Thank you to @MrFioz1 for bringing this detail to my attention. The BSP-D8 that I cover is in fact the BSP-D8 Pro, please excuse my mistake as I did not realize there were two different models. Cheers!
I'm very happy to see this video because I just bought the D8 pro and it's the first video where they give it a review and it has a high score!! I bought it for my iPhone.
@@elchg9102 I have received the BSP-D9 and D10 and will be making a video soon comparing all three, stay tuned for that if you want to know more and I'll also go more in-depth on the D8 Pro. Cheers! :)
Yes the D8 was very popular, it was basically the first trully good controller from them to me, the D9 is the D8 but with the PS5/PS Portal looks (which looks hideous IMO) and the one in the video is the D8 Pro which seems to be the one reaching almost Gamesir in terms of build quality, the standard D8 was good but still felt quite cheap and the D8 Pro kinda fixed that. As far as I know the D8 Pro still doesn't have a single video review out, it's very recent so if you want to do a solo quick review of it I think it would do well. Or maybe do a quick look at it in the D10 review.
Man I have a G8 in order, looking forward to modding it and playing during summer vacation on my iPad mini 6 on holiday. Can’t wait! Thanks for all the great info!
Please!!!! Add you the Jack audio 3.55 mm in your future telescopic gamepad. Start you for a base like Easysmx m10 o m05 and add you: action key better and with color (a, b, x ,y or playstation key), than interchangebale internal grip for smartphone with cover, feedback aptic, possibility of connect device via bluetooth or type-c always, and possibility to positioned the smartphone in vertical for play DS/3DS game. Also the different case color: white, black, grey, Red, green, blue, trasparent or clear white-purple-black-acqua blue etc.... in style gameboy color or retroid pocket 4.
Brother is THE most underrated youtuber ever, love the quality content + the constructive criticism and the experience with every single product, this vid is quality on top of quality and can't wait to see more of you
WOW! That comment is heartfelt on my end, I assure you! Thanks @Anubisson that is very pleasant to read on this Sunday afternoon. Cheers and hoping to continue to deliver meaningful and helpful content!
I found this channel a good while back when the G8 Galileo (the goat) released and was shocked at how the nice the production quality of the videos are and how pleasant he is to hear, a real gem of a channel.
For your next tier list, could you mention if a controller is recognized by Call of Duty Mobile (on Android)? I know it’s a very specific thing, but that game has a very weird controller support implementation. All bluetooth controllers seem to work fine, but hard wired controller support seems to be exclusive to Backbone. Even for controllers that spoof a Dualsense, I can’t find confirmation that they work natively since all footage of them playing the game use button mappers. What’s even more bizarre is that this is not a problem on iOS. Every wired telescopic controller I’ve tried works fine in that game on my iPhone. My only theory that I can’t confirm yet is that iOS has a better controller protocol so game developers don’t have to do anything to support third party controllers, as long as they support a Dualsense or X-Input. Meanwhile on the Android side, Backbone seems to have worked out a deal to be the only usable wired telescopic controller for that game. It seems very anticompetitive and might mean the only way for a controller to work would be to spoof a Backbone and not a Dualsense. Sorry for the huge wall of text, but this is now my white whale when it comes to mobile controllers. Because so far no other telescopic controllers work in the game and Backbone refuses to update their design with sticks that are good for a shooter, Android CODM players have just been screwed by this situation for a while.
Sure, great suggestion btw! I went ahead and tested every "wired" telescopic controllers I owned and you were right, they all did not work except the Backbone One, that's crazy!
@@GameTechTalk Yeah, like you said this is my gripe with Backbone as a company. They had a great product at first, now they use their money from that for big marketing pushes and anti competitive stuff like this instead of improving their now outdated controller
Exactly, all the bluetooth controller can spoof as a dualsense/xbox, but it is still bluetooth. I just know that the wired ones only support backbone after reading ur comment, thats fkd up actually.. Oh yea and i have a question, does wired controller has wireless support too? like if i want to use it for my laptop
@@Fielith To your question, historically? No. However, this seemingly is starting to change and the first controller I've seen do that is EasySMX M05, there may have been more but if so I'm unaware. With that said, there are more controllers that will be coming out VERY SHORTLY that have this feature as well. Stay tuned! ;)
It means a lot Gregory, I've been trying to improve my content and output to hopefully grow a bigger audience and find better support from brands, that's the mandatory steps to be able to keep informing gamers of the best gaming solutions out there! Thanks for being part of the journey! ♥
Thanks for the vid! I got a bsp awhile ago for $25 to scratch the itch of wanting a phone controller. Now that i came back to it i just have a bigger obsession with these so im looking to upgrade. This list really helps. Im eyeing the gamesir or the easysmx.
Happy I could help, if you are in no rush, I should have a new tier list by the end of the month, you may want to keep your eyes peeled for that one. Also, I would recommend watching my Abxylute S9 review. Cheers!
I understand your point of view. Do I wish ASUS had designed the Kunai 3 for every phone? Of course. Technically it does so but only wireless with the center connector. I didn’t rate them by what they weren’t designed for but rather by what they were. Still, your suggestion is a fair one and something I’ll keep in mind when I do this again. Thanks for watching!
Most people only have one phone so…it’s either good or it functionally doesn’t exist for you. I wouldn’t rate a restaurant in Italy a D tier just because I can’t go there
He makes it very clear why pal. If the controller was universal it would probably be an S. Also it's not one phone it's a brand of phone. As much as that sucks it's still a quality controller. Worth an A FROM HIS PERSPECTIVE which he made clear too.
I have the x4 Aileron, and for me it's a tier s, THE QUALITY IS PERFECT, SUBLIME EVEN. It's soo good, and the software is also really good, I've never encountered any problem whatsoever, and I've tried it in many phones and even tablets, and the software is perfectly functional.
It's a very robust solution, glad you love it this much! To me it's a specific product for specific gamers and much like I paraphrased when making my review, I knew there would be people exactly like you that find it to be the best controller ever because it does have amazing appeal for the right person!
I love my GamesirX4. It's also a decent computer controller. For those who don't know, it has 2 modes which is gamesirx4(mobile) and Xbox for PC. Not sure if it works on XBOX consoles tho.
Waii whhattt?? I've gone through the manual, I tried shortcuts, I tried plugging it in on PC, sync'ing through Bluetooth, nothing worked. What am I missing? Or is it a firmware update thing? I didn't update it since having reviewed it... 🤔
@@GameTechTalk I didn't see it in the manual. Even their support team on Discord is unaware of this feature 🤣 Hold the Xbox and B button ( 3-4 secs) for the Xbox controller mode and the Blue LED will blink. Xbox and A button to go back to the Gamesir phone mode, white LED should then blink. You can still use the Xbox mode on mobile but the app will not recognize the gamepad. When on Xbox mode, it should show up as an Xbox controller on your computer.
@@soumybhow4398 Sorry, I don't play natively on my phone as I use my phone you stream games on my PC. Knowing that their functions are the same, probably not.
Other than Bluetooth options, it appears the only option on this list for foldable phones is the X2S? Just not a fan of the color of it and hoping for something in black and in the same small + slim profile. I currently have a G8 Galileo but am a bit irritated with the Surface Duo screens coming downward rather than up like a traditional DS. I am contemplating the BSP-D8 Pro now that I see it though, especially in black. Great job on the review, it was very insightful.
Yeah unfortunately the left side USB-C is not common at all. But Bluetooth has been better and better. I’d argue that if using a Foldable, best to just go towards that tech by default and there are some PRETTY SEXY options coming out soon that I can’t yet speak about. Rest assured that, this market is growing rapidly and option are becoming more and more in our midst. Lots of amazing things coming in Q3/Q4! 😉
That it most certainly is! Welcome to the beautiful world of no compromise (or just a little) telescopic gaming. It's such a viable solution that so few people know about still!
About Ipega, just a few months back they came up with a new model (9777s) which copies the design of the Samsung Glap controller, but extends to fit large tables. It has adjustable analog sticks sensitivity, new spring mechanism, and RGB lights. I think those sold a lot that they have to restock. The thing is the restock version is a stripped down version of the original. They removed the sensitivity sliders and changed the spring mechanisms. But still, probably a good affordable alternative to the BSP D8 Pro you've shown here.
@@GameTechTalk You're very welcome! btw do you have any plan to check the controllers with built in coolers? Like the Gamesir X3 and BSP D10 Pro. There even the cheaper ones available, namely the Coolshark JK02 and JOHF X5 Mini.
@@ramadhanisantoso2973 Not the X3, but the X3 Pro Aurora that should be coming out late August or September, most definitely yes. As for the BSP-D10, I have it with me, just haven't gotten around to making reviews on them yet. I saw the JK02 and though I was tempted to order one, I'm a bit strapped for time so it's a maybe. Didn't know about JOHF X5 Mini, I'll look it up, thanks!
The M05 is a sleeper hit and I think EasySMX are starting to realize they need to give that controller a bit more marketing. Or at least, I hope so. Thanks for your kind words and for watching, out of those 15+ which would you say is your favorite?
@@GameTechTalk i love the color too, but i might go for the usb-c version, i wanna play emulators in long time sessions so maybe charge the controller is not the best for me
Can you make a list of tablet friendly gamepad, BT, so they can be used on Windows tablets like OneXplayer 1 11inch, onexplayer X1 mini, the minisforum V3, LegionGo and so on
After Years Trying Telescopic controllers and doing my own testings, my top is: Gamesir G8 Plus Gamesir G8 Galileo Gamesir X4 Aileron Gamesir X2s BackBone V2 Backbone V1 RazerKishi V1 Razer Kishi V2 (the worst, in my opinion) I started with a Razer Kishi V1 than a Backbone V1, and i was amazed with the backbone. Then I got a Razer kishi v2, but you can't use it with a case and the joysticks are awful then the Backbone V2 came out and I was amazed again with backbone, but the first time i tried a Gamesir controller and having the possibility to use a slim case with it and having back buttons with the G8 Galileo i couldn't see my backbone V2 The same way again and i even got a X2S that is even better than the Backbones and cheaper with the hall effect joysticks and for prime day i got the X4 Aileron That can be use with any case after waiting they announced The Gamesir G8+ That You can Use it with a NINTENDO SWITCH making the G8+ the best controller around the globle in my opinión ❤
Thanks for taking the time to reply to everyone of your comments. That is truly impressive. This is the list I was looking for. Currently on a Galaxy Fold phone with a Nacon MGX Pro controller and looking to upgrade to something new. You have me stuck betweem the Kenshi and The Galleo. I am currently checking out your personal reviews for these 2 controllers on your page. Is there anything out there on a high price point yet? $200+ market
The highest price point remains the Kisha Ultra and it definitely is a solid controller. If you haven’t seen it, check out the G8+, maybe it’ll strike a superior balance for you? Tks for the kind words, much appreciated!
You have to mod to fit that tablet and your options are Galileo G8, Galileo G8+ and the Abxylute S9 (but that you'll have to wait if you back it). I honestly STRONGLY recommend watching my Abxylute S9 review if you haven't seen it. Great opportunity for an amazing deal right now!
So the SMX got rated S without having hall effects, above the Gamesir X2s which has same features plus hall effects. Also I would like to mention I've had an absolutely horrible experience with Razer, Ive used the Kishi V1 and Kishi V2, both broke within my first months. Not putting any money on razer on the controller department ever again. Edit: I am happy you put Kishi V2 at D because it is truly horrible and i totally agree the clickiness feel absolutely wrong. After watching the whole video I will have to checkout the Galileo, too many roses thrown at it.
