Omg so true! I hadn’t even thought of that & IM A HUFFLEPUFF!🤣 but can confirm, we are EXCELLENT at finding things! No joke I’m the finder of missing things in my house 😅
@rowenaravenclaw6741 Its from a very potter musical. The first play i think. Cedric says "hufflepuffs are particularly good finders" with an energetic smile, to which Dumbledore answers "what the h*ll is a hufflepuff?"
I like to imagine that every time the secondary prophecy about the dark Lord's servant occurs but Peter is captured or stopped, and therefore presumably ending the prophecy, it just cuts to Barty Crouch Jr doing the Bully Miguire dance out of where he was kept prisoner by his father and winky.
@@batlord7690 *Also, don't forget that those in Azkaban have been there for **_thirteen_** years, not twelve, the reason the prophecy fits Barty Jr is because he was broken out of Azkaban after a year and he has been **_"chained"_** by the Imperius Curse.*
@@takumi2023 my first reaction is to disagree, but i won't. I think most of my appreciation is from seeing the novel brought to life, and not because of the actual quality of the film.
He’s an amazing actor and puts so much emotion behind his acting. I heard the reason they muted his screams after Sirius passes is because Emma and Bonnie couldn’t watch it without crying
I can only imagine the wizards' therapy Ron and Percy both would have needed after finding out that each of them were unknowingly sleeping with a thirty-year-old man for years on end.
now lets take a step back, he quite literally couldn't have been a thirty something year old for twelve whole years, Percy slept with a late twenty year old rat man for some of that.
And last time they did What if Harry were in Slytherin, they added the art that subscribers and people made. I'm no artist myself, but I'd love to see some Ron in Hufflepuff stuff!
A very fun “What If?” that I think would change so much of the original story; What if Regulus Black had lived? Because it would confirm Dumbledore suspicions about horcruxs sooner plus would have started the hunt for them faster as well. Would Regulus have taken Snape role as the double agent as well?
REST IN PEACE to Dame Maggie Smith, aka Professor Minerva McGonagall, she just passed away this morning (09/27). A Legend to be remembered for years to come.
I think it’s harder for him in this story because unlike in the normal story losing his parents didn’t result in him having a miserable childhood. He had brothers a sister a childhood filled with magic & love. I think this will pay off in order of the phoenix when he can throw of voly quicker but for the dementors I think hearing his mother scream and experiencing her death when the dementors are around effects him much more because his childhood was so full of happiness and wonderful memories. He’s not used to the despair and feelings the dementors make him feel
Here’s the thing, I don’t think Sirius would extend Harry an offer to live with him. I think one of the main reasons he offers in the main story line is because Sirius had been watching Harry at the Dursleys all summer. I think seeing how happy Harry is at the burrow, Sirius may not extend the same offer.
@@LonKirk I was thinking neighbours, what with how crowded The Burrow was. He had enough for a Firebolt, he can probably afford a cozy cottage near the Weasleys with whatever remained. I can see a bit with Mrs. Weasley feeling a bit insecure, and Harry reassuring her that she's his mum as much as his biological mum is.
Sirius seems surprised about Harry wanting to join him in the main story. I don't think he offered because he saw how bad the Dursley's were treating Harry. He offered because one he wouldn't be alone and two he would be able to full fill his role of godfather.
Well it’s kinda sure it is barty, because like for every situation like this before it was barty, they even did a vid on why he would for the prophecy, I think
Man I love this series! One quick comment though, as someone with adopted siblings, most people in the adoption community prefer the term “biological parents” to “real parents”. Adopted parents are still real parents! ❤️
It would be neat if Sirius moved in with the Weasleys, or into a home in the neighborhood. (Surely Bill and/or Charlie left a room vacant when they moved out?) Part of me wants this because he and the twins would get along phenomenally, and then he can offer to invest in their joke shop.
