►Follow us on Instagram @autogefuehl and @thomas.letsgo ►Subscribe here: th-cam.com/users/autogefuehl ►Compare the Mercedes GLE: th-cam.com/video/-J8A-gsd6eI/w-d-xo.html ►Compare the Mercedes GLC: th-cam.com/video/AHzgckHPjzE/w-d-xo.html 00:00 BMW X3 vs BMW X5 ! 01:01 Length and design comparison 01:51 Sound, rear and technology 03:05 Interior and seats BMW X3 04:46 User interface X3 06:20 Infotainment system OS7 06:54 Digital instruments M40i 07:13 Interior and seats BMW X5 08:27 User interface X5 09:15 Infotainment system and instruments X5 09:30 Rear seats comparison X3 vs X5 09:53 Trunk / boot comparison 12:15 Exhaust and engine check 13:16 BMW X5 40i Autobahn acceleration 14:45 Air suspension vs adaptive suspension 16:05 User interface while driving 16:25 Driving difference X5 vs X3 17:36 Fuel economy / consumption X5 40i R6 vs M50i V8 18:17 More high speed motorway driving 20:00 Agile driving X5 21:27 Driving part BMW X3 with acceleration 22:15 Faster and sportier than the X5? 24:50 Difference X3 and X1 25:18 X3 and X5 with same engine today 26:12 Assistance systems and user interface 26:58 More high speed motorway driving X3 M40i 28:07 German Laufkultur 29:18 BMW X3 vs Mercedes GLC vs Audi Q5 comment 30:09 Agile driving with the X3 M40i 31:13 Driving comparison X3 vs X5 32:28 Conclusion: Which one will I take home? #BMW #BMWX5 #BMWX3 Transparency note: Autogefühl videos are independent and free from editorial influence on opinion and rating. But since manufacturers enable us to do the reviews in the first place, for legal reasons this video is marked as _advertisement_.
please do BMW X4 m40i vs BMW X6 comparison REVIEW please do BMW X4 m40i vs BMW X6 comparison REVIEW please do BMW X4 m40i vs BMW X6 comparison REVIEW please do BMW X4 m40i vs BMW X6 comparison REVIEW please do BMW X4 m40i vs BMW X6 comparison REVIEW
In my 55 years driving history, I have owned an X5 3.0d auto for the last 20 years, and just passed 150k miles. Despite it's outdated 5 speed GM gearbox, it's been my most enjoyable and rewarding motoring experience, even compared with a 1972 Lotus in my younger days. The X5's blend of comfort, practicality and performance is second to none, and I'm just hoping the wife will let me buy a replacement very shortly before I'm too old, 'cause frankly no other SUV cuts the mustard like a 3l X5.
Hey I concur to that - especially the facelift version with stage1 modding, that diesel is like a rocket tank. Never had so much fun with any other car... except e39 3.0D with the same configuration :D One major drawback though is that those cars rust sooner than their running capacity wears off (if properly maintained). Those doors accumulate water and eventually you have to either replace or bore a hole in them and repaint, which translated to extra care and effort. Other than that e53 & e39 in carbon black look visually stunning even today. Very gracefully cars.
Update: I took notice of all your comments & advice, thanks. A new X3 40i is expected at month end, having realised the growth in size over the past 20 yrs, and wife is happy too!
I was searching for comparison of these two models and found your video, what a gem! Never seen anyone who made such a good scientific comparison video. I'm totally satisfied and will be at a dealership with some knowledge 😃
Excellent comparison - Really needed. Nobody is doing such comparisons between cars from different segments. Please do a similar 3 series vs 5 series comparison as well!! Highly interested to know if the sophistication of the 5 wins vs the agility of the 3 - kind of a similar situation in the X3 vs X5 dilemma :)
I had this doubts in 2019. My heart was telling me X5 but my head the X3. You’ve put things perfectly, as usual, Thomas. The X5 is a bit more sophisticated, mostly on certain details like softer leather, better seats or certain optional extras. But for a daily use the X3 has better driving since feels more lighter, is easier to park and the price difference didn’t seem justifiably to me. That said, I hope someday I can afford to move up towards the next X5 gen.
I currently own an older X5 which is in the shop; I have a 2021 X3 as a loaner. I find the X3 with the 4 cylinder is plenty fast and significantly lighter and hence more nimble than the X5. I thought the 4 cylinder might be too loud at idle, but from inside, you can't even tell it's running when at a stop. Main downside is that the X3 seats seem a bit too narrow for my taste.
@@Niles-Guy Ever owned one? I've owned 8 and they've all been very reliable. Like all cars, they require maintenance and sometimes things break. My car was in for an air bag recall, not because it broke. BMWs are expensive to maintain, I will admit because parts are expensive, come from Germany and are in many cases, over-engineered.
I own the newer x5 45e plugin. I’m telling you please drive that before you make any assumptions sheesh it’s just so good at so many modes. It’s SOOOOOOOOOOO much smoother and quieter.
