Euro NCAP Crash & Safety Test of Tesla Model 3-2019-Best in Class-Large Family Car/Hybrid & Electric
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ก.ค. 2019
- More information on our Best in Class awards www.euroncap.com/en/press-med... or www.euroncap.com/en/ratings-r...
Euro NCAP performs a series of crash tests on each model tested:
- a frontal impact test, the car impacts a rigid barrier
- an offset frontal impact test, 40% of the width of the car is striking a deformable barrier
- a pole test, the tested car is propelled sideways into a rigid pole
- a side impact test, a mobile deformable barrier impacts the driver's door.
A series of pedestrian tests are conducted with different impactors, adult and child head form, lower and upper leg form and whiplash tests are performed on a sled.
Active safety is tested based on the car’s equipment: autonomous emergency braking systems (car to car, with a pedestrian and a cyclist target), lane support and speed assist technologies and seatbelt reminders.
All details on the Euro NCAP Website:
Tesla Model 3 2019 test information www.euroncap.com/en/results/T...
Euro NCAP July 2019 Press release www.euroncap.com/en/press-med... - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
0:32 so in the Model 3 your biggest injury will come from the person beside you's backhand slap
Haha I was thinking the same bit of sibling rivalry
Rennie Ash no it's when the battery's self combust and cook you alive
@@deeeeeeeench1209 nah, thyre made so if they malfunction incase of a crash, so they dont explode. Gas cars dont have any protection and fuel can easily start burning and cook you alive
ElectroBytezLV petrol maybe diesel not so easy. Gas is so rare. So there is zero chance they can catch fire I doubt it.
@@deeeeeeeench1209 Rare is not zero mate. No possible device with Gigawatts of power, whether EV or IC is completely safe from a fast discharge due to damage.
System avoided crash
System avoided crash
System avoided crash
System avoided crash
*BZZZZT* What are "last 4 log entries before the fire".
@@tychothefriendlymonolith Internal combustion engines catch fire all the time, I've driven past multiple on fire in my 20yrs driving. Yet to see an EV spontaneously combust you bullshitter lol
David P the core part of my comment was intended to be a light hearted remark around systems not crashing, and then in a hypothetical comedy scenario having some sort of catastrophic event, much like a cartoon horse falling off a cliff, surviving, then exploding inexplicably. It was not in any way meant to be a critique or positional statement regarding electric vehicles, their design, quality, statistical or observed safety nor an attempt to use commonly reported misconceptions about electric vehicles as a factual lynchpin in an anti EV comment. It is obvious by your straight for the jugular style of reply that this poor but spontaneous and improvised attempt at humour did not come through in the text, but at the same time I can’t help but feel slightly saddened that what was intended to brighten the readers day has been met with such needless hostility. Be calm, and go with God to a more serene and rewarding electric future.
Ed sometimes, what is meant is not what is seen, especially through a medium such as plain text :)
System made this video and uploaded on youtube
Engineers: How rigid do you want the cabin to be?
Musk: Yes.
Engineers: Got it.
Fuggin ay that thing’s wheels are like “teehee”
Accident prevention, crumple zones and ridgity in the right places. Something impressive.
YouFube Tesla cars are very tough. Old school of Toyota. Toyota have owned 25% stakes of Tesla and the first factory in Freemont CA is a former Toyota’s facility. Good old school of engineering tough cars :)
Jet powered glove box will be next
Wow! The pedestrian walking out from the side of the road onto the traffic is the most scary and common issue, and it could stop for it! That is impressive!
Wesley Chuen I literally gasped! Guess I didn’t expected it!
Pretty much every car tested in 2019 with this new AEB features stops the car before the pedestrian is hit, so nothing special for Tesla. Most of the new cars have AEB fitted as standard, and I imagine it will soon be required by law, like ESP was in 2012.
@@neo5462
In 2019
@@neo5462 Yeah but im pretty sure the extra sensors would allow it to detect the pedestrian coming up way before any other cars could with just their front radar.
Vanguard nah they all detect it at the same time, if you watch the test of other cars
Side pole test is amazing... And scary lol
Driver chest was rated as marginal, so...
