@Tara Rawson For one, I'm probably older than you. Two, I have my own successful business, so succesful that I pay people to run it and lastly, if I'm not in a position to judge her, then neither are you as you are defending her because you have judged her too, just not like I have. P.S. Now go back to your super high paying job I'm sure you have with that amazing grammar you displayed. My 9 year old forms better sentences! Lol
According the description, this is an album version, the vocals were taped separately, so she was laughing about something different. PS. I'm just here bc I ve read the name Kurt Cobain, CL was always an asshole to her fans, do u think she 'd care about you? No, all she did was screaming " fuck you" at her fans. Kurt never did that, the opposite, remember? "The worst crime I can think of is...." CL is a money hungry bitch
They featured this song on the radio! I remember a video floating around here, that had this version of the song, with a picture of Courtney kissing a red-haired Kurt and the ending said "for Frances!" Right at the beginning before it began to play, I heard a female radio host speaking. Gah, I wish I could find that again!
It's such a disgraceful shame Courtney got branded 'the wife of' and was never really able or allowed to crawl out from under Kurt's shadow. Because holy fucking shit does she have a voice on her.. I swear to God this woman has one of, if not the best screams in rock history. Every time I hear that raw, boisterous emotion in her voice I'm just instantly transported.
Not true, hole was big in the 90s and had hits post Kurt's death but in the end, grunge died with nirvana.... She didn't reinvent herself like dave grohl did
Courtney Love was an incredible singer at this time but she destroyed her own legacy with her narcissistic tendencies. Doesn’t mean she’s a bad person. But her reputation precedes her.
The album was dedicated to Joe Cole who was one of Holes roadies. He was shot coming home with his roommate Henry Rollins. Henry has told the story many times.
I agree. I don't understand why some Nirvana fans don't like when you are a fan of both Nirvana and Hole. I get it that losing Kurt Cobain was a shock and fans are still missing him. The police ruled Kurt's death a suicide. I used to believe that Courtney had Kurt killed, as the popular theory went. Now I'm not so sure if I believe that. Kurt was depressed. Kurt did struggle with a mental illness. He was a beautiful, gentle soul, but he was tormented. Courtney is a trainwreck, but she owns it and I respect that. Was Courtney the best wife on earth? Or have the best character or integrity on earth? Well... No. Nobody is perfect. She is a brilliant writer and musician though, in my opinion. She's not dumb. She made an ass out of herself when she was using heavy, absolutely... But she is an incredibly intelligent woman. It was easy to jump on the "Hate and Blame Courtney Love" bandwagon. While many of Tom Grant's revelations were suspicious and Courtney looked guilty, doesn't mean she actually was. Kurt did love Courtney. Courtney couldn't be faithful, and he was really hurting over that, among other things. He was stressed out. He didn't want fame and excessive wealth. He enjoyed playing and singing, performing, until he didn't. Courtney was a songwriter and musician before she met Kurt, and actually pushed him to become more known in the grunge scene. She saw the potential Nirvana had. To act as if Courtney Love was just some bimbo groupie who rode the coattails of her husband's success, is so ignorant. They both became big in the Grunge genre around the same time. The woman had her own talent and career. What happened was unfortunate, but let's face it... Two successful rockstars with heroin addictions and underlying mental health issues get married and have a child. Recipe for disaster. Heroin is a bad animal that steals your soul. You can also can be wealthy and successful and want to kill yourself. Sorry for the article here. I just wish Nirvana fans didn't alienate or hate on those of us who also like the band Hole.
What makes me sad is both Kurt Cobain and Kristen Pfaff (the bassist of Hole) died not long after this. And they are the core of this song mostly because of Kurt's guitar and Kristen's bass combination. Both of them didn't live through this and died so young.
It’s interesting that Courtney sings “if you live through this with me” while Kurt just sings “if you live through this”. Maybe, to him, it was only important for Courtney to survive.
