We own a 2017 CX5, plus a CX9 and an MX5, and I'm a firm believer in the better driving experience Mazda offers. Not the highest tech, but the Zoom-Zoom is still there.
I have the Turbo AWD Carbon Edition . I can afford the extra fuel costs . The Mazda puts a smile on my face everytime I drive it. I'll find almost any excuse to take it out !
I leased a Mazda CX-5 after looking and test driving several cars. After pricing it turned out that I got so much more in the Mazda then I did in a base model of all the other cars I looked at. I was coming out of a Mitsubishi Outlander and decided that driving experience and interior design where more important then space for me this around! So far I love it!!
Do it! I just bought the 21 CX 5 Carbon Turbo w red interior and it is a KILLER vehicle. I've owned a BMW M3 & a BMW X5 and this Mazda is nicer and better built than either of them. Their complaints on the Mazda controls are funny to me. After 2 days with the CX5 I ended up much much MUCH preferring the Mazda's control system over the touch screens. Go check the Carbon Turbo w the red seats... It's BEAUTIFUL, unique, & fun to drive!
Nissan Rogue all the way. Much nicer, more well rounded car. The motor will certainly be followed by some sort of hybrid, which would be my choice. The CVT I don't mind at all, but I live in europe, and we seem to get different versions of the CVTs over here. They actually are awesome. I read a lot about CVT problems in America in the past, but we didn't have those problems over here. And the current CVT is super nice. It feels like a traditional auto, but smoother, much much quicker to react and with much more sophistication when driving off-road, on snow or in the mountains. It pairs perfectly with all wheel drive.
I test drove both for an hour each. No comparison. The Rogue LOOKS great, but the seats are thin and cheap feeling in comparison to the Mazda. The Rogue is just made/feels cheaper, but it does look great (they both do). The Mazda (turbo) driving experience blows the Rogue away as well: Way quicker/faster and much better steering. The Mazda feels like driving a luxury sedan and with the Nissan it just felt bigger. With it, I could tell I was driving an SUV sized vehicle. With the body roll, break feel I felt as if I were dragging the Rogue around the road. The Nissan had some nice interior storage, more rear seat leg room, a bit more (pracrical) cargo room, and a neat glass roof. Other than that, the Mazda was far nicer.
The seats are thin and cheap feeling? Funny that Nissan's Zero-Gravity Seats are thought of quite highly in the automotive industry. And as far at the CVT issues? There are hundreds of thousands of Nissan (and Honda and Toyota) CVT engines on the road. As I mentioned previously, I never had one trans issue with my 2012 Rogue. But that's just me. I would ask that you point to stats that show CVT's fail at a higher rate over standard transmissions. Talking with service people, that does not seem to be the case. But I will defer if you show me. Body roll? "break feel" (sic). What does that even mean? I know nothing about Mazda, but evidently there are lots of fans out there. Good for you. I'll stand by my Rogues. 2012, and now 2021. To each his own, but I have a TON of practical experience. Not an hour.
@@lindab2323 mazdas drive is specially tuned to be more refined than the standard car of its segment. thats where the heart vs brain part of this video comes in. the mazda drives handels breaks and feels better on the road than any toyota rav 4 nissan rouge or honda crv that being said that doesnt make the mazda the best car in this segment just particular catagory. where mazda excells it also lacks. it doesnt sell as much cars as the rest to have more refined robust infotainment systems and redesigns as often. is a nissan rogue a bad car not at all they are great cars its what your looking for that matters. some people want a comfortable ride good tech and a nice design and the rouge delivers on that others will sacrifice some tech for more refined and tuned suspension handeling and whatnot. its a subjective end point and there is no better than the other car its whatever you like best
I just got the Mazda and agree if you don't need a big CUV and want to have some fun it's the one. I wish it had a touchscreen too, but otherwise no real complaints.
I've been driving this extraordinarily beautiful Mazda CX5 with the the 2,2L Diesel for two years now and got 36,2mpg. Perfect engine for this car. But I guess you don't get this engine over there...
@@brianpopelka3165 That's what my car was, former service loaner because they had trouble selling it 🤣. But $10K off msrp and certified works for me. Oh and for mpg I certainly don't get 36 but 29, 30 is reasonable average for me. Bit less now I do local roads.
US emissions standards killed it. But also the normal turbo is tuned with high torque to feel like a diesel. The 2 engines were too similar and nobody could justify spending so much more for the diesel for nearly the same performance.
@@ant208 you could be right. Nissan isn't getting good reviews lately. I don't think any SUV should have a CVT. I would NOt buy the Honda CRV/HRV either. I do own a Honda Ridgeline with the 6 speed. Would like the newer 9-speed. But if you like Nissan, go for it and enjoy. Nissan should have some good deals to sell them.
@@ant208 Before You Reach The 60,000 miles Mark Upon Your Transmission, I Can Only *Suggest* That You *Trade-in* Your Vehicle; Possibly a RAV4 Non-Hybrid 🤔😷
@@stevewierzbicki2495 Brilliant advice Steve unless you can get a extended warranty don't buy the Nissan nobody deserve to torcher yourself and before anyone says anything I know it's spelled wrong but I can't spell it and Google pixel keyboard and voice type is on strike.
I just got my Mazda CX5 Grand Touring Reserve last Friday and it was an easy choice over the Nissan and Toyota options. The fit and finish of the Mazda, although it was the oldest design amongst the 3, were better and more luxurious. I love how it felt on the road as well. I didn't mind that it had the least amount of space in the boot or back seats as I'm a single person.
I’m on my 3rd Nissan and I’m ready to jump to another brand after 5 years. I tested a Mazda CX-5 and loved it over the cx30. I got used to the info knob in seconds on the test drive. It’s either going to be a Mazda or Jeep when the time comes.
So my takeaway is to go with the Rogue if you hate Van Halen and want a numb, boring drive. If you love Van Halen and want to have a little fun while driving go with the CX-5.
