RIP Bessie Matthews RIP Copper RIP Anabelle RIP Jenny Kirk RIP Davey Callander RIP Mac Callander RIP Sean Maguire RIP Kieran Duffy RIP Hosea Matthews RIP Lenny Summers RIP Molly O'Shea RIP Cain RIP Susan Grimshaw RIP Arthur Morgan RIP Leopold Strauss RIP Karen Jones RIP Cleet RIH Joe RIH Micah Bell III. RIP Javier Escuella RIP Bill Williamson RIP Dutch van der Linde RIP Uncle RIP John Marston RIP Abigail Marston
We did though - that’s the point. They both got their redemption - Arthur through doing good in the latter stages of life and John through protecting his family and hunting down the traitors in the Van Der Linde gang
How fitting that the last gunslinger was also the youngest member of the gang Edit:Dudes and dudettes this is the highest amount of likes i have ever got thank you
@@dkharmer05We don't know that. Just because they survived the epilogue of 2 doesn't mean they're still alive. They could have died off screen. I think Charles would probably still be alive but Sadie was way too reckless and a loose canon so she's probably dead.
Yep the worst nightmare to not have anyone but an empty house that John build with such effort and a hat and his gun that's all I don't think he even had Rufus in rdr 1
The fate of Jack is known, in GTA V at franklin’s new house you can see a book in one of his shelves called “Red Dead” by J. Marston and considering he loved reading books so much its evident that he became a writer in later years.
@@Altair582cl I think Jack living to 100 is a bit far fetched. Guy was born in 1895 he probably never moved into a city cause of the entire Gang’s hate of big cities (meaning he never got good healthcare) and lasted till about the 60s and died of an infection or something
John going after Micah pretty much made everything Arthur fought for at the end obsolete. Arthur told him to run and never look back, that revenge was a “fool’s game.” John looked back, went after Micah, and ended up getting the Pinkertons on his trail again.
@@denizgurel8949Lenny, literally probably one of the most honourable people in the gang. And so young too, unlike Sean who even though he was likeable, was an arsehole. Lenny didn’t deserve his death, but it plays into the tragedy of RDR
i think about this often too. surprisingly you’re the first person i’ve come across that mentioned it. but yeah John and Arthur are like brothers without the same blood. it would be interesting to see how they would have incorporated that if Arthur had made it out alive in the end of RDR2.
The ending I wanted for this game was John coming back and shooting Micah and then taking Arthur to somewhere dry and he miraculously survives and then Arthur goes to live with Mary and John settles down with his family
@@royale_legend1497 back then if you had tb your only chance was to go somewhere dry and warm and maybe if John took Arthur somewhere like that he mightve survived but I think he was too sick in the end anyway
Fortunately, Jack Marston, Charles Smith, Pearson, Josiah Trelawny, Reverend Swanson, Sadie Adler, Mary-beth Gaskill and Tilly Jackson are in 1914 alive.
Great story improvement from Gta5. GTA 5: every bad guy dies, you can choose not to kills your friends. Rdr: almost everyone dies. You don't like it? Too bad.
Oh my God, i Miss josiah trelawny, reverand, captain Monroe (i like him) when i enter chapter 6. But, those 3 and the rest of the Van der Linde gang (or not all of them are Van der Linde gang) we're lucky
@@htk_ket Sadie was not even an idea until the making of RDR2. Only Javier, Dutch, Bill, Abigail, Jack, Uncle, Rufus(the dog), and Edgar Ross are characters that are ideas that are in RDR2. The rest don’t exist in the brain of John in RDR1. This is why RDR1 should be remade, not because of the graphics but because John doesn’t mention the new characters even once. Arthur as a person doesn’t exist in Johns head in RDR1.
@@Banjo1111 I don't think you get what I'm saying. What if in RDR2 they specifically named Sadie Adler Sadie because they wanted to match it with the newspaper death in RDR1? Not the fact that Sadie Adler being apart of the gang happening.