I hear you, so the thing is, Hall-Effect is not exclusively all better, it does become a question of preference and sure, it is great to prevent stick drift, but not for stick resolution. Not for stick jitter. Not for "raw inputs". At the end of the day, some favor hall-effect and that's perfectly fine and legitimate but ALPS is not exclusively all bad, there are positives too. If you watch my M05 review, I talk a bit more about it. As for Razer... Yup. Haven't necessarily experienced what you have but... Not surprised? 😅
I have a Game sir X2 Pro and while I really like it, I HATE how clicky the face buttons are. They make a lot of noise. Please answer to me, are the face buttons on the Galileo the same? What about the buttons on the Easymx m10?
Galileo G8 and M10 both have membrane which are definitely more silent and not clicky at all. With that said, the membrane on the G8 is a bit lower pitch, whereas the M10 is a bit higher. For that reason, I'd favor the G8 but it's extremely trivial at this point. Cheers!
I personally thinks that the Gamesir X4a is on the S tier because how much it can do, for example it can connect to Android, IOS & PC. Also it got Joycon Mode which you can use the controller as 2 separate controller to play local co-op multiplayer games like Metal Slug or Overcooked. And then with this feature you can use either single left grip or the right grip to play competitive games like CODM Warzone Also to mention the Grip Connector & Clip Extender accessories that we can 3D Print. Literally underrated gamepad, Gamesir failed to deliver the correct marketing promotion
Well, you brought a lot of info to me that I didn't even know existed but that is why I gave it an A and also why I had a very positive review on it. You have, in my humble opinion, gave my take all the more validity by showcasing just how niche this controller is, and that is why it pushes this high, don't think of A as being bad, it's pretty impressive when you think of a product that has half a dozen other variant in existence. GameSir is leading (by a large margin) the landslide for this form factor, and that's saying something. But making it an S means that it would cater to every single need in the form factor and I just can't see that to be true. You don't have a USB-C on both sides, you don't have rumble, you don't have gyro, you don't have wired connectivity, you don't have a candy bar connection in the box, there are a lot of ways that this controller could improve as a market solution, but in the current shape and form that it is? I think it corners every "mandatory" aspects that consumers looking for this solution would want. I hope my scoring makes more sense now but the good news, because it has such a loving community behind it, you can take it from an A and bring it all the way up to an S, and that is awesome, let's hope GameSir will give you that S out-of-the-box for future versions! :)
As of today, I'd say Galileo G8+, especially in light of the new data that just got covered on my channel. If you are looking for small form-factor, I might go Scuf but that review is not out yet, though I do have the product with me. Cheers!
@@CSagan710 Oh for sure my dude, at that price, I don't see how one could go wrong! My unit should arrive today, hopefully, I'll have a hands-on in the coming days if not hours! :)
Hard to give you that answer right now because we are right in the middle of having new models. I'm literally in the middle of filming a video for one and I have at least 2 more to film in the coming month, if not three. M15 and G8+ are safe bets but I'd sit at least a few days to see the reviews. The new tier list will come out in late September, if not mid. Cheers!
@GameTechTalk thanks for your reply. I'm not sure if g8+ works on pc using bt. On their website, only pc with usb-c is shown. I'm trying to contact the gamesir support to confirm. Thank you again, and I can wait for the new update video.
I really wish more of the wired controllers like G8 etc had the type C connector on the left like the X2s. In a year-ish i'd like to get a OnePlus Open (maybe their Open 2 will be out), and the connector on the left is less awkward/more folding phone friendly with the result of the top of the screen being above the controller IMO. Rather than bottom of the screen being below the controller.
Yeah, unfortunately, very few controllers do, basically just the X2s as far as I know. With a bit of DIY, you might be able to reroute a cable to the G8+ though.
I'd say the bsp d3 should have been at least a b. It's pretty good for its price. It works via Bluetooth for android and ios, and can be used wited to a PC. battery life is good as well. Sure it doesn't have some features like analog triggers, it's still really good for its price.
The way I look at it is, it’s not. It’s hardly good at all. But for its price? It’s good. I realize I’m just flipping your words but I do think it changes the meaning of how to perceive this device. Someone said it very well in the comments, great solution to dip your toes into the market but that should be where it ends in my personal opinion. If you think about it, 2 BSP-D3 get you a BSP-D8 Pro pretty much, now that’s a great deal. However, during the time that the D3 was released? I would’ve rated it higher because at that time, there weren’t that many options in the low price point. For that, we can all be thankful for the D3 and I certainly am.
somebody knows how to pause usb power delivery on samsung when using a controller? i am using easysmx m15 connected to my s24 ultra and i have a pd 30w charger but for me its not showing its always charing its not enabled but without the controller i can enable it please help... because that feature is useless if cannot be worked with a controller
Interesting that you left out if they need to be charged, I only have 1 telescopic controller Gamesir Galileo G8 and it feels like what a controller should feel like, except for one downside that the buttons are nearly completely vertical with the sticks even though it's shaped in a way that could allow it.
Most telescopic controllers are plugged in but you are right with the BSP-D8 Pro at least, that one is battery and do need to be charged. Thanks for pointing it out, I'll make sure to mention it when I do this again. As for the sticks, I like them slightly off as well but seeing as the Galileo has a large enough ergo grip, I find that to be more trivial than on something like a retro handheld or a joycon, you know something with a slimmer profile. Cheers and thanks for engaging!
I do not have the combination that you mentioned but I can attest to not being able to use the M05 with the case on my Fold 4 and it’s a fairly slim case. With that said, the ultra slim on my iPhone 15 works just fine.
Thanks for this, man. I was torn between the EasySMXM05 and the EasySMXM10. Despite me not necessarily liking the overall boxy shape of the M05, I can definitely see that it is the better option compared to the M10. I just bought it off of Amazon for only $42. Such a great product for its price tag and is maybe even on par with the controllers that are closer to $100
Totally! And I assure you, it's not my go-to shape either but like Shem said (RetroBreeze), somehow they managed to make it feel different despite looking like other controllers of that same type. I think that perfectly sums up how I feel about the EasySMX M05 shape and I would add that the differences it has makes it more comfortable than the options it looks like. Cheers!
@@GameTechTalkSo sorry to bother you again, but now Im wondering if I should have gotten the Gamesir x2s instead of thr Easysmx M05. Which one would you think is better. The x2s looks a little small in terms of overall buttons, but has a better look
@@GameTechTalkAlso, is hall effect needed on controllers? And what exactly does it even do? Ive heard other reveiws talk about hall effect but I was confused what that even meant. Since the M05 doesnt have hall effect, would that make it a lesser controlller or no?
@@danieloku7560 Don't worry, you don't bother me at all, I was editing and taking a break before the last stretch! The X2s has one very specific advantage over the M05 and it is the fact that you can stretch it for a tablet mode. If that is not important for you, don't bother. Otherwise, the M05 is pretty much on all front a superior product as far as I am concerned.
@@Semuskid If you want small but that feel full-size like console controllers, go EasySMX M15 (or Memo S3 same thing). It's light, small and very very great feature-wise, the price is also quite affordable.
I want something low profile that I can just throw in my bag. I am currently using an 8bitdo zero 2 but would like something similar that can connect to my phone with just a d pad and a few face buttons.
That is telescopic or not necessarily? Because indeed, in the low profile department, 8BitDo takes the cake, even with options such as the SN30 Pro with a phone clip.
@@GameTechTalk there is no telescoping with the zero 2. It’s just a tiny controller I toss in my bag. For holding my phone I have a mag safe wallet that doubles as a phone stand.
Lots of work went into that one, but the filming part was so much fun! It felt like just casually having a chat with a friend, so for you to be excited to watch it, it's very much that conversation happening on the other end! 😊 Thanks for being here for it; it wouldn't be the same otherwise!
That would be the goal, probably not gonna make another tier list but I will review the Scuf Nomad and when I do, I will say in that review where I would slot it in the tier list. Cheers!
That's a big ask and one currently not in existence basically. The closest to what you are saying is the M05 because it has the connector, it has antennas but it has no battery! :3 Maybe it could be modded with one but I'll leave that to the bawss tinkerer Shem from RetroBreeze! Otherwise, it's usually one or the other, not both. The one exception is the MOGA XP-7 Plus that I talk about in this video but it's not a USB-C connector, a big disappointment to be honest. If I was MOGA, I'd do a revised unit with USB-C and rumble because otherwise, It was an AMAZING product! BSP could also surprise us all with an D11 model but they said that product line was done so time will tell.
@@GameTechTalk i am getting the kishi v1 for around 50 euros. Should I get that. It does meet some of my portability and type C requirements. I'm only afraid if it's durable and has any connectivity issues. If you can tell me about this. Thanks for replying :)
@@gatebreaker44 The Kishi V1 is surprisingly good, you'll probably just want to add some type of holder to keep it more stable on your phone but by no means is it a bad controller, quite the opposite. The one concern I have for you though to be honest, 50 euros seem a bit steep for that controller seeing as it's probably no longer in production? Are you not able to get it cheaper?
@@GameTechTalk Europe is expensive in general, I don't think so, even the g8 is 80 euros. Can you explain what you mean by a pad? Also I've had a gamesir X2pro before and my software experience with it was really bad. Key mapping was a no go essentially. That's why I thought I may as well get the V1 where there is also probably no key mapping but at least hopefully there is no connection issues.
loved this video. about time someone made a modern update to mobile gaming controllers as that market is growing fast with many AAA titles coming out recently and more coming in the future. my fav in the list is the razer kishi ultra. its very similar to the G8. but the big selling point of the razer is that USB C external plug in to a pc or a 13 inch ipad pro. that way i dont have to carry around 2 controllers. i can just have the kishi ultra. play on my iphone 15 pro. then if i wanna switch to my ipad pro. I can just plug it in hard wired via USB-C. great feature. sure the 150usd is quite alot of money. but the razer has haptics which the G8 does not. so with that the price can be a bit more justified. and also G8 dont have the external USB-C plug in like the razer one has. i did test. and nothing happens it just blinks. like it has power but no data signal is coming through. the G8 only has the USB-C for input charging it seems.
The G8 does have external support but you need to use a USB-C female to USB-A male (or USB-C male) which is not a cable most people usually have lying around. You plug the female part on the male of the G8 that usually plugs into the phone/tablet you're using. Thanks for the kind words by the way, I really enjoyed doing this video and I already have a few brands contacting me with future models (that I'll be reviewing of course) but I'm already contemplating making a follow up video for maybe Q4. Until then, thanks a lot, I'm glad to know it was enjoyable to you! :)
Backbone can do this too and through the charging port, so no weird adapter cables. Unfortunately they charge you a subscription fee to do it. The only reason I keep mine around is because I have a lifetime access to Backbone subscription due to lucking out and getting the controller just months before they switched to a subscription model.
Great video, you've got a new subscriber. I'm actually thinking about the ipega pg-9777s since it can stretch too fit my 12.6 inch tablet. Cheap enough at around $45 CAD, so i might take a chance with it. Fingers crossed.
I'll first mention that I have not laid hands on the iPega 9777. With that said, I have had multiple viewers report back to me that it was best to steer clear from it, that it basically was terrible in fact. As the audience trusts me, I decided to trust them 😂. With that said, I do have the BSP-D8 Pro, D9 and D10. I would recommend turning towards one of those instead. I am planning to do a video on them shortly.
@@GameTechTalk thanks for the quick response! I’m not sure it the 9777s is similar to the normal 9777, cause the S version seems to have a different layout and has dials to adjust rocker sensitivity, which I think is pretty cool if it actually works well. Looking forward to your video on those BSP controllers! Your review on the Galileo G8 Plus definitely has me contemplating splurging a bit more for it 😂
@@KevinDeLeon91 Ahhh, yeah that could very well be the case. If 9777s is new, that's definitely not the model I heard about because those comments I'm referring to are from a few months back. I'm gonna try to look this up, maybe there is a review opportunity, I'd like iPega to somehow make it back into the market, effectively so, they were a staple at some point. Thanks for being here, I appreciate the support!
