Hard to argue with a Chinese descent who had forgotten his roots. A generation influenced heavily by the barbie and rainbow culture of the US. Dangerous road ahead of new Singaporeans.. If u follow the East, ur nation will become stronger and richer, u follow the west, good luck
Most Singaporeans Chinese ancestors came to Singapore to run away from famine in china during mao rule or even before that, same for Taiwanese and hongkongers whose most them were smuggled into hongkong to run away from mainland regime, why would any of them support ccp when they all know most mainlanders stayed cuz they couldn't escape. Go to usa borders and speak to the chinese migirants who carrying little babies try to cross border into usa or canada why they left ccp heaven did they forget who they are 😂
I got automatic love by default for other Chinese people. I know a lot of people don't feel that way, but after living abroad my whole life I understand how important it is. Not everyone gets how important this unity is. Because nobody reallllly likes us. We challenge the current world order. Of course we're demonized
That why I think Chinese should stay in china dont migirant to other countries and behave like this cuz this basically what the jews been doing and that why everyone hated them, one thing Chinese have that jews didn't is large country and large numbers minus the religious ideology but the racial superiority complex does exist in Chinese just like the jews. I have nothing against Chinese but if you go to someone else land you need to respect the natives culture and language heritage religion, and integrate and assimilate with the native population, this only way cuz read about jews and why they were kicked out everywhere they went they were arrogant racist looked down on Europeans arabs even though arabs were related to them, they always seek to control the government to help their own while didnt give back to the community they supposed to serve, so before crying victimhood you wouldn't tolerate outsider coming into china and do what you guys do to others
@ super smash bro. “I got automatic…”. If you consider that those of non Han Chinese ethnicity, dislike you then it isn’t because “we” challenge the current world order, that’s just your inferiority complex disguised as hubris showing through. The general sentiment towards those identifying as Chinese hasn’t changed in centuries, when subjugated serfs. But don’t indulge in self pity too much, going by what you read in these and other TH-cam comments columns, surely the most disliked ethnicity/race are of North European or British extraction, the ones who established and maintain the world order
@@angusmckenzie9622 I'm not sure what you're on about and I definitely don't agree Europeans are the most disliked. And brotherman, we taking down that world order. It sucks for nonwhites. That's why you mad. You'll deny that with all your heart but it is what it is. I'm very hopeful.
@@dunzhen "I'm not sure what you're on about and I definitely don't..." Let me put it another way, so that you and supahsmashbro can understand better. Stop being chauvinistic and claiming victimhood. The country which has most benefitted from the US led world order has been China, but for which it would still be an agrarian, poverty stricken society. I'd say you both live in anglophone countries, ask yourselves why. The following might help. 如果你认为非汉族人不喜欢你，那并不是因为你挑战了现行的世界秩序，那只是你伪装成傲慢的自卑情结。当中国人还是被奴役的农奴时，对那些自认为是中国人的人的普遍看法几个世纪以来都没有改变。不要沉迷于自怜，从你在这些和其他 TH-cam 评论专栏中读到的内容来看，最不受欢迎的肯定是北欧或英国血统的人，他们建立和维护了世界秩序
We are the other “Jews”. Both (diaspora) Chinese and Jews have similarities towards their ancestral lands. Both people inwardly defined themselves by their civilization (i.e. recorded historical text) and ethnicity first, then nationalities. And because of that, both Chineses and Jews have been viewed as “others” by the natives.
I worked in China for 20 years and the concept of 'Chinese' always facinates me. At the end of the day, it's really just geography. The combination of 2 of the largest and most fertile rivers, with natural boundaries against outside enemies, combining to support a huge population that can continuously define its culture. The difference between Southerners and Northerners aside, I have worked for years with manchu, korean, and hui colleagues for years before I know them to be 'minorities'. Because they look, act, and sound exactly the same as a Chinese! The Chinese basically assimilate anyone that looks and acts vaguely like them into their culture. For this one 'ethnicity' there might as well be 30 ethnicities.
“ Chinese “ is a term that can mean cultural/civilizational/ethnicity, not just nationality. Another group are the Jews. Both groups have similar phenomenon, that diaspora Chinese/Jews strongly identify towards their ancestral motherland.
