Ryobi One+ 18V Brushless Cordless 7-1/4" Circular Saw Review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 พ.ย. 2017
- Amazon: amzn.to/2DbwRdi
Home Depot: homedepot.sjv.io/nZJoA
Ryobi introduced their newest P508 circular saw with a brushless motor and full sized 7-1/4" blade. Lightweight at just 6 pounds, with a decent amount of power and run time. The 3800 RPM no load speed is a little slower than most, and the electronic blade brake stops the blade in just a second or two. - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![BOWKYLION - เจ้านายคะ (work-life imbalance) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6bFj8G2pOi4/mqdefault.jpg)
Great concise review: power, longevity, blade, cut depth, perpendicularness, even secret brushless battery contacts.
I just bought this saw and I love it I'm not into carpentry much so I won't use it every day but so far it worked fine cutting 2x4 4x4 and fence boards building a 700ft fence
Excellent video! Thank you for making this video. I bought mine last December and haven't used it yet but I am about to since you made it less intimidating.
I have the 5.5 and the 6 1/4 excellent saws this will be my next saw ,great review
I got it free with the promotion at Home Depot and I'm going brushless now so I'm good for a while and I like that the blade is on the left and not the right like the ridgid but both brushless saws are awesome great review
This was a great review and the saw looks great. I am planning to get one as soon as I am able to sell my 6 1/2" one.
Gotta say
When our buddy first brought one of these on the job site, we laughed at him
Does it have the power, the durability or the prowice of an expensiver tool?
Well no....but....we’ve been using it for 2 years..and it’s lightweight and cordlessness...just makes it hella convenient
If you are a home gamer and have a shop, or want to do some light duty work, I’ll have to say I’m surprised that it’s lasted this long after all the abuse we put it through
Any tool you get “beats using your teeth”
You just gotta be honest with yourself
You making a project in your garage...or are you building an entire Neigborhood?
most people want overkill tools...but...be honest with yourself...no reason to spend money you don’t need to, cause....this saw, even though it’s slow and a little weak....it’s worth the money for light use
appreciate the heads up. 👍😎🏝
thanks for the info, but i am still deciding if i should get the brushless or brush model
@@tweakydancemusic8209 Brushless 100%, they dont need maintenance .
@@Francisco17Berrios that's good to know, i ended up getting the brushless one, which cost extra $100, i am very happy with it, cuts very good.
Thank you so much for an excellent review.
This is the first video of yours I stumbled across and I’m pretty impressed with your thoroughness! Good review
Thanks!
I have the 5.5 inch one and really love it, but I think the cut max is 1.7" So, for some 2x4/6/whatever I can't cut all the way through especially if it is bowed or thick. Overall awesome tool and it has a full aluminum guard other than the bottom is clear plastic.
Good video with pros and cons. Thank you I ordered one
Great review. Keep them coming.
Excelent review, I'm an electrician and I've been using Ryobi for over a decade. I'm happy to hear there could be super high amp/hour batteries.
It's definitely happening in Europe at least. The release date there is April 2018 - we'll just have to see how long it takes to get to North America. toolcraze.net/news-ryobi-aeg-9-0ah-batteries-will-available-early-2018-france/
Has ryobi been reliable for you over the years?
Good over view. I'm a DIY'er and just purchased this saw.
Thanks for the very detailed review!
The two additional contacts are for the tool communicating with the battery. When the tool is under heavy load the battery sends more power to the tool.
I finally figured out an excuse to buy one of these and I am impressed. It’s powerful, lightweight, inexpensive and has the blade on the correct side. Considering what it is, I don’t think the plastic guard and steel shoe are drawbacks. They help make it light and cheap without seriously compromising its capabilities. This is the kind of saw that can get the job done, but you don’t really have to worry too much about it disappearing.
Good video pal, thanks. Looks like a really nice saw actually. I have the HITACHI C18DBAL brushless 18V, it's a 6 1/2inch saw, but it has deep depth of cut at 67mm! Really don't want a 7 1/4inch when this achieves even slightly more than a lot of 7 1/4inchers! It has the motor on the left and blade on the right. Just in process of making some cutting and trim jigs for it.
Great review!
Great Review! Very informative. Thank you.
Great review. Thanks!
Thanks for the excellent review. Subscribed.
Can you get blades for this to cut metal
The blower is at the front of the blade on the motor housing.
I found that the Ryobi cordless circular saw is much quieter than say my Dewalt corded saw. Many thanks for your info.
Great review , looking at buying one on Amazon . I have the 5 and a half inch , but cut depth is bad .
Nice vid, great info
You have great videos. Thank you.