It’s questionable. I’ve always been a big believer in raw inputs but raw means the missteps and mistakes are also more captured. So much like dead zones eliminate the raw input jitter at base value, too much sensitivity is like bringing that jitter back on stick travel. Cheers!
Wired is from 8ms to 2ms so far that I've seen on the telescopic market. I'd say 95% are 8ms, the 4 and 2ms are just starting to appear, very uncommon. For bluetooth, it goes from 15ms to approximately 3ms. So that depends, and there are far worst too when it comes to bluetooth but that range is from 1 year old released controllers on average. Right now, the best controller I've tested bluetooth is the G8+, I have a review on my channel and it'll be part of the next tierlist video which will probably be around september. Cheers!
Which one is best EasySMX M10 or GameSir X2S ? I have 13 pro max so lighting is downfall for now lol this will be first gaming controller. Would love your feedback.
Yeah I figured you meant the X2s Bluetooth, the new model. Quite frankly, I would go X2s Bluetooth. As much as I know the Lightning M10 will work. Once you upgrade your phone, it’ll become e-waste. As for the X2s Bluetooth, it’ll still be good after. They are both ok but to me the X2s is the better product of the two and also, it spoofs as Dualsense which works better with iOS than spoofing Xbox 360 wireless (which M10 does). The M10 only advantage are the two extra paddles but they aren’t in the ideal position for most people. My vote is X2s Bluetooth personally, and I love the colors!
@@santijr007 Arguably, lighting could be better because of lower latency but with iOS releasing Game Mode extremely shortly, Bluetooth connections will be getting a boost. Also, the difference on everyday use should be trivial, that is why I would recommend to go "function over form" by going Bluetooth. Technically, you do have to keep a battery charged but I would expect that to be minimal effort. Cheers, keep the questions coming if you have more, always happy to help! :)
I have a G8, but honestly considering the Kishi ultra so I don't have to deal with an app that's marked as malware, needing to turn on/off the controller to get it recognised. Feels like it would also be better in touch emulation (have some annoyances in wuthering waves with the G8) and has a bit more space between the right joystick and buttons
Not under that category for sure. But for the upcoming updated list video, I would like to rank them within categories, still debating on that but thinking it'll be a thing.
I'm leaning towards the Atom, especially if you see value in being able to split your controllers. If not, the Kishi V2 Pro does have more features like rumble, 3.5mm jack, wired support.
@@GameTechTalk I have 2. Black and Playstation edition. My Wife plays with headphones and started to get defected. My still worked fine. Then she played with the Playstation with headphone. It defected too.
@@angelgnievestorres5769 Hmmm. So some headphones flip the polarities, Apple was notorious for doing that. Maybe that’s what caused an issue with the controller? Sorry I wouldn’t know more or anything at all about that issue but I would strongly recommend that you reach out to Backbone as soon as possible. That is not normal.
If they invent one that has Qi Charging combined with a Cooler, like the Oppo 45w liquid cooler magsafe charger. Like a controller combined with a Blackshark Fun Cooler 4 pro, it would be a winner by my standards!
I'd love to try that controller for sure! Technically for Qi Charging, the MOGA XP-7 Pro does do that and I don't know when that happened but I tried it the other day and it worked on iOS (it didn't before). I might even make a video about that!
One thing that I always want to know because it's make or break on these controllers is the right thumbstick placement. It's always too low. It's the main thing that keeps me from love the Galileo G8.
You know, lately I've been wanting to see a controller try to have symmetrical sticks but over rather than under or assymetrical, much like the Steam Deck type of thing. I think that could definitely work and the way I see it, sticks maneuvers are way more "cramp inducing" than buttons, so by having them over, I think it would greatly improve the "long session" usage of some of these controllers. Do you think that could be an interesting solution?
@@GameTechTalkthe BSP-D9 has symmetrical sticks that are definitely not very low relative to the D-pad and face buttons, since the D9 is a clone of the the DualSense design. Even the Steam Deck's sticks are slightly below the D-pad/buttons, not above them.
@@ydgmdlu I meant the upper portion of the available footprint, not necessarily the order from top to bottom of sticks and buttons. However, on a traditional controller, due to available space, if the sticks were to be over, the buttons would most likely be under. Sorry for the confusion.
I never did and it seems they stopped producing it too, sold out, couldn’t even find the listing on Amazon Canada. Maybe they have a newer model coming out shortly? 🤷🏾
I'd say Backbone One probably, those rounded corners fit quite nicely in pockets, real talk. However, the sticks do poke out and feel a bit more flimsy than full-sized ones, purely impressions mind you but still, I'd say it's the most pocketable.
Because the difference, while nice and important for some people, was too little. At least in my opinion. It’s more of a gen 1.1 than a gen 2 from where I stand but I understand marketability. I didnt buy the gen 2, but whenever (if ever) there will be a proper new model, I’ll be happy and excited to review it.
Do very much enjoy my G8 but the 3.5 mm port never works with my Pixel 6. I also wish that data could be transmitted through the USB c port so I could connect to ethernet wile using the device. Otherwise good list, though I'm curious how the M-Con will fit into this list when it is eventually released.
I'd love to hear back from the creator, I tried to reach out but I'm small time and I can't imagine how much buzz the controller generated. Either way, I'll get my hands on the M-Con as soon as it is possible.
I was in the initial hype with the G8, but the lack of app support to configure the stick dead zones became a deal breaker for me personally. The more I play with it the more annoyed I get and I don't feel about using it anymore. Playing warzone, AC Mirage and other similar games makes it pretty noticeable how much you need to move the sticks until movement is registered! Horrible. Scuf nomad is next on my list even though I am concerned about the BT connection. Not because of BT that is not a problem for me. It is because I won't be able to charge my phone while playing unless I remove it from the controller. Anyway, some high expectations there.
GameSir do not seem to have managed to establish a "buddy buddy" relationship with Apple but I think they are actively trying. That iPad Pro controller is one indication, but also, there is a Galileo G8 MFi edition that was shown at CES but we haven't heard since, all white, so sexy. I really think GameSir is trying to appeal to Apple but until Apple agrees, that is the number one reason for the app on iOS to really be COMPLETELY different than on Android. Everything you just said? You can do all of it and so much more... on Android. So yeah, I get where you're coming from and I sincerely hope GameSir and Apple can figure things out because more options is best for buyers. As for Nomad... you know I'm already on it! 😉
If they reach out I'd love the opportunity to review their products but as I don't own it, that ship might have sailed for me and a future model would make more sense to review. Thanks for the suggestion though!
I was going to say, the Kishi V1 is definitely up there in most quiet, the problem is even the membrane quiet ones will do a bit of noise. But if not the Kishi V1, I'd argue that the Galileo G8 is up there, the membrane is a bit "low pitch" so by being more of a low frequency sound, I find you tend to hear it less than others but for a proper "less noise" experience, you'd most likely have to mod it to dampen the sound even more, something I haven't tried. Cheers!
The gamesir 4 (own one) is on a own tier since I don't care if u have galaxy s24 ultra or iphone pro max15, ur phone will be an over in no time playing heavy games. U need the cooling
I hear you. You’re not the first person to address this issue. I guess I do live in a cold country and have a constant cold temperature in my living space. I’ll try to consider that in the future as I personally have not encountered that issue in quite some time and I have done some LENGTHY sessions.
With the G8+ now out (which got released after this video released), I'd be 100% recommending that one. I have a review on my channel if you want to learn more about it, as well as a follow-up mod video. Highly recommend watching both!
By making a controller that only supports iPhone, not Android? That's aIready a bad stance from where I stand, not everyone is iOS locked. However, I have every intention of loving the Nomad if it is as good as I'm hoping it will be. But I'll believe it when I see it, Scuf has a reputation of overpromising and underdelivering. With that said, the Nomad will get its review and when the time is right, a new tierlist will happen, I really enjoyed doing it.
@@GameTechTalk yes I agree it’s weird that it’s Bluetooth but only iOS. Maybe they’re testing the waters, and releasing an android down the road or making the BT protocol on the nomad android compatible. Scuf has a bad rep online but also, any products that people are dissatisfied with they will let others know, but a positive experience most people will not go online and leave a review.
@@YanFries@YanFries I agree wholeheartedly on people being more vocal about bad experiences than good ones, but as someone that hangs in the "nerd tests everything" kind of forums (I'm one myself 😅), I'm talking more from an objective performance point-of-view, though the hardware seems to often be a point of contention as well. With that said, I'll always form my own opinion and Turtle Beach lately is a great example of that, they also don't always get the best rep and sure, it's not a perfect product but I still was able to give it credit, I'm hoping to be able to do the same with Scuf. Time will tell! Cheers and thanks for the chat, always fun to share experiences with fellow gamers!
@@YanFriesYeah saying that controller is the best overall is jumping the gun a bit for 3 reasons 1. It’s iOS only 2. It’s bluetooth and not hard wired 3. It has the Xbox Pro D-Pad style It looks like a very solid controller, but these alone will make it a nonstarter for a lot of people, myself included.
@@terribletimes902 spawnpoiint just made a video on it. Fantastic. I think 1. It’ll be compatible with android through firmware update I’m sure but who knows. 2. Bluetooth doesn’t look like that big of a deal 3. Some prefer it. Also look at the positives, the camera bumps don’t matter and neither does case removal
When you say type-C, do you mean that has a connector to connect directly to the controller? Because if so, the only one will be the EasySMX M05. Controller don’t usually have the wired connector AND radio antenna. That’s an anomaly of the M05 essentially. If you mean it’s wireless but charges with USB-C I would recommend either the X2s Bluetooth or the G8+ that I released a review for yesterday. Cheers!
I think I ask the question wrong which one can connect to both android and ISO and charge using type c and is compatible with pubg and the other top games other their?
No, in fact, most to not say all aren't. Telescopic controllers that are "licensed by Microsoft" is more to say it's guaranteed to work on XCloud but most telescopics controllers do anyway.
@@GameTechTalk so is there a video or any info by chance telling us which controller is compatible with Xbox/PS & ect? Or no cause I’ve been looking for a mobile gaming controller so I can play Xbox for curtain situations like when I don’t have my Xbox with me but I still wanna play it
@@saraibeeman5518 So, unfortunately, these controllers are not designed to run on native hardware. Spoofing does give third-party solutions the "information" they need to let these controllers in but first party hardware usually have tighter verifications. In other words, an actual Xbox console will work with very few controllers, because they tightly monitor what is plugged on their devices, same for Playstation. Nintendo Switch would've been the same but they were massively cracked which led to a floodgate of third party solutions fully compatible, it is by far the exception, not the rule. So with that information, it is best to assume that all telescopic controllers do not work on native consoles (with the one exception being Switch for *some* controllers).
Thanks and hey, trust me, it's a challenge every day. Still is after 100+ videos. It's a long and arduous road but it all comes down to showing up, if you can do that, the rest will follow. It's learning to appreciate, love the process with the acceptance that it could lead to none other than letting out creativity. It's a balancing act but the closer I get to doing it, the better I seem to be doing. I'll tune in to your stuff when I have a bit of free time, thanks for engaging! 😊
None in this list and now that you mention it, I can't think of one that does in the telescopic mobile space if being perfectly honest. Maybe something to do with not cause any more strain on connected device's batteries, or their own if it is a wireless controller? Fine observation from you, I'll keep my eyes peeled in case. Cheers!
@@GameTechTalk The only thing I hate is that you can't disable the bright LED lights (which sucks for playing in bed at night) and I wish the sticks were a little tighter like the Xbox gamepad. The sticks feel kinda loose.
@@GameTechTalk I am curious if attempting to swap the sticks to ones from a console gamepad would help any. I imagine the tightness isn't from the sticks themselves but the device the sticks attach to, maybe the bands could be swapped for tighter ones.
