Muslim Schism: How Islam Split into the Sunni and Shia Branches
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 เม.ย. 2021
- Go to NordVPN.com/kingsandgenerals and use code kingsandgenerals to get a 2-year plan with a huge discount plus 1 additional month for free. Protect yourself online today!
Kings and Generals historical animated documentary series on the early history of Islam, as we discuss the events that led to the schism within the Muslim community, as Islam split into two branches - Sunni and Shia Islam. This happened in the latter stages of the Early Muslim Expansion, as the Rashidun caliphs - Umar, Uthman and Ali were assassinated, which led to the war of succession, killing of Ali's son Husayn in Karbala, and the creation of the Umayyad dynasty under Muawiyah I.
Early Muslim Expansion - Yarmouk, Al-Qadisiyyah: • Early Muslim Expansion...
Early Muslim Expansion Season #2: • Siege of Ctesiphon 637...
Third Crusade: • Third Crusade 1189-119...
Turkification of Anatolia: • Turkification of Anato...
Hashashins: • Hashashins: Origins of...
Christian Schism: • Great Schism: The Bitt...
Mos Maiorum: What led to the fall of the Roman Republic?: • Mos Maiorum: What led ...
How Rome Conquered Greece: • How Rome Conquered Gre...
Caesar in Gaul: • Caesar in Gaul - Roman...
Support us on Patreon: / kingsandgenerals or Paypal: paypal.me/kingsandgenerals or by joining the youtube membership: / @kingsandgenerals We are grateful to our patrons and sponsors, who made this video possible: docs.google.com/document/d/1o...
The video was made by Yağız Bozan and Murat Can Yağbasan, while the script was researched and written by Turgut Gambar. This video was narrated by Officially Devin ( / @offydgg & th-cam.com/channels/79s.html....
✔ Merch store ► teespring.com/stores/kingsand...
✔ Patreon ► / kingsandgenerals
✔ Podcast ► kingsandgenerals.libsyn.com/ iTunes: apple.co/2QTuMNG
✔ PayPal ► paypal.me/kingsandgenerals
✔ Twitter ► / kingsgenerals
✔ Facebook ► / kingsgenerals
✔ Instagram ► / kings_generals
Production Music courtesy of EpidemicSound
#Documentary #Islam #Schism
Chill
Greeting Brother!!!!
I shall try my best.
Eagerly waiting First & Second Battle of Tarain..
expecting a storm?
Thanks for providing this content!
I always wondered how and why Islam split.
"Death with honor is better than a life of degradation"
- Hussain Ibn Ali
Well He got death of degradation.
@@greaterisraeliscoming8859 how?
@@greaterisraeliscoming8859 تخسى
@@greaterisraeliscoming8859 تخسي
@@greaterisraeliscoming8859 how was it a death of degradation as he is considered a hero in all muslims while his murderer is considered a cruel king
Learned a lot from this one. As an European and Christian, it's wonderful to have such a topic described this way. Never knew why Muslim women did that gesture of mourning, and the sign of respect towards some of these pivotal figures by subsequently mentioning "Peace be upon him" after saying their names.
Easy to love this channel.
Happy Ramadan to all Muslims.
Thank you! All Muslims say Peace be upon him after the mention of Prophets. We even say peace be upon him for Prophet Jesus as well.
And for the companions of the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him, we say May God be pleased with them.
Peace to you brother and may God guide us all! Amin.
@@muhammadkhan2007 really nice, thanks for the info!
If you want some good reading of some of the historical context between Islam and its relationship with the west can I recommend A Line In The Sand by James Barr and Empires of the Sea by Roger Crowley.
Thank you Daniel :)
@@syedmuhammadkhan 👍
Not even Muslim and the story of Husayn still makes me cry.
Don't cry for Converted Muslim
MashAllah
Imam Husain isn’t only for Muslims it’s for all of us humans , When our master was asked by the tongue of God, the speaker, Jaafar bin Muhammad, Imam Al-Sadiq ( imam Hussain grandson) (peace be upon him), about the hadith, "Al-Hussein is the lamp of guidance and the ship of survival": Aren't you the ships of survival? He (peace be upon him) said: We are all ships of survival, but the ship of Hussein is widest.
????@@Dragon_Emperor_Supreme_Flight
My brother God loves you
It's a little embarrassing to get this far without knowing about such a pivotal event in world history. Thank you for shedding light.
It's not taught in most schools around the world, so it's fair not to know. History is filled with pivotal moments we don't know the details of nd there's nothing wrong with that. Humans are wide spread, complicated, and very contentious and nobody knows everything. Stay learning my friend 🎉
I feel bad for Ali and his sons. They were brave and honest men
Indeed. Stay Blessed.
Imam Hussain was killed thirsty and hungry. I really feel sad for him. I wish I could bring him food and water. I wish could.
@Middle Eastern
Still man this kind of death no one deserves. At least water it is basic universal need of all living organisms. I've heard that he was a nephew of your prophet and those who killed him were believers of prophet and Quran then why did they killed Hussain. He was a blood relative of Muhammad ? Why ?
@@atharvsingh6901
Because truly he ( yazeed ) didn’t cares about anyone the only things he’s care was he’s POWER he get rid of anybody who not listening to him. Actually yazeed was talking about Islam but in fact he’s true actions was against Islam. I hate ( yazeed ) my god keep him forever in hell 🙏
Thank you @Atharv Singh
Your comment means a lot 👍🙏
"Seeking justice left me with no friends"
Imam Ali.
True, he was the chief judge of Caliphate
True. Ali was backstabbed.....
@Lionel Musa Respect our Prophet's Wife otherwise ALLAH will destroy you.
@@nazimhassan2951 let him go preach what he believe till the day of judgement
@Lionel Musa funny how quran calls the wives of prophet s.a.w azwaj ul mutaharat and even ayats came to defend ayesha r.a but you muta borns will not know their rank
Hold firmly to the rope of Allah together and do not become divided.
Quran - 3:103
Thankyou for the reminder
One thing that is interesting for me is that, Ali and his sons, Hasan and Husein, have never been dictators, they didn't want to achieve political power in any cost, they always considered people, I think they were the men of democracy in their own time and situation.
@@khabibgt6688you’re delusional and you will burn in hell for eternity among those that share your beliefs inshallah
@@khabibgt6688 dude i don’t know who taught you that by origin of Shia comes from imam jafar sadegh great grand son of imam Hussain, when abbasi Khalift were forcing people to join one of the 4 religions such as hanbeli, shafeii, maleky …etc. it was at that time people who believed in ahl bait were called Shia.
So god bless your soul double check your sources
so after watching the video the first thing you thought shia not Islam @khabibgt6688
This is a good example of how religion gets hijacked by nepotism, favoritism and politics and what may have been intended does not remain the same later
They knew the risk of killing the prophet's grandson.
They did it anyways.
Money trumps faith
@@syed1431 bruh.
Don't mind me, I just gonna leave my comment here so I'll not miss any notification if war broke out in this comment section.
@@syed1431
Not really. Sunnism is more of a moderate middle ground that sees all companions of the prophet, including Ali and the other 3 caliphs, as virtuous men. Mu'awiyah, despite his differences with Ali, held him in high regard and the masses refused to be whitewashed by Yazid's propaganda
Even Mu'awiyah did. His last act with Yazid was to implore him to honour Ali and his sons. Yazid was too headstrong to give a damn, though.
It's similar to the dynamic between Septimius Severus and Caracalla
I am a muslim, yet I never learned about this at school. And now I've held a master degree. This channel is a blessing in disguise. No channel has ever covered this topic in detail before. God bless this channel and its patrons.
Same,
Am in my last year in college and about to receive my degree in Islamic studies , this period in specifically censored from the history we learned
u should watch this
@@loveofmangos001 Both!
I am a Muslim, from Egypt, and I love this channel, God bless this channel.
Its your lazyness to not learn tho
Born in a sunni family. But after reading more and more about islam. I have to say that "ALI" was the rightful successor of Muhammad pbuh. ❤️
And Harry Potter was the rightful successor to Voldemort
Brother I’m a Shia and there are some big differences. Lern about them and think logically. There are many reasons for me to be a Shia Muslim. By the way my parents was Sunni and later on they change there path. I can only say to you you should look in Sunni books to lern about Shia and you will for sure finde a good reason. And my girlfriend and I hope my future wife did this also and changed her path. I wish you very much luck and be open minded.
@@mason96575😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
It shouldn't matter today whether we're Shia or Sunni. what is important is that we believe in god and are muslims. we are brother and sister. disputes only weaken us.
only God knows what events took place. Instead of judging who or what should have been let's be united and follow the basics.
You forget to mention what went on after Karbala. Karbala incident was not just massacre of Ali's family but it went on to Yazid imprisoning the females and children of Ali's family, Hussein's daughter died in the prison in Damascus. The wedge kept going on because Shia muslims stood behind rest of Ali's family including the eldest son of Hussein, Zain-ul-Abideen (the only male survivor after Karbala). This continued the Ahu-al-Bait (family of Prophet) who were supported by Shia and Caliphate that was supported by Sunni for later years.
😂😂
What you are saying is not true and this is not mentioned in history books
@@HumanAncestor luagh at yourself isis supporter
@@FuhhFyuhb-wb1zpYou didn't read doesn't means that it is not written in books...
Tareekh e Tabari is best Sunni history book on Karbala Tragedy .
Umm go search google is free!! Just search "imam hussain story" @@FuhhFyuhb-wb1zp
Ali known for being the bravest and strongest warrior in his generation. He never fought under any commandment after the prophet's death (think why)... Also did not start a civil war in Madina to regain his stolen position. He always put Islam interest first. A true leader. My leader.
True brother. He was a great Muslim.
I heard the king of Sindh gave refuge to prophet's families, is it true?
@@Abhishek-sr2pu I didn't come cross this matter in my readings. Maybe it's true.. but I'm not the one to confirm.
@Jamie Cole that was too long so I didn't read it.. sorry not sorry
@Jamie Cole you too lad... Have a nice day and be safe 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
As a Christian, K&G always puts up great and entertainingly educational content. Happy Ramadan to you my Muslim friends.
thanks..!
Thank you mate!
You're not born again
Thanks
i did not expect this comment from that profilepic
Relate with people in a manner that if you die they will cry upon you and if you be alive they will love you.
