Ranking EVERY 2D Mario Game
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.พ. 2023
- In today's episode I give a bunch of cntroversial takes on 2D Marios. From the New Super Mario Bros. Series to the classic Super Mario Bros 3, there is a ton of variety from just one plumber. Thank you all for EIGHT THOUSAND SUBSCRIBERS!!!
Video Credits:
New Super Mario Bros U Footage: • New Super Mario Bros. ... - NintendoCentral
New Super Mario Bros U Challenges Footage: • New Super Mario Bros U... - Nintendo Base
New Super Luigi U Footage: • New Super Luigi U Worl... - NintendoCentral
New Super Mario Bros 2 Footage: • New Super Mario Bros. ... - NintendoCentral
New Super Mario Bros 2 Gold Rush Footage: • New Super Mario Bros 2... - packattack04082
New Super Mario Bros 2 1 Million Coins Footage: • New Super Mario Bros. ... - YTSunny
New Super Mario Bros DS Footage: • New Super Mario Bros. ... - NintendoCentral
New Super Mario Bros DS Mario v Luigi Footage - • New Super Mario Bros D... - packattack04082
• New Super Mario Bros D... - packattack04082
New Super Mario Bros DS Minigames Footage -
• New Super Mario Bros. ... - YTSunny
• New Super Mario Bros. ... - YTSunny
New Super Mario Bros Wii Footage: • New Super Mario Bros. ... - NintendoCentral
New Super Mario Bros Wii TAS Footage - • [TAS] Wii New Super Ma... - TASVideoChannel
Super Mario World Footage - www.youtube.com/watch?v=F9q20... - RetroGame.Stream
Kaizo Mario TAS Footage - • [TAS] KAIZO MARIO WORL... - Amaraticando
Super Mario Bros Footage - • [Longplay] NES - Super... - xRavenXP
Super Mario Bros 2 Footage - • [Longplay] NES - Super... - xRavenXP
Super Mario Bros 3 Footage - • [Longplay] NES - Super... - xRavenXP
Super Mario Land Footage - • [Longplay] GB - Super ... - xRavenXP
Super Mario Land DX Footage - • Super Mario Land DX (G... - Street Mozart VIDΣӨ GΛMΣ
Super Mario Land 2 Footage - • Super Mario Land 2: 6 ... - NintenU
Super Mario All Stars Footage - • [Longplay] SNES - Supe... - xRavenXP
Super Mario Bros 2 (JP) Footage - • Super Mario Bros 2: Th... - Typhlosion4President
Super Mario Bros 2 (JP) Warp Zones Footage - • SMB The Lost Levels Wa... - Channel 84 Winnipeg
Yoshi's Island Footage - • [Longplay] SNES - Supe... - xRavenXP
Wario Land Footage - • [Longplay] GB - Super ... - xRavenXP
Mario Maker Trailer - • Wii U - Super Mario Ma... - Nintendo of America
Mario Maker 2 Trailer - • Super Mario Maker 2 - ... - Nintendo of America
Super Mario Advance Footage - • [Longplay] GBA - Super... - xRavenXP
Paper Mario Origami King Footage - / watch v=uKeDjjDcr8I - Boss Fight Database
Super Mario 3D World - • Super Mario 3D World +... - Nintendo of America
Doki Doki Panic Footage - • Longplay of Yume Koujo... - LongplayArchive
Mario Bros Footage - • Arcade Longplay [500] ... - World of Longplays
Music Used (In Order):
Menu - NSMB U OST
1-1 - Super Mario Land OST
1--3 - Super Mario Land OST
2-3 - Super Mario Land OST
Overworld - Super Mario All Stars OST
Atheletic - NSMB Wii OST
Castle Boss - NSMB Wii OST
Beach - NSMB Wii OST
Overworld - Super Mario Bros OST
Underworld - NSMB 2 OST
Rainbow - NSMB 2 OST
Volcano Underground - NSMB OST
Overworld - Super Mario Bros 2 OST
Underworld - Super Mario Bros 2 OST
Ending & Credits - Super Mario Bros 2 OST
Overworld - NSMB DS OST
Vs. World Overworld - NSMB DS OST
Mini-Game Menu - NSMB DS OST
Card Game - NSMB DS OST
Overworld - NSMB U OST
Athletic - NSMB U OST
Final Boss (Phase 1) - New Super Luigi U OST
Athletic - Super Mario Land 2 OST
Staff Roll - Super Mario Land 2 OST
Overworld 2 - Super Mario Bros 3 OST
Airship Theme - Super Mario Bros 3 OST
Ending Theme - Super Mario Bros 3 OST
Athletic - Super Mario World OST
Ending & Credit - Super Mario World OST
Rest Area - SSBM OST - เกม
Bro just said Wario wasn't a human being 💀
i mean he really isnt
Well he isnt
and you're saying he is???????