Great review, this one looks great... I hope you can make a review of the new ryobi brushless impact driver... Cheers
jaguar1822 just search there’s thousands
Looks like might have listened, I’ve just picked one up with the dust diverter! So happy with it, also has its own measure which lines up accurate cuts. Thanks for this review m8, I didn’t notice the align key and used a shifting spanner - haha!
The Australian and European versions have the dust collection nozzle while the US version doesn't. I have no idea why though.
I used it and got one and I thought it was good but once I took the blade off and put a $10 Diablo one it made a huge difference and was so much better!!!!!
Yes, that was one of the first things I did too. Also, the new HP batteries make night and day difference for this saw when ripping.
I can't use it for a tracksaw I guess. I was ok making a custom dustport but it the blade comming out of square ruins what would have been perfectly adequate for my application and the new large capacity batteries may kick up the power if they chat with the motor. I need better performance regarding accuracy in a circ saw.
Great review! Will you be reviewing the new Ryobi 18v canister vacuum and stick vacuum?
Thanks! I hadn't made up my mind on whether to review the new stick vacuum yet, but it looks pretty interesting.
I have had the earlier 5.5 inch brushed saw for awhile and it is pathetic, so I hesitantly bought this new 71/4 one in right handed version ,for the Australian market . I am very impressed with the performance even in long rip cuts ,very powerful and well balanced, then I put in the new 6amp hp battery and it boosted it even more ,I use it professionally at work .👍👍👍👍👍
Good vid. anybody know if it will rip 3/4" plywood several times. 4 x 8 sheet. how many cuts 8' Rip ? and how many cuts 4' cross cut with a mid range battery. 3 or 4 amp hr. i am looking to make a Box 2' wide x1' tall x 12' long to hold a Extension ladder on a truck ? No Electricity close by. Could i use the smaller 5 1/4" saw its lighter ?
I've ripped 2x material multiple times with this saw on a 4Ah battery, it should have no problem with plywood. If you're doing a lot of cutting, this is going to be way better than the 5-1/4" saw.
Excellent video! Keep them coming! Just an FYI: Ryobi, Rigid, and Miwaukee are the same company.
Is that true? Can you provide some more info on this? Thanks
@@rlee6984 I know this is a year later but I was flown out to the HQ of this company for an interview. They own a lot of brands. www.ttigroup.com/our-business/brands/
Please let Ryobi know I am adding this to my Ryobi Nation Collection because of your review!
I noticed your first cut of the 2x4 you had most of the sled or base in the air. Was that comfortable?
Not really but it's manageable. I prefer blade right for that reason.
Super comprehensive review! Thanks.
How's it do cutting pressure-treated lumber?
I haven't used it on any and don't think I have any scraps laying around, sorry.
I used a Diablo blade to rip a piece of plywood but the battery over heated 1/4 of the way through
Are you using a slim pack battery with it? I'd recommend a 3Ah HP battery at minimum for this saw. If one of those overheats with one cut, there's something wrong.
Will the adapters work on these so we can use dewalt batteries on this saw? Ryobi batteries aren’t very enduring for big jobs.
I haven't used any battery adapters with this saw, so I can't speak from direct experience. Ryobi's 6Ah abd 9Ah batteries really give this saw some more oomph and runtime though. I doubt an adapter will provide the additional power boost, since it won't have the extra set of contacts the Ryobi HP batteries have: th-cam.com/video/Qf3_WJqg8mg/w-d-xo.html
i've got an old ryobi circular saw (blue) and it's weak as heck even with the new HP batteries, was shopping for a new saw and have some dewalt and milwaukee tools chargers and batteries, definitely thinking i might go with one of the others based off this review
Thanks for the excellent review. I got one today for $99 at Home Depot. I believe that is a permanent price drop. Can hardly wait to use it. Batteries come in Wednesday.
I'd highly recommend the new 6Ah batteries for use with this saw - they make it a completely different tool!
I ordered a Powilling 5Ah battery from Amazon. It has excellent reviews so I took a chance on it. It was $37. I will let you know how it performs with the saw.
Also, I thought I would add a comment on the blade lock. I am a female and not very strong. When I was trying to install the blade I had the saw in my lap and was trying to push the lock mechanism. No dice. So I put it on the floor and that gave me enough leverage to do the job. I thought it would have been a little easier to do but maybe with time it will get better.
Good to know! Here's the comparison video I did between the 4Ah and the 6Ah if you're interested. th-cam.com/video/Qf3_WJqg8mg/w-d-xo.html
I did watch the video and the difference was noticeable. I am curious about and hopeful that the 5Ah battery will perform well.
Great review. I didn't see anything about the weight of the saw compared to an electric type or other battery saws. I love all my Ryobi tools.