So Lucius is fuming but sees it as opportunity for him to get close to Harry. Malfoy ends up losing not of his friends as is pitted as traitor by those like Crab and Goyle. However the story would play out similar to harry in Slytherin but with Malfoy becoming one of the group, essentially turning Malfoy into Sirius, Hermione is Lucius without the curse, Ron becomes Peter without being cowardly and Harry is a non bully version of James. What be interesting is then when Voldemort returns and his family dynamics. 😅 Oh and if he gets with Hermione... Or worse Ginny! 😂 A Malfoy and a Weasley!
Even more so if you think about it, during book 2 Malfoy would know about the chamber but not be suspect this time, able to help the trio, he might even help save Ginny... Feeling guilty it was his dad he might try and make it up to her, starting their relationship. His father disapproval ships it even more as he rebels against him
I like to think in the books it takes so long for the Firebolt to come back because all of the teachers want to have a go on it 🤣 after they realize in 5 minutes it isn’t jinxed 😄
@@joimumu , in the movie, Harry says that, while Voldemort feels the horcruxes getting destroyed, they aren't making him weaker. "If anything, he feels more dangerous."
She's a Ravenclaw one year behind. Apart from being occasionly in the same class as Ginny (who they interact with about as little as in the main timeline) they have no connection to her. But don't worry, they'll meet her at the beginning of 5th year like usually. (And they're going to ship her with Ron too, I bet.)
It just occurred to me that the Quidditch Cup point system is kind of tilted towards the team(s) in the final match. If still in the running, they KNOW how many points they need to win.
@@atafakheri8659Not in a league system. In every major football (soccer) league all matches of the last matchday are played at the same time to avoid this very issue. It is the same in the group stage of the worldcup for example.
@@Nico-wg5jo That's part of the reason I dislike the format of the Six Nations (rugby) they stagger the matches for TV, so if the championship is still on the line at the time of the last game, the teams know what's required.
I’ve been feasting on HP content between this series and Through the Griffin Door and it’s been doing so much healing about the pitfalls of the wizarding world! I really love where this series is going!
Hilarious ad timing. 18:56 ". . . a large silver *ad starts for a Nissan Rogue, which happened to be silver.*" All these what-if episodes are very interesting and well thought out, cool to see Hufflepuff being more prominent in the story this way too!
Honestly Ron being a Keeper versus Harry as a Seeker is just the worst, like no matter how many goals you block he might just catch the snitch and then nothing you did matters.
I see it more as, they can both do a phenomenal performance in their respective roles, since they don't overlap. It's just that Harry's role is more important overall (again).
Yeah I think Hermione and Ron would have gotten closer because of that situation. Honestly I'm surprised that Ron and Hermione didn't both try to tell McGonagle at the same time.
Another what if idea I've been pondering lately is, What If Snape was nice to/liked Harry? Like what if instead of seeing Harry as just a copy of his father, like he already does, he sees all the similarities to Lily instead? What would have to change in the story to get Snape to view Harry this way? How would that impact Harry's time and performance in Potions with Snape as the teacher? How would the interactions Harry has with Draco change? How would both Harry and Snape's interactions with Lupin and Sirius change? Would Snape be able to successfully infiltrate the Deatheaters if a more friendly demeanor towards Harry was common knowledge?
Could you eventually do "What If Ginny was sorted into Slytherin?" I think I've come up with a way she can get sorted into Slytherin: Charlie catches her sneaking into the quidditch supply which makes him train her and it fuels her ambition to be a professional quidditch player, so she's even more determined and ambitious so she gets sorted into Slytherin.
Hmm I suppose Trelawny’s prediction could just as easily apply to Barty Crouch Jr., who, based on the timeline of Book 4, would have gotten out of Azkaban about the same time as Pettigrew escaped.
I love the change of patronus from Terrier to Badger considering he no longer has the connection to Hermoine but instead so many warm memories of Hufflepuff house
Loving this series and cant wait to see where things go from here. Hearing this happier childhood does make me wonder, what if Snape hadn't overheard the prophecy?
With Sirius being announced innocent, I would like to believe that Harry still stay with the Weasleys but meets up with Sirius now and then. There's not much reasoning for Harry to move out of the Burrow when that is a happy life for him. so i hope you don't force that into the story.
