How Accurate is FGO's Sherlock Holmes?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ค. 2024
- How well does Fate/Grand Order portray Sherlock Holmes, The Great Detective? How close is Holmes' in-game version to his literary counterpart? In this video we delve into his character design, in-game skills, and characterization in order to determine that, followed up by giving it a grade in terms of its accuracy to the source material. Was Sherlock Holmes a master detective who was a solid ally despite his quirks? Find out here!
Check out JasonDoesWhatever's channel here to see FGO Story Content! youtube.com/@JasonDoesWhateve...
---
Gameplay footage comes from the mobile game Fate/Grand Order.
Maps are from Google Maps or Wikimedia.
Artwork consists of images created since the original writing of the 'Sherlock Holmes' novels, chiefly works in the public domain from the 19th century.
Animated footage is from Fate/Grand Order - Absolute Demonic Front: Babylonia (2019-2020) by Cloverworks. Animated footage from this source is labeled by their source in the top left corner whenever such footage is used.
I am not the original creator of any of the images, maps, artworks, film, or music shown in this video. All materials used in this video are for the purposes of education and fall under Fair Use. If you are the copyright owner of materials found in this video and object to its use here, please message me. See the About section of my Channel Page for further information on how to contact me.
00:00 Intro
00:14 Class
00:53 Character Design
02:33 Skillset
04:05 Noble Phantasm
05:31 Craft Essence
06:11 Characterization
08:38 Drugs!
09:25 Characterization Pt 2
11:11 Conclusion
11:59 Final Grade - เกม
Both literary and FGO Sherlock keeps "magical white powder" in their stash
As an avid reader of all things Sherlock Holmes, I can very much confirm that Holmes being a more kind and friendly character is waaaaaaaay more in tune with the Sherlock Holmes of the books than many modern incarnation. There is quite a few moments actually that make me think that the person writing him has a good grasp on him. The whole part where Holmes likes being celebrated for his deductions is something that very much seems to be in character to him (in "A study in scarlet" he does even blush because they applaud him for it, although Watson describes him as being extremely happy, so it seems it's a happy blush).
Modern interpretations of Sherlock often lean into the "Asshole Genius" trope, which does not quite line up with how he is very often described as being incredibly kind to people within the framework of the society he lives in. He has a gaggle of street kids that he pays good money to to pick up word on the street... but also to make sure they get to eat. He takes interest in cases as a mental challenge, sure, but baring that his main motivation is still helping people out. Especially if nobody else is willing to help them.
Sidenote, he wears that hat he is famous for once. And he finds it gaudy at that point, but it is for a disguise... which is the only thing that does not get brought up nearly enough, that Sherlock is a master of disguise, which is how he manages to fool Watson for so long that he is dead.
Yep, the fact that he is a master of disguise is also a part of his skillset in FGO. One of his NP is just that, a really good disguise.
One thing I love about the violin being his Craft Essence is that it seems apparent that his fondness for violin playing is a good contrast to his typical disposition, or the image he forms in the minds of other people--it reflects on his more artistic sensibilities, and therefore, on the softness of his humanity amidst the rigidity and stark logic. In other words, it's a fitting gift for raising our " _Bond_ " points with him.
I hadn't thought about it that way. Very interesting, and it makes sense too!
Don't forget that his illustrator (Yamanaka Kotetsu) has only drawn other beast class enemies...
Uh oh...
Really late here, considering how caster sherlock was described there is a chance that a caster sherlock may become a beast
I would have liked if you could include the unutilized Noble Phantasms of servants into your analysis for these videos. Sherlock Holmes has a second Noble Phantasm called Empty House which (as far as I remember) was used in the Shinjuku storyline in order to maintain a disguise.
I'll look into those more!
Ah, Sherlock. I think he has one of the only triple + ranked skills in FGO. I think he might be the only one with an A+++ skill. Makes you wonder why it isn't just EX at that point.
EX would mean it falls outside the ranking system so if that skill doesn't it won't be EX.
Also I believe Li Shuwen has a +++ skill.
@@Lucaintheninjatank also Vlad III extra and First Hassan with protection of faith A+++ (and both Li Shuwens have but different skills)
Daily reminder EX is not stronger than A+ skills, people always forget or just straight up thinks EX has the same status in every other media where its the best rank while actuality Fate does it abit differently where its EX cant be calulated like how comparing apples to orange cant be the same. Also some EX are straight up weaker than C rank skills lorewise
@@tixrobux2930 well its mostly apply to skills like madness enchancment EX because they are mad in a different way so they can talk etc. Other than that most EX skills are straith up stronger then their one-lettered counterparts. But a great point especialy concerning ridiculous skills with A+++ ranking
I think, lore-wise, it might also be A+++ because he is not in his caster saint graph, being able to solve all mysteries
Ritsuka: So... Not counting Da Vinci. Are you our most reliable Servant ally?