@@LafemmebearMusic it’s a fact that bmw breakdown consistently. Every owner I’ve known has stated this. Even mechanics have warned stay away from bmw or Landrover . And as for your new phev…congrats but that too will end up breaking down especially after warranty
My 4th BMW will again be an X3 Sport. I moved from my beloved X3 to the X5 to drive grandchildren around (yes, laugh aloud, 78 year are old German grandma here), but soon missed the agility and simple “Fahrvergnügen“ with my boring X5. Now I’m returning to the 2023 X3 (currently on the ocean). I’m very excited. BTW, to those denigrating BMW reliability, I say baloney. Maintained my BMW’s well and never, ever had a problem over the many years (since 2006). Used to drive VW before that, no comparison. I can’t think of driving any other make (spoken as a born Münchener Kindl and somewhat prejudiced).
Love your comment, "Listen & Repeat"..that took me back to my high school German classes when my instructor also said "listen and repeat"..."hören und wiederholen Sie". I really appreciate this X3 & X5 comparison. Particularly interesting was your conclusion that rear seat passenger space between the two is nearly identical. Both are "possibilities" to replace our aging Volvo V60 Cross Country. I also viewed your x5 45e review...and to me, if ONLY a x3 plug in hybrid was available here in the U.S....that might be the perfect fit for us as here in the Midwest US, it's a bit too soon for a full EV due to minimal available charging infrastructure. Thank you Thomas.
I own a X3 30i 2020 and I rented a X5 30d 2020 for a week so both Gxx pre LCI I think X3 is the clear winner to me: - more agile - faster (the X5 above 200kmh is a pain…) - easier to sit in, you climb onto the X5, you sit in the X3, seat is exactly at the height of my bottom - rear seats: there are the same width !!! I measured it in case I wanted to set 3 child seats (i have 2 kids), Basically the second row external is further from the door in the X5. - Trunk: the X5 is a pain, I hated this tail gate. Thomas is 1m86, I am only 1m80, couldn’t reach the front end of the trunk. And guess where things end up after driving/breaking … :D for a family, X5 brings zero benefit for a large/tall driver, yeah, driver will be more comfy in the X5
Genuinely great video looking at the true differences and similarities between these units. You were not just a talking BMW brochure which many reviewers seem to be
Great review Thomas. I have been watching your channel for a couple of years now and have been waiting for this comparison. I owned a 2018 X5 M50d, great car, lots of power but nightmare to park in many places due to the size. When I changed this year I looked at a new X5 but as the newer model was even longer and wider I opted for the X3 30d MSport instead. The X3 is not much smaller inside the car, there is more than enough power, the tech is great and I feel it drives more like a car than the X5 so I can be more aggressive around the corners than I was with the X5. Parking and narrow country roads are way better with the X3 as well. After 3 months I am very happy with the X3 and don’t miss the X5 at all.
Thanks, I needed to read this. My wife has just been told she can have an X5 company vehicle and she is not confident at parking. I will advise her to opt for the X3.
I just got my BMW3 2023. Never had a luxury car and it rides like a dream. So comfortable too. I just love it. Question. Premium gas recommended. I read so many conflicting comments of which gas to use. Recommended vs required????
Great review! Personally I prefer X5 - It’s more elegant, brutal and comfortable! One more thing - X3 fits more to younger people and woman’s , but X5 - for gentlemen’s from 40..
Another great video. Great comparison and super useful to compare different models within the same brand! I've watched this channel for a long time, hugely underrated: consistently delivers quality content
What a way to start a review. "Does size really matter" really had me laughing😂 Great review as always Thomas and I'd personally take the X5 but with the M sport package🔥
I have owned many BMW models starting with a BMW 1600, which made me a BMW man for ever, after 3 x 5 series’s tourer’s & 2 x 3 series sot tops i now have a x3 M sport suv 🙀just great plenty big enough for golf clubs & a wonderful drive thanks for your comparison really enjoyed it, i made the right choice there is a smile on my face when ever i drive 😀
I owned a X3 but now have an older X5 there is no comparison. By far the X5 is better vehicle. X5 is a muscle car that handles and hugs the road. It’s a strong build whereas the X3 felt very thin and a little too light for my taste. As well the X3 didn’t perform well here in Chicago with the winter months. It’s definitely a X5 as the winner.
I like the front face of the G01 X3. Understated and the kidneys aren't obnoxiously large. But, given the fact that I needed space for my family, I ended up with the X5 (although E70 40d. The width does definitely count in the X5's favour, but it makes it an absolute pain to park in tight multi storey car parks.
I bought 2022 x3 xdrive msport 3.0, gas mileage was very important, and have had my m240i convertible, the power wasn't a big factor in my choice, only one disappointment, no adaptive cruise control for the price
Thank you Thomas. This is the comparative video I have been waiting for years. I will get both if I have the money. If not, I will get the X5 because it is the all round winner.