I agree, he's got a happy settled life and it wouldn't make sense to move in with someone he hardly knows. He might spend a week but for the most part Molly and Arthur are his parents
*in my Lockhart voice* Benny… Benny… Benny… Helga Hufflepuff could not possibly allow gingers in her house… they would clash with the uniforms. 😀 But no, seriously, can you imagine how bad Barty Crouch Sr. would have looked had Sirius been found innocent; considering that he sent him to Azkaban without a trial? I don’t think it’ll matter in this theory however, because I think Barty Jr. is the servant that will rescue Voldemort, meaning that he might kill dad first.
@@joimumu I could see the Dursleys no longer so against magic if their Diddykins was a wizard and I believe things would either go much better or a LOT worse.
Yeah unless they began to shun Dudley for him having odd mishaps earlier in life and they realized he was magic like Harry, then maybe they would have been more bonded over their tough life at home. I don’t know if this would actually happen tho and I honestly think it could go either way. Maybe they do spoil him out of it and train in him their ways while they try the other approach with Harry, they could even maybe stop Dudley from going to hogwarts and maybe he’d form an obscuris so as to try and prevent being mistreated the way Harry was.???? Idk what are y’all’s thoughts
Finally Ron getting some shine, i really cant wait for ron to keep shining, maybe even ask hermione to the yule ball. Since this time there wont be the pride aspect
Great question personally I preferred the format the the what if Harry was in Slytherin with longer episodes… and you know, the 7th one split up because this kinda hurts my brain but it’s still great work
Ah, I really liked this episode! I'm glad Ron's getting his time to shine. Cannot wait for my personal favorite villain, Barty Crouch Jr. to make his appearance ❤❤❤
In the second year match against Slytherin Draco has the better broom and yet Harry catches the Snitch. Better equipment is a huge advantage, but it's not everything.
@chcucivtxzclccucifudohzfu6766 in book 3 it's mentioned that the Irish all had one and they are now favorites for the world cup kind of implying they are one of the only ones to have one
Harry and Ron surrendering the map to a suitable authority figure in a time of crisis! What's next? Harry being able to use the invisibility cloak without getting caught by Peeves, Snape, Filch, Mrs. Norris, or some random passing house elf? In all seriousness, Harry giving the map up to protect Ron whereas he wouldn't give it up to protect himself makes a weird amount of sense. Although you'd have thought he might have spent more time looking at the map in the 3rd book anyway to see if Black was somewhere on the grounds, though I suppose that would be an enormous amount of space to search.
dont wanna nag, am sure youre very busy but i wanna encourage u to keep working on this series as its really good and Im really looking forward to the rest of it. in your own time of course, no rush, im not desperate or anything, lol.
It's so exciting to see these every week! Love that Sirius is innocent, but I assume that means the servant that returns to Voldemort won't be Peter Pettigrew, rather Barty Crouch jr...
Nice series 👍 after all the house switching may U try to do a Grindelwald and Voldemort character swap? Only suggestion though, and I'm just happy if U continue posting
What if the prophecy shifts from Wormtail to Crouch Jr.? When Jr. finds out Wormtail is still alive, he breaks free of his father's imperius and goes to find his master!
This what if is just pure fan fiction. The fact you guys had to make so many logic leaps in this one with Harry being adopted to get Ron in hufflepuff, making Harry wear a hufflepuff badge so Sirius still looks like he’s after Harry, it’s very stretchy 😅😂
@@Axoguy13 harry and luna, ron and hermione, neville and ginny, could happen but i think theyll just go with harrmione especially with ben being a harmione and runa shipper
Peter never had a chance of escaping.