There is the pretence by some non-Chinese to not be able to understand the nuanced and profound notion and reality of civilization. and culture. The Chinese is a word akin to the word Jew, and perhaps even more because it more encompassing than a religion, or culture only. For lack of a better word, it is civilizational heritage in the encompassing content of language, norms, values, culture, history, and identity. So, you can take a Chinese out of China, but you cannot take the Chinese Civilization heritage out of a Chinese.
Germans invaded Austria and the Austrians did not resist because similar culture and political opinions. Russia invaded Ukraine out of anger and hatred. You cannot use killer methods to unite, because the result is mutual hatred and eternal seperation.
. @@user-hf8nb9mb4e . The next time, someone tells you that if you resist her attempt to rob your property, you should give her what she wants, as it would "only result in hatred and eternal breakdown in possible future friendship. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Draw line cuz china ccp whether you believe it or not have ambitions and they can and want to use those overseas Chinese as their gate way to spread their agenda into those countries, also if I come into your house and then removed all your family pictures and put mine and told you my brother is coming to visit and I will give him your room, and now you have to stay in corner cuz my brother is blood and you who took me into your house is stranger and blood is over everything, how would you feel 🤔
Without the Chinese who propel mainly the economy in ASEAN. This region will not be so prosperous. However, it still need the ethnic groups and other rooted races to work together in harmony for a peaceful environment. With business without peace, the country can’t thrive too. Being able to be accommodating and inclusive with other religion and races. Is paramount for a strong nation. Respect is essential. That’s why the Asians are thriving today, their values of respect, accommodating and always kind and sharing. Caucasian in history till today. Still the same. So long as they are more superior than you, they will conquer and colonized you. War mongering. Invasion, plundering, looting and killing. Is in their culture and nature. From Alexander, to Napoleon, to genocide of North and South America ethnic groups, slavery, Colonial era from Europe nations around the world. The the process massacre millions, rob their countries dry. The Chinese race has never invaded others in the last 500 years.
Stop with the lies, Chinese history is full of invasion of others and subjecting them to the ruling culture or extriminating all them or exile them out the kingdom, also how do you identify Chinese cuz from what I see lot Chinese are very comfortable online saying that person not chinese or dont look Chinese, so obviously they have image in their mind to what Chinese person is, and obviously again they dont veiw the minorities in china who not of the same definition of what Chinese is to be legitimate Chinese. If by Chinese you mean the han Chinese the why do you keep hold of the non han Chinese land that was by no mean your land originally, tibet, Mongolia, Manchuria, Uigyur land, if you decentants of the yellow river or yellow emperor then why you even trying to oppress others who don't want to be part your sht
Some HK people don't think they are Chinese and some even get annoyed at the prospect of you calling them Chinese. But they still celebrate CNY every year😂
No matter how good you explain, some questioners mindset is stuck. They follow with more questions, and say why this and why that,... And in reality this people isn't rationalizing the answer.
See the true facist nature of Chinese come when someone try to question their chinazi ideology. That guy ancestors went to Singapore to run away from hell of mainland China, why would he want to support same regime that caused his family exile 😒
There are only two different writing systems of the Chinese language. The simplified system is invented by the government in Peking. The old way of writing is used in Japan, Hongkong and Taiwan. Are Chinese the same? The Chinese race is the same. But in thinking Chinese from the mainland who still adore Mao dse Dong are totally different. There is no general agreement among all Chinese. In many areas on politics such as Ukraine, there is disagreement with mainland China.
I’m Chinese. I’m Malaysian. I’m at one with both. Yes, it’s possible!
How do you feel if china tried to invade Malaysia?
@tjtan "I’m Chinese. I’m Malaysian. I’m at o..." You are not Chinese. If you think you are, go back and stop infecting honest Malaysians.
Hard to argue with a Chinese descent who had forgotten his roots. A generation influenced heavily by the barbie and rainbow culture of the US. Dangerous road ahead of new Singaporeans.. If u follow the East, ur nation will become stronger and richer, u follow the west, good luck
Most Singaporeans Chinese ancestors came to Singapore to run away from famine in china during mao rule or even before that, same for Taiwanese and hongkongers whose most them were smuggled into hongkong to run away from mainland regime, why would any of them support ccp when they all know most mainlanders stayed cuz they couldn't escape.