So far I have only watched 2 of your videos and have found them very informative and captivating. (Of course I subscribed.). I like the ride on the autobahn when you are driving 125 mph and driving through the tunnels where you can see the ambient lighting in daylight. Very well done. You are becoming my go to resource for Mercedes and BMW. Thank you very much!
I have a 2022 X3 M40d and 2021 X1 2.0i X-Drive and have owned 3.0d M-Sport X5’s in the past. I agree with others that the X5 has a wider, more comfortable and sophisticated cabin and with air suspension a better ride. The X3 in comparison is a far more sportier SUV, with a cabin to match, more so with the optional ‘M’ seats which are an extra cost option in the U.K. but are extremely comfortable and worth that extra cost IMO. Practicality between both models is hardly noticeable, with both accommodating 5 adults comfortably. For me it came down to price. The X3 does everything the X5 does but the X5 is a more cosseting and comfortable environment and cabin to be in, is that comfort worthy of the premium cost over a X3?……you decide.
I like them both but I prefer the X5’s looks and profile. I can’t fit comfortably in the M40i and it’s too small inside but quality on both is first rate. I need the extra room on cargo area and I have dogs. But the ‘23 X5 doesn’t have that amazing B85 w/hybrid power. Why not? The M40i’s engine makes it feel like a sports car. Good comparison. 👍
I have test drive them both for a day, the X5 feels much more premium! Cabin difference is much bigger than is mentioned in this video. X5 had far more better seats and everything feels like a big luxury SUV Also chassis and Technology wise the difference is very big, X5 has al Aluminium dual whishbone suspension, even the subframe is Aluminium.
@@willemb8689 I think I don't wanna drive a huge car that handles like a minivan. I don't wanna be in a car that is too anemic when it comes to handling and acceleration. On the other hand after driving 2020 4 cylinder X3 I was impressed with the technology, with screens and to some extent the engine. Some people say that BMW intentionally "downplays" their Horsepower numbers so that X3 was pretty fast. However if a much larger X5 has the same acceleration I would not wanna buy it
The six cylinder diesels are the engines to go for with shocking levels of torque, a better drive, 60's mpg and the highest resale values. BMW's best kept secrets. You will not be disappointed !
X-3 looks better in appearance. For the price, the X-3 is a better buy! The $10,000 difference made my mind up on purchasing the X-3 plus better MPG and I haven't regretted it! The X-3 2022 model is redesigned and different from the earlier X-3 so no comparison there.
Great review! You really feel the difference getting out of the X5 and getting into the X3. The X5 cabin feels much bigger. I had the X5 40e without rear wheel steer and my current X5 45e with rear wheel steer. I would recommend that option. All though it is pricy, the difference in agility and manouvering round in the parkin lot is like two worlds. But then I would say that the 45e is a huge step up in every way over the 40e. Huge difference.
BMW have mastered the art of making cars not look and feel big or small. My X3 seemed big until someone pointed how a Subaru was bigger. My X5 seemed small until I had an X4 for a few years.
X5 is by far the better car. I love the M40i, but the interior appointments of the X3 are a complete let down. The X5 X drive 40i fully loaded is the best option. Now that is 15 to 20K more than the X3.
We went with the X3 M40i in May 2024 because we would need to step up to the X5 M60i to get the M Sport Differential. Also the I6 should be more balanced than the the V8. The X5 should be more plushed and comfortable but the X3 does just fine.
I know , BMW should make a crew cab, extended cab or single versions, 4x2 or 4x4 pick up trucks with a hood scoop option, lifted with high ground clear stock , and a short 6' box or long box 8' truck bed. Then offer a V6 straight six turbo charged all the way to a large V8 or V8 turbo diesel dually!!! Ohh with descent fender flares and all terrain tires. With classic modern BMW front end design. Maybe even a dually diesel version for heavy towing. With all the bells, whistles, and lights!
Amazing review as always Thomas! I have a 2021 X5 and love it, it’s my second one in a row. A quick note, the X5 does have seat releases in the cargo area, they were right by your hand next to the X logo on the side of the cargo area ;-) no need to reach forward to lower the back seats.
Maybe for those who haul a trailer with a lot of weight a Double dually crew cab V10 twin turbo diesel with all wheel drive or V8 turbo,10'-12' long box truck bed , goose neck and standard trailer tow hitches and all the bells, whistles, and lights!!!😁 I know it would be called the BMW series x 10 HDT(heavy duty truck) maybe and the lighter trucks the series x 8-9 LT (light tuck). Of coarse with a tilt forward front end like the Peterbilt semi trucks for easier accessibility for maintenance with locking hood release latches!
X5 sucks without rear seats reclining, on other side X3 is so good with reclining rear seats for families with kids and relaxing on long trip. Power is most same.
