Test Driven - Apple's iPhone 15 FineWoven Case vs Silicon Case vs Clear Case
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2024
- In today's deep dive, we're going re-explore the world of Apple's iPhone 15 cases. Specifically the FineWoven case after I've used it for 7-days. Oddly enough, my goto Apple branded case, the Silicone Case had a big red flag. More in the video!
See what colors Apple has for these cases (via Amazon links):
Apple Silicone Case: mreh.ca/45ePBoX
Apple FineWoven Case: mreh.ca/48ByyjO
*I'm not giving a link for the clear case because it's terrible
In this video:
0:00 Intro
0:14 Apple Silicone Case
2:02 Apple Clear Case
3:17 Apple FineWoven Case
#reviewernotinfluencer #iphone15 #apple
Apple Silicone Case Review:
-Slim and smooth design with a comfortable grip.
-Attracts pocket lint, especially on lighter colors.
-Loose corners raise concerns about face-first drops.
-Questionable fit for the iPhone Pro Max, especially on one side.
Apple Clear Case Review:
-Ultra-slick feel, reminiscent of a wet bar of soap.
-Tight buttons; excessive force can crack the case.
-Magnet for fingerprints and face grease.
-MagSafe accessories struggle to grip, especially on the smooth back.
Apple FineWoven Case Review:
-Initially slick but offers a secure feel when gripped harder.
-Fabric scuffs easily, showing wear after just a week.
-Memory foam under the fabric feels out of place.
-Issues with wear and tear rebound after using MagSafe accessories.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subscribe to stay in the loop! We release 2-3 videos a week so there's going to be something new every week. We're all about helping you get the most out of iOS so click Subscribe!
WEBSITE: www.mobilereviews-eh.ca
T-SHIRTS: mobilereviewseh.spreadshirt.com
PATREON: / mobilereviewseh
INSTAGRAM: / mobilereviewseh
TWITTER: / mobilereviewseh
AARON: / aaron_the_ho
FACEBOOK: / mobilereviewseh - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
I went through this journey myself - got the finewoven case first, sent it back immediately. Got the clear case and used it for a couple days - nearly dropped my brand new phone multiple times its so slick, and it actually hurt my hand because I instinctively gripped the phone much, much tighter to compensate for the dubious grip. Got the midnight silicone case - perfect. I don't even really like silicone cases but this will work fine, and maybe in a year I can get one of those nice third party leather cases like a Bullstrap.
Such a calm dog.
Clear case completely tarnished my iPhone XR’s back glass. I loved having Apple’s leather case on my SE1, but with a lack of Apple leather cases for most non-pro iPhones (and now the loss of leather Apple cases entirely) I learned that a bare iPhone is a much more enjoyable experience than having any of Apple’s cases applied.
Whenever I get my first MagSafe iPhone (likely a 14 Plus), I’ll just get a MagSafe grip accessory instead of a case
I've been using the silicone cases for like 10 years now and honestly they are the best. The only thing that sucks now is that they don't honor the warranty as much as they used to. I got two silicone cases last week and both corners are covered.
Great video! I'm happy with my silicone case, I had the fine woven case for less than 24 hours before I returned it. Silicone case fits it just right and isn't too tacky to where it's constantly pulling my pockets inside out while removing the phone.
been using the clear case since i got my 15 a couple days ago and i like it so far! Mainly want to see the natural titanium color instead of hiding it
i bought it aswell and damn.... i remove it most of the time because it collects dust like crazy and it feels SOOOO SLIPPERY! i love the bare feel of the iphone and i have the feeling that i will drop it with the case.... right now i use the phone how it is supposed to be used.... without case
@@Moosbuckels_sexy_brotherworst idea you could ever have
@@Moosbuckels_sexy_brother used Iphone X for 6 years without a case actually never used a case before but for the first time I went big screen and got 15 plus immediatly told my self I need the best case out there because I will sure drop it one day first of all its slippery and huge to get hold of
I think the clear case looks really cool and really digging the smooth buttery feel of it in hands. The plastic cracking tho, now thats not nice.