@@BryceCzirr-jz7ju Most definitely that it would, the tension is a physical component to the sticks. It probably wouldn't be this hard too, the challenge would most likely be to just find a stick that is compatible with the controller's calibration process. So ideally, same make, same manufacturer, different tightness.
I don't have the 9s but maybe I can assist? Do you mean the screen mapping? The thing is, you can map with Redmagic 8 Pros using non-Redmagic controllers, so as long as it's compatible, you are set but using other features for mapping specifically past Redmagic's own software seems to be where the problem stems from. Anywho, happy to test whatever you may need, just tell me what it is exactly what you need to know and I'll do my best. Cheers! :)
@@Pixel8080YT Interesting! The Kunai 3 does have the connector off to the side so if it is the case for the Red Magic 9 too, it just might. As far as I can tell, every ROG Phones have a "non-centered" USB connector, which was the sole reason why compatibility of that controller was null. But with the right wire, it did work elsewhere, including on PC.
Of all the controller the X4 Aileron is the superior one for me and my iPhone 15 Pro Max. Why? Simply because iPhone now runs AAA games and where I live the climate is very hot. So my device becomes a lava brick, specifically with Resident Evil, Death Stranding or AC: Mirage type of games. So I need a phone cooler like the BlackShark Fun Cooler 4 Pro I just ordered, and I need my controller to be 2 part with no spine joining them so I can fit my cooler.
@@GameTechTalk yes, the only reason I got it was because of this iMore review:”You might think it’s strange that we at iMore are reviewing the X4 Aileron. After all, it’s marketed as being made for Android and Xbox. Yet when we asked GameSir about it, they told us it works perfectly well with iOS as well.” Might be worth a second look by you.
@@GameTechTalk yes it does work on IOS but you have to turn on the "Blue" mode, there's a lot more things that this controller can do, which i posted the video, consider checking it out i also recently posted full gameplay on IOS 😊😊
the bsp d8 pro actually works with the nintendo switch. pretty sure it also claims to have hd rumble, would be curious to see you make a review of that product.
It does work for the Switch, tested it. As for the HD Rumble, it is absolute lie OR there is an iteration out there from a different production batch that does. But rest assured, which I'll cover in the review, that the rumble while there, is definitely not HD and definitely sub-par.
@@GameTechTalk ah I was hoping IT was HD rumble. What do you Think about it as a switch controller. Thinking of getting it for the switch. Seems like a way cheaper alternative, for the mobapad m6
@@normanosborn6236 It's decent but not great to be honest. The hold on the Switch, while functional, is not the best. You're much better off with ergonomic ones. If you don't want to dish the price for Mobapads, which I totally get, check out my review on the COIORVIS HD Rumble pads on my channel. They are amazing and considerably more affordable tbh.
@@GameTechTalk ive watch that video like 3 times, and it was very informative and overall great video. But the price is a bit too much for me. What do you think of the nyxi hyperion non pro. I can get it for 30$ or I could also get the Dobe eggshell II (which ive watch your review of). But im Still not sure about cradle style controller.
@@normanosborn6236 The NYXI Hyperion non-Pro are good and would be a better pick for sure. I have a NYXI coupon code, you can use that for an extra discount if you haven't already. I'm pretty sure they have a special event where you can stack rebates right now, I need to make a short video about that actually!
@@GameTechTalk damn. Bought m10 because I tought It was newer, for 42$. Started tô find out about better compatibility and structure durability of the M05. Found one for 25$, but when i went tô cancel m10 order It was already shipped 🤧
@@MrDudumassa The M10 is not bad though. I think you’ll like it still and by the time you feel like replacing it, there just might be considerably better! 😉
Imagine finding out your ride or die for the past 3 years has reviewed a D. The Kishi V2. I thought I had top tier.. what would I do with an S in my possession? lol I need to upgrade.
There is a fair amount of subjectivity when it comes to controllers so it could remain your "by default" despite trying other solutions but with that said... I'd be extremely shocked if none of the S ones would leave you wanting. Honestly, I would suggest that you go EasySMX M05 or M10 if you don't want to have too drastic a change. But if you really wanna go to a completely different tier, get the G8 or G8+. I have a review of the new one on my channel, it's as far as I am concerned, the very first Tier S+ the market has seen. Thanks for commenting btw! :)
@@GameTechTalk I’m definitely leaning on the G8/G8+ , honestly the only reason I’ve been fine with my Kishi is because I lack experience with the much better controllers on this list. I’m sure if I try one I’ll never want to touch this one again lol it’s on its last leg anyway so I do need to upgrade soon. Thanks for the recommendation 🙏 subscribed.
@@CvntForceDrama All I ask, if you do get one or the other (highly recommend going straight for G8+ tbh), please let me know whatever you pick up, how you feel about it! 😁Cheers and thanks for the sub!
Why with every gamesir controller we have to turn on wireless debugging or Through pc to use it, isnt there a controller out there that doesn't do that??
Unfortunately, not that I know of. Basically, GameSir's controller even goes a step further by being able to give the "authorization", which usually requires an external device such as a PC. Btw not every GameSir controller can do that but I know for a fact the X4 Aileron can. With that said, it's bypassing a security measure that Android has in place, I would probably need to test Backbone or Razer, I could see one of the huge companies pay a licensing right to not have to put that effort onto the consumer. Or the other solution is to get one of those gaming centric phones, these have the screen mapping features deeply rooted, you won't find a better "frictionless" solution than dedicated gaming phones/handhelds.
@@GameTechTalk oh I see, a controller that only uses Bluetooth without the need of activation & also uses an app for mapping and all that is not available at the moment Too bad, I'm always on the go so I use mobile data & the Gamesir controller needs WiFi lol
@rolins3279 I definitely prefer the d-pad of the Kishi V1 over the one from the Galileo G8. What I don't like with the G8's d-pad and the ones that do that in general is when the corners are pretty "sharp". I prefer the edges to be rounded, I feel like they land better for longer playtime sessions.
@@GameTechTalk Ok ok I see, so it's more a matter of preference. I'm waiting for the next "G8" which will not need to be modified to handle 8-14" tablets, which will have its type C port on the right, which will have rumble, especially in black.
Thank you to @MrFioz1 for bringing this detail to my attention. The BSP-D8 that I cover is in fact the BSP-D8 Pro, please excuse my mistake as I did not realize there were two different models. Cheers!
I'm very happy to see this video because I just bought the D8 pro and it's the first video where they give it a review and it has a high score!! I bought it for my iPhone.
@@elchg9102 I have received the BSP-D9 and D10 and will be making a video soon comparing all three, stay tuned for that if you want to know more and I'll also go more in-depth on the D8 Pro. Cheers! :)
Yes the D8 was very popular, it was basically the first trully good controller from them to me, the D9 is the D8 but with the PS5/PS Portal looks (which looks hideous IMO) and the one in the video is the D8 Pro which seems to be the one reaching almost Gamesir in terms of build quality, the standard D8 was good but still felt quite cheap and the D8 Pro kinda fixed that. As far as I know the D8 Pro still doesn't have a single video review out, it's very recent so if you want to do a solo quick review of it I think it would do well. Or maybe do a quick look at it in the D10 review.
@@GustavoFil350 Might be a quick and easy review to do! Thanks for the suggestion!
@@GameTechTalk have you tried the asus tessen?
Man I have a G8 in order, looking forward to modding it and playing during summer vacation on my iPad mini 6 on holiday. Can’t wait! Thanks for all the great info!
Pleasure is all mine, it's a fun solution and one I'm sure you'll come to be shocked to see just how viable it can really be! :)
Thank you so much for your love and support on our gamepads and we will try our best to bring more high quality gamepads in the future. ❤❤
You're sitting on good foundations for your product designs EasySMX. Keep up the awesome work!
Please!!!! Add you the Jack audio 3.55 mm in your future telescopic gamepad. Start you for a base like Easysmx m10 o m05 and add you: action key better and with color (a, b, x ,y or playstation key), than interchangebale internal grip for smartphone with cover, feedback aptic, possibility of connect device via bluetooth or type-c always, and possibility to positioned the smartphone in vertical for play DS/3DS game.
Also the different case color: white, black, grey, Red, green, blue, trasparent or clear white-purple-black-acqua blue etc.... in style gameboy color or retroid pocket 4.
Brother is THE most underrated youtuber ever, love the quality content + the constructive criticism and the experience with every single product, this vid is quality on top of quality and can't wait to see more of you
WOW! That comment is heartfelt on my end, I assure you! Thanks @Anubisson that is very pleasant to read on this Sunday afternoon. Cheers and hoping to continue to deliver meaningful and helpful content!
I found this channel a good while back when the G8 Galileo (the goat) released and was shocked at how the nice the production quality of the videos are and how pleasant he is to hear, a real gem of a channel.
For your next tier list, could you mention if a controller is recognized by Call of Duty Mobile (on Android)? I know it’s a very specific thing, but that game has a very weird controller support implementation.
All bluetooth controllers seem to work fine, but hard wired controller support seems to be exclusive to Backbone. Even for controllers that spoof a Dualsense, I can’t find confirmation that they work natively since all footage of them playing the game use button mappers. What’s even more bizarre is that this is not a problem on iOS. Every wired telescopic controller I’ve tried works fine in that game on my iPhone.
My only theory that I can’t confirm yet is that iOS has a better controller protocol so game developers don’t have to do anything to support third party controllers, as long as they support a Dualsense or X-Input. Meanwhile on the Android side, Backbone seems to have worked out a deal to be the only usable wired telescopic controller for that game. It seems very anticompetitive and might mean the only way for a controller to work would be to spoof a Backbone and not a Dualsense.
Sorry for the huge wall of text, but this is now my white whale when it comes to mobile controllers. Because so far no other telescopic controllers work in the game and Backbone refuses to update their design with sticks that are good for a shooter, Android CODM players have just been screwed by this situation for a while.
Sure, great suggestion btw! I went ahead and tested every "wired" telescopic controllers I owned and you were right, they all did not work except the Backbone One, that's crazy!
@@GameTechTalk Yeah, like you said this is my gripe with Backbone as a company. They had a great product at first, now they use their money from that for big marketing pushes and anti competitive stuff like this instead of improving their now outdated controller
Exactly, all the bluetooth controller can spoof as a dualsense/xbox, but it is still bluetooth.
I just know that the wired ones only support backbone after reading ur comment, thats fkd up actually..
Oh yea and i have a question, does wired controller has wireless support too? like if i want to use it for my laptop
@@Fielith To your question, historically? No. However, this seemingly is starting to change and the first controller I've seen do that is EasySMX M05, there may have been more but if so I'm unaware. With that said, there are more controllers that will be coming out VERY SHORTLY that have this feature as well. Stay tuned! ;)
@@GameTechTalk would love to see it!
Excellent effort in this video. Thanks!
Thank you greatly!
🤯😁🙃...
A-O2 Mini LED got leaked at 26:49...in the video...
You are awesome...
With those genius content...
😎👍
It means a lot Gregory, I've been trying to improve my content and output to hopefully grow a bigger audience and find better support from brands, that's the mandatory steps to be able to keep informing gamers of the best gaming solutions out there! Thanks for being part of the journey! ♥
@@GameTechTalk Indeed...😎
Thanks for the vid! I got a bsp awhile ago for $25 to scratch the itch of wanting a phone controller. Now that i came back to it i just have a bigger obsession with these so im looking to upgrade. This list really helps. Im eyeing the gamesir or the easysmx.
Happy I could help, if you are in no rush, I should have a new tier list by the end of the month, you may want to keep your eyes peeled for that one. Also, I would recommend watching my Abxylute S9 review. Cheers!
Why rate a controller A when it only works for one phone? That along should rate it a C or maybe B and that all.
