EP-168 | Caste Census, Muslim Quota Row, Constitution, Dalit Politics with Prof. Dilip Mandal
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 พ.ค. 2024
- Prof. Dilip Mandal is an author and a seasoned journalist. He is the former managing editor of India Today Hindi Magazine, and has authored books on media and sociology.
Often known for talking about the plight of dalits in India, Mandal has often seen himself in controversies for voicing out strong opinions on social media sites like X.
In this episode of ANI Podcast with Smita Prakash, the senior journalist speaks up about the ongoing Muslim Reservation Row, and why, reservation should not be on the basis on religion. He also speaks up on the important of a caste census in India. He also alleges that Congress has never acted in the interests of the country's Dalit community.
#ANIPodcastwithSmitaPrakash #DilipMandal #Podcast
Timestamps
0:00 - Coming Up
2:00 - Introduction
3:47 - Muslim Reservation Background
16:30 - Wealth Redistribution
18:36 - Congress' and OBCs
23:00 - Caste Census
27:04 - Ambedkar's Discord with Congress
30:16 - VP Singh's Reforms
31:20 - Ranganath Mishra Commission
46:30 - Constitution Amemdment Row
57:00 - Swachh Bharat Mission
1:04:18 - Controlling The Narrative
1:06:25 - Bhatta-Parsaul
1:08:11 - Wealth 'Dilution'
1:15:48 - Congress Policies & Backward Castes
1:23:18 - Universalization of Policies
1:27:20 - Politics of Caste
1:29:16 - Savarkar's 'Virat Hindu' Ideals
Join ANI's TH-cam membership to get access to perks:
/ @aninewsindia
Subscribe now and press the bell icon 🔔 to get new video updates: bit.ly/2UV4ygi
--------------------------------------
ANI is South Asia's leading Multimedia News Agency providing content for every information platform, including TV, Internet, broadband, newspapers, and mobiles.
Subscribe now! Enjoy and stay connected with us!!
☛ Subscribe to ANI News TH-cam channel: bit.ly/2UV4ygi
☛ Visit our Official website: www.aninews.in/
☛ Follow ANI: / ani
☛ Like us: / aninews.in
☛ Email to: anicontent@aniin.com, internetani@aniin.com
☛ Copyrights © All Rights Reserved ANI Media Pvt Ltd.
On Twitter i didn't quite like Dilip Mandal. But i must say this man is very knowledgeable about history 😊
Muslims: Mine is mine, yours is ours and then yours is mine.
Con gress: Take it, then more take it.
And the only way to get that is victim card..
Hindus have an obligation to their fellow Hindu OBC, SC ST but have no obligation to other religions sect or sub sect
Hindus have no obligation
😂
Yeah, ' hindu ' is just a meaningless term as far as religion goes, but even so if you really felt the obligation, you wouldn't have been beaching about reservation since the past 75 years or so. Yes?
@@Pantherazure yeah hinduism is a dharm, not religion.
Also yeah hindus have no obligation, you got that right
कुल मिलाकर कांग्रेस ने कन्वरजन को प्रोमोट करने का पूरा रास्ता रंगनाथ मिश्रा आयोग के द्वारा खोलने का प्रयास किया था ।
Dilip Mandal is hardcore critic of BJP and RSS. He is speaking very sensitive issue. INC is becoming threat to India integrity
दिलीप मंडल जी बहुत इंटेलिजेंट और ज्ञानी व्यक्ति है। समाज और राजनीति की बहुत अच्छी समझ है
Every OBC/SC/ST should listen this poadcast and decide who are against them 👍
Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel or babashahab peaceful community ke thought process se Puri clear the
This guy is a Library, amazing knowledge on constitution and politics. Respect sir🙏
Very insightful.. the Ranganath Mishra part, how OBCs were neglected by Congress was very interesting
Smita ji,
Undoubtedly, one of the best podcast with full of knowledge on caste-politics-policies.
You can have another looooooong podcast with him.
This is for my all SC, ST and OBC brethren who say Modi is going to finish the reservation.
Please watch.