My own personal view on BMW and Mercedes is that the lightly optioned versions lack some of the features you would expect to find at the price point, especially if you compare it to similar Asian luxury cars (though I realize German luxury cars are in a different league in terms of driving). If it’s me, I’ll pay the extra $10k and option up. If that leads you to the X3, great - as long as you don’t need the extra room. I did, and went with the heavily optioned X5 40i.
our bmw x3 got the manual seat adjustments. i taught electric adjustment seats were standard on the facelift. also they didnt put the harman kardon on our car
I don't know why but the X5's knee room in the rear is ridiculously small, especially for a car of this size. Every Audi Q3 or even a Skoda Scala has more to offer ...
i own this gen X5, yes the rear seat room isn't amazing but worth noting the cushion itself is long and the comfort of the rear seats is very high. as long as you're not transporting very tall people its sufficient.
@@autogefuehl it is 4000€ of difference in German market. After 3 years/60k km of driving there will be no differences, costs should be the same. So what I meant before is driving impressions- which is better- 40i or 40d for you personally?
As an example- tomorrow you have to drive from Berlin to Mardid, and you have two x5's on your parking- 40i and 40d. Which will you choose? Money is not object.
I have 2022 330i m sport. I love it so much but since reality is that getting kid in and out is tough in the low slung sedan, I am considering either of these two cause I loved the BMWs … now x3 is cheaper, do you think interior space in x3 is sufficiently large for a family of 4?
►Follow us on Instagram @autogefuehl and @thomas.letsgo
►Subscribe here: th-cam.com/users/autogefuehl
►Compare the Mercedes GLE: th-cam.com/video/-J8A-gsd6eI/w-d-xo.html
►Compare the Mercedes GLC: th-cam.com/video/AHzgckHPjzE/w-d-xo.html
00:00 BMW X3 vs BMW X5 !
01:01 Length and design comparison
01:51 Sound, rear and technology
03:05 Interior and seats BMW X3
04:46 User interface X3
06:20 Infotainment system OS7
06:54 Digital instruments M40i
07:13 Interior and seats BMW X5
08:27 User interface X5
09:15 Infotainment system and instruments X5
09:30 Rear seats comparison X3 vs X5
09:53 Trunk / boot comparison
12:15 Exhaust and engine check
13:16 BMW X5 40i Autobahn acceleration
14:45 Air suspension vs adaptive suspension
16:05 User interface while driving
16:25 Driving difference X5 vs X3
17:36 Fuel economy / consumption X5 40i R6 vs M50i V8
18:17 More high speed motorway driving
20:00 Agile driving X5
21:27 Driving part BMW X3 with acceleration
22:15 Faster and sportier than the X5?
24:50 Difference X3 and X1
25:18 X3 and X5 with same engine today
26:12 Assistance systems and user interface
26:58 More high speed motorway driving X3 M40i
28:07 German Laufkultur
29:18 BMW X3 vs Mercedes GLC vs Audi Q5 comment
30:09 Agile driving with the X3 M40i
31:13 Driving comparison X3 vs X5
32:28 Conclusion: Which one will I take home?
#BMW #BMWX5 #BMWX3
Transparency note: Autogefühl videos are independent and free from editorial influence on opinion and rating. But since manufacturers enable us to do the reviews in the first place, for legal reasons this video is marked as _advertisement_.
please do BMW X4 m40i vs BMW X6 comparison REVIEW
please do BMW X4 m40i vs BMW X6 comparison REVIEW
please do BMW X4 m40i vs BMW X6 comparison REVIEW
please do BMW X4 m40i vs BMW X6 comparison REVIEW
please do BMW X4 m40i vs BMW X6 comparison REVIEW
In my 55 years driving history, I have owned an X5 3.0d auto for the last 20 years, and just passed 150k miles. Despite it's outdated 5 speed GM gearbox, it's been my most enjoyable and rewarding motoring experience, even compared with a 1972 Lotus in my younger days. The X5's blend of comfort, practicality and performance is second to none, and I'm just hoping the wife will let me buy a replacement very shortly before I'm too old, 'cause frankly no other SUV cuts the mustard like a 3l X5.
Hey I concur to that - especially the facelift version with stage1 modding, that diesel is like a rocket tank. Never had so much fun with any other car... except e39 3.0D with the same configuration :D One major drawback though is that those cars rust sooner than their running capacity wears off (if properly maintained). Those doors accumulate water and eventually you have to either replace or bore a hole in them and repaint, which translated to extra care and effort. Other than that e53 & e39 in carbon black look visually stunning even today.
Very gracefully cars.
The new X3 is 2 inches longer than your old X5 so you may want to buy next X3 for the same driving experience. New X5 is a lot bigger than your X5...
@@benjamintran6539 thanks!
Forget getting your wife’s approval for anything. Hope you did it
Update: I took notice of all your comments & advice, thanks. A new X3 40i is expected at month end, having realised the growth in size over the past 20 yrs, and wife is happy too!
I was searching for comparison of these two models and found your video, what a gem! Never seen anyone who made such a good scientific comparison video. I'm totally satisfied and will be at a dealership with some knowledge 😃
thanks!! Glad we could help. Feel free to share and subscribe :-)
Excellent comparison - Really needed. Nobody is doing such comparisons between cars from different segments.
