Understanding the Sunni-Shia Split | Dr. Shabir Ally
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 มิ.ย. 2024
- Dr. Shabir Ally addresses the popular, and often misunderstood, topic of why there are two major branches of the Islamic faith: Sunni and Shia Islam. He also shares his insights on the importance of keeping harmony within the faith, while respecting the few differences that came about following the death of the Prophet.
Like us on Facebook at / letthequranspeak
www.quranspeaks.com
For your FREE copy of the English Quran, visit: www.quranspeaks.com/free-quran/
![[UNCUT]"เศรษฐา" โดนบีบให้ลาออก เผยดีลลับ "ทักษิณ" ต้องต่อโปร ไม่งั้นเจอจุดจบ! I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XlH3k81dxmE/mqdefault.jpg)
I am not a Muslim, but I have listened to a few of your videos today. Dr Ally, I am impressed by your level-headedness and open-mindedness. Thank you!
Helen read the Quran yourself you will gain huge knowlege
@salmanura Suleimani is a fraud. And no, i not a wahabbi.
@@claudiotavares9580 I don’t think hes a wahabi
@@hvkhbojnlinlubobilib3220 I didn't say that he is, i said i am not.
If you want to know Islam then listen Farooque Razvi Sahab all Taqrir in youtube.
salam to all sunni and shia from a uk muslim revert allahu akbar
Watch these videos for the sake of educating yourself:
Shia or Sunni? The Qur'an answers:
th-cam.com/video/wuRE4Ck-w-4/w-d-xo.html
Who to follow after the prophet?
th-cam.com/video/YYjynD09onI/w-d-xo.html
The prophecies about the Twelver Shia Islam:
th-cam.com/video/TFB36_X0grM/w-d-xo.html
Walaikum Assalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu brother.
W alykum asslam wa rahmatullah WA brakatuhu welcome brother.
وعلیکم السلام ورحمۃ اللہ وبرکاتہ
Wa alaykum salaam wa rahmatullah
" HOLD THE ROPE ALLAH !
BE NOT DIVIDED !
BELIEVERS ARE BROTHERS ! ".
U yoo
❤️
Watch these videos for the sake of educating yourself:
Shia or Sunni? The Qur'an answers:
th-cam.com/video/wuRE4Ck-w-4/w-d-xo.html
Who started the sects in the Islam?
th-cam.com/video/RaEAzNp4w3Y/w-d-xo.html
Who to follow after the prophet?
th-cam.com/video/YYjynD09onI/w-d-xo.html
The prophecies about the Twelver Shia Islam:
th-cam.com/video/TFB36_X0grM/w-d-xo.html
We must unite by one God Allah
There's no reason to the split of sunni and shia persist today. We must unite again.
LOVE ALL MY SUNNI BROTHERS AND SISTERS. PEACE BE UPON YOU.
From your Shia brother from ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN.
+Falis I was pointing to my Sunni fellows. Not to you wahhabi ISIL members who only have a mask of Islam.
+nomercy2406
I know brother. In any religion in the world you shouldn't discuss things with extremists of that faith. This guy Falis like other ISIL members calls you Kafir only because you show your love to the family of your prophet. Let him do that. He will be ashamed anyways.
+Tent Kittingham You are absolutely and definitely correct brother. Unfortunately I didn't have any other words to use to reach out to those brothers/sisters who call themselves Sunni. Otherwise anyone who says: La elaha ellaAllah, Mohammadan RasoolAllah, is a Muslim, no matter what.
After that it's completely personal if anyone follows, loves and respects the family of Prophet PBUH first or others. Hadith Saghalein حدیث ثقلین:
"انی تارک فیکم الثقلین کتاب الله وعترتی اهل بیتی ما ان تمسکتم بهما لن تضلوا ابداً ولن یفترقا حتی یردا علیّ الحوض؛
"So I will leave you two valuable things after me. The Book of Allah, and My family. As long as you follow these two, you won't get lost. These two won't be divided until they get returned to me at the Kowsar spring."
Or
اللهم صلی علی محمد و آل محمد
Peace be upon Mohammad and his family/descendant (in our prayers).
----------
Peace and Love brother
Brother why are u a Shia when there were no Shias at the time of the prophet. and why do u say such bad things about the companions of the prophet pbuh when the prophet pbuh loved them so much.
+Ali Mohiuddin Brother, If you look at it that way, then neither Shie nor Sunni did exist the time of our prophet. Shias don't consider Imam Ali higher than the prophet.
*So here are what Shia believes in order by priority:*
1- Allah (Sobhannallah Ta'ala)
2- Quran Majid and Prophet SalawatAllah.
3- Sunnah
4- Ahl-Albayt or family of the prophet and their teachings اهل البیت و العترت
5- Imam Ali as the next leader after prophet based on these three Hadiths
~ Ghadir Khom in Hajjatol-Veda غدیر خم فی الحج الوداع
~ Hadith Saghalayn حدیث ثقلین
~ Hadith Kasaa حدیث کسا
Now you tell me please. believing in these Hadiths is a crime that Shias must be beheaded because of that by Wahhabis?
And believing in the above items makes Shia Kafir?!
I am Shia and I love this guy. Speaks very humble and has a righteous mind. My best friend of 15 years is Sunni and we are brothers more than friends. We both go to mixed mosques Shia or Sunni and both welcome any one who wish to worship Allah. Leave all this politics bs behind and unite as one!
Inshallah that will be the only way forward we are uma of prophet Muhammad and bow to allah we need to unite and make efforts to unite
Let Iran stop its brutal occupation of Muslim countries and regions (Syria, Iraq, Yemen), Al-Ahwaz, and secular Lebanon, then we can talk and live and let live.
Iran (who claims to be a Muslim country) is more hostile, ruthless and brutal than the zionists, crusaders, Hindus, Buddhists …etc.
We read the same book, We have the same messenger, We prostrate to one God. We are One.
Except some believe Aisha RA commited adultery when in fact this claim was refuted by Allah in Quran in Surah Nur so if they read the same Quran then they should know not to insult the wife of the prophet, would the prophet not know if his wife committed adultery and stay with her? On the other hand some shias repsect the Sahaba but hold Ali in a higher status for some reason but this is fine as they are still Muslims.
You are wrong, Shi'a have their own kalima.
Some shi’a Ulema believe Qur’an is not preserved
GOod
@@kenkaneki9138 its not what u think pl!
Accepting Islam has been like being reborn- and seeing this split has made me feel that I was reborn into a broken family. I have learned from friends and teachers from both schools, but also found some very difficult people from both too. “Love both but identify with neither” has been my approach so far- and it is a lonely road.
Alex remain so
identity yourself only a muslim and the follower of Muhmammed PBUH. And pray that on the day of judgement Allah unites you with him.
Is there anything more you can desire my friend ?
Sadly, Islam is a broken religion
Salaam alaikum brother Alex, I pray that your life as a Muslim becomes easier and filled with grace, material and spiritual ease Ameen.
The thing about this world is that Allah swt created darkness alongside the light, and the ego is usually stronger than the soul in an individual, save for His mercy and guidance.