@@ferise1 Courtney isn't smart enough to murder kurt & she did write her own songs maybe you should actually believe that she is talented lyricially even though your sounds a bit misogynistic to me 😬
Every time that, I sell myself to you I feel a little bit cheaper, than I need to I will tear the petals, off of you Rose red, I will make you tell the truth Was she asking for it? Was she asking nice? If she was asking for it Did she ask you twice? Every time, that I stare into the sun Angel dust, and my dress just comes undone N' every time that I stare into the sun Be a model, or just look like one Wild-eyed, rot-gut, do me in Do you think, you can make me do it again? Was she askin' for it? Was she askin' nice? If she was askin' for it Did she ask you twice? If you live through this, with me I swear that, I will die for you An', if you live through this, with me I swear that, I will die for you Was she askin' for it? Was she askin' nice? If she was askin' for it Did she ask you twice? Was she askin' for it? Was she askin' nice? If she was askin' for it Did she ask you twice?
Goddamn great album.I was a senior in high school when Kurt died,I consider myself lucky to have had such an amazing soundtrack to my adolescents .I feel bad for kids now...
ShootStuff I’m 13 and I hate the music on the radio now I wish it was all like this now honestly it must of been amazing when the recent music back then was like this
‘Hole’ (from 1993 - 2002) is: ------------------------- Courtney Love - Lead Vocals and Rhythm Guitar ------------------------ Eric Erlanderson - Lead Guitar ------------------------ Kristen Pfaff/ Melissa Auf der Maur - Bass, piano’s, backing vocals ------------------------ Patty Schemel - Drums ------------------------ ------------------------ ------------------------ ------------------------ ‘Hole’ from (2009 - 2012) is: ------------------------ Courtney Love - Lead Vocals and Electric Guitar ------------------------- Micko Larkin - Acoustic Guitar ------------------------- Shawn Daily - Bass ------------------------- Stu Fisher - Drums -------------------------
its probably bc shes more on the front and hes way at the back, theyre the same height as seen in vids and photos, but its also possible courtney was wearing heels haha, but yeah cute small kurt :3
Miss this duo so much everyday. Wish I was present during this era to see such great music release. It truly is such a shame that their love was so toxic, you could tell it was true but hurtful to the both of them. This song is truly so sad to think about because they didn’t live through this and neither did Kristen
The producers have said in many interviews that the song was written in the studio with the band. Kurt came into the studio high off his rocker and sang only the chorus because he had to learn the song first.
I don’t think they really every wanted to I wish they made songs together or atleast Kurt cover some of holes songs mainly because hole was becoming more known and not underground it wasnt really as popular some people claim hole as like the sister band to Nirvana a band that has a Kurt influence since some of the songs definitely seem like Nirvana songs
@@hehasnolips1371Actually, Kurt himself in an interview mentioned that when he played with Hole it was an energy so great and he played so well with them he’d give up Nirvana to play with them more. That’s why we probably see Kurt have so much influence on so many songs in Hole’s discography but not so much influence from Courtney in Nirvana songs. I’m sure he would’ve definitely played more with Hole and maybe even started projects with them had he just left Nirvana and stayed alive.
That’s most likely Kristen or Courtney because Everyone had been working on this version together including Kurt for just the backing vocals at the bridge
This was the norm in a day in a life. I lived through it and they were apart of it. It wasn't orchestrated. It was a generation, a movement. That eventually like everything ends. Hopefully, is found again. I think it might have for real this time...current events.
the album was going to be released before Kurt passed but because of his health problems got pushed back to April. The album title is a quote by Scarlett from Gone with the Wind. It was chosen in 1992 after all the negative press she had. Kurt D in 1994...
I thought the same thing, I have never heard this song before didn't know that they made songs together. Interesting lyrics though, hope that's why he didn't die. Miss him. ❤❤
Well, he wrote it, he may as well as sing on it. I could always hear him on it even back in the day on the released version, just barely in the mix, but singing the same as her.
That isn't Kurt Cobain at 2:08. That's some dumb ass dubbing on top of the track. Kurt just sings the lines "Live through this i swear that i would die for you" from the second and third verse.
@@MakeMeLo I wish they would release the last songs he recorded I can hear what Kurt sounds like when he tries to sing before I die. He was preparing to do an acoustic folk rock collab record with Michael Stipe, which Stipe has confirmed. I've read that's what Courtney and him were supposedly arguing about in Rome and the night the police found him in the closet because she was afraid they'd lose money because the fans would see him as a sellout.
