How Hindi damaged Bihar's languages
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 มิ.ย. 2024
- Download KuKu FM app using this link: kukufm.sng.link/Bpksi/3gsk/z9hk
Use coupon code: Mohak20
#KuKuFM
******
Liked the background music? I use Epidemic Sound. You can get a 30-day free trial using this referral: www.epidemicsound.com/referra...
******
Research: Priyanshu Sinha ➡️ / bol_priyanshu
Editing: Harshit Singh ➡️ / @ocural7696
Subtitles: Dhruv Bambhaniya ➡️ / dhruvkumar_2920
******
Markers
0:00 Introduction
1:53 How Hindi became popular in India
5:36 How Hindi replaced Bihar’s languages
7:20 Negative image of Biharis
8:49 Consequences of Hindi use
9:15 Influence of Hindi academia
10:01 Recent changes
******
Support on Patreon:
/ sochyoutube
Contact:
Facebook: / sochyoutube
Instagram: / mohak.mangal
Twitter: / mohakmangal
******
Creative commons:
Pixabay
Unsplash
Flaticon
Freepik
Videvo
******
Sources:
0. Introduction
• Shri Narendra Modi add...
scroll.in/article/965501/how-...
www.livemint.com/Leisure/Nl73...
www.thenewsminute.com/article...
1. How Hindi became popular in India
www.amazon.in/Hindi-Nationali...
www.livemint.com/Leisure/hF0p...
thediplomat.com/2017/05/how-h...
pdfs.semanticscholar.org/56a9...
2. How Hindi replaced Bihar’s languages
www.jstor.org/stable/44144797
www.jstor.org/stable/26906192
www.outlookindia.com/outlookt...
link.springer.com/content/pdf...
3. Negative image of Biharis
journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/...
www.jstor.org/stable/4370220
eprints.lse.ac.uk/28318/1/WP3.pdf
timesofindia.indiatimes.com/c...
www.iipsindia.ac.in/sites/def...
web.archive.org/web/201210220...
hindi.oneindia.com/news/2008/...
4. Consequences of Hindi use
www.freepressjournal.in/weeke...
5. Influence of Hindi academia
www.thehindu.com/news/nationa...
www.jstor.org/stable/44144797
6. Recent changes
www.hindustantimes.com/educat...
www.thehindu.com/news/cities/...
• MITHILA MAKHAAN | OFFI...
• Bambai Main Ka Ba | Bh...
The folk song at the end is sung by Sharda Sinha. Here is the link: bit.ly/3euff1e
Correction: The name of the author at 9:06 should be Shillpi A Singh. This is her news article: www.freepressjournal.in/weekend/kaithi-this-200-year-old-script-is-fading-into-oblivion
Pls pin
Bhojpuri Music is really much more than Songs like Rinkiya Ke Papa🙌🙌
💖
please make a discord
Make video on pew research survey.
As a Maharashtrian, I agree that there is an impact of migration. It’s due to flawed policies of the politicians of Bihar state. Apart from south India, even in Maharashtra, Hindi is seen the way it is seen in south India, though the scale is not that much. We always thought that Hindi is from the Hindi belt and is ruining local language and culture. Little did I know that infact Hindi ruined other language of this Hindi belt! Thanks for another informative video mohak!
As a Maharashtrian you should know there is difference between your own Marathi language and some dialect is considered as "pure" and others are mocked upon. You should also know how the Pune centred state board has been slowly killing the other "ashudda" dialects from Vidarbha and Marathwada and enforcing their own version of Marathi in these parts.
@@AnilKumar-wj2tz yes interstate language have to be English
I grew up in Maharashtra , Mumbai I faced a discrimination and harrsment by Marathi people . Unlike other country trade capital Mumbai is stucked in state politics of Maharashtra . As Mumbai has much higher Hdi , unfortunately a politician from Mumbai have to talk about Marathi farmers , instead doing metropolitan politics . Maharashtra steals the taxes of Mumbai and didn't invested it back . Mumbai is special economy region , but not self administered or full state like Shanghai , Newyork , Tokyo, etc . I asked this question to former IAS officer Jagannath murty , he told Mumbai or BMC , has it own tax collecting system , etc . But further decentralisation of special region , is needed as Mumbai need a special administrative region , not just special economy region by Central government . He too told me output and input of taxes , etc are rigid in Mumbai , compare to that of Shanghai , Newyork , Tokyo . He told me that Mumbai give more taxes to Maharashtra and get lesser taxes back , inshort Mumbai is trapped in politics .
@@AnilKumar-wj2tz try to learn Tamil. Then you'll understand the trouble to learn a new language of completely different language family.
If you talk about a link language then it's already there as English. And it's a second official language & also a global language.
As well a decision making power , in Mumbai is limited , as being apart of state , not itself a state or union territory ! . So Mumbai can't take quick long term action .
I am from Bihar and never knew that Bihari languages has own script like Kaithi and Maithili. Thank you Mohak for sharing such types of information's. :)
@Bhaskar ojha
See the old literature in Bhojpuri and maithali sir ,you will find the grammer rule there
They are more than 1000 years older than hindi
@Bhaskar ojha read Ramayan , our language is spoken from That time 🔥
I knew about kaithi script.This language is used in courts even now
@@kashutosh9132 then why hindi is your official language. Make maithili and bhojpuri your official language and preserve your language and culture. Don't kill your identity.
Bro Kaithi was used as the primary script for Hindi in the beginning.
I remeber when two Bengalis used to talk bengali in school it showed that how they respected their language but when people spoke in bhojpuri it is said as vulgar why , even though I am a maithili speaker but this is partiality , both are languages and one is considered sweet while other is considered vulgar , but this is also our fault we solely don't know to respect mother tongue
Are you bihari army?
We proud to be bengali and bangla language is our emotion
@@sudipganguly8405 cringe
@@thelivingdead1728 Speedwagon is cringe.
Bhojpuri isn't considered vulgar.
I am proud of being a Maithil. I can fluently speak Maithili and also read and write in the Tirhuta script. I will never let my language die. The generations after me will also learn Maithli. Jai Mithila!
Love from a Tamilian.
Never let your mother(mother tongue) down.
Valga Tamil(Long Live Tamil)❤
Valga Mithila❤
Jai Mithila Jai Anga 🚩
Same bro, I am also from Mithila and a proud maithili speaker
In my district (Madhubani) almost everyone speaks in Maithili, except in school(beacuse Maithili is banned there😔)
But, I don't know Maithili script, but I will learn that in future
Jai Mithila
Jai Maithili 🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@Kinshuk.Rai_Saheb.Bihar_wale Beta tu fir aa gya yahaan pe bhi
🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
Mere teacher ne 9th me maithili likhna sikhaya, usse pahle hme pta hi nhi tha maithili ki alg lipi h 🥺
I'm from Bihar and I still remember that I was slapped by my teacher in school because I talked in my mother tongue Bhojpuri. They create inferiority complex for our languages right from our elementary education in the school. Speaking different language at home and taking education in totally different language is really very difficult. Hope our script Kaithi and language revives. We love Bhojpuri, Maithali and Maghi languages. Thank you for bringing this here :-)
Same happened with me. I proudly say my mother tongue is Bhojpuri.
Jai Bhojpuri
Jai Bihar🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Same here bro😔😔
Same conditions with Haryanvis vro
Wow. What a crappy mentality. I remember singing Bhojpuri bhajans with my grandma when we used to visit jagratas. And I am born to Malayalees living in the north. Always loved them.
Hamar sath bhi ihe bhail rhe jb school me baat kaini taa ...😂
Funfact: Maithili was considered as a prestigious language in medieval or early modern Bengali society, a Bengali person who speaks Maithili, was considered a refined person of culture, a large number of Bengali Brahmin's are of Maithili extract. Vidyapati, Rabindranath Tagore all composed in Maithili language. But see how the tables have turned, time and fate played a cruel joke on Bihar. And the biggest thing is rural Biharis today would rather migrate to Kolkata than Patna.
Well Tagore did not compose all songs in Maithili but those songs which were there in Bhanusingh (Tagore's pen name) er Podaboli which had songs like sajani sajani Radhikalo, sundari radha aoe bani etc
Maithili had a strong influence on Bengali, Odia and Assamese literature, now look what Bihar government has done to it.
Mithila used to be a Kingdom in ancient days right?
@@vetiarvind yes
@@vetiarvind But the world's first republic is also in Mithila in Vaishali
Very true. We have lost our glory of Magadha (Bihar) because of Hindi language. Hindi is just a replica of urdu language. The day Urdu / Hindi came to Bihar. We all Biharis lost our identity.
