I do appreciate the CGI timeline mainly being a slight retelling of the model series, due to both still carrying the Thomas show as it’s presented to us whilst subtly making sure it’s it’s own canon that can be separated, just shares mostly the same events up to that point as confirmed by flashbacks
I don't it's necessary to make CGI a separate timeline because like you said, it shares mostly the same events, and the few retcons and contradictions that it has can be either explained or ignored
2:11 Before The Beginning (King Of The Railway) 2:40 Pirates Attack (Sodors Legend Of The Lost Treasure) 3:02 The Rain Hill Trials (King Of The Railway) 3:26 Railways Developed 3:34 The Skarloey Railway 3:39 The North Western Railway 3:46 Japan (Hero Of The Rails) 4:03 The Adventure Begins 6:28 Skipping Ahead 8:00 Blue Mountain Mystery 8:42 Hero Of The Rails 9:05 Next Year 9:11 Misty Island Rescue 10:26 Day Of The Diesels 10:41 Return To Blue Mountain Mystery 10:55 Finding The Car 11:09 Return To King Of The Railway 11:47 New Wheels 11:56 Tale Of The Brave 12:46 Slip Coaches 12:54 Long Lost Friend-Monsters And Volcano 13:09 Season 19 13:32 Sodors Legend Of The Lost Treasure 14:14 Season 20 14:28 The Great Race 14:45 Before Christmas 15:07 Season 21 15:42 Journey Beyond Sodor 15:53 Big World Big Adventures 16:11 Season 22 16:44 Around The World (Season 22-23) 17:31 Season 24
I wonder if it is possible that Andrew Brenner might have possibly retconned Hiro saying he was the first engine on Sodor. But if we recall Hiro saying he was ONE of the first engines to arrive on Sodor, it may be possible he arrived in 1935, who knows. I am just trying to make sense of everything if CGI was canon with models.
I imagine that has been retconned similar to how TATMR was retconned. I have this headcanon that Hiro came to fill in for the North Western engines while they were away on the mainland during the war and he arrived after they left.
I may have only been actively following the series for the Miller Era of this timeline, unfortunately, but after seeing the glory of the Brenner Era after discovering The Unlucky Tug, I can say that this has some of the best locations, characters, and episodes in the entire series, and I admire Tug's efforts to tie it all together.
I feel that when Hiro went back to Japan most of his friends had either passed away, scrapped, moved or preserved. Also maybe steam isn’t used in Japan anymore and only on Sodor can he be really useful.
9:36 this always has pissed me off. *THERE IS A LITERAL 1-IN-A-MILLION CHANCE THAT THE BARGE THOMAS WAS ON ACTUALLY ALIGNED WITH RAILS THAT RANDOMLY SHOW UP*
Thomas and the Magic Railroad also had a lot of these things as well. For example when Mr. Conductor gets caught by Diesel 10 Mr. Conductor cuts the wire and THERE IS A LITERAL 1-IN-A-MILLION CHANGE THAT HE WOULD JUST SO HAPPEN TO LAND ON THE BAGS OF FLOUR AND SURVIVE. Here's another example when Thomas takes Lilly back to her grandfather and Thomas then falls of the mountain and this scene is so annoying because THERE IS LITERALLY 1-IN-A-MILLION CHANGES THAT THOMAS JUST SO HAPPENS TO FALL INTO IT. Here's another example the stone bridge starts crumbling apart and THERE IS A LITERAL 1-IN-A-MILLION CHANGE THAT BOTH LADY AND THOMAS WOULD GET ACROSS THE BRIDGE BEFORE IT COMPLETELY CRUMBS APART. So yeah Thomas and the Magic Railroad did this much worse than Misty Island Rescue.
And before someone responds to this guy telling him Thomas and the Magic Railroad isn’t canon, the "canon" 2014 map from Sam Wilkinson marks some of the places from the movie on it and Britt Allcroft has said that it is canon.
This is fire! I always wondered when and what happened during all the episodes, I watch this with my younger son but somehow it makes me wanna dig deeper. Keep it up!