Imam Ali
As a Shia Muslim you explained it very well love from 🇯🇵
❤God bless you
Muslim in Japan 😮
@@user-up7nb6id1f shia in Japan😮🤲❤️
@@khabibgt6688Shush 😂
@@khabibgt6688 Can you stop hating on us? Read Bukhari and Muslim narrations that proved that Umar attacked the house of Fatima AS along with your sahaba Abu bakr should.have never been the first calipha your sahaba and aisha narrations ruined the image of Islam and the image of the Prophet Muhammad (SAW)
So much Backstabbing actually made me sympathize with Ali's Family and plight
If anyone's learning about Islam. You must know some basics.
Muslims follow Prophet Muhammad and his noble household called Ahlulbait. Which includes Prophet Muhammad's successor Ali , Prophet Mohammed Noble and Holy Daughter Fatima and the Grandchildren of Prophet Muhammad Hasan and Hussain. These Muslims are known as Shias.
While Deviants who claim to be Muslim but in reality are Non Muslims such as Sunnis they follow Abu Bakr , Umar ,Usman ,and Abu Bakr's daughter Ayesha ,Umar's son Ubaidullah and Usman's cousin Muawiya all of those who fought against Prophet Muhammad's Successor Hazrat Ali in Jang e Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ). Many of Supporters of Abu Bakr and Ayesha such as the cousins of Ayesha named Talha and Zubair and Umar's son Ubaidullah were killed in Jang E Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ). Muslims defeated all of them led By the Commander of Ali's Army Sahaba ( Companion of Prophet Muhammad ) Malik e Ashtar and Ammar bin Yasir ( Hazrat Ammar was killed and got Martyred by Usman's cousin Muawiya at Battle of Siffin ).
Most sunnis are Nasibis ( Supporters of people who fought against Ali and his son Hasan and Hussain ) and Sunnis hate Muslims and hate Shias and call them Rafedah for rejection of People who fought against Prophet Muhammad's successor Hazrat Ali and Ahlulbait such as Ayesha and her dad Abu Bakr and Ubaidullah and his Dad Umar and Muawiya and his Yazeed son and his uncle Usman..
The only people who follow the true teaching of Prophet Muhammad are Shias.
While Sunnis follow Abu Bakr al Baghdadi and Umar.
Sunnis the followers of Abu Bakr,Umar and Usman betrayed Prophet Muhammad and Supported Usman's cousin Muawiya against Hazrat Ali and supported Muawiya's son Yazeed and killed Prophet Muhammad's Grandson Imam Hussain in Karbala. But the Killers of Properts Family the followers of Abu Bakr,Umar and Usman and Abu Bakr's daughter Ayesha who fought against Prophet Muhammad' successor Hazrat Ali blame supporters of Hussain in Iraq for being weak and not strong enough against them while they were killing Imam Hussain in Karbala. After Sunnis killed Imam Hussain they threw all the blame on others claiming others didn't support Imam Hussain hence they had to kill Prophet Muhammad's Grandson as they had no choice.
Muslims the Followers of Prophet Muhammad ,Fatima and Ali and Hasan and Hussain have nothing to do with followers of Ayesha and Muawiya who fought against Ahululbait in Jang E Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Suffin ( Battle of Siffin ). Sunnis hate any respect given to Martyrs of Karbala and instead celebrate the death of Grandson of Prophet Muhammad. Muslim have nothing to do with Sunni Nasibi who supported killing of Prophet Muhammad's family and Grandson. Sunnis are supporters of Abu Bakr and his daughter Ayesha, Umar and his daughter Hafsa and Usman and his cousin Muawiya while Muslims are followers of Prophet Muhammad ,Fatima ,Ali and Hasan, Hussian.
@@bigDaddy-lx9sn as a Sunni you are very wrong about the Karbala thing. We DO honor the martyrs at Karbala. The ONLY real difference is, as the video explained, we don't believe the original succession happened the way you say it did. We believe those people were friends at ALL times after they accepted Islam. But I do respect your opinion if you believe it went the other way and I ask you to imagine a person who didn't believe your version of events actually happened, do you think that person would be angry at ANYONE among the first converts to Islam? Then ask yourself, is that person a "deviant" or is that person just following a set of beliefs based on a different version of events?
And yes, both versions can exist at the same time. We believe one set of events happened you believe a different set of events, to you be your beliefs to me be mine.
@@jhonshephard921 I respect your understanding, in the end the truth will be confirmed , and it’s important to stand together as for as possible were truth lies , because oppression happens in the world due to our lack of unity and in the end Allah will ask us why we didn’t make every effort to be sure and not to fall for falsehood, I wish you and all the good /believers the best outcome in this world and the next inshaa Allah
@@bigDaddy-lx9sn Very well put indeed. I've been trying to explain people the same thing for ages!
@@jhonshephard921 although I slightly disagree, I have a lot for respect for you for not being irrational and calling shia names.
Having many people around me does not increase me in strength,
nor does standing alone make me feel forlorn.
Imam Ali (AS)
non can clam who is the true Muslim.. islam is islam... Forget about the companies if they bothers u or divides u in parts.
Worship Allah & follow prophet (SAW).
Coz Allah didn't said if u don't follow the companions u r wrong! Allah says to follow the prophet (SAW) & don't get divided.
Non gives u authority to divide islam.
@@shafayet2756 Yes we love the companions, but not hypocrites, not those who are right
@@shafayet2756 And also those who divided and teams of Islam known from (Abu Bakr-to Osman)
@@shafayet2756 And we also take our actions from the descendants of the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him. You are where they take from Islam
@@shafayet2756 Following the Sahabas Radiyalahum is praised in the sunnah.
As a shia convert from sunni Islam, I would say that anyone who study the history can see clearly that Imam Ali a.s was the rightful successor of the holy prophet (s). Anyone who feigns neutrality after seeing the facts are behaving just like those people who after knowing about genocide in gaza still say 'oct 7'.
Sorry bro but you're wrong, Shia is a very weak and unconsistant road.
There's no proof of Ali being the successor of the prophet ﷺ directly and the stories of Umar killing Zahra is not real made by shia
Do you beat yourself
@@r4zrr159hahahaha yeha prophet tod bastard tunnis to choose bakri by saqifa 😂
@@yazzy6415 do you blow yourself up
@@r4zrr159Abu Bakr when he was dying said three regretted them and one of them broke into the house of Fatima and wished to be a cow in the exit of the horse Is it really the one who is righteous wishes that this in the books of the Sunnah in addition to stealing the inheritance of Fatima the land of Fadak under the pretext that the sons of the prophets do not inherit Fatima Zahra the lady of the women of the worlds the best woman in the world Do you really not know what is hers?
Search well and you will find the truth The prophet Mohammed said I am leaving you as long as you hold on to him you will never stay after me The book of God and my family and the Hadith is true in the books of the Sunnah there is
Very accurate depiction on one of the biggests divides.
I am from a Syed family who are the family of Ali and Hussain, my family has the scholars in these historical topics. So grew up with nearly 1000 books on such topics.
I do not see a single point of contention in this video.
Great work.
No you’re not
Not that well just because the shia side is usually totally neglected doesn't mean it is very good when they mention some.
8:25 If he going take the weak claim umm kulthsum married Umar he needs to make it clear that if she was daughter of Imam Ali she was 3 or 4 years old. Needs to mention we don't accept it.
Some views are it could have been a step daughter of Imam Ali from Abu Bakr widow who was originally married to his brother Jafar.
Even then according to shia sources he didn't agree.
So it very misleading to make out he gave his daughter in marriage. Huge error which is one sided
Yess I’m from a sayed family too
@@HBN_97you are not a Muslim
You are not from quraish i bet you dont even live in hejaz region, you are pretenders
Feel so bad for Ali, his family members and those of prophet Muhammad.
What happened was unjust.
Even though they were scared of killing the prophet's grandson they eventually did in a brutal way.
Ali was a good man and will never be forgotten.
Certainly you did not hear the story of Karbala when they killed Hussein and left him for days in the desert, killed and oppressed and crushed in the chest by horses. I imagine Hussein alone
Kindly say R.A and PBUH
If you cant say then please dont mention their names
@@milyasilyas841 keep dreaming
My brother, you cut my heart, I swear to you, you reminded me of the case of Hussein, how they killed and tortured his children and beat his women, and children die every hour of thirst. Yazid and fennel
Yes, the shoes of God who oppressed Hussein, and the shoes of God who cut off the water on the children of Hussein, the shoes of God Shammar and his servants Ibn Ziyadah are the ones who sat on Hussein’s chest and slaughtered
Im digging the historical background stuff the KG crew is getting into to help with understanding the warfare history.
@@user-jv3mm6vt6e Where is it wrong?
@@Mighty_Deeds could you clarify? What would you add friend, for us ignorant of Islam’s history?
@@user-jv3mm6vt6e what’s not correct, example?
Find a book Khulafaur Rashidun.. It cover all the story of 4 Caliph..
From their background family,character, achievement (also include the war, intrigue, etc)
@@Mighty_Deeds thats basically any interpretation of history, especially something this far back and by someone who isn't taught it on the lay-mans level in society. And honestly its possible you're too close to the material in that context to see the story clearly the way that some Americans are with American history
I’ve studied all the spiritual faiths of the world. I love learning from the ascendant masters. There is a middle ground here, I don’t believe in a blood right to spiritual leadership yet I 100% believe that Ali was the correct successor. Leadership must be based on the quality of that leadership. Chosen based on the vibrance of that human.
Agreed on the final statement. Aside from superior intellect, and integrity, a leader must be well equipped to lead, as there is Heavy Responsibility that comes with it.
Going off the above, unity is also critical in a leadership role. The enemy is most likely to defeat a group/nation if the group/nation is partly or mostly Devided. We only need to look at the destruction of the Native nation in what was to become the United States of America. The various tribes did not join forces against the English and it cost them dearly.
That “spiritual right” is paganism talk, that’s what every pagan religion believed in. I believe the person who takes over should be the person with the most religious knowledge & most equipped for leading warfare. In this case we don’t know who was the best candidate.
@@jacai4Site a source for that being paganism
@@jacai4I’m not talking about a spiritual right, I’m talking about a right through the family of the prophet.
God bless Ali, but Abu Bakr literally the Vice Captain of Islam ship on Muhammad's age.
He's the Imam and the Khatib while Muhammad sick and couldn't lead the rite.
I was born sunni. Never understood plight of shias..... But when i learned the story, i feel that the shias have a legitimate beef. Now i have love for shias and side with them.
Do you also side with them hating the sahaba and Rasul's wife?