@@therealJJ12 we don't know if the newspaper was talking about Sadie Adler or some random person named Sadie, and I don't think Sadie Adler was thought of in rdr1
@@mrepical7235 They could have decided to name Sadie because of the Sadie that died in the newspaper. It would've shown that we know Sadie's death even before.
Fun fact: the vanderlin gang was based off an actual gang from the 1800’s that they also robbed trains and stores but soon fell apart near the 1900’s. Tho most of the gang members died to lawmen or were captured and hung. But after most of them left the gang some members continued their crime spree and turning on each other but only one lived to see the 20th century but died to heart failure.
Of i remember right Charles said Strauss was captured by the Pinkerton soon after being kicked out by Arthur. He was apparently tortured to death to force him to reviel informations on the gang but he said nothing
honestly, it’s Dutch’s fault that Arthur died, Micah killed Arthur but Dutch kept trusting Micah. Even though they only knew each other for a few months in the event’s of 1899. And also, don’t forget Dutch didn’t do anything in the mountain, he could’ve shot Micah because Arthur is a “friend” to him. I also forgot in one of the missions of chapter 6, when someone attacked Arthur with a knife, Dutch just left, Eagle Flies was the one who saved him. It’s normal to think that Micah was the one who “killed” Arthur, but if you think deeper, there could be a hidden antagonist in the shadows.
@@lieutenantghost9339 she wasn’t old, she was 36 when she died (she had Jack when she was 18). She probably had tuberculosis because she was coughing a lot before she died.
Lenny my boah, was cropped out at the beginning sorry 🥲
LENNAAHHHH
Ynnel
We shall miss him and everyone else who we lost
LNENY
Well there’s no Turing back he was a good kid so young
Still funny to think uncle was called lazy by the whole gang but still outlived all of them
Almost
Kinda unfair to say, he's lovable but there's no denying he was a freeloader that stayed away from the action
Beecher’s hope raid:
He didn’t outlive John or Abigail or Jack or Charles or Mary beth or Sadie or Pearson or Tilly or Reverend Swanson or Trelawney.
@@wheatbuckley7569 From what we know 🤐🤐🤐
Im just glad Charles lived, he was a good guy, and the missions with him were great
real
Fr this needs more comments
Facts, Charles was a real one.
He even dropped micah oh sorry the rat
Mhm just read Arthur’s entry he really had a good soul I untormented by evil temptation
All because of Micah.
"Shouldn't have went after Cornwall, Dutch"
@@rougmark2523 Sure. He should've listened to Hosea.
Nah they would've went down either way after Hosea died bc that's when dutch went out of control
💀what Lenny and Hosea died because of Dutch. Micah wasn’t even a rat then
@@joenuts3299 He sure was.
Little jack lost everyone😢
Arthur morgan spawn in 2023 enter in chat:
I mean like in the good ending John survives so like
@@SKULLGAMER-77spoilers if u haven’t played rdr1
John gets shot by Ross and his army, so no John does die
@@masteroogweyy oh I see thx
@@SKULLGAMER-77did you fr just spoil yourself?
"Our time is past, John" - last words of Dutch Van Der Linde.
I gave you all i had i did
The Red Dead Redemption games summed up in one line.
Passed*
That's his quote from Arthur, very sad when you take a moment to think that his whole speech was from the time he jumped with Arthur in the river
@@InAeternumRomaMaterthat speech is in the first rdr. it has literally nothing to do with arthur
RIP Bessie Matthews
RIP Copper
RIP Anabelle
RIP Jenny Kirk
RIP Davey Callander
RIP Mac Callander
RIP Sean Maguire
RIP Kieran Duffy
RIP Hosea Matthews
RIP Lenny Summers
RIP Molly O'Shea
RIP Cain
RIP Susan Grimshaw
RIP Arthur Morgan
RIP Leopold Strauss
RIP Karen Jones
RIP Cleet
RIH Joe
RIH Micah Bell III.