Everyone knows that Hufflepuffs are great at finding things. 😂
Omg so true! I hadn’t even thought of that & IM A HUFFLEPUFF!🤣 but can confirm, we are EXCELLENT at finding things! No joke I’m the finder of missing things in my house 😅
You are the founder of hufflepuff 😂
We are particularly good FINDERS
help, I know this joke/reference but can't remeber where it's from. It's hilarious to see it again
@rowenaravenclaw6741 Its from a very potter musical. The first play i think. Cedric says "hufflepuffs are particularly good finders" with an energetic smile, to which Dumbledore answers "what the h*ll is a hufflepuff?"
I like to imagine that every time the secondary prophecy about the dark Lord's servant occurs but Peter is captured or stopped, and therefore presumably ending the prophecy, it just cuts to Barty Crouch Jr doing the Bully Miguire dance out of where he was kept prisoner by his father and winky.
That is the way.
How else? 😂
It literally couldn't be anyone else, all of Tom's other servants are either in Azkaban or vehemently denying their involvement with him.
@@ericgarcia3802 *Absolutely. Super Carlin Brothers has already explored this scenario in a what if video*
@@batlord7690 *Also, don't forget that those in Azkaban have been there for **_thirteen_** years, not twelve, the reason the prophecy fits Barty Jr is because he was broken out of Azkaban after a year and he has been **_"chained"_** by the Imperius Curse.*
Daniel Radcliffe screaming Expecto Patronum at the end of the film never fails to give me chills. Don't know why. It just does.
For me, the chills come from how cringy it is. But that's just me. It always felt too forced and insincere dont know why.
@@takumi2023 my first reaction is to disagree, but i won't. I think most of my appreciation is from seeing the novel brought to life, and not because of the actual quality of the film.
@ailynrenee1796 i did enjoy the books. I still reread them from time to time for nostalgia, especially when i get sick.
Same here
He’s an amazing actor and puts so much emotion behind his acting.
I heard the reason they muted his screams after Sirius passes is because Emma and Bonnie couldn’t watch it without crying
I can only imagine the wizards' therapy Ron and Percy both would have needed after finding out that each of them were unknowingly sleeping with a thirty-year-old man for years on end.
Nothing a little memory modification can't fix.
now lets take a step back, he quite literally couldn't have been a thirty something year old for twelve whole years, Percy slept with a late twenty year old rat man for some of that.
Let's be honest, I doubt wizards even have therapy....
@@Lordpooz09if they did ol Voldy needed it 😅
yeah, peter probably needs it too for how uncomfortable that must've been.
I hope this series gets edited into a full-blown master cut afterwards, because I'd like to relisten the whole story after it's completed
And last time they did What if Harry were in Slytherin, they added the art that subscribers and people made. I'm no artist myself, but I'd love to see some Ron in Hufflepuff stuff!
I'm sure they will but it will be in their Playlist, if they don't
Right? Like I’ve been just going around and re-watching each individual video as a new installment comes out
@@wiidasander9626 Yes! It was so good to see all the art
A very fun “What If?” that I think would change so much of the original story; What if Regulus Black had lived?
Because it would confirm Dumbledore suspicions about horcruxs sooner plus would have started the hunt for them faster as well. Would Regulus have taken Snape role as the double agent as well?
I've been asking for the same thing.
"What If Regulus Black Survived?"
That's a good what if idea
Ooooohhh, that's an intriguing idea!!!
REST IN PEACE to Dame Maggie Smith, aka Professor Minerva McGonagall, she just passed away this morning (09/27).
A Legend to be remembered for years to come.
Fun fact: Harry would have more good memories with the Weasleys than the Dursleys to produce a Patronus.
I think it’s harder for him in this story because unlike in the normal story losing his parents didn’t result in him having a miserable childhood. He had brothers a sister a childhood filled with magic & love. I think this will pay off in order of the phoenix when he can throw of voly quicker but for the dementors I think hearing his mother scream and experiencing her death when the dementors are around effects him much more because his childhood was so full of happiness and wonderful memories. He’s not used to the despair and feelings the dementors make him feel
@@melissaferguson7630 He still lost his parents. The dursleys weren't really that bad compared to the loss of his biological parents.
I’ve… BEN waiting for this all week.
Good one
👏👏👏Nicely done!
