Hamilton Eliza Comparison-Burn
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- I got all the portrayals of Eliza that I could find. If a certain actress is not on here, it is because I couldn't find audio/video. I do not own the audio/video, all the credit goes to the rightful owners.
I love that five of these ladies were used for the recording of First Burn - up until now I thought it was random but it makes it so much better that they all portrayed Eliza at some point
0:00 Philippa Soo
0:53 Ari Afsar
1:46 Lexi Lawson
2:48 Sydnee Winters
3:43 Solea Pfeiffer
4:44 Rachelle Ann Go
5:37 Julia Harriman
6:33 Shoba Narayan
7:25 Erin Clemons
8:21 Isa Briones
9:15 Zoe Jensen
10:11 Sharon Rose
Phillipa’s rendition is more broken, confused, and hurt, with a little anger mixed in. It’s just perfect!
Yaaas
Agreed!
Yes
Yus yus she is amazing and honestly (my favorite )
There are a lot of theories why Eliza burned her letter. One of them is that Hamilton and Eliza were involved in some kind of financial scheme with the Reynolds and were about to get caught because the letters published in the Reynolds Pamphlet from Maria looked like they were actually written by Hamilton in an attempt to sound like an uneducated woman. The style was so similar to his own that Eliza burned her letters so they couldn't be compared to each other. But we'll never know...
I hate it when the singers have silent moments and then there are someone who will cough out loud like wtf 🙄
kjan noel u better hold that cough in😂😂😂
@@laurynward1016 lols 😂
what time?
Speaking of coughing, I was thinking about this the other day:
When COVID-19 started hitting NYC, Hamilton still had a few performances going on. How awkward do you think it was for some people when James Madison was sick on stage and coughing into a handkerchief??
As a person with really bad allergies I'm so sorry, one time I coughed when I went to see Newsies, and like I felt horrible about it.
I'm SORRY BUT PHILLIPA JUST REALLY DID THAT SHE IS ELIZA! she is so good at this role and her voice is phenomenal!
AGREED!
She’s irreplaceable 👑
AGREED
I AGREE!
Ik she is fits the role good but sadly she quit 😭😭😭😭😭
Dude, this clip doesn’t do Julia Harriman’s voice justice. I watched her last year in Hamilton, in SF and her voice was just so hauntingly beautiful. I honestly can’t say whose voice I liked better, hers or Phillipa’s, she was so good.
Same! I saw Julia when she was in Atlanta two years ago and her voice literally gave me chills
that’s awesome to hear honestly cos i thought she sounded incredible here !
Same! I saw her in SF and thought she made an incredible Eliza!
I watched Ari.
But Julia’s voice is so pretty!
She’s my cousin lol maybe i’m a little bias but she’s my favorite out of all the elizas. Don’t get me wrong, all of them sing beautifully but something about Julia is just unique and so angelic.
Zoe is very underrated!!! She shows the innocence of Eliza during act 1 well and matured as the story goes
Zoe blew me away in the show in SF. Had me completely sobbing during quiet uptown through the end
Absolutely loved Zoe when she came to Miami! She blew me away with her voice!
Out of the two Eliza’s I’ve seen, (Zoe and Erin) while both were great, Zoe was absolutely my favorite. She left me in awe.
I would love to see her entire performance.
She is the best out of all of these renditions in my opinion.
I had never heard Solea’s burn before and wow...i’m in tears. she had so much anger and disgust in her voice, she sounded so vicious and i loved it. the way she put a very tiny delay on the last ‘burn’ and then made a disgusted face was really something that made me get chills.
Solea has definitely been cheated on in real life!!
Sakeenah Evans she sung like she was gonna set HIM on fire. Like burn...in hell.
He was in the audience! 😭😭
Donnise W
Her ex? Really?!
i loved her fire omg she snapped
Emily Kiana nah, I’m just joking. Her level of intensity was on 1000, like the cheater had a front row seat.
Your brain is more likely to remember the first time you hear something. That’s why so many us of us often favor Phillipa. It would react similarly if these other women performed as Eliza first!😊
P R E A C H
That’s true but I do prefer Samantha over Aimee in six which confuses me
I saw it live in the UK with Rachelle then watched it on Disney+ and still favour Phillipa, I guess my brain is special 😂😂
@@danielblair9535 sameeee
@@krau2880 I watched the Broadway version first and now when I listen to the cast recording it sounds odd
Julia's has the most nuance to me. It's a mix of anger, despair and pain. But her last line is calm and detached, which makes it feel ominous and almost creepy.