Thank you!!! For calling out the reboot being crap!!! It makes no logical sense!!! I hate it with a passion!!! It's so bad it doesn't even deserve it's own ring in hell or in he'll at al!!! It deserves it's own hell where it's tortured by the three other shows for how unrealistic it is!!!
Thank you so much for reuploading all the old videos and still producing videos, I had a dream last night (and I didn’t even know that you have your channel deleted) but in the dream you didn’t reupload your videos and I could never watch them again and I woke up this morning and went to check your channel as quick as possible
One of many things I don't like about CGI era is that it didn't utilize character's personal theme song as much as it was in model era where you could tell the characters by just hearing music and it gives them more personality. The other thing I don't like is they hadn't done Emily a justice (but to be fair, she got butchered since series 8).
So The rws era then model era and now The CGI era, congrats for that The chronological order of the Thomas and Friends from seasons 1 to 24 + movies, WOW just WOW Three eras are both great and amazing
Thomas the Tank Engine Series was one of my oldest childhood memories and since then I love both the models and the CGI. It's a shame that the CGI Thomas and Friends series has coming to the end because I would to see continuing visiting other countries a bit more as he hasn't have a chance to visit American, Germany, France, Mexico, Berlin, and Japan as well as meeting the other engines featuring in "Thomas and Friends The Great Race" like Vinnie, Frieda, Axel, Ivan, Etienne and Carlos. But sadly it's not going to happen now no thanks to Mattel.
Well I don’t even consider the first one as proof that MIR happened. Misty Island is probably part of Sudrian folklore and the former is from an episode that was supposed to be in season 21 and I see the original version as the canon one.
Cally's ship looks like the Mayflower The Royal Navy's finest ship in the sails period might have been the Heavy First Rate Ship of the line (HMS Victory) but that was in the 18th century or 17th century
As much as I and so many more people in the Thomas community hate the CGI series, mainly specific parts of it, I respect the thought and work put into this video.
If I ran Mattel, I’d make EVERYTHING just perfect as fans would want it, fix every series error and flanderzation, with a few character developments and a slight land edit and EVERY location on Sodor fixed
The model series is referenced multiple times throughout the story, with some events even be recreated, such as Thomas falling into the mine in Down The Mine, and he even recalls the details. Other references to the model series include Duncan recalling pulling an elephant statue from The Runaway Elephant and Rheneas recalling pulling a dinosaur skeleton from Rheneas and the Dinosaur, both from Emily Saves the World. Emily Saves the World actually references many episodes, the others being Paint Pots and Queens, Thomas and the Jet Engine, and Percy and the Magic Carpet. A couple more that I’ll list include Percy Takes a Plunge and the Sad Story of Henry, with the climactic events of both being retold by Percy and Henry, respectively, and also recreated. Just based on this is enough for me to believe that the model and CGI series are in the same continuity.
fyi the events of Donald and Douglas (the signal box smashing) and Twin Trouble are referenced in Emily in the middle, sooo that probably happened sometime when they joined the railway in that weird time period thing
The new thomas will never be as good as the cgi i loved watching it it was a big part of my childhood i remember the movies coming out and they made awesome track master sets after or before the movie
I don't think Thomas the Tank Engine would have had nearly the same impact on me if i was growing up with the CGI stuff, instead of the classic series. I get some glimpses of it now that makes me want to take a look, but then they pull the "oh we need to make new toys" moves and turn me completely off the idea.
Misty island isnt fully refrenced in this song but it is hinted at by paxton and Sidney. In the song wheres Thomas? Paxton says "he could have found a secret tunnel to some island thats unkown" sidney replies "how can there be and island around here thats unkown?" "Well what if it was always coverd in mist? Oh that sounds very mist-erious"
for misty island my head canon is that the draw bridge was broken which is why thomas had to go by ship (still makes the movie make no sense but now just a little more)
I doubt the writers had that in mind, but you do you I suppose. I personally don’t consider the movie canon (I know Thomas mentioned Misty Island but I can write that off as being Sudric folklore).