He’s not and I refuse to acknowledge him as such
He isn’t human. He’s a god.
I appreciate you actually compared the new super Mario bros games for what they offer instead of just throwing U and 2 at the bottom of the list because we’re tired of them. Really nice list!
I would die for another sprite art mario game with new theming, enemies, and open world mechanics.
seems like Nintendo is focusing a lot of their creative efoorts into the 3D Marios but hey it has been a while since the last "new" game
@@SlightlyInDepthGaming i mean, its been 10 years since the last original 2D game and 6 years since the last original 3D game.
@@wogardrodriguez2671 Technically it's only been two because of Bowser's Fury
@@bowandarrow688 Last original Full 3D Mario*
Well now wonder is coming out
Thank you all for 8 THOUSAND SUBSCRIBERS!! I'm sorry I couldnt get this video out on Sunday like I promised, I had the worst tech issues of my life trying to render this and so I had to use a couple workarounds. There are a few font errors and all but otherwise it's in full form! Let's keep pushing onto 10K!
No problem, keep up the great content! Your channel deserves more views with how well edited the videos are and how consistent the quality is. Oh, and have you tried possibly rendering the videos in chunks before combining them? That could potentially help make rendering for the final revisions of the videos less slow/troublesome.
you are at 11k
Mario Bros. 3 is the GOAT in my heart.
Not a bad choice at all
And now we have Super Mario Bros Wonder on it’s way and I’m genuinely curious on how you would rank the game to this video’s list when it comes out?
there is no alternative universe where New super Mario Bros 2 is better than New Super Mario Bros Wii
This is the very first time I ever heard that. Saying Wii is the worst of the series? I couldn't believe it.
2 is basically Wii but with better level design and without all that empty space from Wii.
Agreed. New Mario 2 gets way too much hate.
SLIDG: These two games don't feature a controllable human character.
Wario: Am I a joke to you?
he's not a human, he's Wario
That’s the joke
That’s a bit long of an acronym Sig or Slightly work better really
@@SlightlyInDepthGaming I was only kidding I don't really care that much
I WONDER when that next 2D Mario will come out?
I see what you did there 😉 😂
Lmao.
Boy do i have a suprise for you. Watch the June 2023 Nintendo direct and Scroll to the end of the direct
SMW was just so good to play. The level design, the huge "open" world, the secret Ghost houses, the Star Road, etc.
SMB3 came close, but Mario World just blew it away.
There's a reason why the Kaizo Scene from SMW took over and made Nintendo release Mario Maker 1+2.
I like the NSMB entry on the DS, too.
Here's my Top 5:
1. Super Mario World
2. Super Mario Bros 3
3. Super Mario Land 2
4. Super Mario Bros
5. New Super Mario Bros DS
That’s an extremely solid top 5, the original super Mario bros over all the New games is a little crazy tho
@@SlightlyInDepthGaming It's nostalgia mainly. It was either this or SMB2.
Didn't like the Wii versions aswell as every other 2D entry after it.
They're too easy IMO.
nah smb3 clears smw
Put some respect on NSMBW ☠️😭
I grew up on Super Mario World and it’s still probably my favorite game of all time. It’s just perfect.
Your videos are just too good!
I thought you were some 1mil ytber with these videos!
Hopefully you grow more :D
That’s the plan! I’ll keep going until I am a 1 million sub youtuber
@@SlightlyInDepthGaming Then what? You'll stop? That's not a good plan. Keep going.
@@ChadWSmith Forever. Without end.
Finally another based super Mario land 2 enjoyer. Such a creative and fun game
based and sml2 pilled goated game
My response to the auto scroll complaint is that at least SMB3 keeps them engaging with a lot of obstacles thrown at you. Compare that to NSMB2 where they’re just painfully dull and lacking in substance. Yes that super giant boo was cool for like, a few seconds.
But yes, choosing between World and 3 is a very thin line. I’m in the Mario 3 camp because I feel like the secret exit hunting slows the pacing in World down sometimes, but both are top quality.
You know that’s fair enough but there’s gotta be more auto scrollers in 3 (I haven’t done an exact count) so it feels worse
Thanks for the Land 2 appreciation, that game is awesome.
It’s a great game so it deserves it
Dude your jokes are actually so hilarious without feeling forced and without distracting from the vid. Content is informative and interesting even tho i dont actually care about mario. Love the channel and you def gonna blow up to like 100k soon, keep it up
Thanks a lot yo! I really hope I’m able to hit 100k!