We have our own causes.. we are not pledged to love or hate them.. and hating them doesn't make us kaffirs.. just learn more about history to know wy do we hate them and dont complain@@Irfan87
sure bro LMAO
@@S20_A.A I like how you ASSUME i didnt learn enough. I understand some of the sentiment, but really, hating of the sahaba, and Rasul's wife, has no basis, im fairly cetain our dear Rasul himself would not be ok with it.
@@Irfan87yh
I'm a muslim and I'm really astonished by the accuracy of the content. You guys really did your homework in researching for this episode, keep it up 👆
Fr fr
no i think so umm khultum age was just 5 her height can not be that tall
@@darshanmarathe FO will you? Spamming every comment section. Have pity on your country do something for it people are dying and you are here shitting.
@Shivangi Tripathi racist how the hell do i sound racist? I only told him to instead of spitting venom which he is clearly doing go and do something productive .
@@sarfaraz8751 bro I am sayang just potry the right history so world can know the truth infact they should make a video on that wholy marriage why you think is it wrong to show the truth
Even though I am Hindu the story of imam Hossain brings me to tears. Though he was on the right side he lost the war. May God grant him peace forever.
Sagnik Bro it was not war. If it was war imam hussain a.s would've bring his army and not family. Yazeed and his army took benefit of him traveling alone with his family.
@True islam True 💗 war hoti to yazeedion ki naslain yad rakhti
I think he won the war.
Imam Husain R.A(may allah be pleased with him) and his brother Imam Hasan R.A(may allah be pleased with him) will be the leader of the gate in Jannah/Paradise!
@Zhig Shaw I'm sunni and A.S is used for Prophets not companions or descendants of Prophet Muhammad thanks. If you remember that after Muhammad SAW there was no prophet so there is no need to use A.S.
What an amazing presentation. Very well researched and Putting so much information and in such coherence just in 19 minutes. Keep up the good work 👍
Quran and ahadith about Ali(AS) and his Shias.
Surrah Al Bayyinah v7,
The word(خَيْرُ ٱلْبَرِيَّةِ), who are they?
Ibn Abbas (ra) narrated:
When the verse,, Those who believe and do righteous deeds are the best of the creation (Qur’an 98:7)
was revealed, the Messenger of Allah (S) said to Ali: They are you and your Shi’a. He continued: O ‘Ali! (On the day of Judgment) you and your Shi’a will come toward Allah well-pleased and well-pleasing, and your enemies will come angry with their head forced up. Ali said: Who are my enemies? The Prophet (S) replied: He who disassociates himself from you and curses you. And glad tiding to those who reach first under the shadow of al-’Arsh on the day of resurrection. Ali asked: Who are they, O the Messenger of Allah?”He replied: Your Shi’a, O Ali, and those who love you.
(If you really love you would follow him)
Sunni sources:
• al-Hafidh Jamaluddin al-Dharandi, on the authority of Ibn Abbas
• al-Sawa’iq al-Muhriqah, by Ibn Hajar, Ch. 11, section 1, pp 246-247
. al-nahaya ibne Al-athir v4, p106.
Shawahid Al-tanzil,v2,p459.
Al-manaqib,p265,hadith247.
. Al-dur Al-mansoor, v8,p589.
(ينابيع المودة لذوي القربى، ج 2، صص357 و 452 ; النهاية، ج 3، ص276 به نقل از الغدير، ج 3، ص78 )
Why would this idea ever come to anyone's mind that Prophet stopped his companions for only saying whom his friend is !? Happy Eid al-Ghadir❤️
Why won't he? To show his love for Ali alot of people always stopped people to complement someone
@@r4zrr159You think PrProphet Muhammad SAW would stop everyone just to say Ali is his friend? Everyone knows Ali was his friend. Learn Arabic. He told everyone that Imam Ali A.S should be the caliph
@@r4zrr159so he stopped 120,000 people just to compliment Ali AS? You're joking right?
he didnt
@@r4zrr159 you guys are never gonna convince anyone using this argument lol
"Be afraid of a gentleman when he is hungry, and of a mean person when his stomach is full." - Ali ibn Abu Talib
What does that even mean?
@@CutieZalbu there are two mean here...,first you're are dumb,second u just act dumb
About attitude and character of a person I guess..when her had everything and when he got nothing.
@@CutieZalbu When a person is hungry, they are easily swayed to do harm in order to fill sate themselves. a mean person with a full stomach shall act evil deeds just for being evil for they have the energy to do so since they are full.
something like that
@@CutieZalbu It means when a gentlemen is at a low point he might do questionable things to betray you. When a mean person is full, he does not need you anymore for safety/protection and thus will abuse you.
Islamic schism happen
Christianity: hey, i've seen this one, it's a classic!
🤣
Islamic schism happens first than the Christian.
@@atowav2 If you talk about Great schism, you are right. But Christianity already had other schisms, that happened before existence of islam, like arian or nestorian schism and many more.
@@atowav2
Early Christian schism: Are you sure about that?!
@@atowav2
This schism isn’t related to the christian one from any way
It began to form a theologian dispute after centuries
It began as a political dispute
I am a Sunni and I think Muaya was wrong to oppose Ali RA and his family. ALI RA was the most loved and repected man after prophet SAW.. Muaya and Yazeed damaged Islam...
You did a good job in gathering these vast information through Islamic documents. I can't imagine hard it was.
It's hard to see such unbiased version of the story in muslim sources. you guys did it well well.. thanks
@@bigDaddy-lx9sn That's one big biased side of the story you're mentioning
@Anam Alia how is it biased to what side. he only put in facts and the things that where not facts he said both sides of the story. that is very unbiased. and this channel is not a muslim channel so why would they be biased to either side. use your brain.
@@unkownuser1814 They are sunni. 😂
Shia is a new religion,
Christian worship ( father , son , Holy Spirit)
Shia worshiping ( Ali , Hussein, Fatima)
@@user-rb4tz6hs6p astukfirllah. another sunni spreading lies because he cannot use facts to defeat a Shia. Shias do not worhsip anything or anyone except allah the glorified and there is no prophet after Mohamed pbuh. we have strong love and respect for ahlul bayt but we do not worship them. also Shia islam has been around since Ali as we follow Ali after the prophet. Shias do not follow Ali because he was better than the prophet. we follow Ali after Mohamed because no one followed Mohamed like Ali. also there is no Shia or sunni when it comes to the tragedy of Karbala. you are either with imam Hussain or with his killers. ''you cannot love Ali and his enemies'' a Hadith. states. you sunnis are with yazeed who is the one who ordered the murder of imam Hussain the prophets grandson and member of ahlul bayt.
This is a very sensitive topic is Islamic history but you were the only person I know who put this in respected manner without hurting anyone emotions and feelings. It shows how responsible and sensible you are.
@@Mighty_Deeds can you explain further?
I'm interested
@@Mighty_Deeds Then what is wrong in that that's true don't you believe in that then go read history.
@@Mighty_Deeds Be more specific, i'm curious in what they got wrong
@@Mighty_Deeds Either say how they butchered it or it’s useless.
why is it sensetive ?
Visual Correction: In the day of Ashoura, Imam Husain’s group were prevented the water, the enemy were between Imam husain’s group and the Furat river, the thirst on Imam Husain’s side was one of the big struggles that was accruing in the event of Karbala Battle. Efforts appreciated👍🏻
Thank you so much, i recently started actually being a practicing muslim and i've had a lot of doubts about which is the right side of islam and i want to thank you for reminding me that i do follow the right path of islam. i am a proud shia and i am proud to be a follower of ahul-al bayt!
I am proud Hassan abbas
welcome brother, you win heaven and passed the great test put by god
@@OMNISSIAH-VERY-GREAT thank you brother, alhamdullAllah for everything, i know with all my heart that allah is the only path to true success. its the greatest peace i've ever felt and the more i learn the more peaceful and better of a person i become. may allah grant us both jannah, AMeen rabil alameen.
@@hassanabbas-sy5cm Hope we see each other as comrades in the army of imam Mahdi brother
@@OMNISSIAH-VERY-GREAT Ameen! InshaAllah
The only channel that releases an islam related video during Ramadhan, good job👍
advertising 🙂
You mean the only non Muslims channel to release Muslims content in Ramadan
They got many things wrong though
@@mrdragonage7446 Like what exactly? I actually think they were factually correct on the whole
@@beno1129 first and foremost is the point widely known to the whole world: prophet Muhammad (salalahu aleyhi wasalam) couldn't neither read nor write. And yet these people claim that he wanted to write his successor's name. The rest is filled in the comments section of this video.
PS. Cannot avoid writing this. Companions of the Prophet (salalahu aleyhi wasalam) were very respectful of each other, and they would never hurt those who Prophet (salalahu aleyhi wasalam) himself held in very high demand.
Expectation: Sunni vs Shia War in the comments section a hundred times fiercer than the Iran-Iraq War.
Reality: Everyone greeting happy Ramadan and appreciating how objective the video is.
Both are Shia majority countries...In that case, Saudi Arabia vs Iran would be more appropiate...
Iran and Iraq war was not about the branches of Islam. It started for the Race and the Land.
you bet lol
@@debanjanbiswas6930 I get what you’re saying but the Iraq-Iran war lasted for 8 years and so many men were dying it got to the point that any man who was 16 or older and hadn’t done military service was to fight whether they liked it or not. It was a literal blood bath that resulted in Iraq getting a few metres of land and fully controlling Shatt Al-Arab.
Edit: also Saudia Arabia vs Iran isn’t a real war just a cold war between the two similar to the Cold War of America and Russia but just the Arabian countries and the Middle East
@@sigmagrindset7848 In Iraq soldiers or solitary service wasn't from the age of 16 it was 18 and if the man choose to go to college then they can push their service until they graduate and then they serve in the military.
Thank you for this great video! no one could say this events this accurate. i appreciate all the effort you've done on this video. Love ya 💚
ليس دقيق الامام علي لم يزوج ابنته ام كلثوم هذا كذب
@@khabibgt6688 Well thats a sunni prospective.
Shia says something different.they say abdullah was a jewish man who recently converted to islam! How people will listen to this man to make a revolution against the caliph and create a new cult?
I dont want to debate cause my knowledge is not good for it but i believe if you are a true muslim one of your important responsibilities is to respect others belief and dont think radical.only Allah knows who's right. Peace
@@khabibgt6688 i see hatred in your words, majusi iran?? Really?? If you are talking like that then talking with you is just a waste of time cause you are radical and you are saying your own thoughts instead of facts. You say "persians hate umar and abu bakr because of the conquer of iran" that can be true but its not related to the topic. Because all of the shia people are not iranian. Does a iraqi shia muslim hate abu bakr and umar because of the conquest of iran?