I again say I support caste based reservation as long as it is given to my Hindu brethren only because caste curse was among Hindus only. It is their constitutional right and no meherbani.
Whatever he may have said and done in past, his words are now opening eyes of millions of Indians.
Bhai majority Indians ki ankhen pehle bhi khuli thi ye to in meem bheem supporters ki ankhen khul rahi hai this is important.And why he is doing now bcoz what congress did terminating reservations of sc st obc from AMU and JAMIA ISLAMIA Back in 90s.They didn't followed what Babasaheb wrote about muslims and Islam and just for their cheap causes they always chose selected.But never mind jab aankh khule tabhi savera
Being vegetarian doesn't means one have to eat poisoned fruits or vegetables too likewise being secularism doesn't mean we have to recognize islam /Cristianity ... we should reform our constitution which is written by invaders and mullah only... 🕉 🕉
Wow ❤what an analysis done by Proff Mandal.
Every Obc and Sc St should listen. It might make things clear. Need Captions for English speaking audience.🗣️
Most eye opening interview. Thank you Dilip ji
This podcast is so absorbing, revealing and comprehensive that I could not resist watching it until the end.
Prof Mandal is real gem. His knowledge on the subject is simply outstanding. It was a great pleasure listening to him.
I liked his starement 'Congress is a disruptor not Narendra Modi'. He put his stamp of approval on most of the tasks achieved by NDA goverment under the leadership of Modi ji.
Congress needs to be outrightly rejected by the masses for at least 25 more years so that the continuity of progress is ensured.
Mam iss podcast ke short videos viral kijiye so that people know what congress had done and what BJP is doing now
OBC and ST/SC should listen to Mandal ji 👍
Really great discussion. In depth knowledge of caste politics. Congress was such a force against OBC.
Prof Dilip Mandal was thought provoking and debate was full of facts and thoroughly enriching. Thankyou
OBC reservation was secretly given to Indian Muslims and Muslims caste were added in obc ,secular politics has suppressed obc rights .
And u PPL said reservation should not be on religion 😂 such a hypocrite
Eye opening discussion. The Congress has damaged India so much. They're now trying to institutionalise the power of Muslim Ashraf high castes, who are already rich and oppressive.
I wonder if even one SC/ST voting in India will be listening to Prof. Dilip Mandal.
Eye opener discussion, Dilip mandal is great
BJP se jyada Khatarnak Congress hai SC ST aur OBC ke lie
EWS me Muslim Sikh Christian aur hindu k sare general category k log aate hai..
OBC SC ST k liye kaun zada khatarnaak hai khud decide karlo ab
The guest has researched very well and speaking with the information he has gathered through credible sources. It is definitely a wake up call for all to know about Congress and how it is playing with the country’s future. It is sad that Telangana and Karnataka is not seeing these issues and electing Congress at the state level. People are thinking that since they are electing at the state level it does not impact nationally. People are giving fodder to the Congress party to stay relevant which is not good. There should more parties based on national and the majority. BJP is doing fine but not enough.
मै पहले मंडल जी को बहुत गाली देता था, लेकिन उनके विशाल ज्ञान भण्डार के बाद उनका प्रशंसक बन गया हूं।
कभी कभी उनसे अभी भी disagree करता हूं।
पर बहुत knowledgeable आदमी है।।।
Beta tu gandhi family ki napies change kar.
Excellent and thoughtful account by Professor Dilip Mandal
Excellent view and ideas from prof Dilip Mandal .This is first time i heard him but he has amazing knowledge. Must watch video
He is very knowledgeable
Eye opening podcast! Thanks Smitha
Ab kuchh log bolenge ki mandal sahab ka-mandal Waley hogaye. 😂 Bro he's just spitting facts.
Mandal Real Voice of the voiceless.
Hero of BAHUJAN SAMAJ .
I like professor Mandal's knowledge and perspectives in nation. Think broadly think differently.
