Hogwarts Legacy Nintendo Switch vs PS5 Graphics Comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ต.ค. 2024
- Hogwarts Legacy Nintendo Switch vs PS5 Graphics Comparison
Buy Hogwarts Legacy here: amzn.to/3SAeiJz
Thanks for using my Amazon Affiliate links!
PS5 version was captured in Fidelity RT OFF Mode.
Kanał GRANALIZA po polsku:
/ @granaliza
Cycu1 Bilibili official Channel: space.bilibili...
Consider supporting my channel for cool bonuses:
/ @cycu1
Looking good quality gameplay for your own videos?
Consider subscribing my other channels to be up to date!
Cycu1 Xbox Archive / @cycu1xboxarchive130
Cycu1 PlayStation Archive / @cycu1playstationarchi...
Cycu1 Nintendo Archive / @cycu1nintendoarchive454
Looking for gift cards?
PSN: amzn.to/3eFkAjM
Xbox: amzn.to/3gzvsl8
Nintendo eShop: amzn.to/2TRMbqf
Looking for RTX Graphics Cards? Check on Amazon: amzn.to/3dzcGYZ
Follow me on Twitter: / cyckiewicz
Find me on Facebook: / cycu1yt
Cycu1's friends:
Jabcook:
/ jabcook
Easy Unboxing:
/ @easyunboxing
Quick Expert Reviews
/ @quickexpertreviews
FA Gamez:
/ mrxboxgamer007
#HogwartsLegacy #PS5 #NintendoSwitch #Switch
![Unboxing Nintendo Switch OLED [in White] + Accessories](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/f7UeE2S_K-8/mqdefault.jpg)
Buy Hogwarts Legacy here: amzn.to/3SAeiJz
Thanks for using my Amazon Affiliate links!
I think they did a good job porting it but some of these scenes are absolutely a testament about how badly Nintendo's hardware needs to be updated at this point
This.
Hopefully if the Switch 2 is as fast as the rumors suggest, fingers crossed that it gets a graphics upgrade in the future
One more year to go.
@@oppa1319 yeah not gonna happen maybr maybe 2025 the earliest.. but I predict around 2026
@@Pinkieloverthey'll announce Switch 2 as soon as the Switch surpasses PS2 in sales
@horrorg.c.l4244scalpers will buy em all up and charge double the price 😂
The fact that they were able to port Hogwart's Legacy onto a Switch is amazing!
The graphics are CLEARLY not the same, but I cannot complain. It really looks great!
They didn't though did they. They downgraded the hell out of it to the point it's not really the same game
They should have made this port a version of its own for the switch.
I mean they should have remade this game back from square one to repolish the assets they use so they can well optimize and integrate the system on weaker hardware.
@@brianlaudrupchannelit literally is the same game just downgraded graphics. I remember when I was younger they would make different versions of the same game for GBA, DS, and Consoles. My family could never afford the consoles so I would always be disappointed how my DS version was not as cool as the PS3 version. I can imagine it's cool for younger generations now to be able to play the same game you can on PS5 just with scaled back visuals instead of them making a side scroller hogwarts legacy.
@@kraftp no they even turned it from an open world game to a non open world game
yeah the grafiks are miles away, but so is the power of the 2 consoles :D
Ports like these are always so fascinating to me, to see all the cut-backs necessary to get a game like this to run on under-powered hardware.
Always impressive when a developer manages to pull it off.
I’m so glad I’m not the only one! It really is fascinating to see what they had to do to make it run smoothly. Sonic Frontiers is another great one to compare
@@stumpy5760and wolfstein 2 port for nintendo switch always blows up my mind
1:11 switch version looks pretty good. 😂😂😂😂
You can pull it off with any game if enough graphical drawbacks are implemented. Switch looks like a ps2 game
El Port es bueno si... pero este juego lamentablemente su unico punto que destaca son los graficos...
notas que le daria despues de pasarme el juego y casi todas las secundarias
9,7 de 10 Recreación del entorno
5,4 de 10 banda sonora
1,8 de 10 Historia principal, peor no se puede hacer....
4 de 10 secundaria y cosas que puedes hacer.
> En este juego tienes a tu disposición el crafteo y ser boticario pero no puedes vender tu pociones.
>>Habria sido más acertado ganar dinero vendiendo lo que creas a estar desvalijando los cofres de las casas ajenas...
:::
Si llego a jugarlo otra vez seria estrenando tarjeta grafica para revisionar el casillo en graficos maximos porque menuda mierda de historia se cascaron...
They really put a lot of passion to getting this software up and running. This is more than I expected. They made a lot of sacrifices but they got it to work as promised
4:05 Can you say that after THIS ?!
@@danielcastaneda4975Yes, it's fine.
If it were a PS3/360/Wii U game, (which is closer to what the Switch is) no one would be complaining.
Remember, it's essentially a handheld port.
Far cry 3 in ps3 and xbox 360 looks millions times better than this . Let's not even talk about GTA V is on ps3 and a xboxx 360 and it looks amazing and you know how it looks and how it's like@@davetheimpaler204
You are such a dolt, as long as people like you continue to accept mediocrity, that's what the rest of us will get. It's 2023. Stop allowing Nintendo to give us graphics that were relevant 10-12 years ago.
