भारत का भविष्य क्या है, Harvard और Oxford के स्कॉलर सूरज येंगड़े की नजर में
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ธ.ค. 2022
- #dilipmandal #surajyengde
विदर्भ के वंचित समुदाय के साधारण परिवार से निकलकर सूरज येंगड़े ने दक्षिण अफ्रीका जाकर पीएचडी की. फिर हार्वर्ड यूनिवर्सिटी में फेलो रहे. अब वे ऑक्सफोर्ड यूनिवर्सिटी में शोधरत हैं और पढ़ाते भी हैं. देश और दुनिया के लंबे अनुभवों के आधार पर भारत को देखने का एक खास नजरिया उनके पास है. वे भारत को लेकर कुछ मामलों में आशावान है तो वहीं भारत की कई बातें उन्हें चिंतित करती है. खासकर आधुनिकता और वंचित समुदाय प्रश्न पर उनकी सोच बेहद दिलचस्प है. सुनिए उनसे कि हार्वर्ड और ऑक्सफोर्ड से भारत कैसा दिखता है. #Castematters #SurajYengde
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
The sad reality is that OBC, and Dalit communities have so many layers with extremely discriminatory practices. This is being conveniently ignored by both the Right and Left. We only search for communities from a different category to blame.
Agreed . Casteism Hierarchy based hai
Jo jiske upar woh apne niche waale ko dabayega
What if we set the hierarchy upside down......
your wedging tactics will not work. Dr Ambedkar brought us together. you will not divide us.
@@ashwinkr4770 Refer to the list of caste based crimes in India. Wiki is updated and has primary source references. You'll see 95% of it is between two backward communities. Your cowardice will not alter facts.
Suraj & Dilip both icons in their own right, always pleasure to listen to them.
Dilip Mandal ji, please teach about Jogendranath Mandal in your pattshala.
He already white washed him years ago.
Jogendranath Mandal fought for Pakistan along with a large section of Scheduled Caste people. He was unfortunately allowed to come to India after Scheduled Caste people were massacred in East Pakistan. Both Muslims and Scheduled Caste people should be deported to Pakistan
@@keyurpatel1982only muslim and follower of yengde.
Lol .. dukan band ho jayegi uncle ki
शिक्षा वह शेरनी का दूध है जो पिएगा वो दहारे गा।।
जय भी।।
I proud of you dillip mandal sir.and suraj sir
Mai Suraj yengade sahab ko janata hu jay bhim jay bsp
Pr wo sherni brahmin ki hi. r brahmin ne apni bakri ka naam sherni rakha hi.
St obc sc ko 'videshi Sherri' ka doodh Peena padega suraj yengde ki tarah.
A pleasure to hear the discussion. The interaction of modernity and caste discrimination is highly nuanced and as Suraj and Dilip says we need to understand it through the nuances. Very imp!
Educate , organise, agitate !
शिक्षित बनो, संगठित हो, संघर्ष करो !
Thank you Dr Yengde for ripping apart the layers of NRI CASTEIST men
I disagree. Educate , organise, and capture! capture the power positions. that is the only way
This guy got humiliated by a Buddhist priest when being asked about meditation.
He's another progeny of foreign forces to further divide the Hindu Society but the wave of Hindutva would most likely end up bringing even more unity.
Who was the Buddhist Priest? Can you give more details please.
Sounds like the Kashmiri guy who was supposedly turned terrorist because he was once slapped by an Indian soldier! 🤓🤓🤓
He is a NEO BUDDHIST 1956 wala
Shut up you criminal
@@mangalpal8921 mian shut up kehene wale tum hote kaun ho?
You are in a public forum, tum unhen kitni bhi galian do, parantu Modiji ke Raj main we still have freedom of speech. Jo man ayega bolenge, bakwas bologe toh galian bhi denge!
Dileep Sir,
I always appreciate your views, the multy dimensional analysis on the issues, you always try to get us known the issues minutely, I always appreciate.