Here’s the thing, I don’t think Sirius would extend Harry an offer to live with him. I think one of the main reasons he offers in the main story line is because Sirius had been watching Harry at the Dursleys all summer. I think seeing how happy Harry is at the burrow, Sirius may not extend the same offer.
I see a freed Sirius living with the Weasleys paying his and Harry's way. With Lupin coming to visit.
Yeah I can see them more so being invited over for sleepovers
@@LonKirk I was thinking neighbours, what with how crowded The Burrow was. He had enough for a Firebolt, he can probably afford a cozy cottage near the Weasleys with whatever remained.
I can see a bit with Mrs. Weasley feeling a bit insecure, and Harry reassuring her that she's his mum as much as his biological mum is.
@@ThatSoddingGamer I think you have got that about right. I agree.
Sirius seems surprised about Harry wanting to join him in the main story. I don't think he offered because he saw how bad the Dursley's were treating Harry. He offered because one he wouldn't be alone and two he would be able to full fill his role of godfather.
I’m guessing the escaped servant is Barty Crouch Jr. Look forward to seeing how that plays out next week!
Well it’s kinda sure it is barty, because like for every situation like this before it was barty, they even did a vid on why he would for the prophecy, I think
"Harry meets up with Neville who's waiting for him at the bottom of the silver ladder...Dead"
that joke will never get old
@@lucasM005neither will Neville.
Man I love this series! One quick comment though, as someone with adopted siblings, most people in the adoption community prefer the term “biological parents” to “real parents”. Adopted parents are still real parents! ❤️
This is only getting better. Can’t wait for the “What If Hermione was in Ravenclaw” timeline!
I didn’t think Pettigrew would be caught!! That was such a fun twist!! Good job, Ron 👏
Definitely like the extra Ron props in this version. It's also very much in keeping with the series' theme of love, friendship, and family.
And Neville! So glad he got his moment in catching Scabbers there, too bad it got him siriusly injured.
It would be neat if Sirius moved in with the Weasleys, or into a home in the neighborhood. (Surely Bill and/or Charlie left a room vacant when they moved out?) Part of me wants this because he and the twins would get along phenomenally, and then he can offer to invest in their joke shop.
I can imagine how devastated Ron will be when Cedric dies
IF he dies, maybe he survives this version
Or he dies later
We'll see about that
I love this series. Another video idea: What if Draco was in Gryffindor?
Yesssss please make this happen!!!!!!!!
So Lucius is fuming but sees it as opportunity for him to get close to Harry. Malfoy ends up losing not of his friends as is pitted as traitor by those like Crab and Goyle. However the story would play out similar to harry in Slytherin but with Malfoy becoming one of the group, essentially turning Malfoy into Sirius, Hermione is Lucius without the curse, Ron becomes Peter without being cowardly and Harry is a non bully version of James.
What be interesting is then when Voldemort returns and his family dynamics. 😅 Oh and if he gets with Hermione... Or worse Ginny! 😂 A Malfoy and a Weasley!
Even more so if you think about it, during book 2 Malfoy would know about the chamber but not be suspect this time, able to help the trio, he might even help save Ginny... Feeling guilty it was his dad he might try and make it up to her, starting their relationship. His father disapproval ships it even more as he rebels against him
I love how much attention you pay to Quiditch 😂 also Ron with badger patronus is really nice change
I like to think in the books it takes so long for the Firebolt to come back because all of the teachers want to have a go on it 🤣 after they realize in 5 minutes it isn’t jinxed 😄
Recommendation: What if Lucius Malfoy never gave the diary to Ginny Weasley?
Dumbledore never figures out the Horcruxes, and even if he did, he would never find the diary to destroy it.
@@coolnerdlll6053 I believe Voldemort lost 1/7 of his power when that diary got destroyed so that would tipped scale in the graveyard in his favor
@@joimumu , in the movie, Harry says that, while Voldemort feels the horcruxes getting destroyed, they aren't making him weaker. "If anything, he feels more dangerous."
he'd probably plant it on a different weasley.