I dont hate it but it does feel a bit slick. Way overpriced for what it is but its not as bad as he said in the video.
I agree, I returned mine because of the cracking noise.
I’ve used Apple’s clear cases for years. Never had any issue with it cracking at all - except when I dropped it on concrete. No idea what this guy is doing with his…
Which is better clear case or silicone ?
Your video saved me from making a 60$ mistake! Thank you
If you’re looking for leather alternatives specifically, both Moft and Cyrill seem higher quality at a cheaper price with their vegan leather options. I can vouch for Cyrill since it’s the case I use.
If you want good actual leather then the amount of options out there is insane. Many higher quality than any leather case Apple has put out. At this point I would stop bothering with official Apple cases.
@@terribletimes902how was the weight？
I like these videos where you say why something is bad. Good to have these along with the top case videos.
Would love to see a screen protector comparison for iPhone 15 pro max
FWIW, I love my Torras screen protector - it has a border that goes pretty much all the way to the edge and has a black rim around it so you can't really see that it's there. I hate screen protectors that have a hard edge I swipe against every time I do anything in iOS.
Get Flolab screen protector. You won’t regret it since it has matte, glossy, and tinted finishes as choices.
I bought an ESR branded clear soft case for £8. My phone hasn’t arrived yet but the case feels excellent to hold. There are tiny micro dots lining the inside and the corners have extra protection. As the phone hasn’t arrived yet, the real test is yet to happen but given the price point I am impressed. It’s also non slip with good grip and ESR claim that it is shock proof to military grade standards.
I am a fan of Spigen Clear Cases - however, the "bumper" or frame part of the case does peel away from the the back plastic flat backing and it does yellow, but in terms of showing off a cool colour like gold, it does an ok job, but mainly it provides for the me the best grip and protection from falls. The edge sticks up higher than the glass so it 360 protection for me. To each their own.
Weirdly enough I had the alignment issue with this Apple silicone case on my 15 pro max but when I took it out and put it in top to bottom the problem went away & fit perfectly even with a spigen screen protector. So far after a week no issues other than the few filling fibres that may sometimes stick to the case.
When I had the XSMAX Apple case it started losing the silicone on the bottom corners as the design was poorly made. They had the bottom exposed but covered the rest of the phone.
I bought an Apple silicon case for my 15 Pro Max and it fits perfectly! I actually already dropped it on it's screen from about 3 feet up onto hard tile and it survived! I'm really liking it so far.
Oh c'mon Aaron, that is how your woven case really looks after a week? I've been taking mine in and out of jeans pockets and using magsafe continuously for stands and mounts and charging, and there is not a mark on mine. It has the small ring starting to form the same way the ring formed on the leather case (I've always used leather cases and wish they were never discontinued). Other than the ring it's like new. What are you doing to your phone to get those marks on there?
Ordered grips through your links based on your recommendation on your last video. Thank you!
Monty looks great with that tie!
Thank your for your reviews
The Spigen’s clear case is pretty good amazing magnet strength too
I love the feel of the finewoven
Great review. What is your take on otterbox lumen clear case? Does it offer good protection?
Cheers
Great video. I have had the fine woven case for a week with no issues so far. But also pretty gentle and no big drops or issues.
I got the silicone case for the iPhone when I had a 12 mini, and I had a great finish just like you talked about, but eventually the outer layer rubbed off, and you end up with the very sticky silicone after a month or two, and I had to stop using it completely, because it was hard to even get out of my pocket.
I was crouched down in Best Buy trying to decide between silicone and clear. Glad I went with silicone after watching this video.
I know the silicone gets a lot of hate, but I really like it. I love the texture and simplicity.
Great video… tbh I love your dog and his shirt and tie. 😂 I’m a subscriber now 😊
So glad I saw this before buying a case for my iPhone, Thanks! 👍🏻
What do you think of clear case ?