It is first time for me listening Yengde Sir, no doubt he has a marvelous depth on the issues discussed here,the discussion goes well yet I feel that this is not a interview taken handsomely, in a interview taken handsomely can get more extracts from the person interviewed, may be I wrong but I feel it.Therefore, I request you sir, kindly prepare the questionnaire before the interview from a person like Yengde Sir, he can give us more if he was interviewed well, this may be called a good discussion but not a well interview, sir please! don't take it otherwise!
Awesome and deep discussion...❤❤
I have made a video on the BUDDHIST CASTE SYSTEM, i provided not only religious or textual evidences but, evidence of caste system in modern Buddhist societies.
Very enlightening video ,,keep up the good work
No doubt as half of buddhist ladakh has converted to islam
Bro please do research and make a video on caste discrimination within dalit community
शानदार चर्चा
Can they also talk about the enormous progress we have made with regard to caste? Two of my cousins married outside caste. Their families are treated no different. The whole interview had a pessimistic tone.
are they married to lower caste or among upper caste only
@@VishalKumar-xp6gz We are Brahmins. One is married to a Vyshya (Bania), and the other to someone of fisherman caste. Both are highly educated and work in senior positions.
Education makes all the difference. We, as a nation, are on the right track, from a caste perspective. Unfortunately there is no acknowledgement of that from these two gentlemen.
You are someone sane, so I gonna try to tell the context they are talking about, you see they are not talking about the blatant manifestation of casteism but a modern, more nuanced version followed by "upper caste". As a student of sociology this transition of lower castes going abroad and trying to tell their story from a different POV other than mainstream conversation on castes.
Do you really think we as a Indians are totally done with castes when only ~75 % are functionally literate?
Casteism still exists in our society that's very hush-hush, so it's a lie if you say we as a society don't practise casteism! Let's be real.
@@ajaxjaiswal3442 No, we are not done with castes or casteism, and I don’t think that’s anyone’s argument.
I was pointing to the fact that we did make a lot of progress, and we are going in the right direction. It is not a stretch to conceive a future, in the next few decades, where caste becomes a lot less relevant and important.
@@ajaxjaiswal3442 as of today the only people who make caste an important issue are the one's who want to compensate for the older times (which is fine). Apart from that, I've not heard or seen anyone practicing casteism.
I've seen people with Gita Vedas and Puranas in their homes. But I've not seen a single person with a manusmriti.
Caste-ism is an obvious blotch on our culture, but it's going for good and it's not coming back again that's for sure. Hence I don't see why we keep bringing back something from our past that has no significant existence now, and that none of the Hindus care about anymore.
Discrimination is very high in India against upper cast they fase discrimination in education system because 90 %percent scored not get admissions and lower scores enjoying reservations and facilities
Are you going to bring Rajiv Malhotra as well? The video had to be a mosque!!!!
I would have thought there would be some depth to the conversation. This guy is a poster child of a colonial vision and view. We will see where he goes. He is still young. At the end of the day, we need to govern with a view of providing people with equal opportunities to education, livelihood and justice. The outcomes will depend on the Individuals. For a guy that states we are mired in history he quotes from history throughout the conversation.
As for modernity, we have a skewed view of it and what it means. For most Indians it is mere speaking Englais. Social mobility and right to livelihood are fundamental and have nothing to do with modernity. This is where I agree with Yengde. We need to promote local tongues, write science, math and other sciences in native tongue. What modernity is typically, is adoption of technology and using natural resources to economically grow. This can happen without adopting western tongue.
Western view of Caste!!! Why should we care. A group that has committed the worst atrocities on natives and blacks. Do you think they ever wonder how India views them? LOL!!! Inferiority complex galore.
What we forget is to hold a mirror to the west. What they have done in terms of destroying native civilizations and people and marginalized them to a point where they currently hold access and use of those resources has never happened anywhere. That implies they do not have any moral high ground. We continue to have the romantic view of the west as Modern STATES!!! Hamara naya dristi kahan hai?