This one's quite a bit lighter than most 7-1/4" saws I've used, corded or cordless.
How does the 71/4 ryobi do with ripping plywood? Would you buy it again?
Does great with plywood. I would buy it again.
I used this to rip a piece of plywood but it wouldn't finish the rip of the board
Great info so 🙏🏻
will any ryobi battery 18 work in this saw?
Yes, any Ryobi One+ 18V battery will work with this saw. A compact style one may overheat with heavy use though. I recommend at least a 3Ah HP battery, but the 6Ah and 9Ah will work best.
Is the spindle lock part important? Cuz that seems to be the only part I’m having a hard time doing. I can do it I’m just hoping it’s correct and wish someone went into more detail about this.
Without the spindle lock it will be very hard to remove the blade. The brushless motor indexes, which makes it a little tricky to find the detent in the shaft - you just need to keep rotating until the button depresses all the way.
Doresoom Tool Reviews ok cool, ty for explaining! I feel better now. That knock back I was reading in the manual sounds pretty scary.
Can you recommend a straight cut guide to use with this? I don’t think kreg rip cut is compatible with this.
I've used the Kreg Rip Cut and Accu Cut with this saw. It's compatible, here's a video I used it in: th-cam.com/video/8WidbNunPXY/w-d-xo.html
Doresoom Tool Reviews thank you .
i have a black and decker 3 amp jig saw and it took me 5 mins to cut threw a 3x8 and i had to keep stoping cause it was so hard for it to cut threw the wood, in 10 mins in your saw cut threw that 2x4 like butter.
A jigsaw doesn't clear chips as well, and doesn't have the blade speed a circular saw does, so that's expected. I pretty much only use my jigsaw for curved cuts or inside corner cuts that a circular saw can't do.
Also, this Ryobi brushless saw gets a HUGE power boost from their One+ 18V HP batteries. I was just using a P108 in this video, so the saw is capable of even faster cuts than shown here.
@@DoresoomReviews good to know, the jig saw i used is not a 3 its a 5 amp, still even curves will take a long time to cut, maybe it was to thick for suck a small amp jig saw, I do have a Ryobi jig saw it was messed up when it come, i have to send it back but the black and decker help the my project done. i have to get a circle saw next
Where can I get this version with the saw on the right and the dust shoot in the United States? The version in the United States is different.
I am looking for this version in the United States: th-cam.com/video/q7018708Nss/w-d-xo.html
Doesn't exist in North America unfortunately. The one with a dust port is the European version. You may be able to buy it online somewhere, but it will be expensive to ship.
Great review, how would you compare it to the dewalt circular saw? I have ryobi tools at home, but dewalt at work. Was wondering if I should buy a ryobi circular saw.
I haven't used any of DeWalt's cordless circular saws, but I'd say compared to my point of reference of an M18 FUEL saw it's going to feel a little underpowered. The newer HP batteries help a ton with the power on this saw though, and will make the difference a lot less noticeable. I compared its performance with regular 4Ah P108 vs the HP batteries here: th-cam.com/video/Qf3_WJqg8mg/w-d-xo.html
The two other contact points are for for the one+ Lithium+HP 18 batteries that are made for the brushless cordless drills
The left pin outputs 2.8v & right pin puts out 18.7v when measuring from common ground on stem.
Yeah, at the time I made this review the new HP batteries weren't out yet to confirm. I'm betting the voltage on that second set of pins varies when you place the tool and battery under load in order to balance run time vs current draw for high demand applications.
One ofy our gripes about a left blade saw was the heavy part being on the waste edge, but then you show plenty of cuts where you simply cut the other direction where the lighter part is on the wasted edge?
Cutting plywood or ripping you can usually manage to cut with the lighter part on the waste edge if you plan it out. But when cross cutting dimensional lumber the heavy side is always gonna be on the waste edge if you're right handed and want to hold the rest of the workpiece with your left hand.
Does it come with a one plus + battery !? Like is the battery one plus !?
This is usually sold bare tool, which means it doesn't come with a battery or a charger.
All Ryobi 18V One+ batteries will work with all their 18V One+ tools.
You can cut from the opposite direction so it shouldn’t really matter which side is wider.
If you're cross cutting, you generally hold the saw with your dominant hand and hold the workpiece with your non-dominant hand, and let the offcut just drop. If you cut from the opposite side, now you're holding the offcut instead of the workpiece.
Great review!
What is your thoughts between the Ryobi and Kobalt brushless circular saw? 👍🙏❤️
I haven't used the Kobalt saw, sorry. Between Ryobi and Kobalt, Kobalt seems slightly higher quality to me, but Ryobi has a much broader 18V platform. I'd pick Ryobi, especially since Kobalt has switched battery voltages a few times on their customers.