Why y'all sleeping on Shoba? I saw her in Hamilton a few years ago and she's amazing! So lucky to have seen her!
For real though, she's incredible! I think it may be a little hard to tell because of the low-quality audio, but she's still 😍
I literally came from TT to yt to find her rendition
To compare audios with videos can be a bit unfair because people are unable to see the emotion! :( especially when that seems to be a factor in ranking. Aside from Pippa my faves are BY FAR, Julia Harriman and Solea Pfeiffer love themmmm. Wish there was a video for Julia!!
Do you mean phillipa not pippa
@@dawnafulton Pippa is her nickname across the fandom :)
Solea’s burn is just breathtaking!
ignacia vande shes my voice teacher!
@@kyleigh8028 Omg! so lucky!
Kyleigh she’s mine too!
@@kyleigh8028 waitwaitwaitwaitwaitWAIT SHE TEACHES?????!
@@cherry5552 HOW DO I SIGN UP?
why is no one talking about zoe, she slayed, you could hear the anger too
I saw Zoe in person also, and her voice is angelic, she’s really good, I say front row when I saw her, and you could see her emotion
Yes. When I went to see Hamilton, she was the one who played Eliza. I loved her because her version had the perfect balance of sadness and anger. That’s really important in my book. If I am ever fortunate enough to play Eliza, that would be a huge priority for me when I perform Burn.
9:37 she sounds ANGERY
I agree
Philippa is not portraying Eliza.
SHE is Eliza...
ᴘᴇʀɪᴏᴅ
Facts
no me
No! I'm the real Eliza
yeah and i would actually believe if she's the reincarnation of eliza
All of them struck a certain chord within all of us in certain ways, most likely having to do with which emotion correlates with our current circumstance. At times I’ve felt the resolute of Pippa and Ari, and at times the anger of Rachelle and Erin. This to me is the beauty of this song and the characteristics Eliza. Competition cannot apply to a work so incredibly interpretive.
However I must say, Solea’s final note in “when you were mine” cannot be outdone. (IMHO) I haven’t felt a resonance for that specific pain in a long time. Personally, her performance struck a very strong chord. How a single note can move someone in such a strong way is exactly what Lin Manuel intended in creating the masterpiece.
XOXOXO
I'm convinced Julia Harriman is the best Eliza. I saw her live in SF a few times and was blown away
SAME SIS SAME
YES YES YES. I saw her in LA and in SF and she was beyond amazing both times
She blew us all away
I was just trying to hear Zoe Jensen again. She’s really good! I saw her in January, and I sat front row, and she had so much emotion it’s crazy.
Okay, of course we all love Philippa. However, we need to be talking about Solea and Shoba!! They both sounded incredible. I wish I could have seen Shoba act. She is a star! Her voice just melts the soul. It’s special. It’s angelic yet can be powerful too! Solea gave me chills. She was IN that character. I loved her interpretation. It was powerful! I also really enjoyed Sharon Rose’s voice, especially the power and chest mix in the bridge!
This clip doesn’t do Isa justice but it’s literally the only one existing 😫 she did such a good job
Lexi was so good !!! why’s nobody talking about her!!
I think it's lower sound quality than the other clips :( she sounds amazing though
Angharad O'Donnabhain ohh yeah that’s true lol
@@ethanl886 that's what I was thinking!😮
EXACTLY
SAME IDK WHY NO ONES TALKING ABOUT HER
My Top 6 Eliza Hamilton's/Schuyler's Are
#1: Phillipa Soo
#2 Rachelle Ann Go
#3 Erin Clemons
#4 Ari Asfar
#5 Shoba Narayan
#6 Sharon Rose
Hey! Our top three is the same!
I saw Erin Clemons and she did AMAZING! I do think we need to stop comparing all of the women though because each has her own flair and her own techniques :)
You forgot isa briones 😂
And zoe Jensen
Its My Top 6, Not all
Solea made me feel chills...y’all sleeping on her.
phillipa 🥺🤍 !!!! BUT I ALSO LOVE THE OTHER ELIZA’S. THEY WOULDNT BE ABLE TO BE IN THEIR PLACE IF THEY WERE’NT GOOD. BUT AAAA PHILLIPA!!!