Please do a similar 3 series vs 5 series comparison as well!! Highly interested to know if the sophistication of the 5 wins vs the agility of the 3 - kind of a similar situation in the X3 vs X5 dilemma :)
thanks so much! :)
I had this doubts in 2019. My heart was telling me X5 but my head the X3. You’ve put things perfectly, as usual, Thomas.
The X5 is a bit more sophisticated, mostly on certain details like softer leather, better seats or certain optional extras. But for a daily use the X3 has better driving since feels more lighter, is easier to park and the price difference didn’t seem justifiably to me.
That said, I hope someday I can afford to move up towards the next X5 gen.
thanks for the feedback !
I currently own an older X5 which is in the shop; I have a 2021 X3 as a loaner. I find the X3 with the 4 cylinder is plenty fast and significantly lighter and hence more nimble than the X5. I thought the 4 cylinder might be too loud at idle, but from inside, you can't even tell it's running when at a stop. Main downside is that the X3 seats seem a bit too narrow for my taste.
Get used to it being in a shop because that’s what bmw is known for .
@@Niles-Guy Ever owned one? I've owned 8 and they've all been very reliable. Like all cars, they require maintenance and sometimes things break. My car was in for an air bag recall, not because it broke. BMWs are expensive to maintain, I will admit because parts are expensive, come from Germany and are in many cases, over-engineered.
@@Niles-Guy I guess you’re disappointed that the cars in the review didn’t breakdown 😅
I own the newer x5 45e plugin. I’m telling you please drive that before you make any assumptions sheesh it’s just so good at so many modes. It’s SOOOOOOOOOOO much smoother and quieter.
@@LafemmebearMusic it’s a fact that bmw breakdown consistently. Every owner I’ve known has stated this. Even mechanics have warned stay away from bmw or Landrover . And as for your new phev…congrats but that too will end up breaking down especially after warranty
To me since E70, X5 has lost it's road status, back then it was clear, it's X5 driving, now, its hard to tell difference between x5 and x3.
My 4th BMW will again be an X3 Sport. I moved from my beloved X3 to the X5 to drive grandchildren around (yes, laugh aloud, 78 year are old German grandma here), but soon missed the agility and simple “Fahrvergnügen“ with my boring X5. Now I’m returning to the 2023 X3 (currently on the ocean). I’m very excited. BTW, to those denigrating BMW reliability, I say baloney. Maintained my BMW’s well and never, ever had a problem over the many years (since 2006). Used to drive VW before that, no comparison. I can’t think of driving any other make (spoken as a born Münchener Kindl and somewhat prejudiced).
Interesting 😎 enjoy m8
Love your comment, "Listen & Repeat"..that took me back to my high school German classes when my instructor also said "listen and repeat"..."hören und wiederholen Sie". I really appreciate this X3 & X5 comparison. Particularly interesting was your conclusion that rear seat passenger space between the two is nearly identical. Both are "possibilities" to replace our aging Volvo V60 Cross Country. I also viewed your x5 45e review...and to me, if ONLY a x3 plug in hybrid was available here in the U.S....that might be the perfect fit for us as here in the Midwest US, it's a bit too soon for a full EV due to minimal available charging infrastructure. Thank you Thomas.
🙌😎
Always well done my friend. I traded my X30i for a 5series. This makes me miss my old X3.
cheers!
I own a X3 30i 2020 and I rented a X5 30d 2020 for a week
so both Gxx pre LCI I think
X3 is the clear winner to me:
- more agile
- faster (the X5 above 200kmh is a pain…)
- easier to sit in, you climb onto the X5, you sit in the X3, seat is exactly at the height of my bottom
- rear seats: there are the same width !!! I measured it in case I wanted to set 3 child seats (i have 2 kids), Basically the second row external is further from the door in the X5.
- Trunk: the X5 is a pain, I hated this tail gate. Thomas is 1m86, I am only 1m80, couldn’t reach the front end of the trunk. And guess where things end up after driving/breaking … :D
for a family, X5 brings zero benefit
for a large/tall driver, yeah, driver will be more comfy in the X5
How does the road noise compare?
@@irfaanbaksh5159 X5 will be quieter at high speed, but at 130kmh, i don’t think you will notice
Genuinely great video looking at the true differences and similarities between these units. You were not just a talking BMW brochure which many reviewers seem to be
Highly appreciated!! Please recommend us 😎
Most important statement, barebone X5 vs fully loaded X3 coming to nearly the same price. Make your choice. You would not go wrong. Excellent review
thanks m8 !
Love the manual buttons. I thought for sure there would be more leg room in the back with the X5. Interesting.
Great review Thomas. I have been watching your channel for a couple of years now and have been waiting for this comparison. I owned a 2018 X5 M50d, great car, lots of power but nightmare to park in many places due to the size. When I changed this year I looked at a new X5 but as the newer model was even longer and wider I opted for the X3 30d MSport instead. The X3 is not much smaller inside the car, there is more than enough power, the tech is great and I feel it drives more like a car than the X5 so I can be more aggressive around the corners than I was with the X5. Parking and narrow country roads are way better with the X3 as well. After 3 months I am very happy with the X3 and don’t miss the X5 at all.