If we see each human as a unique human being first, who is then programmed into a faith system according to inheriting from their family of origin. It may be the case their soul isn't supported by those beliefs and they may shift afterwards.
Identities are usually very central to a person unless Allah swt helps them to smash all identities and to remember they are multidimensional souls with the essence of Divine within.
Being born into this faith of misogyny as well as varying narratives is something I contend with, especially when I began questioning my Shi'a roots of being so convinced they are correct to the exception of every other belief, and the Ahle Sunnah have exactly the same beliefs. And so do every other faith.
This might be to allow us to transcend this in time and follow what the heart and intuition as to what actually has happened and who are the people worthy of reverence and those who may have succumbed to their ego and the whispering of Shayateen.
Things don't become clearer, but it may inspire us to focus more on Irfaan and the Sufi aspects of the faith.
Once one is blessed with spiritual awakenings through meditation and murakkabah, things may become more expansive to the heart 💖 and the differences can be taken as historical facts and drama that belongs to others, and not us
@@skyejacques Aleykumselam, ramadan karim!
Becoming into sects has been already warned in The Quran it's self, but what can't be avoided is that Human will never agree with something, and that there's no people except that there's difference between them,
And All things is as the trial is, the religion which Allah has granted his prophet and whoever believes him is islam, and they are called muslims,
and these shia and sunni are not different islams rather it's a differences between Muslims themselves which they have caused, that shia disagree things with sunni So they Got to be a sects, the only difference between them started when the prophet died and some part has choosed Ali to be the Caliph while others choosed Abu Bakr to be the Caliph, So most people voted for Abu Bakr to be the ruler of the islamic empire After the prophet, and this caused the party who voted for Ali to split and become a shia and disagree with others,
And by the way Muslim is the only name given to a person who believes in Allah his messenger and follows the Quran, There's no shia nor sunni in the Religion of Allah it's what people who differed have created.
and note this verse:-
{وَلَا تَكُونُوا۟ كَٱلَّذِينَ تَفَرَّقُوا۟ وَٱخْتَلَفُوا۟ مِنۢ بَعْدِ مَا جَآءَهُمُ ٱلْبَيِّنَـٰتُ ۚ وَأُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ لَهُمْ عَذَابٌ عَظِيمٌۭ}
{And do not be like those who split ˹into sects˺ and differed after clear proofs had come to them.and It is they who will have a tremendous punishment}Ali imran verse-105
{مِنَ ٱلَّذِينَ فَرَّقُوا۟ دِينَهُمْ وَكَانُوا۟ شِيَعًۭا ۖ كُلُّ حِزْبٍۭ بِمَا لَدَيْهِمْ فَرِحُونَ}
{[and not be] of those who have divided their religion and become into sects, every faction rejoicing in what it has} Ar-Rum 32.
is it clear? So better not to put yourself into these factions, and the trial is that you will find Good and bad from everywhere and Allah is testing you if you would follow the desires of people who want to be different from others, and this is exactly what happened to the former Religions-the Religion of Moses and Jesus, And it caused many of them to bring new things into their Religion until it has totally changed.
So these have failed in the Taste and followed their own desire and a falsefied Books, So better not to pass through the same way the formers have passed.
So there can be no two ways to the truth, So the only muslim is who believes in Allah and All what he have commanded him, And I'm not saying that person is not muslim, and the judgment is for Allah, he will ask those who were happy with their faction, So be a true muslim! that's All and you will inshallah succeed!
I’m a shia and I respect this Dr. May Allah bless him.
I'm Christian with an interest in Islam we all brothers and sisters no matter what we believe please love each other and love our God peace
Matthew 12:46-50: 46 While Jesus was still talking to the crowd, his mother and brothers stood outside, wanting to speak to him. 47 Someone told him, “Your mother and brothers are standing outside, wanting to speak to you.”
48 He replied to him, “Who is my mother, and who are my brothers?” 49 Pointing to his disciples, he said, “Here are my mother and my brothers. 50 For whoever does the will of my Father in heaven is my brother and sister and mother.”
John 6:40: 40 For my Father’s will is that everyone who looks to the Son and believes in him shall have eternal life, and I will raise them up at the last day.”
Lee Thomas repent from your lukewarm ways, and sinful (or evil) ways of thinking. stop selling muslims a false dream or hope and tell them to repent and be baptised in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit for the remission of their sins.
@@chuckchuck80 John 6:40: 40 For my Father’s will is that everyone who looks to the Son and believes in him shall have eternal life, and I will raise them up at the last day.”
We believe at the time of Jesus this is 100% true. Here Jesus makes a distinction between him and the father and speak's of father's will aka God's will and believe in Jesus shall have eternal life, here Jesus said to believe in Jesus as simple as that and we Muslims believe that at the time of Jesus you need to believe in Jesus to attain eternal life.
@@kenkaneki9138 so you believe Jesus is or was a means to attaining eternal life or is he the only means to attaining eternal life?
@@chuckchuck80 was at his time as was every prophet at his time, now its prophet Muhammad's time so come back to the real religion and preaching of Jesus.
@@chuckchuck80 i would suggest both of you brothers to watch “similarities between Christianity and islam" by dr zakis naik
I'm sunni muslim, as-salamu'alaykum to my brothers sunnis and shias, we are not so different, we must unite! We also love Ahli Beyt a.s, but if we want to unite, we must go back beyond our devide, and that is Qur'an and example of Prophet Muhammad sallallahu'alejhi wa 'alihi wa sellem
Brother how can you love ahlul bayt (AS) and love the killers and people that hurt ahlul bayt (AS)
@@shadishour407 Bro I can tell you no one from Sunni side likes the killers of Ali and Hussein. It’s literally common sense and it was a wrong thing. May Allah curse the killers of Hussein.
@@darkvaderr6062 I think another issue is that people downplay the story of Hussein RA, if it wasn't for him Islam wouldn't have grown he took a stand against tyranny and not many people know his story and sacrifice because over time politics and separation of Muslims let differences grow so people think that love and knowledge of ahlul bayt only belongs to shias, at the same time shias feel that there is a disrespect when people dismiss the actions that the ummayds like muawiya took against ahlul bayt and the suhaba like the battle of siffin where many suhaba died because of the battle even tho all muslims knew the haq was with Ali RA even the prophet PBUH fortold that a fitnah will happen within the ummah and the fault will be with the transgressors that killed Ammar RA, the prophet PBUH also said that those who go to war with my ahlul bayt go to war with me and he also said to hold on to two things so we dont go astray and that was the Quran and his Ahlul Bayt and he said that three times so shia feel and love deeply for the Ahlul bayt as do many sunnis but they see many sunnis as dismissing certain historical events and downplaying events thats why many of them dont want to unite and i can understand what they mean because not all of us are taught enough on islamic history.
May Allah guide us all Ameen
@@darkvaderr6062 I forgot to add one thing so edited my last comment
True we need to unite,insha Allah.
I’m Shia and l have a lot of Sunni friends that they’re like brother to me.
I'm from a sunny background, and in many issues I go to some shii fatwa 🌺
Why are there some Shi'as who insult the sahabas
We are all brothers sunni or shia, sunni here ✋
@@msq5980 why are there some sunnis who call shias kaffir, rafidi or murtad? The point is there are extremists on both sides.