Therefore, I request all my Bihari brothers to come forward and demand for our ancient Prakrit Magadhi/ Pali language to make a regional language of Bihar and give us a regional identity.
Thus we Biharis will gain back our lost glory of Magadha....
nah language cannot cause a fall of a glorious empire. And hindi is not an replica of urdu. All modern day indo aryan languages are descendant of sanskrit and hindi is if not, one of the closest to sanskrit.
Bihar lost its glory even before hindi, magadhi, bhojpuri was a thing.
@@AudioMixedVideoAMVHow can you say that Hindi is similar to Sanskrit, Hindi is an artificial language just to remove Urdu / farsi imposition. Hindi is more similar to urdu rather than sanskrit. Bihar was the first state to adopt Hindi as official language..
Dont blame Hindi if Bihar lost its glory , this is because of Bihari people themselves , the rampant corruption and the lack of education and civility in many people across the state resulted in this , but we can still improve
Jai Bharat
Jai Bihar
Kannadigas (locals of Karnataka) also face lot of challenges. If we try to be protective about our language.....migrants , IT folks, from other states think we are too emotional......
added to this is the medium of education being English......
Yea very true
No, Kannadigas may be facing a lot of challenges. But even Kannadigas impose their language on others. In Karnataka, Kannadigas are not the only natives. In the coastal regions and in Coorg, Tulu and Kodava Takk are spoken respectively. They accept Kannada as the language of the state since they are comfortable with it. But they have their own regional identity. And that has to be respected in every state not just in the country.
Ok but don't impose kannada on tulus konkanis etc
Man, a literate person should learn language.
*We Biharis are responsible for our language distruction , personally as a bihari I don't care what other thinks about my bhojpuri or angika but i feel shame using it publically not because it is defamed by others but by us , like our so called bihari directors who makes obscene and utter nonsense movies and songs showing shamelessly only lust , sexualized scenes and nudity in them . It is the key reason why i feel ashamed and unfortunate. Whereas bhojpuri is such a sweet language*
*¯\_༼ ಥ ‿ ಥ ༽_/¯*
Agree
(╥╯﹏╰╥)
Yes it's a true fact
I am from Punjab, I can see a tamil movie or song with family but not bihari coz of extra sexualization
Because of it films which is the best way to promote a thing is not being utilised to promote a positive image but a dirty one
Let's hope for a bright future of bihar and India 🙏🙏
even the anchors like ravish kumar took his time from prime time show once to refer this issue and image of language bhojpuri, how these media, songs, films ruining it.
Obscene films are available in ever languages. You please start speaking publicly in your mothertongue. Don't worry about anything else. Speak proudly. Not for yourself. But for preserving India's Rich Cultural Diversity. Please.
I'm from Nalanda and i know nothing about magahi ....everyone in my village use hindi or urdu...i feel so bad about myself that i could not learn my ancient language...😭😭😭...I'm so ashamed of myself...
😥😭😭
अभी देर नहीं हुई है. आप अभी भी सीख सकते हो.
@@swatikumari765 you're so right....jai bihar
Me too but atleast we are aware and not ashamed of our language like our elders are! we must preserve our culture brother.. the change will start from us and we can also make others aware.❤️
@@abdullahhassan9544 जय भारत
Being a Bihari myself, I literally fell into tears at 1:36. Country before state is a perfect description of us. That's so true and that's why despite facing racism to such an extent that the term Bihari itself is used against us in a derogatory manner, we still don't care and respect and love every Indian equally ❤️🇮🇳. India before any state ! Jai Hind !
this is the fault of Bihari politicians who enjoyed lawlessness and created the bad reputation of Bihar and Biharis
@@Raj_Das Mithila region iske liye responsible hai Bhojpur Magadh aur baki regions devlop ho Gaye hai mithila abhi bhi undevlop hai Mithila is burden on Bihar
Pata nahi tumlog ko kaha racism hota hai,Par Bhojpuri ko nahi hota.
Maithili Bhagao Champaran Bachaao Maithili Bhagao Bhojpur Magadh Anga Bachaao Jai Champaran🚩Jai Bhojpur🚩Jai Anga🚩Jai Magadh🚩💪
Country before anything else is the sentiment of every Indian, not just Biharis, the problem is considering Hindi and Hindi alone as the country, that is where the problem begins
Hmmm that's why south India States opposes hindi as national language..
Believe unity in Diversity !!
Hindi is not national of india
I mean thats a flawed argument, cause if Hindi makes people lose their language doesnt English do the same , so why do not say no to English
If after your respected mother tongue and English , I would sincerely advise you to learn hindi , not imposing but just advicing because in India sometimes it becomes increasingly difficult to socialise without knowing hindi
Sincerely respect all our Dravidian Brothers down south
Bihar need more singers like sharda sinha who created a great image of bihari language. We bihari must discard vulgar songs being made by wicked youngsters. We should recognize more folk singers like sharda sinha.
Some recent voices in government circles and action by Bihar government is giving hope towards this
No hate but I don't think you have any right to control the music tastes of others one single bit. Teach them to appreciate their language and culture, not destroy their preferences like this
sharda sinha and maithili both are from mithila.
Udit narayan jha, Sharda ji , maithili thakur , Ram babu jha , kunj bihari , punam mishra they r some well known folk singer among bihari even they perform internationally especially devotional song
Kuch singers Hai bhai jo pehle shaandar folk singers the jaise pawan singh pr waqt ke hisaab se wo bhi badal gye ,aur vishnu ojha ji he is our gem of Bhojpuri folk singing and bharat sharma too ❤️
Being a Bihari I never felt ashamed of using my language in public. I and my brother both work in Ministry of Railway and there too we use bhojpuri with each other. It's our root we just can't leave it.
Regards bhaiyya
Why people from Bihar work in railways? I mean max I don't understand that thing
@@aninditasen7738 It's not like they always or only work with Railways. And also not only at group D posts. As joined CSS ( Central secretariat services) as Assistant Section officer in Ministry of Home Affairs. Then later deputed to Ministry of Railways as Section officer. And and brother too is a group B of officer. Now are you able to understand that we don't always work with Railways.😊
@@aninditasen7738 Yes, some of us who are weak at English language opt for Railways group D aur ALP exams as these are the only exams except Defence jobs which don't have English as a subject.
I was not differentiating between groups bt the jobs in railways either of official or group d doesn't matter bt here in assam we have seen people from Bihar are there in maximum in railways. One thing I know nd have noticed that since northeast zone has less no. Of applicants nd a little less IQ than the people from up Bihar, they opt to give exm from this zone for better rate of success
The South Indians, unlike Marathis, Gujarathis and Punjabis, didnot allow Hindi to overwhelm their languages.All the South Indian states have vibrant film industries.There is a saying about Tamils, "You can take a Tamil out of Tamil Nadu but you can never take the Tamil out of him. The Tamil in him dies only when he dies". There are third and fourth generation Tamils in Malaysia, Singapore and Lanka who are bilingual /trilingual but speak only Tamil at home. If you are ready to discard your mother tongue and embrace Hindi, it is only a matter of time before it becomes your child's and grandchild's mother tongue. Biharis, Punjabis, Marathis and Gujarathis are themselves to blamed for facilitating the slow but sure death of their own languages. The Hindi zealots have already included these areas as part of the Greater Hindi Belt.
I agree as a gujarati...Northies(hindi speakers) keep migrating in gujarat and don't learn gujarati,If you to to any banks,shops in SURAT city for eg, They will only talk to you in hindi and won't make any effort to learn gujarati because people have accepted it...
SURAT does not even feel like gujarat,All the central offices and road signs have now Hindi signboards as compared to gujarati we had 20 years ago...Ofcourse other cities like ahmedabad are also going there.
Bro Tamil is dying in Singapore.. During 1900s nearly 10-12% people spoke Tamil, now only 2.5% people speak Tamil.
@@DarkPhychic true many egg and fish hawkers are also migrating from bihar and up and are increasing meat consumption
I am a Bihari and never knew that we had a language with separate script. I used to think them as local dialects..
Thank you so much.
LOL! What?
I can read mithilakshar
Bcs you lost your language bcs of Hindi and Urdu. That's why we don't want Urdu or Hindi in Bengal.
Hindi is just a shortened version of "Hindustani" which is a blend of Urdu, Persian etc. That was a language of the Mughals. None of the original languages of the states in India is the current textbook type "Hindi".