Thanks, I needed to read this. My wife has just been told she can have an X5 company vehicle and she is not confident at parking. I will advise her to opt for the X3.
took delivery of our X3 20d LCI few months ago, absoutely love it.
enjoy!
If you’d buy it today, would you go with a X3 M40i or M40d? Thanks ❤
I have an X5 and having that tailgate is a gamechanger for me. I owned an X3 and wasn't happy with it because it's smaller and no tailgate.
Have had two X1's, Mark 1 & 2. Waiting to order e-X1 in UK ,now we have 18 400 w panels on roof and 11 kv of batteries in garage!
I just got my BMW3 2023. Never had a luxury car and it rides like a dream. So comfortable too. I just love it.
Question. Premium gas recommended. I read so many conflicting comments of which gas to use. Recommended vs required????
Owning X3 seems the more practical choice here😊. Great comparo!
👍👍👍
Great review! Personally I prefer X5 - It’s more elegant, brutal and comfortable! One more thing - X3 fits more to younger people and woman’s , but X5 - for gentlemen’s from 40..
Another great video. Great comparison and super useful to compare different models within the same brand!
I've watched this channel for a long time, hugely underrated: consistently delivers quality content
highly appreciated! Please recommend our channel :-)
What a way to start a review. "Does size really matter" really had me laughing😂
Great review as always Thomas and I'd personally take the X5 but with the M sport package🔥
I have owned many BMW models starting with a BMW 1600, which made me a BMW man for ever, after 3 x 5 series’s tourer’s & 2 x 3 series sot tops i now have a x3 M sport suv 🙀just great plenty big enough for golf clubs & a wonderful drive thanks for your comparison really enjoyed it, i made the right choice there is a smile on my face when ever i drive 😀
Wonderful review man!
Thank you so much! Please recommend / share our channel and our videos 🙏
Best cameraman and mc review
thanks so much !
I owned a X3 but now have an older X5 there is no comparison. By far the X5 is better vehicle. X5 is a muscle car that handles and hugs the road. It’s a strong build whereas the X3 felt very thin and a little too light for my taste. As well the X3 didn’t perform well here in Chicago with the winter months. It’s definitely a X5 as the winner.
great video. no doubt the X3 is higher performance but the X5 feels a class above. More substantial and luxurious
Appreciate that you give measurements in both systems! Much better for most Americans. Great review!
Cheers Bill !
Agreed. To us in the US it makes the video so much more meaningful.
I like the front face of the G01 X3. Understated and the kidneys aren't obnoxiously large. But, given the fact that I needed space for my family, I ended up with the X5 (although E70 40d. The width does definitely count in the X5's favour, but it makes it an absolute pain to park in tight multi storey car parks.
I bought 2022 x3 xdrive msport 3.0, gas mileage was very important, and have had my m240i convertible, the power wasn't a big factor in my choice, only one disappointment, no adaptive cruise control for the price
It is a good comparison. I prefer X3, more agile and sporty.
Even better would be: X3M or X5 40i, similar price. I take X3M any day.
Outstanding comparison!
Thanks 🙏 please recommend 😎
great overview! X3 for me
Great video! Please compare a base x3 with a b48 engine to the one you reviewed here, with the b58.
Thank you Thomas. This is the comparative video I have been waiting for years. I will get both if I have the money. If not, I will get the X5 because it is the all round winner.
I would be so interested to find out how would you compare x3 with the Macan.
First thing I did after this video is subscribed, fantastic comparison! love it!
Welcome !!
Thomas’s reviews - I would say - are a little bit more better than other reviews. Actually, for sure they are a lot better 👍
Thanks 🙏 please share 😎
So far I have only watched 2 of your videos and have found them very informative and captivating. (Of course I subscribed.). I like the ride on the autobahn when you are driving 125 mph and driving through the tunnels where you can see the ambient lighting in daylight. Very well done. You are becoming my go to resource for Mercedes and BMW. Thank you very much!
Welcome !! 🙏
Excellent comparisons.
Lots of my questions answered
👍👍👍
I have a 2022 X3 M40d and 2021 X1 2.0i X-Drive and have owned 3.0d M-Sport X5’s in the past.
I agree with others that the X5 has a wider, more comfortable and sophisticated cabin and with air suspension a better ride.
The X3 in comparison is a far more sportier SUV, with a cabin to match, more so with the optional ‘M’ seats which are an extra cost option in the U.K. but are extremely comfortable and worth that extra cost IMO.
Practicality between both models is hardly noticeable, with both accommodating 5 adults comfortably.
For me it came down to price. The X3 does everything the X5 does but the X5 is a more cosseting and comfortable environment and cabin to be in, is that comfort worthy of the premium cost over a X3?……you decide.
Wow!!! Great video!! So thorough!! Greatly appreciated !!!