@@khabibgt6688it’s funny how you first mention that Iran was 90% Sunni before the Safavids and then you say we curse abubakr and Umar because they conquered Persia! 😂😂😂
im travelling to karbala this year for arbaen...my mother is a shia and my father a sunni.. i was raised a sunni always rejecting what my mother told me until i read the narrations in sunni books my teacher snatched the book and said you will become a rafidhi (the defectors)....i later converted to shia islam
Balanced, researched and well narrated.
I am born into an Indian Sunni Muslim family which has Rizvi as our surname. Many times people have asked me if I am a Shia. I have always wanted to know how the Sunni & Shia schism happened/started.
I feel terribly sad for Hazrat Ali & his family. Will research more now. May Almighty Allah grant me correct perspective. Aameen 🤲🏼
As you can know from video Yazeed did all illegal means to gain support but Imam Ali as stood on truth❤
The earlier Shias were also Sunnis. They differed only on the succession. However after the safavid invasion of Iran, they mixed kufr and shirk with Shias and now you have the modern day Shiism. I suggest you look up Daniel Haqiqatjou's video on how he became Sunni.
@@infernoo365 😂😂 don’t knw frm whr u knw this lie…..
@@goldenbrush657 What lie? Read about Safavid invasion and their introduction of twelver faith.
@@infernoo365 Why do you lie so much.. The Shiites at the time of the Messenger of God, may God’s prayers and peace be upon him, his family, and his companions, as in the books of the Prophet’s Sunnah, more than 90 hadiths say that. Ali and his Shiites are the best of creatures, and they will be victorious on the Day of Resurrection ... in addition to the religion of the Sunnah, which appeared more than a hundred years after the martyrdom of the Messenger of God, may God bless him and grant him peace. May God bless him and his family, and Abu Hanifa was a disciple of the sixth imam of the Shiites, Imam Jaafar al-Sadiq, peace be upon him, then he opposed him ... Abu Hanifa appeared 150 years after the martyrdom of the Messenger of God, peace and blessings be upon him and his family
I still remember before you changed your name and got the current narrator on board. It’s crazy (but understandable) to see you have 1.8 million subscribers now! You guys deserve it and I’ve loved your content from the very very start.
I was there too. One of the oldest channels I am still sub too.
What was their original name?
what did they use to be called?
What was their original name?
@@Fuad_ Probably Kings and Queens and Their Generals.
Muslim here: A balanced and well-informed take on the subject. A good introduction for anyone wondering.
Shias are are on right path. Sarat al mustaqeem. Sunni think neither Prophet nor Allah thaught to leave someone as leader substitude or write Quran or hadith at the time knowing how big issue this will become. Such a big insult on Allah and Prophet knowledge that later on person like abu bakr and some companions thought about this.
THis is lie btw. According to Shia muslims, it was Imam Ali (AS) who was chosen as we see in Prophet's last sermon at Ghadeer and many other hadtih like Ali to Prophet is like harun to musa. No musa means Harun or Ali as leader.
Also how abu bakr stole fadak and lied about it *Sahih bukhari 4240* from daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima like She is ordinary person, she is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise not just a women, clearly he is not saddiq and umer not farooq.
The Prophet Muhammad said to Ali
O Ali, no one loves you except a believer and no one hates you except a hypocrite
yea sunnis love ali r.a.
Yes and it’s very clear who fought against Ali 🤔
Can we just appreciate how great of a research this guy did! CLAPS!!
BS ALI MOLA
I AM SUNNI BUT ALI AS IS MY MOLA he should be the successor of MUHAMMAD SAWW
@@ranababarali9461 your not a Sunni then
@@amaankarim9283 lol
@@amaankarim9283 alhamdulillah i am not sunni nor shia
I AM ONLY MUSLIM
And i remember who broke the door of ALI RA and fired it up and because of door fall on the stomach of FATIMA RA she had a miscarriage i remember that course of history too
As my SUNNI ULAMA try to hide this but truth remains truth what ever you do
Or you can say whatever these BNI UMAYYAH dump ASS done in their rule
"JHOTTO PY ALLAH KI LANAT HO"
KROODOO BAAR 🖐🖐🖐
👍✌😎
@@amaankarim9283 my sunni sect people believe in liars of BNI UMAYYAH
Eighty members of the prophet's family against 4K Umayyad warriors yet the former stood with Al-Hussain without hesitation knowing that they were literally marching to their deaths!!
May Allah have mercy on their souls and curse all those who massacred the ones holding the prophet's blood within veins...
By the way I'm Sunni Muslim!!
Edit: Whenever I watch the suicidal cavalry charge of Erwin and the scouts against the Beast titan scene from the Attack on Titans anime I immediately recall Karbala and the suicidal charge of Al-Hussain and his brave comrades. May we be united with them in Heaven :"(
Brother those were the conservative numbers. On imam Hussein’s side was 72 fighting men. while the highest number for yazids army is 70k but. Most likely it was 30k.
May you have a blessed Ramadan brother.
From a fellow Muslim
Who happens to be a Shia.
You should not curse anyone brother , this is not what we’re taught by our religion, do not show a bad image of Islam
Why are you a Sunni if you know that Sunnisim is a cope about the extermination of Prophetic bloodline and establishment of dynasties that Prophet himself cursed?
@@suhhirsamle6615 So I shouldn't curse the criminals who murdered our prophet's family??!
For the record a lot of Sunni scholars allow the cursing of Al-Hussain's killers!!
@@amarjamakovic1222 That's not a debate I can discuss in TH-cam comment section, brother. And I know for sure there's no answer I give you however reasonable it might be can change your mind because it's clear you already have specific convections about Sunnis as I once had about Shias!!
Nonetheless I pray God guide you and me, brother and the whole Islamic nation to his straight path!!
Thanks for this great video
Thank you for this full explanation 🙏,
To any Muslims brethrens who reads this, happy Ramadan, aloha and God bless.
To any fellow Christians who reads this, Ave.
Thxs
Happy Ramadan and Ave, Frater!
what does "Ave" mean?
Please read quran in ur mother tongue and accept Islam before you die
@@silencia08 it's latin for "Hail, greetings, hello,hi"
Something like that.
Being a Shia of ali and Knowing about Imam Hussain has taught me one thing- amongst others- is that there is no greater purpose in any humans life except for showing their humanity. Being a lover of the life of my brother.
So as a shia do u support the other caliphs?
@@_._._._3862 I support them because Imam Ali supported them. I do disagree with their tactics, but if Imaam Ali being the imam if the time did not revolt or retaliat then it is our job as his followers to support them too.
@@zainababbas4852 well said.
@@zainababbas4852 imam ali never supported them, he withdrew completely from political and military life publicly to show his dissent with their unjust rulership but offered his advice when asked, like our other imams. Imam Ali simply back and waited for the evil that had begun to reveal itself for all to see instead of going on the offensive, so that history will know who caused the fitna in islam. Otherwise he would be the one blamed for starting fitna (which he was accused of in Ummayad propaganda but you cant hide the truth forever).
@@zainababbas4852 he was forsed to support by burning his house and they tied rope in the ali's neck and to stop fitna he did so
Correction; Bibi umm e Kulsoom A.S was married to Hazrat Aoun bin Jaafer A.S(who was the son of Hazrat Jaafer Tayyaar A.S, the brother of Imam Ali ibn abi taalib A.S)
As a practicing shia, I have learned it and I want to pass the right information, in many books it is said that she (Bibi umm e kulsoom A.S) married the second caliph (which is wrong), Imam Ali A.S never gave his daughter to the second caliph.
Crazy
Umm what's your source?
That is what's called "revisionist history". It has no firm foundation.
@@sasuke1496use your brain first, umar wanted to marry with fatima (sa) prophet muhammad (s) denied that she's too young because umar was over 40, according to sunnis umar married with fatima's daughter in his caliphate reign, that's mean his age was around 60 or above, now let's be real how even it is possible prophet (s) denied him because he was so old for her daughter fatima (s) but same umar married fatima's daughter after 25 years lol
@@the.tribal_chief Exactly not even Umar Abu Bakr also wanted to marry Prophet's Daughter but he was also denied because he was even older than Umar. 😂
Man💪🏻, I loved everything about your video. It was very non-biased.
But you missed one small fact
That Ali wasn’t amongst the first people who converted to islam, but he was the first, who converted to islam
even i love Ali(as) so much, first was Khadija
Yes first man was imam ali@@user-re6mv1ms6m
@@user-re6mv1ms6m first man.
One thing to add is that the envoy to Husayn in question was al-Hurr. Despite being a soldier in Yazid's army, Hurr was still an honorable man. After 9 days of going back and forth, on the night before the battle, al-Hurr was out walking around the Umayyad camp reflecting on the coming battle. And after looking at the camp of Husayn and his own camp, and understanding the horrible events he had helped set in motion, al-Hurr resolved to abandon the Umayyads and rode along with a handful of his loyal men to join Husayn, knowing full well what that meant. It is said that upon reaching Husayn, he began sobbing at Husayn's feet and begged forgiveness. Promising to fight and die for the Imam's cause.
The next day, when the battle began, Hurr was the first man to ride out to meet the Umayyads. First pleading with his comrades to spare Husayn, and after his pleas fell on deaf ears, chastising and berating them for their duplicity in inviting Husayn to Kufa, only to kill him. In the end, Hurr fought and died valiantly as the first casualty of Husayn's camp.
For me personally, Hurr's story remains one of the most powerful to come out of the events of Karbala. Where every other companion of the Imam had grown up with him and his father and even the Prophet. Where they had grown up learning right from wrong, learning the value of honor and integrity, Hurr was an outsider. He was a soldier who was in the employ of Yazid and had become wealthy and powerful for it. He had no reason to switch sides. Staying with Yazid guaranteed a life of comfort and ease, but joining Husayn meant certain death. But in the end, he knew that no pleasures in the world were worth a guilty conscience. He knew that hiding behind orders was not enough, that much as he tried to pretend otherwise, he DID have a choice. It was not a choice between life and death, but a choice between salvation and damnation. And in the end, he chose salvation. It is one of the most powerful tales of redemption in Shi'a theology. And I know for myself and so many other Shi'a, it is a moral standard. To strive for what is right, even if it costs you everything.