15:3316:14 Edward and Henry will return to Tidmouth Sheds and Nia and Rebecca would move to Vicarstown with Rosie because another engine who was send to the mainland in 1998 to do a lot of work there will return to Sodor and move back to Wellsworth with Philip we’ll have to wait and see
His driver is stroking his face trying to comfort him he’s also watching the workmen, the fat controller and his assistants walling him up in his tunnel
Henry is getting bricked up inside the tunnel and has also had his rails taken away so he can’t get out of the tunnel and is stuck there with no way out and after he was bricked up everybody left him in the tunnel all on his own
The wall is only in front of him the tunnel is left open at the back and the rails are still there behind him so he can get out if needed and people can get into the tunnel but he doesn’t know that
I'm planning to make that myself with new scenes added to feature The Skarloey engines and Series 5 characters in them with more touch upon like repairs on the railway and other characters appearing, either speaking or cameo.
@@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967 That's great, and I think the characters from Seasons 2-7 and The Railway Series books that never appeared in the CGI series should have speaking roles such as Boco, Bear, Derek, Caroline, Elizabeth, Thumper, Duke, Ivo Hugh, Fred, Arthur, Murdoch and Fergus.
If you think about it really well, no, that season 18 episode did NOT happen in Tale of the Brave. Here is my evidence. In Tale of the Brave, Gator goes to the Fenland and says that he is sorry for giving James a fright. Although, in the episode, Gator just keeps going when the signal turns green. Thus, Gators lamp just goes out twice and James is a total scaredy cat that shouldn't be making fun of Percy when he got scared of Gator twice in a row. Unlucky Tug, I know you and other people probably won't read this, but I just wanted to say this to clarify things. His ship is also delayed twice.
Excuse me, but Misty Island rescue was released in 2010. I used to be afraid of it when I was a little kid but now I just think it’s special and it’s on Prime Video today too.
I was gonna point out Big Mickey from Tugs, but you say it enough that when it’s referenced, it’s canon, then it makes sense Tugs never happened anyway 😂
20:43 We’re not going to have a fourth timeline like this because one of Donald Trump’s team is going to make a fourth timeline in the future CGI series very soon
God, I'm so glad I fell out of love with the Thomas series partway through the model series. But I must admit through your videos that I'm getting the urge to watch more of the seasons I skipped. But let's face it, I'll happily stick to the first 26 books as my canon.
I actually have a head cannon that everything after the BWBA movie, is in present day, and that would make Marvelous machinery, make a lot more sense AND: The internation episodes and the BWBA movie take place at the same time, its a lot of not showing, showing, and a WHOLE lot of no nia, but if you shape every clip in a certain manner, it can just about work And here's' my timeline: Seasons 13-16: 1950's Seasons 17-21 1980's Seasons 22-onwards: Modren day (Excluding TRE)
Fun fact: you actually CAN hear how Thomas returns from his second world tour… through the form of an official ASMR story on a sleep app called CALM! (It sucks ass tho) basically, Thomas comes home but gets sad no ones talking to him, turns out… everyone planed him a surprise party. YaAaAy
As for the Magic Railroad. If I remember correctly, and don’t quote me on this, Lady is seen later on Sodor in either the classic or CGI timeline, making the events of the movie canon to one of them.
Fun Fact: There is no such thing as a model series continuity or a CGI series continuity its one continuity and always has been. This is a common misconception I keep seeing when its very obvious its all one timeline for the TV series.
I like to think that the events in the CGI series are out of order, simply because of the inconsistencies. In canon, it has a drifting timeline so it literally doesn't matter. But being Autistic, realism and timelines matter for me. The RWS has a timeline though. It's fascinating how fans are able to get around with the CGI's continuity problem.
Timelines of TTTE: 1. Railway Series (Books 1-42 and the Island of Sodor book) 1945-2005 2. Model Era (Season 1-12) 1984-2008 3. CGI Series (Season 13-24) 2009-2020 4. All Engines Go/Anime Series (Season 25-32) 2021-2026? 5. Jayden The Locomotive/My Timeline (Season 1-13) 2027-2038
15:02 I thought you were going to mention something about the line " you look as splendid as the day I built you" from the same episode, might not have been the word Splendid
The way you make the argument that all 3 canons are the same is by using Awdry's BS statement from the IoS book that not all the footage/illustrations are accurate to the actual events, like NWR1991 did with NWR Tales.