@@SlightlyInDepthGaming The well researched videos along with the humor are sure to get you there! Soon enough explosions like the wario mario pill will become the norm I'm sure :)
just found this channel, great mario channel!
I approve of the majority of this list, except for the unfair treatment of Wii. The stupid fun of 4 players is really, well, fun! And, let’s not forget this is the first 2D Mario game that allows more than 2 players, and it really was my childhood, as I always used to play the game with my dad. I am definitely biased, but I thoroughly believe it deserved to be ranked higher than Mario Bros, and New Super Mario Bros 2. I respect your opinion, but what confused me is how you really only criticized the boss fights, which let me remind you, are almost exactly the same as New Super Mario Bros 2 (minus the mini-castles), along with being the first game since Super Mario Bros 3 that brought back the Koopalings.
Bruh, Super Mario Land was a Gameboy launch title. It only exists to be on Gameboy. In any case, the game is well worth it if only for its OST.
Mario bros wonder shows that Nintendo are finally getting creative with the art style instead of the same copy paste formula from years ago
Fnally somebody who doesn't just shit on NSMBU for 15 minutes
Oooh boy you’re going to LOVE Super Mario Bros Wonder when it comes out. Only 1 day until release!
I find it so funny how you make the worst game on your list sound so great
I wish Nintendo would make a 2d Mario game that's as creative as the Mario Land series. But maybe because the modern ones are in 3d, the assets aren't worth making for them.
Yeah it seems a lot of the creativity goes to projects like Galaxy and Odyseey but 2D Mario has been working with the new series for a while
@@TJS2009why you might get your wish because now we got a new 2D Mario game
This guy is so unbelievably underrated, I thought from his content that he’d have at least 250k. It’s not much, but you earned my sub bro, keep up the good work 💯
Da king is back baby he neva miss
I wouldn’t be the king if I eva missed now would I
I like The Lost Levels in the same way I like The Perfect Run from Super Mario Galaxy 2. It requires you to play perfectly and it gets creative with how to make levels more difficult. The thing is Lost Levels shouldn't have been its own game. If all the levels from it were just bonus stages that you unlock after beating the original, it'd be great, but by being a standalone game the difficulty curve is wrecked from the start (unlike The Perfect Run which is the final level in Galaxy 2, giving the player 241 stars to master the game)
this is a great take, the lost levels just feels like an extension of the first game but as a standalone title. Imagine if that was someone's first Mario game, it would completely put them off the series. The perfect run is also a fantastic level!
they're both difficult but for different reasons. the perfect run is difficult because it's challenging, lost levels is difficult because it has god awful level design
Even if you put it at number 7, I'm glad you actually gave appreciation to Mario 2. Seriously, what IS it with people looking over Mario 2? Like sure; it is a re-skin of Doki Doki Panic, but if it's fun I don't think it should be overlooked even if it is a re-skin. Besides, Doki Doki Panic didn't even have a run button. Mario 2 added it. Plus, I don't even think it's a stretch to say it's the best looking NES Mario game, and one of my personal favourites visually.
Watching this after wonder announcement
Great video, well researched, good humour - easy sub!
Thanks for subscribing!
I mean the wind chapter in Celeste is great, but that's not a Mario wind level I suppose
Not at all, the chapter doesn't really do anything to test your platforming skills, it's just annoying. Unlike other mechanics in Celeste, this one doesn't let you have a slimmer of a chance to pass a hazard even if you have technically failed, in a wind section you're either frame perfect or u have to wait for her to fall in a bottomless pit
@@ros9764 agree to disagree? 🤝
@@FeeshUnofficial Hey, if u have found enjoyment in that level, more power to you man
Damn an actual civilized discussion on the Internet???? Btw golden ridge was my least favorite level when I played Celeste for the first time but now that I’ve played it like 8 billion times I’ve grown to like it
@@SlightlyInDepthGaming Honestly i really love the B side of chapter 4 because it's very fast but also super precise. It gives you the same feeling you get after P ranking a Pizza Tower level
With The Lost Levels, you should also relize that America was still recovering from the video game crisis
Wait this guy only has 12k subs? Someone got this mans some views he should have at least 100k.
It’s cruel how low you ranked super mario bros wii. In my opinion it’s the best of the games labeled “new”.
I feel like New Super Luigi U at least deserves to slot over it due to his unique gameplay, U and 2 are debatable for sure. DS got that goated multiplayer
SMW! Not to mention the graphics and colors!