@@DoresoomReviews 👌👍🙏❤️
FYI, we are new to this and previously we didn't have any power tools. Recently we brought several Kobalt brushless tools plus 4 & 6ah batteries and we found that Ryobi tools are nice too if you use 4ah or high batteries
ill stick with my first gen old blue model...might not run as long but its not as heavy and does what i need
I'm having problems with the saw lock clicking and the blade coming loose
I'd check to make sure the spindle lock is fully engaged. It's a little deceptive because the brushless motor has very strong resistance and it can feel like it's the spindle lock that's engaged when it's really the motor magnets resisting.
If that's not the issue, it's possible you've got a defective spindle lock.
I think I have a bad lock will be exchanging it tomorrow thanks for the fast response keep up the good reviews there great
Mine is doing the same thing..
I love ryoby tools
Just bought this on an online promotion. Buy the 2 pack 3.0Ah battery starter kit with bag and charger get a tool free. $106 with tax. I'm excited after watching the reviews. I have other 18 volt Ryobi tools so the extra batteries alone are nice.
How do you like it so far? I'm thinking of getting that same deal!
@@mtalamantes100994 I have no complaints. I ripped 3 sheets of 1/2" plywood into (9) total pieces. One battery did it no problem. Six cuts 4ft long. Cut some 2x4's as well too after I was done. I would buy it again.
👍 jw. i was wondering too. i want to cut up some 3/4 plywood to make extension ladder box for my truck & a few 2x4's. no electricity nearby.
@@OcRefrig All my cordless stuff is Ryobi I use 6ah batteries I have 3 of them for the tools that suck a lot of juice and use the small ones on the 1/4 impact to keep it light I really like how the saw works with the bigger batteries
@ steve - Appreciate the info. 👍😎🏝
Does anyone know if this model has built in laser?
It does not have a built in laser. My personal opinion on lasers for circular saws is that they're just a gimmick though. If the kerf indicator on the front of the shoe isn't sufficient for keeping the cut lined up accurately, then a rip guide is needed.
Doresoom Reviews thanks for the heads up this was super informative on picking a circular saw I like. Personally not a fan of lasers seems like you don’t need them
Good deal if you already have other battery powered Ryobi tools like blowers, leaf cutters, drills, etc, like I do...no need to buy more batteries/charges, just the circular blade. I’m getting one. My 18V Lithium P107 are more than enough.Thanks for the cool review.
Just a note, the compact style batteries (like the P102 and P107) will run the saw, but won't put out as much power. I could feel a difference in performance when using the P108 vs the P102.
Isn’t the P107 stronger than the P102?
Well, not only you convinced me, but makes more sense buying the kit from Home Depot...as for only $20 more, you get the circular saw plus two P108 batteries and charger. The stand alone saw with no batteries and charger is not a good buy...
www.homedepot.com/p/Ryobi-18-Volt-ONE-Cordless-Lithium-Ion-Brushless-7-1-4-in-Circular-Saw-Kit-with-2-4-0Ah-Batteries-and-Charger-P1958N/302858633
www.homedepot.com/p/Ryobi-18-Volt-One-7-1-4-in-Circular-Saw-Bare-Tool-P508/301848641
It’s a no brainer, I’m order the kit with batteries, ha.
Thanks, man!
The P107 has five 3.6V cells with an energy storage capacity of 1.5Ah each, while The P102 has five cells with a 1.3Ah capacity. The main difference between those two is a little bit more runtime offered by the P107. On the other hand, the P108 has ten cells with 2.0Ah of capacity each, which equates to 4Ah total for the 18V battery. The reason the P108 can output more power (not to be confused with runtime) is because it can draw current from both sets of 5 cells simultaneously. For a power tool, current draw is directly related to power. The P107 may be able to output a little more power than the P102 if the cells are a better quality with a higher max discharge rate, but where you'll really see the difference is moving to the P108 which has twice the cells.
And yeah, that's a sweet deal they've got going on right now!
Hey Doresoom how would you compare this to the Ridgid Brushless circular saw you reviewed in July 2016? Would you recommend one over the other?
I personally like the Ridgid better. They're pretty comparable tools as far as performance goes, but the Ridgid just feels a bit more polished.
thanks for the reply. I'm about to start my first cordless tool collection and am trying to decide between Ryobi and Ridgid. Last week HD was having some deals on both models. I picked up the Ridgid LImited Edition 4 piece brushless set w/ 2-4.0ah batteries for $299. Also grabbed the same exact brushless tools from Ryobi w/1-4.0ah battery for $270. Having trouble deciding which route to go. Ryobi tools going forward will be a lower cost. Plus all the brushless tool coming out have that extra set of contacts they you mentioned in this video which my give them a performance advantage over similar Ridgid models. Ridgid does have the great LSA. And like you mentioned the tools in general seem a little more polished. Do you have any further info on what the extra contacts do?