Hi, this is muralidharan from tamilnadu, your contents are excellent. But, in recent videos there is no subtitles. I just used to share every video in my class group. So, it is not plea of single man. Thanks for giving excellent content again.
Noticed that too brother, hope he updates the subtitles so our people from every corner can see his videos 🙏🇮🇳
He usually adds them in a day or two
His previous video has been updated with english subtitles .
Yeah
Do u know hindi😳
@@umesh3579 impossible
They never leave their mother tongue and their culture
Yes, infact in my state Arunachal Pradesh, young generation have lost their indigenous dialect and often speak in hindi ( that also broken🙄) with friends!
@@madhavireddy1792 yeah you're exactly right!!
@sanyati khatri yes brother, we don't have any problem with hindi or any other language in our state, the main problem is our state government not taking necessary actions to save the culture and language, as our state has the lowest population density and coz of it our native language is almost in path of extinction!!
@@madhavireddy1792 kyu arunachal ki mother tung english h agar unhe hindi se problem h v mother tongue language se pyar h to phir esme english kha se aayi.
Even I learnt Hindi to connect with more people in my college 👁️👄👁️
@Rahul Chaudhary no!!! We don't have native language in acadmic subjects!
This is why we south Indians are against Hindi. Not bcoz we hate it bcoz we are afraid that imposing Hindi, we will lose our regional language.
#❤️Kannada #❤️Hindi
And Big Love n Respect to all the other regional Languages too, from Karnataka
Jai Hind! 🙏🏽🇮🇳
@parth gupta lol no one is jealous of ur hindi,ur mother tongue is only 200 yrs old but kannada has a history of 2500 years lmfaooo
We punjabis also fear the same just think about us we are so much close to hindi belt than tamil nadu
we speak Bangla in Bengal. and will always do so. My Hindi is also very good so I am covered
@@harmansidhu7359 u should be feared of urdu.
@@harmansidhu7359Punjab is totally surrounded by hindi-urdu speaking states
Bhojpuri sounds thousands times sweeter than Hindi spoken in Delhi and western UP.
@@Menthusiasm you need to enhance your knowledge go and learn first 🙏
@@Menthusiasm it is a political dialect. If I will write anything in Bhojpuri you will not get even single word wanna play to prove it ?
@@BHOJPURIYA_Maati Dude Bhojpuri can be understood by Maharashtrian but I bet You can't even get the bits of Marathi. That's the difference between a dialect and a Language. Bhojpuri is a dialect while Marathi is a Language.
@@kislay1418 Dude the Bhojpuri you understand is the outcome of hindi imposition from last 75 year's if you'r Marathi is removed from 8th schedule na then after 75 year's you guys will also speak mix language. Read Bhojpuri novels of 1800 in our lipi kaithi you will get that it is totally different from Hindi also if you read the history indo Aryan languages you will find Bhojpuri bin different branch 🙏 so please read and Bhojpuri is very old language than hindi it is also proved 🙏 jai hind the power of india is unity in diversity so please do not impose anything to anyone
@Saurabh Chaubey If your language is so rich & well preserved then why hasn't it been given the distinct status?
Marathi is a language dude not a dialect like Bhojpuri and if you say that old Bhojpuri was dichotomous than it's spoken today then well I'd say even old Awadhi is not intelligible but yet Awadhi is a part of Hindi.
Both Awadhi and Bhojpuri could be well understood even by south indian people who have the knowledge of Hindi but the reverse can't.
BTW I ain't a Marathi, though I speak it because I've been brought up here in Mumbai but my mother tongue is Maithili.
People of India makes fun of Bihari accent. This has created an inferiority complex among Biharis who try their best to speak "shuddha" hindi instead of their own language. Once I was talking to my mom in magahi language. The women beside me (A bihari) looked at me as if I am some illiterate. This needs to change. No one makes fun of Bengali, Punjabi, Haryanvi for speaking their language but we Biharis have to face constant discrimination.
Because Bengalis shed blood for their language in Assam as well as East Bengal. Biharis are still light years behind in the language pride game.
@@theinstayatri9463 Agreed. Tamilians shed blood and some lost their lives too to prevent Hindi imposition.
Bihar's cinema has a great role in making bihar's culture, language etc inferior and us to feel embarrassed...
Bengalis get mocked a lot too, but we've learnt to laugh it off. Also we take pride in our culture so that helps. But what you're talking about is understandable. Really unfair.
Many punjbais also dont speak Punjabi in delhi because of its same reasons
Hope you guys understood how important native language is !! Love from Tamil nadu :)
Yes, it is important. But knowing more languages is always better 😁
@@daredevil30000 its up to you :)
@@user-wo6le8im7s Even 'Amma' was a polygot. She knew Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam, English and Hindi.
@@daredevil30000 ok . what for that ?
@@user-wo6le8im7s Same happening with bengal...Hindi destroying every local language and culture in the name of unity 😢
Maithili and Bengali are parallel languages and Hindi was introduced as a collection of non dialects languages in order to promote nationalism
It was deadly.
Maithili will promote strong bond between Bihar and Bengal.
It was a bit British policy to dethrone Bengal of its peak of nationalism mwhich then comrised of parts of Bihar,Orissa,Bangladesh and total of Assam,Tripura and Jharkhand
तुम सही में कितने मूर्ख हो ना!
मतलब हिंदी से भारत की क्षेत्रिय भाषाओं पर खतरा है परंतु तुम्हारे अंग्रेज़ी में भौंकने से सब ठीक रहेगा।
तुम जैसे लोग गुलामी के नशे में चूर हो कर अपनी ही भाषाओं और संस्कृति को चोट पहुंचाते हो।
@@user-gn7wb7ht1b Don't be so rude
I don't know to write Hindi
I know Bengali,English and Maithili
I am from Bengal. To avoid the linguistic problems, I use English
Even I am interested in writing bengali articles specifically poems in Sukhtara, Ananda Patrika, Anandamela also.
And most interestingly I am only 16 yrs now, hope to promote Bengali to a international stage
Once again, You shouldn't have used such harsh languages.
@@amrit6858 मुझे किसी भी भारतिय भाषा से कोई आपत्ति नहीं पर लोगों के जबरदस्ती अंग्रेज़ी बोलने से है।
@@user-gn7wb7ht1b কোন ভাষা ব্যবহার করা উচিৎ ছিলো আমার?
বাংলা! যেটা বললে 10 percent ও বুঝতে পারবে না? তার চেয়ে এক্ষেত্রে ইংলিশ ব্যবহার করাটাই ভালো ভেবেছিলাম আমি ।
In the Caribbean bhojpuri is still cherished even though 100+ years separated from India! My surname is actually bhojpuri. 🇹🇹
Jai Bhojpuri
Jay bhojpuri ❤️
Sach kahat hawa ka ho???
Agar e baat baa toh chala humaara bhojpuri ke kauno khatra nahi hai😇😇😇🙏🏿🙏🏿
Jai hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🏿🙏🏿
Pumpkin is a bhojpuri surname ?
I believe all Indian languages are precious and need to be cherished.
no
@@Manish_Kumar_Singh No u
U know its kinda impossible
@@Manish_Kumar_Singh Ok Hindi ka bache
But some people need only one language.....
But why...?
As a South Indian I am proud that I have my mother tongue and it's alive. Mother tongue is not jus a language. It's a culture and affection towards your community. Feeling sad for Bihar people
I dont understand why everyone wants to resist the change..Shouldnt we try to adapt and evolve with time. Culture is dynamic in nature , it keeps on changing so i dont understand why ppl are so keen on preserving it. And how is it something to be proud of ? you only speak it because people around you do , its not like you are living in another country and still speaking your native tongue.
@@lakshyagoel1280 u can demand for ram temple in north,as it is a very important temple mentioned and plays major role in culture
If we do the same thing for our language it becomes wrong
@@lakshyagoel1280 we can adopt change but we cannot adopt new mother. We have only one mother
@@lakshyagoel1280 bro then why don't you learn Tamil and Telugu
@@lakshyagoel1280 mother tongue is not only language , it's a represent of your unique culture , it's political representation , it's a identify , it's binding force of various segment of people , more over research says people speak English views world different from people speak Spanish , it's differs from viewing world , also south indians didn't resist to evolve , we adapt English as common communication for other states people and other countries , also it gives jobs , social superiority etc..
That’s why we don’t speak Hindi in our Telugu states as Telugu is our mother tongue and nothing can replace mother.