@@abbz753 so that is equal to insulting the companions of rasulullah? Shia's practices are out of Islam
I'm a Shia and I have so much love and respect to this honest scholar May Allah bless you and all muslims I wish all shia and Sunni scholars were like him as we my brothers are all victims of political agendas, always remember Allah is most knowledgeable most merciful more merciful then a mother with her own son
Muslims will unite soon In Sha Allah, Ameen!
Ameen
Ameen
Aaamen
Ameen
@@MyDavidlynch for me Religion Is Freedom. one who serves his Creator, that in a truer sense is what freedom is all about.
I vote for Ali (as) because he has the all knowledge of Quran and he is the most victorious in all battles of Islam and a true protector of Prophet and his deen Islam.
As a 65 yr old white man from USA, born and "conditioned" in the 'conservative right' branch? Of christianity? I "broke out"? Of such? 35 yrs ago? Not intentionally? But because of work with inter. Human Rights. My times in Bangladesh, Indonesia, Pakistan, and South Sudan...brought me to my knees upon hearing the 'call to prayers' in humble adoration!!! I still love to hear such!!! In the opening of this video!!! (I've been left bleeding and dying from "religion". But TRUE-TRUTH won't let me rest. I passionately reach for it!!! And LOVE!!! The Muslim Call to Prayer!!!
It's about time we Muslims be a Sunni or Shia put our differences aside and unite. Too much blood had been spilled and nothing gained except regret, sorrow and loss. We shall respect people of other religions too and may Allah grant us all peace and prosperity.
I'm a Sunni and i have Shia freinds, they are good as gold. Respect each others customs.
You wrote Sunni in capital letters and
Shia in lower case letters which makes one question your sincerity.
Dante Rizo Thank you for you input Rizo it was a simple case of my spell check not having that word and me not noticing.
On youtube you can correct your mistakes, and pretend like it never happened.
You are lucky to have shia friends, then why you have no courage to adopt the direct path of connectivity of the family of prophet ? sunnimunafiq@yahoo.com
I am a Shai and I have Sunni friends, and they are one of the most loyal and loving people I have met. We shouldn’t judge people by their religions and beliefs, but should judge them by their actions.
I'm a Muslim and I follow Islam and authentic hadith
*"انمالمومنون الاخوة"*
Sunni
Watch these videos for the sake of educating yourself:
Shia or Sunni? The Qur'an answers:
th-cam.com/video/wuRE4Ck-w-4/w-d-xo.html
Who started the sects in the Islam?
th-cam.com/video/RaEAzNp4w3Y/w-d-xo.html
Who to follow after the prophet?
th-cam.com/video/YYjynD09onI/w-d-xo.html
The prophecies about the Twelver Shia Islam:
th-cam.com/video/TFB36_X0grM/w-d-xo.html
he is a true muslim.we should encourage people to unite, rather then to divide
we have to whorship GOD with truth not with forged allegations about sahaba
BEWARE! BEWARE!
Shabir Ally is a misguided individual who have left the ways of the Salaf & who thinks himself as someone knowledgable, & knows everything. He holds agnostic type belief & is a strict follower of modern scientism, & trying to reconciliate Islām with scientific theories which he thinks are fact & criteria to check truth! The form of Islam he tries to spread is alien to true Islām. Shamelessly rejecting Ahaadeeth which were found authentic bc it goes against his weak scientifically rational mind, this guy's seem to reject even some core matters of Aqeedah inorder to please the kuffaar, calling for interfaith! & excusing original disbelievers with not making Takfīr on them, giving hope that they may enter Jannah! May ALLAH guide you or deal with you!
@@suaydibrahym718 I think he is fairly balanced and is trying his best
Suayd Ibrahym brother we know that Allah says in the Quran , u have the word of God and the best example the prophet
We know that the prophet a.s said on his last hutba speech The only way to Allah is Quran and sunnah , Anyone who rejects these two is in big loss
Question are shia fallowing Quran and Hadith? No
Better to be divided in truth then united in a lie.
We should forget all the political differences what happened in past.
And should start follow the QURAN AND SUNNAH.
QURAN AND AHLULBAYT
theres no thing as quran and sunnah, it is a farce!
Faster Hard House there is no bigger sunnah than the ahlulbayt from Fatima, Hassan and Hussain til imam Mahdi... this is the sunnah of rasoolilah... plus prophet saw said ‘I leave for you two weighty thing make sure you keep them close to you. The quran and my ahlulbayt’ also ruling out the argument that the Quran was compiled after the death of the prophet,. How can the Quran be complied after is rasoolilah already said ‘I leave for you these two things’
@@MogguSama QURAN and SUNNAH ---> WHICH TEACHES LOVE OF AHLULBAYT
nadeem arbaaz Because, the Quran is narrated and so is his sayings and doings. Also, the prophet married Aisha (ra) so she could remember the sunnah of the prophet sallahu alayhi wa sallam.
@@louiscarter-adams4226 Quran and Ahlul Bayt. Not Quran and Sunnah. Do your research. Even Sunni scholars admit that the "Quran and sunnah" hadith is weak, and the "Quran and Ahlul bayt" hadith is undeniable.
Masha'Allah ,Shabir says it as it is.. No one can dispute what he has clarified!
As a Shia I would like to clarify that we DO NOT believe that the Holy Quran was changed. This is completely incorrect, and quite frankly deceiving. The authenticity of the Holy Quran is among the most exalted miracles of Allah the almighty. Do not lead people astray sheikh.
These are SHAKHOL SHAITAN Brother !
yes! they represent the Shaitan ,not Allah & his messenger !
***** You've been mislead brother, there is no such clam in the Shia school of thought. And he isn't just our last Imam, he is of all the muslim ummah, Imam Mahdi (A.S).
***** show me where the Shia claim the Quran is incomplete.
That is your hate filled propaganda that the Zionist Saudi royals are making sure you have a fitna, for their true master is Al Zion.
Wake up to the trap and ASK who benefits from Muslims hating and killing each other.
Do not be a tool of satan
Henok, you are like a little girl being chased around the block. You are all over the place. Answer my first question, where is the proof that we believe the Quran is incomplete, then I will adress your other wahabi infentile questions
Wa Ajjil farajah
Prophet Muhammad (Saw) said to Ali "You are to me as Harun was to Moses only that there is no prophet after me"
Sahih al Bukhari
James71 This hadith is not evidence of khilafah of Ali radiyallahu anhu after the death of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, because the comparison is with Haroon alayhi assalam, and Harun alayhi assalam died before Musa alayhi assalam and thus was never his successor after him.The following is an explanation by al Qurtubi -rahimahu Allah- in his tafsir (tafseer of ayah 2:30)
@Afghan Jalebi Astonishing, really astonishing…. and disappointing... it’s a cherry-picked, selective... farrago... distorted and self-serving interpretation of Hadith... absolutely ameature deduction, I think you even don’t know a basics of Sciences of Interpretation. Hadith and Quran…if you sincerely want to understand… let me help you and quote from Quran...