RIP Javier Escuella
RIP Bill Williamson
RIP Dutch van der Linde
RIP Uncle
RIP John Marston
RIP Abigail Marston
17 of these people died because of Micah.
@@djangofreeman4932 who all did? I only counted 4-5
@@jakesprospective8509 Jenny, Davey, Mac, Hosea, Lenny, Molly, Cain, Susan, Arthur, Cleet, Joe, himself, Javier, Bill, Dutch, Uncle and John.
@@djangofreeman4932 Damn. Micah caused their deaths!
@@dutchvanderlinde44 Shouldn't have gone after Cornwall Dutch
If we could have gotten a better ending for both John and Arthur 😢
We did though - that’s the point. They both got their redemption - Arthur through doing good in the latter stages of life and John through protecting his family and hunting down the traitors in the Van Der Linde gang
I agree an ending where Arthur died in the farm they built instead on the mountain
It's as Arthur himself said "You don't get to live a bad life and have good things happen to you"
Yep😢
John survives in one of the ending hunting down Micah and kills him ……
The picture where arther, dutch and Hosea were together and were young is just so wholesome
Everyone always forgets the horses RIP the horses man
Managed to keep the same horse the whole game, took great care of her too. I was so sad when she died man, then Arthur minutes later
My horse was a blue nokata and she stayed till the end
@@electro9753 hits way harder when you keep the same horse the whole game
@@bardockssj708 yeah even when I get another nokata as John it not my nokata
@@electro9753 exactly, it jus ain the same
" I promise you, we aren't gonna lose anymore people.'
- dutch 1899
rest in hell micah bell
True that
May he rest in PISS
It ain’t rest in hell it’s BURN IN HELL!!
Rot.
Fr
sadly, in rdr1 theres a newspaper that states a lady named sadie died in a cave and people think its sadie adler
She was in south America
Ya it is I saw the paper
"People think" so not cannon
There’s zero proof of this. This is false.
@@empty351canon
I wish I could just erase my memories of this game and play it again 😢
How fitting that the last gunslinger was also the youngest member of the gang
Edit:Dudes and dudettes this is the highest amount of likes i have ever got thank you
I mean the last person alive is almost certainly going to be the youngest tf…😂
@@BrainDead_ Sadie and Charles are still alive soooo
@@dkharmer05We don't know that. Just because they survived the epilogue of 2 doesn't mean they're still alive. They could have died off screen. I think Charles would probably still be alive but Sadie was way too reckless and a loose canon so she's probably dead.
@@vengeance1450 still no evidence leading to it or confirmation, so until then I’ll wait
@@vengeance1450 you don't know if she's dead bruh
Rdr2 is a masterpiece
The story is a masterpiece
@@n3xus190and Gameplay
@@JonathanSM_95gameplay is alright
Gameplay isn’t a masterpiece
It breaks me knowing that Jack is all alone in the end
Yep the worst nightmare to not have anyone but an empty house that John build with such effort and a hat and his gun that's all I don't think he even had Rufus in rdr 1
Rufus probably got killed or ran off after all that gunfire
For anyone wondering the songs Dark side of the moon
TYSM I SPENT HOURS TRYING TO FIND THIS SONG
Thank you
Helped me out with a vid, thanks
And to think that Jack was supposed to be the end of it, what John worked so hard for…just to begin a new life as yet another outlaw.
Jack retires and writes a book about his time in the gang you can find it in GTA 5
@@jordanmcintire it's just an easter egg, GTA and red dead don't take place in the same universe
@@elesestaodiolhoemnoisdasilv4and it was a hint to us that they are making rdr 2
Imagine someone confessing to Swanson that there in a gang and he says “ aw that’s cute, ever heard of Dutch van der linde?”