The best female scream / roar in rock now belongs to Avienne of the band VINTERSEA , keep them on your radar , gonna put the Pacific Northwest back on the map soooon
@@heirrose1606she got pregnant in like november of 1991 way before they were married so what you’re saying makes zero sense. iirc, what she DID say is she didn’t think their relationship would’ve lasted long if it wasn’t for frances
You can hear the love in the smile on her voice when Kurt starts singing too....tends to cause me to smile...
Only because she was thinking about the money she'd make off of it.
@Tara Rawson Because she deserves the hate. 😁
@Tara Rawson By your logic, your opinion isn't valid either. Lol
@Tara Rawson For one, I'm probably older than you. Two, I have my own successful business, so succesful that I pay people to run it and lastly, if I'm not in a position to judge her, then neither are you as you are defending her because you have judged her too, just not like I have.
P.S. Now go back to your super high paying job I'm sure you have with that amazing grammar you displayed. My 9 year old forms better sentences! Lol
According the description, this is an album version, the vocals were taped separately, so she was laughing about something different.
PS. I'm just here bc I ve read the name Kurt Cobain, CL was always an asshole to her fans, do u think she 'd care about you? No, all she did was screaming " fuck you" at her fans. Kurt never did that, the opposite, remember? "The worst crime I can think of is...." CL is a money hungry bitch
This version is much better than the cut on the album!
@Ramon Uribe yes
For real
Waaaay better!!!
possibly.
When they start singing "Live through this, I swear that I will die for you" you can hear Kurt singing. It starts around 2:08!
2:08
thx
They featured this song on the radio! I remember a video floating around here, that had this version of the song, with a picture of Courtney kissing a red-haired Kurt and the ending said "for Frances!" Right at the beginning before it began to play, I heard a female radio host speaking. Gah, I wish I could find that again!
Aw man
their voices together, it hits, dear god
It's such a disgraceful shame Courtney got branded 'the wife of' and was never really able or allowed to crawl out from under Kurt's shadow. Because holy fucking shit does she have a voice on her.. I swear to God this woman has one of, if not the best screams in rock history.
Every time I hear that raw, boisterous emotion in her voice I'm just instantly transported.
Not true, hole was big in the 90s and had hits post Kurt's death but in the end, grunge died with nirvana.... She didn't reinvent herself like dave grohl did
Courtney Love was an incredible singer at this time but she destroyed her own legacy with her narcissistic tendencies. Doesn’t mean she’s a bad person. But her reputation precedes her.
She is true legend and Inspiration to be authentic self in her own right .
Hole and Courtney was something and it meant something.. so yeah
She is the more punk auteur
His voice is so beautiful in this I want to cry
They did look so good together. I can’t even deny it.
The way he looks at her at 3:50 is so cute😭
Unfortunately they were a toxic pair.
Dang. With Kurt towards the end it sounds amazing.
I do really like the version they ended up keeping, still good.
2:06 Kurt starts singing
😢😢they were so great singing together…its just epic
The album was dedicated to Joe Cole who was one of Holes roadies. He was shot coming home with his roommate Henry Rollins. Henry has told the story many times.
I knew that story through unsolved mysteries! Never knew cole was hole roadie
Hole WAS a great band.
Henrik högberg Courtney, Eric, Patty, and Kristen forevere
Ang dust in the sun Courtney love the freddy mercuryhollamd.hill rd little.Evie prior.reincarnations8....
The good dude no Joseph f mastronardis production no.love just provide adderall anytime anyyear...
still is imo. courtney has released great songs after hole, you know my name and miss narcissist
I agree. I don't understand why some Nirvana fans don't like when you are a fan of both Nirvana and Hole. I get it that losing Kurt Cobain was a shock and fans are still missing him. The police ruled Kurt's death a suicide. I used to believe that Courtney had Kurt killed, as the popular theory went. Now I'm not so sure if I believe that. Kurt was depressed. Kurt did struggle with a mental illness. He was a beautiful, gentle soul, but he was tormented. Courtney is a trainwreck, but she owns it and I respect that. Was Courtney the best wife on earth? Or have the best character or integrity on earth? Well... No. Nobody is perfect. She is a brilliant writer and musician though, in my opinion. She's not dumb. She made an ass out of herself when she was using heavy, absolutely... But she is an incredibly intelligent woman.