This is though changing in how BJP and Jaishankar are standing up. We need to change quite a bit there. Yengde did not have to go to Harvard or Cambridge to study caste system and give caste commentary. YET!!!
For a guy that says we need an Indic view, he speaks about and quotes only western view. He has not quoted even one of the Dasas, Basavanna, Ramanuja etc. Yengde is doing exactly what most Indians do. They go out for justice instead of fighting it out in India. The western view matters so much and the affirmation a necessity.
As for practicing a religion, it is not the same as saying I believe in the caste system. Hinduism is not a dogmatic religion where you need to take every word literally and believe every word. You pick and choose and leave out what does not agree with you. I understand the perspective that they are coming from. After all, Yengde and his interviewer are presenting the victim view. I am ok with what their opinion about religion and religious practice is. I am glad later they realize that they cannot be victims forever. The card does not work.
As for discrimination in the US on caste basis. It is a cooked-up story. How do they think it is practiced? Most folks in the US are Christian Protestant. Cisco has been the one instance. It does not make it a wide practice. Yengde goes onto explain how caste discrimination has been internalized via different mechanisms of Sanskriti, language etc. GEE man!!! Laughable. This is working in the US because of the place where US and the west is today in implementation of Critical Race Theory. Ask Yengde to give examples of widespread caste practice in the US or in the West. It is interesting to see how Yengde paints the entire savarnas as caste discriminating. Unbelievable!!!
Endogamy is a choice. Endogamy is a mutual choice. The issue is when people choose to violate this agreed endogamy. There we can be a bit more approving and should be.
😂 that joker left INDIAN citizenship, he should not be allowed to interfere in INDIA'S issue.
@@praneet1377 so has Yengde?
@@MrRk540 he has not,he just went there to study.
@@praneet1377 keep thinking that. It is a matter of time boy. Rajiv did the same.
You can hold mirror to west when you're doing better than them. And we all know we are third world country with third rate social structure.
Bahut achcha video hai
Good knowledge, thank you very much.
बहुत ही उत्तम और ज्ञानवर्धक बातचीत ॥॥
Although I couldn't make a head or tail of this conversation (my bad),I seriously hope this helps to address the concerns of people concerned.
Me too man. They both don’t know what they are talking about!
Amazing conversation
Dilip Mandal is the true example of mediocrity.
It’d have been alright if he was a mediocre. He holds less intellect than a 2 year old.
Haha true
Modiji is mediocre
He is very pessimistic. He sees no progress in the last 75 years
You are true example of casteist criminal
This is a fantastic analysis, presented simply.
Super job sir ji ,aap sabhi se bahut kuchh sikhane ko milta hai,sadar jay bhim namo budhay.
What nonsense! They both don’t know what they are talking about! This guy can’t answer a single question properly! Kuch bhi bakwas kar raha hai!
Only being from Harvard/Oxford doesn’t mean that the guy is smart. Stop promoting stereotypes.
I am trying to share this guest speaker hindu phobic comments but my comment keep getting deleted. Search this fellows comments in twitter and TH-cam, you will know his true colour . It’s so Sad that a respected channel like Print is inviting him. I was thinking of taking paid membership but not any more. Extremely mediocre journalism
plz get away from the print asap and block it if possible
Jay Bhim Prof.Dr. Suraj sir🌹🙏📚✒️🎤
I am reading this book now.must say it’s nothing more than a rant against Brahmins.
Why should’nt there be a ‘rant’ against the Brahmins?
@@serenity8145 When you use "the" before communities you want to 'rant' against, your latent bigotry is exposed.
Because Brahmins alone are not responsible for the Dalit issues. Brahmins are not in power OBCs are
@@serenity8145 then be ready for the counter rant and then don’t cry foul😂
@@ghostk7993 who is whining we can see. Brahmins are worst creature in through human history. One Tam Brahmin Pichai can't do a thing.
