a Drill" three times live in 3 different cities, but I rEAlLY hate his pOLitiCs.
ERETZ ISRAEL!!!!
Yes hear me please
I am sorry folks....I love Pink Floyd for all of their beauty, diversity and harmonic musical prowness. Rodger Waters IS NOT Pink Floyd!!! Rodger is a very ANGRY MAN, who HAS BEEN the majority of his life!!! Music should express the vast gambit of human emotion, not just "ONES" preclusion for all that is wrong with the world. Rodger makes interesting MUSIC, but has LOST the need to present the BEAUTIFUL side of this existance. Where is the BEAUTY of sweeping keyboards, guitars, flutes and harps expressing this beauty and LOVE. If I want to hear a well programed PRERECORDING of mostely ANGER, I am quite content to hear it in the perfection of my home listening room, with the ability to ALSO enjoy the BEAUTIFUL....I don't want to pay over $100 to hear precorded tapes and one mans pervisons....mostly PRERECORDED!!!! COMMON all you SHEEP out there....REQUIRE something BETTER out of HIM!!! He IS capable of doing so, but the POOR GUY has lost all of his EQUALLY talented mates and co-musicians that ARE, or were PINK FLOYD.
The concerts was all great that my sexy babe Roger Waters did
too many times a gun speaks where a human being should . in our history it has been our problem for far too long. Roger has many good things to say . in context , they are good. but, he does not address the issues that cause the strife in the region. I wonder how many people roger has met that have a blue tattoo on their arm that is just numbers. i have. When you lose someone you love, there are only 2 emotions left anger and sadness. Roger has a journey yet. I hope he gets there safely.
senza i solo di David è nulla........!!!!!!
Sono assolutamentedaccordo con te ,non sento la musica positiva ,sento solo i bassi molto cupi
Oh well I'll have a double.
Well just watched Waters butcher Comfortably Numb! What a dark soul he is! Proves Gilmour, Wright and Nick were Pink Floyd!
He wrote the thing. As an artist,.he is free to do what he feels right for it.
This version might miss the classic thing we love, but this take is equally good. It is a much more haunting song now ;)
Darker days call for darker song
@@HM-2011 I totally agree. What a great artist ! ❤❤
Well, it’s not you who has been doing this masterpiece, so leave it to the all of us to decide
TUTTA SCENA, MA NELLA SOSTANZA NON C'E' NULLA!
You must not have real music in your Country .
Предверии 3 мировой?
OROK , CSODALATOS
tellement dégouté d'avoir à le dire, tu n'as plus grand chose à dire Roger ... 😪
do people pay to see this wish version of Jhonny Cash?
Was the lead guitarist away to the toilet. Not on the same level as Dave Gilmoir
the guitar is absent from this revisited version, but Dave Kilminster, the lead guitarist on this tour is very good, certainly not at David's level, it's a shame but it's been like that for 30 years...
Nah, it sounds like surfing on a corps. 40 years
Aargh! Where is Gilmour’s sublime guitar solo??? 😡
it's a totally different version, without guitar to make up for David's guitar, but I nevertheless find this version interesting, with a much slower tempo, very different arrangements
9:20 wtf'? he did lip sync