Starting with Super Mario Land immediately told me that my guy hasn't played Super Mario Bros. Special.
Good video though!
we don't talk about super mario bros special
“You collect more bodies than the manager of a sweatshop” JESUS
I do wonder where the e-reader levels would have ranked if you had included them
This channel is super underrated. Great videos bro
Thanks a ton!
Underated af.
Underated
Im biased because Mario bros Wii was my first game but I think Mario bros Wii is the best 2d Mario
They listened, mario wonder direct tomorrow
Love the vids! I just found you today and watched a few videos!
I'm glad you found me!
finally, someone who put wii where it belongs
9:49 lol
He said "not in a sex way" so fast i almost didn't catch it. at 20:47
Can't believe you didn't mention those damn phantos. Worst enemy in the entire series. Like something from Castlevania one.
Ive played every single one (not to completion). If I kept my opinion in there, NSMB2 might win due to fun factor and nostalgia
Super Mario Land has what all other Mario games don't have: Adultery
lmao ok that's actualy really funny
New Super Mario Bros.
Is the only game I own physically since it's not available digitally (I believe all DS games aren't), I just have that one that's permanently in the cartridge slot of my 3DS which also just happens to be the only console I still own even if it's technically a handheld and not a console but it's still the closest I have.
It’s on wiiu
I need some help from some of yall..... I want to get mario bros u deluxe but im not that good at 2d platformers plus there is no manual saving wich can get annoiyng , so what do yall think?
Am I the only one who unironically thinks that potato chips is the best chips?
Also I am pretty sure that Mussolini is the most famous italian.
Potato chips are pretty good just not better than other food
I think Julius Caesar is more famous than Mussolini
@@Hi-fd4cw Bro couldn't even make the trains run on time he ain't got shit on Mario "Jumpman" Mario
im so happy you are still making videos
even though you uploaded not long ago i just barely found you and most people when i find them they have already quit youtube
Of course! I’m gonna keep going till I hit the top!
5:20 I’d argue Celeste has a great wind level (chapter 4)
wonder!
New Super Luigi U🙏
You want controversial? Wario give you controversial!
1) New Super Mario Bros U
2) New Super Luigi U
3) Super Mario World
4) New Super Mario Bros
5) New Super Mario Bros Wii
6) Super Mario Bros 3
7) New Super Mario Bros 2
8) Super Mario Bros 2
9) Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins
10) Super Mario Land
11) Super Mario Bros
12) Super Mario Bros: The Lost Levels
banger, become more popular or else
This is not Triston
Thanks definitely not triston
i *wonder* what number mario wonder will get
New super Mario bros Wii fans: cries softly pretending to not want anyone to see them when in reality they just want everyone to know that they are sad
All bias no thoughts I would put new super mario bros just for the multiplayer alone.
We stan Mario vs Luigi
Now, where does Super Mario Run fit into the picture? That is a 2D Mario.
can we pretend that one didn't happen
@@SlightlyInDepthGaming You said EVERY 2D Mario game.
great video as always! keep it up man
Don’t worry I will!
I wanna play mario now, fuck.
0:11
Emulation?
Miyamoto is hunting you
im just like the lost levels
um ackshually in certain sections of yoshis island you do control baby mario
there's no way yoshis island isn't a 2d mario game but luigi u which doesn't even have mario in it is
Thanks for finally giving U the credit it deserves, never understood why ppl thought it was lesser than the other when it’s definitively the best version of the “new” games.
Wait a second, WHERE IS SUPER MARIO WONDER? I'm just joking rn, but unfortunly this video got old in 2024. Still you did an amazing job... You were kidding when you said that nsmb wii is worse than smb, right?
This list has some crazy placements but I can say that I respect them.
what placements do you think were nuts?
@@SlightlyInDepthGaming
Mario Wii at 2nd worst.
Celeste has a good wind level
golden ridge was my least favorite level on my first playthrough, now I don't mind it
When I first saw your Mariopill & Wariopill video, I assumed you had at least 50k subs. I am incredibly surprised that you do not, but I know you'll get there sooner rather than later!
Hopefully I will!
You have good videos I'm surprised you only have 8 thousand subscribers.
Hopefully I can get more!
If super mario bros 2 copied doki doki panic, then how was the game allowed to be published?
It was done through the proper channels, Nintendo didn’t just take the game lol
Super mario land is not a bad game, in fact its so good because of how weird it is!
it definitely has a certain charm to it
great video!