That Mazda engine and 6 speed is fabulous in our CX-9. Getting it in the lighter CX-5 is a no-brainer. That engine makes it feel like you've got a big block V-8 under the hood and the transmission is virtually unnoticeable. And no start-stop, at least in the CX-9.
My last Mazda caught 🔥. My last Nissan had a transmission issue. But my biggest issue was the Mazda gave me back problems and cost me dearly at the chiropractor and general health. I have heard Nissan has stepped up their quality on the transmissions. I'd go Nissan...I like my back too much and I won't need a fire extinguisher.
Where did you hear Nissan stepped up the quality of their transmissions? Is it the same place that says Subaru don't have head gaskets issues any more?
@@kevinstarski1598 It was recent but I can't remember exactly. The jist if the article was describing the enroads Nissan had made with the new leadership. Eg. less marketing, more engineering, design and quality. I also own a Subaru Forester 2014, got it new and I just turned 200k miles and no head gasket issues. So I think they have that dialed in as well.
@@stevewierzbicki2495 I recent got a Ford Escape hybrid Titanium for work and love it. I test drove the RAV and found it uncomfortable. The different height of the armrests were annoying.
@@nilsjohansson9739 That is AWESOME 😎, I Completely Forgot about the Escape Hybrid 🙂! Did You get FWD or AWD? My Little Brother is thinking about Buying One.... How many MPG are you Averaging, estimate??
Funny how vast majority of viewers here prefer Mazda, but Rogue still outsells CX-5 without even trying. Looks like there is a difference between youtubers and customers after all...
That's because you can get really aggressive discounts and financing or lease offers on nissan, so yeah. The msrp on rogue is not reflective of it's actual price OTD. Mazda on the other hand, not so much.
I went with the rogue.. it’s not slow lol it’s not a race car, but then I wouldn’t purchase either for that 🤷🏻♀️ CVT has come along way if you look after your vehicle it’s like anything.. you could get a lemon 🍋
Mazda. However I may be biased since I own an 2018 CX-5 and have enjoyed my experience with it so far. The disadvantage to the Mazda is cargo space is small in the class and the infotainment is okay at best and does not offer a huge moonroof. It's also not the most fuel efficient in the class either. However great steering with a somewhat stiffer sporty drive. Plus I love the exterior and interior design, although the front seats aren't amazing.
I'm really enjoying the 2021 Rogue SL AWD premium, very comfortable and the sound system is amazing. I haven't had any issues with the CVT and I also have an Altima and also no CVT issues.
The rouge and cx5 mid level are comparably priced. We rented a rouge over 7 days SV trim and here are our observations: great space overall. Eco mode really saves the fuel. Seats are very conformable. High tech with touch screen, push start with 360 views. Quiet ride with semi smart acc. Not a big fan of Nissan before but this new design did surprised us. The functionality is just there. Lots of small design that make sense and convenient. Like this video, if you are looking for fun to drive, go with cx5, that’s what they sell and what you should get, but everything else just lack a bit (the knob screen control kills the deal these days). If you are looking for a everyday car and sudden acceleration is not your thing or just want to get A to B comfortably, take the rouge and life will be easy and happy. We were looking at cx5 hard and after this trip, rouge got us. The comfy seats plus make sense design (storage) and new tech is the way to go. Last but not least, I do appreciate Mazda, you know what you get, and you know what you are giving up off.
both appeal to a very different customer groups, people who really like driving buy Mazdas, Nissan customers( aside from trucks and Z crowds) buy their cars like they buy appliances, shoes, furniture etc
The Mazda has blind-spot monitoring, cross traffic alert, lane keeping assist, radar adaptive cruise control, automatic pedestrian braking, traffic sign alert, heads up display, front and rear parking sensors, adaptive LED headlights, heated and cooled front seats, heated rear seats, Napa leather interior with Abachi wood trim, heated automatic windshield wipers, and automatic high beams. The handling is very competent. The CX-5 Signature makes my heart happy as I look back at it when I walk away😊
I own a CX-5 and in the few years I have owned it I have never needed any extra power or AWD. I wish Mazda had the more squared back end that would increase cargo space and one has to be very cognizant of the road as Mazda does not have the best views for the driver, the lane departure warning system is nice. My wife has a Honda with the CRV and I am not sure I am a fan. The Rav4 has some issues as well.
I have the ultimate 2020 CX 5 in Soul Red with white leather and turbo. Replaced a 2016 CX 5. Never had a space problem. We love out annual three week road trips and we pack all luggage plus two full sets of golf clubs. .
Maybe it's the quality of the CVT used by Nissan. I know that they make them themselves. My wife had a Murano and never had an issue with it. Traded it in with 130k miles on it.
Just purchased a Mazda C5 touring so far love it, I had a Nissan rogue hated how it drove but like the space but it's just me now don't need all that room.
Gotta love the “Zoom! Zoom!” that’s built into the CX-5 Turbo DNA. I’m in the market to get a SUV end of 2021/beginning 2022. I’m looking for fun to drive, mid-20’s gas mileage and practicality. The CX-5 is on my Top 5. 👍🏼
@@musicman6887 There is a recall on the CX5 2019's automatic transmission and its not just JD. Stop spewing car reviewers paid opinions. Most said Audi and VW was reliable for years in thrir reviews but no data to support it. BTW I won't buy a Nissan with CVT
@@ant208 No No No don't do it ask any mechanic that works on these cars or transmissions don't get a Nissan with a CVT Audi VW just buy the diesels they are very reliable in Europe in the USA I don't know anyone over there so I don't know.
FYI. Mazda does have all the safety tech, lane keep assist, adaptive cruise control that stops and goes during traffic. 👍🏼 360 surround camera is also a plus.
This was one of those very chatty episodes without numbers. No 0-60 comparisons, no 60-70 roll on or quarter mile races. I would've liked to see how the Rogue's AWD system performed on the roller test since previous models underperformed in off road conditions. Not one of your better videos and I've watched many of them. Van Halen forever!
