At the very least, The Luminous Mysteries can be prayed as a Chaplet if someone doesn't want to break with the Rosary as the Psalter of the Blessed Virgin Mary. However, the Luminous Mysteries really do fill out the Life of Christ aspect of the Rosary. I am happy you reviewed this Pocket Guide because it made me aware that there are additional prayers included that can be added on to the Rosary. I also agree with you that the artwork is excellent. A picture paints a thousand, as they say. The artwork can assist one's meditation when praying the Rosary.
I bought this shortly after I started praying the rosary a couple of years ago. I loved it quite a bit, and still use it. I particularly like to use it for the Glorious Mysteries. I've just begun OCIA and I definitely agree that this book is a great buy for a convert. It's a good introduction to some of the Marian typology. I found the prayers in the back particularly useful. I'm not as enthused about the art work as you were, but I do like the black & white/clean lines aspect of it. If someone wanted a next-step (and thorough) examination of the typology, I'd recommend Brant Pitre's book _Jesus And The Jewish Roots of Mary: Unveiling The Mother of The Messiah_.
The story about the Muslim and the Holy Eucharist most likely came from an article by Peter Kreeft entitled, _What I Learned From A Muslim About Eucharistic Adoration,_ The article can be read on the *Catholic Culture* website.
As I expect you know, Professor Kreeft told the same story but with more or fewer details. My intent was not to give the impression that the story was an ever-changing excursion into the world of fantasy. However the story is a favorite of his, for the obvious reason, it gives proper emphasis to how precious the sacrament of communion is
I'd say that the book contains very useful study or reflective study on mysteries. However, I think using it for meditating before the prayers is too lengthy and disruptive. The meditation guide should be a scripture passage to support the mystery and while praying the Hail Mary's contemplating on the mystery or scripture passage, not wondering your mind too much on how to emulate Mary - that's more of a reflective kind of meditation. I prefer deep contemplative meditation when praying the Rosary. Otherwise, the descriptive passages for each mystery are very useful for reflection. Our Lady did say to spend time meditating on all of the mysteries separate to the prayers too. That seems to be overlooked.
I am currently a Protestant that God has called overwhelmingly to look into the Catholic faith. I have been very interested in buying this pocket guide but have been somewhat hesitant as I have not seen many good reviews of the actual contents of it (other than the obvious overall topic and the tie to Matt and Pints with Aquinas). It is definitely going on my Christmas list after watching your review. Thank you and God bless❤
I'm a former protestant who is preparing to enter the Catholic Church, and I'd recommend this book. Not sure how far along you are, but I've also found Joe Heschmeyer's work extremely helpful. His book _The Early Church Was The Catholic Church_ really knocked down most of my objections.
Reasonable review. That Rosary beads picture looks inaccurate! The Glory Be is not said on a bead. And the Our Father is not said on the Hail Holy Queen medal.
@ConvincedCatholicism enough to mislead! Makes me wonder how many other flaws the book has. I'd recommend reviewing some other Rosary books. One that you might be keen to explore is called the Liturgical Rosary. This is based on the traditional Divine Office and scriptures. Others you could review would be scriptural Rosary books. Or these: Father Peyton's Rosary Prayer Book: The Family That Prays Together Stays Together, Rosary Warfare: Methods of Praying the Rosary with Fruit, Praying a Scriptural Rosary by CTS. But I'm definitely curious as to what's included in Taylor Marshall book on the Rosary. Those three I mentioned - I decided to purchase these. I would definitely consider The Liturgical Rosary some time but the price is a little too steep for me at this time.
@@deusvult8340 That's true. I read somewhere that the second part was added during the plague (1350-ish), hence the addition, "in the hour of our death", which seemed immanent to many at the time. I think the book I read it in was _Champions of the Rosary_ , by Fr. Donald Calloway. Which is an excellent book.
@@deusvult8340are you claiming that the Rosary that was introduced by Mary to St. Dominic only contained the first half of the Hail Mary? And were all of the 15 mysteries meant to be prayed in one sitting per day, or was it supposed to be 5 mysteries alternating each day?
At the very least, The Luminous Mysteries can be prayed as a Chaplet if someone doesn't want to break with the Rosary as the Psalter of the Blessed Virgin Mary.
However, the Luminous Mysteries really do fill out the Life of Christ aspect of the Rosary.
I am happy you reviewed this Pocket Guide because it made me aware that there are additional prayers included that can be added on to the Rosary.
I also agree with you that the artwork is excellent. A picture paints a thousand, as they say. The artwork can assist one's meditation when praying the Rosary.
Yes the imagery certainly elevates the book and the prayer.
Thanks for making this video! And thank you for taking in my suggestion! I really appreciate it.