Exactly I agree as a shia muslim
As an indonesian muslim, i did not know of this story. Thank you for telling about it!
@@Fadlankhs I'm from Malaysia, one of mufti here of Perlis state told about this Al-Hurr story. So it's also famous in Sunni narration. Only you don't know. Perlis state a Wahabi state in Malaysia, the only Wahabi state in Malaysia. Even Wahabi knew about Al-Hurr martyrdom
If anyone's learning about Islam. You must know some basics.
Shias follow Prophet Muhammad and his noble household called Ahlulbait. Which includes Prophet Muhammad's successor Ali , Prophet Mohammed Noble and Holy Daughter Fatima and the Grandchildren of Prophet Muhammad Hasan and Hussain.
Non Muslims such as Sunnis they follow Abu Bakr , Umar ,Usman ,and Ayesha and Muawiya who fought against Prophet Muhammad's Successor Hazrat Ali in Jang e Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ).
Most sunnis are Nasibis ( Supporters of people who fought against Ali and his son Hasan and Hussain ) and hate Shias and call them Rafedah for rejection of People who fought against Prophet Muhammad successor Hazrat Ali such as Ayesha and her dad Abu Bakr and Muawiya and his son..
@@sayeedhusseinsadat3284 i am also shia but the statement you write above is not proper usman, abubakr and umar died way before jamal siffin and nahrwan the reason we don't aprove of them is 1st we believe ali as caliph after prophet muhammad as caliph mean succesor. 2nd there is hadees which state that after prophet death abu bakr and umar slammed the door of ali and threat him not interefer in politic 3rd about usman as you see the video he bring nepotism and unlike umar who take guidance from ali or banu hashim family he put them on side and take many athority from them of medina
As a shia i gotta say sunni and shia are all brothers and we all belive in allah and prophet, thats what all islam is .your brother from iran❤
Your brother from Pakistan agrees
we are not spilt..we are brothers..respect n love from PAKISTAN
@@merikhel4314 come to indonesia, you'll be badly persecuted
Sunni and Cristian are brothers.
@@ryumtk2581 .. bro..if u involve in such kind of actions.thn u will face tht negativity not only in Indonesia but where ever u r...mean to say ..when facing outsider u will introduce ur siblings with great honour n pride..but when u have a debate on something with ur siblings thn a little anger is so natural..
“According to sunnis the prophet of mankind didn’t appoint a successor” yes according to them he left the Muslim world confused and to fight in wars.
What a narrative…for someone who believes in the prophet peace be upon him
The sunnis would rather believe in this than the truth
I am a non Muslim. After watching this video it appears to me that Ali was the true successor. Just my opinion I am not biased in any way, just looking at the facts.
the thing is if something had happened why to cry over it accept and move on ali became the 4th caliph anyways
The only factual part of your comment is that you are non-Muslim. 🙄
@@GoodVibes9988 الامر يتوقف حول ترك النبي اختيار الخليف لعامة المسلمين !!! هل تعتقد ان النبي سيترك امراً كهذا بالغا الاهمية ليقرره عامة الناس ؟ ؟ هل هذه حكمة الله وعلمه ؟
@@GoodVibes9988it is not only about Ali but also about the other 10 Imams who where mistreated. May Allah curse the oppressors.
Christian and Islamic schism done.
Next K&G episode: Schism of Buddhism - Hinyana and Mahayana.
Would love to see this.
Then schism in Hinduism, Dvaita and Advaita... And Sankhya, Mimansa, nyayika, yogika
@@tentathesane8032 I don't think we can call it as a schism. Hinduism is very open to different interpretation of God or Ultimate truth or whaterver you call it. People of different sects of Hinduism could have debated on their differences but it is extremely rare to find them spilling blood over those disagreements. Where as in case of some religions, only one interpretation of truth is considered as valid while other are regarded as heresy. That was never the case with Hinduism. So calling existence of different Philosophical schools of Hinduism as products of schism sounds a little wrong to me.
@@shubhammadane6150 exactly.
What's Hinyana? Theravada?
The worst thing about a betrayal is that it doesn’t come from an enemy.
That's exactly what betrayal means
That’s why it’s called betrayal
???
Bro banu ummayya were always enemy during prophet (s.a.w) rule he never put them first in any political advisory you will find yezid speach when he take the head of hussain(a.s) he says i have take the revenge of my father and his which imply his hatred was for a long time with ahle bait
If anyone's learning about Islam. You must know some basics.
Shias follow Prophet Muhammad and his noble household called Ahlulbait. Which includes Prophet Muhammad's successor Ali , Prophet Mohammed Noble and Holy Daughter Fatima and the Grandchildren of Prophet Muhammad Hasan and Hussain.
Non Muslims such as Sunnis they follow Abu Bakr , Umar ,Usman ,and Ayesha and Muawiya who fought against Prophet Muhammad's Successor Hazrat Ali in Jang e Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ).
Most sunnis are Nasibis ( Supporters of people who fought against Ali and his son Hasan and Hussain ) and hate Shias and call them Rafedah for rejection of People who fought against Prophet Muhammad successor Hazrat Ali such as Ayesha and her dad Abu Bakr and Muawiya and his son..
As a Iranian, when speaking about Ali (AS) I don't know whether to speak about his sorrow, or to speak about his greatness. Love to all our Sunni brothers La Illah Ila Allah Muhammad Rasul Allah
This is the most based video about this matter.
Peace be upon the prophet and his righteous family.
I m a follwer of Buddhism but watching this really made me sympathize on Ali n his family not just bcoz they are from prophet's family but as people who lived without ego being direct descendants of Mohammad Nabi. It s hard to accept a massacre of a family who s so humble that they even relinquished their right. So in my aspect I think regardless of schisms all Sunnis should respect n venerate Ali as a person of pious,humble and compassionate sentiments...
@Mr. Riffian its caliphate genius
Oh we do respect Ali. In fact , we also despise what ummaiyah did to his family.
Sunnis do respect and love Ali(R.A), for sunnis all the companions are worthy of respect and love
@Mr. Riffian its isis not sunni or shias
@@kikijihan8316 yes apparently Sunnis do not like yazid
Im a Sunni and i never knew about the event of (Ghadir Khumm) where the Prophet(PBUH) held Ali's hands up and appointed him as a successor in front of 120,000 people our sheikhs during friday Khutbahs has never mentioned about this event. This event has opened my eyes now after researching about it.
You have to understand that what you mentioned is what our Shia brothers believe... that he raised his hand 🤚 to appoint him as a successor.... but that’s not what the 120,000 companions attending understood cause if the prophet had really intended by raising Ali’s hand to appoint him as a successor the companions would’ve understood that and knew it just like the prophet taught them and clarified many things to them before.
1. There were no 120,000 companions on the day of Ghaddir e khum.
2. Event of Ghaddir e khum occurred after the pilgrimage days.
3. If our prophet wanted to name Ali (asws) as his successor, he would have declared him as his successor on pilgrimage days in mecca or madinah after returning there, when there were a lot of muslims, not in a small place called "khum" where there were only some Syrians and people of Madinah who were returning to their homes from pilgrimage.
4. On that day of Ghaddir e Khum, Mohammad (saww) said, "Whoever considers me his Moula, should consider Ali as his Moula" and held the hand of Ali (asws) and raised his hand so that everyone who was present there could see it clearly. This was not an act of prophet declaring Ali (asws) as his successor because he was a prophet not a worldy king, but this was a warning to Syrians and people of Madinah because he knew what will happen to Ali (asws) in future. When the time came, people of Madinah stayed loyal to Ali and his family, while people of Syria rebelled against him and eventually killed his family in Karbala.
5. If you really want to educate yourself on this topic, go read a book of hadith or ask a question about this to any good moderate scholar who actually knows history, not TH-cam peeps, and Allahh knows best 🤝🏻💚
@@issam8122 Yeah and why would the Prophet(PBUH) shortly before his death gather everyone and raise Ali's hands up surely he appointed Ali as his successor but most companions didn't accept his message and later on unlawfully elected their own leader in (Bani Saqifah)
@@jameswohley3332 They were returning from pilgrimage and Ali was sent by the prophet to Yemen to gather the spoils of war and some of the companions started complaining to the prophet about Ali so the prophet said this to show the importance of HAZRAT ALI RADIH ALLAH AHNHU. The fact that this is what all people attending understood. No one understood that the prophet wanted Ali to be the successor even Ali never claimed that himself. So how can we claim such things????
@@issam8122 Every Prophets in Islam appointed a successor and you’re telling me my Prophet(PBUH) forgot to appoint a leader and let the whole Muslim world go lost?
Thank you for shedding light on this very important part of history. As someone who recently started practicing Islam, It is clear to me that I will be a Shia Muslim. Thank you.
Congratulations brother لا اله الا الله محمد رسول الله علی ولی الله❤
A lot of his information are quite wrong, at least to my knowledge and I have done a lot of research.
Please listen to Sheikh’s and well reputed people such as Dr. Said Al Kamali or Mufti Menk and compare the narratives
اخي لا تأخذ الدين من الغرب الاسلام الحقيقي هو السنه لاننا نحب ال البيت وعلي الصحابه
Are u being serious??
no, please do more research. lots of shia theories are misleading from quran
There are some mistakes in this video kindly ask scholars of both sects if anyone wants to know more
There is no mistake in this video, it is all truth!
truth is hidden from our Muslim brothers and sisters!
I saw the faces were obscured in the animations, very thoughtful
He doesnt want to be killed
@@kayvan671 what
@@Saku19 what
Lol, important religious figures in Islam usually can’t be depicted in art/film etc as it is considered very disrespectful
He doesn't want to be sexually assaulted
Call people to righteousness through means other than your tongues so that they may observe.
diligence, truthfulness and piety in your actions
grandson Imam Ali
Excellent summary...
am a muslim from kenya and i would love to wish all my muslim brothers and sisters ramadhan mubarak
thanks my brother 🌹 from Iran.
Thank you brother
where is god in this. its all wars for control over information in quran and power over land
Who is Mubarak? Hosny Mubarak?
@Arthur james I know, I am trolling them
This channel is a service to humanity. Thank you Kings and Generals.
By your name, I'm guessing a fellow South African? Cheers bud!
Shia Islam is the Truth and carries the true teachings of Prophet Muhammad and Ahlulbait. 😎
Absolutely love this channel
Well done brother👍🏻❤
As a sunni growing up they never tought us the history of how things happened post prophets death becuase its very messy and some respected people in the sunni school had done some things that could be hard to defend, even in sunday school they never thought this. My love for the family of the prophet grows more and more each time i hear there history stories and become saddened to find what they went through.