I love both of those recommended CX-5 for fun and reliability. I'd take the Rogue for new styling and lots of new features. Think Nissan improved the CVTs in later years early years wasn't reliable at all + reliability seems be better than average in early 2010s the brand had problems now after Ghosn left Nissan is trying come back as did in the 90s. I love Nissan's, Mazdas, Ford crossovers/pickups my favorites still never thought wanted chose another Rogue but this newer is better than the last generation while makes RAV4 and CR-V boring but CX-5 much more reliable and believe would last longer, Mazda is the most reliable behind Toyota I hope now since Nissan getting back on right track they be behind their cousin, all manufacturers has problems read last night on on some problems with Toyota's and Honda's few Toyota's had exploded sunroofs and Honda had problems with acceleration/electronic problems.
The Mazda is fun to drive but you missed some elements of Rogue's interior that help it stand out. Like pass through and the split open console that allows access from the back. Mazda is driver's vehicle but the new Rogue is leagues better than the old model.
only thing with the new rogues, have your dealership make sure the a/c works properly and doesnt blow in hot air before you take it home, otherwise perfect car. pray for me that they can fix it
I like the looks of the rogue but that transmission scares me. The mazda hasnt changed much. In recent data the Mazda brand has surpassed Nissan in overall quality and reliability. After Nissan ruined Mitsubishi they ruined themselves and it makes me sad. I hope they can recover. Anyways go Mazda for keeping things consistent and not putting unreliable technology in your vehicles.
Rogue all the way lol Mazda is nice and the engine is where it’s at but in a few years i feel the Mazda interior is gonna feel really old compared to the rogues idk🤷🏽♂️
@@neilmurphy845 well if you change the cvt fluid they just keep going, my buddy has a 16 Altima with 335k and he beats the piss out of it and i have family members who have Nissan cvt vehicles well over 200k
Why did you use an SL ROGUE and compare it too a Signature turbo Mazda ? Should have used the platinum especially since that model is 38k and has FAR MORE FEATURES THEN MAZDA... AS CAR REVIEWERS I would expect you to do a FAIR COMPAIRSON.
We just checked out both. Traded in our old rouge. We bought the cx5. Biggest reason Nissan transmissions are garbage. Cx5 rates most reliable. Who cares about tech if your car leaves you stranded
I do like the Nissan Rogue,..the Mazda CX5 is pretty fair too, but the towing capacities are woefully low,..why don't you guys get a Ford Escape that is rated at 3500 pounds towing capacity, and has a turbo charged 2.0 litre engine.
@@chrissimmons9969 On the mark ,there Chris,.. ,it's why I switched from Nissan to other makes,..to get away from the CVT. It might be a smoother transmission,... but the newer 6 , 8 or more speed auto boxes are just about as smooth these days,,..... how smooth do we need it anyway LOL!
I was looking at crossovers a few months ago and test drove the RAV4, CX-5 and Escape all on the same day and the Escape was by far the worst of the three. Not even in the same league.
@@Nikephorus :) I had a feeling that comment would come along soon....! Just as long as you made a choice that you're pleased with, that's all that matters.
Mazda USED to look better than every other car in the segment. Now? Not so much. The suvs are becoming a lot more masculine looking (except for the escape) and having much nicer features standard. I was in the market for one of these a few years ago and really really really wanted the Mazda. It was not only more expensive, but it was always the least well packaged. Went with a forester that was amazing in the snow, and much better than any vehicle I’ve ever owned.
@@kristians2704 everyone on my block has kept cars until they became unusable mostly or cost 2 much money. I drive 100k miles a year. Imagine having 2 pay for turbos every whatever miles? How reliable is the 2.5 turbo anyway? Its not like anyone really knows.
@@occckid123 100k miles a year is crazy and yes for you relibility is very important but the average person that buys a new car will drive for 5-7 years and then get rid of it (90% people) and for those reliability won’t matter. Of course if we are talking about used cars then that is a different stoty
No cvt I have already bad experience to my murano after 65.000 transmission field. Worse thing accelerating engine is crawling. I got cx9 luv I enjoy driving fun n much torque n power.
That Nissan Rouge looks like it has tons of room, which is nice. Too bad it is just not screwed together as well vs. the Mazda. The Jatco CVT is also a major pain point for reliability. But, if I was shopping for an vehicle in this class, I would be looking at the RAV4 or possibly the CRV anyway.
I get that in dash looks better, but from a manufacturing point the tablet style makes it a lot easier to incorporate different screen sizes based on trim level
I test drove both and am actually going to be finally taking home my Platinum trim Rogue today! Much roomier and more spacious for us with 2 car seats; the heated back seats will be great for an additional backseat passenger; the cargo space was a nobrainer with needing to keep a double stroller in the back and still have room for groceries and other items. The platinum trim is exceptional and the moonroof makes the car feel huge and bright!
Rogue all the way. Their ProPilot L2 semi-autonomous driving experience kills Mazda. Mazda difficult to use "must use the stupid knob for anything on the screen tech is asinine. Mazda looks like a fluffy sedan, not a crossover ute. Rogue crushes mazda with creative storage space, touch screens, nearly 3 ft of digital infotainment, fully customizable digital dash, superior sound system, panoramic roof, heads up display in platinum model, two tone paint option, all new styling, go drive one, memory seats with seat slide back on key-off, immersive audio graphics, navigation system that is reactive and immersive, trizone hvac,......... Nothing else compares.
Hands down bought the Rogue Platinum. No comparison for me. I don't feel the need to comment more - those above do the job just fine. Mazda fanboys are just that, I guess
@@tony69rocks I agree the Mazda tech is outdated and not the most user friendly but the driving makes up for it. All tech is outdated in a year but good driving dynamics will always be good.
I just bought a rogue. I recognize the Mazda engine is better but I’m not a fast driver and also working from home 50%. Rogue is more aggressive and different looking, love the interior better. Mazda is certainly a reliable brand though. The Nissan CVT issues are naught for people leasing (like me) if there were to be any issues - it’ll be with whoever buys the used version of my rogue when I bring it back to dealership 😉
Im just little curious and a bit bothered by the walkie talkie radio. haha Could have used bluetooth in the audio? Just my nitpick about this video. But I love it overall! Great content :)
I really like both but Nissan loses me with the engine I don't mind the CVT but I need to tow on occasion about 1800-2000 lbs that's the only reason Ill be buying the Mazda not the Nissan.