القرآن: إِنَّ مَثَلَ عِيسَىٰ عِندَ اللَّهِ كَمَثَلِ آدَمَ۔۔۔۔
[The similitude of Jesus before Allah is as that of Adam۔۔۔۔]
*[if to follow your method of reasoning]*
Tell me how come Jesus similitude Adam? Where;
*Adam*
_No father No mother_
_Adam is Father of Mankind_
_Mankind Begotten from Him_
*Jesus*
_Begotten from a mother_
_Came many years after Adam_
_Mankind not begotten from him_
being similitude doesn’t infer a meaning of an “absolute similitude” even Logically it’s not possible to have “2” different people in different times absolutely similitude of each other…Now here goes the Orignal [text] of Hadith. الحدیث: أنتَ مِنِّي بمَنزِلَةِ ہَارونَ مِن مُوسَي إلا أنَّہ لانَبيَّ
Muhammad[PBUH] had never used any word describing to similitude. He has used a beautiful Word “بمَنزِلَةِ” Meaning *Ali your ‘‘Position/Designation” to me is like Haroon was to Moses.*
Now Lets Quran Tell What Haroon was to Moses… what quran has to say about the designation of Haroon... here you Go!
القرآن: وَقَالَ مُوسَىٰ لِأَخِيهِ هَارُونَ اخْلُفْنِي فِي قَوْمِي وَأَصْلِحْ
[Moses Said! O Haroon *My Brother* You’re *my Caliph* among people….]
Pls. Take time and look it at again…
Open the quran at your home and try to thoroughly explore this Ayah…
Look at the word Quran has bring in… اخْلُفْنِي you see… *‘‘My Caliph’’*
May Almighty Help you to understand…
James71 the Prophet (pbuh) also said: If there was a to come a messenger after me it would have been Umar (ra). So whats your point? The prophet (pbuh) loved all his followers
1) The Isnaad of this tradition is not Sahih
2) This tradition contradicts with Quran
Additionally, there's no prophet after him therefore no point of discussion :)
Orginal Fake
Sahih al Bukhari
Volume 5, Book 59, Number 700:
Narrated Sad: Allah’s Apostle set out for Tabuk. appointing ‘Ali as his deputy (in Medina). ‘Ali said, “Do you want to leave me with the children and women?” The Prophet said, “Will you not be pleased that you will be to me like Aaron (Harun) to Moses (Musa)? But there will be no prophet after me.”
Translated by some like this: (‘Your relation to me shall be like the relation of Harun to Musa…) & (You hold in relation to me the same position as Harun held in relation to Musa)
Hadith in Arabic:
عَنْ مُصْعَبِ بْنِ سَعْدٍ عَنْ أَبِيهِ أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ خَرَجَ إِلَى تَبُوكَ وَاسْتَخْلَفَ عَلِيًّا فَقَالَ أَتُخَلِّفُنِي فِي الصِّبْيَانِ وَالنِّسَاءِ قَالَ أَلَا تَرْضَى أَنْ تَكُونَ مِنِّي بِمَنْزِلَةِ هَارُونَ مِنْ مُوسَى إِلَّا أَنَّهُ لَيْسَ نَبِيٌّ بَعْدِي
This hadith is not evidence of khilafah of Ali radiyallahu anhu after the death of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, because the comparison is with Haroon alayhi assalam, and Harun alayhi assalam died before Musa alayhi assalam and thus was never his successor after him.The following is an explanation by al Qurtubi rahimahu Allah in his tafsir (tafseer of ayah 2:30) regarding this narration:
[There is no disagreement that the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam didn’t mean, by (saying) “you will be to me like Harun (Aaron) to Moses” the khilafah after him, and there is no disagreement that Haroon died before Musa alayhima assalam … and was not a khalifah after him, for the khalifah (successor of Musa) was Yusha’ bin Noon, so if he wanted by his saying “you will be to me like Harun to Moses” the khilafah, he would have said “you will be to me like Yusha’ was to Musa“, so when he didn’t say this it proved that he didn’t want that meaning, but he wanted that “you are my deputy over my family in my life and my abscence from my family, like Harun was deputy of Musa over his people when he left to speak to his Lord.]
Other scholars of ahl assunah explained it the same, him being deputy of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam over the women and children when he went to the battle of Tabuk just like Musa alayhi assalam left Harun alayhi assalam as his deputy when he went to his appointment with Allah ta’ala.
In a Shia site it says:
((To this we answer that whenever the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him and his family, left the Islamic capital, he would always appoint someone to act as his deputy. If by comparing Ali, peace be upon him, to Harun, the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him and his family, had intended nothing more than the usual appointment of a deputy, restricted in his authority to Madinah for the period of the Prophet’s absence, why did he not use a similar expression for those other favored Companions he would appoint as deputy? Why did he not use the same or similar words to describe the services they rendered?))
Answer: Those sahabah might have not asked the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam to go with him and not stay behind to watch who is left behind from women, children and others, so there was no need for him to tell them that, but Ali radiyallahu anhu objected to staying behind with children and women and not go to fight with the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, and he wanted to go to the battle instead, so the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said that to him, showing him that he would be to him, by staying behind watching over women and children, like Haroon was to Musa when he left him behind as a deputy over his people, and it is an honor and that he wouldn’t be less than the ones who went to fight in battle.
Again brother/sister, your argument to claim that Ali was the chosen Khalifa is wrong. I hope Allah guides you to understand that that wasnt the reality. I gave you proof and for every argument you have i will give more proof inshaAllah. May Allah guide you
This is an example of a true Muslim. We should unite and respect each other for the betterment of Muslims and humanity.
Read Quran everyday and never ignore your five daily prayers
Great work guys .. should have more informative videos like that . May Allah reward you for it .
Allah says in surah Anam ch:6 v156-159 those who make sects in the religion of islam O prophet you have nothing to do with them .
+hadi nazzal
You are too late !
You should have been around when Abu bakar & umar were running the show ! they were the first one who broke the Islam of muhammad(SAWA) apart !
+Guiding light I know you mean well, but dear, let's think. Are we better than Abu Bakr and Omar? Would we ever get the chance or honor to meet the prophet? I cannot hate anyone. I love all of them equally. Imam Ali(as), loved them too. So let's practice real Islam and forgive and unite
Nadine Chamas hello my brother do you understand arabic ?
أحبك بالله
+hadi nazzal Im a sister hehe. Sorry I can't read Arabic
Nadine Chamas oh sorry :)
Love Both Shia and Sunnis.
Some branch of siah like sunny,, but the other branch not like sunny
I’m Shia and I respect this guy so much he really needs to reach out to those people on TikTok who really create the real division
The problem is very much deeper than he discussed
I'm so grateful for your willingness to share and teach me this about the difference. Brilliant and sincerely presented
Its a promise of God that quran cant be changed. Shia sister
your elders don't bleve in Allah promise and say that this Quran is fake and your imam mahdey "" WILL "" bring the original Quran sooooo who is a """"" LIER """""
It´s just amazing how fair Dr. Shabir Ally is.
I am a Shia and I love my brother Dr. Shabir Ally. Masha Allah he is such a good brother.