Thanks 🙏 please recommend our channel 🤟
I go for x3 no different just little bit size
Very good and informative review. Your English is impeccable as well.
Highly appreciated! Please recommend us! 😎
The engine is probably situated in the same place, but it looks lower in the X5, because the car is taller.
that might be
I like them both but I prefer the X5’s looks and profile. I can’t fit comfortably in the M40i and it’s too small inside but quality on both is first rate. I need the extra room on cargo area and I have dogs. But the ‘23 X5 doesn’t have that amazing B85 w/hybrid power. Why not? The M40i’s engine makes it feel like a sports car. Good comparison. 👍
👌
Hmmm...here in the U.S, the x5 45e DOES have the B58 engine albeit a bit detuned from the "regular" B58 in the gasoline versions.
I have test drive them both for a day, the X5 feels much more premium! Cabin difference is much bigger than is mentioned in this video.
X5 had far more better seats and everything feels like a big luxury SUV
Also chassis and Technology wise the difference is very big, X5 has al Aluminium dual whishbone suspension, even the subframe is Aluminium.
You think lower horsepower X540i with 335 hp still better than X3 M40i with 385 hp?
@@borghorsa1902 Depending what you are looking after? A Sporty smaller suv (x3m) or a bigger premium and more comfortable luxury suv (x5)
@@willemb8689 I think I don't wanna drive a huge car that handles like a minivan. I don't wanna be in a car that is too anemic when it comes to handling and acceleration. On the other hand after driving 2020 4 cylinder X3 I was impressed with the technology, with screens and to some extent the engine. Some people say that BMW intentionally "downplays" their Horsepower numbers so that X3 was pretty fast. However if a much larger X5 has the same acceleration I would not wanna buy it
My first bmw was the bmw x5 but I love the bmw x3 2008🥰❤️
I really enjoy these comparison reviews. Always top notch. Thank you!
The six cylinder diesels are the engines to go for with shocking levels of torque, a better drive, 60's mpg and the highest resale values. BMW's best kept secrets. You will not be disappointed !
Highest resale value it depends on new environmental rules… :(
Great comparison. Good job lad!
Thanks 🙏
Great video. Exactly what I was looking for.
Thank you so much! Please recommend our channel 🙏
Very useful comparison! 👌
thanks! please share!
Comfort seats and air suspension would be the key arguments for me!
X-3 looks better in appearance. For the price, the X-3 is a better buy! The $10,000 difference made my mind up on purchasing the X-3 plus better MPG and I haven't regretted it! The X-3 2022 model is redesigned and different from the earlier X-3 so no comparison there.
Great reviews! I like watching your videos, they are very thorough and informative . Thanks for the effort Thomas.
Cheers Colin!
your reviews are always very good Thomas. Keep up the good work. we'll done.
thanks so much, keep recommending! :-)
Best journalist and comparing from while, soft,smooth and smart! Also as an Albanian I think that god created germans to make this world better 👍
Great review! You really feel the difference getting out of the X5 and getting into the X3. The X5 cabin feels much bigger. I had the X5 40e without rear wheel steer and my current X5 45e with rear wheel steer. I would recommend that option. All though it is pricy, the difference in agility and manouvering round in the parkin lot is like two worlds. But then I would say that the 45e is a huge step up in every way over the 40e. Huge difference.
Do you mean x5 is much more agile and better at manoeuvering or vice versa?
@@ruslannovikov5734 No. Just refering to the size. I have not driven the X3
@@palgjermstad9857 overall, do you find the steering of x5 satisfying? How does it compare to most sedans?
Great comparison. 👏🏼👏🏼
👍👍👍
BMW have mastered the art of making cars not look and feel big or small. My X3 seemed big until someone pointed how a Subaru was bigger. My X5 seemed small until I had an X4 for a few years.
X5 is by far the better car. I love the M40i, but the interior appointments of the X3 are a complete let down. The X5 X drive 40i fully loaded is the best option. Now that is 15 to 20K more than the X3.
We went with the X3 M40i in May 2024 because we would need to step up to the X5 M60i to get the M Sport Differential. Also the I6 should be more balanced than the the V8.
The X5 should be more plushed and comfortable but the X3 does just fine.
Thanks for the report! 😎
27:59 so what's the best 6-cylinder for economy?
Comfort levels so much such higher in X5 why can’t we get massage seats in X3 ? Thomas as always awesome review thanks
Excellent review! Thank you.
👌😎
BMW has so many additional options available, I'd love to see a video with your thoughts on which one would you choose ;)
The X3 front has a more badass look
X3 for me thanks 😊
I know , BMW should make a crew cab, extended cab or single versions, 4x2 or 4x4 pick up trucks with a hood scoop option, lifted with high ground clear stock , and a short 6' box or long box 8' truck bed. Then offer a V6 straight six turbo charged all the way to a large V8 or V8 turbo diesel dually!!! Ohh with descent fender flares and all terrain tires. With classic modern BMW front end design. Maybe even a dually diesel version for heavy towing. With all the bells, whistles, and lights!