Any advice on which brand to go with ?
I haven't seen anything else about the extra contacts on the new Ryobi brushless tools. My advice between Ridgid/Ryobi is to look at what tools you think you'll want down the line. If it's just the standard drill/impact/circular saw/recip saw, etc. then I'd go with Ridgid. However, Ryobi is much more of an innovator and crank out a ton of new products all the time. Their One+ line is a lot bigger than Ridgid's is, and they have random tools that are very useful for homeowners like the drain auger and hot glue gun, as well as lawn care equipment that Ridgid doesn't offer. Personally if I had to pick between just those two it would be Ryobi, since they offer way more options and seem to be getting into higher quality/performance tools lately with all the brushless releases.
Turns out my hypothesis on the extra Ryobi electrical contacts was correct. The 6Ah P164 batteries showed up on HD's website for a short while, and had the description: "Communicates directly with Ryobi Brushless tools to deliver the optimal level of power for the best performance."
"optimal level of power" is worded so vague it could mean anything. Would be interesting if you got your hands on a 6ah battery down the line to compare some tools with it and with the 4ah battery. After all the back and forth between Ryobi brushless tools and Ridgids I ended up going with Milwaukee m12 Fuel tools, reallying liking them so far. Love the smaller size and lightweight.
Great review. I probably won’t buy one, as I already have three cordless circular saws, but for some reason I really do like Ryobi tools. What I’d really like to see them do is build a line of compact tools like Milwaukee’s M12 line. I suspect that Ryobi’s cheap, lightweight build style would really lend itself to compact tools. Milwaukee makes good tools, but they sure ain’t light.
Thanks! I forgot to mention in the video - this saw is pretty light, at just 6 pounds without battery. I think my Ridgid Gen5X brushless is over 8 pounds. All that plastic does have at least one clear advantage!
The weight of certain Ryobi tools is almost as big an advantage as their price IMO. Their recip saw for example is more than 3 lbs lighter than most of the competition. I think their 6.5” circular saw is actually lighter than Milwaukee’s 5 3/8” M12 saw too.
Cut in the other direction, then you have support on the proper side AND you have better site line.
That works well for sheet goods. I'm right handed though, so for cross cuts I'd either have to use my left hand to hold the saw, or cross my arms to hold the main portion of the work piece.
Good video but you really need to do something about that sound or the area you're using for making your video, otherwise perfect. Been using mine for about a year now without any problems. I would verify that when you set it up for shallower cuts it's' off by about 5/1000 of an inch but since all my projects call for using a jointed it's easily corrected. It did take a little bit to get used to the blade on the opposite side and I had to set up one of my jigs differently but all in all despite the added cost I'm happy and would recommend it.
Thanks! This is an old video - I use a mic now for much better sound quality.
I got the drill, the impact driver, the jigsaw, and the circular saw, PLUS 4 batteries (1 of the 2 ah, 1 of 3 ah, and 2 of the 4 ah), for a mere $256. Absolutely amazing deal from Ryobi. For my purposes, these tools are more than adequate. I can't believe the value, honestly. All are brushless. The jigsaw works great. I actually haven't even used the circular saw yet.
Someone call the cops, because that was a STEAL! 😄
Definitely run the 3Ah HP battery in the circ, there's a huge boost in performance.
I'm here looking because I saw that deal in the store! I can't decide which freebees to get. I want them all!
@@tinkytinkz Yeah, it was a tough call. I went with the 4 tools I thought I'd use the most given the types of projects I usually do (building / fixing decks, docks, etc.) I don't do a lot of "fine" carpentry, so I didn't go with a router or sander. In addition to the base of the two drills (drill and impact driver, actually), I went with the jigsaw and the circular saw, and extra batteries. (The batteries are expensive, and you always need more batteries.)
@@DoresoomReviews I have two 4 ah batteries, so I was thinking that would be best for the circular saw.
If they're the old P108 4Ah batteries, they last longer but won't perform as well as the 3Ah HP battery in the circular saw. I tested it out here: th-cam.com/video/14XWnygzEDo/w-d-xo.html
You probably won't notice it for cross cutting, but ripping is where it's very apparent. If you want the short version, here's a side by side of the P108 4Ah and the 6Ah. (The 3Ah performs the same as the 6Ah.) instagram.com/p/BjA_qPvABJU/
I'm getting cold feet on Ryobi, lots of the 2021 reviews on HD say faulty battery.