मुस्लिम मे बागवान cummunity सबसे ज्यादा पैसे वाले हे फिर भी ये obc मे हे ये कोनसे आधार पर किया हे ये काँग्रेस का काम हे
हिंदुओं के अंदर से जाति व्यवस्था समाप्त करना ही होगा। ये हर हिंदू का धर्म है। मैं एक ब्राह्मण होकर भी ये बातें हृदय की गहराई से कहना चाहता हूं। धर्म को सुरक्षित रखना प्रमुख उद्देश्य है इसे जाति व्यवस्था की भेंट नहीं चढ़ा सकते।
Ye hinduo ko bachane ka theka bamano ne le rakha hai.
Ye khud apas me jatiwad krte hain
Sbse jyda dalito ko obc marte hai nam bamano ka ata hai.
Impeccable knowledge. He raised very pertinent points.
outstanding episode! Professor Mandal needs to be heard more! I personally feel looking at our Hindu society from last 10 years and compare it from before, we are better integrated. Even Mantra delivering pandits relished when modi himself did pran pratisthan and invited dom raja inside garb griha. Modi actually shown how we have to be as united Hindus. This actually is the true worship of God's because lord ram was actually for everyone without any discrimination
Great interview with very knowledgeable individuals.
Smita Ji Please bring this type of guest ahead of interviewing politicians.
Also it seems your research team need to learn a lot. Again and again he corrected you and your information about the subject matter.
🙏 I learned a lot! Mishra & Sachar commission is so dangerous for all Indians. Congress doesn't understand even they won't stay in power if they promote radical islamisation! Thanks a lot ANI 🙏
Muslim asked for separate country they got Pakistan(East-West)
After that again asking for reservation.
Next day every State or Minority will ask separate country some will remain with India and again they ask reservation... Yes it is absolutely Anti-national....Thanks for complete picture sir....
Smita shouldn't interrupt her guest so much. It is so irritating
Caste census ki baat tera baap krra hai road pe ? Congress hi hai na vo . To usko counter to karna pdega meri jaan
Serious Request to ani ..please give English subtitles to what prof mandal is saying so that the message can reach to the audience who doesn't understand Hindi properly..would be a great step
Superb 👌, very informative about the diabolical Kangress.
Shame on Congress Culture
1:14:37
Epic : "pani uthega to saari naav uthti hai"
mindblowing clarity this person has. his pro-success approach
मैं सामान्य कैटोगरी से हूं, पहले मै इससे असहमत था , लेकिन ये वीडियो देखने के बाद मै इसका फैन बन गया हूं
Although I don’t agree with Mandal for looking for caste in everything but here he’s stop on. Congress wants to get back Muslim vote hence endorsing Muslim quota. This should be spread far & wide.
Dilip Mandal got a 180-degree shift in opinion...👍
Jamia amu msin sc ka reservation kyon kata.
ऐसे विद्वान लोग मीडिया के हर प्लेटफॉर्म के विमर्श मे होना चाहिए।
दिलीप मंडल जैसे लोग अपने शोध व जानकारी को आसानी से हर जागरूक भारतीय के लिए उपलब्ध हो।
🙏🏼🙏🏼
Sardar patel was not a politician he was GOD🙏 actual son of soil
Dilip Mandal ko kya ho gaya. Mujhe yaqeen nahi ho raha. Modi ji aap magician ho
What a wonderful and informative podcast. Smita ji, Thanks for bringing Prof. Mandal to your show.
Though you didn't directly discuss PM Modi's accusations in his "Mangalsutra" speech, Prof. Mandal provided enough evidence to support PM Modi's contentions.
To me PM's most significant contentuon was that Congress' manifesto reads like its been written by MIM. Prof. Mandal layed out strong evidence to support that claim.
I also like the closing conclusion--the churning during the electoral process its like samudra manthan. At the end of it the country will come out ahead.
Prof. Mandal made a beautiful observation why PM Modi will not change the Constitution. He is what he is today due to the Constitution. So it doesn't make sense for him to change it.
Thanks again.
Why they are not talking about price rise and atrocities against Dalits?
@@hemantsolanki3676 I am guessing because this podcast has a particular topic: to provide insight into the evolution of social justice policies. I am sure you can find other podcasts that talk about the topics you mentioned.