If anyone's learning about Islam. You must know some basics.
Shias follow Prophet Muhammad and his noble household called Ahlulbait. Which includes Prophet Muhammad's successor Ali , Prophet Mohammed Noble and Holy Daughter Fatima and the Grandchildren of Prophet Muhammad Hasan and Hussain.
Non Muslims such as Sunnis they follow Abu Bakr , Umar ,Usman ,and Ayesha and Muawiya who fought against Prophet Muhammad's Successor Hazrat Ali in Jang e Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ).
Most sunnis are Nasibis ( Supporters of people who fought against Ali and his son Hasan and Hussain ) and hate Shias and call them Rafedah for rejection of People who fought against Prophet Muhammad successor Hazrat Ali such as Ayesha and her dad Abu Bakr and Muawiya and his son..
@@bigDaddy-lx9sn sunni and shia generally are both muslims stop ur nonsense when Ali thought Abu bakar Umar and Usman Aisha were all muslims than who are u to say they are not .. Ali rA even gave his daughters for marraige to them and named his sons Abu bakar
You are right i hope sunni accept the truth i think both side have took a extreme stand even though there are several hadiths in sunni books of sahih muslim,Bukhari prophecy of prophet Mohammed that battle between mauwiya and hazrat ali r.a he was at righteous prophet Mohammad pbuh prophecies that amar hazrat amar r.a one of the companion of hazrat ali r.a would be killed by the unreightous group he was killed by the mauwiya group and he would be taking peaple to heaven side and that group would take peaple to hell and there are hadiths which prophet Mohammed prophecies after his death how much year of a reightous rule will it be and that years end at the death of hazrat hasan r.a and in term of sunni i can say they attleast took an silence on this topic but shia totally misinterpret it
@@bigDaddy-lx9sn Shia love Ali R.A so much that they beat themselves to death, yeah beating yourself to death and cursing the companions of prophet is totally permissable. Imagine loving someone else that much other than Allah and His messengers.
@@bigDaddy-lx9sn non Muslims? Are you Allah? I have Shia friends from childhood even I would consider twice before calling Shia non Muslim.
I appreciate that Ibadi is also shown. That +10% goods produced modifier is really good.
@Avi Eh, I've played it a bit.
I Call it bullshit you have to use Sunni + Shaafi for the AE reduction
@Anam Alia They do.
@@asikkanarya But... the +10% goods produced modifier is so good....
2000+ hours I need help lol
The font that you used for English is so beautiful! May I ask what is that font?
Abu Bakr and Umar rushing over to the meeting while Ali stayed behind to bury the Prophet tells you all you need to know about who actually deserves to be the successor of the Ummah
"And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided..." - (The Holy Quran 3: 103)
The rope of Allah are the Ahl ul-Bayt.
Quran 9.5: When sacred months have passed, kill polytheists wherever you find them. Capture them, besiege them.
@@FactStorm Your word is like "I will kill you" without mentioning the before "If you kill me, I will kill you"
@@beautifulbangladesh5838 How peaceful!
Also, the fact that polytheists are distinguished is enough to prove religious sectarianism, which is inherent in every religion.
@@FactStorm I don't want any comment war,but you should not see any IT cell channel. And you should respect muslims,at the same time, I respect your religion
I remember when I found your channel some years ago, it's unbelievable how much the content you produce has evolved, alongside the graphics of each episode and the amount of subscribers who follow you. I think we're kinda blessed to be able to watch such high content documentaries for free. :)
@@Mighty_Deeds stfu
@@Mighty_Deeds Does your brain hurt when you watch this?
If anyone's learning about Islam. You must know some basics.
Shias follow Prophet Muhammad and his noble household called Ahlulbait. Which includes Prophet Muhammad's successor Ali , Prophet Mohammed Noble and Holy Daughter Fatima and the Grandchildren of Prophet Muhammad Hasan and Hussain.
Sunnis are not Muslim they follow Abu Bakr , Umar ,Usman ,and Ayesha and Muawiya who fought against Hazrat Ali in Jang e Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ). Most sunnis are Nasibis ( Supporters of people who fought against Ali and his son Hasan and Hussain ) and hate Shias and call them Rafedah for rejection of People who fought against Prophet Muhammad successor Hazrat Ali such as Ayesha and Muawiya..
@@bigDaddy-lx9sn Dude u got some mental issues
Im christian but seeing this makes me sad. It was not fair.
Shias are are on right path. Sarat al mustaqeem. Sunni think neither Prophet nor Allah thaught to leave someone as leader substitude or write Quran or hadith at the time knowing how big issue this will become. Such a big insult on Allah and Prophet knowledge that later on person like abu bakr and some companions thought about this.
THis is lie btw. According to Shia muslims, it was Imam Ali (AS) who was chosen as we see in Prophet's last sermon at Ghadeer and many other hadtih like Ali to Prophet is like harun to musa. No musa means Harun or Ali as leader.
Also how abu bakr stole fadak and lied about it *Sahih bukhari 4240* from daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima like She is ordinary person, she is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise not just a women, clearly he is not saddiq and umer not farooq. ...
2:06 Imam ali a.s was bron insside the holly kaba in makka ...
Yes he was 😊❤
You just did an extremely extremely difficult job by summarising this history in a respectful objective way. Most Muslims couldn’t do this. Thank u, may Allah bless u
If anyone's learning about Islam. You must know some basics.
Shias follow Prophet Muhammad and his noble household called Ahlulbait. Which includes Prophet Muhammad's successor Ali , Prophet Mohammed Noble and Holy Daughter Fatima and the Grandchildren of Prophet Muhammad Hasan and Hussain.
Non Muslims such as Sunnis they follow Abu Bakr , Umar ,Usman ,and Ayesha and Muawiya who fought against Prophet Muhammad's Successor Hazrat Ali in Jang e Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ).
Most sunnis are Nasibis ( Supporters of people who fought against Ali and his son Hasan and Hussain ) and hate Shias and call them Rafedah for rejection of People who fought against Prophet Muhammad successor Hazrat Ali such as Ayesha and her dad Abu Bakr and Muawiya and his son..
@@sayeedhusseinsadat3284 You just proved why it was an extremely difficult job. The key words in my comment was 'objective' and 'respectful'. Making takfir on all Sunnis and calling majority of them Nasibi is ignorant and dangerous. You are starting to sound like the people you hate, the takfiri extreme Sunni sect.
@@sayeedhusseinsadat3284 I would be careful of calling all other Muslims as non-Muslims, if Shia did support Ahlulbait then why did you abandon Hazrat Hussain A.S and their blessed family to be slaughtered? Why do you insult and curse Sahaba Ikram? when It was narrated that al-Bara’ (may Allah be pleased with him) said: I heard the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) say: “The Ansaar: no one loves them but a believer and no one hates them but a hypocrite. Whoever loves them, Allah will love him, and whoever hates them, Allah will hate him.”
Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 3672; Muslim, 75.
as since you are insulting the Sahaba Ikram and the blessed wives of Nabi Muhammad peace be upon them and their families you have indeed exposed yourself for being a cursed Hypocrite. Also at the battle of the camels Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman were not involved as they all had been martyred by that time
Islam is from the deceiver, it is full of lies
Yehoshua Hamashiach is the way truth and light
@@simonmainamugo4865 is that a Japanese football player??
I am a non Muslim. So lemme get this straight. Ali was Mohammed's son in law and was a very good friend of Mohammed, so much so that Mohammed gave his daughter up to Ali for marriage. Everybody knew Mohammed loved Ali and was his good friend. Then during Mohammed's last sermon, Mohammed stopped a massive crowd in the middle of the desert just to tell them that Ali was his friend? Doesn't make sense to any neutral. Then Yazid killed Hussein and all of Mohammed's direct family and humiliated them even after death? I'm sorry but I am siding with the Shias here.
If anyone's learning about Islam. You must know some basics.
Muslims follow Prophet Muhammad and his noble household called Ahlulbait. Which includes Prophet Muhammad's successor Ali , Prophet Mohammed Noble and Holy Daughter Fatima and the Grandchildren of Prophet Muhammad Hasan and Hussain. These Muslims are known as Shias.
While Deviants who claim to be Muslim but in reality are Non Muslims such as Sunnis they follow Abu Bakr , Umar ,Usman ,and Abu Bakr's daughter Ayesha ,Umar's son Ubaidullah and Usman's cousin Muawiya all of those who fought against Prophet Muhammad's Successor Hazrat Ali in Jang e Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ). Many of Supporters of Abu Bakr and Ayesha such as the cousins of Ayesha named Talha and Zubair and Umar's son Ubaidullah were killed in Jang E Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ). Muslims defeated all of them led By the Commander of Ali's Army Sahaba ( Companion of Prophet Muhammad ) Malik e Ashtar and Ammar bin Yasir ( Hazrat Ammar was killed and got Martyred by Usman's cousin Muawiya at Battle of Siffin ).
Most sunnis are Nasibis ( Supporters of people who fought against Ali and his son Hasan and Hussain ) and Sunnis hate Muslims and hate Shias and call them Rafedah for rejection of People who fought against Prophet Muhammad's successor Hazrat Ali and Ahlulbait such as Ayesha and her dad Abu Bakr and Ubaidullah and his Dad Umar and Muawiya and his Yazeed son and his uncle Usman.
The only people who follow the true teaching of Prophet Muhammad are Shias.
While Sunnis follow Abu Bakr al Baghdadi and Umar.
Sunnis the followers of Abu Bakr,Umar and Usman betrayed Prophet Muhammad and Supported Usman's cousin Muawiya against Hazrat Ali and supported Muawiya's son Yazeed and killed Prophet Muhammad's Grandson Imam Hussain in Karbala. Later the Killers of Properts Family the followers of Abu Bakr,Umar and Usman and Abu Bakr's daughter Ayesha who fought against Prophet Muhammad's successor Hazrat Ali blamed supporters of Hussain in Iraq for being weak and not strong enough against them while they were killing Imam Hussain in Karbala. After Sunnis killed Imam Hussain they threw all the blame on others claiming others didn't support Imam Hussain hence they had to kill Prophet Muhammad's Grandson as they had no choices.