I understand your point of view. Do I wish ASUS had designed the Kunai 3 for every phone? Of course. Technically it does so but only wireless with the center connector.
I didn’t rate them by what they weren’t designed for but rather by what they were. Still, your suggestion is a fair one and something I’ll keep in mind when I do this again. Thanks for watching!
@@GameTechTalk based response honestly
Most people only have one phone so…it’s either good or it functionally doesn’t exist for you. I wouldn’t rate a restaurant in Italy a D tier just because I can’t go there
He makes it very clear why pal. If the controller was universal it would probably be an S.
Also it's not one phone it's a brand of phone. As much as that sucks it's still a quality controller. Worth an A FROM HIS PERSPECTIVE which he made clear too.
I have the x4 Aileron, and for me it's a tier s, THE QUALITY IS PERFECT, SUBLIME EVEN. It's soo good, and the software is also really good, I've never encountered any problem whatsoever, and I've tried it in many phones and even tablets, and the software is perfectly functional.
It's a very robust solution, glad you love it this much! To me it's a specific product for specific gamers and much like I paraphrased when making my review, I knew there would be people exactly like you that find it to be the best controller ever because it does have amazing appeal for the right person!
I love my GamesirX4. It's also a decent computer controller. For those who don't know, it has 2 modes which is gamesirx4(mobile) and Xbox for PC. Not sure if it works on XBOX consoles tho.
Waii whhattt?? I've gone through the manual, I tried shortcuts, I tried plugging it in on PC, sync'ing through Bluetooth, nothing worked. What am I missing? Or is it a firmware update thing? I didn't update it since having reviewed it... 🤔
@@GameTechTalk I didn't see it in the manual. Even their support team on Discord is unaware of this feature 🤣
Hold the Xbox and B button ( 3-4 secs) for the Xbox controller mode and the Blue LED will blink. Xbox and A button to go back to the Gamesir phone mode, white LED should then blink.
You can still use the Xbox mode on mobile but the app will not recognize the gamepad. When on Xbox mode, it should show up as an Xbox controller on your computer.
@@yuunatica9136Sorry to bother, but would you happen to know if the Xbox mode on mobile works with COD Mobile without key mapping?
@@yuunatica9136 Dude, I prostern in front of you! Great freaking find! 👏
@@soumybhow4398 Sorry, I don't play natively on my phone as I use my phone you stream games on my PC. Knowing that their functions are the same, probably not.
Other than Bluetooth options, it appears the only option on this list for foldable phones is the X2S? Just not a fan of the color of it and hoping for something in black and in the same small + slim profile. I currently have a G8 Galileo but am a bit irritated with the Surface Duo screens coming downward rather than up like a traditional DS. I am contemplating the BSP-D8 Pro now that I see it though, especially in black. Great job on the review, it was very insightful.
Yeah unfortunately the left side USB-C is not common at all. But Bluetooth has been better and better. I’d argue that if using a Foldable, best to just go towards that tech by default and there are some PRETTY SEXY options coming out soon that I can’t yet speak about. Rest assured that, this market is growing rapidly and option are becoming more and more in our midst. Lots of amazing things coming in Q3/Q4! 😉
Take a look at the Nacon MG-X pro
@@maximepeladeau5334 I'll look it up, thanks for the suggestion!
Just bought the Galileo G8 it's amazing❤
That it most certainly is! Welcome to the beautiful world of no compromise (or just a little) telescopic gaming. It's such a viable solution that so few people know about still!
About Ipega, just a few months back they came up with a new model (9777s) which copies the design of the Samsung Glap controller, but extends to fit large tables. It has adjustable analog sticks sensitivity, new spring mechanism, and RGB lights. I think those sold a lot that they have to restock. The thing is the restock version is a stripped down version of the original. They removed the sensitivity sliders and changed the spring mechanisms. But still, probably a good affordable alternative to the BSP D8 Pro you've shown here.
Dang, I'm learning more and more about this controller. Lots of comments about it today! Thank you greatly, I'll pay close attention to this.
@@GameTechTalk You're very welcome! btw do you have any plan to check the controllers with built in coolers? Like the Gamesir X3 and BSP D10 Pro. There even the cheaper ones available, namely the Coolshark JK02 and JOHF X5 Mini.
@@ramadhanisantoso2973 Not the X3, but the X3 Pro Aurora that should be coming out late August or September, most definitely yes. As for the BSP-D10, I have it with me, just haven't gotten around to making reviews on them yet. I saw the JK02 and though I was tempted to order one, I'm a bit strapped for time so it's a maybe.
Didn't know about JOHF X5 Mini, I'll look it up, thanks!
@@GameTechTalk Awesome. Looking forward to the video. Thanks!
Thanks so much for the video bro helped me decide on gamesir g8
Glad I could help!
Man i love your video, i love you didnt put the most expensive ones on the top like others do and in fact put cheapest ones higher up
The M05 is a sleeper hit and I think EasySMX are starting to realize they need to give that controller a bit more marketing. Or at least, I hope so. Thanks for your kind words and for watching, out of those 15+ which would you say is your favorite?
@@GameTechTalk i really like the Razer Kishi v1, but im not going to buy that one, so maybe the X2s, i like the cute design
@@guillermocardenaschava8601 They have silent launched the X2s Bluetooth too, loved the color scheme, I'm tempted to pick one up.
@@GameTechTalk i love the color too, but i might go for the usb-c version, i wanna play emulators in long time sessions so maybe charge the controller is not the best for me
Can you make a list of tablet friendly gamepad, BT, so they can be used on Windows tablets like OneXplayer 1 11inch, onexplayer X1 mini, the minisforum V3, LegionGo and so on
That’s a good idea, I’ll keep it mind, thanks!
Thanks it's Great video,
Btw i already have D3 but never used it again, and want to buy X2s, but D8 and easySMX also great
Lots of great options to chose from nowadays!
After Years Trying Telescopic controllers and doing my own testings, my top is:
Gamesir G8 Plus
Gamesir G8 Galileo
Gamesir X4 Aileron
Gamesir X2s
BackBone V2
Backbone V1
RazerKishi V1
Razer Kishi V2 (the worst, in my opinion)
I started with a Razer Kishi V1 than a Backbone V1, and i was amazed with the backbone. Then I got a Razer kishi v2, but you can't use it with a case and the joysticks are awful then the Backbone V2 came out and I was amazed again with backbone, but the first time i tried a Gamesir controller and having the possibility to use a slim case with it and having back buttons with the G8 Galileo i couldn't see my backbone V2 The same way again and i even got a X2S that is even better than the Backbones and cheaper with the hall effect joysticks and for prime day i got the X4 Aileron That can be use with any case after waiting they announced The Gamesir G8+ That You can Use it with a NINTENDO SWITCH making the G8+ the best controller around the globle in my opinión ❤
We have similar tastes and similar pathways. Thanks for watching by the way!
Thanks for taking the time to reply to everyone of your comments. That is truly impressive.
This is the list I was looking for. Currently on a Galaxy Fold phone with a Nacon MGX Pro controller and looking to upgrade to something new. You have me stuck betweem the Kenshi and The Galleo. I am currently checking out your personal reviews for these 2 controllers on your page.
Is there anything out there on a high price point yet? $200+ market
The highest price point remains the Kisha Ultra and it definitely is a solid controller. If you haven’t seen it, check out the G8+, maybe it’ll strike a superior balance for you? Tks for the kind words, much appreciated!
31:06 tier list :3
thanks for this video. please can you recommend any that would fit a tab s8 ultra.
You have to mod to fit that tablet and your options are Galileo G8, Galileo G8+ and the Abxylute S9 (but that you'll have to wait if you back it). I honestly STRONGLY recommend watching my Abxylute S9 review if you haven't seen it. Great opportunity for an amazing deal right now!
So the SMX got rated S without having hall effects, above the Gamesir X2s which has same features plus hall effects. Also I would like to mention I've had an absolutely horrible experience with Razer, Ive used the Kishi V1 and Kishi V2, both broke within my first months. Not putting any money on razer on the controller department ever again. Edit: I am happy you put Kishi V2 at D because it is truly horrible and i totally agree the clickiness feel absolutely wrong. After watching the whole video I will have to checkout the Galileo, too many roses thrown at it.
I hear you, so the thing is, Hall-Effect is not exclusively all better, it does become a question of preference and sure, it is great to prevent stick drift, but not for stick resolution. Not for stick jitter. Not for "raw inputs". At the end of the day, some favor hall-effect and that's perfectly fine and legitimate but ALPS is not exclusively all bad, there are positives too. If you watch my M05 review, I talk a bit more about it. As for Razer... Yup. Haven't necessarily experienced what you have but... Not surprised? 😅
I have a Game sir X2 Pro and while I really like it, I HATE how clicky the face buttons are. They make a lot of noise.
Please answer to me, are the face buttons on the Galileo the same? What about the buttons on the Easymx m10?
Galileo G8 and M10 both have membrane which are definitely more silent and not clicky at all. With that said, the membrane on the G8 is a bit lower pitch, whereas the M10 is a bit higher. For that reason, I'd favor the G8 but it's extremely trivial at this point. Cheers!
Ended up getting the Galileo G8 and the buttons are exactly what I wanted. Happy with it. Thanks!
Yes, yes, yes! 2 videos in 2 days!
You know, he's on that grind! 😄
I wish the gamesir g8 had the charger on the otherside because i got a foldable phone. But i love it.
Yeah, you're not the only one who wish that was a thing.
whats the best for the ipad pro m4 11 inchs hows the latency will use it for competitive gaming
Definitely the Galileo G8, do it requires a bit of modding, it'll serve you the absolute best overall.
Kishi V1 better than the V2 pro? Yeah that's crazy. I own both and the V2 pro was night and day better than the V1
Glad that you like it! I wish I did cause it's not like it was cheap... price-wise that is! 😂
really enjoyed your video very informative. you earned a new sub. keep up the good work
Just out here trying to do the good work, welcome aboard and thank you greatly! 🫡
I personally thinks that the Gamesir X4a is on the S tier because how much it can do, for example it can connect to Android, IOS & PC. Also it got Joycon Mode which you can use the controller as 2 separate controller to play local co-op multiplayer games like Metal Slug or Overcooked.
And then with this feature you can use either single left grip or the right grip to play competitive games like CODM Warzone
Also to mention the Grip Connector & Clip Extender accessories that we can 3D Print. Literally underrated gamepad, Gamesir failed to deliver the correct marketing promotion
Well, you brought a lot of info to me that I didn't even know existed but that is why I gave it an A and also why I had a very positive review on it. You have, in my humble opinion, gave my take all the more validity by showcasing just how niche this controller is, and that is why it pushes this high, don't think of A as being bad, it's pretty impressive when you think of a product that has half a dozen other variant in existence. GameSir is leading (by a large margin) the landslide for this form factor, and that's saying something. But making it an S means that it would cater to every single need in the form factor and I just can't see that to be true.
You don't have a USB-C on both sides, you don't have rumble, you don't have gyro, you don't have wired connectivity, you don't have a candy bar connection in the box, there are a lot of ways that this controller could improve as a market solution, but in the current shape and form that it is? I think it corners every "mandatory" aspects that consumers looking for this solution would want. I hope my scoring makes more sense now but the good news, because it has such a loving community behind it, you can take it from an A and bring it all the way up to an S, and that is awesome, let's hope GameSir will give you that S out-of-the-box for future versions! :)
Best one for iphone 15 pro max please ?
As of today, I'd say Galileo G8+, especially in light of the new data that just got covered on my channel. If you are looking for small form-factor, I might go Scuf but that review is not out yet, though I do have the product with me. Cheers!