But I have to say Shia does not believe Hadrat Ali's name was in the Quran. We have the same Quran just like our Sunny brothers.
mesmariland Mashallah and most Shia do believe in the Quran we have AH. Unfortunately my brother, many of the earliest Shia scholars believed that the Quran was corrupted as it did not mention the Imamate of Ali (i.e. that the Quran was changed by Sahabah). This is why the early Shia were not regarded as Muslims. Salaam.
May Allah unite all our Sunni-Shia brothers and sisters and make them to avoid all there past political differences😇
We should have more sheikhs like this one. Hats off to him
I just listened to Reza Aslan on his new book "Zealot" and totally liked his historical perspective. Then I listened to Dr. Ally on Reza Aslan and was impressed by Ally's objectivity. Now I've heard Dr. Ally on the Sunni / Shia split - again wonderfully objective. As an athiest I will now bookmark Dr. Ally as my reference point for a Muslim perspective on current affairs. Excellent. Plus I've subscribed to Qur' an Speaks - a breath of fresh air on all things Islaam. Thanks guys :)
@Jay Mathews you must be Christian brother. Rather than cherry picking verses out of context. I suggest you read the whole quran with context and InshaAllah you shall be rightly guided. We beleive in the Bible and we beleive in jesus and moses and all the other prophets. We beleive that virgin mary gave birth to jesus without a man ever touching her. You and i have more in common than you might fathom. Just start from surah Ale Imran and don't stop until you read the whole of it. Better yet read it after finishing reading bible. These are my suggestions and may Allah forgive if i have transgressed in any way and may he guide you Ameen!
@Jay Mathews you have a context of hate and violence with islam therefore you are blinded by it.
Reza aslan is such a terrible example to be mentioned regarding islam. lol
Peace be upon All my Sunni brothers and sisters.
But No Shia Believes that Quran has been Changed!
Our Quran doesn't differ with yours, actually the Quran of Uthman taha (Uthman Taha hand writing) is one of the most popular in Iran.
This is a big mistake to think Shiites Quran differ to Sunnis.
maybe you don't differ with the sunnis with regards to the Quran but many of your scholars in Iran and Iraq still think the Quran has been tampered with, they use Taqya many times which as per Sunni understanding has no place when there is no need for it (ie. when your life is not in danger or you are not severly threatened) you are bound to speak the truth about your beliefs (and everything else) see: islamqa.info/en/175632
Just hear what Kamal al haidary or Yasir al Habeeb or Ali al Sistani or Khamenai or the late Khomeni have to say about: Tawheed, preservation of Quran, Iman of the Sahabah or any other article of faith and you will notice the difference between people of sunnah and the rawafidh, or read your classical books such as al Kafi and Bihar al anwar, compare it with the Quran, and if you are sincere you will surely be guided
+Tony Al, no I dont want to debate, plenty of filmed debates have alread taken place between sunni scholars and shiite students and you can check them up if you know Arabic, and we are much less than qualified to do that but I just need to clarify 2 points:
1-You talked about the orthodox understanding of taqya (a concession to save one's life or ward off terrible harm)
Allah says:(interpretation of meaning) Whoever disbelieves in Allah after his belief... except for one who is forced [to renounce his religion] while his heart is secure in faith. But those who [willingly] open their breasts to disbelief, upon them is wrath from Allah , and for them is a great punishment; Al Nahl (16:106) but what rafidis do is quite different, they hide their corrupt beliefs and pretend to be following the sunnah like any other muslim, you can find references to this corrupt kind of Taqya from your classical books like al Kafi here:
->www.discoveringislam.org/taqiya.htm
2-about what you mentionecd pertaining the "lost" verses mentioned in the sunni hadith books those are abrogated (mansookh) verses which the prophet commanded us to remove or not to count in the final Quran because Allah the almighty commanded him to do so not because people tampered with the revelation afterwards, not because of the whims and the desires of the noble caliphs of Islam as per the Rafidi claim, you can read the orthodox Islamic understanding concerning those verses here:
->islamqa.info/en/105746
Finally a sincere advise to you and all of the people who follow a shiite denomination please research about your religion; what your books say about tawheed, Iman of the companions of the Prophet or preservation of the Quran and so on, and then come back to the Sunnah (way) of the Prophet peace be upon him and to real tawheed (monotheism).
Useful link with many references:
www.discoveringislam.org/sunnis_vs_shia.htm
Al Mubadara
Iam shia.(IN arabic shia means followers) we are proud to be called shia of ali ibn abe talib or shia of ahlulbayt.
you must know some facts about shia beleif system:
1.The prophet mohammed(pbuh) order us in hajj al wada to follow 2 things :The quran and Ahlulbayt a.s
2..shia follow their imam and not sahaba because simply ahlulbayat or imam are the carrier of quran and its knowledge and they are batter than al sahaba .
3.shia imams are better than sahaba in everthing from knowledge to tafseer to courage and brave to ethics or akhlaq and patience with all people since thy are infallible. if you beleive that prophet mohammed(pbuh) was infallible then you should know that ahlulbayat were infallible too as they get their teaching from prophet mohammed(pbuh).if you dont then how allah subhano wa talla order us to follow his prophet if he was not infallible.in fact sunnei consider the prophet a regular person who can be wrong or fault ,sunneis donot beleif in infallibility
4.in order to know the importance of ahulu bayet or the imams ,i asked you to compare imam ali ibn abe talib with other sahaba,since the imams of shia are all sons of imam ali. and they have taken the values of imam ali both geneticaly and by teaching.
5.after the death of prophet omar ibn alkhatab burn the hadiths of the prophet so many hadiths will be added later and of course ,a forgery of hadiths and false hadiths had been created by enemeis of islam who pretend to be muslims which we call them al monafiqoon(hypocrites) and this is the main cause of division seen between muslims.
بنو العباس
6.You need to know that NOT ALL SAHABA(COMPANIANS) ARE GOOD
some would sacrice him self easily for the sake of prophet mohammed(pbuh)as imam ali was,others would argue or has doubts about what prophet said.others ran away from battles against islam enemeis leaving prophet mohammed alone except with his loyal followers .the quran said that clearly read it!!!!
Aliakbar Raefipoor Fans lol your name says Aliakbar? Do you know what that means?
Aliakbar Raefipoor Fans when he said that it showed he is dishonest
Thank you so much dear Dr. Shabbir Ally for your beautiful thought we do really appreciate your logical speech about sunni and shia's conflict and split or differences.
I really appreciate the way you gather the whole history to one main point which is Islam, Quran, Deen, Angels, live after death, hell and paradise plus books of Allah that we do believe and accept as a Muslim, Thank you so much, Turkey, Ankara
I have questions how can I reach you team?
This man just won my heart. thank you Dr. Shabir. May Allah bring ALL Muslims together and unite them under one banner which is the banner of ISLAM.
in sha Allah.
BEWARE! BEWARE!