@sash9868 Do you mean the Lucius Malfoy never gave away the diary? Or gave it to someone else?
I like to imagine that Neville would be a great rat catcher. Surprised Luna has still not made an entrance yet.
She's a Ravenclaw one year behind. Apart from being occasionly in the same class as Ginny (who they interact with about as little as in the main timeline) they have no connection to her. But don't worry, they'll meet her at the beginning of 5th year like usually. (And they're going to ship her with Ron too, I bet.)
The suspense is killing me as we wait for the next part!
We need part 5 it's been 12 days since part 4
Anyone else get scooby doo vibes from that lupin is a werewolf line 😂 I loved it.
ZOINKS! Come on, Scoob! The noseless freak is gonna get us!
It just occurred to me that the Quidditch Cup point system is kind of tilted towards the team(s) in the final match. If still in the running, they KNOW how many points they need to win.
That is litteraly any sports cup
@@atafakheri8659Not in a league system. In every major football (soccer) league all matches of the last matchday are played at the same time to avoid this very issue. It is the same in the group stage of the worldcup for example.
@@Nico-wg5jo That's part of the reason I dislike the format of the Six Nations (rugby) they stagger the matches for TV, so if the championship is still on the line at the time of the last game, the teams know what's required.
Your what-if theories are incredible. I don't care how far-fetched the idea is, I love hearing you guys talk about it
I’ve been feasting on HP content between this series and Through the Griffin Door and it’s been doing so much healing about the pitfalls of the wizarding world! I really love where this series is going!
Hilarious ad timing. 18:56 ". . . a large silver *ad starts for a Nissan Rogue, which happened to be silver.*"
All these what-if episodes are very interesting and well thought out, cool to see Hufflepuff being more prominent in the story this way too!
As a hufflepuff I agree
I freaking love these, almost more than the canon... especially when you right a wrong that I've took personally lol.
I love that even though Ron’s in Hufflepuff he, Harry and Hermione are still close friends
I'm going to watch this video soon, but I'm BEYOND STOKED that another "What if......?" episode. Ben and Jonathan, keep up the good work!
Honestly Ron being a Keeper versus Harry as a Seeker is just the worst,
like no matter how many goals you block he might just catch the snitch and then nothing you did matters.
I see it more as, they can both do a phenomenal performance in their respective roles, since they don't overlap. It's just that Harry's role is more important overall (again).
My only concern is I don't think Hermione would support harry in the fire bolt situation
Yes, I have agree.
Yeah I think Hermione and Ron would have gotten closer because of that situation. Honestly I'm surprised that Ron and Hermione didn't both try to tell McGonagle at the same time.
This is probably my favorite theory they have done
Another what if idea I've been pondering lately is, What If Snape was nice to/liked Harry? Like what if instead of seeing Harry as just a copy of his father, like he already does, he sees all the similarities to Lily instead? What would have to change in the story to get Snape to view Harry this way? How would that impact Harry's time and performance in Potions with Snape as the teacher? How would the interactions Harry has with Draco change? How would both Harry and Snape's interactions with Lupin and Sirius change? Would Snape be able to successfully infiltrate the Deatheaters if a more friendly demeanor towards Harry was common knowledge?
The perfect timing, I'm halfway my day of work and was hoping for something to play in the background.
Could you eventually do "What If Ginny was sorted into Slytherin?" I think I've come up with a way she can get sorted into Slytherin: Charlie catches her sneaking into the quidditch supply which makes him train her and it fuels her ambition to be a professional quidditch player, so she's even more determined and ambitious so she gets sorted into Slytherin.
Been waiting all week for this!
this is becoming a really really good series
I love it when you guys make “what if” series, but waiting for each episode is so hard 😔🫶🏽
So do you want rushed videos or long awaited good videos?
Well in a perfect world you’d have neither but you know …
So hard to wait that I always tap the box with the "next episode" on screen! Just incase it has been a week & I was sleeping or in a coma😂!