@@hemantsolanki3676atrocities against Dalits... where and how?
Arfa would die of a heart attack if she heard such cogent arguments
Very informative interview : Prof Mandal is really know what he is talking about.
Good research and open mind - great Indian intellectual
Smita this was very informative. Hats off to Prof Mandal on explaining all the fault lines.
The best ever viewed Podcast.Salute to Mr Mandal & Smita Prakash!
Sigh!!!! Smitha, stop interrupting your guests. It breaks the flow of conversation. Expats/young audience that watch your program are not dumb. If you want to further explain a topic while it is being talked about, then how about using text in the video or a Wiki link. I understand there maybe situatiions when you do want to add to the conversation, but please wait till the guest has finished making his/her point.
It's a podcast not an interview that she shouldn't interrupt her guest
Intellectuals like him are the need
ये इंटरव्यू प्रधानमंत्री भी देखने वाले हैं और अगले चुनावी भाषण में बहुत सी जानकारी लेकर कांग्रेस और ढंग से पेलने वाले हैं 😂😂.....मंडल जी वाकई में बहुत जानकारी रखते हो आप । गजब व्यक्ति 😮😮
What a pod cast ❤
Please make more of such masterpieces
I salute Dilip sir, such an intellectual guy
In this entire conversation the speaker Dilip Mandal seems to be most meaningful and knowledgeable academician, contrary to his image established previously. Compliments to ANI for bringing Prof Mandal on the pod.
देश में लोकतंत्र है , संविधान है, इसलिए नरेन्द्र मोदीजी -एक चायवाला प्रधानमंत्री बना,एक आदिवासी महिला राष्ट्रपति बनीं और गांधी परिवार का राजकुमार प्रधानमंत्री नहीं बन सका।
Very informative views from Prof Mandal. I wish Smitaji would not interrupt is thought process so frequently
Very informative..but I wish Smita shouldn't interrupt so much...
Ladies and gentlemen watch this podcast completely and think what congress is and what kind of secularism they followed and how much cunning they were
This podcast is very important and must be replayed over again. It is extremely unfortunate that some parties have worked in every possible way to defeat Bharat. Yet janta is so disinterested - they won't take a little trouble to watch this podcast
Genius dilip Mandal
Pakistan was the OG Muslim Quota goddammit
Very interesting podcast. Smitha ji and professor Dilip provide many unknown facts regarding our past with politics.loved this hearing as it enhanced my understanding.
Brilliant 👏. What an insightful conversation. Smita ji pls bring such speakers more often on your podcast, instead of movie actors or flunky politicians!
clarity of the thoughts every word on point
Smita ji. Can you please stop interjecting when your guest is stating his/her view. Let them please complete whatever they are trying to say 😀🙏🙏
yeah and she does to make it about herself most of times
Agar riots ke vakt tumhe hindu mana jaata hai to tum HINDU ho
Fir chahe tum SIKH ho DALIT ho SC ho ST ho yaa fir BUDHHIST
You are also the target🎯
Smita, this podcast is perhaps one of your best ever in educating the Indian population regarding issues of minority appeasement and caste conflicts, reservations and it's impact on the uplifting of the poorest of the poor, especially the Dalits.
Thank you very much Smita for such a well balanced and non partisan discussion. Mr Mondol is a National treasure and I can imagine his involvement in this vital issue for his being a member of the OBC/SC category. His knowledge is immense and I have gathered enough information about him to bow down and show my reverence towards him. Jai Bharat.
What a great podcast, eye opening, full of knowledge and statistics. Now I understand why Congress wants to divide Hindus into castes just for the sake of power.
This is One of the best podcasts ever
prof dilip mandal and other ambedkarites have only tried to get more and more quota for SC category, He keeps quoting USA diversity plans, but fails to mention a very recent verdict of the US Supreme Court specifically rejecting racial quota-based selection for USA universities. USA do not support freebies, and he is misleading about gender diversity plans, many ambedkarites in USA are also trying to somehow equate racial discrimination to caste discrimination to get same privileges.
there is one difference. In India SC OBC ST are Majority 70% holding 10% of govt posts. Supreme court has 99% brahmin judges.