Will you be reviewing IPEGA 9777s? It sells well in my country but I don't find many people talk about it, hoping that you will put your hands on it 🙏
I will not at this point in time as I never ordered that controller, sorry. :(
EasySMX just launched the M15, looks like a G8 Galileo clone. Would love to see a review/comparison with that one. Appreciate the comparisons, thanks!
Not to worry, I got you! 🫡
@@GameTechTalk I couldn't wait, lol. I just scored one for $25. Still looking forward to your review.
@@CSagan710 Oh for sure my dude, at that price, I don't see how one could go wrong! My unit should arrive today, hopefully, I'll have a hands-on in the coming days if not hours! :)
Do you know any bluetooth android controllers that is quiet or without the clicky sound on the buttons?
The G8 and G8+ are quite muted, so is the Abxylute S9, but no sound at all is pretty much guaranteed to require a mod of some kind.
Excellent vidéo
Merci!
this video is so well done,
Thank you so very much!
Just the video I was looking for !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Happy to oblige and serve the community! Thanks for watching and engaging! :)
Very interesting video. I'm looking for a telescopic controller to play in android and Windows using Bluetooth. What is the best option?
Hard to give you that answer right now because we are right in the middle of having new models. I'm literally in the middle of filming a video for one and I have at least 2 more to film in the coming month, if not three. M15 and G8+ are safe bets but I'd sit at least a few days to see the reviews. The new tier list will come out in late September, if not mid. Cheers!
@GameTechTalk thanks for your reply. I'm not sure if g8+ works on pc using bt. On their website, only pc with usb-c is shown. I'm trying to contact the gamesir support to confirm. Thank you again, and I can wait for the new update video.
@@gabrielmenezes7237 Yes, it does work using wire! :)
I really wish more of the wired controllers like G8 etc had the type C connector on the left like the X2s. In a year-ish i'd like to get a OnePlus Open (maybe their Open 2 will be out), and the connector on the left is less awkward/more folding phone friendly with the result of the top of the screen being above the controller IMO. Rather than bottom of the screen being below the controller.
Yeah, unfortunately, very few controllers do, basically just the X2s as far as I know. With a bit of DIY, you might be able to reroute a cable to the G8+ though.
I'd say the bsp d3 should have been at least a b. It's pretty good for its price. It works via Bluetooth for android and ios, and can be used wited to a PC. battery life is good as well. Sure it doesn't have some features like analog triggers, it's still really good for its price.
The way I look at it is, it’s not. It’s hardly good at all. But for its price? It’s good. I realize I’m just flipping your words but I do think it changes the meaning of how to perceive this device.
Someone said it very well in the comments, great solution to dip your toes into the market but that should be where it ends in my personal opinion.
If you think about it, 2 BSP-D3 get you a BSP-D8 Pro pretty much, now that’s a great deal. However, during the time that the D3 was released? I would’ve rated it higher because at that time, there weren’t that many options in the low price point. For that, we can all be thankful for the D3 and I certainly am.
somebody knows how to pause usb power delivery on samsung when using a controller? i am using easysmx m15 connected to my s24 ultra and i have a pd 30w charger but for me its not showing its always charing its not enabled but without the controller i can enable it please help... because that feature is useless if cannot be worked with a controller
Interesting that you left out if they need to be charged, I only have 1 telescopic controller Gamesir Galileo G8 and it feels like what a controller should feel like, except for one downside that the buttons are nearly completely vertical with the sticks even though it's shaped in a way that could allow it.
Most telescopic controllers are plugged in but you are right with the BSP-D8 Pro at least, that one is battery and do need to be charged. Thanks for pointing it out, I'll make sure to mention it when I do this again. As for the sticks, I like them slightly off as well but seeing as the Galileo has a large enough ergo grip, I find that to be more trivial than on something like a retro handheld or a joycon, you know something with a slimmer profile. Cheers and thanks for engaging!
You do really good reveiws . I have a question thoe. Whats the best all around controller for steamdeck? Say under $ 100.
I'd give 3 options. KK3 Max, Apex 3 and Sony Dualsense.
Thx 👍
i have a magbak case on my s24 ultra and i saw somewhere that s24 ultra with a case is a no go for the easysmx m05. Is tha correct?
I do not have the combination that you mentioned but I can attest to not being able to use the M05 with the case on my Fold 4 and it’s a fairly slim case. With that said, the ultra slim on my iPhone 15 works just fine.
Thanks for this, man. I was torn between the EasySMXM05 and the EasySMXM10. Despite me not necessarily liking the overall boxy shape of the M05, I can definitely see that it is the better option compared to the M10. I just bought it off of Amazon for only $42. Such a great product for its price tag and is maybe even on par with the controllers that are closer to $100
Totally! And I assure you, it's not my go-to shape either but like Shem said (RetroBreeze), somehow they managed to make it feel different despite looking like other controllers of that same type. I think that perfectly sums up how I feel about the EasySMX M05 shape and I would add that the differences it has makes it more comfortable than the options it looks like. Cheers!
@@GameTechTalkYa, that's very true. Keep up with the amazing videos. Ther're very, very informative but also fun to watch.
@@GameTechTalkSo sorry to bother you again, but now Im wondering if I should have gotten the Gamesir x2s instead of thr Easysmx M05. Which one would you think is better. The x2s looks a little small in terms of overall buttons, but has a better look
@@GameTechTalkAlso, is hall effect needed on controllers? And what exactly does it even do? Ive heard other reveiws talk about hall effect but I was confused what that even meant. Since the M05 doesnt have hall effect, would that make it a lesser controlller or no?
@@danieloku7560 Don't worry, you don't bother me at all, I was editing and taking a break before the last stretch! The X2s has one very specific advantage over the M05 and it is the fact that you can stretch it for a tablet mode. If that is not important for you, don't bother. Otherwise, the M05 is pretty much on all front a superior product as far as I am concerned.
u got my subss broo!!
😊 Thank you greatly, glad to have you join!
@@GameTechTalk broo my hands is small so i need lightweight gamepad for android. what would u recommend bro?
@@Semuskid If you want small but that feel full-size like console controllers, go EasySMX M15 (or Memo S3 same thing). It's light, small and very very great feature-wise, the price is also quite affordable.
@@GameTechTalk thanks sensei!!
Very good video mate
Thank you greatly! I'm excited to re-do these in the future! :)
@@GameTechTalk I was also fan of these. Had kinda 4 of them. But eventually moved to Steam Deck
pretty sure that's the bsp d8 pro and not the original d8, pretty different devices
Ahhh... You are absolutely right, my apologies as I didn't even realize there were two different SKUs! Thanks
I want something low profile that I can just throw in my bag. I am currently using an 8bitdo zero 2 but would like something similar that can connect to my phone with just a d pad and a few face buttons.
That is telescopic or not necessarily? Because indeed, in the low profile department, 8BitDo takes the cake, even with options such as the SN30 Pro with a phone clip.
@@GameTechTalk there is no telescoping with the zero 2. It’s just a tiny controller I toss in my bag. For holding my phone I have a mag safe wallet that doubles as a phone stand.
I haven't even watched it yet lad and I'm excited.
Lots of work went into that one, but the filming part was so much fun! It felt like just casually having a chat with a friend, so for you to be excited to watch it, it's very much that conversation happening on the other end! 😊 Thanks for being here for it; it wouldn't be the same otherwise!
@@GameTechTalk It turned out brilliant lad! Great great list.
Great video !
Thank you for tuning in!
Are you gonna update the list when the Scuf Nomad comes out this summer?
That would be the goal, probably not gonna make another tier list but I will review the Scuf Nomad and when I do, I will say in that review where I would slot it in the tier list. Cheers!
Hello! Thanks for the video, I'm liking the x2s but in your opinion whats the most portable one that can be charged and with type C connector.
That's a big ask and one currently not in existence basically. The closest to what you are saying is the M05 because it has the connector, it has antennas but it has no battery! :3 Maybe it could be modded with one but I'll leave that to the bawss tinkerer Shem from RetroBreeze!
Otherwise, it's usually one or the other, not both. The one exception is the MOGA XP-7 Plus that I talk about in this video but it's not a USB-C connector, a big disappointment to be honest. If I was MOGA, I'd do a revised unit with USB-C and rumble because otherwise, It was an AMAZING product!
BSP could also surprise us all with an D11 model but they said that product line was done so time will tell.
@@GameTechTalk i am getting the kishi v1 for around 50 euros. Should I get that. It does meet some of my portability and type C requirements. I'm only afraid if it's durable and has any connectivity issues. If you can tell me about this. Thanks for replying :)
I have a s21+
@@gatebreaker44 The Kishi V1 is surprisingly good, you'll probably just want to add some type of holder to keep it more stable on your phone but by no means is it a bad controller, quite the opposite.
The one concern I have for you though to be honest, 50 euros seem a bit steep for that controller seeing as it's probably no longer in production? Are you not able to get it cheaper?
@@GameTechTalk Europe is expensive in general, I don't think so, even the g8 is 80 euros.
Can you explain what you mean by a pad?
Also I've had a gamesir X2pro before and my software experience with it was really bad. Key mapping was a no go essentially. That's why I thought I may as well get the V1 where there is also probably no key mapping but at least hopefully there is no connection issues.
loved this video. about time someone made a modern update to mobile gaming controllers as that market is growing fast with many AAA titles coming out recently and more coming in the future. my fav in the list is the razer kishi ultra. its very similar to the G8. but the big selling point of the razer is that USB C external plug in to a pc or a 13 inch ipad pro.
that way i dont have to carry around 2 controllers.
i can just have the kishi ultra. play on my iphone 15 pro. then if i wanna switch to my ipad pro. I can just plug it in hard wired via USB-C. great feature. sure the 150usd is quite alot of money. but the razer has haptics which the G8 does not. so with that the price can be a bit more justified. and also G8 dont have the external USB-C plug in like the razer one has.
i did test. and nothing happens it just blinks. like it has power but no data signal is coming through. the G8 only has the USB-C for input charging it seems.
The G8 does have external support but you need to use a USB-C female to USB-A male (or USB-C male) which is not a cable most people usually have lying around. You plug the female part on the male of the G8 that usually plugs into the phone/tablet you're using.
Thanks for the kind words by the way, I really enjoyed doing this video and I already have a few brands contacting me with future models (that I'll be reviewing of course) but I'm already contemplating making a follow up video for maybe Q4. Until then, thanks a lot, I'm glad to know it was enjoyable to you! :)
Backbone can do this too and through the charging port, so no weird adapter cables. Unfortunately they charge you a subscription fee to do it. The only reason I keep mine around is because I have a lifetime access to Backbone subscription due to lucking out and getting the controller just months before they switched to a subscription model.
Easysmx m15 alread out. Wait for ur review. I think it can compete with galileo
Look out for the 20th! 🫡
Great video, you've got a new subscriber. I'm actually thinking about the ipega pg-9777s since it can stretch too fit my 12.6 inch tablet. Cheap enough at around $45 CAD, so i might take a chance with it. Fingers crossed.
I'll first mention that I have not laid hands on the iPega 9777. With that said, I have had multiple viewers report back to me that it was best to steer clear from it, that it basically was terrible in fact. As the audience trusts me, I decided to trust them 😂. With that said, I do have the BSP-D8 Pro, D9 and D10. I would recommend turning towards one of those instead. I am planning to do a video on them shortly.
@@GameTechTalk thanks for the quick response! I’m not sure it the 9777s is similar to the normal 9777, cause the S version seems to have a different layout and has dials to adjust rocker sensitivity, which I think is pretty cool if it actually works well.
Looking forward to your video on those BSP controllers! Your review on the Galileo G8 Plus definitely has me contemplating splurging a bit more for it 😂
@@KevinDeLeon91 Ahhh, yeah that could very well be the case. If 9777s is new, that's definitely not the model I heard about because those comments I'm referring to are from a few months back. I'm gonna try to look this up, maybe there is a review opportunity, I'd like iPega to somehow make it back into the market, effectively so, they were a staple at some point.