Amazing. Sir.
This guy roams around circles who themselves are oppressors. Never engages in debates with those who oppose his views. His activities doesn't address the discrimination issue but further destroys the society.
It's his profession. He gets money and funding by talking about caste. These people who have a vested agenda and no real love for upliftment of people. Stooges of the Western world.
Salute Respected Professor Shahab 🙏
Wonderful conversation
After listening to Mr Yengde, I can say that the standard at Oxford has reduced a lot.
Good 👍 discussion Jay Bheem Jay bharat Jay sambhidhan namo budhay Jay mulnivasi Jay loktantra
Too simplistic and shallow. Cant bear after 10 minutes watching.
Both of you our role model
His book talks about caste and doesn't mention Savarkar or RSS which was founded to tackle this issue . Further he even rejects these
Rate A hypocrite
rss is a bigoted organisation ofcourse we have to battle caste system and we dont want to be bigot also hence rss excluded
RSS is just eye wash to call everyone hindu and oppress Dalits. Ja re manuwadi, koi nayi technique use kar
Excellent interview
Great
Hindus click join button, Prints uses money to divide the Hindus at just rs 159
Very nice presentation sir.
जय भीम, जय मंडल, जय जोहार, संविधान-जिंन्दाबाद
💙💙💙
Great job sir
...........sir for me you and the other student of you or friend ...were together ..inspired me ..
Salute to both of you🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Great conversation both of you
But normal Indian are not properly understand or importance of point of views.
Thank you sir both of you.
I got more knowledge🎉❤
always agreed SIR
Need to include meitai in schedule tribe categories immediately for the solution for Manipur problem 😊
Yup
Shaandaar interview sir
Suraj yengde should marry a royal white European girl to Stop casteism in his own family..and be role model against Caste
Very good analysis sir please find the way of jobs, create a structure on jobs. 🙏🙏🙏🙏 Jai bhim jai bharat jai samvidhan. And think about poor people.
शानदार बातचीत
sasta afrikan 😂
A vacuous interview.
Nice discussion
Nice sir ji ❤❤❤
Good experience... social media
Jayvigyan Jaymandal jaysamvidhan Jayloktantra 🙏
The Great jurneilst Delep mandal je ne agde je ka Exilant Intarviewe nice video
Great ग्रेट 💞❤
हमारे जो बच्चे है, उनको ये जानकारी नहीं है, बिलकुल सही विश्लेषण 👍🙏
Waiting Interview in English
Read about Jogendernath Mandal.
Best interview
If at all this reaches Yengde, my questions to him would be:
1. The entire west is an oppressor civilization. At least we hear the voices of oppressed blacks because they are here now to talk about it, but where are the voices of native Americans and aboriginal Australians? They are killed. Gone from this world!!
You are promoted by the oppressors to retain oppression narratives of India. Where is your conscience??
2. You speak of understanding the nuanced layers of casteism, if you truly believe so, do you even study or understand that there are layers and layers of separation within dalit community?? Instead of parroting the propaganda prepared by British when they wanted to divide and rule India, you can study the roots of endogamy.
We all must understand the roots of untouchability. As we saw during Covid, untouchability in a culture starts with large scale pandemics and epidemics. If untouchability didn't serve an existential purpose, it wouldn't become a part of the culture in the first place. Access restrictions to shared places such as water bodies only come into effect when there is an epidemic. When there is an endemic, people learn to stay away from others and practices of untouchability, access restrictions enter the society.
Two wrongs doesn't make a right. But I happy your manuwadi ass is burning like Manusmriti
sir I m agreed ..and how to communicate to our people .. ...
Good
Yengde Sir please motivate your community that they escape out of work they are do...even in our community in sc st ..I have communicated all your videos in your caste .. but I think it will be shown to your next generation ...and surely they will be benefitted
please bring rahul sonpimple on your channel 😊
🙏🙏🙏💙💙💙👏
sir please how to communicate...