What fool you are, you guys speak English which is a foreign language but no hindi or Sanskrit. You guys are disgrace to sanatan dharma
@@shubhangagarwal925 our language is sanskrit not hindi
@@shubhangagarwal925 Muh Tanatana Drum
Are you a fool..? Telangana people speak Hindi.. in fact, urdu is an official language of Hyderabad... So please stop saying all telugu people...
@@nirup2844 Telangana people speak Hindi?
It was a big blunder to replace Maithili and Mithilakshar by Hindi and Devnagari . It ruined the regional Identity of a State
The demand for MITHILA RAJYA is purely justified.
I had a classmate in school who called people "Bihari" when she wanted to insult them. Basically she used "Ae Bihari" as a slang. My younger siblings don't want to tell their friends that they speak in Bhojpuri at home , feeling they might be judged. This what happens when we fail to realise the importance of our languages. It's a sad state of affairs.
Importance of our languages and state
Unfortunate reality for us
😞😞
So many people still do that! And that is sad.
@@deepdoshi2734 are you gujrati??
@@singh16711 Yes
As a telugu we were taught that forgetting mothertounge is As same As forgetting mother
But I have heard from some Telugu speakers that we should encourage Hindi also and that Hindi should be made compulsory in other states. Is that the general feeling among Telugu people or yours?
@@manifest2203 yeah you are some what correct..... Some people feel like ...... If you observe 2 educated Telugu guys met they will speak in english like a prestige symbol and in south telugu people some what less priority for language...... But if i know other person knows telugu.. Even he speak in English i speak in telugu only..... As a part of schooling muje hindi atahe north me bath karunga.... English jeene keliye seekhe.... If you impose hindi also much don't feel imposition..... As a telugu sahitya abhimani.. I am feeling shame..... Like me lot of there.... We don't hate other language... But we oppose imposition...... In telugu only we have... Padya,astavadhanam,harikatha,burrakatha, we enjoy sweetness of the language
@@manifest2203 no , i guess nd it depends from person to person . but telugu ppl dont have a big problem with adding hindi in school syllabus . and i think except some ppl from hyderabad , i dont think telugu ppl would ever put hindi above telugu
@@manifest2203 it's just very very few who think that. And also Hyderabad and other area speak Urdu so they don't know difference but in South India we strongly believe there is no necessity to actually learn Hindi. As we are not going to Bihar Jharkand or Uttar Pradesh for job . If someone is going then they can learn.
@Adhishree Singh official language of Tamil Nadu is Tamil, Kerala is Malayalam but for Bihar and Jharkand it is Hindi. So why did they choose Hindi over their langauge? As the official language of the state?
I am Bihari and I speak Surjapuri which is a reagional language of Bihari. This language is mainly spoken in Katihar Kinsanjung part of Bihar. This language is also spoken in West Bengal and Nepal. I fell proud to tell world about my language.
Plz recommend any folk songs, poetry something about Surajpuri, I didn't know about this language so I would like to know how it sounds
@@kashutosh9132 kaay aapan kaay praya movie surjapuri dekho
@@ramdayalism
Ok thanks
@@kashutosh9132 It's dialect of Maithili
@@adarshkumar1081 it's more bangla than maithil
I am from Bihar and today I was so confused which is spoken in my mom's birthplace(Bihar) and I asked her more than 100 times which language is spoken by my grandmother she said hindi but then I asked we also speak hindi but this is very different from that language then I search on Google it's also said hindi is official language but I just can't belive the fact that my grandmother defiantly not speak hindi that's a whole different language. Then I confused between bhojpuri devnagri and thethi language now I have understood that in my grandparents house they speak bhojpuri and that's the language I heared whenever I visited them.
A big thanks to you, u cleared my all doubts 😊
Yes brother. Your mother tongue is Bhojpuri and not Hindi.I too have Bhojpuri.We all have to save Bhojpuri together.Jai bhojpuri.
Save your roots and cultures.
You lost your identity. And adopted someone's culture. Don't you realise still.. you are fool. Nothing else
So sad
Jai magahi
Blessed that I had a geography teacher and she was our incharge too and she always said talk to me in bhojpuri I'll reply in bhojpuri, English and Hindi ... She said not to feel inferior while speaking our language.
Jai Bhojpuri
I'm from Patna, Bihar and Bhojpuri is the worst language ever made!! Whenever someone talks to me in bhojpuri, it seems as if he's abusing me
(Don't get offended, just my opinion)
I from kolkata bihari
@@user-ik8fh8wp9h youre a nice fisherman
@@umapolymer6341 That doesn't even make sense lol
There is a quote which says " If you want to destroy a culture, destroy the language first"
English bhi wohi kar rha hai
English has already started destruction of Indian culture and language
@@mcdon1395 use English to some extent so that it won't affect mother tongue
@@logeswaran1823 bro I never use English while speaking in real life. But English has already destroyed many words of our native languages. We already speak hinglish (hindi + English) even in hindi we use Urdu lol. Same with other languages
@@mmmm9083 it is better to use English with regional language ,it is not good to use English , Hindi and regional languages at same time.
Not only Hindi but Hindi+Urdu mix is destroying our regional languages.
True that
I speak Garhwali. I think Hindi is a link between Indo-Aryans for Communication, & we need a common language but at the same time regional language deserve official status.
@Atheist You don't want official status for regional language?
Or maybe..
You don't consider Hindi to be a link language among Indo-Aryan States?
I do think so 😩
Very true
10:50 goosebumps❤...emotional❤
aha maithil chhiye
I belong to Mithila region of Bihar. I live with my family in Delhi. But we speak Maithili in house. Recently I have learnt Mithilakshar script also.
Respect Brother . 🙏
🙏🙏🙏
You are maithili, I suggest you to read Bhanusimhas padabali
আমি মালদার মৈথিলী ব্রাহ্মণ
Good 👍👍
India is a union of many cultures each unique in their own way.
The sooner the people realize this and appreciate the beauty of diversity that comes with it,the better.
India is a continent struggling as a country
Define 'realisation' and 'appreciation' of beauty of diversity in terms of actions/deeds. Just for the sake of riposte and also for the records.
@@vishalmanchala7898 so true
@@vishalmanchala7898 yeah its like europe which is not different land from asia but considered a different continent because of cultural and language differernces . But if india is divided into many countries today it will be more like africa than europe.
unity in diversity is a joke in india😂😂😂
Maharashtra government last year passed bill and made marathi as compulsory language from std 1st to 10th in all boards of Maharashtra (such as CBSE, ICSE, IB, etc), violation of act will fine upto ₹ 1lakh to schools(fine may increase as suggested by opposition leader). And the bill also mentions there must be not restrictions directly or indirectly by schools on student's for speaking marathi. Other states must also pass this bill in their States.
@Spell Check they will choose hindi because it's easy to learn and score than marathi and people don't know that India has no national language everywhere fake statement is make that hindi is national language. Student must have choice to pick language whichever they want but that must third language. Maharashtra had highest number of immigration and most of then are from North India so they will definitely choose hindi and that's how marathi will decline, we have hindi compulsory language till 10th why ?
@Spell Check if you don"t want to learn marathi ,then don't come to MH. the state language should be the first priority . i am also a non-maharastrian , but i felt ashamed when my marathi friends got bullied because they talked in marathi with each other . i think mh gov should remove hindi and make marathi compulsary for all students . we hindi speakers come and then expect them to talk with us in hindi . i hv decided ,no matter what happens , i will treat marathi as my mother tongue ,because this land has given me everything .
@Spell Check langauge is something that you shallow and narrow minded ppl will never understand .
@Spell Check u cant allow free-market when it comes to bhashas
@Spell Check lang isnt just for communication but it is also abt identity if maharastra doesnt promote marathi who else will
in my country, there's a famous phrase people used to say (u can see this mostly in our movies) "udal mannukku uyir thamilukku"
which literally means "my body to the land and my soul to my language" and I really love the fact how we people see our language as nearly equal to our soul not just as our pride!
in my country ???
Which country ?
@@flyingdragon6275 Tamilnadu
@@Surendhar-uz1ch Tamil nadu is a state, Those who call it a country are Rice Bag converts or infiltrators or ltte extremists
@@flyingdragon6275 I just reply to your question. I'm always indian first but In Tamil language "Nadu" means Country or place (more likely country). Tamilnadu means country for Tamils or land of Tamils . 🇮🇳💛 Tamilnadu is indian state forever
@@Surendhar-uz1ch Great to hear that, And I am from Karnataka.