I do appreciate the CGI timeline mainly being a slight retelling of the model series, due to both still carrying the Thomas show as it’s presented to us whilst subtly making sure it’s it’s own canon that can be separated, just shares mostly the same events up to that point as confirmed by flashbacks
I don't it's necessary to make CGI a separate timeline because like you said, it shares mostly the same events, and the few retcons and contradictions that it has can be either explained or ignored
Maybe Hiro, Salty and Carly are prototypes and that’s why they exist before their build dates
No he literally explained and also the produces would of never thought of that
Sure, just make 2023 Nowadays English Dictionary in 1920.
that still makes no sense
Every single engine on Sodor is a prototype lmao
@@RickAtanga2023 not all of them lmao
2:11 Before The Beginning (King Of The Railway)
2:40 Pirates Attack (Sodors Legend Of The Lost Treasure)
3:02 The Rain Hill Trials (King Of The Railway)
3:26 Railways Developed
3:34 The Skarloey Railway
3:39 The North Western Railway
3:46 Japan (Hero Of The Rails)
4:03 The Adventure Begins
6:28 Skipping Ahead
8:00 Blue Mountain Mystery
8:42 Hero Of The Rails
9:05 Next Year
9:11 Misty Island Rescue
10:26 Day Of The Diesels
10:41 Return To Blue Mountain Mystery
10:55 Finding The Car
11:09 Return To King Of The Railway
11:47 New Wheels
11:56 Tale Of The Brave
12:46 Slip Coaches
12:54 Long Lost Friend-Monsters And Volcano
13:09 Season 19
13:32 Sodors Legend Of The Lost Treasure
14:14 Season 20
14:28 The Great Race
14:45 Before Christmas
15:07 Season 21
15:42 Journey Beyond Sodor
15:53 Big World Big Adventures
16:11 Season 22
16:44 Around The World (Season 22-23)
17:31 Season 24
You forgot Royal engine
And marvellous machinerys
I still don’t understand how Victor falling into the sea was Luke’s fault when it’s obviously Cranky’s fault
It was an accident all along.
Guilt doesn't have to make sense.
cause then they would not have a story about it.
The crew should of check Victor’s chain before unload the engines.
Why luke tident see Victors chains broke?
I wonder if it is possible that Andrew Brenner might have possibly retconned Hiro saying he was the first engine on Sodor. But if we recall Hiro saying he was ONE of the first engines to arrive on Sodor, it may be possible he arrived in 1935, who knows. I am just trying to make sense of everything if CGI was canon with models.
Yea that’s what I thought too
@@Nerguy By the way, you just gave me an idea. I’ll have to work on a video about that.
I think he might be referring to the Scarloe engines
I imagine that has been retconned similar to how TATMR was retconned. I have this headcanon that Hiro came to fill in for the North Western engines while they were away on the mainland during the war and he arrived after they left.
I may have only been actively following the series for the Miller Era of this timeline, unfortunately, but after seeing the glory of the Brenner Era after discovering The Unlucky Tug, I can say that this has some of the best locations, characters, and episodes in the entire series, and I admire Tug's efforts to tie it all together.
Man, the CGI series had so many crazy events.
Yeah like how Thomas and the fat controller meets the queen and her son, even though before Salty was build like unlucky tug said. 1:04
Big Mickeys reveal was one of the most suspension like moments in the show
I feel that when Hiro went back to Japan most of his friends had either passed away, scrapped, moved or preserved. Also maybe steam isn’t used in Japan anymore and only on Sodor can he be really useful.