I've been on the Ryobi One+ 18V platform for about 5 years. I have over a dozen batteries and only had two fail. Both were 2Ah slim packs that wouldn't charge. I fixed both of them by taking them apart and charging the cells individually.
Brushed motors the rotor is much heavier as well because the copper windings causing more losses .
Excellent review. I hope you're right about the 6.0 or 9.0 batteries. I think it's been long over due.
I tagged Ryobi about it on Instagram, and they replied, "We can’t say...but stay tuned!" I'm optimistic, since I have no idea what those extra contacts would be for otherwise.
There are already leaked part numbers and schematics for the 9.0 ryobi battery so its on the way for sure.
Are those contacts not on the charger? I have the older green charger and a swear the contacts are on there. I would have to check tonight, but I'm thinking they are just monitor contacts probably to a thermal couple or something. I also thought the batteries had those contacts on them already.....
Nope, they're not on the charger either. The charger does interface with the batteries with a single contact at the base of the post on the old batteries. However, these two new contacts are on the opposite side of the post. I show it in a little more detail on my Instagram: instagram.com/p/BbXbFHdl7HR/?taken-by=doresoom
I've seen the 6Ah battery on some Ryobi tools in their literature. Also, see this article.
toolcraze.net/official-ryobi-18v-6ah-9ah-compact-3ah-batteries-real-probably-using-20700-cells/
just got one free i like it use it as a back-up to my dewalt ele.
I like it because it was free from brushless drills combo I bought. It is nowhere near though from Dewalt counter part ergonomics, materials and features wise. I noticed that most brushless Ryobi are coming up lack some good features like the P239 Impact. Maybe it is Marketing ploy I suspect. Entice people to buy for the brushless feature then come up later with another batch of models with brushless full with good featuress.
The P239 came out after the P238, which is their full-featured brushless impact. I think it was an attempt to offer a lower cost base model brushless impact, since the drill/impact two battery kit that includes the P239 goes for $150 rather than the $99 of the P238 bare tool.
Some people say it dont cut straight what u think
I haven't had any issues with it cutting straight myself. If I need a perfect cut, I'll use a guide with it. Now bevel on the other hand, this thing has some problems if you need perfection. I found it only hit 90° perfectly when I had the blade at full depth. When you raise it up, it goes a tiny bit out of square for bevel unless you re-adjust the bevel setting.
I'd probably get this in that kit they have for $200 if it had a dust port. Just looking for a lightweight circular saw that's cordless.
The UK/Australian versions actually have the dust port if you can find one online.
1. Is it dangerous to have a plastic upper blade guard when cutting certain materials?
2. Has anyone here had a problem with making a 90 degree angle when setting the blade depth as noted at 8:10?
The plastic upper blade guard shouldn't be a safety concern. It's more of a quality indicator than anything - the shoe of a saw is often attached to the upper blade guard, so if the guard deflects a tiny amount, then the squareness of cut can suffer.
@@DoresoomReviews Thank you for letting me know.
Great videos. What battery do you recommend with this brushless saw?
Thanks! I'd go with any of the HP batteries with this - the 3Ah, 6Ah, or 9Ah. They make a huge difference in performance under heavy load.
Doresoom Tool Reviews thanks! One last question, with any of those three batteries (3Ah, 6Ah, 9Ah) does one provide more power to the saw than the other or is the difference simply just how long they last?
The 3Ah and 6Ah seem to provide the same power output, with the 9Ah having a slight advantage. th-cam.com/video/8WidbNunPXY/w-d-xo.html
Have you compared the P191 3Ah to the new P195 3Ah. Wondering if there is a big difference in performance.
Those are hp connections for the tool to talk to the battery
Yes - I made this video before HP batteries existed. So my guess turned out to be right.
@Doresoom Tool Reviews I didn't know tools without the hp badge or black an green colors could do the connection now I want this thing even more not just cause the left handed blade
Quite a few of the initial Ryobi brushless tools have the contacts, even though they were released prior to any "HP" branded tools or batteries. I guess Ryobi was just planning for forward compatibility.
I find the light sucks on it.
why does ryobi put the blade on the opposite side on their cordless saws? It's a deal breaker for me..
It's really a matter of personal preference for blade position. If you look at the comments on my review of Milwaukee's blade right saw, at least half the comments are lamenting that it's not blade left: th-cam.com/video/oEkdf6vIJkU/w-d-xo.html
@@DoresoomReviews Well 98% of saws have the blade on the right side. It's just one of those things you dont change. Like Ford just suddenly making all their vehicles with the steering wheel on the passenger side or something.