@@fatpigeon1066 Well visually the occupant looks to receive much less energy than the Skoda Scala, where the side impact is pushing into the cabin, and the occupant is shoved across almost to the other seat, I'd rather be in the Tesla.
@@AnatoleBranch in some cases yes, but crumpling tends to be good thing in a crash because it absorbs and dissipates the energy
@@fatpigeon1066 right but doesn't it depends on speed, if you crumple too much then cabin integrity starts to falter, the higher the impact speed. I think the Tesla can handle/dissipate higher impact energies, maybe this leads to lower speed impacts having less energy absorbed by the car, but at least visually it looks way better in the cabin than he Skoda or the Mercedes B Class.
@@AnatoleBranch true, there has to be a valence between both
That side impact protection is crazy! From someone who lost a friend when his car was wrapped around a pole, this will save lives!
bob jones no it won't. It's too ridged, and doesn't absorb the impact well. A lot of other cars score better in the measurements. For example: a Suzuki vitara has better scores in this test for occupant protection
@@Flaakk That shows the Model 3 is better over all but the Vitara is better for lateral impact tests.
@@rhamph Did you actually read the links properly mate? The tesla has pelvis-located airbags. The airbags are exactly for impact absorption. It's better to hit harder against a cocaine mega pillow than splatter yourself against soft metal at 60 per hour.
Driving 100+ no car will be secure.
Feral Survivor I read them, Tesla scores 15.3 out of 16 for lateral impacts Vitara scores 16 out of 16.
Best side pole test result I've ever seen 👏👏
Actually no, the driver's chest was rated as marginal
The car is way to rigid, and didn't absorb much energy for the occupants. Looks very safe, but isn't.
@@michiel75 Well visually the occupant looks to receive much less energy than the Skoda Scala, where the side impact is pushing into the cabin, and the occupant is shoved across almost to the other seat, I'd rather be in the Tesla.
@Zukals that's the point of the crash avoidance tech, where Tesla is miles ahead.
Ümit Ünal because have the batteries, the batteries are very hard and solid
Extremely impressive results
That goes for every car tested then because the B Class scored the same and the Skoda did even better.
Pretty average. The Skoda Scala did better on everything except on the emergency braking. But i must say, the emergency braking on Tesla's is quite good.
SDav21 I’d say all the crashes it avoided were impressive. The rest of the tests were just as good as I would expect for the price and hype. But yeah, the kid jumping out from behind the car and still not being hit was pretty good
Beaten by 2018 BMW Z4 and 2019 Mercedes CLA.
@@paname514 best in class at the time of testing is best in class mate. I don't see any BMW or Merc even competing near a model X roll test, see what I did there, unfairly compared ^-^
Crash test dummies should have a surprised look painted on their faces.
Adlin Ling best comment of the year. 😂
They should poop a little when the Tesla hits the breaks too.
D:
0:25 and all this smoke in the cabin? Are those airbags inflated with some dusty gas? Or the battery was about to ignite? I mean all the test was impecable... Except for that...
@@santiagosanchez2704 well the airbags are inflated via a reaction of sodium azide and potassium nitrate to create nitrogen gas, which comes out a little cloudy so it's probably just that.
For a Company that is only a few years in the market, that is even more impressive.
2008
@@NicholasLittlejohn but for mass market cars: 2012
Tesla has been making cars as safe as this starting in 2012 with the model S
Making start to question every other company
It’s even more amazing that the model 3 is the safest car ever tested! Look it up, if you don’t believe me!
Impressive real world tests, well done Euro NCAP (& Tesla too!)
You know....theres nothing special about this, this is a european standard and they do this for every car model made....also it's very common for there to be 5 stars
@@mateoslab but model 3 got one of the highest scores (not just stars) recorded for recent cars.