I loved all of them! It's sad how no one talks about Isa Barones, she was pretty great!(all of them were great doe ha)
I saw Erin Clemons back in 2019 and she’s amazing! Her vocal performance pairs perfectly with her acting! She’s one my favourites :)
I saw her too and she was amazing!
solea's "I hope that you burn" sounds like this low key edits of songs that people make for tiktok and IM LIVING FOR IT. solea puts so much anger and I love her vocals
Philippa Soo set the benchmark for the role of Eliza, IMHO.
I wish you had Hannah Cruz up there. She blew me away in Boston. Truly an impeccable performance.
Zoe Jensen (9:15) is now Katherine Howard in SIX on Broadway! Yayy!!! She is such a great fit for both roles.
EDIT: My favorite is Rachelle's.
Erin Clemons did an amazing job when I saw her in theater. I thought she portrayed Eliza EXTREMELY well. I love Phillipa but I will say that we need to all open our horizons up to more Elizas and not compare them to each other. Each has their own personal singing technique and there own flairs.
I saw her too and she was GREAT!
Just saw Zoe in NC and she was a standout of the touring cast. Awesome!
Krystal Joy Brown was absolutely fantastic! The feeling of being broken she brought while also increasing her voice and tone throughout the song gave everybody goosebumps. 100% the best!
I love it when they get that raspy voice part that makes them seem hurt and angry it just adds so much emotion! 😄
We all know that OG will always be the best but give credit to the other Elizas they all did a great job at this performance
i love shoba! she doesn’t get enough love!!
Phillipa set the stakes so high nobody else could reach it
Eliza had 8 of Hamilton’s Children and was pregnant in the duration of the affair, she has every right to be FLAMING, she probably didn’t leave him cause she knew she’d be ostracized
I think the clips should include that line of “you you you” in order to make a decent comparison
Philippa Soo all the wayyyy
I know Deneé Benton wasn’t in here but I would’ve definitely loved to see her rendition especially since I really like The Great Comet of 1812 too bad it closed early. :(
In my opinion no one could be better than the original cast
There’s people definitely better!
I agree.
Kristofer Parker And Thats why I said my opinion
I agree, there's amazing people that play them but no one can beat the originals.
Favorites, Pippa, Solea, Rachelle
Good choices
How did they not include Hannah Cruz from the Anjelica tour? She was outstanding.
zoe’s just sounds so angry and passionate.... exsctly what i felt it needed in that moment
THEYRE ALL SO GOOD ASIEPEOIURPAWOIUN
Zoe Jenson was like, extra angry, loved it
1. Julia
2. Solea
3. Rachelle
4. Isa
5. Phillipa
6. Erin
7. Sharon
8. Shoba
9. Lexi
10. Zoe
11. Ari
12. Syndee
Come at me
Tie between Philippa and Rachelle
I love how you added "And Peggy" on Julia Harriman's part
Pippa will always be my favorite, but I like all of them lol
Rachelle, Erin, and Shoba were amazing. Phillipa too of course!
Everyone is amazing!
all of these women are such queens with these vocals
I was hoping to see the current Eliza on Broadway, Krystal Joy Brown. She absolutely killed this song with her acting which was heartbreaking and her strong & beautiful voice! The night we went you could hear a pin drop during that song. Chills!
Philippa, Rachelle & Sharon are the best ones.
I thought I was gonna like Phillipas more than the rest Bc she was the obc but they’re all just as good I think
oh my god these women are literally incredible
I agree with most saying that Pippa portrayed Eliza the best. Let’s also give a round of applause for the other Elizas. You can tell they worked their butts off so let’s not downsize them. They did amazing!
Rachelle Ann Go
im not sure if it's possible, but if it is
can you do a guns and ships comparison? because i really want to know how the other lafayettes did
Phillipa’s gives you chills throughout the show she killed the role she was made for it
Philippa Soo and Rachelle Ann Go are my Eliza 😫👌
But Solea gave me goosebumps tho
Solea for the win!! Julia was very good too!!
all of them are amazing !
seeing ari was magical so good !!