@@marshawargo7238 so do i
Hmm I suppose Trelawny’s prediction could just as easily apply to Barty Crouch Jr., who, based on the timeline of Book 4, would have gotten out of Azkaban about the same time as Pettigrew escaped.
I love the change of patronus from Terrier to Badger considering he no longer has the connection to Hermoine but instead so many warm memories of Hufflepuff house
Loving this series and cant wait to see where things go from here. Hearing this happier childhood does make me wonder, what if Snape hadn't overheard the prophecy?
I’m always so exited when a new video for this series comes out!
This feels like it will become a much happier version of the story from this point onwards.
With Sirius being announced innocent, I would like to believe that Harry still stay with the Weasleys but meets up with Sirius now and then. There's not much reasoning for Harry to move out of the Burrow when that is a happy life for him. so i hope you don't force that into the story.
I agree, he's got a happy settled life and it wouldn't make sense to move in with someone he hardly knows.
He might spend a week but for the most part Molly and Arthur are his parents
*in my Lockhart voice*
Benny… Benny… Benny… Helga Hufflepuff could not possibly allow gingers in her house… they would clash with the uniforms. 😀
But no, seriously, can you imagine how bad Barty Crouch Sr. would have looked had Sirius been found innocent; considering that he sent him to Azkaban without a trial? I don’t think it’ll matter in this theory however, because I think Barty Jr. is the servant that will rescue Voldemort, meaning that he might kill dad first.
Love this series! Great work😊😊😊
17:46 so if ron was in hufflepuff voldemort would have no chance of returning unless barty crouch jr found him
3pm feels early. I'm definitely not complaining lol
i was expecting Peter to escape & Sirius joining Harry at the Burrow as his new "pet" until the 5th book.
This is easily my favorite “episode” of any what if, you guys have done!
What if Dudley went to Hogwarts with Harry?
His world would crash knowing Harry is basically Jesus
@@joimumu I could see the Dursleys no longer so against magic if their Diddykins was a wizard and I believe things would either go much better or a LOT worse.
Yeah unless they began to shun Dudley for him having odd mishaps earlier in life and they realized he was magic like Harry, then maybe they would have been more bonded over their tough life at home. I don’t know if this would actually happen tho and I honestly think it could go either way. Maybe they do spoil him out of it and train in him their ways while they try the other approach with Harry, they could even maybe stop Dudley from going to hogwarts and maybe he’d form an obscuris so as to try and prevent being mistreated the way Harry was.???? Idk what are y’all’s thoughts
Question: Which memory would Harry use for his patronus? The realization that he can leave the Dursleys would not be available.
Finally Ron getting some shine, i really cant wait for ron to keep shining, maybe even ask hermione to the yule ball. Since this time there wont be the pride aspect
I love these videos so much! I really hope you guys do one for Hermione in Ravenclaw!
I predict Barty Crouch will bring back Tom Riddle next episode and Peter gets sentenced to life in Azkaban
That's just called knowing the plot
I wasn't around to watch the previous series when they where being released, so I love I'm here for this one that is being my favourite yet ^^
Part 5!!!!
I was literally on the edge of my seat for the whole thing please keep it up it's amazing❤
Could you eventually do "What If Ginny was sorted into Slytherin?"
There was no better help ad..... So I was able to give the video a like this time. good for you
I’m loving this series and can’t wait for part 4
Finally a nice big change in this What If storyline! ❤❤❤
HEY BROTHER
It's only the third book and we're already splitting it into two episodes, how many episodes will Order be?
Great question personally I preferred the format the the what if Harry was in Slytherin with longer episodes… and you know, the 7th one split up because this kinda hurts my brain but it’s still great work
The idea of Ron being able to use his patronus to save Harry is easily a better idea then what we got, I’m really loving this story as it progresses
Hey brother greeting from the Netherlands
Yeeees! This is so satisfying. Bugs me that PP got away from the secont time attempt too
Ah, I really liked this episode! I'm glad Ron's getting his time to shine. Cannot wait for my personal favorite villain, Barty Crouch Jr. to make his appearance ❤❤❤
I really hate that because Harry has a better broom he can always win in Quidditch. The team with the richer seeker always wins.