It was easy to jump on the "Hate and Blame Courtney Love" bandwagon. While many of Tom Grant's revelations were suspicious and Courtney looked guilty, doesn't mean she actually was. Kurt did love Courtney. Courtney couldn't be faithful, and he was really hurting over that, among other things. He was stressed out. He didn't want fame and excessive wealth. He enjoyed playing and singing, performing, until he didn't. Courtney was a songwriter and musician before she met Kurt, and actually pushed him to become more known in the grunge scene. She saw the potential Nirvana had.
To act as if Courtney Love was just some bimbo groupie who rode the coattails of her husband's success, is so ignorant. They both became big in the Grunge genre around the same time. The woman had her own talent and career. What happened was unfortunate, but let's face it... Two successful rockstars with heroin addictions and underlying mental health issues get married and have a child. Recipe for disaster. Heroin is a bad animal that steals your soul. You can also can be wealthy and successful and want to kill yourself.
Sorry for the article here. I just wish Nirvana fans didn't alienate or hate on those of us who also like the band Hole.
"Asking for it" is the name to this song by the way. Live through this is the name of the album
AlieNation is this is a mashup?
I swear I would die for you! Such simple lyrics, yet so haunting
Some of those photos are really beautiful shots of K&C
There is something very sad about the reality of this song
The fact that She KILLED KURT!!! He wrote al those songs!! Why couldn't she write anything good since??? Idiot
What makes me sad is both Kurt Cobain and Kristen Pfaff (the bassist of Hole) died not long after this. And they are the core of this song mostly because of Kurt's guitar and Kristen's bass combination. Both of them didn't live through this and died so young.
The title of album is SO eerie...spooks me,r.i.p. Kristen Pfaff,she was so beautiful ALSO alumni of 'the unlucky 27 club'
@@ferise1 HAHAHAHAHA
ferise1 were you there? No. Now could you please do us all a massive favour and shut the fuck up.
It’s interesting that Courtney sings “if you live through this with me” while Kurt just sings “if you live through this”. Maybe, to him, it was only important for Courtney to survive.
2:07 came the tears 😢 I replayed it over and over cause it didnt hurt enough the first time. 🖤🔪
Shit, u give up , I’m lissenen to Doors Stranger Days, let’s hear it
For President Harris!
If u Live thru this .... I swear I would die for u.....
Farrah D you can hear the love in the duets parts.....like there fighting to keep going together...
Best line!
She KILLED KURT!!! He wrote al those songs!! Why couldn't she write anything good since??? Idiot
Did she
@@ferise1 Courtney isn't smart enough to murder kurt & she did write her own songs maybe you should actually believe that she is talented lyricially even though your sounds a bit misogynistic to me 😬
Both of them have an amazing voice!
if you live thur this you can here the love in the smile that came over her voice when he walked in and started a duet in there home studio....
“If ya live through this i swear ‘i would die for YOU” I’d die for ya”.
Her face @ 1:23 kurt’s hand on her face,nostrils & ears pulled 😉
So eery!
Every time that, I sell myself to you
I feel a little bit cheaper, than I need to
I will tear the petals, off of you
Rose red, I will make you tell the truth
Was she asking for it?
Was she asking nice?
If she was asking for it
Did she ask you twice?
Every time, that I stare into the sun
Angel dust, and my dress just comes undone
N' every time that I stare into the sun
Be a model, or just look like one
Wild-eyed, rot-gut, do me in
Do you think, you can make me do it again?
Was she askin' for it?
Was she askin' nice?
If she was askin' for it
Did she ask you twice?
If you live through this, with me
I swear that, I will die for you
An', if you live through this, with me
I swear that, I will die for you
Was she askin' for it?
Was she askin' nice?
If she was askin' for it
Did she ask you twice?
Was she askin' for it?
Was she askin' nice?
If she was askin' for it
Did she ask you twice?
'90'S WILL LIVE ON BECAUSE THE STORIES ARE THRU THE INTERNET RAISE!