I just love pippas voice is so sweet,smooth, like silk I love it to much. But they all did great. I just love the first one more it was almost angelic.
Damn. Julia Harriman gave me chills. I wish the audios with her voice were still up :/ If anybody knows where I could find the audios, please tell me
I also LOVE Julia’s version!!!
Does anyone have recording with carleigh bettiol?
1. Phillipa Soo
2. Julia Harriman
3. Ari Afsar
4. Zoe Jensen
5. Lexi Lawson
HONORABLE MENTIONS:
Shoba Narayan
Rachelle Ann Go
OH AND THE CLIP WASNT IN THIS VIDEO, BUT CARLEIGH BETTIOL (u/s Eliza og Broadway) IS AMAZING
Pippa and rachelle!
No one can ever top Pippa. No one. Ever.
Sydnee.... gorl. Were you having an off day? That wasn’t good.
Sorry but no-one comes close to Rachelle ann Go x
Solea Erin and rachel I love the most
Solea is just like-
the two original eliza! Phillipa and Rachelle. Love them both♥️
Solea was SO BEAUTIFUL IM SORRY IM JUST CANT
Now, who hurt Solea and why is she mad like that 😂😂😂
I was about to say she really went for it 😳
there is not an ounce of sadness, sis is ANGRY.
😂😂😂
she snapped
Oh my! Shes mad mad
Philippa is Eliza forever! No offense to all the others
Period
Still gives me goosebumps.
agreed!! i love her so much 🥺💓
i agree
Yes the best!!!!
Why is nobody talking about Ari DAMN THAT BELT AND THEN THE SOFTNESS OF HER VOICE RIGHT AFTER
Fr I’m so thankful I got to see ari. 🥺
Ari >>>>> Everyone else.
Yeah hers was amazing
I heard ari and was just like danhgg
I KNOW RIGHT
How come there’s someone coughing in every, “I hope that you burn” LIKE GIVE HER THE MOMENT SHE DESERVES!!
Covid hit hard..
It’s so annoying when u just hear a random person cough when the singer is singing like BRUH
I don't know but I have this theory that it could be because of the smoke from the fire or maybe it's part of the audio
Solea’s performance has so much expression. I think she gave off the feeling of hurt and pain so much more than the rest
Honestly I disagree with the “too angry” comments. I feel like anger works very well in that part they were singing and then they compose themselves into a coldness on the last line. Rachelle and Solea do this very well and I completely believe them.
Exactly, like you wouldnt be mad if that were you?? Lol
LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE AT THE BACK !!
However, they described Eliza as gentle and kind. So much anger in her voice just doesn't fit her character. That's why Phillipa's version is so fitting. She sounds confused, hurt and a little angry but anger is not the main emotion evoked in her rendition.
I see both sides tbh. I feel like first burn was more angry but each actress should put their own twist on the song and that might be anger
@@gabrielabernal5596 I think with this song especially it's up to each actress what she wants to do with the role. Even a gentle person can show rage in certain circumstances. The song tells us that we don't know how she reacted when she went through this painful, private moment, so you can play it a bunch of different ways and have it still make sense. Then it's just up to the audience to decide which interpretation they like more.
I wish there were more videos of Julia Harriman’s Eliza floating around. She’s so freaking good. I didn’t think anyone could be better than Phillipa but I saw Julia live in SF and she blew us all away. Pun intended.
I KNOW, NOBODY IS EVEN TALKING ABOUT HER IN THE COMMENTS
I KNOW. I saw her twice and she’ll always have a special place in my heart, she’s amazing!!
Is she in this video? I haven't watched the whole thing.
@@rinasauruss She is, I finished the video!
Julia Harriman is both my 2nd fav Angelica (tied with Emmy raver lampman), and one of my favorite Eliza’s.
Solea gave me chills with all the emotions she put into that. You can really feel the hurt and anger, and then the coldness at the end, wow.
But my god, they were all amazing. There wasn’t one where I thought eh, not as great as the others.
same...
Same but they were all good
But who was it?
Personally, I dont like to compare the actors to other people who play their part. I judge the actor for how well they did they're part, not how well they did they're part compared to others.
I’m sorry but why is no-one talking about Shoba? She was so good!