This is a travesty!
Wow it’s crazy seeing them next to each other. It looks like they really took their time and manually gutted the game rather than just scaling it down into oblivion.
Eh, looks like they tried doing it manually but halfway through they couldn’t be asked and just scaled it down.
@@RoseInnncouldn't be *arsed
@@RoseInnnthere was a lot more they could have done so yeah you're definitely right. There are definitely some better looking games but this isn't bad looking.
@@zombwars7749 yeah for a port where you can play anywhere it certainly isn’t bad at all.
i mean... they did scaled it down by a lot lmao.
The fact that they could even make this game run on the switch is
fantastic.
Yeah it’s pretty impressive but you can really see the difference in graphics with the water seems to me the devs got lazy there I mean there are some switch games with some great looking water
The devs who ported this game to the Switch are wizards! No muggle would ever achieve that!
I say Muggle bad Quality i like Playstation 5 looks more convensing
They did a demake for PS2 and that is the version of switch
RDR1 is amazing too, and it uses same G engine that RDR2, gta 5 etc, obiously not the gta 5 version up to date graphic, a previous one, I remember when people laughed when N said rdr2 cold have been into switch but never happened cuz lack of time or some crap, of course could have been ported, worst case ps3 version but it can handle a close to ps4 version. When looking the comparison of this game, ps5 lake water seems real and switch is 3 or 4 leagues down, trees too, but castle looking, cliffs, and lot of shit I don't feel ps5 is better just different looking since it is not real space they are what they call mipmaps, little textures and you can make it look as you want ( up to a point obviously ).
Ps5 is better just cuz joy cons never got fixed, incredible, but there are usb controllers that make switch the device it should have been, stable and ver similar to steam deck. Fucking hybrid shit ^^... no matter, tinfoil and n3ds full of exclusives for 3 lives.
@@DavidRamirez-qw3jpno one can fathom that disgusting grammar and spelling of yours
I actually really like the Switch port. It reminds me of the games I used to play as a little kid. Back when videogames truly felt like videogames, and nobody worried about how realistic they could possibly get before wrecking the hardware.
This story that "nobody cared about realism" is pure imagination of yours, I remember very well at the time of the PS2 how much people were always talking about how realistic the graphics of game X were, or how detailed the graphics of game Y were and etc... people have always paid attention to graphics in all generations of consoles.
@@matheusreiss2 I grew up with Nintendo consoles and it was a completely different community. Nobody was looking for said things with the Wii, Nintendo DS, or 3DS. I use the term “nobody” very lightly though. I don’t mean that LITERALLY NOBODY AT ALL WHASTOEVER was looking for said aspects in their games.
With this mindset developers won't care anymore
@@VSN-wb2lynot true at all. art can be beautiful and high quality without always aiming for realism. if photorealism is every developer's goal then all games will end up looking the same.
@@seanmoss7887 low resolution is different than art style, you can see how good Zelda looks in PC than in switch.
I don't care if the art style is weird or different but I do care about resolution, low res is different
Looks like they did a decent enough job. I’m sure many kids will be happy with this for Christmas.
it looks like cyberpunk on ps4
just as long as they dont see what the game looks like on pc
but since its switch players who probably dont know how to read yet, it should be fine
@@jkeebla I'm a Switch player, and I... Know how to read.
Atleast they arent stupid idiots who think their little game is better because it has better graphics@@jkeebla
in 1:02 there is a mistake, its a gameplay from switch not PS5 😅
Yeah and at 14:45 no way the switch version looks that sharp 🤣🤣
Just remember male=ps5 female=ns that's it!
Its always so interesting to see what needs to happen to make games run on lower hardware. From a graphics perspective, hogwarts will pass if its the first version youve played and know what to expect from a switch. But from making the game run, its really cool to see the difference, but all the while still being the same game.
True. In the past ports sometimes changed the whole game structure/scenario. This is a 1:1 recreation in a much weak hardware. We have come a long way.
What is a good job about this? Absolute puritan display, no optimization and no visual design. A game released a long time ago on inferior hardware, it was designed to look good on it as well. Harry Potter, released on ps3/xbox360, looks better than this. Better geometry, higher resolution, more detailed textures.
@robertkurta559 a good job is somehow seeing this massive game on a tiny little console with specs that were decent in 2015. Like... I don't think you realize how nutty it is to have a game that needs 12gb of ram minimum run on a console that has 4 and only 3 of them dedicated to gaming. That's super cool and I hope some developers speak about how they did it.
@@CognizantZen saying there's no optimization is crazy.
@lucascamelo3079 yeah, going back to the wii and ps2 versions of 0s3 and 360 games. We have come so far from porting down and making entirely new versions
I downloaded it on my Switch Lite and I'm enjoying it so far. It really doesn't look too bad in handheld. It's passable. Actually remarkable that they were able to do this.