Where I live that Nissan does come with a turbo and a manual also 🤔 In my opinion the 2016 model looked the best from the outside, if they put this new interior in the 2016 shell it would be perfect lol
The Rogue really needs more engine options to be competitive. It's growing in size and becoming more and more underpowered. It must be because Nissan wants to make the Murano the one to get if you want a V6. I sell cars and have never had anybody cross shop those two. Rogues aren't a bad buy, but will most definitely feel cheaper in quality when comparing these two.
@@blkbimmer90 yep, the Rogue actually lost about 2-3 inches this year, and got a bump of 11hp, over the outgoing model. So, little as it may be, the new Rogue is more powerful than ever before
Let's just say this anyone that knows about transmission will tell you a cvt is garbage very expensive to work on can't tell how much fluid is in it if there's a leak just not a good idea for the difference in cost to replace not worth it to save a little fuel
We own a 2017 CX5, plus a CX9 and an MX5, and I'm a firm believer in the better driving experience Mazda offers. Not the highest tech, but the Zoom-Zoom is still there.
Purchased a 2020 CX-5 for my wife 8 months ago and I'm a complete convert. I've never owned a vehicle that I enjoyed driving as much as that CX-5.
I bought a 2021 CX5 Carbon w/turbo. MPG sucks, but damn it's fun to drive!
I have the Turbo AWD Carbon Edition . I can afford the extra fuel costs . The Mazda puts a smile on my face everytime I drive it. I'll find almost any excuse to take it out !
I leased a Mazda CX-5 after looking and test driving several cars. After pricing it turned out that I got so much more in the Mazda then I did in a base model of all the other cars I looked at. I was coming out of a Mitsubishi Outlander and decided that driving experience and interior design where more important then space for me this around! So far I love it!!
Every time I see a Mazda CX-5, I think "I should already own one of those by now."
Do it! I just bought the 21 CX 5 Carbon Turbo w red interior and it is a KILLER vehicle. I've owned a BMW M3 & a BMW X5 and this Mazda is nicer and better built than either of them.
Their complaints on the Mazda controls are funny to me. After 2 days with the CX5 I ended up much much MUCH preferring the Mazda's control system over the touch screens.
Go check the Carbon Turbo w the red seats... It's BEAUTIFUL, unique, & fun to drive!
Nissan Rogue all the way. Much nicer, more well rounded car. The motor will certainly be followed by some sort of hybrid, which would be my choice. The CVT I don't mind at all, but I live in europe, and we seem to get different versions of the CVTs over here. They actually are awesome. I read a lot about CVT problems in America in the past, but we didn't have those problems over here. And the current CVT is super nice. It feels like a traditional auto, but smoother, much much quicker to react and with much more sophistication when driving off-road, on snow or in the mountains. It pairs perfectly with all wheel drive.
I had a 2012 Rogue SL that I just traded in Not one issue, CVT or otherwise. Loving my 2021 Platinum.
Purchased a 2020 Mazda CX-5 about 8 months ago and have not regretted that decision at all. Nissan Rogue wasn't even on my radar because of the CVT.
There is no comparison to be had. Easy victory for cx5
The Platinum Edition of the Rogue should have been used for interior comparison, not the SL model.
I test drove both for an hour each. No comparison. The Rogue LOOKS great, but the seats are thin and cheap feeling in comparison to the Mazda. The Rogue is just made/feels cheaper, but it does look great (they both do).
The Mazda (turbo) driving experience blows the Rogue away as well: Way quicker/faster and much better steering. The Mazda feels like driving a luxury sedan and with the Nissan it just felt bigger. With it, I could tell I was driving an SUV sized vehicle. With the body roll, break feel I felt as if I were dragging the Rogue around the road.
The Nissan had some nice interior storage, more rear seat leg room, a bit more (pracrical) cargo room, and a neat glass roof. Other than that, the Mazda was far nicer.
The seats are thin and cheap feeling? Funny that Nissan's Zero-Gravity Seats are thought of quite highly in the automotive industry.
And as far at the CVT issues? There are hundreds of thousands of Nissan (and Honda and Toyota) CVT engines on the road. As I mentioned previously, I never had one trans issue with my 2012 Rogue. But that's just me. I would ask that you point to stats that show CVT's fail at a higher rate over standard transmissions. Talking with service people, that does not seem to be the case. But I will defer if you show me.
Body roll? "break feel" (sic). What does that even mean?
I know nothing about Mazda, but evidently there are lots of fans out there. Good for you. I'll stand by my Rogues. 2012, and now 2021.
To each his own, but I have a TON of practical experience. Not an hour.
@@lindab2323 mazdas drive is specially tuned to be more refined than the standard car of its segment. thats where the heart vs brain part of this video comes in. the mazda drives handels breaks and feels better on the road than any toyota rav 4 nissan rouge or honda crv that being said that doesnt make the mazda the best car in this segment just particular catagory. where mazda excells it also lacks. it doesnt sell as much cars as the rest to have more refined robust infotainment systems and redesigns as often. is a nissan rogue a bad car not at all they are great cars its what your looking for that matters. some people want a comfortable ride good tech and a nice design and the rouge delivers on that others will sacrifice some tech for more refined and tuned suspension handeling and whatnot. its a subjective end point and there is no better than the other car its whatever you like best
@@tonymante8759 You last line says it all. Thanks!!
@@lindab2323 I am looking to upgrade my 2017 so to a 2021! Can’t wait!
I had a friend with a 2014 Rogue who’s CVT failed at. around 70,000 miles. So between the two, I’ll take the Mazda.
Michael Miller 2021 now
@@Tinrs80 Yeah, and?