Muslims the Followers of Prophet Muhammad , Ali ,Fatima and Hasan and Hussain have nothing to do with followers of Ayesha and Muawiya who fought against Ahulbait in Jang E Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Suffin ( Battle of Siffin ). Sunnis hate any forms of respect given to Martyrs of Karbala and instead celebrate the death of Grandson of Prophet Muhammad. Muslim have nothing to do with Nasibi Sunnis who supported killing of Prophet Muhammad's family and Grandson. Sunnis are supporters of Abu Bakr and his daughter Ayesha, Umar and his daughter Hafsa and Usman and his cousin Muawiya while Muslims are followers of Holy Messengers of God and his Prophets such as Prophet Solomon, Prophet Isaac , Prophet Jonah ( Sunni ISIS destroyed his Grave ),Prophet Jacob , Prophet Joseph, Prophet Samuel, Prophet David ( Dawood ), Prophet Elijah ( Ilyas ) ,Prophet Noah and Prophet Abraham ( Ibrahim ) and Prophet Moses and his Successor Aaron ( Hazrat Harun ) and Prophet Jesus ( Isaah ) his Successor John the Baptist ( Hazrat Yahya ) and God's Last Messenger Prophet Muhammad and his Successor Hazrat Ali and his Holy and Noble daughter Fatima and the grandchildren of Prophet Muhammed Hassan and Hussain.
If you haven't heard anything about Ayesha and Muawiya and Ubaidullaha's war against Prophet Muhammad's successor Hazrat Ali and Ahlulbait in Jang E Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang E Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ) it's probably because you're a Sunni and you're a follower of Abu Bakr ,Umar, Usman, Ayesha and Muawiya or under the influence of Sunni Propaganda.
He said that he loved ali because before this event happen some companions critized ali , thats why the prophet became angry and did the sermon in ghadir khum
That’s not how the narrative works but ok
@I'm So Enlightened just shut up about the taqia crap... whenever their cornered with facts they bring up shit that has nothing to do with the story... whats wrong with saying ahlu-bait are holy and oppresed.. they accepted every false caliph to prevent fitna until enough was enough but yet still the ahlu-bait haters still want to kill their followers which are prophet mohammeds followers... you start fitna and we try to stop it but doesnt seem to work
@@alijabbar1522 they Consider Abu Bakr as their prophet. They are not muslims they are sunni nasibah.
I'm a suñni but it mks me cry about hassan husband they were prophet off Allah's grand children .
5:15
Actually omar did not say (seriously ill)
And in order to get the correct translation i checked Sahih Al-Bukhari in English and was shocked it was (seriously ill), this proves that who ever translated Sahih Al-Bukhari translate this Hadith Wrong or purpose to soften omar words and reduce the ugliness of it..
What omar really said that night is ( إن الرجل ليهجر، حسبنا كتاب الله)
In english:
(The man is raving, book of god (Quran) enough for us)
يهجر = raving
By consensus of Muslims: saying that the Messenger is raving enough to drive you out of Islam
And if anyone interested to know why Umar stopped the messenger from writing that letter 1 like is enough to know someone has read the entire text.
I am Asian Christian. I recently got the Quran and got curious about it so I searched the specific topic I want to learn more about. Thank you for this easy and understandable explanation.
Edit: Ive read I think majority of the Quran, it's Beautiful and very similar to Christianity.
Edit 2: Don't go to the comments, someone started a War...
Edit 3: No I did not convert...
If you wish to talk or learn about Islam please reply to this comment we can have a chat about it.
Something you should keep in mind: the Quran explicitly commands against sectarianism. The Shias are a sect that chooses to create division and even though in my opinion they are correct in the fact that Ali should have been the next Caliph, it is not cause enough to oppose the literal command of God in the Quran.
Always look for pure monotheism if u r lost with propaganda every where, & look always for authentic evidences. When it comes to shia creed it's based on polytheism (invocations towards others than God + giving their imams attributes that only befit God & many other blasphemies) & on propaganda (they believe 9/10 of the religion is taqiyah so they r always lying & even accept hadiths of well known liars). I don't advice u to rely on non muslim non scholar documentaries you have to read the Qur'an & study properly from reliable scholars but not blindly always examine the evidences. May ALLAH Guide us all
This specific matter you want to find out about, you won't find in the Quran. Hadith literature deals with this matter, but Hadith literature can be a little tricky to deal with since it is more along the lines of a primary source. Primary sources usually require expert treatment, so you would be better off talking to an expert such as a mufti (Islamic jurist). But what sort of mufti you might ask? You have seen that sectarianism exists in Islam as well. So who to trust you might rightly ask?
The key obstacle for anyone unfamiliar will be knowing which group is the correct one or who is a reliable source. But it's not impossible to know who is correct. With a little reasoning you can figure out who the original group of Muslims are and thus who is trustworthy. Religion comes to us via a historical process, so you simply find out whose methodology for preserving the sources of Islam is sound and whose arguments are consistent.
To save you a little time and give you some direction, I can tell you now that the Sunni group is the original group that is upon correct guidance. A sunni follows one of 4 schools of law - Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi and Hanbali. The original shia group known as the Jafari are also considered to be more or less upon correct guidance, except that they are mistaken in their belief concerning the 3 caliphs before Ali. Other shia groups are seriously misguided needless to say.
The justification I can provide for you is that the Sunni group was and still is the majority group. Since we are dealing with a historical matter, corroboration is important. The shia constituted a minority. We don't take the view of the minority over the majority.
In the video you saw mention was made of the incident of Gadir Kum 4:00. The word 'mawla' can mean a couple things as shown. Context provides the key. Ali had returned from distributing some war booty in Yemen if i recall correctly, and the people there were discontent. Word of this spread. So to prevent any false allegations from being believed as being true, Muhammad proclaimed Ali in the manner he did to dispel these allegations. The sunni have justification. The shia usually only have accusations. But you will see this for yourself in your research.
There are other groups too who broke away from the main body of Sunnis in the early part of Islam such as the Ibadis. So look at the reason why these groups formed. Always beware of splinter factions who believe that they are upon the truth. When it comes to historical corroboration the main body of Muslims will always have the strongest corroboration.
Also beware of the Wahabi sect and Salafi sect. They believe themselves to be true Sunnis, but are far down the historical timeline. Logic will compel one to ask what could they possibly know of the religion that the older groups (i.e. Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi, Hanbali) do not know?
Being a muslim, I only heard major sections of history like karbala and battle of Ali and ayesha but never in a sequence.. This cleared a lot of things for me.. Great work on the animation as well, looking forward to more videos on Islam
P. S already a subscriber and a follower
If anyone's learning about Islam. You must know some basics.
Muslims follow Prophet Muhammad and his noble household called Ahlulbait. Which includes Prophet Muhammad's successor Ali , Prophet Mohammed Noble and Holy Daughter Fatima and the Grandchildren of Prophet Muhammad Hasan and Hussain. These Muslims are known as Shias.
While Deviants who claim to be Muslim but in reality are Non Muslims such as Sunnis they follow Abu Bakr , Umar ,Usman ,and Abu Bakr's daughter Ayesha ,Umar's son Ubaidullah and Usman's cousin Muawiya all of those who fought against Prophet Muhammad's Successor Hazrat Ali in Jang e Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ). Many of Supporters of Abu Bakr and Ayesha such as the cousins of Ayesha named Talha and Zubair and Umar's son Ubaidullah were killed in Jang E Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Siffin ( Battle of Siffin ). Muslims defeated all of them led By the Commander of Ali's Army Sahaba ( Companion of Prophet Muhammad ) Malik e Ashtar and Ammar bin Yasir ( Hazrat Ammar was killed and got Martyred by Usman's cousin Muawiya at Battle of Siffin ).
Most sunnis are Nasibis ( Supporters of people who fought against Ali and his son Hasan and Hussain ) and Sunnis hate Muslims and hate Shias and call them Rafedah for rejection of People who fought against Prophet Muhammad's successor Hazrat Ali and Ahlulbait such as Ayesha and her dad Abu Bakr and Ubaidullah and his Dad Umar and Muawiya and his Yazeed son and his uncle Usman..
The only people who follow the true teaching of Prophet Muhammad are Shias.
While Sunnis follow Abu Bakr al Baghdadi and Umar.
Sunnis the followers of Abu Bakr,Umar and Usman betrayed Prophet Muhammad and Supported Usman's cousin Muawiya against Hazrat Ali and supported Muawiya's son Yazeed and killed Prophet Muhammad's Grandson Imam Hussain in Karbala. But the Killers of Properts Family the followers of Abu Bakr,Umar and Usman and Abu Bakr's daughter Ayesha who fought against Prophet Muhammad' successor Hazrat Ali blame supporters of Hussain in Iraq for being weak and not strong enough against them while they were killing Imam Hussain in Karbala. After Sunnis killed Imam Hussain they threw all the blame on others claiming others didn't support Imam Hussain hence they had to kill Prophet Muhammad's Grandson as they had no choice.
Muslims the Followers of Prophet Muhammad ,Fatima and Ali and Hasan and Hussain have nothing to do with followers of Ayesha and Muawiya who fought against Ahululbait in Jang E Jamal ( Battle of Camel ) and Jang e Suffin ( Battle of Siffin ). Sunnis hate any respect given to Martyrs of Karbala and instead celebrate the death of Grandson of Prophet Muhammad. Muslim have nothing to do with Sunni Nasibi who supported killing of Prophet Muhammad's family and Grandson. Sunnis are supporters of Abu Bakr and his daughter Ayesha, Umar and his daughter Hafsa and Usman and his cousin Muawiya while Muslims are followers of Prophet Muhammad ,Fatima ,Ali and Hasan, Hussian.
@@bigDaddy-lx9sn sunnis are not muslim ? you must be kidding, look at Shia today , they are pagans
@EveryIsnaad IsFabricated all this nonsense you bring has already been refuted not only by Muslim scholars, but even Orientalist scholars like Angelika Neuwirth. Moreover ,the Quran does not simply "copy" these stories but also has information not found in those writings and often corrects these stories.
Secondly, just because the Quran contains information found in apocryphal writings doesnt mean that it is wrong. There was great dispute in the early church about which books were to be included in the Canon. And even biblical inheretists themselves admit this because they realize that the bible itself contains some quotations of Apocryphal writings. There are quotes in there from 1 Enoch which is considered a pseudonymous writing. There are numerous examples from scripture of quotation of religious works that are not canon. The Book of Jasher is quoted in Joshua 10:13, 2 Samuel 1:17-19, and 2 Timothy 3:8.
Book of Shemaiah, and of Iddo the Seer is quoted in 2 Chronicles 9:29, 2 Chronicles 12:15, and 2 Chronicles 13:22
Book of the Wars of the Lord is quoted in Numbers 21:14.