My choice: X3
Why? Please justify.
I think everyone who has the money is going for the X5. Economically the X3 is smarter, but that’s it. Just as you said.
awesome review!
Thank you so much! Please recommend / share our channel and our videos 🙏
Very good comparison.
Cheers 🙏
On the rear seat comparison, please compare shoulder width. This tells us if 3 passengers will have room
I thank you for measuring the cargo space. Measurements let me know what might fit. Where the cubic liter/ feet manufactures use tell me nothing.
5:35 ... like P DIDDY said "it´s all about the benjamins" in this case, the meme is "it´s all about the buttons" ;)
What do you think of the new one without manual buttons and traditional shifter
Amazing review as always Thomas! I have a 2021 X5 and love it, it’s my second one in a row. A quick note, the X5 does have seat releases in the cargo area, they were right by your hand next to the X logo on the side of the cargo area ;-) no need to reach forward to lower the back seats.
The same for The X3 :-)
Impressive review .
Do you have X4 review too on your Channel please . Thanks
Thanks 🙏
Yes of course just TH-cam search autogefuehl bmw x4
@@autogefuehl Thanks
Maybe for those who haul a trailer with a lot of weight a Double dually crew cab V10 twin turbo diesel with all wheel drive or V8 turbo,10'-12' long box truck bed , goose neck and standard trailer tow hitches and all the bells, whistles, and lights!!!😁 I know it would be called the BMW series x 10 HDT(heavy duty truck) maybe and the lighter trucks the series x 8-9 LT (light tuck). Of coarse with a tilt forward front end like the Peterbilt semi trucks for easier accessibility for maintenance with locking hood release latches!
X5 sucks without rear seats reclining, on other side X3 is so good with reclining rear seats for families with kids and relaxing on long trip. Power is most same.
This is super helpful and informative, thanks for posting!
I have a 2015 X3, still can't decide to upgrade to a low spec X5 or High spec X3. Budget of course is the deciding factor.
My own personal view on BMW and Mercedes is that the lightly optioned versions lack some of the features you would expect to find at the price point, especially if you compare it to similar Asian luxury cars (though I realize German luxury cars are in a different league in terms of driving). If it’s me, I’ll pay the extra $10k and option up. If that leads you to the X3, great - as long as you don’t need the extra room. I did, and went with the heavily optioned X5 40i.
great review as always👍
🙏🙏
Very good Video on the X5 vs X3
our bmw x3 got the manual seat adjustments. i taught electric adjustment seats were standard on the facelift. also they didnt put the harman kardon on our car
Considering X5, F15 3.0D. Are there items recommended for replacement above 100k miles or 160k km?
Love my x3 m40i but definitely wish it had more x5 features available such a pity it doesn’t
I don't know why but the X5's knee room in the rear is ridiculously small, especially for a car of this size.
Every Audi Q3 or even a Skoda Scala has more to offer ...
I’m 6’1 and have plenty of room in the rear. Not 7-series spacious or anything, but it does the job.
@@cenkarson777 You must have short legs than.
I am 6'2 and touch the front seat with my knees. Something that doesn't happen in a compact Audi SUV.
@@mart_en My legs are pretty long actually, in trains I rarely have enough leg room. Might be because your passenger/driver seat is set further back.
i own this gen X5, yes the rear seat room isn't amazing but worth noting the cushion itself is long and the comfort of the rear seats is very high. as long as you're not transporting very tall people its sufficient.
Great review as usual.
If comparison between X3M40i verse X5M60i what would you think is the more fun drivers car then. At a guess.
Cheers!
Awesome comparison as always, would also like to see a Subaru outback vs Subaru Forester comparison review if possible.
Great review, as always. Why you'd recommend 40i? What about 40d?
Diesel is more expensive these days
At least in many countries
@@autogefuehl it is 4000€ of difference in German market. After 3 years/60k km of driving there will be no differences, costs should be the same. So what I meant before is driving impressions- which is better- 40i or 40d for you personally?
As an example- tomorrow you have to drive from Berlin to Mardid, and you have two x5's on your parking- 40i and 40d. Which will you choose? Money is not object.
Plane @@bartoszszarota7069
Wonderful review Thomas! I am waiting for the X1 driving lounge and your review of the gen5 plug in drivetrain! Keep the good work!
thanks !! Of course we ll keep you updated!
IMO X3 is better… a lot cheaper and more fun to drive
X3 M40i owner here. Driven he X5 multiple times too. It's not as fun and nimble as an X3. I prefer the X3, but X5 def more grown up.
I have 2022 330i m sport. I love it so much but since reality is that getting kid in and out is tough in the low slung sedan, I am considering either of these two cause I loved the BMWs … now x3 is cheaper, do you think interior space in x3 is sufficiently large for a family of 4?
Hey! Yeah that should work. The X3 doesnt offer sooo much more space as you ve seen in this comparison
Both are great, but buyer's choices depend on their needs
Excellent comparison review