@@MichaelMiller-rg6or 2021 now
@@Tinrs80 oh, you're a troll. okay.
@@MichaelMiller-rg6or Yep 🍆 biggie meal
I go Mazda
I just got the Mazda and agree if you don't need a big CUV and want to have some fun it's the one. I wish it had a touchscreen too, but otherwise no real complaints.
@@TheAccordingtoyou and no stupid ass cvt
Me too
I have no interest in either car. But, you guys make it very entertaining to watch! 🤣
I've been driving this extraordinarily beautiful Mazda CX5 with the the 2,2L Diesel for two years now and got 36,2mpg. Perfect engine for this car. But I guess you don't get this engine over there...
We had it for 1 model year, 2019. I own that version and I agree it's amazing. Makes it such a different car. And the mpg!! 😁
I got a diesel one as a loaner car for a few days, but I didn't notice a big mpg gain (I still love the diesel tho!)
@@brianpopelka3165 That's what my car was, former service loaner because they had trouble selling it 🤣. But $10K off msrp and certified works for me. Oh and for mpg I certainly don't get 36 but 29, 30 is reasonable average for me. Bit less now I do local roads.
US emissions standards killed it. But also the normal turbo is tuned with high torque to feel like a diesel. The 2 engines were too similar and nobody could justify spending so much more for the diesel for nearly the same performance.
@@TheAdventureAuto definitely agree. Makes a great used car buy though 😁
Mazda, better powertrain, no CVT, nice interior, and better reliability. Rogue is nice looking, but it's a dog with a CVT!
The old Rogue was more reliable than the CX-5 according to JD power 2020 list
@@ant208 you could be right. Nissan isn't getting good reviews lately. I don't think any SUV should have a CVT. I would NOt buy the Honda CRV/HRV either. I do own a Honda Ridgeline with the 6 speed. Would like the newer 9-speed. But if you like Nissan, go for it and enjoy. Nissan should have some good deals to sell them.
@@ant208 Before You Reach The 60,000 miles Mark Upon Your Transmission, I Can Only *Suggest* That You *Trade-in* Your Vehicle; Possibly a RAV4 Non-Hybrid 🤔😷
@@stevewierzbicki2495 Brilliant advice Steve unless you can get a extended warranty don't buy the Nissan nobody deserve to torcher yourself and before anyone says anything I know it's spelled wrong but I can't spell it and Google pixel keyboard and voice type is on strike.
@@rondail5675 actually Nissan is having very good reviews
If Nissan has figured out the CVT thing as far as reliability then I think the Rogue would be the far better choice for a family hauler.
Well we won't know for another 5 years so its best to assume it's still dog shit
and if Ford Explorer had figure out the roloover issuee... really?
I just got my Mazda CX5 Grand Touring Reserve last Friday and it was an easy choice over the Nissan and Toyota options. The fit and finish of the Mazda, although it was the oldest design amongst the 3, were better and more luxurious. I love how it felt on the road as well. I didn't mind that it had the least amount of space in the boot or back seats as I'm a single person.
We just purchased a 2021 CX5 signature love it😁
I’m on my 3rd Nissan and I’m ready to jump to another brand after 5 years. I tested a Mazda CX-5 and loved it over the cx30. I got used to the info knob in seconds on the test drive. It’s either going to be a Mazda or Jeep when the time comes.
There's no comparison. Get the Mazda. You get much more bang for your buck compared to other brands, and everything is designed thoughtfully.
Jeep? Lol
This is not a review, this is just two guys telling you how much they love a CX-5
I went from an Acura TSX (rip) to the CX-5. Thought about another Honda product but really love the Mazda. Especially no CVT.
So my takeaway is to go with the Rogue if you hate Van Halen and want a numb, boring drive. If you love Van Halen and want to have a little fun while driving go with the CX-5.
If you want better technology, equipment, practicality, space, comfort, convenience features and value, Nissan Rogue is a lot better.
@@rafaelg9016 *BUT THE TRANSMISSION SUCKS, After 60,000 miles*
I had a rogue with over 130,000 miles
@@blkbimmer90 I *Trust* My Neighbor and He has been working for Nissan for 14yrs. .
That Mazda engine and 6 speed is fabulous in our CX-9. Getting it in the lighter CX-5 is a no-brainer. That engine makes it feel like you've got a big block V-8 under the hood and the transmission is virtually unnoticeable. And no start-stop, at least in the CX-9.
My last Mazda caught 🔥. My last Nissan had a transmission issue. But my biggest issue was the Mazda gave me back problems and cost me dearly at the chiropractor and general health. I have heard Nissan has stepped up their quality on the transmissions. I'd go Nissan...I like my back too much and I won't need a fire extinguisher.
Where did you hear Nissan stepped up the quality of their transmissions? Is it the same place that says Subaru don't have head gaskets issues any more?
@@kevinstarski1598 It was recent but I can't remember exactly. The jist if the article was describing the enroads Nissan had made with the new leadership. Eg. less marketing, more engineering, design and quality.
I also own a Subaru Forester 2014, got it new and I just turned 200k miles and no head gasket issues. So I think they have that dialed in as well.
I'm gonna Suggest that You Buy a RAV4 Non-Hybrid, Simply for the Reliability. I'm Not Sure about the Hybrid...🤔🙂😷
@@stevewierzbicki2495 I recent got a Ford Escape hybrid Titanium for work and love it. I test drove the RAV and found it uncomfortable. The different height of the armrests were annoying.
@@nilsjohansson9739 That is AWESOME 😎, I Completely Forgot about the Escape Hybrid 🙂! Did You get FWD or AWD? My Little Brother is thinking about Buying One.... How many MPG are you Averaging, estimate??
Mazda design is very cohesive and it'll age gracefully
Tommy's wearing a subzero jacket, where's Nathan's comfortable in a tee lol
The Mazda is a no brainer for me
Rogue I’m ready for a couple of kids Mazda not yet zoom zoom 🏎 good video 👍🏼
Funny how vast majority of viewers here prefer Mazda, but Rogue still outsells CX-5 without even trying. Looks like there is a difference between youtubers and customers after all...