The fate of Jack is known, in GTA V at franklin’s new house you can see a book in one of his shelves called “Red Dead” by J. Marston and considering he loved reading books so much its evident that he became a writer in later years.
What is crazier is how developers connect things therou different games … thats why rockstar is on whole other level
Yes, and he even says he wants to write a book about John in rdr1
Jack died of heart disease between 1992 and 96
@@Altair582cl I think Jack living to 100 is a bit far fetched. Guy was born in 1895 he probably never moved into a city cause of the entire Gang’s hate of big cities (meaning he never got good healthcare) and lasted till about the 60s and died of an infection or something
@@incognito5952He died in 1992 at the age of 97
John going after Micah pretty much made everything Arthur fought for at the end obsolete. Arthur told him to run and never look back, that revenge was a “fool’s game.” John looked back, went after Micah, and ended up getting the Pinkertons on his trail again.
Red dead really is depressing and sad but still a goated franchise
Imagine if all the x’s were from deadeye
This edit make me scare the s*it of myself
I’m glad Tilly survived. She deserves it the most.
i guest you never heard of Arthur Morgan
@@Welshman656i guess you dont know he was a killer and Tilly wasnt
@@maxmanczgames shut up no one likes tilly if i could i would shot her
@@maxmanczgames Tilly killed someone before meeting dutch
@@nac990who held her captive, iirc.
I’m grateful Charles is still alive
Me starting at Arthur the whole time😢
We will too in rdr3
Or dutch
Cleet really didn’t deserve to die even tho he worked with Micah he could’ve told them and then Sadie and john and charles could’ve spared him.
Cleets death is overlooked
@@michaelpanagakos2324 kieran is the only one who aint deserved to death
@@denizgurel8949Lenny, literally probably one of the most honourable people in the gang. And so young too, unlike Sean who even though he was likeable, was an arsehole. Lenny didn’t deserve his death, but it plays into the tragedy of RDR
Yes after cleet said he stoped working with micah after he killed a little girl i didnt want to kill him but i knew that sadie dosnt ket him survive
ARTHUR MORGAN.
Chapter 1 : 🙂🥶☺️
Chapter 2: 😄😎🤠😒
Chapter 3: 😒😤🏠🔥
Chapter 4 : 😔💵🏦🪦💀
Chapter 5 : 🥵☀️🏝️🚣♂️
Chapter 6: 😷🤒🤧😔🐀🪦
Epilogue Part 1: 🪦
Epilogue Part 2: 🪦
The whole of RDR1: 🪦
Can u add chapter two this 🍾👬🥴
@@Kieran_DuffyThe whole of undead nightmare probably:🪦
Yall gonna be sad when rdr2 undead nightmares is out🤣
That scares me with that music
This was the most sad gang fall in the history of games
Lenny's death was quiet sad.
It wasn’t even a cutscene 😢
It was too quick
It's so sad how Jack watches everyone around him die
everybody has to leave the world, death is just an excuse.
Okay? And you do realise these characters are not real so stop turning this into some therapy session
@@ArthurMorgan_5074bro the characters are more main characters but you get attached to them when you play the game
@@ArthurMorgan_5074ye it's not real but this does connect with a life lesson
Makes me wonder if John would have went after Arthur in the first game if it meant getting his family back
i think about this often too. surprisingly you’re the first person i’ve come across that mentioned it.
but yeah John and Arthur are like brothers without the same blood. it would be interesting to see how they would have incorporated that if Arthur had made it out alive in the end of RDR2.
Probably, and Arthur likely would've left him capture him or figured out a plan to save him
The picture with John, Abigail, and Jack looks like an actual photo that would be in a documentary about life in the frontier
The third one hits hard becouse its the 3 that started it the bond the memories all gone because of micah it show what grief can do (hoseas death)
I see Dutch and hosea who is the third guy
@@jalenharrison7955the third guy is Arthur, but is his younger versión
@@sebastianvasquez3732 thankyou
True
The ending I wanted for this game was John coming back and shooting Micah and then taking Arthur to somewhere dry and he miraculously survives and then Arthur goes to live with Mary and John settles down with his family
Never become a fucking writer man
What about tuberculosis ?