Idiot. Kurt wrote all those songs
@@ferise1 no
@@josefa-yb4lw duuuuh
Ya, I'm very, VERY, sure that the lyrics you posted ARE NOT quite accurate!!
Goddamn great album.I was a senior in high school when Kurt died,I consider myself lucky to have had such an amazing soundtrack to my adolescents .I feel bad for kids now...
ShootStuff I’m 13 and I hate the music on the radio now I wish it was all like this now honestly it must of been amazing when the recent music back then was like this
Don't. They can listen to this as well as everything else you listened to, and then some. Pirated in studio quality from the internet ;)
Same for me
nah man I'm sixteen and this will still be the soundtrack to my adolescents.
Beth you're just sucking up to oldies, you don't believe what you say you perceive us as oldies quit lyin you pos
‘Hole’ (from 1993 - 2002) is:
-------------------------
Courtney Love - Lead Vocals and Rhythm Guitar
------------------------
Eric Erlanderson - Lead Guitar
------------------------
Kristen Pfaff/ Melissa Auf der Maur - Bass, piano’s, backing vocals
------------------------
Patty Schemel - Drums
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
‘Hole’ from (2009 - 2012) is:
------------------------
Courtney Love - Lead Vocals and Electric Guitar
-------------------------
Micko Larkin - Acoustic Guitar
-------------------------
Shawn Daily - Bass
-------------------------
Stu Fisher - Drums
-------------------------
qué gran canción. y el disco este de hole es uno de los mejores discos que hay.
Makes you wonder what would have happened to Kurt if he could have gotten clean from the drugs? He was the John Lennon of my Generation .
kindly do not compare kurt cobain to john lennon, he was a woman beater and a racist thank you
John Lennon was pretentious
this is actually a pretty good song
The greatest punk album of the 90's
Wow great it's like bringing Kurt back for a final bow!
Great music, great moment of Hole ❤️❤️
I love this sm, Ive been watching this on repeat
HAPPY BIRTHDAY COURTNEY LOVE 💗💗💗💗 I LOVE YOU BABEZ
So beautiful
Just imagine if Kurt had been prepared, how much more immense Live Through This would have been.....
From my heavenly perspective, love lives through All this. 🌾
its like listing to his suicide note at the end . she did annd he did, dame i miss the mighty K C
Great version.
2:45 best moment
This is beautiful I am crying
I’m so sorry for them
That pic in the leather jackets and sunglasses is so cute. I had no idea that she was so much bigger than him!
its probably bc shes more on the front and hes way at the back, theyre the same height as seen in vids and photos, but its also possible courtney was wearing heels haha, but yeah cute small kurt :3
Miss this duo so much everyday. Wish I was present during this era to see such great music release. It truly is such a shame that their love was so toxic, you could tell it was true but hurtful to the both of them. This song is truly so sad to think about because they didn’t live through this and neither did Kristen
Love this💖😢 beautiful ❤️💯
Thank god I discovered this song
This is pretty good
Fun fact kurt wrote this song with kristen ptaff who shortly died a month after kurt did from a mixed hot shot
Kurt didn’t write none of her songs keep spreading more and more lies
The producers have said in many interviews that the song was written in the studio with the band. Kurt came into the studio high off his rocker and sang only the chorus because he had to learn the song first.
does it feel good spreading false information on internet?
This version is better than the album
I prefer this over the song we got
i love these pics
@TTFPouyii what?
Lost a old friend. Nick Bonds this one goes up to you old friend!
Love ❤
Im gonna cry😭💕
Cool ❤
STILL a great duo.
I love Kurt
Wonder if they would have went the john and yoko route and put out music together after kurt leaves nirvana
I don’t think they really every wanted to I wish they made songs together or atleast Kurt cover some of holes songs mainly because hole was becoming more known and not underground it wasnt really as popular some people claim hole as like the sister band to Nirvana a band that has a Kurt influence since some of the songs definitely seem like Nirvana songs
@@hehasnolips1371Actually, Kurt himself in an interview mentioned that when he played with Hole it was an energy so great and he played so well with them he’d give up Nirvana to play with them more. That’s why we probably see Kurt have so much influence on so many songs in Hole’s discography but not so much influence from Courtney in Nirvana songs. I’m sure he would’ve definitely played more with Hole and maybe even started projects with them had he just left Nirvana and stayed alive.
if u live through this i swear that i would die for u
I fucking LOVE this song, holy heck
Hearing this song for the first time after a breakup hurts rip kurt
Kurt started singing at about 1:10 . I can hear his voice😢.