Agreed the Rogue out sell the CX-5 by a huge margin.
That's because you can get really aggressive discounts and financing or lease offers on nissan, so yeah. The msrp on rogue is not reflective of it's actual price OTD. Mazda on the other hand, not so much.
Because Nissan is a king of rentals and Mazda is not....
I went with the rogue.. it’s not slow lol it’s not a race car, but then I wouldn’t purchase either for that 🤷🏻♀️
CVT has come along way if you look after your vehicle it’s like anything.. you could get a lemon 🍋
Mazda. However I may be biased since I own an 2018 CX-5 and have enjoyed my experience with it so far. The disadvantage to the Mazda is cargo space is small in the class and the infotainment is okay at best and does not offer a huge moonroof. It's also not the most fuel efficient in the class either. However great steering with a somewhat stiffer sporty drive. Plus I love the exterior and interior design, although the front seats aren't amazing.
I really want a CX-5 but if the seats aren't comfortable, how can I buy this car? Lol I'm stuck
I'm really enjoying the 2021 Rogue SL AWD premium, very comfortable and the sound system is amazing. I haven't had any issues with the CVT and I also have an Altima and also no CVT issues.
The rouge and cx5 mid level are comparably priced. We rented a rouge over 7 days SV trim and here are our observations: great space overall. Eco mode really saves the fuel. Seats are very conformable. High tech with touch screen, push start with 360 views. Quiet ride with semi smart acc. Not a big fan of Nissan before but this new design did surprised us. The functionality is just there. Lots of small design that make sense and convenient. Like this video, if you are looking for fun to drive, go with cx5, that’s what they sell and what you should get, but everything else just lack a bit (the knob screen control kills the deal these days). If you are looking for a everyday car and sudden acceleration is not your thing or just want to get A to B comfortably, take the rouge and life will be easy and happy. We were looking at cx5 hard and after this trip, rouge got us. The comfy seats plus make sense design (storage) and new tech is the way to go. Last but not least, I do appreciate Mazda, you know what you get, and you know what you are giving up off.
The Rouge looks like somthing from the movie vacation...being a cx5 owner i am bias to the Mazda.
It's truly a exceptional drivers vehicle.
both appeal to a very different customer groups, people who really like driving buy Mazdas, Nissan customers( aside from trucks and Z crowds) buy their cars like they buy appliances, shoes, furniture etc
The Mazda has blind-spot monitoring, cross traffic alert, lane keeping assist, radar adaptive cruise control, automatic pedestrian braking, traffic sign alert, heads up display, front and rear parking sensors, adaptive LED headlights, heated and cooled front seats, heated rear seats, Napa leather interior with Abachi wood trim, heated automatic windshield wipers, and automatic high beams. The handling is very competent. The CX-5 Signature makes my heart happy as I look back at it when I walk away😊
I own a CX-5 and in the few years I have owned it I have never needed any extra power or AWD. I wish Mazda had the more squared back end that would increase cargo space and one has to be very cognizant of the road as Mazda does not have the best views for the driver, the lane departure warning system is nice. My wife has a Honda with the CRV and I am not sure I am a fan. The Rav4 has some issues as well.
A lot of haters taking about the CVT without knowing, newest Nissan CVTs are with a better quality and response.
They're trash. And only the tip of the iceberg for nissan sore spots like paint
Mazda = great daily. Nissan = fleet/rental.
I have the ultimate 2020 CX 5 in Soul Red with white leather and turbo. Replaced a 2016 CX 5. Never had a space problem. We love out annual three week road trips and we pack all luggage plus two full sets of golf clubs.
.
The Nissan makes more sense, more space, more efficient but CVT is a letdown
Why?
@@rubenbraekman4515 because Nissan CVTs breaks down but i didn't experience it don't have a nissan car
@@nuk3fishydude902 oh, just get one with a manual then... my dad has a 2016 one
@@rubenbraekman4515 nissan rogue not offered with manual transmission. At least in the 🇺🇸
@@griffo5 that sucks
Got the CX5 sport 2021 no complaints
How are you enjoying it I’m thinking of buying one.
OH YEAH! I love my 2019 MAZDA CX-5 GT Reserve. SO many features and pretty quick as well, to match that good handling.
People say that they don’t buy Nissan because they use the CVT but they are crazy about Honda and Toyota CVT.
Maybe it's the quality of the CVT used by Nissan. I know that they make them themselves. My wife had a Murano and never had an issue with it. Traded it in with 130k miles on it.
Just purchased a Mazda C5 touring so far love it, I had a Nissan rogue hated how it drove but like the space but it's just me now don't need all that room.
Love the rugged look of the rogue especially in that white the Mazda getting a little bit stale in my opinion
Thanks for touching on the fuel consumption aspect. All too often reviewers completely ignore that part as if in's a non-issue to the average Joe.
Gotta love the “Zoom! Zoom!” that’s built into the CX-5 Turbo DNA. I’m in the market to get a SUV end of 2021/beginning 2022. I’m looking for fun to drive, mid-20’s gas mileage and practicality. The CX-5 is on my Top 5. 👍🏼
Love the new Rogue styling
I'll go Mazda, better looks, better reliability, better build quality, better drivetrain. I'd say it's better everywhere lol
JD power Mazda did not do as well on reliability as Rogue...its not as reliable as you think.
JD power gave awards to the chevy equinox for built quality😂😂. Don’t trust JD power
@@ant208 jd power? Bwahaha
@@musicman6887 There is a recall on the CX5 2019's automatic transmission and its not just JD. Stop spewing car reviewers paid opinions. Most said Audi and VW was reliable for years in thrir reviews but no data to support it. BTW I won't buy a Nissan with CVT
@@ant208 No No No don't do it ask any mechanic that works on these cars or transmissions don't get a Nissan with a CVT Audi VW just buy the diesels they are very reliable in Europe in the USA I don't know anyone over there so I don't know.
9:48 “for my big American Ass” 🤣🤣
excellent review guys! thank you for sharing!