I think he just came back to sodor not to be preserved
Love this video! So much fun trying to piece together the CGI series, and I love the Brenner Era a ton so this was wonderful to see
I have a deep feeling the Brenner Era took a big step into Sodors lore very seriously 10:23 17:22
9:36 this always has pissed me off. *THERE IS A LITERAL 1-IN-A-MILLION CHANCE THAT THE BARGE THOMAS WAS ON ACTUALLY ALIGNED WITH RAILS THAT RANDOMLY SHOW UP*
Thomas and the Magic Railroad also had a lot of these things as well. For example when Mr. Conductor gets caught by Diesel 10 Mr. Conductor cuts the wire and THERE IS A LITERAL 1-IN-A-MILLION CHANGE THAT HE WOULD JUST SO HAPPEN TO LAND ON THE BAGS OF FLOUR AND SURVIVE. Here's another example when Thomas takes Lilly back to her grandfather and Thomas then falls of the mountain and this scene is so annoying because THERE IS LITERALLY 1-IN-A-MILLION CHANGES THAT THOMAS JUST SO HAPPENS TO FALL INTO IT. Here's another example the stone bridge starts crumbling apart and THERE IS A LITERAL 1-IN-A-MILLION CHANGE THAT BOTH LADY AND THOMAS WOULD GET ACROSS THE BRIDGE BEFORE IT COMPLETELY CRUMBS APART. So yeah Thomas and the Magic Railroad did this much worse than Misty Island Rescue.
And before someone responds to this guy telling him Thomas and the Magic Railroad isn’t canon, the "canon" 2014 map from Sam Wilkinson marks some of the places from the movie on it and Britt Allcroft has said that it is canon.
Wow!! That's so cool that the king at 2:24 looks a lot like King Friday from Mr. Rogers Neighborhood!
6:16 model duck caught on cgi
Good Job Brenner!
I hope that the kids that grow up with this new/4th Thomas time line really like it and grow up to find all the amazing originals.
17:57 We will be sure to see Hiro again if Thomas will visit him at Japan someday
Yep
This is fire! I always wondered when and what happened during all the episodes, I watch this with my younger son but somehow it makes me wanna dig deeper. Keep it up!
9:25 Vicarstown bridge was probably being repaired
Or perhaps it wasn't built?
I doubt that was on Sharon’s mind cause they would have said it otherwise.
Thank you!!! For calling out the reboot being crap!!! It makes no logical sense!!! I hate it with a passion!!! It's so bad it doesn't even deserve it's own ring in hell or in he'll at al!!! It deserves it's own hell where it's tortured by the three other shows for how unrealistic it is!!!
The reboot deserve that
Gordons reaction to all the changes is exactly how I felt
Great video. CGI timeline had a lot of events!
Thank you so much for reuploading all the old videos and still producing videos, I had a dream last night (and I didn’t even know that you have your channel deleted) but in the dream you didn’t reupload your videos and I could never watch them again and I woke up this morning and went to check your channel as quick as possible
I’m glad that dream wasn’t canon to real life.
I don't undertsand why people say CGI series didn't have realistic location and sets. The CGI series has a lot of this things.
Agree
Let’s goo more Unlucky Tug
One of many things I don't like about CGI era is that it didn't utilize character's personal theme song as much as it was in model era where you could tell the characters by just hearing music and it gives them more personality. The other thing I don't like is they hadn't done Emily a justice (but to be fair, she got butchered since series 8).
Series 17 is when she got her original character back.
0:01 *Bertram Jumpscare*
*BAHAHAHAHA*
sir topham hats mom calls him that
Can’t wait til the model era timeline is reuploaded!
This video is all about making sense of a show's timeline which is senseless😂😂. I enjoyed this
So The rws era then model era and now The CGI era, congrats for that The chronological order of the Thomas and Friends from seasons 1 to 24 + movies, WOW just WOW Three eras are both great and amazing
Thomas the Tank Engine Series was one of my oldest childhood memories and since then I love both the models and the CGI. It's a shame that the CGI Thomas and Friends series has coming to the end because I would to see continuing visiting other countries a bit more as he hasn't have a chance to visit American, Germany, France, Mexico, Berlin, and Japan as well as meeting the other engines featuring in "Thomas and Friends The Great Race" like Vinnie, Frieda, Axel, Ivan, Etienne and Carlos. But sadly it's not going to happen now no thanks to Mattel.
10:12 17:04 Non-canon opportunities that are ruined by Thomas
Well I don’t even consider the first one as proof that MIR happened. Misty Island is probably part of Sudrian folklore and the former is from an episode that was supposed to be in season 21 and I see the original version as the canon one.