In US Blacks r Minority. So in India rights like reservations were Taken forcibly by the ppl and not given free.
U can Jump and shout as much u like , but with Time, SC ST OBCs will take the Representation forcibly in national resources by hook or crooks. In past they were poor, ileterate. Today they have good quality nucleus of Educated people to fight for.
general people were rich in the past? OBCs are poor ?? OBCs have more land in India than anyone else in india, yadav, jat, gujjars, patel etc? they are poor ? they will buy your entire generation! you are very dumb to come up with such logic, and no dalits were barred from education in the past, go do your propaganda somewhere else, there is this book called" the beautiful tree" by rampal it has compilations of various reports and data on indegenous schools in india during 1820s( before the birth of ambedkar and phule, who are claimed to have given education privilege to dalits) that books clearly debunk your propaganda, almost in all schools shudra students outnumbered or matched the number of brahmin kids in those schools, on a contrary it was kshatriyas kids who were least in numbers in schools, by this logic i should be getting all the privilege and not you!.
and what is this logic of getting resources based on the population, decades of effort of the government in creating awareness about family planning were worthless? if your logic is taken seriously then everyone will start a race to have more kids to get more of the so-called resources in india?
and diversity program is not just about blacks only, the diversity program includes Native Indians, Mexicans, Jews and many other races as well, many white races of the USA are also part of the diversity program of these companies, USA is against freebies, it is merit dominated society. even the last judgement of the Supreme Court of the USA also reiterated the same logic that merit is the only criterion for selection into universities. @@GuzzarAwan
what a phenominal interview, both the host and guest were excellent, conversation was on point. Excellently unwinding, one by one
ऐसा बहुत कम होता है कि जब किसी को सुनकर लगे कि बहुत कुछ जानने को मिला।
Brilliant. Should be shared as much as possible
Congress just made pakistan, bangladesh and creating pakistan 3.0 and people didn't even know
He is wise man of India
An other problem is Ten types of Taxes in Bharat .
This type of men can make new re search
For simple one window tax system
To save people from Bureaucratic coruption
Congress is morethen musilm party, congress did such a brutal things with consistution & 🕉 hindus of 80% population of india
I wonder Dhruv Rathi and Ravish Kumar like people listen to content like these or not.
May be they do, but Propaganda chalana bhi toh Jaruri hai..papi pet ka sawal hai
Mandal sir rocked here.
This was the most important podcast of this year....
Every Indian should be made to watch this.
It's one of the best podcasts.. bring such less known people.
A great eye opening podcast.. This man is so crude with reality. Loved every moment of this podcast.
Every Indian and Hindu should watch this podcast.
Dilip always surprise with his intelligence and understanding
Dilip mondal is much more sane guy ,compare to his twitter avatar,where he just want to caste divide larger and larger..
Great Political. Thinker
Ye aadmi Saanp hai sarawati ji. Brahmin hate failata hai.
@@sagar_654chup reh... abhi ye fact bol rha ... baat uspe ho rai...
This man is so clear about his thoughts and such fresh perspectives. Really an underrated gem
Really interesting and lot of great information, such a simple man , super like
Prof is a very articulate person. I love his analyses. This is exactly what Congress and the INDI alliance are afraid of...Hindus uniting.
We had the partition in 1947. After that Muslims should not stay in India at all. The British agent Ambedkar put the reservation for 25 years only. It cannot go on for ever; particularly for those whose parents already got jobs due to reservations.
Poor and uneducated Muslims were the main killers in every communal riots. None has seen the barristers like Jinnah or Suhrawarddy killing the non-Muslims. They directed the killers and provided immunity to the killers.
@@DipakBose-bq1vvthat's why you took another country no ? Still you stayed back and took our resources and land
Excellent conversation, so much clarity in thoughts as well as analysis. Will love to hear Prof. Mandal more often.
It's an eyeopener podcast! No wonder why Pundits say "Knowledge is power"!
Thanks ma'am, please make a video on waqf board