FYI. Mazda does have all the safety tech, lane keep assist, adaptive cruise control that stops and goes during traffic. 👍🏼 360 surround camera is also a plus.
CVT's are the reason i dont buy Subarus anymore. CVT ..Thanks but no thanks.
CVTs are the reason Subaru leasing is up and financing is down. Seriously.
I like the Rogue
This was one of those very chatty episodes without numbers. No 0-60 comparisons, no 60-70 roll on or quarter mile races. I would've liked to see how the Rogue's AWD system performed on the roller test since previous models underperformed in off road conditions. Not one of your better videos and I've watched many of them. Van Halen forever!
Mazda all the way! Maybe I'm partial as an owner.
I love both of those recommended CX-5 for fun and reliability. I'd take the Rogue for new styling and lots of new features. Think Nissan improved the CVTs in later years early years wasn't reliable at all + reliability seems be better than average in early 2010s the brand had problems now after Ghosn left Nissan is trying come back as did in the 90s. I love Nissan's, Mazdas, Ford crossovers/pickups my favorites still never thought wanted chose another Rogue but this newer is better than the last generation while makes RAV4 and CR-V boring but CX-5 much more reliable and believe would last longer, Mazda is the most reliable behind Toyota I hope now since Nissan getting back on right track they be behind their cousin, all manufacturers has problems read last night on on some problems with Toyota's and Honda's few Toyota's had exploded sunroofs and Honda had problems with acceleration/electronic problems.
We love our 2018 rogue ❤️
The Mazda is fun to drive but you missed some elements of Rogue's interior that help it stand out. Like pass through and the split open console that allows access from the back.
Mazda is driver's vehicle but the new Rogue is leagues better than the old model.
We own a 2017 CX5. Love it. But it is kinda small for long road trips. If they bring back the CX7 size with the Turbo, I’d buy one.
Cannot say either I would go after. For long distance comfort ride, Rogue. Sportier, better design, CX-5.
CVT? Mazda please.
No CVTs aloud in my driveway. Plus that Nissan reminds me of the only rental car(Hyundai Tucson) in recent years to ever break down on me. Nope.
only thing with the new rogues, have your dealership make sure the a/c works properly and doesnt blow in hot air before you take it home, otherwise perfect car. pray for me that they can fix it
I like the looks of the rogue but that transmission scares me. The mazda hasnt changed much. In recent data the Mazda brand has surpassed Nissan in overall quality and reliability. After Nissan ruined Mitsubishi they ruined themselves and it makes me sad. I hope they can recover. Anyways go Mazda for keeping things consistent and not putting unreliable technology in your vehicles.
I wouldn't touch the rogue with a 10 foot pole. Those tires will last longer than that cvt transmission.
The 2022 Rogue will get the Hybrid motor that's in the Qashqai.
Rogue all the way lol Mazda is nice and the engine is where it’s at but in a few years i feel the Mazda interior is gonna feel really old compared to the rogues idk🤷🏽♂️
The CVT isn't going to hold up they may have fixed it now but at least the old ones didn't last.
@@neilmurphy845 well if you change the cvt fluid they just keep going, my buddy has a 16 Altima with 335k and he beats the piss out of it and i have family members who have Nissan cvt vehicles well over 200k
@@7g6_66 Oh so Nissan purposely tell you not to change the fluid then like a engine it overheats and eats the belts thank you .
@@neilmurphy845 yea but it’s super important to change the filters as well... most of nissans cvt transmissions have two filters
@@7g6_66 Yah and them there not to expensive to replace.
Why did you use an SL ROGUE and compare it too a Signature turbo Mazda ? Should have used the platinum especially since that model is 38k and has FAR MORE FEATURES THEN MAZDA... AS CAR REVIEWERS I would expect you to do a FAIR COMPAIRSON.
Mazda for sure. Though the only cuv I would buy is the bronco sport.
Imagine spending $38k on a Nissan Rogue and its worth $12k in three years.
Lol so true
Fast track hooptie status.
You right on that, Nissan lose value fast then any car in this class.
@@kromahj idk I Ford Escape or a Chevy Equinox might be worse
@@johnfrantz5885 na, they hold more the rogue . Most people don't want to deal with the CVT after the warranty over
Do a comparison with the Tucson. I am really curious to hear what you guys think @tflnow
We just checked out both. Traded in our old rouge. We bought the cx5. Biggest reason Nissan transmissions are garbage. Cx5 rates most reliable. Who cares about tech if your car leaves you stranded
I do like the Nissan Rogue,..the Mazda CX5 is pretty fair too, but the towing capacities are woefully low,..why don't you guys get a Ford Escape that is rated at 3500 pounds towing capacity,
and has a turbo charged 2.0 litre engine.
I wouldn’t tow with a CVT no matter what they claim for capacity.
@@chrissimmons9969 On the mark ,there Chris,.. ,it's why I switched from Nissan to other makes,..to get away from the CVT. It might be a smoother transmission,... but the newer 6 , 8 or more speed auto boxes are just about as smooth these days,,..... how smooth do we need it anyway LOL!
I was looking at crossovers a few months ago and test drove the RAV4, CX-5 and Escape all on the same day and the Escape was by far the worst of the three. Not even in the same league.
@@Nikephorus :) I had a feeling that comment would come along soon....!
Just as long as you made a choice that you're pleased with, that's all that matters.
@@regsparkes6507 I'm not anti-ford by any means, but the Escape was surprisingly bad.
40 thousand dollars and 181 hp??Hell no. Waste of 40 grand. That's where they all go wrong.
Mazda USED to look better than every other car in the segment. Now? Not so much. The suvs are becoming a lot more masculine looking (except for the escape) and having much nicer features standard.
I was in the market for one of these a few years ago and really really really wanted the Mazda. It was not only more expensive, but it was always the least well packaged.
Went with a forester that was amazing in the snow, and much better than any vehicle I’ve ever owned.
After owning a Subaru Outback with a CVT, I will never buy another vehicle with one.