Go to usa borders and speak to the chinese migirants who carrying little babies try to cross border into usa or canada why they left ccp heaven did they forget who they are 😂
I got automatic love by default for other Chinese people. I know a lot of people don't feel that way, but after living abroad my whole life I understand how important it is. Not everyone gets how important this unity is. Because nobody reallllly likes us. We challenge the current world order. Of course we're demonized
That why I think Chinese should stay in china dont migirant to other countries and behave like this cuz this basically what the jews been doing and that why everyone hated them, one thing Chinese have that jews didn't is large country and large numbers minus the religious ideology but the racial superiority complex does exist in Chinese just like the jews.
I have nothing against Chinese but if you go to someone else land you need to respect the natives culture and language heritage religion, and integrate and assimilate with the native population, this only way cuz read about jews and why they were kicked out everywhere they went they were arrogant racist looked down on Europeans arabs even though arabs were related to them, they always seek to control the government to help their own while didnt give back to the community they supposed to serve, so before crying victimhood you wouldn't tolerate outsider coming into china and do what you guys do to others
@ super smash bro. “I got automatic…”. If you consider that those of non Han Chinese ethnicity, dislike you then it isn’t because “we” challenge the current world order, that’s just your inferiority complex disguised as hubris showing through. The general sentiment towards those identifying as Chinese hasn’t changed in centuries, when subjugated serfs. But don’t indulge in self pity too much, going by what you read in these and other TH-cam comments columns, surely the most disliked ethnicity/race are of North European or British extraction, the ones who established and maintain the world order
@@angusmckenzie9622 I'm not sure what you're on about and I definitely don't agree Europeans are the most disliked. And brotherman, we taking down that world order. It sucks for nonwhites. That's why you mad. You'll deny that with all your heart but it is what it is. I'm very hopeful.
@@dunzhen "I'm not sure what you're on about and I definitely don't..." Let me put it another way, so that you and supahsmashbro can understand better. Stop being chauvinistic and claiming victimhood. The country which has most benefitted from the US led world order has been China, but for which it would still be an agrarian, poverty stricken society. I'd say you both live in anglophone countries, ask yourselves why. The following might help. 如果你认为非汉族人不喜欢你，那并不是因为你挑战了现行的世界秩序，那只是你伪装成傲慢的自卑情结。当中国人还是被奴役的农奴时，对那些自认为是中国人的人的普遍看法几个世纪以来都没有改变。不要沉迷于自怜，从你在这些和其他 TH-cam 评论专栏中读到的内容来看，最不受欢迎的肯定是北欧或英国血统的人，他们建立和维护了世界秩序
We are the other “Jews”. Both (diaspora) Chinese and Jews have similarities towards their ancestral lands. Both people inwardly defined themselves by their civilization (i.e. recorded historical text) and ethnicity first, then nationalities. And because of that, both Chineses and Jews have been viewed as “others” by the natives.
I worked in China for 20 years and the concept of 'Chinese' always facinates me.
At the end of the day, it's really just geography. The combination of 2 of the largest and most fertile rivers, with natural boundaries against outside enemies, combining to support a huge population that can continuously define its culture.
The difference between Southerners and Northerners aside, I have worked for years with manchu, korean, and hui colleagues for years before I know them to be 'minorities'. Because they look, act, and sound exactly the same as a Chinese!
The Chinese basically assimilate anyone that looks and acts vaguely like them into their culture. For this one 'ethnicity' there might as well be 30 ethnicities.
May Chinese worldwide band together to support China for a better future; stop US from destroying China, stop US from spreading hate
@@ixanaths support Chinese occupation of the south china sea? Never!
@@ixanaths stop the yellow invasions into America and Canada.
Well said - I'm a Chinese but not PRC citizen!
Hua ren are the Han looking people. In Chinese language hua ren means the Han.
“ Chinese “ is a term that can mean cultural/civilizational/ethnicity, not just nationality. Another group are the Jews. Both groups have similar phenomenon, that diaspora Chinese/Jews strongly identify towards their ancestral motherland.
There is the pretence by some non-Chinese to not be able to understand the nuanced and profound notion and reality of civilization. and culture. The Chinese is a word akin to the word Jew, and perhaps even more because it more encompassing than a religion, or culture only. For lack of a better word, it is civilizational heritage in the encompassing content of language, norms, values, culture, history, and identity.
So, you can take a Chinese out of China, but you cannot take the Chinese Civilization heritage out of a Chinese.
So why then prepare to kill your cultural brothers in Taiwan? Some are your blood relatives !