Karnataka is derived from word Karunadu, which can mean Land of Black Soil in Kannada. (Karu-Black, Nadu-Region)
To all the people who feel ashamed to speak their mother tongue or dialect just because others look at you the wrong way don't be ashamed. Look at south Indians in 1940s to 1980s malayalis and Tamils they were teased, our grandparents and parents had many stories of how the North Indian City people made fun of them and discriminated them for culture and language and accent. But they never changed for them they stood their ground proudly. Appropriating yourself for other culture will eventually destroys your culture.
@yitzhak shekkelsteingoldmanberg ummm ok
@yitzhak shekkelsteingoldmanberg ummm..what?
@@samuraijosh1595 He is saying not only North make fun but whole world makes fun of Tamilian English
@@anamay5930 lol, Tamilan accent isn't even what represents India on a global scale. Tamilan accent isn't what comes to mind when foreigners think of "Indian accent" lmao. What makes you think Tamil accent is even decently popular globally in the first place? Both of your are bullshiting. It's mostly the North Indian tech support accent that get's made fun of.
@yitzhak shekkelsteingoldmanberg What are you talking about? Tamilians have worse english accent than rest of the country?
One of my professor once said " The day you become a fan of a politician the day you failed to become as a citizen...
Politicians and rigid casteism system ruined Bihar completely
Ek hi cheez kitne videos me copy karoge. Aur professor ka name keya hey. 😅
@@srijansarkar9202 jab tak log Apne citizen right ko samjhe
@@srijansarkar9202 Andhbhakti chorr ... citizen bana Kar 😂🤗
@SmartAss Sooo... Minority (Shantidoot) of indians fail at being a citizen...As they acknowledge Pappu Gandhi as their Aaka..😂😂🤪
Acc. to me it's not hindi which killing their mother language but the people themselves !
I am a bihari who lives in delhi from his birth , and can speak & understand 'magahi' ( my mother tounge ) . thanks to my mom and dad .
Exactly , the responsibility of protecting one's own language remains with the person. We need a common language to connect with people who don't speak our native language. Its basic common sense.
और अंग्रेजी का चयन क्यों करे ? अगर कोई भाषा होगी जो देश को जोड़ेगी तो वह देश की ही कोई भाषा होनी चाहिए।
Is there any primary education in magahi? No.. This is the reason hindi is killing bihari languages
That's why we bengali fight against hindi... this wrong purpose that hindi is not our national language...
हिंदी इंडिया में सबसे जड़ा बोले जाने वाली भाषा है
I'm Bihari living in Berlin, and here in Germany, many people know Nalanda University, Gaya, and other famous places from Bihar. We had Great History and will have the greatest future. A proud Indian and a proud Bihari. Keep up the hard work and mehnat ek din rang pakka lai orr bihar k aapan glory fir se miili! Jai Hind!
Jai Hind bhai, vapas aayenge vo din mein pure visvas ke saath kahta huun 🙏🇮🇳
Hopefully
Jai bihar jai maithili
@@gamingsisters1200 meri angika and maghai hain but meri mother tongue Hindi hain
Respect
I am a Bihari, presently living in delhi. Honestly saying, I don't feel any connection with my regional language😕(magadhi). Whenever I see any person who belongs to diff. state talking in their native language, I kinda feel jealous coz I can't speak even a single line correctly!!!!! But, I will master it one day🥺
I'm also a magadhi, I can understand the language but can only speak 10-15% of it. Although my grandparents spoke it well, all of whom are dead now.
I am bihari i am lucky because i know my regional language.
Same here , I am maghdi person but I barely speak magadhi because I don't know it
I talk in Magahi even in metro when I’m with a fellow Magadhi or even on phone. But when I visit my village everyone who lives in Patna or any small city speak only in shudh Hindi. Even our elders don’t want us to speak in Magahi in front of kids. It’s really bizarre tbh.
@@ms.550 same case for all migrant bihari families
I remember being rediculed for speaking Haryanvi in school & teacher slapping me for being rude while I was new to Delhi & struggling to speak standardised hindi (haryanvi has almost 30% words that aren't there in hindi and also Syntax of sentence is different too)
Delhi ke native bhi to haryanvi bolte h
Haryanvi is more close to Punajbi than hindi
Delhi native language is Literally haryanvi
Even marathi was earlier not written in devnagri!
It was written in modi script!!
Don't Impose hindi in Maharashtra too!
It's good that South Indians are always conservative about their language and culture!
Every region should stand up for their language and culture .
Please, don't loose your identity. Save your culture, traditions and culture.❤️
Oh bhai pahle khud sudhro fir dusro ko gyan do khud English me likh rhe ho or aye bada culture save karne
@@naitikkumar2734 my mother tongue is telugu, If I write in telugu do you understand?
@@kashettyavp no
@@naitikkumar2734 yup, so as a medium of communication where in india after every 100 kms language or Dailet is changed, I had used English so everyone can understand for the northeast who speaks Assamese, for northwest who speaks Gujarati, marati, marwari etc or a up guy with Braj Bhasha, Awadhi, and Bhojpuri and bihari people who speak Bhojpuri, Maithili, Santhali. Or who protected there language since 1000 years Telugu, tamil, kannada, malyali guy.
@@naitikkumar2734 He wrote in english so that everyone can understand. Do u think all indians speak hindi? Hindi already killed so many languages in UP, bihar etc.. That's why nowadays so many other state ppl are opposing hindi. English we use only when we need to communicate with other language ppl, in home we speak our mother tongue only, unlike you ppl, who worship hindi more than your mother tongue and who allow hindi to kill ur language.
So called "Hindi Belt" doesn't speak that much of Hindi. Even Madhya Pradesh has it's languages like Nimadi, Bagheli, Malvi. Similarly it can be seen in Uttar Pradesh too it has Bundelkhandi, Avadhi, Bhojpuri and even Nepali. But this makes India as a concept look like much more of a Frankenstein then something on globe. This nation is really walking on a thin but strong string.
@Ninad Kulkarni
Then why not the Persian language with the Devanagari Script??? I mean, the entire Northern India ( Indo-Aryan Belt ) is a heavily Persianized region.
@@hunkwasbisyan007 No it is not. Persia(Iran) and India have always influenced eachother but can't be merged together. What ever one may say all these languages might be different but we as indians have common grounds to communicate that's our culture.
@@hunkwasbisyan007 I guess you don't know anything about Persia (Iran) then
Whoa I actually didn't know that. Dude thanks for telling
I am from Rajasthan here most people speak marwadi and where I live they speak shekhawati dialect, my parents speak these languages but I don't. They never teach me these languages, they always used to talk to me in hindi, whenever I try to speak in marwari it looks like I am speaking like a robot.
Actually Hindi is damaging whole north indian languages. Hindi/Urdu was not universal like nowadays. It was just language around Delhi(west up, east haryana, south uttarakhand). Rajasthan had Marwari, Malwi, Bhili, up had Awadhi, Bundeli, Braj Bhasha, etc, Bihar had Maithili, Bhojpuri. Mumbai had Konkani. Chhattisgarh had Chhattisgarhi and Gondi. Uttarakhand-hp had numerous languages. Rawalpindi-Islamabad had Punjabi. Karachi had Sindhi. But nowadays most of these regions has become Hindi/Urdu. Barely some regions like outter north india(Maharashtra, Goa, Gujarat, Punjab, Kashmir, West Bengal, Odisha) and undeveloped rural places maintain their authentic languages.
Very true ... Just a correction- Malwi is spoken in Malwa region in MP. I speak Malwi that's why.
@@heya-fq2nb in Rajasthan also malvi is spoken jhalawar pratapgarh and chittorgarh districts
I am a bihari but whenever i look my nearby bihari families they speaks in hindi . even my childhood friend, with whom I used to talk in bhojpuri but now she has changed . and now she speaks in hindi because they considered that the bhojpuri languages is chip to speak. Not only this my all relatives speaks hindi .
I feel very very bad about this such behavior. My mother told me too to speak hindi but I said no... Because looking others I changed my mind and decided to speak always bhojpuri still end of my life....
I'm requesting my bihari friends to never forgot you language and keep spreading you language among your next generation 😟😟😟
Great ✌️
Many people from purvanchal and west bihar are trying to make bhojpuri offcial Language of india
Imagine your netas defaming your mother tongue so badly that you fear to even speak in it 😶
True! One should be ashamed of that.