MSRP for both as they stand would of been nice at the end
Mazda wins already because of reliability.
I love Van Halean his music is very good.
Are the zero gravity seats in the base model, or part of the SL trim?
Smiles Per Gallon over Miles Per Gallon for me!!!
Nissan: Quantity vs Mazda: Quality.
Quality over quantity
I'd get the Mazda that CVT I just don't trust it the qashqai in Europe is very good because I think you can get a manual witch then the cars are even.
Not a big fan of this trend of putting the headlights below the parking/fog lights like the rogue. Looks awkward to me even on the new Silverado 2500
You mean below the turning signal
Rogue, CR-V or RAV-4 for bigger adults often in the back seats. CX-5 for how it drives and reliability. The CX-5 has much better cornering to me.
all cars will be reliable for the first 5-7 years
I would trust the rogue 2 hit 200k miles with its normally aspirated engine compared to the mazda with a turbo engine.
@@occckid123 how many people that buy a new car drive 200k miles? They will probably get a new car anyway by then.
@@kristians2704 everyone on my block has kept cars until they became unusable mostly or cost 2 much money. I drive 100k miles a year. Imagine having 2 pay for turbos every whatever miles? How reliable is the 2.5 turbo anyway? Its not like anyone really knows.
@@occckid123 100k miles a year is crazy and yes for you relibility is very important but the average person that buys a new car will drive for 5-7 years and then get rid of it (90% people) and for those reliability won’t matter. Of course if we are talking about used cars then that is a different stoty
I do care for bhp! That's why I'm buy cx5 turbo as my 2010 crv replacement when my crv is dead.
Regardless of looks....I would never buy a rubberband transmission. Nissan why you continue to beat a shitty horse
I know. I’m glad the other companies are choosing 8-10 speed autos instead of crappy cvts
You know everyone uses cvt’s right?
Not just a Nissan thing
@@TylerRivera635 mostly Subaru and Honda. Not everyone
It is actually metal chain not rubber band...
No cvt I have already bad experience to my murano after 65.000 transmission field. Worse thing accelerating engine is crawling. I got cx9 luv I enjoy driving fun n much torque n power.
I’ll pick the Nissan design over the Mazda anyday it looks more masculine
😧
I thought the same, I got the dark blue with some deep tints looks good
That Nissan Rouge looks like it has tons of room, which is nice. Too bad it is just not screwed together as well vs. the Mazda. The Jatco CVT is also a major pain point for reliability. But, if I was shopping for an vehicle in this class, I would be looking at the RAV4 or possibly the CRV anyway.
Hate those screens that look like a afterthought. Put them in the dash. Why does anyone need or want a sunroof?
I get that in dash looks better, but from a manufacturing point the tablet style makes it a lot easier to incorporate different screen sizes based on trim level
If you shop both of these and take home a Rogue... I have to know why.
(Except for cargo necessity. I get that some people need the space.)
I test drove both and am actually going to be finally taking home my Platinum trim Rogue today! Much roomier and more spacious for us with 2 car seats; the heated back seats will be great for an additional backseat passenger; the cargo space was a nobrainer with needing to keep a double stroller in the back and still have room for groceries and other items. The platinum trim is exceptional and the moonroof makes the car feel huge and bright!
Rogue all the way. Their ProPilot L2 semi-autonomous driving experience kills Mazda. Mazda difficult to use "must use the stupid knob for anything on the screen tech is asinine. Mazda looks like a fluffy sedan, not a crossover ute. Rogue crushes mazda with creative storage space, touch screens, nearly 3 ft of digital infotainment, fully customizable digital dash, superior sound system, panoramic roof, heads up display in platinum model, two tone paint option, all new styling, go drive one, memory seats with seat slide back on key-off, immersive audio graphics, navigation system that is reactive and immersive, trizone hvac,......... Nothing else compares.
Hands down bought the Rogue Platinum. No comparison for me. I don't feel the need to comment more - those above
do the job just fine. Mazda fanboys are just that, I guess
@@tony69rocks I agree the Mazda tech is outdated and not the most user friendly but the driving makes up for it. All tech is outdated in a year but good driving dynamics will always be good.
I just bought a rogue. I recognize the Mazda engine is better but I’m not a fast driver and also working from home 50%. Rogue is more aggressive and different looking, love the interior better. Mazda is certainly a reliable brand though. The Nissan CVT issues are naught for people leasing (like me) if there were to be any issues - it’ll be with whoever buys the used version of my rogue when I bring it back to dealership 😉
Im just little curious and a bit bothered by the walkie talkie radio. haha Could have used bluetooth in the audio? Just my nitpick about this video. But I love it overall! Great content :)
The Rouge is absolutely a better looking car than the Mazda, hands down.
I really like both but Nissan loses me with the engine I don't mind the CVT but I need to tow on occasion about 1800-2000 lbs that's the only reason Ill be buying the Mazda not the Nissan.
Where I live that Nissan does come with a turbo and a manual also 🤔
In my opinion the 2016 model looked the best from the outside, if they put this new interior in the 2016 shell it would be perfect lol
I have no interest if it's not a truck. I watch because it's TFL.
The Rogue really needs more engine options to be competitive. It's growing in size and becoming more and more underpowered. It must be because Nissan wants to make the Murano the one to get if you want a V6. I sell cars and have never had anybody cross shop those two. Rogues aren't a bad buy, but will most definitely feel cheaper in quality when comparing these two.
The rogue actually got smaller
@@blkbimmer90 yep, the Rogue actually lost about 2-3 inches this year, and got a bump of 11hp, over the outgoing model. So, little as it may be, the new Rogue is more powerful than ever before
Mazda all the way. Nissan CVT is a nightmare
Let's just say this anyone that knows about transmission will tell you a cvt is garbage very expensive to work on can't tell how much fluid is in it if there's a leak just not a good idea for the difference in cost to replace not worth it to save a little fuel
Test the 2022 rogue with the vc turbo
The knob is so easy to use and then there’s no fingerprints.