Forced unity will only result in hatred and eternal seperation.
Germans invaded Austria and the Austrians did not resist because similar culture and political opinions. Russia invaded Ukraine out of anger and hatred. You cannot use killer methods to unite, because the result is mutual hatred and eternal seperation.
. @@user-hf8nb9mb4e . The next time, someone tells you that if you resist her attempt to rob your property, you should give her what she wants, as it would "only result in hatred and eternal breakdown in possible future friendship. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@HTeo-og1lg On internet there are some evil characters.
四海之内皆兄弟也。
Why is there a need to draw a line?
你中有我，我中有你。
Perhaps it's a western mentality to always draw a line.
Yeah, divide you first, and they come and kill all of you later.
Draw line cuz china ccp whether you believe it or not have ambitions and they can and want to use those overseas Chinese as their gate way to spread their agenda into those countries, also if I come into your house and then removed all your family pictures and put mine and told you my brother is coming to visit and I will give him your room, and now you have to stay in corner cuz my brother is blood and you who took me into your house is stranger and blood is over everything, how would you feel 🤔
Without the Chinese who propel mainly the economy in ASEAN. This region will not be so prosperous. However, it still need the ethnic groups and other rooted races to work together in harmony for a peaceful environment. With business without peace, the country can’t thrive too. Being able to be accommodating and inclusive with other religion and races. Is paramount for a strong nation. Respect is essential. That’s why the Asians are thriving today, their values of respect, accommodating and always kind and sharing. Caucasian in history till today. Still the same. So long as they are more superior than you, they will conquer and colonized you. War mongering. Invasion, plundering, looting and killing. Is in their culture and nature. From Alexander, to Napoleon, to genocide of North and South America ethnic groups, slavery, Colonial era from Europe nations around the world. The the process massacre millions, rob their countries dry. The Chinese race has never invaded others in the last 500 years.
Stop with the lies, Chinese history is full of invasion of others and subjecting them to the ruling culture or extriminating all them or exile them out the kingdom, also how do you identify Chinese cuz from what I see lot Chinese are very comfortable online saying that person not chinese or dont look Chinese, so obviously they have image in their mind to what Chinese person is, and obviously again they dont veiw the minorities in china who not of the same definition of what Chinese is to be legitimate Chinese.
If by Chinese you mean the han Chinese the why do you keep hold of the non han Chinese land that was by no mean your land originally, tibet, Mongolia, Manchuria, Uigyur land, if you decentants of the yellow river or yellow emperor then why you even trying to oppress others who don't want to be part your sht
Some HK people don't think they are Chinese and some even get annoyed at the prospect of you calling them Chinese. But they still celebrate CNY every year😂
Such a trivial and irrelevant question.
The guy that asked the question is clueless!
Ask Wang Gungwu for clarity.
Lots of people cannot differentiate between ethnicity and citizenship. They get into a twist.😭😭😭so create problems.
Lot Chinese support ccp even thought lot them dont want to live in china cuz ccp
Without PRC or mainland Chinese, who else in this world really cares about Chinese?
No matter how good you explain, some questioners mindset is stuck. They follow with more questions, and say why this and why that,...
And in reality this people isn't rationalizing the answer.
Very good observation.
If that bro doesn't think he is 中华儿女，then stop using mandarin. He is not worthy
See the true facist nature of Chinese come when someone try to question their chinazi ideology.
That guy ancestors went to Singapore to run away from hell of mainland China, why would he want to support same regime that caused his family exile 😒
Not every person of Chinese descent share your boss, Robert kuok's mentality on this issue.
Who is that joker who asked those queations omg
There are only two different writing systems of the Chinese language. The simplified system is invented by the government in Peking. The old way of writing is used in Japan, Hongkong and Taiwan.
Are Chinese the same? The Chinese race is the same. But in thinking Chinese from the mainland who still adore Mao dse Dong are totally different. There is no general agreement among all Chinese. In many areas on politics such as Ukraine, there is disagreement with mainland China.
Ure stuck in old ways. Luckily, ure not a leader. Yr followers will only meet a dead path.
You do not know what you are talking about.
Either you are not educated in Chinese education or you are loa motivated.
Traditional Chinese still used in japan called Kanji
the old way is 官话，ultimately still Chinese roots lmao what are you even arguing
@@iw4075 your English cannot be understood.