@@hocineted7594bad
Another great video & your dog Monty is a legend 👏👍
Hi, I have an Orange Sorbet silicone case for 15 Pro Max and the corners are fine, with none of the screen protruding and it’s a good tight fit. I also have a fine woven wallet in Mulberry and so far, so good, but I do look after my stuff. As this is my first MagSafe phone, I did buy 3 😳 x apple leather wallets (forest green, dark cherry and umber) from a reseller before they sold out, because I do prefer the leather to the fine woven and I wanted future use options. I’m tempted to try a fine woven case, but my go to for out and about days, so for when taking photos and for selling at farmer’s markets is a mous limitless 5.0, with additional strap in the new Forest Green colour.
I love the Newton gauge push test, thanks.
Fantastic review
I picked up the Cypress Silicone case at launch, no tapping of the screen on mine. It actually feels more snug than the 14 Pro case did -- to remove it, I have to push pretty hard on the camera array to get it out.
My only gripe with the silicone case is ,every one I’ve owned ended up having chips on the rim of the case…exposing the plastic inner shell. Otherwise,it’s one of apples best case!
Great revisted fair review. 👍🏻
Thank you! Hi Monty! 🐾
Any chance that the base model iPhone 15 “Fine Woven” case would also fit on the iPhone 14?? 👀
Thank you for the Fine Woven Case review, because I was gonna get that case and your video really helped on changing my decision! Instead, I got the Clay Silicone Case for 15 Pro Max, the case is thin but it does look nice and the MagSafe works well too... so I just bought a lanyard, cause I'm really scared of dropping this gorgeous Natural Titanium lol
Monty is so obsessed with his dad haha
So adorable
Can you make a video about the top 5 silicone cases with MagSafe?
Received my Keyway leather case for the 15PM and WOW! Hands down my favorite leather case to date. Beats Nomad and Bullstrap for comfort, grip, color and button firmness (to me that matters a TON!) Maybe do an updated review of Keyway? I always look to your videos for buying knowledge because we have the same taste, but I could only find one short of your write up on this brand.
Nothing wrong with the Apple clear case. I’ve used them for years and have never thought they were that slippery after some use. I just want a clear case with smooth sides and no raised edges.
Yeah, they are absolutely fine - really not especially slippy or greasy at all. The raised edges are there to protect the screen.
Which is better clear case or silicone ?
I have a Cypress green silicone case for the 15 Pro and it sits in the case just fine in all corners.
I also have an ESR clear case which is way better than the Apple version and has nice super-strong magnets.
I have the ESR MagSafe clear case as well as a coupe of their MagSafe chargers. Absolute perfection.
Does the microfiber lining extend to the sides of the ESR cloud case?
And my ear case only cost me $17 dollars and the magnetic strength is amazing and too boot it fits tight on my phone unbelievable for $17.00 wow
How is that casetify lineup video going? I’d love to see the comparison of the models!
Me too love casetify cases and want to order one but hanging off till I see Aaron’s review
I have the Apple Clear case - absolutely nothing wrong with it.. best of the 3 you featured!
Which is better clear case or silicone ?
@@hocineted7594 Clear
Could you do a video on the Woodcessories cases (especially the bio case) pls? It looks interesting from a sustainability angle but I'd like to know whether it's a good case in general.
My silicone case is fine on all corners with a screen protector. Seems to have just a bit of lip for drop protection and loving the precision cutouts for the speakers.
omg this dog is so cute!!!
I strongly prefer cases with an open bottom. It makes swiping up from the bottom smoother and helps usb-c cables and accessories stay put.
How much does it disperse energy on a fall would be far more interesting. I think the clear case might have an edge on absorbing damage since i’ve seen those break, while I don’t know if finewoven will pass that energy straight to the phone (like my previous leather one did)
good vid. now I don’t have to worry about trying the woven case! i made the right decision yellow silicone! cheers
I’ve always had the clear cases since 11PM. Now I’m using it on my 15 Pro Max.