Shabir Ally is a misguided individual who have left the ways of the Salaf & who thinks himself as someone knowledgable, & knows everything. He holds agnostic type belief & is a strict follower of modern scientism, & trying to reconciliate Islām with scientific theories which he thinks are fact & criteria to check truth! The form of Islam he tries to spread is alien to true Islām. Shamelessly rejecting Ahaadeeth which were found authentic bc it goes against his weak scientifically rational mind, this guy's seem to reject even some core matters of Aqeedah inorder to please the kuffaar, calling for interfaith! & excusing original disbelievers with not making Takfīr on them, giving hope that they may enter Jannah! May ALLAH guide you or deal with you!
Shiya and Sunni conflict was not just to find khalifa. It's more than that people don't want you to know. Shia believes Allah can come in any place, he can be Jesus , Ram & Krishna, or any religious God because all are the same supreme power in different Avtar.
But Sunni believe Allah is only one and last.
So they killed Ali (son & law) of abu bakar while he was doing his pray or slah.
Hence the reason conflict is haven't been solved or less likely!
@@suaydibrahym718 If you happen to know so much about this brother, Why don't you sit face to face in an intellectual argument and let us watch it live. Please give up this kind of back biting.
Well, I'm not muslim either, but what a great orator and communicator that Dr. Shabir is. I'm a professor and I'm amazed by his elegant and educated way to explain things even in such difficult matter. I'm sure that with people like you all matters can be solved.
Is the host the daughter of the speaker? Also what is dr shabbirs background and what fiqh/school is he from? Enlighten please im just wondering
Dr. Shabir Ally can you kindly expose elements of zionism involved in the split, I lost a document that documented this fact and the name of the man involved. Is there any books one can buy online that covers this topic.
Sunni and shia are muslim, we are brothers and sisters.
No, we are not. You can't brother someone who crosses Aiysha who is the wife of your prophet and Allah calls her the mother of believers. You can't brother people whose Athan, prayers, fasting, zakat, are all done differently. You can't brother people who cross Abu Bakr and Omar, the best of the Omma after the prophet!!!
Noor Friends but what did Allah say? ““And hold fast, all of you together, to the Rope of Allah, and be not divided among yourselves”. Shia are Muslims too, and thus part of the ummah. If you are going to hold millennia old grudges like that you’re only going against the teachings of our prophet and the words of Allah swt.
@@fai-pe7oq
Shias aren't Muslims
Shia's are not muslim .
@@hmmm3210 swerve, they say the Shahaadatayn, believe in Tawheed, Nubuwwah, Qiyaamah, angels and whatnot. So they categorically Muslim.
I'm sure Imam Ali(as) didn't mind if he was the 4th khalifa. We both believe in the same God, have the same Quran and we need to love one another and be united. When our awaited Jesus(as) and Mahdi(atf) return we will know the truth and the tenants of God and belief are the same and that's what we have to focus on. The fact that we are Muslims. Let's love one another
"Everyone" is kind of limited to the Shia. Which are a minority in Islam.
This issue was addressed by adnan rashid in his response to dr.ammar nakshwani
do the issue be gone, create peace in our current time to established unity to the next generation,so will Allah bless us all
We all Muslims have to forget about this issue, becouse now it doesn't matter. We have to believe in God and his prophe(SAS) and nothing else.
@@GrumpX Don't say wives. Its only towards Aisha.
Sunni Shia both read the same QURAN
No ask a Shia about his views about Quran!!!! You ll be amazed. They are taught that Quran is not complete! It has few missing verses! Unbelievable right??? Ask and see what they say.
but they don't interpret it the same way
Fefee10 says who? I’m Shia and I believe Quran is complete.
we need to concentrate on the present situation. forget whatever happened after the Prophet's death and especially after the completion of Islam. Simplify the equation or we will find ourselves in point of no return, a vicious circle. And Allah do not guide the Zalimun. The Qur'an speaks not to do sects, the Sunni were not the first to make a sect in Islam. If a decision was made for caliphate whats the point in making a sect afterwards. khallaas.
Omair Enam Event at Ghadeer Prophet Muhammad (SAW) appointed imam Ali as his successor.
In the end we are all Muslims and that’s what matters.
Just wondering, is the Original Quran still in existence? I.e was it preserved in a museum or other methods?
Bermingum university it's in
It's the oldest Quran ever founded dated back to prophet Mohamed's life time
@@retrogamingfrenzy2373 how did it get there?
Subscribed, Dr Ally speaks very eloquently.
i love this guy... lets put our difference apart and come together as one
Masha Allah excellent program, subjects and guest, a subscription is a must.
Stumbled on this chat, Dr Ally... intelligent ,calm, articulate and humble, How difficult is it really to focus on commonalities rather than differences, the core of our religious belief is the same.
One point that I'd like to include, Non neither Shia or Sunni said that the Qur'an was changed, referring to 8:18.
As muslims we do believe that Qur'an is the only Holy book that haven't been changed. When i say Holy book, I mean ones from God such as Torah, Zabur, bible and Quran of course.
We need to unite and forget our differences in this difficult times.
Jazak Allah khair, Nice explaination , eye opener for many brothers and sisters in Islam
_ As a Shiite we say that the Koran is the same as the time Prophet.
Being a shia. appreciate your remarks of being a family and have to get riddance of 1400 yrs conflict and should move forward to promote islam and brotherhood.
as a sunni i agree we do not need sects. we are all muslims and must unite. to promote islam as you said brother
I love Islam. My heart is sorrowful for any violence. For all those in refugee (virtual concentration camps -- not comparing to what the Nazis did), my heart goes out to you. Wouldn't it be a beautiful world where all religions could live in peace and harmony, and UNDERSTAND one another, even though we may not agree on all teachings. Peace be upon you, my Sunni, Shia, and Ahmadi brothers and sisters. This short film is filled with knowledge, insight and wisdom. It should be shared with all Americans. Muslims are not "the other." They are us. Muslim or not.
Glenn you have a peaceful heart. I wish you study miracle of Islam. From Pakistan.
i think most of us wants to leave peacefully. But some might not. İts really sad to see the division of us as human from bad to worst as times goes. İm sorry if i speak wrongly im not good in explaining.
Ahmadis and Shias aren't Muslims
@@hmmm3210 all are except you.
outstanding explanation. clarity of thought is superb.
Thank you. Now I understand. We should follow Allah, the Quran and our prophet Muhammad S.A.W. Things that happened in the past is something we should put behind us, and start focusing on how to be a better Muslims according to fardh and sunnah! :) InshaAllah
most clear & concise explanation...thank you Doctor Shabir Ally.
jul
Perhaps, Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, Judaism and all other beliefs in the ONE GOD...is the creators way of uniting us.............not a bad idea, right?
Daheshism.com/
Jules Rensch
RIGHT !
But ! My dear the idea of uniting is only good for this life ,not the one there after !
yes i am all for that the people of the world to be United against all the matters of LIFE ,yet the one for the next world ,we are all obligated to find the TRUTH & Follow it !
Dont you agree ?
I agree, irooni 100, yet perhaps ruth is constantly revealing itself...to us, as we need it...
I found this, perhaps you will find it interesting:
after 20 centuries, the new name of Christ is: Dahesh
..............................................................................