That’s most likely Kristen or Courtney because Everyone had been working on this version together including Kurt for just the backing vocals at the bridge
i love it
his voice :(
You have to wonder how much of the look was orchestrated, and how much of it was just the norm.
This was the norm in a day in a life. I lived through it and they were apart of it. It wasn't orchestrated. It was a generation, a movement. That eventually like everything ends. Hopefully, is found again. I think it might have for real this time...current events.
The song is called Asking for it
Live through this xx
love courtney or hate her, this album is perfect from start to finish
I love Hole and Nirvana but it's highly suspect that she comes out with an album with this title right when Kurt dies the way he did.
the album was going to be released before Kurt passed but because of his health problems got pushed back to April. The album title is a quote by Scarlett from Gone with the Wind. It was chosen in 1992 after all the negative press she had. Kurt D in 1994...
I thought the same thing, I have never heard this song before didn't know that they made songs together. Interesting lyrics though, hope that's why he didn't die. Miss him. ❤❤
i wonder why this original version didn't end up being on the album
Well, he wrote it, he may as well as sing on it.
I could always hear him on it even back in the day on the released version, just barely in the mix, but singing the same as her.
It's Asking For It ;)
Acceptable...
This is so cute
La voz de Kristen :(
La amo. RIP Kristen Pfaff
This song is called Asking For It
Grunge forever!
I dont think Kurt didnt love Courtney. Wish he was alive 😔
'ASKING FOR IT' is the name of the song. I hate when people do this.
Would like to hear a cobain only version. Maybe with dave harmonising. Ie a nirvana version.
this is a hole song, not a nirvana song lmao
Holey Moley!
He kept his end of the bargain
2:07 kurt sings
Beautiful daughter Francis Bean 💟
That isn't Kurt Cobain at 2:08. That's some dumb ass dubbing on top of the track. Kurt just sings the lines "Live through this i swear that i would die for you" from the second and third verse.
Doesn't sound like him to me either.
@@MakeMeLo I wish they would release the last songs he recorded I can hear what Kurt sounds like when he tries to sing before I die. He was preparing to do an acoustic folk rock collab record with Michael Stipe, which Stipe has confirmed. I've read that's what Courtney and him were supposedly arguing about in Rome and the night the police found him in the closet because she was afraid they'd lose money because the fans would see him as a sellout.
Where you can find this version of this song to stream or purchase? This is not the album version. I like this one better.
🌹
Did Kurt help write the songs it kind of sounds like it's me?
The best female scream / roar in rock now belongs to Avienne of the band VINTERSEA , keep them on your radar , gonna put the Pacific Northwest back on the map soooon
I love the way they loved
When love is not enough it is not love at all. Courtney admitted having Frances to try to save their marriage. That is a trap. That is NOT love.
@@heirrose1606she got pregnant in like november of 1991 way before they were married so what you’re saying makes zero sense. iirc, what she DID say is she didn’t think their relationship would’ve lasted long if it wasn’t for frances
Where is the rest of the song thats 3 now.
Or so, oh well.
Damn she was so B E A UTIFUL bak n the days of “HOLE” esp. like on “Malibu” video. Omg kurt waz up on this version ya selfish bastard?!👀🏩🚗
I can't get past her!!!
I can barley hear Kurt tho
Colby Ainslie yo for real.this is the school.of visual arts church of silver.tiles thks stars and stripes.please restore.....
k Maz what
You can barley hear Kurt and I can wheat hear Courtney 🤡
why they didnt sing together longer
Why is this not on spotify!
it is, it's called asking for it BUT IT'S WITHOUT KURT SADLY
Kurdt . Nice.
nice
💚
💕
Haters will follow you FOREVER!!!!!….and so will the ones that LOVE YOU!!!!…
Which one will you choose???