@@spidermain so did the Audi E-tron
Mateo Ceballos Querol - www.euroncap.com/en/ratings-rewards/latest-safety-ratings/#?selectedMake=0&selectedMakeName=Select%20a%20make&selectedModel=0&selectedStar=&includeFullSafetyPackage=true&includeStandardSafetyPackage=true&selectedModelName=All&selectedProtocols=34803,30636&selectedClasses=1202,1199,1201,1196,1205,1203,1198,1179,1197,1204,1180,34736&allClasses=true&allProtocols=false&allDriverAssistanceTechnologies=false&selectedDriverAssistanceTechnologies=&thirdRowFitment=false
Not all cars receive 5 star. Looks like Fiat Managed yo receive zero star and Jeep with one star. There are others with 4 stars.
Mateo Ceballos Querol this is standard in the US too with IIHS and NHTSA
1:58 ah yes, those dangerous pedestrian heads falling around!!
Glad they are testing this.
Lmao 😂
Ikr falling pedestrian heads are the worst
I think when a pedestrian's decapitated head hits the windscreen, you don't need to worry any more about how much damage they've sustained
@@tomkandy - Good point xD
best comment xD
Why in the world would someone downvote this? I'm a proud Model 3 owner and these results make me happy. The car not only protects its riders, but also pedestrians and other drivers in many cases!
Just junk from usa
petrol sellers downvote this video. More electric car, no money with gasoline.
can't run over children in this car. Clear disadvantage over muh coal truck.
They think it's too expensive but don't add up the weekly cost of gas.
Oil companies shareholders.
So glad I'm driving this car.
Wash it.
;-)
Rennie Ash what??
@@RennieAsh never!
@@DirtyTesla why
@@diamondofficial758 Because look how safe it is!!!
That's really great to have this kind of video easily accessible to the public !
0:31
Jimmy: *hits dab*
His sister: stop acting like dork yeet
At last a 2nd hand Model3 I can afford.
Minor dents, easy fix
But with Tesla's reputation on parts, you'll be waiting a while.
It'l buff out......
Tesla, white, slightly used
The crashed one 🤣🤣🤣
Don't let mannequins drive your car
@Toad come on give me a break
Mosque y u here?
@@lemon5501 shhh im a bot
Oh shit shhhh....
And so said prophet Elon the Illuminator "for verily, as firmly as my Angel Autopilot holds the steering wheel, thou [who art] in my Chariot are safe as in my own hands. No harm will come to my Flock"
What a rock solid car!
So too are the other cars then. They got better results.
Totally best and safest car on the road, also top NHTSA car ever. Just look at pole slam comparison and watch occupants to see the difference.
@@AnatoleBranch The way the car looks in a crash does not determine if it's safer. You follow the same ignorant logic of people who don't know anything about crashes and crash forces. There's basically zero crumple zone. It still only scored marginal because the forces on the passengers are high.
@@SDav21 you need to read more carefully, look at the occupants. But I understand haters gonna find anything.
Anatole Branch shills are gonna shill :>
I remember these crash tests as I used to work for a child car seat company which my dad managed and we had our own crash test laboratory. I think that the car seat we see in the rear is actually one of ours.
I remember watching these crash tests for real and I was really impressed.
And what is your opinion on the car?
Brand of the baby car seat?
David Chavez For having driven it not long ago, I was quite impressed. I’m actually thinking about getting one.
Ronald Cortez Britax - Römer
Well Done NCAP great testing ...it pushes the car manufacturers to strive for perfection .
Wow, Teslas are incredible
Then so is the Mercedes and Skoda and other cars they tested that did better.
@@SDav21 Ok dude, whatever
This video is about the Tesla Model 3, stop answering every comment with your ICE Mercedes and Skoda
We don't want your pollution, old infotainment system and flammable liquids thanks
@@romainhedouin The point of this is not safer than any other car tested. And yet you'll find more teslas caught fire than a competitor vehicle. Model s vs e class or A6 etc and you'll find the tesla has more fires percentage wise. So you can keep your flammable battery and less safe than other cars tesla.
@SDav21 you high man? Every do as he says and look them up side by side crash test.
@@HIGHLIFE4EVA The way the car looks in a crash does not determine if it's safer. You follow the same ignorant logic of people who don't know anything about crashes and crash forces. There's basically zero crumple zone. It still only scored marginal because the forces on the passengers are high.