The CGI timeline is like Thomas in CGI as a whole. Most of the time it’s a bloody mess, but there are times when it makes sense.
Cally's ship looks like the Mayflower
The Royal Navy's finest ship in the sails period might have been the Heavy First Rate Ship of the line (HMS Victory) but that was in the 18th century or 17th century
Common Tug W (sorry about what happened)
Tug W
As much as I and so many more people in the Thomas community hate the CGI series, mainly specific parts of it, I respect the thought and work put into this video.
How dare you hate the cgi series, what about the brenner era?
0:14 456K views?! Well done. Shame it's only 8.2K on the reupload forced by TH-cam and Mattel.
Mattel didn’t do anything
@@tallboiedd2846 ^someone works for Mattel.
If I ran Mattel, I’d make EVERYTHING just perfect as fans would want it, fix every series error and flanderzation, with a few character developments and a slight land edit and EVERY location on Sodor fixed
The model series is referenced multiple times throughout the story, with some events even be recreated, such as Thomas falling into the mine in Down The Mine, and he even recalls the details. Other references to the model series include Duncan recalling pulling an elephant statue from The Runaway Elephant and Rheneas recalling pulling a dinosaur skeleton from Rheneas and the Dinosaur, both from Emily Saves the World. Emily Saves the World actually references many episodes, the others being Paint Pots and Queens, Thomas and the Jet Engine, and Percy and the Magic Carpet. A couple more that I’ll list include Percy Takes a Plunge and the Sad Story of Henry, with the climactic events of both being retold by Percy and Henry, respectively, and also recreated. Just based on this is enough for me to believe that the model and CGI series are in the same continuity.
2:10 before the beginning
8:42 nitrogen/Miller Era
11:09 The Brenner era
15:53 the Bwba Era
6:41 Both Model and CGI a Scarf for Percy
oliver came out of the junkyard in the cgi series! and is mentioned in an episode called toad's adventure
I remember day of the diesels.
I used to watch it after being picked up at school
fyi the events of Donald and Douglas (the signal box smashing) and Twin Trouble are referenced in Emily in the middle, sooo that probably happened sometime when they joined the railway in that weird time period thing
No, it takes place the same year Salty arrives.
@@TheSpongeBobGuy01 thats never confirmed tho, right?
@@ww08 It happened in the same season, so while it's not confirmed, it's more likely than them taking place in different years
It could be that where Thomas had to go on the mainland for logs was more quickly accessible by boat than by going across the bridge
The new thomas will never be as good as the cgi i loved watching it it was a big part of my childhood i remember the movies coming out and they made awesome track master sets after or before the movie
How i understand Gordon in "Forever and ever"😔
I don't think Thomas the Tank Engine would have had nearly the same impact on me if i was growing up with the CGI stuff, instead of the classic series. I get some glimpses of it now that makes me want to take a look, but then they pull the "oh we need to make new toys" moves and turn me completely off the idea.
Is edward a legend or no and edward is my favorite
The HIT and CGI eras deserve to have retcons for their characters and storylines.
if you look at hiro's wheels at 3:54 they aren't moving
I noticed that goof
Misty island isnt fully refrenced in this song but it is hinted at by paxton and Sidney. In the song wheres Thomas? Paxton says "he could have found a secret tunnel to some island thats unkown" sidney replies "how can there be and island around here thats unkown?" "Well what if it was always coverd in mist? Oh that sounds very mist-erious"
The bridge to the mainland probably did not exist so that's why thomas had to be on a ship
We don’t know yet, but if this was true, why ship him over on a little raft behind the ship? That’s so dumb.
@@joshuaW5621 exactly
It's so dumb I don't understand why they put him on a raft being dragged by a ship
What is the reason toby arrives
I think this CGI series was written like most of model series and made little more realistic it would been way way better . Great videos on all these
Probably the bridge was under repair so thats why thomas had to go by boat
for misty island my head canon is that the draw bridge was broken which is why thomas had to go by ship (still makes the movie make no sense but now just a little more)
I doubt the writers had that in mind, but you do you I suppose. I personally don’t consider the movie canon (I know Thomas mentioned Misty Island but I can write that off as being Sudric folklore).