I definitely appreciate your idea
I bought this shortly after I started praying the rosary a couple of years ago. I loved it quite a bit, and still use it. I particularly like to use it for the Glorious Mysteries. I've just begun OCIA and I definitely agree that this book is a great buy for a convert. It's a good introduction to some of the Marian typology. I found the prayers in the back particularly useful. I'm not as enthused about the art work as you were, but I do like the black & white/clean lines aspect of it. If someone wanted a next-step (and thorough) examination of the typology, I'd recommend Brant Pitre's book _Jesus And The Jewish Roots of Mary: Unveiling The Mother of The Messiah_.
That is awesome to hear!
Just read that book by Brant Pitre, amazing book!
I would use Ascension's Rosary booklet as a First Saturday aide. (Pls do a review of the Marian Press' Rosary booklet)
@@KJSCalderon I will look into it
The story about the Muslim and the Holy Eucharist most likely came from an article by Peter Kreeft entitled, _What I Learned From A Muslim About Eucharistic Adoration,_ The article can be read on the *Catholic Culture* website.
So which version is the true version? If there is a true version
As I expect you know, Professor Kreeft told the same story but with more or fewer details. My intent was not to give the impression that the story was an ever-changing excursion into the world of fantasy. However the story is a favorite of his, for the obvious reason, it gives proper emphasis to how precious the sacrament of communion is
How's this book compare to other Rosary books, such as Taylor Marshall's book? Or from a more Traditionalists perspective?
I haven't really taken a look at Dr. Marshall's book
I am predictable, eh? Ironically, I am expecting a book from CB tomorrow or the next day.
Looking forward to a possible review
I'd say that the book contains very useful study or reflective study on mysteries. However, I think using it for meditating before the prayers is too lengthy and disruptive. The meditation guide should be a scripture passage to support the mystery and while praying the Hail Mary's contemplating on the mystery or scripture passage, not wondering your mind too much on how to emulate Mary - that's more of a reflective kind of meditation. I prefer deep contemplative meditation when praying the Rosary. Otherwise, the descriptive passages for each mystery are very useful for reflection. Our Lady did say to spend time meditating on all of the mysteries separate to the prayers too. That seems to be overlooked.
Hello I'm a fan
I am currently a Protestant that God has called overwhelmingly to look into the Catholic faith. I have been very interested in buying this pocket guide but have been somewhat hesitant as I have not seen many good reviews of the actual contents of it (other than the obvious overall topic and the tie to Matt and Pints with Aquinas). It is definitely going on my Christmas list after watching your review. Thank you and God bless❤
God bless! Hope your journey goes well
I'm a former protestant who is preparing to enter the Catholic Church, and I'd recommend this book. Not sure how far along you are, but I've also found Joe Heschmeyer's work extremely helpful. His book _The Early Church Was The Catholic Church_ really knocked down most of my objections.
Reasonable review. That Rosary beads picture looks inaccurate! The Glory Be is not said on a bead. And the Our Father is not said on the Hail Holy Queen medal.
I think the number was poorly placed and I think they group the glory be with other prayers for convenience
@ConvincedCatholicism enough to mislead! Makes me wonder how many other flaws the book has. I'd recommend reviewing some other Rosary books. One that you might be keen to explore is called the Liturgical Rosary. This is based on the traditional Divine Office and scriptures. Others you could review would be scriptural Rosary books. Or these: Father Peyton's Rosary Prayer Book: The Family That Prays Together Stays Together, Rosary Warfare: Methods of Praying the Rosary with Fruit, Praying a Scriptural Rosary by CTS. But I'm definitely curious as to what's included in Taylor Marshall book on the Rosary. Those three I mentioned - I decided to purchase these. I would definitely consider The Liturgical Rosary some time but the price is a little too steep for me at this time.
Have you thought about doing an actual Rosary review?
I have. I have a Rugged Rosary somewhere. I may review that
@@ConvincedCatholicismRugged Rosaries are great 📿👍
Lovely video, but comparing the art to that from Catholic Book is setting the bar very low.
I was hoping the comparison would catch your attention haha
Their is a BIG difference between the traditional vs new rosary. Do your own research but the traditional is more rewarding than the new.
Besides one new set of mysteries how is it different?
The most ancient versions only have the angelic salutation and our father. Anything else is an addition
@@deusvult8340 That's true. I read somewhere that the second part was added during the plague (1350-ish), hence the addition, "in the hour of our death", which seemed immanent to many at the time. I think the book I read it in was _Champions of the Rosary_ , by Fr. Donald Calloway. Which is an excellent book.
@@DavidWilson-hd6iz From what I heard the only addition was the name of Jesus as the fruit of her womb
@@deusvult8340are you claiming that the Rosary that was introduced by Mary to St. Dominic only contained the first half of the Hail Mary? And were all of the 15 mysteries meant to be prayed in one sitting per day, or was it supposed to be 5 mysteries alternating each day?