A good reminder watching any crash test to drive safely!
The results are impressive! Now i feel much safer driving around :)
Model 3: I make this look good.
Model 3: Hey old people
😆
Best car in the World right now, end of story!
Agreed.
Safety ✔️
Driver assist ✔️
Fun to drive ✔️
Relatively affordable ✔️
Zero emissions ✔️
Fast ✔️
@rabitman3000 ill get better, they should
rabitman3000 they might have challenges with paint quality and panel fittings, but when it comes to servicing Teslas and evs are the most reliable cars there is
@@lambosuperl www.google.com/amp/s/www.teslarati.com/tesla-model-3-paint-quality-issues-debunked-by-specialist-video/amp/
www.roadandtrack.com/new-cars/a28008116/tesla-model-3-build-quality-bob-lutz/
The two issues are mostly already fixed.
I love the crash tests !!!!
i'm not even mad, that's amazing
Another reason to get you a Tesla🤷🏼♂️
Another reason not to get a tesla is the 2018 BMW Z4 and 2019 Mercedes CLA are safer. The safest cars on the road.
Idk man have you ever owned a Tesla?
@@paname514Here you are again with your Mercedes and BMW. Nobody cares. They're old and rubbish. You are obvs bitter and can't afford a Tesla
Why is Euro Ncap liking the comments only on this video 😂
PugLordTR probably only just learnt they can do it. Or not idk.
we are not ;)
@@EuroNCAP_forsafercars, you bloody legend
Coz it's the only car worth liking?
They'd be like, this is next level
Blown away! Extremmmmly impressive
I completely flipped out at the system reaction to the kid crossing. Insane breaking.
Good result and it shows good performance in km77 test
Wow it did really well in the pole test compared to the BMW X5 and 3 series !
I'd put a new door on that and drive it!
Test is amazing! Thanks
Wow, EuroNCAP was pretty patient waiting all those months for the pre-ordered model 3's to individually arrive.
0:09 The entire cabin retained it's shape in an off-set crash. I am not used to seeing that. I'm used to at the very least the A-pillar buckling a little.
Damn that Tesla Model 3 is excellent car I wish I wanna see the Tesla Model X for crash test
The video is on YT too.
Tesla model X is amazing. In the rollover test, it basically "refused" to be roller over, turning upright every time.
It’s the first SUV to have a 5 star rating
@@tdg9281 Volvo XC90:
*_Am I joke to you_*
Unusuaa can the XC90 do barrel roll ? Model x can’t
Absolutely incredible!
Now I love my Model 3 even more!
Why we got a Tesla. Safest car in the business 😎😎😎
You have not seen or heard the news yet :D
I think the safest car in the business is Merkava, with active shield installed)
well done
Amazing hoping to have one of these vehicles in a future not so far away.
That pedestrian test is incredible! 🙌
I might just jump under a model 3 passing by just to see if it really feels so good :D
Tesla model 3 is a pace setter. It is now the world's safest car .
It is not. You clearly didn't see the other tests performed with this. The Skoda did better. Lol.
SDav21 yeah but Elon said it was, so must be true.
Yep safest car ever, also topped the NHTSA top rated US car ever. Just watch the pole slam comparison between the M3 and any ICE car. Tesla built like a tank.
@SDav21 you high man? Every do as he says and look them up side by side crash test.
@@HIGHLIFE4EVA The way the car looks in a crash does not determine if it's safer. You follow the same ignorant logic of people who don't know anything about crashes and crash forces. There's basically zero crumple zone. It still only scored marginal because the forces on the passengers are high.
I wish EuroNCAP did a small overlap test like the IIHS! It would be a nice test to add to their arsenal, and could highlight changes manufacturers are only making for US cars and skimping out on EU cars!
I enjoyed watching this
Insane results!, impresive how well design Tesla cars are, I want one!
That.......My friends is why Tesla has a five star safety rating in all categories.