I bought the Spigen clear magsafe case for my iPhone 15 Pro Max. Seems grippy enough for me!
the same here I have spigen clear case too much better then apple one
Agree sadly. I bought the clear case with my iPhone 15 and while it looks fine, it's so slippery. Buttons are bad. $75 in Australia for a case I've replaced with a $10 knock off until I get a proper one I like. At least the knock off doesn't slip right out my hand. Shame. Also I'd like to use your links but need one that works in Australia. Can you do that?
I have the clear case for the 14 pro max and I love it.
My fine woven taupe looks great after … well since the 22nd. I’ve washed it once and despite all its cons I’d pick it any day to the silicone case purely for how it feels in the hand.
Oh and fw is thinner than the silicone case. I know a lot of people don’t mind thick ass borders around their screens coz it “gives them protection” but I kinda like my case complementing my phone rather than turning it into a brick
Great video :)
Which clear case do you suggest that does not yellow, minimalist & thin and offers basic/good protection?
Dbrand ghost case or sth
I truly appreciate your scientific approach to testing. You really back things up instead of just speaking from your ass and I appreciate it!
i need to see a droptest with the FineWoven case
Fine woven case user for 8 days no blemishes looks great still and the MagSafe wallet to match looks good on the phone so far so good
My iPhone 15 Pro Max Apple silicone case does not have any tapping, corners are great. Since I originally pre-ordered a 15 Pro and pre-ordered an otterbox, the Apple silicone case was an unplanned, blind purchase. Better than I thought it was going to be, but I have an otterbox coming since this is my first large iPhone and this thing is a big piece of glass.
Decided to hold on to my 14 pro max leather case and put it on the slightly narrower 15 PM
Hey, could you please do a video on the ‘softest iphone cases’ for those of us that want the feel but aren’t too bothered about the protection necessarily (since you have so many cases)!! Thanksss
Do u think the pro max is worth the extra $500 in Canada over the plus?
What's the weight difference if i may ask between these 3 cases?
The Apple pink silicone case for my 13 Pro Max has the same issue with the upper left corner.
Can you make the same Video with the new Nomad cases? comparing leather and sport
Thank you !!
Just tested my grey 15pro case, screen doesn’t stick out but you made me check.
I do find that they are a little lint magnety for a couple weeks but once they get broken in they don’t seem to attract lint anymore.
You need to review the new green and blue Mous limitless. They have this nylon material on the back that’s so good and shows zero fingerprints. Best case I’ve ever owned
When is the cables’ review coming out?
Well I liked the clear case better when I had a gold iPhone 13 pro. Current colors are dull. For the record I still like the clear case. Mine is really tight on the phone, screen never hits, buttons work great, Open bottom make the speakers and microphone work better and at least you don't have to worry about the USB cable fitting unlike the off center finewoven. I liked the leather cases. Waiting on my Bullstrap case
Curious what wallet you use on the regular with the Mous case. I got a Mous case off your recommendation and have an ESR wallet and a Distil Union one and both feel just a tad loose on the case. They felt far more secure on and Apple brand case. Is it just the magnets in the Mous are weaker?
Could be or could be just the texture some MagSafe accessories just work better with different textures
Have you reviewed the new Moft accessories? The Snap Float Folio for iPads (2023) and the Snap Phone Tripod Stand ? Would love to get your unbiased opinion on it!
Are we not going to talk about the fact that the dog was starring at him the whole video💀
The bottomless rim on the clear case is great for using the swipe gesture at the bottom of the iPhone. I like it shows the color and although it’s greasy and slipperly indeed, it good enough for my use case.
CAN YOU MAKE A REVIEW ON THE TORRAS UPRO CASE PLS?!
Such a sweet dog 😍
I really like fine woven cases, I purchased two. The feel in the hands sold me and so far they're holding up well.
Do you still like them?
@@abbakus_ I still like mine. I used 1tsp of liquid detergent and diluted it in a cup of water to clean it. Looks brand new again. It also got rid of the magsafe charger ring.