Jai Bhim Suraj. We proud of you.
Suraj ji 🙏
Sooraj is perfectly right and logical. I had listened scores of talks. Even on subject of British Rule the learned Shree Shashi Tharoor is bias against the English. But if English were not here We and Pakistan and Bangladesh, Nepal wouldn't have been democracies. We wouldn't have been technological advanced. We might would have been divided in many kingdoms.
Not necessarily bro.
Even there was no nation of Germany as we know today. But Bismarck bought it together in 20th century.
Similar thing could have happened in India. Why do you ASSUME otherwise?
who knows ,would have been slaves again burning widows and females for dowry,marrying young uneducated girls, raping and exploiting weak,eating food without washing hands with soap,stinking in sweat with dung and scum
Japan was a very isolated feudal society. The Europeans forced them to trade with them and after lot of fight/resistance Japanese opened up and started trading. The Japanese never allowed Europeans to bully them like British and Americans did with China (Opium Wars). They realized Europeans were advanced and little by little Westernized their society, bought technology and advanced themselves. Something similar could have been done in India too.
Jai Bheem 🙏🙏
Both explain Worldwide castisium clearly
Mndal sir, I proud, u.
Salute Respected Professor Shahab 🙏
Can suraj discuss this with people opposing his views? Or this will only be seen in print,scroll and newslaunday?
Dilip mondal sir,sc st obc की तरह एक होंगे, इसपर भी कभी ट्विट करिएगा,,rs Praveen sir बीएसपी तेलंगाना प्रदेश अध्यक्ष के बारे में ट्विट करें,plz
Kya gol gol ghuma raha hai bhai... Seedha jawaab ek bhi nahi diya!
Sahi kaha
either it is communicated
Caste system is prevalent across the world 😢
what about hair, is it original??
Awesome conversation about caste system in Argentina, which persists despite their world cup win. At least that’s what I understood based on this highly erudite discussion
Ratanlalji and Suraj please read Myth of Tilak, and you both will understand that British already highlighted the caste system and Brahminisham
भारत को कास्ट के बेसिस पर अलग होने पर कैसा होगा कृपया ये भी बताएं,अफ्रीका की तरह छोटे छोटे देश में हो जाने पर दलित का क्या विकाश होगा ये डिटेल से बताएं
Oh.... Brahmins are in africa tooo😅😂 question is realted to a but answer is related to b....wokes are always confused 🤔
Just ask a simple question that when SC , ST actually got some benefits..is it before or after independence
Shree Suraj Yengdey ji your thoughts are quite real and should be acceptable to SC,ST, OBC and other Indian people. Jay Bheem.
Greatjob sir.....
Jay bhim 💙
Wish the interviewer was Rajiv Malhotra. The audience would then have a nuanced view of both sides and be free to make up their own minds.
Read Rajiv Malhotraji and you’ll know a lot more about how these folks operate!
Rajiv Malhotra is a tatta of RSS
Some people are claiming that casteism is slowly going to be irrelevant,,, it's like becoming an ostrich in the face of the danger,, if it were not still there,, these much educated people might not have been talking about it,,if education could make you accepted within upper strata,, then these people would have been indifferent about caste but the fact remains that casteism still exists for lower castes in an unspoken way in urban areas but openly and brutally in rural areas, caste supremacy still haunts and untouchability still exist...and India on the path of becoming Hindu-rashtra will clearly demarcate castes even more aggressively... it's sad but it's truth...
Self victimisation is the biggest reason of defeat.....
Agar hum caste cencus ka bahiskar karte hai to is se sarkar ke upar kya asar hoga, batayen.
Best interview 🔥💙
Criminal castes people may say that this interview is a propaganda or useless.. Truth is that this is the most needed interview..
suraj bhai hair style thodi casual h 🙂🙂🙂
Jay bhim sir
in simple language chamber and Balmiki . .. Ambedkarite.. it will take time but it will be .
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