Wow I am so glad we bought one! Amazing vehicle besides "wall street analysts" best efforts... and I ferl sorry for that test equipment😂😂😂
This is amazing
Pole test is Excellent
Man look at the kids in the back they are having the best time of their lives, waving their hands and arms allover, nodding their heads back and forth. Fun for the whole family!
Amazing !!!!!
Amazing results, especially side crash is WOW.
Just crushed the test. Wow 😮
That is the most rigid car I´ve ever seen.
TESLA are Built like TANKS but handle BETTER than a Euro Sports car.
@@markplott4820 check out sarbe, they made really good cars. Also, don't over estimate these cars, they're great, but they're not gonna handle like a jag f type or bm
@@AlexSlavenDrums Why not? Have you driven one?
@@AlexSlavenDrums They handle batter u right.
Rigidity is the not the best thing, for instance, in the pole test, the driver's chest was rated as marginal
Wow! Thai Side post view from the top is the best I’ve seen, almost no deformation. And the system avoided accidents is just impressive.
Tesla will be my next car for sure
Horacio Lezcano that doesn’t really mean nothing, there are other cars that crumple more in the pole test and score higher
@@gustavomercado1599 Which cars?
Very impressive, that was one reason we bought a Tesla Model Y. You can feel how strong the structure is when driving it.
This is amazing..
I am eternally grateful that people like Elon Musk still exist.
The only negative thing about this video is that they wrecked a few perfectly good cars! But then again, that is where the test is for.
Awesome results, especially the crash avoidance system!
I was looking for this comment. Thanks.
Consider those Teslas a fallen hero... Kinda..
My next car!! I can’t wait
wow the results look amazing
Wow, colour me impressed
Wow. This should be the lead story in any broadcast about the automotive industry or technology. Congratulations Tesla and thank you for making my Model 3 so safe. ps: I doubt if any other car company can avoid pedestrians and bicyclists like that. Amazing.
The ignorance is astonishing. You clearly didn't see the other crash tests then. Done at the same time. Those cars also avoided the pedestrians and cyclists.
@@SDav21 None of them as good as the Tesla. The Model 3 has the highest ranking (94%) in safety assist of all cars tested with the current protocols (introduced 2018/19). The only other cars with a similar rating are Volvos from 2017 (93% and 95%), but as the protocols have changed since then, those ratings are not directly comparable.
@@wermagst Incorrect. Look at the scores for front occupant, passenger and pedestrian protection. The Skoda Scala, Mazda 3, VW T Cross, Seat Tarraco etc all got better front occupant protection scores. Just look at all results on euro ncap. You will see the scores for front occupant protection, passenger protection and side protection. The tesla only got higher in safety ASSIST systems specifically which they have as standard. Most cars do anyway but some additional parts are still optional. So it got higher there but in protection in an actual crash it is not the best one.
@@SDav21 I was explicitely talking about *avoiding* accidents, which is rated in the safety assistance part. Do you want to deny that Tesla's 94% rating is the highest?
SDav21 did you even drove one I have one and I can promise you that it feels like the safest car in the world
That is impressive!
You know its a safe car when every time there's an accident, its a major news report
Tesla is once again, ahead of the game!
No, although the result was good, it was not the best
How could it have been better?
@@a_pav it scored 96% for adult occupant protection (which is good) but other cars have scored higher...
@@fatpigeon1066 like?
@@RahulJha-mc6nzVolvo for a start, mercedes, alpha romeo and even a Skoda! with adult occupant protection
Buying any other car is like buying a horse.
Eventually a Tesla will be like a horse. You will be able to let it roam for the day and it will even feed itself.
@japanwatchconnection but the competition is ten years away. and in ten years, Tesla will be another 10 years...
@japanwatchconnection All Audi Etron delivered have been recalled due to a design issue and Tsla has outsold Etron and I pace in UK and Norway, while those models had a head start. What competition is there for Tesla? It is nothing but spin. Even the casual retail investors can see the professional analyst are full of crap.
@japanwatchconnection true
@@harrychu650 so you really think electro cars are the future? 😂
Next Level 👌
Exzellent 👏✌👍
0:12 so are we gonna ignore those beautiful rims hidden behind those aero wheelcovers?