The loss of local languages can be seen through generations very well. My parents were taught local language(maghi) in their childhood and they speak in maghi with others. I wasn't taught maghi but learnt to understand it and to some extent speak it by seeing my grandparents. My younger brother dosen't understand maghi very well. He resorts to hindi while speaking with grandparents. If this trend continues in 1 or 2 generations we will lose our languages.
See this is the problem, our older generation failed to teach us our native languages. And people blame everything on politics it's hideous and ridiculous. Your comment is very true to many other experiences.
This problem can be seen all over India even in our families.
exactly same situation in my house with avadhi. Only grand parents speak hence we do understand but cant speak that fluently. parents speak either hindi or english with us.
First regional language should be given priority then other languages for communation and help.
😩😭
We want separate state "Mithilanchal" to protect our Heritage and culture...
Mithila rajya chahie and Maithili ko official langauge bnana chahiye...no hindi in Mithila rajya only Maithli will work. Chaii ki nahi bhai?
@@user-re9ml7je3y ha bhai
Imagine being a state of highest number of immigrants (which is another topic to discuss) and then learning Hindi as compulsory language till 10th...
Yes we are Maharashtrian's
@Tanmay Kand yes bro. We must support them first bjp and congress must be second option first option must be always regional parties.
Hindi should be learned as a common language to converse with Indians from other parts of the country...but never at the cost of a mother tongue. Arre bhai, learning three languages in no big deal for us.
@@shreyasadhikari1474 LOOK , Lets have some reality check, In south a significant population in urban areas know english very well. English is the link language in the south for students and other professions to communicate with other states, As each state has different language. We learn a language based on its USE/Value it provides for business etc.
If you see Though South has different languages it is far developed, less population,high literacy compared to North states. ITs important to know that India is a union of Linguistic states. Making Hindi National language would be an imposition of Lang on other non hindi speaking states and such decisions/legislation will be nullified by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. I have never heard people in the south say they want either tamil/telugu/Malayalam/Kannada to be National lang. So here problem is not language it is *QUALITY EDUCATION*.
@@shreyasadhikari1474 no english as link bhasha is fyn
@@shreyasadhikari1474 learning hindi as common bhasha itself has killed many uttar-bharatiyo bhashas , english itself can work as link bhasha.
Yes we accept Hindi language whole heartedly to communicate with other state people. But we should also be allowed to preserve our own language. That's seems cultural genoside. Yes my langauge do not have script. But that's doesn't make it inferior. We should be allowed to speak in school. And teachers and government should support in preserving our dying langauge. 😓😓😓😓
Haryana se hai kya?
@@vikaskardam8052 Bhadohi (U.P)
@@prateekpathak1652 bhadohi mein Bhojpuri boli jati hai ya awadhi🤔
@@shobhitraj5591 banarasi ka thoda variant hai... Thoda thoda variation hr jagah hai... Mirzapur, Bhadohi,jaunpur, Badlapur, Varanasi, chandoli etc... Ese he same langauge share krte hai... Bhojpuri nhi hai.... Rauaaa koi use nhi krta... 🤦🤦🤦
Sorry...We dont want any hindi in our state. Our state lang and english enuf. If you work in mumbai, learn Marathi. English a temporary link.
I'm from Punjab, Pakistan and I'm pure Urdu speaker. I believe in Hindustani language (Urdu/Hindi). So I have learnt both scripts, Persian and Devanagari. I love my Mother Language Punjabi too. So I have also learnt both scripts of Punjabi (Shahmukhi & Gurmukhi). I would love all the people to give respect to their mother tongues. Love and respect for you all! 💙
_____________________________
Our Mother Language Our Identity Our Pride
ہماری مادری زبان ہماری پہچان ہماری شان
हमारी मातृभाषा हमारी पहचान हमारा सम्मान
ساڈی ماں بولی ساڈی پہچانڑ ساڈا مانڑ
ਸਾਡੀ ਮਾਂ ਬੋਲੀ ਸਾਡੀ ਪਛਾਣ ਸਾਡੀ ਮਾਣ
💙
Nice bro
Great 👍
I am also Pakistani Punjabi and love both Urdu and Punjabi equally and I want to learn Gurmukhi script.
To be honest here government also don't promote Bihari languages in school they don't teach us also like other state. Example in Bengal bengali is taught but here we are not taught any of our mother tounge.
In my school we get fined for not speaking English
Every regional language should be protected, no matter what political leader says, "Language is our mother".
From a Bengali❤️
আমি মালদার মৈথিলী ব্রাহ্মণ
@@suryadevthakur5212 amaro ekta bondhu aache .. maithili ...jha surname ...je ekhon proudly nijeke bangali bole .... Ebar bhujlen keno Hindi imposition baaje ??.
I guess bihar has been looted by its politicians.
And society is the place from where these politicians come from. Let's educate ourselves and our society guys. For which will give us better politicians and a better society. Enough of us blaming all on our government. 🙏🇮🇳
how is this looted by politics? there might even be a time where people may forget hindi too in order to adapt English.
I m from bihar and here caste is bigger than anything. They voted for nitish despite stable job promises from rjd.
@@nitkills7070 that's not how it works, politicians change the society, and if it changes in a good way then we will have good politicians in the coming generations but past politicians and leaders never really tried to make our society better so there is nothing surprising in the condition of India today and current ones are also not doing anything!
Bihari looted by Hindi speaker man
I'm a Bihari and never knew that we have some languages other than Hindi and Bhojpuri. And I'm shocked that these languages had there own script
If you research about it you will find that hindi destroyed many languages
How can you not know maithili?
@@harmansidhu7359 why would i? He did it for the people like me
I fall in love with Hindi just because of Munshi Premchand. Hira aur Moti story was my first story that I read in Hindi.
You mean "Do Bailon Ki Katha".
@@srishtidebnath8313 yes. I studied when I was in 6th standard.
@@Kk-yi6hk I have studied this when I was in 9th standard. Now I'm in 10th standard.
@@Kk-yi6hk CBSE board?
@@daredevil30000 no SEBA
I still remember how sad I felt when few years ago I came to know that my ancetral language was Bajjika and being a third generation migrant bihari, I had no idea how to speak it, neither did anyone in my family new of such a language. People in my family have a vague idea of 'bhojpuri' being the mother tongue of all bihari, (thanks to popular Bollywood stereotypes). I've had the fortunate experience of visiting my ancestral village only once in my life and I found that even there people were not aware that there language was called Bajjika, which carries the great cultural heritage of being the language of the Lichhavi Republic. The decent of the language in which Mahavira spoke, the language in which Amrapali spoke, the language of the Gupta queen.
There is great cultural stigma associated with speaking the native languages of bihar. Primarily because of two reasons 1) these languages being classified as a 'dialect' of hindi, hence people think that they are basically speaking bad hindi. 2) the popular stereotyping of these languages as being spoken by uneducated uncultured people. That is the reason why migrant Biharis never want their children to speak these languages and hence hindi has replaced these languages even at home, of all migrant bihari families and even in Bihar itself people prefer to talk among each other's in Hindi to show that they are educated.
The only region that has maintained some linguistic conciousness is Mithila. All the folk songs that are sung during marriages, birth rituals, pujas, etc are rapidly getting lost. My grandmother was the last one who remembered some of these folk songs, and used to sing them during pujas alone. Now no one does.
Bihar itself does not recognize these languages as official language of the state. Even big politicians never give their speeches in the local languages. And biharis are not realizing the kind of cultural and linguistic devastation that they are doing to themselves. This devastation is almost complete in all "educated" migrant families and it is at its peak in Bihari homes itself, radiating from urban centers to villages now.
I'm a bihari and since childhood my parents never encouraged me to learn the local languages and we speak hindi at home. I wish these local languages were given more preference.
@@ashi5276 Even the Bihar government doesn't recognize any of these languages as official languages.
well said
If u consider Bajjika and Angika, a separate language, not Maithili. Then u are itself promoting Hindi in Bihar because these two words where bought in 1954 by a Hindi writer of Bhojpuri speaking region, on Mahajanpad basis, to strong Hindi and weaken Maithili, because at that time Maithili was too strong in Bihar. Before 1954, there was no any words like this. And now see the position of Hindi in Bihar.
@@divyansh7572 I agree with u
To weaken Maithili Language , and to demolish the Separate Mithila state movement, they spread rumours that Angika and Bajjika are different languages
But in reality, Both Angika and Bajjika are dialects of Maithili, just like Surjapuri dialect which is spoken in Purnea and Kisanganj side of Bihar
I am a bihari but I never knew that Maithili and Bhojpuri had a separate script. How shameful for me!!