Blade left is a selling point for me. I hate the motors hitting my hand when using a square as a guide.
@@MrC9Oh3 the reason that most saws have a blade on the right is because most people are right handed and do not know how to safely operate their power tools. When held in the right hand this design keeps the motor and body of the saw between the user and the blade so that when Joe idiot is holding the saw down by his thigh and accidentally pulls the trigger the chances of him cutting half way through his thigh are drastically reduced. If you look at the type of circular saws carpenters and professionals tend to use (worm drive and hypoid) almost all of them have the blade on the left since this allows a right handed person to make accurate cuts with much greater ease which is of great importance to the professional for whom time is money and safe practices are second nature. The correct side to have the blade on is the side that you are most comfortable with. Don't let anyone tell you otherwise.
@@casper18795 I'm with you there 100%. Using a saw with a blade on the right hand side feels like trying to hit the brakes in my truck with my left foot. Extremely foreign and uncomfortable for me.
The extra battery prongs are because this is a one plus it takes several battery's even some other brands battery
No that's not what One+ means, it only takes Ryobi 18V batteries. The only exception I can think of is Arctic Cove, who uses the exact same batteries with a different color scheme. Most other Ryobi One+ 18V tools do not have the extra contacts unless they have brushless motors. I have a garage full of them, and I have checked. The only batteries that have the matching contacts are the new HP versions, which came out after I made this review - so my hypothesis was correct.
Great Review, Will give you a BIG TIP, I think you will Like it. when you cut 2x4 or even 2x6< try using a Speed Square. Just hook it to the face of your 2x and now you have a stight fence to put the saws shoe aginest & match the blade to your marked to cut, You will find that you have less bind on blade, you always get a square cut on the wood all around it saves time , battery life and blade life. And ya don't have resquare your wood your working with. and I would bet you could have cut a extra 10-20 Pieces of 2x4. Its a hack all wood Framers use.
That is a great technique that I do use when I actually care about the cut - I'm just cutting so much with an endurance test like this that I don't bother with it. But now you've got me thinking that I might actually be able to squeeze some more run time out of the saw if I take extra care to keep it from binding.
Bought one of these today and returned it immediately. Brand new out of the box, not even a refurbished one, and the arbor lock does not all the way so it was impossible to put a new saw blade in. Injured my finger attempting to replace the blade when the arbor lock slipped after multiple attempts. The one I got had zero quality control, they literally slapped it together at the slave labor camp and called it a day.
Are you sure you had the actual spindle lock spot and weren't feeling the brushless motor indexing like I explain around 9:05? It was a little tricky to find on mine, but it was there. Otherwise, I agree - I'd be taking it back to the store if I had the same problem.
Thanks for the reply. I did find the arbor detent/gap slot, but it would slip out after a certain amount of torque no matter how hard the arbor lock button was pushed down. First time I've experienced this kind of problem with a circular saw. Even tried crescent wrench and an impact wrench with an allen bit. I'll probably try my luck with the Ridgid brushless gen5x one next.
“The weight of the saw is on the cut off portion”?? Cut it the other direction then! Whew. That was easy!
True, but then you're cutting with the other hand. So in most people's case their non-dominant hand.
@@DoresoomReviews Wait...what? Do you even cut bro?
I don’t understand why ryobi’s 6 1/2 saw does like 4700 rpm but this one does only 3700.
Don't forget the larger blade diameter puts the surface feet per minute a little closer between the two saws, but this one's still fairly slow when compared to other cordless brushless saws. The P507 comes out to around 8,000 SFM, and the P508 is 7,022 SFM. They likely lowered the blade speed for power reasons, since power=torque*rotational speed, and they're bumping up torque required due to the larger blade diameter.
Doresoom Reviews hmmm I see. Let me ask you another question since you seem to be very knowledgeable. Would the ryobi 36v (one + one) brushless 10” miter saw be more powerful than the 15 amp corded 10” miter saw?
That one's a little harder to gauge, since some of the leading manufacturers are starting to make "more powerful than corded" claims with their cordless tools. However, Ryobi isn't at the leading edge of battery technology, so I'd say it's a safe bet that their corded 10" saw is more powerful than their X2 cordless.
That's disappointing! Thanks for the information though. The x2 battery one is so much more expensive too though.
do you think this is the case EVEN WITH the HP batteries? the miter saw is brushless after all
I just grabbed one - it comes with a vacuum attachment.
Did you get the new HP version? I think they added a vac port to that one. Also, the European version of this P508 has a vacuum port but the US version doesn't for some reason.