@@royale_legend1497 back then if you had tb your only chance was to go somewhere dry and warm and maybe if John took Arthur somewhere like that he mightve survived but I think he was too sick in the end anyway
It’s just so sad how they just had to die all the good people they must rest in peace
This is the worst spoiler a new player can see
When you realize Arthur the reason why Charlie, Sadie(and more…) they are alive
This is one of the best games ever it just brings you into it emmotionally especially when dutch dies
out of all. 29 members of the gang only 8 survived
Straus not talking is actually a W move since even knowing he got kicked out the way he did, he died in silence, not ratting them out
What breaks me apart is that sadie adler died saying on news paper in rdr1
Fortunately, Jack Marston, Charles Smith, Pearson, Josiah Trelawny, Reverend Swanson, Sadie Adler, Mary-beth Gaskill and Tilly Jackson are in 1914 alive.
Jack Marston survived until 1996🗣️🔥💯🦅
it's not canon
@@elesestaodiolhoemnoisdasilv4 its canon
@@vrimexdit’s not fully canon but it is between 92 and 96 when he died
He died in 1977
@@jackstoker8138nope
Man there was so many great characters that died in this game
Glad that Sadie managed to survive, even though there theories that she died in Rdr1
Looks like a analog horror
Great story improvement from Gta5.
GTA 5: every bad guy dies, you can choose not to kills your friends.
Rdr: almost everyone dies. You don't like it? Too bad.
Trelawny always looking dapper asf
out of 23 van der land membre, only 8 survived 😢
Brings a tear to my eye 😢
I HAD A GODAMN PLAN!!!!!!!!!
Oh my God, i Miss josiah trelawny, reverand, captain Monroe (i like him) when i enter chapter 6. But, those 3 and the rest of the Van der Linde gang (or not all of them are Van der Linde gang) we're lucky
I hope CPT Moneroe got back on his feet after what happened in Ambarino. Maybe escape to Canada and managing to clean is name
LENNAHHH COME BACK TO LIFE lennah:hello
How a couple of years can change a gang
song?
All because Micha wanted to be his favorite
Micha would’ve eventually betrayed Dutch as well.
Sadie sadly died in the newspaper in rdr 1
No That's Not Sadie
Not her man, she wasn’t even an idea until the making of rdr2
@@Banjo1111 Perhaps they named her that specifically to show how she ended up dying?
@@htk_ket Sadie was not even an idea until the making of RDR2. Only Javier, Dutch, Bill, Abigail, Jack, Uncle, Rufus(the dog), and Edgar Ross are characters that are ideas that are in RDR2. The rest don’t exist in the brain of John in RDR1. This is why RDR1 should be remade, not because of the graphics but because John doesn’t mention the new characters even once. Arthur as a person doesn’t exist in Johns head in RDR1.
@@Banjo1111 I don't think you get what I'm saying. What if in RDR2 they specifically named Sadie Adler Sadie because they wanted to match it with the newspaper death in RDR1? Not the fact that Sadie Adler being apart of the gang happening.
This downfall must be studied 😞😞
We don’t know about Charles or Sadie if there ever going to make a red dead three or something
Sadie is dead but idk about Charles
@@therealJJ12 we don't know if the newspaper was talking about Sadie Adler or some random person named Sadie, and I don't think Sadie Adler was thought of in rdr1
@@mrepical7235 They could have decided to name Sadie because of the Sadie that died in the newspaper. It would've shown that we know Sadie's death even before.
I'm surprised that a rat can cause so many deaths
Take him as a snake
The Bubonic Plague:
Fun fact: the vanderlin gang was based off an actual gang from the 1800’s that they also robbed trains and stores but soon fell apart near the 1900’s. Tho most of the gang members died to lawmen or were captured and hung. But after most of them left the gang some members continued their crime spree and turning on each other but only one lived to see the 20th century but died to heart failure.