Thanks a lot Mohak
no, bhojpuri of uttar pradesh didn't have script.
even bhojpuri has lot of variation, from bhojpuri of benaras , arrah, gorakhpur , baliya ,etc. many times they almost sound very different . a unified language was necessary
this new movement is just to destroy hindi .i support both bhojpuri of my state(UP) and hindi
if u want bhojpuri language, question will arise about which variation of bhojpuri to adapt, varanasi one or arrah one.
My mothers maternal ancestors were from bhojpur an I came to know that bhojpuri was written in Persian and kaithi I immediately learnt the script I want my further genration to know that.
@@shreshth6841 in my region , people used devnagri and persian. No disrespect to kaithi script , but as i have seen it in images from bihar, otwas never used here
@@shreshth6841 You know kaithi script?
Being a bihari I felt ashamed of speaking my own language(magahi) in public places although we speak magahi at home and there are many reasons why I felt ashamed and avoided speaking it like whenever I spoke magahi outside my house with my family or anyone who knows it people gave us a weird look, they think we are not well educated or we don't know how to speak Hindi ,some of them also laughed at us and all the vulgarity shown in the bhojpuri songs makes it harder people think we use such words or phrases to speak our language which is not true but now I understand the importance of my native language and i'm gonna communicate with my family in my own native language without caring about place or people..
Thank you Mohak Bhaiya ❤️
Still Magahi People are busy in changing surname to Kumar and second name😂🤣They have spread this bullsh*t trend to other regions of Bihar too.
@@Kinshuk.Rai_Saheb.Bihar_wale kya yah kumar/kumari ka trend inn magahio ne start kia tha 🤨 ??
@@aagman01 Haan Fir ye baad Bhojpuri/Maithili region me faila Pura Undivided Bihar mein.
bhojpuri has almost 6 crore native speaker. It has been derived from magadhi(eastern) prakrit of sanskrit where hindi is derived from sauraseni(western) prakrit of sanskrit. But unjudicially bhojpuri is termed as a dialect of hindi to increase the number of native hindi speakers in census. Bhojpuri people should protest & demand a separate bhojpuri speaking state named "bhojpur" to save their language. In nepal,bhojpuri is considered as a separate language,not a dialect of hindi.
True and in Nepal Bhojpuri is a major language too
Man,this is the channel that I really want to see growing, india needs more and more youtubers like mohak who educates india instead of brainwashing or wasting their time
Is this mohak guy Hindu?
@@carymnuhgibrilsamadalnasud1222 why would that matter?
@@KishanSharma-fe7qo I was just asking because a I've seen him recieve a lot of hate just for having a liberal and secularist mindset.
@@carymnuhgibrilsamadalnasud1222 And, how is this relevant??? Why would that even matter?
@@MohammadAbdullah-dg1rp I already know he is. Don't need to reply.
I want to add something here...I live in Mauritius, where there is a large population that migrated from Bihar in the 1850 to 1930. But here the story is different, people speak a French Creole, and Bhojpuri. They are fighting for their Bhojpuri culture and language. This had been relegated to the backseat for sometime,but in recent years many young and not so young people here are claiming their Bihari and most importantly Bhojpuri identities.
Even the Bihari diaspora spread across the globe is more successful than us native Biharis😢
साची में,हम आपन प्रान्तीय भाषा धीरे-धीरे भूल गईल बानी।कई बरस से हम बंगलुरू में रही ला।ऐ खातिर सब भूला गईले बानी।सोंच-सोंच के लिखले बानी।
भाषा कोई भी हो ,छोटी या बडी नहीं होती।अपने भाव और संदेश सामने वाले तक पहुँचे।यह दो दिलों को मिलाने के माध्यम हैं।अधर से गिरे तो शब्द बन जाते हैं।शब्द,शब्दों से जुडे तो भाषा बन जाते हैं।अपनी भाषा में कही गई बातें रूह तक पहुँचने से तन-मन झंकृत कर जाता है। भारतवर्ष विभिन्न उन्नत भाषाओं से धनी देश है।इंग्लिश के साथ-साथ अपनी -अपनी मातृभाषाओं का भी ज्ञान होना आवश्यक है।हमें इसे प्रमोट करना चाहिए। स्वंय के सम्मान देने से हीं सम्मान बढता है।
Wow I didn't know that
Thanks for it
@@rashmigupta7246 kannada ? Can you speak ?
@@SonuSinghmirzapur hey it's not kannada
Meanwhile south says no to HIndi
Great information Mohak! Keep up the good work.
मैं जब 9 साल का था तब दिल्ली आया था अब 20 साल का हो चुका हूं इन 11 सालों में मुझे असंख्य लोगों ने अपनी टोन बदलने को कहा , भोजपुरी को भुलने को कहा । लेकिन मैंने हमेशा अपनी भाषा पर गर्व किया है
Poore desh ko tumpe garv hai bhai 🙏🇮🇳
Lage raho bhaisahab. Banawati bannane ki koshish karne waalon ko sharmasar karne ka yahi tareeka hai
hindi is the best language in the world , every person must speak only hindi . we have haryanvi dialect but that must be erased only hindi
@@Aloksharma-oe1gm Aaagya trolll, ignore guys
'
@@Aloksharma-oe1gm why you not wrote this in hindi , I hope your children learning science in hindi language
Just speak your language
How hard is it ?
I’m from Telangana and I proudly speak Telugu
But I’m Indian first ✨
EXACTLY, THESE PEOPLE THEMSELVES DONT WANT TO LEARN THEIR REGIONAL LANGUAGES AND THEN THEY WILL SAY "AWWWW HINDI IS DESTROYING US, HAVE MERCY ON OUR LANGUAGES" I'M A BIHARI AND PROUDLY SPEAK BHOJPURI AND BESIDES IT ALSO HINDI, BENGALI AND ENGLISH(ENGLISH ONLY FOR WRITING PURPOSE COZ I DONT LIKE ENGLISH XD)
my parents are bihari and they don't know how to write in maithili script. their maithili is more like hindi and they were not taught how to write in maithili in school.....my grand parents don't know how to write in maithili either.....now tell me how will i teach my future generation maithili.....i don't even know how to speak in maithili and jo aati hai tuti futi hai
@@Roma-kf1vriss sab ka Karan hai Islamic invaders ka north india Mai rule kerna aur unke culture and identity ko destroy kerna....
It's not so easy. There are no schools teaching these languages nor any official or formal work happening. Only Hindi is used for educational and official purposes in all over North India. Consequently Hindi comes to be seen as the language of the educated and other languages remain used only among the less educated and rural folks. The Government of India has consciously created an ecosystem that would incentivise Hindi at the expense of other languages. Hindi colonisation is real and insidious.
OK.. What is Telugu is destroyed by goons like they did in many areas on Northern India
Hindi damaged Maharashtra's language, Marathi used to be written in a different script known as 'Mody' long before we changed to Devanagari, our pronounciations, nouns and vowels are similar to that of the Southern Dravidian languages. No wonder so many Marathi people are pissed off at the decay of their language and forceful introduction of Hindi in our school while erasing Marathi from our syllabus.
Hindi has damaged Rajasthani language too.
I am Bihari, I have lost my language Magahi. I request people from different states to learn from our story and don't disown your language. My parents discouraged me to speak in my local language.
Only Bihar? LOL! Hindi Killed a lot of languages in UP, Uttaranchal, HP, Haryana and most importantly Rajasthani in Rajasthan!
@Priyvrat Mourya In Small part of North Western UP, called Khariboli region. UP is not the size of peanut my friend!
And English
Hindi is mixture of noth languages
Alongwith many local dialects like bundelkhandi and awadhi
@@manasraj2632 lol what?
My Family migrated to Sikkim 3 generations back, yet our elders made sure that we speak our mother tongue at home and I am so proud that I can speak my mother tongue Bhojpuri unlike my other friends who speak either Hindi or Nepali at home or outside.
I'm bihari Living in Odisha my family
Mother tongue is magahi from nalanda
I have living in Odisha from past 12 years
And I don't know to speak magahi
I know only hindi and some other language
My parents used to take in magahi
And sometimes I cannot understand it
But my parents talk in Hindi with me.
Jisko Jo bhasha bolni hai bole sabko freedom hai
Proud of bhojpuri❤
You should respect and must be learn Sikkim's local language if you earn bread from that community.
Many UP Bihari came bangal and spread Hindi Mania.