1:58 Im sorry, what?
Blue Mountain mystery
Unlucky tug out of context:
I still think Thomas and Friends CGI timeline is still Cannon to the models timeline
1:28 is that the battersea power station?
Yes
Note: Prince Charles is now King and Queen Elizabeth II you can guess what happened
15:33 16:14 Edward and Henry will return to Tidmouth Sheds and Nia and Rebecca would move to Vicarstown with Rosie because another engine who was send to the mainland in 1998 to do a lot of work there will return to Sodor and move back to Wellsworth with Philip we’ll have to wait and see
BoCo will be in Wellsworth with Philip if he returns to CGI. Also, if we get back to the Brenner era style and old story telling format.
1:58 what was Henry doing???
He is lookin for the workman when hi is brikin up Henry.
His driver is stroking his face trying to comfort him he’s also watching the workmen, the fat controller and his assistants walling him up in his tunnel
Henry is getting bricked up inside the tunnel and has also had his rails taken away so he can’t get out of the tunnel and is stuck there with no way out and after he was bricked up everybody left him in the tunnel all on his own
The wall is only in front of him the tunnel is left open at the back and the rails are still there behind him so he can get out if needed and people can get into the tunnel but he doesn’t know that
The CGI era had some mostly good development for the TV series timeline even though it had some flaws.
I’m pretty sure the model timeline and cgi timeline are connected
Yeah
Yeah they're canonically the same, dunno why Tug thinks they're not
Don’t forget the RWS
How are they connected? I have tk agree with tig though. It doesnt seem right if they are the same.
I think this was confirmed after Tug made his timeline videos.
Just realized at 0:47 The fat cantroller can be seen to the right
You know, I would love to see a CGI version of TATMR, but with better writing, the original villain P.T. Boomer and George the Steamroller.
I'm planning to make that myself with new scenes added to feature The Skarloey engines and Series 5 characters in them with more touch upon like repairs on the railway and other characters appearing, either speaking or cameo.
@@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967 That's great, and I think the characters from Seasons 2-7 and The Railway Series books that never appeared in the CGI series should have speaking roles such as Boco, Bear, Derek, Caroline, Elizabeth, Thumper, Duke, Ivo Hugh, Fred, Arthur, Murdoch and Fergus.
@@dylanlyles9453 Well, it would take place between Series 5 and 6 but as for featuring BoCo, Thumper, Caroline, sure.
If you think about it really well, no, that season 18 episode did NOT happen in Tale of the Brave. Here is my evidence.
In Tale of the Brave, Gator goes to the Fenland and says that he is sorry for giving James a fright. Although, in the episode, Gator just keeps going when the signal turns green.
Thus, Gators lamp just goes out twice and James is a total scaredy cat that shouldn't be making fun of Percy when he got scared of Gator twice in a row. Unlucky Tug, I know you and other people probably won't read this, but I just wanted to say this to clarify things. His ship is also delayed twice.
I don't think vicarstown bridge happened in misty island rescue
What do you mean the bridge didn’t happen? What kind of grammar is that?
Excuse me, but Misty Island rescue was released in 2010. I used to be afraid of it when I was a little kid but now I just think it’s special and it’s on Prime Video today too.
I was gonna point out Big Mickey from Tugs, but you say it enough that when it’s referenced, it’s canon, then it makes sense Tugs never happened anyway 😂
20:43 We’re not going to have a fourth timeline like this because one of Donald Trump’s team is going to make a fourth timeline in the future CGI series very soon
Yea, making the fourth timeline would be a big mess.
Ha nice loop hole (I mean I like how he’s considering century but said no years) that’s a good one (I actually didn’t realize that until recently)
WTF did the fat controller make a bullet train locomotive pull goods.
Imagine putting all 3 of these timelines together somehow (including magic railroad). That would be a mess. Lol
God, I'm so glad I fell out of love with the Thomas series partway through the model series.
But I must admit through your videos that I'm getting the urge to watch more of the seasons I skipped.
But let's face it, I'll happily stick to the first 26 books as my canon.