In the Holy Qur’an, it is also written that Christ’s Second Coming will be to warn people about the Day of Judgment:
“He [Christ] is a portent of the Hour of Doom. Have no doubt about its coming and follow me.” (Sura 43.61 Al-Zukhruf)
The Holy Qur’an also gives signs about the time of Christ’s Second Coming:
“When the heaven shall be rent asunder and turned red like pigment.” Sura 55.37 Al-Rahman)
All these spiritual sayings are further proofs that “Doomsday” will be brought about by a nuclear war-unless humanity reverses its course and change history. Such a reversal can only take place by man’s free will to accept salvation through Christ’s New Name: DAHESH
In the inspired book “Jesus of Nazareth,” by Dahesh, young Jesus, addresses his hometown as he is about to depart from it by saying:
“O City of Nazareth!
When my last hour draws near,
I shall depart from your midst
To return to you after twenty centuries…”
Theres more here:
Daheshism.com/
Salaam Alaikum, Observer Jules
Jules Rensch
Those are good ones you have said ,Brother !
But i dont think it is such good idea to consider the Dahesh as Christ ,that would be offending our Christian brothers & sisters !
Dahesh leaders are those who used to bow before Saddam Yazid in Iraq and now they are supported by the Enemies of Islam to take over the Islamic lands & they are not going to make it because Alhamdolillah Most Muslims are fully awake & aware !
Salaam !
Dear iroon100....
I don't think they are refering to the man Jesus..we both know that many of our Christian friends think that Jesus the Christ was God....others believe that Jesus and Buddha and Abraham and Moses and others were just "men" enlightened by our Creator...to bring us the message of the Divine'.
Mohammed being the latest of these messengers from Allah.
In the spirit of these revelations....all Messengers of the Divine are "Christ"
Dr. Dahesh was among us in the 20th century, performing miracles...interestinly there are people still alive, who knew him and were witness to his gift. I think he died in 1984. Anyway, thats what some believe.
Just an idea to consider.
I can tell you love investigating matters of Faith...so do I
salaam alaikum Jules
He forgot quickly what happened on the day of ghadeer khumm
Oh get over it please. Ali was and still is loved by Muslims and the companions would have made sure Ali became the first Caliph if that was a direct command of the prophet pbuh. There is no evidence that the prophet designated Ali as his successor. Shia went too far in their claims
@@osumanaaa9982 than why do Sunni scholars said the prophet just saying that Imam Ali is my friend, when it's clearly wrong because why would prophet waste everyone time saying get out of your homes I have important message than he gathered everyone he grabbed imam Ali hand said his muwla. Explain that why do you think muwla mean friend and why gathered everyone just to say his my friend
@@ItzSpekk Mawla does not mean Khalifa. The reason why he called him his Wali was when someone came to him and complained about Ali taking more from his share of war gains. That comes after he asked people in his speech to take care of his family ahl al bayth because as ahl al bayt, they cannot receive charity money. this is the reason why Moaouiya took care of Ali's family financially as well as the rest of the prophet's family. Also, if the prophet peace be upon him wanted to appoint Ali was his Khalifa, he would have done it when he was in Hajj where most of the Muslims from different tribes were gathered. Why would he wait until he left Mecca and stopped on the way in Ghadir to say that ? You guys hate and insult the prophet's closest friends and wife. How can you even claim to love him pbuh ??
@@osumanaaa9982 this is first time I heard this every Sunni scholar said means friend but you saying war and something and shia say means next successor. Now there's 3 stories. Do some research brother read sahih bukhari
@@ItzSpekkMawla has different meanings. I'm talking about the reason why the prophet said that. This is from authentic sources but I feel like you don't understand what I wrote (maybe I summarized too much). Please watch how shamsi explains it in a TH-cam video.
Thank You!
Actually the last haji ,prophet Mohammed declared Ali as him to guide people. But people decided to let Abubark to be ghalifa, but Ali didn’t say anything,because he didn’t want to separate people.I am Shia and I am proud of it.
If Ali had decided not to say anything, why would you say !!!!???
Then let me ask u something, why shia are not respecting the sahaba like abu bkar etc, on the other side, sunni respecting ali?
He's absolutely right. Islam isn't about the succession of the Kalifat, it's about the things that are mentioned in the Kuran and it's about believing into the almighty God, his books, prophets, angels, the day of resurrection, being a good and genuine person, praying, fasting in the month of Ramadan, Hajj pilgrimage etc.
Yes Islam is follow Quran and follow Rasool. simple. But if you worship dead people's graves,....then you are committing shirk! That makes Shias get out of circle of Islam if they do shirk and hate their Muslims brothers,...a Muslim can not hurt or harm another Muslim but Shias openly insult sahabis and Sunnis and Saudis! They just can't hide their hatred. Our Prophet was not a Shia,....and his sahabis were not Shias!
1. Mohammad (pbuh) did declare at Ghadeer in his last days that "man kunta maulah'a fahaza Ali'un maulah'a" and raised Ali's hand in front of thousands from all areas of the Muslim empire.
2. Ali was not happy with the forced decision of making Abu Bakr the caliph, and same when he appointed Umar after himself. Ali describes his emotions about those events in a firm manner in "Nahj-al-balagha" in his famous sermon called "Shaqshaqiya".
3. The sect Ahle sunnat Wal-jamaat or Sunni did not exist until Abu Hanifa after more than hundred years after the death of the Prophet (pbuh) started spreading it as a sect.
Having said that, I totally agree with Dr. Ally on how to deal with this situation today.
Thanks Ali Raza ;) everybody seems.to "forget" Ghadeer
ok, then answer my question, just a small logic. if muhammed s.a.w.s had the intention of appointing his successor then he had done it at a large gathering in mount arafath where there were large number of muslims present...why did he did at qom....when many of the muslims had left after their rituals.???
Shaqshaiya is interpoLation and misfabrication in Nehja uL baLagha because this sermon goes against many of the sermons of MouLa Ali (AS) which are written in this book soo pLease read nehja uL baLagha with a wide angLe and without a biased mind then you wiLL be abLe to see the truth but Listening onLy to your favourite zakirs who aLways bLow fire and spit poison from their mouth wiLL make you fight with other musLims who has a difference in opinion.
Why are we even fighting over this such an small issue, sunni & shia are Muslim , we belive in Allah we belive the last prophets Muhammad sallahu Alaihi wassalam , we have the faith, as a Sunni we love ahlulbyt we respect Ali ibni Abu talib , we Sunni Shia are one big Muslim family, why do we even argue over pitty things, who become first and last khalif does that really make difference, we need to stop fighting over it rather we stay unite as one as Muslim .
Sunni isn’t a Sect, sunnis are the mainstream, shiasm is a sect since it’s the smaller group who separated from the larger group (sunni)
Dr. Ally is great scholar. I got the opportunity to participate many of his Friday khutbah(Lecture), those were very helpful in getting a clear idea about religion and to build an inclusive society.
MashaAllah..
Now its quite clear now. Thanks
Ali was the best believer and ali was the clossesed to prophet Muhammad peace be upon him.
Abu bakr (ra) umar (ra) uthman (ra) Ali (ra) best of believers
I have watched so many TH-cam videos trying to understand the separation only to be left so much more confused. I want to know about different cultures and their beliefs. I want to understand the proper way to interact and speak respectively. America is such a huge melting pot; I feel it is so important to learn about the history and beliefs and religion of our neighbors to eliminate stereotypes and misconceptions.