@@Muhammad78661 yeah same thing is happening to maharastra
I am an Angika speaker. Well, I have been away from my home for quite a few years. I miss my mother tongue and its sweetness. From what I remember, It had been taboo for school-going children to speak the local language. Today we lack its literature and cultural identity. Nevertheless, I believe in its restoration. I talk to my relatives in this novel language. As a researcher, I am trying to contribute to the research field of the language ( building machine translation from English to Angika and Bhojpuri). Jai Bihar
Share your project to us common people too
Bro I belong to Ang region of Bihar. I was born and brought up in different states because of my father's job. My parents didn't taught me Angika. I want to learn Angika. Can you suggest me how to do it? Can you suggest me songs, films, literary works in Angika? If you have any suggestions please let me know.
Couldn't resist from commenting myself.
You manage to create such a quality videos only because of your honest research. I personally find most of your videos very informative.
Keep up the good work.
I am Bengali ,born in Muzaffarpur ,Bihar. Whoever tries to defame Bihar, I always standup to show what Bihar actually is ❤️
💝💝💝💝💝💝
I am from Muzaffarpur living in US. I had childhood friends who were Bengali but they left Bihar during RJD period.
@Mr Jitul it is not our fault if we culturally diverse and inclusive and superior
@Mr Jitul Do you even know that bongs once considered Maithili a prestigious language to learn and have made significant contributions to it.... Have you ever studied Tagore's Bhanusingh er podaboli which contains songs written in all pure Maithili like sajani sajani radhika lo, bhavana kusuma kunja majhe etc... Moreover it is so common for Assamese or Tripuri people like you to spread Xenophobia because you very well know that your contributions are horribly meagre and irrelevant
@Mr Jitul Please Explain How?
Yes, Hindi is not Bihar's language.
Bihar accepted hindi as official language but in reality we speak Bhojpuri,Maithili,Maghi,Angika,Vajjika
Vajjika Kya vajji mahajanapada se hein..??
@@utopiancity8138 haa.
Ab ye tirhut ke area me bola jata hai jisme vaishali,muzaffarpur,sitamadhi,sheohar district aate hai
@@kitchenninja1285 acchaaa..
@@utopiancity8138 aur Angika language Ang Mahajanpada se belong karta hai
@@Mr.Endlesss acchaaa...
Really very very awesome you have presented... I love to see ... Just incrediable... Thanks!
Thanks Mohak for this. Really appreciate it
As a bihari myself, I have seen many people from Bihar who are ashamed of talking in their native languages or even from being called bihari, specifically those who have Migrated and settled elsewhere... It's quite deterring that the bihar which once used to be the educational hub of world is now struggling with its own identity
We are not ashamed but just think they abuse you your whole school life just because you are from Bihar... i have discriminated from My Childhood in my school... It make you to feel ashamed when your classmates who are of same age and belong to that region / state abuse you even I was the topper of my class...will you not feel ashamed 😔
I'am from bihar & my local language is "magahi" , and i speaks magahi everytime.
How sweet our mother language. ❤️
Please brother share it with friend
That's why Bihar under development
Because in maghai language not available study metrial, website, content
@@bmyadav4633 Ooo bhaiya kuch to common sense hoga hi, mtlb ek person kewal ek hi language bol sakta hai 😂
And i speaks three different languages :-magahi, hindi, english & something german.
Humhun dostwan ke sathe magahiye baat kara hi ho😀😀.
But there is a problem, when we speak magahi at home or in school, we were used get punishment.
@@adventuresubgames2899 hai bhaiwa thik kahit he😊
Ghar pr magahi bolela la punishment mila hau😅
the loss of native language does not only apply to Bihari. We can say that rise of Hindi have led to decline of many languages/dialects in India. In Uttarakhand the younger generation does not speak the native dialects i.e Garhwali and Kumauni. My own mother tongue is Nepali, I do speak fluent Nepali but the newer generation does not do so. They all speak in Hindi only. Slowly other languages are dying. And we need to act on it asap.
Good.
Yeah, I'm a Garhwali and I can second that.
Thank you for realizing so many things in just a single shot! You are an amazing man !!
Fantastic video! Now hope Ppl will understand why Tamilians protest against hindi imposition.
@Abishek yes nanba..
We are already United with Indian pride..
And we all sing our national anthem of Bengali poet proudly..
We love our Indian sport team..
We all respect our president.
We all are United already in various aspects but still Hindi speaking people thinks other non Hindi speaking people are second class Indian..
English tumhare baap ki bhasha hain
Protect your language from Kerala 🙏
No Area in India has Hindi language as there natural language.. Hindi is mostly language of Western UP, Delhi and Haryana.
I'm from Chhattisgarh and chhattisgarhi is my mother tongue but now no one talks in Chhattisgarh in big cities..
What about southern CG's dialects?? Which are completely different from Chhattisgarhi & Hindi??
@@user-yo1dk8pb4d Nothing about Southern CG dialects 🌝
Learn Hindi 😌
@@user-yo1dk8pb4d They are not Dialects but Languages.. and there are 1000s of such languages in Chhattisgarh spoken by 20 people , 30 people , 50 people and may be 1000 people depending upon their tribe.
@@user-yo1dk8pb4d Remember none of them are Dravidian...
All of them are astroloide languages.. Astroloides came a long before Dravidians in India..
It is language of m.p and central u.p too.
As a kashmiri I have had experienced a resistance to adoption of Hindi in my region. I knew South Indians have the same vews but never knew even north india especialy Bihar, etc have suffered losses as well as a result.
You are the first youtuber i have pressed "join" on, i learnt so much today.
Keep up the good work brother. ❤️
are you anti india
Loved the content and delivering style!
I'm a 23 yr old maithil girl, living in kolkata, but thanks to my parents who were ardent about us of learning maithili, till today we speak in our mother tongue (which many of my cousins don't do)to each other, n people here confuse it with gujrati, because of the "chhe" thing 😂, btw thanks to mohak sir for making this video, got emotional ❤️🌷
Which district ??
I can understand maithili nicely but not able to speak due to lack of use but now i am trying to speak as much as possible..👍
Even I'm a maithil ..
@@bhardwajparth me too bro
Does anyone know Maithili writing script? As it is very similar to bengali, i wish i had someone who could help me with Maithili language and writing system.
People of Bihar open your eyes. You were the cradle of Maurya Empire and Nalanda. Please reclaim your glory.
We are waiting for one more Chandragupta maurya
@@amanprasad1345 amen brother
@@bubundada7094 Amen means ?
@@amanprasad1345 it's like "so be it".
@@bubundada7094 ok . 😁😁 I was knowing it but I just got out mind .I thought you are saying something on any maurya king .
😁😁
Now hindi imposition is spread all over India... we have to protest against hindi imposition...(according to Indian constitution India have no national language)
We have to love all indian languages..including hindi...but fight against hindi imposition
And English emopotion also . because English have potential to destroy all indian languages . sadly I also write in english
Very informative. Thanks!
Wowwwwww this video is like dream of every Bihari... Thanks a ton bro🙏🙏 We are fed up with the xenophobia against Biharis!!!!!
Any thoughtful Indian is fed up of the xenophobia against Bihar and UP but for some halfminds and trolls its cool. But know that many are realising and much of the people are already ahead of this stupid behaviour of stereotyping the people of our country. Here's hoping 🙏🇮🇳
yes sis💯💯💯
Try harder to get rid of it.
@@aparnasingh9358 even when anyone ask me about my place while playing pubg i just not answer or say lakhnow UP as i m from bihar and known few places in up and ashamed of reviling my identity 😔
@@moh_zahk8719 That's sad and unfortunate😢. I have seen it more often as i live in Maharashtra although i am myself proud whenever my relatives even if they came to visit us they did same. people are so openly racist against Biharis and its funny they are the same people who are saying stop racism against NE and lasun..🙂
1:20 This voice is Dr. ChadraDev Yadav. Assistant professor of department of Hindi from Jamia Millia Islamia ❤️
Why bitcoins instability is its biggest enemy
👇👇👇👇
I remember I was once going to Vishahari Mela (Very famous fastival in Bihar specially in Angika region some times also known as Mata Mansa Puja. If u dodn't know please Google it.) with my friends in my school dress. And I was getting late to go home, so I called my father and talked in Angika (Mother tongue) that I will come home late.
At the same time I found that some people standing on the street were looking at me with Inferior sence. I think they thinks that how a English Medium School boy talk in Angika [such a low grade language (in their POV)].
But I don't care what people think. I always prefer to talk in Angika with my family,
and I love my mother tongue Angika. ❣️❣️
Good i respect that
Thanks for the research and info😊