Another good review, but now you leave me torn as to weather or not to buy this saw. I've been getting away from Dewalt, which I've used for decades now, because the Ryobi tools and batteries are so much cheaper. I've been very pleased with most of Ryobi's tools, not so much with others, whereas Dewalt has never let me down. The shortcomings of this saw are the plastic blade guard, no dust chute, and the stamped steel shoe. Those are some pretty serious cost-cutters that will affect the accuracy of the saw, (except for the the dust chute). And seriously, couldn't they include a rip guide? I'd be willing to pay the extra 50¢ it would have cost them. I'm wondering if a rip guide wasn't included because of the plastic blade guard.
It's great that Ryobi is finally getting into advanced features like brushless motors, but I think it's mainly going to be aimed at consumers who are only in the One+ battery platform, and are wistfully looking over the fence at all the other manufacturers who are really innovating and pushing capabilities of cordless.
If you've got batteries in another system (especially Ridgid that's just $20 more expensive), then it's probably worth going with the more expensive competitor for the upgrade in performance and quality. I've even seen the DeWalt FlexVolt 7-1/4" circular saw for as low as $150 bare tool, and that's on a whole different level of performance over this saw.
I’ve had the older 6.5” brushed version of this saw for a couple years now and it’s been used regularly in that time. So far the plastic blade guard hasn’t been a problem.
Thanks for the reply. I'm not worried about the plastic breaking, I'm concerned about how it flexes. Some manufacturers of track saw guides specifically state not to use a saw with a plastic blade guard for that very reason. I'm just going to keep using my old Dewalt as a cordless. I have half a dozen corded skill saws that I can use if needed. Actually, I have a nice Makita cordless but I haven't been able to find the darn thing in years!
You could always cut with the larger part of the shoe on the larger portion of what you are cutting just go in the other direction. That is not why brushless is better by the way.
You can cut the opposite way if you're rip cuttng. But if you're cross cutting, you generally hold the saw with your dominant hand and hold the workpiece with your non-dominant hand, and let the offcut just drop. If you cut from the opposite side, now you're holding the offcut instead of the workpiece.
I don't remember exactly what I said about brushless, but the main advantage is better efficiency which provides more runtime per battery charge. They're also more powerful and don't need the added maintenance of replacing worn brushes.
need to test with hp battery
I already did! The batteries weren't available when I originally made this review, but I tested them as soon as I could get my hands on them, and they make an impressive difference.
3Ah: th-cam.com/video/14XWnygzEDo/w-d-xo.html
6Ah: th-cam.com/video/Qf3_WJqg8mg/w-d-xo.html
9Ah: th-cam.com/video/8WidbNunPXY/w-d-xo.html
I don't like the left hand blade on that ,we are just getting the right hand version now thank heavens.
there is a right handed one now?
this has been the only reason I haven't bought one, I hope you're right
It's got hp contacts on it
$140 with two 4ah batteries and charger Home Depot ONLINE ONLY til January 30,2018. You’re welcome
Link?
I don't see it!
Larry Craig out of stock currently. But you can still pick up the brushless reciprocating saw package deal and the brushless grinder package deal that also each come with 2 4ah batteries. $139
I like to see it cut with original blade really. 😕
I'd really recommend replacing the blade the saw comes with, since Ryobi stock blades are very poor quality in my experience. I see your point though, I technically made a $10 upgrade to the saw and then reviewed it.
You deserve more subs hope your n instagram
Thanks! I actually just started an Instagram account in September: instagram.com/doresoom/
No dude it Hp battery’s and they are already out
Check the date I posted this video. It predates the release of the HP batteries. At the time I made it, the 4Ah P108 was the best they offered.
What sort of crazy person makes anything at two and seven sixteenths of an inch... Ryobi! 😆
Is everyone else thinking what I’m thinking? Great I have all these brushed ryobi one tools that are old news. Now I have to replace them with brushed ryobi. Ugh. They should accept trade ins lol
No Worry! I'm a Left Handed Guy and it doesn't matter if the tools and other stuffs nowadays are made for Right Handed People. I can use anything or everything properly and safely. I'm an Ambidextrous guy. But guess what?! The right handed people like my buddy can't use the conventional Corded circular saw that the motor is mounted on the left side properly and safely Lol! 🤣
Frodo!
Smeagol?
Doresoom Reviews haha, I'm sure ya heard that one b4..
Good review man, Whether pro/dyi/hobbyist we're pretty spoiled with the quality/ability of tools these days, especially cordless. I'm holding my breath and crossing fingers to see if they can match the longevity of some of the old tools though. I think we're getting to a performance point where upgrading for the sake of much better performance is about done with like computers and cellphones, so hopefully they can last the test of time with in reason.