Thank you so much for a clear understand.
Watch these videos for the sake of educating yourself:
Learn about Shia Islam and the logic behind it:
th-cam.com/video/d4IPqy3jYxE/w-d-xo.html
Who to follow after the prophet?
th-cam.com/video/YYjynD09onI/w-d-xo.html
The prophecies about the Twelver Shia Islam:
th-cam.com/video/TFB36_X0grM/w-d-xo.html
finally... i done watched about 5 videos trying to figure this out but when i saw this video with Dr. Shabir i knew this is where ill get the real answer.
I agree on open, tolerant and united ummah instead of fighting each other. Great message in the last part of the video about unity.
I find I like this guy, he is promoting tolerance. I'm not muslim but I would like to sit and talk with this guy.
Believe me !
you dont want to sit and talk with this guy !
He might be good about learning the Christian faith , yet he is dumb as the door knob when it comes to Islam !
Abby Babby I know! He is the hope for Islam extremism
Guiding light how come? Because he is open minded? And tolerant? Unlike many fundamentalist who continue to live in the 7th century
I love this man!
Excellently explained 👍🏻
beautifully said ...
My mum is from Syed family and my dad is from Quadi. But I choose Sunni over Shias. Reasons are many, some are here, 1. If a person believe Quran is wrong and has been twisted he can change whole faith. 2. If a person can insult and deny a wife of Prophet (pbuh) how can we count that person among believers when in Quran all of the wives of Prophet is mentioned as mother of believers? 3. When Ali (rad) himself took bayah of his early Caliphs how can we force him to be the first one? 4. Utman (rad) also was the husband of two daughters of Prophet(pbuh) why he should not be the first Caliph before Ali(rad)? 5. The people who can praise and celebrate a non muslim, non believer assassin, for killing a Muslim Leader and relative also a companion of Prophet (pbuh), how can they be friend of Muslims?
Brother, I don't have hate for Shias, and I like them, but I think everything went wrong after Hussain (rad) was killed. But I don't find any justification of Shiaism before this horrific incident. I see it in positive or negative in this two ways, 1. it was a Political Camouflage of extinct Persian empire's hypocrites and their hate towards Umar also prove that. 2. It was a product of immense grief among righteous Muslims after murder of Karbala.
Can anyone help me to understand these issues please?
Many of the reasons you mentioned are correct. Ignore Haider... let him spend his time better educating the Shia who worship Hussein in Karbala, or the Shia who cut themselves up, or the Shia who believe in infallible imams and so on
Imam Husain had Said to Yazid , if you kill me the Muslim sects would be divided . this is what happened , there has been a spilt in the Muslims . Yazid is responsible for this split not anyone else . Lanaat to Yazid and his troops
it is said his wife Aisha was not loyal to the Prophet (PBUH), hence Shias Oppose Prophet (PBUH) wife . Moula ALI has never given the rule to anyone when Prophet Mohammed (PBUH) selected him during his demise
May Allah give our scholars a long and fruitful life.
Watch these videos for the sake of educating yourself:
Learn about Shia Islam and the logic behind it:
th-cam.com/video/d4IPqy3jYxE/w-d-xo.html
Who to follow after the prophet?
th-cam.com/video/YYjynD09onI/w-d-xo.html
The prophecies about the Twelver Shia Islam:
th-cam.com/video/TFB36_X0grM/w-d-xo.html
Dr Ally is a clear voice of reason in the chaotic world of Islam. God bless him!
dr ally shabir may GOD bless you for you knowledge and posting all your fimlp on you tube amin !!!!!!!!!
Born a sunni but when I look in mirror, I see myself as Shia.
Tetra when you look in the mirror you see shaytan ... since that’s who shias follow
Astaghfirullah
Nicely explained, i am a Muslim from iran living in australia and agree we should unite! I dont consider my self sunni nor shia but a not very religious muslim n i believe being extremist causes more conflicts n those who ask to know if a muslim is shia or sunni are the root of all problems. In fact all people from all belief systems should love n cherish each other's company.
White people gog magog are the root of all murder and problems in muslim lands!!!! And you are not a muslim if you are not religious!!!!!!! Islam is a religion!!! USE YOUR BRAIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Im ashamed to say my knowledge is pretty limited on this matter. Glad I found this. Iv hurd the lecturer previously on other matters and really benefitted.
kindly make louder as i can’t really hear.Add more volume to your sound.
La ilaha illallah Muhammadur rasul allah
Quran never changed. Miss interpreted
This is enlightening. Jazakallah
Its just politics, silly. Unite in brotherhood.
These two make a fantastic duo!
You are a good man and a knowledgeable one at that. However, you conveniently omitted the facts from the event of Ghadir Khumm when Prophet announced Ali as his successor.
I am a Muslim and then a Shia. I have no problem with anyone, be them Muslim or non-Muslim.
Allah hu Akbar
@erfan lavari Agree with you 100%.
Alhamdolillah.
Ya Ali Madad.
Allah hu Akbar.
"this is the time when All Muslims have to be united for more than ever"##ALLAHUAKBER
Did Omar Khattab add to Sunni salat (daily prayers)?
Did taqiyya Shias remove parts of salat?
DO you have a video on the time period that islam had a hold on the Iberian penninsula ?
First, follow the five pillars of Islam then think about these intricacies.
He's respectable Shiak. He talks nicely without any bigotry May Allah bless you
Please keep in this way .
Nice and wise lecture..
Very knowledgeable answer and speech
My father's side is Sunni and mother's side Shiia. I was raised by my beloved parents to call myself a MUSLIM, just Muslim. As Brother Shabbir Ally right said, whether Sunni or Shiia, we all believe in the Noble Quran, we all submit to Allah Almighty alone, 5 prayers, fasting in Ramadan, charity and performing Hajj/Umrah are indispensable for all of us. We all firmly believe in the Hereafter. So why are we fighting? Again, as Brother Shabbir reminded us, this is a time when Muslims need to be united. Infighting within our pan-Islamic community carries zero benefit for us. United we rise, divided we fall. It's that simple. Btw, I do not know of any Shiia Muslim claiming Quran has been changed. If anyone claims it, that person must be some uneducated odd one out. Such freaks exist in every community. They do not represent the mainstream Muslim society. The Almighty says in Verse 159 Surah Al-Anam (Chapter 6) "Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects - you, [O Muhammad], are not [associated] with them in anything. Their affair is only [left] to Allah ; then He will inform them about what they used to do." I appeal to all our brothers & sisters to completely abandon the scourge of sectarianism and come back to being just Muslims. That's what Allah Almighty wants from us, and it's what the beloved Final Messenger (pbuh) taught us.
Thank you for your insightful explanation
سلام علیکم جزا کم الله خیر.
Thanks, brilliant program
NOT SO !
THE MAN IS MISGUIDING PEOPLE !
irooni100 I enjoyed so when you say not so. Then that is your opinion. When I say great program then that's my opinion. Dam you to tell me your biased opinion. To hell with you