My heart dropped when i watched this.
The fall of the legendary wild west gang
I think they should make a dlc for Charles story after leaving the gang
this gonna be Red Dead Redemption III
Might sound stupid but hoseas death hurt the most
Abigail was the only one who wasn't killed by a living thing I think
Music?
dark side of the moon
im not sure if tou got him but Leopold Strauss died as well
Of i remember right Charles said Strauss was captured by the Pinkerton soon after being kicked out by Arthur. He was apparently tortured to death to force him to reviel informations on the gang but he said nothing
Uncle: lumbago, very serious
Jack lost everything and everyone.
"How to anger the whole rdr community in one comment"
RIP. Micah Bell 3rd
I gave you all I had…
Arthur Morgen-1899
Song?
dark side of the moon
@@Vnczeditstnx bro❤
I got confused till I realized it
Best game ever!
From the characters down to the smallest game details, Best. Game. EVER!!!
But there’s one left.
Jack…
From what i heard he died in like… 1990s. Or early 2000s.
@@randominternetguy228Yes but he's still outlived everyone by 100 years
Did Karen die I don’t think she did I mean we can’t find her again and she was an Alcoholic so maybe she had to much and died from it?
We don’t know, Tilly says she assumes that’s what happened but she hasn’t heard from Karen so does not know.
honestly, it’s Dutch’s fault that Arthur died, Micah killed Arthur but Dutch kept trusting Micah. Even though they only knew each other for a few months in the event’s of 1899. And also, don’t forget Dutch didn’t do anything in the mountain, he could’ve shot Micah because Arthur is a “friend” to him. I also forgot in one of the missions of chapter 6, when someone attacked Arthur with a knife, Dutch just left, Eagle Flies was the one who saved him. It’s normal to think that Micah was the one who “killed” Arthur, but if you think deeper, there could be a hidden antagonist in the shadows.
sadie is dead btw you can see in a newpaper of a girl matching her description perfectly in rdr1
Im still alive!
Me too!
I'm also alive
@@maccallander603 dude you died
@@jakeyadler1516 bruh jake I thought you got killed my the o’driscolls
@@Shelly-Ecplisis Everyone thought it.
Nostalgia from Arthur and John the main characters die 😢
Rumor Sadie dies during rdr1
Technically, non of em is alive, cept maybe for tilly's child
Even Tilly’s kid probably isn’t alive, they would be over 100
Abigail die because of what?
maybe she died due to gettin' a cancer cuz she was now old? Or idk the backstory of how Abigail died
Beacause age maybe, I mean that shit is 100 years ago
🤣🤣
@@lieutenantghost9339 she wasn’t old, she was 36 when she died (she had Jack when she was 18). She probably had tuberculosis because she was coughing a lot before she died.
@@marythecontrarian Boah i think Abigail was coughing due to losing John
Song-dark side of the moon (slowed to perfection)
Pearson and Swanson can count themselves as part of the last OGs.
Arthur and Hosea look a lot alike...
I hope trelawny made it out okay because we never hear from him after chapter 6, presumably heading home to his family in Saint Denis after chapter 6.
Fun fact in rdr1 you can see a magazine that has it saying said died
Hurts to remember the night I completed the game now I don’t really play rdr2 and even if I think about I sigh and think about what made me cry
We need a game were we play as trelawny
Actually, Sadie died in a red, dead redemption, one newspaper
Not true. Sadie didn't exist
"yeah mom hes the best uncle ever" for aurther - little jack
Technically Javier can actually survive
If you disarm him in rdr1
He was probably executed by the government
if you run,ur can live...
Your dont know what u talking about
Javier does not die you can choose to let him live or die but I’m pretty sure the agents kill him after