I actually have a head cannon that everything after the BWBA movie, is in present day, and that would make Marvelous machinery, make a lot more sense
AND: The internation episodes and the BWBA movie take place at the same time, its a lot of not showing, showing, and a WHOLE lot of no nia, but if you shape every clip in a certain manner, it can just about work
And here's' my timeline:
Seasons 13-16: 1950's
Seasons 17-21 1980's
Seasons 22-onwards: Modren day (Excluding TRE)
Then what about middle aged Queen Elizabeth and young Prince Charles?
@@pukenmg284 Simple, TRE takes place much earlier
What about Kenji being labeled as the fastest engine in the world when he's pretty slow for an electric engine, and an oudated design of Shinkansen?
@@Zynderion117this is why I don’t consider most of BWBA canon.
Fun fact: you actually CAN hear how Thomas returns from his second world tour… through the form of an official ASMR story on a sleep app called CALM! (It sucks ass tho) basically, Thomas comes home but gets sad no ones talking to him, turns out… everyone planed him a surprise party. YaAaAy
Well, sounds more interesting than anything Sharon Miller wrote.
Small victories, I guess
As for the Magic Railroad. If I remember correctly, and don’t quote me on this, Lady is seen later on Sodor in either the classic or CGI timeline, making the events of the movie canon to one of them.
Calling all engines movie which is part of the model series timeline which is what you’re thinking of
Misty island is special
I totally love how you skipped some things
Fun Fact: There is no such thing as a model series continuity or a CGI series continuity its one continuity and always has been. This is a common misconception I keep seeing when its very obvious its all one timeline for the TV series.
I think this was confirmed after this video came out.
@@joshuaW5621 It was confirmed before it too
When Thomas first went to Misty island, he thought it was strange too but now he just thinks it’s special
I like to think that the events in the CGI series are out of order, simply because of the inconsistencies. In canon, it has a drifting timeline so it literally doesn't matter. But being Autistic, realism and timelines matter for me. The RWS has a timeline though. It's fascinating how fans are able to get around with the CGI's continuity problem.
Timelines of TTTE:
1. Railway Series (Books 1-42 and the Island of Sodor book) 1945-2005
2. Model Era (Season 1-12) 1984-2008
3. CGI Series (Season 13-24) 2009-2020
4. All Engines Go/Anime Series (Season 25-32) 2021-2026?
5. Jayden The Locomotive/My Timeline (Season 1-13) 2027-2038
Model and CGI are the same timeline
@@Kukaak
I was talking about the years these timelines went through in releases.
The vicarstown bridge is neither seen or mentioned in the Miller era
Doesn’t automatically mean it didn’t exist before the Brenner era.
Misty Island Rescue makes BWBA the Movie look like a Railway documentary by comparison
9:23 ''He Goes Via Ship When There's a Railway Drawbridge To The Mainland''
Maybe it's because the Vicarstown Bridge was Broken at the time.
I doubt that was on Sharon Miller’s mind when she wrote this movie, otherwise they would’ve likely mentioned it.
If I have to choose one Thomas series, it’ll always be The Railway Series
15:02 I thought you were going to mention something about the line " you look as splendid as the day I built you" from the same episode,
might not have been the word Splendid
The way you make the argument that all 3 canons are the same is by using Awdry's BS statement from the IoS book that not all the footage/illustrations are accurate to the actual events, like NWR1991 did with NWR Tales.
I’m not sure if I’m correct but why does Thomas always want to go to the mainland even though he’s ACTUALLY from the mainland
He hasn't been there for several decades and he has only seen a small part of it when he was there
oh yeah the adventure begins gets all of the attention
My Thomas and friends universe is a hybrid of all of the three timelines
19:05 now there's a 4th one AEG also known as All Engines Go
What does cgi stands for?
Computer-Generated Imagery
Computer-generated imagery.
You mean to tell me that in this universe... theirs not just talking trains, but talking cars too? Bruh
Exis me when I was little I used to be scared of misty island rescue but now I love it
Timelines? Multiple versions? Paradoxes? What is this, Dr. Strange?
Rip queen elizabth
Trust me AEG Is Worst Than Misty Island Rescue