Thanks!
mario world rewards you so well in secret stages, with an amazing level design and a lot of fun
Honestly, I actually think NSMB2 is the worst out of the NSMB series because it’s just so unoriginal. Like, the only new gimmick is the collecting a bunch of coins, but other than that it just feels like a handheld version of NSMBW and I would argue that the Wii version actually had more new ideas since it was the first home console 2D Mario game in a long time, you can also play with 4 people for the first time, the koopalings made a return after not seeing them in a long time. Like, I feel like it does more new things than NSMB2. I don’t hate NSMB2, it’s a fun game to blast through, but I would rather play the other NSMB games. Also, NSMB DS is no doubt the best game in the series. It has the best level design, has unique, it has mini games and the multiplayer mode (something I unfortunately never got to try), and it was the first 2D Mario since Mario Land 2. Like, NSMBU is good, but I don’t think it should be higher than the DS version.
But the true best 2d mario game is the e-reader levels in super mario advance 4
Ur videos r so funny and ur really well informed idk how you dont have more subs
Good list. I'm surprised you put Wii so low on the list. I agree the game is over-rated but I personally put it in a medium tier. It's just "ok" to me. If you swapped Wii with NSMB 2 I would agree. NSMB 2 on the 3DS is just "bleh" to me. I didn't like Super Mario Land 2 as much as the first one. I'm not sure why exactly but I like Super Mario Land more. As for the "war" between 3 and World, as much as I enjoy World, I find it didn't do much extra...if any. Sure it has Yoshi and ghost houses, but the world map just seems bland. Mostly different variations of green and brown. Too many grassy plain levels and an over abundance of underground levels. Super Mario Bros. 3 is better in almost every way.
I guess my personal list would be this. From least to greatest...
12. The Lost Levels
11. Super Mario Land 2
10. Super Mario Land
9. New Super Mario Bros. 2
8. Super Mario Bros.
7. Super Mario Bros. 2
6. New Super Mario Bros. Wii
5. New Super Mario Bros. DS
4. New Super Luigi U
3. New Super Mario Bros. U
2. Super Mario World
1. Super Mario Bros. 3
You had me until you put Wii below 2 and U
I mostly agree but HOW DARE YOU PUT WII SO LOW
I would love to see your ranking of all the paper Mario games
I’ve only played a few but maybe one day
Which ones have you played?
great writing
9/10 !
dang not a perfect score I'll have to do better
no way bro put the og above wii
just say you grew up with it lil brotha I don't care if you have your own opinion just don't put some useless ass comment here and pretend your opinion is god lil bro
Do people not know wthat 3D means nowadays
Bro you forgot super Mario 35.I’m so disappointed
Your opinion hurts me nsmb wii is my absolute favorite 😅
5:50 Uh what… every single version of the lost levels includes saving. You never have to start the game completely over from a game over. I don’t know why you would even think this
Also NSMB DS is a horrible game and I can’t believe you would put it over Mario 2!
bruh I like mario 2 but nsmb ds aint bad lil bro dont act like yo opinion is the right one lil bro
@@WarioEnthusiast NSMB DS is ugly and I think it's lacking in creativity
@@MaxOakland graphics don't make or break a game and a generic game isn't the same as a bad one your ass dumb
Where was SMBX
Nice video
Thanks!
I completely agree with your list. By that I mean, it is completely correct based on your opinion, as you stated.
HOWEVER, I would like to point out a couple of things.
1. The *3* Super Mario Maker games (everyone forgets the one for the 3DS), came with pack-in levels designed by Nintendo. SMM 2 has like 100 levels, and a "story mode" tying them all together. I would say that it does qualify as a mainline Super Mario 2D platformer. (and they have their own unique mechanics - for example, the Shellmets - which I pray will be included in the next mainline 2D Super Mario game, regardless of it's Maker status.)
2. Super Mario Advance 4 - Super Mario Bros. 3 with the eReader levels has it's own... levels. And those levels combine elements from SMB 1, 2 (both versions of 2), 3, and World in unique ways that even with the 3 Maker games, we still haven't seen done again. (There is no grass in Super Mario Maker 2.) As such, I think that *THIS* game is better than World.
3. I didn't know about the multiplayer for NSMB for the DS. Mind blown. Thanks.
Hmm now I’m curious to try out these E-Reader levels if you hold them in such high regard
who tf names their mom Jillon
A certain individual who shall not be named decided that on his own
You made me hungry for the snack size bag of Lays I had in my kitchen. Thank you.
No problem 🙏
i agree so much on super mario worlds placement
Mario land 1 and 2 remake please nintendo😊
How do you say Wii is the worst it’s better than U and 2 ??
No it isn't all of wiis bosses are shit and it's trash without multiplayer