Thanks for being here, I appreciate the support!
@@GameTechTalk thanks man, I appreciate it. Glad I stumbled upon your videos. Been watching a bunch of them all day during my workday😂
who is the best for fps game ? dead zone sensitive for aimming ?
It’s questionable. I’ve always been a big believer in raw inputs but raw means the missteps and mistakes are also more captured. So much like dead zones eliminate the raw input jitter at base value, too much sensitivity is like bringing that jitter back on stick travel.
Cheers!
Compared to the wired, how is the delay with the bluetooth connection with those gamepad?
Wired is from 8ms to 2ms so far that I've seen on the telescopic market. I'd say 95% are 8ms, the 4 and 2ms are just starting to appear, very uncommon. For bluetooth, it goes from 15ms to approximately 3ms. So that depends, and there are far worst too when it comes to bluetooth but that range is from 1 year old released controllers on average. Right now, the best controller I've tested bluetooth is the G8+, I have a review on my channel and it'll be part of the next tierlist video which will probably be around september. Cheers!
You should tell that's the pro version, i almost bought the baseline D8 because of that
Yeah my apology, it was pointed out to me and guaranteed that I’ll do better next time, thanks!
Which one is best EasySMX M10 or GameSir X2S ? I have 13 pro max so lighting is downfall for now lol this will be first gaming controller. Would love your feedback.
I speaking about GameSir x2s new blue and black control
Yeah I figured you meant the X2s Bluetooth, the new model. Quite frankly, I would go X2s Bluetooth. As much as I know the Lightning M10 will work. Once you upgrade your phone, it’ll become e-waste. As for the X2s Bluetooth, it’ll still be good after. They are both ok but to me the X2s is the better product of the two and also, it spoofs as Dualsense which works better with iOS than spoofing Xbox 360 wireless (which M10 does). The M10 only advantage are the two extra paddles but they aren’t in the ideal position for most people.
My vote is X2s Bluetooth personally, and I love the colors!
@@GameTechTalkthanks that’s I will go go with !!! Thanks 🙏 for advice love your content your have now loyal subscribers 😊
One Last question!! What the best lighting or Bluetooth controller for iPhone?
@@santijr007 Arguably, lighting could be better because of lower latency but with iOS releasing Game Mode extremely shortly, Bluetooth connections will be getting a boost. Also, the difference on everyday use should be trivial, that is why I would recommend to go "function over form" by going Bluetooth.
Technically, you do have to keep a battery charged but I would expect that to be minimal effort. Cheers, keep the questions coming if you have more, always happy to help! :)
I have a G8, but honestly considering the Kishi ultra so I don't have to deal with an app that's marked as malware, needing to turn on/off the controller to get it recognised. Feels like it would also be better in touch emulation (have some annoyances in wuthering waves with the G8) and has a bit more space between the right joystick and buttons
The Kishi Ultra is great. If you're ok with the premium cost, it definitely is a solid option and still top podium in the current landscape.
Would G8+ fall in S like the G8?
Not under that category for sure. But for the upcoming updated list video, I would like to rank them within categories, still debating on that but thinking it'll be a thing.
Would you pick TB Atom or Kishi v2 pro for $50!!
I'm leaning towards the Atom, especially if you see value in being able to split your controllers. If not, the Kishi V2 Pro does have more features like rumble, 3.5mm jack, wired support.
Does backbone left side of the controler stop working after using it with headphones?
It shouldn’t no. If you have a Backbone that does that, it is defective.
@@GameTechTalk I have 2. Black and Playstation edition. My Wife plays with headphones and started to get defected. My still worked fine. Then she played with the Playstation with headphone. It defected too.
@@angelgnievestorres5769 Hmmm. So some headphones flip the polarities, Apple was notorious for doing that. Maybe that’s what caused an issue with the controller? Sorry I wouldn’t know more or anything at all about that issue but I would strongly recommend that you reach out to Backbone as soon as possible. That is not normal.
@@GameTechTalk Yes I have contacted them. it Happend on Both controlers. Thats not normal
which one do you think is better for retro games? easy smx m05 or m10?
M05 easy, better polling rate, more features, just as ergonomically comfortable and even less expensive if shopping around.
@@GameTechTalk ty, i was looking for a controller to play retro games like Super Nintendo, im buying this one today
@renanwz5747 If you get the chance, let me know if you like it when you get it! Cheers and thank you for your trust!
If they invent one that has Qi Charging combined with a Cooler, like the Oppo 45w liquid cooler magsafe charger.
Like a controller combined with a Blackshark Fun Cooler 4 pro, it would be a winner by my standards!
I'd love to try that controller for sure! Technically for Qi Charging, the MOGA XP-7 Pro does do that and I don't know when that happened but I tried it the other day and it worked on iOS (it didn't before). I might even make a video about that!
I love the quality content, as usual
It means so much, thanks!
One thing that I always want to know because it's make or break on these controllers is the right thumbstick placement. It's always too low. It's the main thing that keeps me from love the Galileo G8.
You know, lately I've been wanting to see a controller try to have symmetrical sticks but over rather than under or assymetrical, much like the Steam Deck type of thing. I think that could definitely work and the way I see it, sticks maneuvers are way more "cramp inducing" than buttons, so by having them over, I think it would greatly improve the "long session" usage of some of these controllers. Do you think that could be an interesting solution?
@@GameTechTalkthe BSP-D9 has symmetrical sticks that are definitely not very low relative to the D-pad and face buttons, since the D9 is a clone of the the DualSense design. Even the Steam Deck's sticks are slightly below the D-pad/buttons, not above them.
@@ydgmdlu I meant the upper portion of the available footprint, not necessarily the order from top to bottom of sticks and buttons. However, on a traditional controller, due to available space, if the sticks were to be over, the buttons would most likely be under. Sorry for the confusion.
I still use the razor kishi v1 and still really enjoy it !
That controller did a lot right, glad to know you're getting so much game time from it!
I wonder how you feel about the gamevice flex, if you've ever had one
I never did and it seems they stopped producing it too, sold out, couldn’t even find the listing on Amazon Canada. Maybe they have a newer model coming out shortly? 🤷🏾
Galileio is such a bang for your buck. I just wish more of these are made for tablets.
I did the retrobreeze mod for the G8 and it can fit anything now, the only thing missing is the rumble but I don't really miss it.
What is the most pocketable one?
I'd say Backbone One probably, those rounded corners fit quite nicely in pockets, real talk. However, the sticks do poke out and feel a bit more flimsy than full-sized ones, purely impressions mind you but still, I'd say it's the most pocketable.
For me I love gamesir X3 controller because it has cooling system for the phone, and also because I got one for me 😂
Well, I hopefully will have something to hopefully sway you with in the coming weeks! 😎
i was suprised that you didnt mention Backbone gen. 2
Because the difference, while nice and important for some people, was too little. At least in my opinion. It’s more of a gen 1.1 than a gen 2 from where I stand but I understand marketability. I didnt buy the gen 2, but whenever (if ever) there will be a proper new model, I’ll be happy and excited to review it.
Bro try the Memo S3 or S2, no body has Made a Review yet, pls.
It'll come, guaranteed! :)
Do very much enjoy my G8 but the 3.5 mm port never works with my Pixel 6. I also wish that data could be transmitted through the USB c port so I could connect to ethernet wile using the device. Otherwise good list, though I'm curious how the M-Con will fit into this list when it is eventually released.
I'd love to hear back from the creator, I tried to reach out but I'm small time and I can't imagine how much buzz the controller generated. Either way, I'll get my hands on the M-Con as soon as it is possible.
would the backbone and kishi ultra work for a Samsung A55? i really wanna know so i can buy one.
Sure, they both will, the A55 supports OTG so you can connect a controller no problem.
I was in the initial hype with the G8, but the lack of app support to configure the stick dead zones became a deal breaker for me personally. The more I play with it the more annoyed I get and I don't feel about using it anymore. Playing warzone, AC Mirage and other similar games makes it pretty noticeable how much you need to move the sticks until movement is registered! Horrible.
Scuf nomad is next on my list even though I am concerned about the BT connection. Not because of BT that is not a problem for me. It is because I won't be able to charge my phone while playing unless I remove it from the controller. Anyway, some high expectations there.
GameSir do not seem to have managed to establish a "buddy buddy" relationship with Apple but I think they are actively trying. That iPad Pro controller is one indication, but also, there is a Galileo G8 MFi edition that was shown at CES but we haven't heard since, all white, so sexy. I really think GameSir is trying to appeal to Apple but until Apple agrees, that is the number one reason for the app on iOS to really be COMPLETELY different than on Android. Everything you just said? You can do all of it and so much more... on Android.
So yeah, I get where you're coming from and I sincerely hope GameSir and Apple can figure things out because more options is best for buyers. As for Nomad... you know I'm already on it! 😉
Review the elo vagabond please ! I would love to see your opinions about it❤ 😊.
If they reach out I'd love the opportunity to review their products but as I don't own it, that ship might have sailed for me and a future model would make more sense to review. Thanks for the suggestion though!
Odd request, but which controller is the most quiet? Button mashing at night annoys my wife. I currently use the Kishi v1
I was going to say, the Kishi V1 is definitely up there in most quiet, the problem is even the membrane quiet ones will do a bit of noise. But if not the Kishi V1, I'd argue that the Galileo G8 is up there, the membrane is a bit "low pitch" so by being more of a low frequency sound, I find you tend to hear it less than others but for a proper "less noise" experience, you'd most likely have to mod it to dampen the sound even more, something I haven't tried.
Cheers!
@@GameTechTalk Thanks. I'll try it out!
The gamesir 4 (own one) is on a own tier since I don't care if u have galaxy s24 ultra or iphone pro max15, ur phone will be an over in no time playing heavy games.
U need the cooling
I hear you. You’re not the first person to address this issue. I guess I do live in a cold country and have a constant cold temperature in my living space. I’ll try to consider that in the future as I personally have not encountered that issue in quite some time and I have done some LENGTHY sessions.
What’s the best option for iPhone 14 Pro Max
With the G8+ now out (which got released after this video released), I'd be 100% recommending that one. I have a review on my channel if you want to learn more about it, as well as a follow-up mod video. Highly recommend watching both!
Kishi v2, stopped working, wouldn’t connect to phone after a dew months.
Ahh dang, sorry to hear. And to think that this controller is not even cheap in price. I hope you have a warranty at least.
@@GameTechTalk the warranty was its own saga. I ended up getting g8 and letting that be that.
Should’ve waited for the Scuf nomad. Looks like it’s the best one out of all these, they listened to their customers wants.
By making a controller that only supports iPhone, not Android? That's aIready a bad stance from where I stand, not everyone is iOS locked. However, I have every intention of loving the Nomad if it is as good as I'm hoping it will be. But I'll believe it when I see it, Scuf has a reputation of overpromising and underdelivering. With that said, the Nomad will get its review and when the time is right, a new tierlist will happen, I really enjoyed doing it.
@@GameTechTalk yes I agree it’s weird that it’s Bluetooth but only iOS. Maybe they’re testing the waters, and releasing an android down the road or making the BT protocol on the nomad android compatible. Scuf has a bad rep online but also, any products that people are dissatisfied with they will let others know, but a positive experience most people will not go online and leave a review.
@@YanFries@YanFries I agree wholeheartedly on people being more vocal about bad experiences than good ones, but as someone that hangs in the "nerd tests everything" kind of forums (I'm one myself 😅), I'm talking more from an objective performance point-of-view, though the hardware seems to often be a point of contention as well. With that said, I'll always form my own opinion and Turtle Beach lately is a great example of that, they also don't always get the best rep and sure, it's not a perfect product but I still was able to give it credit, I'm hoping to be able to do the same with Scuf. Time will tell!