If that's the case then why was Krum able to catch the snitch over the Irish seeker in the world cup?
In the second year match against Slytherin Draco has the better broom and yet Harry catches the Snitch. Better equipment is a huge advantage, but it's not everything.
@@saulgoodman8501don’t they both have firebolts?
@chcucivtxzclccucifudohzfu6766 in book 3 it's mentioned that the Irish all had one and they are now favorites for the world cup kind of implying they are one of the only ones to have one
@@saulgoodman8501 it is never said that the Bulgarians don’t have firebolts as well. On the Harry Potter Wiki it even says both teams have firebolts
Great twist! Got me very excited for the next episode.
I like this version so much better!!! 🥹
Harry and Ron surrendering the map to a suitable authority figure in a time of crisis! What's next? Harry being able to use the invisibility cloak without getting caught by Peeves, Snape, Filch, Mrs. Norris, or some random passing house elf?
In all seriousness, Harry giving the map up to protect Ron whereas he wouldn't give it up to protect himself makes a weird amount of sense. Although you'd have thought he might have spent more time looking at the map in the 3rd book anyway to see if Black was somewhere on the grounds, though I suppose that would be an enormous amount of space to search.
well, Harry can now visit Sirius and see what life with him is like
he has the chance to choose for himself
dont wanna nag, am sure youre very busy but i wanna encourage u to keep working on this series as its really good and Im really looking forward to the rest of it. in your own time of course, no rush, im not desperate or anything, lol.
Now I can't wait to see where the story goes.
this is my favorite series yet!
It's so exciting to see these every week! Love that Sirius is innocent, but I assume that means the servant that returns to Voldemort won't be Peter Pettigrew, rather Barty Crouch jr...
It’s crazy how even in this timeline the fire bolt doesn’t have footrests
I've been enjoying this story 😊
Awesome as always thanks guys ❤
Rocking the beard! 🧔🧔
Barty Crouch Jr, here he comes!
Prisoner is the book in which it looks like everything is happening to harry but really it’s ron
Brothers; this series is gonna be better than "What if Harry was in Slytherin?" by the end.
17:03 - I've done it - I've found a mistake! "Aurther"? Its arthur
You guys really like using that scene where the basilisk erupts out of the water. Lol
No! I want MORE!!! When is the next episode?
Next week
I have to admit, I wasn’t sure about the heightened levels of Ron insecurity at first, but I’m really coming around to this characterization of him.
Wow what a twist, pettigrew caught!
Barty Crouch AGAIN!!
Also Ron will side with Percy in year 5
I love these "What if" series...I still want a conclusion to Neville being the Chosen One though.
I doubt they will do conclude it
Nice series 👍 after all the house switching may U try to do a Grindelwald and Voldemort character swap? Only suggestion though, and I'm just happy if U continue posting
What if the prophecy shifts from Wormtail to Crouch Jr.? When Jr. finds out Wormtail is still alive, he breaks free of his father's imperius and goes to find his master!
Pleeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaassssssssseeeeeeeee do a what if Dudley was a wizard and what if Draco was in Gryffindor!!!!!🎉
This what if is just pure fan fiction. The fact you guys had to make so many logic leaps in this one with Harry being adopted to get Ron in hufflepuff, making Harry wear a hufflepuff badge so Sirius still looks like he’s after Harry, it’s very stretchy 😅😂
all their "what if's" are fan fiction! that's just their name for it
stretchy things happened in Harry in Slytherin as well, we all know it's fanfic
It's a what if. A what if is fan fiction no matter what
please, please dont end this with harry and hermione ending up together!
why not?
What? Do you want him to be Alabamian?
Who Else is there?
@@Axoguy13 harry and luna, ron and hermione, neville and ginny, could happen but i think theyll just go with harrmione especially with ben being a harmione and runa shipper
@@OnlyOneEntity well, yeah. I didn’t think about Harry and Luna