No idea what all of the fuss is. People are really upset that the leather case is gone even though it was never that good to begin with. Third party is the way to go for leather imo.
Just got the black fine woven for the regular 15 in black, I absolutely love it. Not sure why all the hate I’ve been reading about
best reviewer out there
can you pls review the bitmolab case that has the extra action button pls
I got a leather case with the same issue that you mention, camera side screen edge is parallel to the case. I thought because of too hard for the case cause my phone bending. (Too much complaint about 15 series titanium too soft when accidentally bend it)After saw you video the realise case could be problem even after installed to the phone 🙏🏻🙏🏻
What about the new pop socket cases
I have clear case. I already dropped it on concrete and it protected good. 👍 Case got a corner scratch worth it in my opinion it feels like strongest one. It is slippery tho and doesnt work good with magsafe but for protection I think its good
Since the new pro max has such fragile glass, will you be testing rear protectors by chance? Even with a case, the glass can break. Its something nobody talks about. I bought one for my bosses 14+ hoping it would help, rhinoshield.
I really don't think its significantly more fragile with a case. The main advantage of the 14 design was that the frame and glass were level, so the frame takes much of the shock. The slight curve on the 15 does mean the glass will take direct hits on specific drops, but in a case this is negligible imo. And the backglass can be replaced more easily.
I hope not but it is expensive and a hassle to replace so better safe than sorry if possible!@@eddieliang16
Is that phone the natural titanium or white?
I wish I had seen your video earlier and saved myself a $ 60 and woe! Totally agree with your review, it’s bang on! Thank you for putting it out there! Huge fan of Apple products but disappointed with this “fine woven“ contraption ☹️
I’ve come to realize textured cases offer little to no finger print smudges as well as better overall grip, even matte finish clear cases are good option
I'd love to see a video of the best (super)slim cases such as TORRAS Magnetic Slim Fit
Please review Vaja leather case. It’s expensive though
I got the clay silicon case for my 15 pro max (only to use until my mujjo leather one arrives). The only thing I like is the colour on my natural coloured phone. Other than that it’s too slippery and too much of a dust magnet
Reg the clear case: I use it, the good thing is that it never yellows (main concern for me) it looks same as new even after 1.5 years of use! Reg slippery issue: it's strange because when out the case sticks to my hand and is just slippery when at home, it's magical I would say since it's reacting to the outside moisture. So I really like clear case 😊
Which is better clear or silicone ?
Can you review the mag safe grip features in this video. Not the pop socket one. I believe the other one is called chubby 3 in 1. Want your honest opinion on it since it didn’t make the top 10 of mag safe grips
I have the fine woven in black for a week now. I cable charge. Don’t do MagSafe. My case looks as it did the day I bought it and am very happy with it, though I was skeptical at first.
This case is objectively bad value no matter how people try to defend it. “Product looks as it did a week ago” is about the lowest bar anyone can have. My $8 Amazon clear case also looks as it did more than a week ago. These woven cases also dont patina, they will look like ass in a few months soaking up some grease.
I’ve returned mine. It was not bad but I could not stand its very slippery edges. I now have silicon case and it has much more grip.
Can anyone tell me if there’s a benefit to using an Apple MagSafe case vs a third party like Caudabe when it relates to wireless charging speed? I know there’s a difference between “Made for MagSafe” and “MagSafe Compatible” but I wasn’t sure if there was a benefit with the case itself.
What Apple Watch band are you wearing?
Do any of these cases leave marks on the titanium edge?
Nope.
Your best choice mous case after few month on usage has some imperfections near volume buttons case frame is not straight anymore, the only downside of that case
Honestly I would like to hear more from Monte he seems more chill
Pls review the pitaka case!
The one thing that really sealed it for me against the finewoven case was seeing them in the Apple Store just a few days after release. Totally scuffed and did not look good at all.
It seems microfiber lining on the inside has been added to offer protection when dropped on the backside of the iPhone. Do you agree?
Clear case heats up my 14 pro like crazy