Cheers and thanks for the chat, always fun to share experiences with fellow gamers!
@@YanFriesYeah saying that controller is the best overall is jumping the gun a bit for 3 reasons
1. It’s iOS only
2. It’s bluetooth and not hard wired
3. It has the Xbox Pro D-Pad style
It looks like a very solid controller, but these alone will make it a nonstarter for a lot of people, myself included.
@@terribletimes902 spawnpoiint just made a video on it. Fantastic.
I think 1. It’ll be compatible with android through firmware update I’m sure but who knows.
2. Bluetooth doesn’t look like that big of a deal
3. Some prefer it.
Also look at the positives, the camera bumps don’t matter and neither does case removal
Gamesir x4 aileron is for hardcore gamer playing with phone cooler attached. Very specific market but it's prob the best.
Lots of people love that feature for that specific reason for sure. GameSir is preparing a pretty interesting product that will provide it all though!
Which controller can be use on both android and iso and still has bluetooth connection and is compatible with all game including pubG Mobile...ect
When you say type-C, do you mean that has a connector to connect directly to the controller? Because if so, the only one will be the EasySMX M05.
Controller don’t usually have the wired connector AND radio antenna. That’s an anomaly of the M05 essentially. If you mean it’s wireless but charges with USB-C I would recommend either the X2s Bluetooth or the G8+ that I released a review for yesterday. Cheers!
I think I ask the question wrong which one can connect to both android and ISO and charge using type c and is compatible with pubg and the other top games other their?
Are all of these compatible with Xbox & ect?
No, in fact, most to not say all aren't. Telescopic controllers that are "licensed by Microsoft" is more to say it's guaranteed to work on XCloud but most telescopics controllers do anyway.
@@GameTechTalk so is there a video or any info by chance telling us which controller is compatible with Xbox/PS & ect? Or no cause I’ve been looking for a mobile gaming controller so I can play Xbox for curtain situations like when I don’t have my Xbox with me but I still wanna play it
@@saraibeeman5518 So, unfortunately, these controllers are not designed to run on native hardware. Spoofing does give third-party solutions the "information" they need to let these controllers in but first party hardware usually have tighter verifications.
In other words, an actual Xbox console will work with very few controllers, because they tightly monitor what is plugged on their devices, same for Playstation. Nintendo Switch would've been the same but they were massively cracked which led to a floodgate of third party solutions fully compatible, it is by far the exception, not the rule.
So with that information, it is best to assume that all telescopic controllers do not work on native consoles (with the one exception being Switch for *some* controllers).
You, my friend, are me but with ambition to make quality videos. I have a couple on my channel that are dumb but I love them
Thanks and hey, trust me, it's a challenge every day. Still is after 100+ videos. It's a long and arduous road but it all comes down to showing up, if you can do that, the rest will follow. It's learning to appreciate, love the process with the acceptance that it could lead to none other than letting out creativity. It's a balancing act but the closer I get to doing it, the better I seem to be doing. I'll tune in to your stuff when I have a bit of free time, thanks for engaging! 😊
@@GameTechTalk no prob man. Keep up the good work
Where did you get that iPad shortcut sticker?
On Amazon, look for Synerlogic iPad Shortcut stickers
@@GameTechTalk sweet, thanks!
Is there any with this list controllers who have illuminated buttons ? Or is other WHO have it?
None in this list and now that you mention it, I can't think of one that does in the telescopic mobile space if being perfectly honest. Maybe something to do with not cause any more strain on connected device's batteries, or their own if it is a wireless controller? Fine observation from you, I'll keep my eyes peeled in case. Cheers!
Backbone makes 0 sense when the G8 costs exactly the same on Amazon (actually less sometimes) and is miles better.
Totally! I hope they are designing a new product because it’s becoming absurd at this point.
@@GameTechTalk The only thing I hate is that you can't disable the bright LED lights (which sucks for playing in bed at night) and I wish the sticks were a little tighter like the Xbox gamepad. The sticks feel kinda loose.
@@BryceCzirr-jz7ju They are looser indeed, it's a comment I get fairly often from people wishing they were a bit more tight.
@@GameTechTalk I am curious if attempting to swap the sticks to ones from a console gamepad would help any.
I imagine the tightness isn't from the sticks themselves but the device the sticks attach to, maybe the bands could be swapped for tighter ones.
@@BryceCzirr-jz7ju Most definitely that it would, the tension is a physical component to the sticks. It probably wouldn't be this hard too, the challenge would most likely be to just find a stick that is compatible with the controller's calibration process. So ideally, same make, same manufacturer, different tightness.
Can anybody confirm that the kunia 3 doesn't work on the red magic 9s? That phone has crazy compatibility features..
I don't have the 9s but maybe I can assist? Do you mean the screen mapping? The thing is, you can map with Redmagic 8 Pros using non-Redmagic controllers, so as long as it's compatible, you are set but using other features for mapping specifically past Redmagic's own software seems to be where the problem stems from.
Anywho, happy to test whatever you may need, just tell me what it is exactly what you need to know and I'll do my best. Cheers! :)
@@GameTechTalk I meant the kunia 3. I wouldn't at all surprise me if the red magic 9 really was just that backwards compatible..
@@Pixel8080YT Interesting! The Kunai 3 does have the connector off to the side so if it is the case for the Red Magic 9 too, it just might. As far as I can tell, every ROG Phones have a "non-centered" USB connector, which was the sole reason why compatibility of that controller was null. But with the right wire, it did work elsewhere, including on PC.
@@GameTechTalk I haven't found backbone yet that doesn't work seamlessly with the 9 s. Mostly because of the built in mapping system.
Of all the controller the X4 Aileron is the superior one for me and my iPhone 15 Pro Max.
Why? Simply because iPhone now runs AAA games and where I live the climate is very hot. So my device becomes a lava brick, specifically with Resident Evil, Death Stranding or AC: Mirage type of games.
So I need a phone cooler like the BlackShark Fun Cooler 4 Pro I just ordered, and I need my controller to be 2 part with no spine joining them so I can fit my cooler.
Wait wait wait... the X4 Aileron works on your iPhone?!? It didn't work on mine when I tested it, was there a firmware patch that fixed that?
@@GameTechTalk yes, the only reason I got it was because of this iMore review:”You might think it’s strange that we at iMore are reviewing the X4 Aileron. After all, it’s marketed as being made for Android and Xbox. Yet when we asked GameSir about it, they told us it works perfectly well with iOS as well.”
Might be worth a second look by you.
@@Chris.Morales Interesting, I'll give it a look when I can. Thanks for mentioning it!
@@GameTechTalk yes it does work on IOS but you have to turn on the "Blue" mode, there's a lot more things that this controller can do, which i posted the video, consider checking it out i also recently posted full gameplay on IOS 😊😊
the bsp d8 pro actually works with the nintendo switch. pretty sure it also claims to have hd rumble, would be curious to see you make a review of that product.
It does work for the Switch, tested it. As for the HD Rumble, it is absolute lie OR there is an iteration out there from a different production batch that does. But rest assured, which I'll cover in the review, that the rumble while there, is definitely not HD and definitely sub-par.
@@GameTechTalk ah I was hoping IT was HD rumble. What do you Think about it as a switch controller. Thinking of getting it for the switch. Seems like a way cheaper alternative, for the mobapad m6
@@normanosborn6236 It's decent but not great to be honest. The hold on the Switch, while functional, is not the best. You're much better off with ergonomic ones. If you don't want to dish the price for Mobapads, which I totally get, check out my review on the COIORVIS HD Rumble pads on my channel. They are amazing and considerably more affordable tbh.
@@GameTechTalk ive watch that video like 3 times, and it was very informative and overall great video. But the price is a bit too much for me. What do you think of the nyxi hyperion non pro. I can get it for 30$ or I could also get the Dobe eggshell II (which ive watch your review of). But im Still not sure about cradle style controller.
@@normanosborn6236 The NYXI Hyperion non-Pro are good and would be a better pick for sure. I have a NYXI coupon code, you can use that for an extra discount if you haven't already. I'm pretty sure they have a special event where you can stack rebates right now, I need to make a short video about that actually!
Just a heads up rhat is not the d8 that is the d8 pro, costs a bit more 👍
Thanks! A few people did point it out, sorry for my mistake by the way!
Im very in doubt of picking a D8 (not pro) for 30$ or a M10 for 45$. This 15$ difference is a bit big for me. Anyway
Get the m05 or d8
I personally think between the two, the D8 still remains the better pick. Just don’t rough it up too much and it’ll stay the course.
@@GameTechTalk damn. Bought m10 because I tought It was newer, for 42$. Started tô find out about better compatibility and structure durability of the M05. Found one for 25$, but when i went tô cancel m10 order It was already shipped 🤧
@@MrDudumassa The M10 is not bad though. I think you’ll like it still and by the time you feel like replacing it, there just might be considerably better! 😉
@@GameTechTalk thank you for answer. I realize now that m05 can connect directly tô computar via blutooh
Imagine finding out your ride or die for the past 3 years has reviewed a D. The Kishi V2. I thought I had top tier.. what would I do with an S in my possession? lol I need to upgrade.
There is a fair amount of subjectivity when it comes to controllers so it could remain your "by default" despite trying other solutions but with that said... I'd be extremely shocked if none of the S ones would leave you wanting. Honestly, I would suggest that you go EasySMX M05 or M10 if you don't want to have too drastic a change. But if you really wanna go to a completely different tier, get the G8 or G8+. I have a review of the new one on my channel, it's as far as I am concerned, the very first Tier S+ the market has seen. Thanks for commenting btw! :)
@@GameTechTalk I’m definitely leaning on the G8/G8+ , honestly the only reason I’ve been fine with my Kishi is because I lack experience with the much better controllers on this list. I’m sure if I try one I’ll never want to touch this one again lol it’s on its last leg anyway so I do need to upgrade soon. Thanks for the recommendation 🙏 subscribed.
@@CvntForceDrama All I ask, if you do get one or the other (highly recommend going straight for G8+ tbh), please let me know whatever you pick up, how you feel about it! 😁Cheers and thanks for the sub!
Why with every gamesir controller we have to turn on wireless debugging or Through pc to use it, isnt there a controller out there that doesn't do that??
Unfortunately, not that I know of. Basically, GameSir's controller even goes a step further by being able to give the "authorization", which usually requires an external device such as a PC. Btw not every GameSir controller can do that but I know for a fact the X4 Aileron can. With that said, it's bypassing a security measure that Android has in place, I would probably need to test Backbone or Razer, I could see one of the huge companies pay a licensing right to not have to put that effort onto the consumer. Or the other solution is to get one of those gaming centric phones, these have the screen mapping features deeply rooted, you won't find a better "frictionless" solution than dedicated gaming phones/handhelds.
@@GameTechTalk oh I see, a controller that only uses Bluetooth without the need of activation & also uses an app for mapping and all that is not available at the moment
Too bad, I'm always on the go so I use mobile data & the Gamesir controller needs WiFi lol
I'm really quite surprised that you find the D-pads of the Kishi V1 and the Galileo G8 average 🤔
@rolins3279 I definitely prefer the d-pad of the Kishi V1 over the one from the Galileo G8. What I don't like with the G8's d-pad and the ones that do that in general is when the corners are pretty "sharp". I prefer the edges to be rounded, I feel like they land better for longer playtime sessions.
Thanks for engaging @vastorogis !
@@GameTechTalk Ok ok I see, so it's more a matter of preference.
I'm waiting for the next "G8" which will not need to be modified to handle 8-14" tablets, which will have its type C port on the right, which will have rumble, especially in black.
The BSP D3 is more for wet your feet in the mobile controller life, yes cheap? Yes, but for a reason, comparing him with this other is kinda unfair
Very well said about making your feet wet.