No.. That's why they sell lug nut and center caps for the 18 inch tires fyi.. That design is sportier imo.
@@ronaldcortez6216 i didnt know that
So this is how TSLA beat sales expectations :)
It didn't perform any better than the other cars they crash tested.
@@SDav21 It did. I looked at the website. just sort them by overall score and Tesla is 1st, followed by other 5 star cars
@@zane003 It did not. Look at the individual scores. There are various other cars which performed better for passenger protection. The tesla is not one of them.
That's the strongest pole test I've ever seen. 😱
Ich denke, eines der sichersten Autos. Hut ab!
no tesla was harmed during this video
*WAIT*
2:20 Me when I'm on my way to return a library book
Wow! Now i want buy some more
Wow I hear about this 5 ⭐️ rating but seeing this in action tho 😱 🤯 The front crash crumple zone is just comical! What! You can only tell the car crashed by looking at the frunk area and the windscreen.
2:31 the cyclist brought the inscription to the frame
1:35 Don't you just hate it when a random pole suddenly t-bones you?
I’M GOING TO BUY THIS ONE
Wonderful
Good car
That's the first time I see the left airbag deploy in the pole crash test, why does it deploy ?
just to be safe for sure i think
Probably because it hasn't got an own impact sensor system....both or none
To keep the passenger window glass from entering the cabin and injuring the driver
Gopinath M S
It's not advisable to just deploy airbags if they're not needed.
As they're a one use item, if there's a second impact on the other side, the passenger is a gonner.
To sell more airbags
Pretty neat!
Very impressive
Absolutely stunning results. Congratulations Team Elon!
Best NCAP result ever. This is huge.
One of the best ;)
No
@@EuroNCAP_forsafercars bit biased?
Incorrect. Other cars have scored higher.
Amazing car!
Very good
I guess Tesla beat its deliveries record in Q2 mainly thanks to the nb of cars Euro NCAP bought lol
Best NCAP result ever? :)
Yep
www.euroncap.com/it/valutazioni-e-premi/valutazioni-di-sicurezza-recenti/#?selectedMake=0&selectedMakeName=Seleziona%20una%20marca&selectedModel=0&selectedStar=&includeFullSafetyPackage=true&includeStandardSafetyPackage=true&selectedModelName=Tutti&selectedProtocols=34803,30636,26061,24370,1472,5910,5931,-1,14999&selectedClasses=1202,1199,1201,1196,1205,1203,1198,1179,1197,1204,1180,34736&allClasses=true&allProtocols=true&allDriverAssistanceTechnologies=false&selectedDriverAssistanceTechnologies=&thirdRowFitment=false
Nope, Mercedes-Benz A Class tops it up (and safety tech aside, 15 cars scored better than the Model 3)
@@edipires15 sort it by overall rating, Model 3 is #1 in 2019, although I'll give it to you the last year A-class rating is higher
Voltaire yup in 2019 it’s so far the best, but since there was no alterations in the tests between ‘18 and ‘19 we should also take into account those from 2018
@@edipires15 I don't think the safety/collision avoidance can be understated though. It's a full 19% better than the A class. While they both scored the same for passenger safety, avoiding an accident altogether is always optimal. Make no mistake, any cars getting 95%+ are excellent, but we're now at a point where prevention will prevent the most injuries.
sick!
Best car. Hope for more more production and success
2:09 2:37 the wite car: me when i want to impress my girl that i have a car but i have no money
0:48 to be frank.. seeing this makes me want rear airbags for my children.
HANS device for bigger children or rear-facing child seat for smaller children
Ford offers optional rear airbags in some cars. They’re integrated into the seatbelts.
I’m thinking the same thing too, something in the back of the front seats? At least the kids didn’t hit the back of the seats in front. There’s a lot more motion then I would expect from seatbelts.
Agreed, the other scary thing is that all these tests are at quite low speeds, yet the damage is very significant!
This is definitely why our 2 year old is still going to be rear facing for a minimum of another year.
Impressive.
Happy to drive a Model 3