Holmes: Elementary, my dear Ritsuka. Unlike your other Servant allies, I am always there to support along with Da Vinci. If not... What Servant was going to help you? Dantes? Jeanne? d'Eon? Mordred?
Ritsuka: Good. As long as you don't die like Lalter or betray us in the future, I guess I can always trust you.
Holmes: That's impossible! I won't be like Lalter since the FGO writers know what to do with me in the story and don't treat me like a walking joke like d'Eon.
Wahahaha. This amused me.
Well now you've done it! My other fav fictional character (along with Edmond Dantes/Avenger). Another wonderful analysis of this character. FGO Sherlock version does feel a lot nicer than his modern interpretations and compared to those, he does seem nicer like his book counterparts. Then again, it's quite hard to fully grasp his personality as the books are almost entirely from Watson's POV. He does have some light-hearted side and is overall less severe and serious than how modern portrayals go (especially the 21st century interpretations). Either way I'm looking forward to your next vid of Moriarty himself! The one man who can go toe-to-toe with Holmes.
I'm actually taking a pause right now from writing the script for Moriarty. I am going to... have lots to say about him. I hope you like it once I finish it in the coming days! :D
@@CrazyYurie Take all the time you need! Moriarty is another complicated individual. Sometimes I think it's amazing how highly intelligent and gifted individuals like Holmes and Moriarty can take such different paths in life. For one who only appears in two of Doyle's story, he has quite the impact upon Holmes.
Btw just as phrase "Elementary my dear Watson" his iconic deerstalker hat also wasn't mentioned in original text and product of one of the first illustrator's depictions.
I seem to have made an oversight. Oops.
I mean, I think it was in the book, it was just a one-off outfit he used on cases in the countryside.
yeah, I also think FGO's depiction of Holmes is closer to the original novel than the modern one. Also, I laugh so hard when they show how excited Holmes is when he sees crack lmao
Imagine being so good at solving mystery that you got promoted to a stronger class just to stop you from solving all possible mystery in life😂
Probably my most favorite servant. The way he chant's his NP is just perfect and the NP animation itself is perfect too, it gives me chills. Just reached the lostbelts a few weeks ago (Lostbelt 2 currently) and I really like him as a character although he's mostly just a supporting cast.
You will get to see lots more of him in the future! He does largely remain a supporting cast member, but still a very important one!
the reason for holmes being a ruler instead of caster is that his np is classified as anti-world with the effect of letting him find the truth in anything.
if he wasnt restricted to be more rational as a ruler he would most likely be inclined to use his np to uncover and dispell all the secrets and mystics in the world and by proxy kill the planet aka gaia.
which makes him a threat to the planet even if he himself doesnt mean to.
The thing that summoned Sherlock Holmes is-
SPIDERS?!?
But does he discombobulate?
Probably.
In my head canon Captain Nemo hates him as well more so because he is British, but also the way he act
Not impossible that that is actually the case. :o
i`ll be waiting with anticipation for continuation of this series, hope you will grade Charles, Marie and Charlotte (maybe in one brief video bc there is already three long ones) and other new characters. Granted I now how hard and time consuming is research for this kind of content so we all need our cup of patience
I do have a pretty good idea for what grade I'd give each of them. I'll get back to them at some point. :3
Your videos are so fun to watch keep going
Thank you! :D
Just found ur channel! I hope u keep making videos like this. Thanks!
Thanks! Making more of these videos is very much the plan! I've written most of the script for the next one, and am hoping to finish it in a few days! ^_^
I know you weren't around for the event, but you should really check out the Murder at the Kogetsukan event. It's a really good showing for both Holmes and Moriarity.
love these videos dude keep em up
Thanks! :D
Holmes is probably my favorite Fate character. Cool analysis
Thanks!
Speaking of which , why isnt it name Storm Border!? it literally summon a giant storm in Rider Davinci np lol
also instant sub! thank for the info and insight
What isn't named Storm Border? Also thanks! :D
Shadow Border
The car thar we ride in every lostbelt
Also the one that mispelling the most in this clip lol ngl I dont see anything relate to shadow in that car except color
@@TTigrex Oh... oh I thought you were connecting this to Holmes somehow. :o
No discombomulate, F tier
Wha?
First…… discombobulate
Uwa?
@@CrazyYurie yeah I just pulled on the banner and got him….. seemed appropriate to celebrate….. so………. Discombobulate
@@DragonKnight90001 Congrats! :D