Thirdly, its hard to Imagine Muhammad having access to these writings Especially in Arabic, and we know for a fact that papyrus hadnt even reached Arabia at that time. Whatever was written down was on animal skin or stones or bones usually. So my point is it doesnt really affect the integrity of the Quran as a scripture and this argument is mostly used by Christian missionaries. But nice try.
@EveryIsnaad IsFabricated bruh 😂 thats pure revisionism. With your "careful scholar" there is a consensus among western scholars that Muhammad was a historical figure. There radical revisionist theories on the origins of Islam which were popularized by Patricia Crone and Michael Cook is all nonsense. Many Orientalist scholars in the field have already debunked these radical revisionist views. Like William Montgomery Watt, F.E. Peters, Norman Daniel, Angelika Neuwirth. Those are careful scholars. Not your weird German scholar no one has ever heard of. You're kind of delusional and sad that you like your own comment 😂 I suggest you go back to school.
you should learn about how unhumane islam is
I love this video. Thank you man.
Thanks for these informations,
Oh My God. You updated this in the Holy Month of Ramadhan.
The only month they can release this.
What’s wrong? It is the truth and we all shall accept the truth
Probably he realized it, that is a great reason to discuss the topic!
So? What triggers u
Errmmm. So ? What does the month have to do with it ! Confused. 😳
The way imam Ali handled the situation with Omar and abu baker was so professional, even tho he should be the chosen one and the fact that his wife was murdered in a very ugly way. Mind you she’s the prophets daughter. His sons all followed his steps and tried to avoid fitna, the fact Hassan gave everything up, yet they brainwashed his wife to poison her own husband. The last one was left and it was Hussein, you all probably wonder why we always shout Husseins name because he saw his whole family and friends die infront of him yet he never gave up and fought for Islam. They are the ones who always chose god and Islam over this world’s power and money. They stood against fitna in all sorts of ways but people are always greedy of this worlds riches, as if they will stay here forever. Your video actually made cry and teached me more about my history. Thankyou so much!
🤣🤣🤣.
Prophet Daughter was being Killed and where was Ali (RA)
I also appreciate History, factual history, as long someone does not try and change history to suit their own needs, even though they did not go into a lot of the conquest Muhammad took on
@@whiteholeeducationcenter Funny i fought for 8 years against Muslims, never saw Ali come down and save any of em from me. Doesn't mean I insult someone FOR NO REASON
@@whiteholeeducationcenter are you making fun of Ali Ra
@@whiteholeeducationcenter Ali was out minding his own business, when he came back, he saw Fatima sick and ill after getting attacked by Omar and Abu bakr bc they thought she was lying that her husband is not home so they attacked the home and accidentally hurt her. everyone in the neighbourhood saw that and admitted to it. She was sick for one month then passed away and after that Ali gave up on the chalipate and they asked him 3 times before he accepted it again.
I’m Indian Sunni Muslim nd from Farooqui family , I have started research about this topic Ali and his family suffered I do have more love towards them my heart cry when I heard about them
Then become shia muslim. They are on right path. Sarat al mustaqeem. Sunni think neither Prophet nor Allah thaught to leave someone as leader substitude or write Quran or hadith at the time knowing how big issue this will become. Such a big insult on Allah and Prophet knowledge that later on person like abu bakr and some companions thought about this.
THis is lie btw. According to Shia muslims, it was Imam Ali (AS) who was chosen as we see in Prophet's last sermon at Ghadeer and many other hadtih like Ali to Prophet is like harun to musa. No musa means Harun or Ali as leader.
Also how abu bakr stole fadak and lied about it *Sahih bukhari 4240* from daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima like She is ordinary person, she is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise not just a women, clearly he is not saddiq and umer not farooq.
Congratulations, you found Islam
Astaghfirullah tauba krle bhaiya kahan mushrik ayr munafiq Shiaon ki baaton mei aarha
Shia ko munafiq log kahte hai jubkey ye nahi daykte kai abu bakr ney kaisa Bibi Fatima ka haq kaya *Sahih bukhari 4240* aur apney apko bani saqifa mey khalifa banaya. Phir uper sey humey munafiq kahte hai
@@syedbaqir2687 Shia mushrik
Ali giving one of his daughters to the second, in historical texts, is extremely vague with the details so diverse from narrator to narrator that many historians don't believe the case
You don't know why he did that ?
@@gq55sqgq55sqdoa First prove to me that he did
@@gq55sqgq55sqdoa first prove to me he did
Yazeed who killed Hazrat Hussain is cursed person.
Both sunnis and shias are agreed on it that yazeed was cruel and curse person.
It's really difficult to know which info is correct or wrong since both sides have their own history interpretations.
In this video, the guy favours the shia's interpretation of the events. At least, he did for the early part of the schism. I think he show provide more from both sources about battle of Karbala.
@@rebelwind6474 Its not the uploader, its historians in general interpret this way. The only way a person will favour a Sunni variation is if he ONLY listen to Sunni works. Which shows academically the position is weaker.
I don’t think personally that Mauwiyah and Yazid accepted Islam sincerely and their actions were all against prophet Mohammad family.
@wim develder You arent even presenting the narrative right. They arent favouring "Shia claims", they are looking at both claims are coming in the middle. You think thats all Shias claim? No, there were many things he left out, but we didnt complain because we realize this is a neutral attempt. So we are accepting if our views are left out. However, its just like you said, since Sunnis are in the majority, they never had to face another opinion. They were stuck in their own bubble of ignorance. But now with the internet, everything is being exposed. This is what happens when you follow taqiyya sunni lies and your scholars dont allow you to research. Your sect are followers of Kaab al Ahbar, a Jewish scholar who came to infiltrate. Thats where Umar got his teachings from.
@wim develder Look like my reply to you was deleted. Points to summarize were: You lied about me, I didnt say that, you are a sunni taqiyya follower of Kaab Al Ahbar, your AISHA (the one who was accused of being an adulterer and consistently lied about the Prophet) said a GOAT ATE the Quran, and your Abu Bakr Umar and Uthman Lanat on all three are burning in hell. You are not a Muslim, you are a Bakri and Umari since you follow Caliphates over the Prophet's dying order.
ramadan mubarak to all my shia and sunni brothers and sisters.... and peace be upon non muslims aswell
shia aren't muslims,
@@justaperson2533 if they believe in Allah SWT and follow Qur'an then they are and rest Allah is the best judge. We are nobody to tear each other down.
Ps- I'm a sunni
@@justaperson2533 Shia are definitely muslims and yes im also sunni
@@Natalia-cm8ez no actually they completely turn everything which is bad halal why is tattoo halal to them? while allah made it forbidden? WHY and WHY do they drink alcohol but ALCHOHOL is forbidden in REAL islam their not real sister but your right, tearing down others isn't helping either
@@mayazmahmud1740 proof?
I don't understand how they found the strength to hurt the Prophet's Children and Descendants. How??😰😰
power and greed blind people
“People are of two types: they are either your brothers in faith or your equals in humanity.” Imam Ali
My Dad is Sunni and my Mum is Shia, and it makes me sad when I go out with Sunnis they say all Shias are bad or when I go out with Shias they say all Sunnis are bad. I would like to say thank you to my mother for looking after me all those years and thank you to my father for supporting me in my hardest times, they truly are the best gifts from Allah to me. But the best gift would be the reunion of this Ummah, so I don't have to worry about people insulting my mother or father simply because they are Sunni or Shia. 🤲 آمين يارب
Just like you wouldn't want anyone insulting your mother or father, sunnis don't want shias to insult their mother Aisha(ra), and the companions of the Prophet(saw).
@@margaretappleton3437 if you truely studied Islam in depth you will understand the reason why they curse (Aisha) and some criminal (companions) the cursing ritual first started with (Muawiyah the son of Abi Sufyan) he was encouraging the whole community to curse (Ali the successor and cousin of Islamic Prophet Muhammad)
@@jameswohley3332 Cursing Ali only happened during Ummayad rule. All sunnis since then praise the companions and the family of the Prophet(saw). Shias took it too far and invented lies about the companions so they can continue cursing them to this day.
@@margaretappleton3437 Yes and you think (Muawiyah) was doing the right thing by cursing the Prophets(PBUH) family? open your eyes you Sunnis praise Muwaiyah by saying (RA) how is Allah pleased with such person that massacred and waged war against the Prophets family.
@@jameswohley3332 Look, the major disagreements between sunnis and shias today are not about Muawiyah vs Ali, or Yazid being wrong. These things are not actively disputed that much beyond in a historical sense, and many sunnis don't like muawiyah and yazid.
In reality it's more regarding the additional claims made by the shias about the companions of the Prophet(saw), how shias continue to insult them, and all the other inventions made by the shias like their imamah.
Even though I’m a Sunni, it breaks my heart for what happened hazrat Husain. We was the beloved grandson of the prophet and the prophet loved him so much 💔
Sunni, Shia don’t matter to me 😊 we all brothers by belief
One in a Billion sunni who has respect for Prophet Muhammad and his Ahlulbait.
@@ibrahim-sj2cr i am upset about the betrayal brother. I am never siding with the peoplw who betrayed and killed Hazrat Hussain. I love Hazrat Hussain. Just because of the name muslim doesnt make you a righteuous person, even in muslims there are wrong doers. I don't side with Muawiyah or Yazzid. But at the same time i cant hate on Hazrat Abu Bakr or Umar, I love them and their teachings at the same time. I think its time for the Muslim ummah to unit under the name of the Khalima and not be fighting each other, because we already have so many groups attacking our ummah.
@@bigDaddy-lx9sn that is not true, I think you have got your facts about sunnis wrong my brother. Believing in the Prophet Muhammad PBUH and his sunnah is the base of islam. If you dont follow his teaching, then I doubt we could even call ourself muslims
@@ibrahim-sj2cr yes I am sorry about that brother, i worded my point wrong. I just want our ummah to be united and nit being split into groups. Insha Allah we all could forget our differences and unite under single flag
@@sarahwewe9201 Abu Bakr and his Gang with Umar and Usman and their followers also known as Sunni Nasiba killed the Prophet Muhammad and his family.
True Islam is with Shias who follow Prophet Muhammad, Fatima ,Ali, Hasan , Hussain.
This is the best channel around. It decepts correctly with little errors
Seems like fellow Muslims were jealous of Ali
Omar and Abu Bakr were definitely jealous of Imam Ali.
Yes they are mostly Sunni Muslim