I’m sorry but why is no one talking about Solea??! The moment at 3:54 when she picks up the letters and sings “the memories,” she has that slight moment of sadness cause she relives those moments for a quick second, and then goes right back into hurt and anger! Also that gaze is so strong and powerful yet subtly! I feel like there can be a lot of overacting in a song like this but she captured it just right! And her voice is phenomenal!!! She’s my fave for sure!! 😍
She's my favorite, too! You can definitely feel Solea's anger and sadness through the song.
YES! I love her so much, she's phenomenal.
LEGITTT
this is my first time hearing her sing this song and she sounds awesome! You can really feel the power and emotions in her voice.
Literally everyone is talking about her what do you mean
I think Solea would make a better Angelica
Same
I agree, she has a deeper voice which if seen more in angelicas songs.
JonSingsBway same
Still she did great as Eliza, but I can see her playing Angelica
I agree but she chose the role eliza probably cuz she feels more fit for that role
Im torn between Phippa and Rachelle. In terms of sound, I like Phippa's better but I was looking for a bit more of anger and disgust. (you can't have your husband cheat on you and only feel sadness) Rachelle's emotion is what I think fits the song.
My top three are Pippa, Rachelle, and Erin
It sounded and looked like Phippa was angry though.
@@xxqueenxx5808 She did. But I felt more of the sadness. I guess I was just looking for a familiar reaction. Most people I know would not react the same way as she does when someone cheats on them. Rachelle's reaction is basically how I've seen everyone react to that same situation which is why it appealed to me more. dunno if I explained that right 😭
@@xxqueenxx5808 Don't get me wrong though. Even if I think that Rachelle's version is very true to the song, I still think that Phippa is better when it comes to being true to Eliza's character.
Josh Huit oh! Alright I see what you mean now thanks!
in this house we don’t pin queens against queens💙 (but y’all sleeping on isa briones fr)
I like this comment
Philippa, the OG Broadway Eliza and Rachelle, the OG West End Eliza. THEY ARE JUST INCOMPARABLE!!! Both gave different attacks and emotions.
PERIODT
That's tough. It would be easier with better sound quality, but I did like the emotion in Zoe. Still, Rachelle and Philippa both seem to have better fullness and range to their voices.
Anyway you slice it, it's a tough song, half almost sweet, half wicked angry.
Edit: I found Rachelle's full recording and I think I still like Phillipa better. I like that she ends "cold"... like she's locking it down. I feel like that's the irony of the song - anyone who was REALLY angry probably would have come out swinging, but Eliza decides to 'get even' in a very calculated way, here. I like the wistful beginning, the angry build, and the cold end.
Ok Solea’s control on the ending that full-on belt is AMAZING . It’s so hard to fade out of something that you’re giving that much energy gradually rather then switching from loud to soft. I think it helps lead in to the ending super well! Julia’s is amazing too, someone else said it sounds detached and I love the different takes
thats something i always did when singing this song as well i feel it's important and a skill to have to sing this
Holy sht, I did not expect Solea to be that powerful. I literally got chills.
I feel like they were all to angry. Phillipa set's it up for the forgiveness. She's my favorite and detestably the best. Rachelle was really good too though!
To be fair, you do realize that it took a few years before Angelica had even forgiven him. It wasn’t just a few months, but years. I love rachelle because she adds so many emotions as well as the anger. She reveals the side to herself that the audience hadn’t seen before, and for that reason, I love her so much.
Adam & Amber Nguyen You say Angelica, but we’re talking about Eliza-
@@Yuki-oq5yl People make mistakes dude, just humans
George Eacker I’ve seen them comment the same thing on a bunch of comments like this on the video though.
k
Pippa is the OG and I love her so much but I love Rachelle’s Burn, she sounds so angry and hurt, and Ari’s voice is so powerful, but my favorite has to be Julia Harriman, she’s incredible and you can tell that she’s feeling a lot of pain and disappointment, I cried hearing her.
I saw Julia live and she’s my favorite Eliza! It sucks bc this is the only recording I’ve found Of her.
Same I absolutely LOVE Julia
I watched ari. But I loved her performance when I watched
I love Solea’s raw anger. Also love Rachelle Ann Go when she takes that deep breath after the “you forfeit” section. It’s so Eliza- she takes just a second to compose herself as much as she can given the circumstances.