It looks horrible, and switch is about the only handheld that runs triple a games this way, get a steam deck instead, same price as the switch with way better performance
@@ETGamer-yl6dmthey said switch lite. They're not gonna see those tiny details on that small screen
@@ETGamer-yl6dm Haha yeah - and much less remarkable triple AAA games too.. can you play Zelda on it? Nope. Mario? Nah. Metroid Prime? I don't think so.
@@Maubariwatch some vids about it so you won't be as clueless as right now. yes you can play zelda on the sd ,even modded ,yes you can see some videos of the last mario on the sd too. you can play switch games on it. do your research instead of posting stupidities
@@ETGamer-yl6dmstop being a jerk by telling what other people need to do. and what if she doesn't want to buy a sd because she prefers a nintendo switch, which has way better battery life than the sd ?(i own a sd) stop being toxic and let people enjoy the games they want on the plateform they want.
This is like the good old days, when we had the same game on PS3 and PS2!
but you can play it on bathroom
@@gogoboba7037and anywhere we go 🤌🏻
@@gogoboba7037Yeah with sh*tty graphics while sh*tting😂
I think they switched it look at the buttons and the character
I’m playing this game on my series x for the first time right now and it’s blowing me away. All the attention to detail that was put into it shows how much the developers love and respect the source material. As long as the gameplay remains fun Switch users are in for a treat. Graphics are second to gameplay in my opinion.
I am totally having fun playing it right now on Switch ✨
And fortunately with the PS5 and Series S/X you get the best of both worlds.
@@sonicgen20and pc version
Honestly I expected it to be way blurrier than this. It does remind me of Prisoner of Azkaban on the PS2/Gamecube at times though 😅
Damn, that game was quite messy on GameCube for some reason, even though this console had more power than PS2. Guess it's all thanks to mini-DVD
What? The graphics are much better than the ps3 game Order of the Phoenix and Half Blood prince, just google prisioner of Azkaban game and see how dated that game is
The biggest difference is in the details in the open world setting where there is a lot of vegetation and trees, other than that, I didn't think it was that bad, although the difference is clear, but we have to take into account the hardware of both, it is an incredible feat to run in this quality on the Switch
"incredible feat" I've seen Playstation 2 games that look better than this games does on the Switch, you must be joking.
@@Nitro192192 My comment is based on the comparison between a ps5 and a switch, but if you say that the ps2 does this too, I believe you ☝🏻🐱
No mention of the lake? Seriously , that is the most jarring difference
@@yobro6053 Forgot to mention that too, thanks (although it's not something that bothers me as much as grass and trees)
@@yobro6053omg the lake hurt my eyes 😂
Switch doesn't looks bad, PS5 looks incredible.
I mean look at that water/lighting!
I've always been curious about how water (or lava) is often the best looking part of a videogame.
Oooof for the lake water, but overall an impresive port. This guys actually managed to cram a next gen game into a 6 years old tablet. Props to them.
I guess that it's still a better option to play the next gen version, but if you only have a Switch and want to try the game, the port is a good buy.
It's not impressive, any game can be ported to switch, the problem will always be that they have to lower the graphics a lot depending on the game and the graphic style it has It will make it look bad or medium good even in very low graphics and by the way the optimization, which they do but of course they have limits due to the hardware
@@zadkielgd5137which is impressive
The game looks worse than Skyrim on switch
90% the main important assets still seem to be there, it’s just some little things were removed or changed. Interiors almost look the exact same between versions though.
@@OrRainoBecause... that's a PS3 game. This is a PS5 game. Some assets are so baked into the game that to turn it into a Switch game you will have to completely redo it. To save time and money you are better off, tuning things down to super low and optimising what you can.
It's clear that Sony is doing a wonderful job and Nintendo needs to update their hardware but I'm impressed that they could port the game to Switch users.
Nintendo is always going to release gaming systems that lag far behind the others. Their business model is to make massive profit on the hardware. It's why the Switch is still the same price as what they've sold it since launch and why the games never get discounted. Their cult fan base settles for technological mediocrity because the games they play will never demand modern processing power.
@@seinfan9 lol get angry about it why don't you? Switch ended up outselling the PS4 despite being released 3.5 years later 😅
@@seinfan9 Please... Switch has completely mopped the floor with Xbox and Playstation for two generations now.
@@seinfan9ok. & their is nothing wrong with that. If you want higher fidelity games play on a PC or ps5 or Xbox. The switch does exactly what it’s supposed to do.
I kind of like the way the switch version looks. It takes me back to the early 2000's when I wished for a Harry Potter game like this.
Yea its got a cozy ps2 game feel too it. But like a really good looking ps2 game and in the best way possible. Definitely reminds me a bit of the old HP games
the cope is crazy
Ngl I'm playing it on switch and keep having this thought! It's making me nostalgic for ps2-ps3 era games lol. Imo it looks great for what it is
@@RonhozZIt is no cope, I own a RTX 4090 and I hold the same opinion
@@byletheisner5006have you tried playing it on switch because I find it unplayable bcos of the frame rate, I had to buy an Xbox to play it 😂
this is why i cant stand nintendo thinking this game deserves the same price as a next gen console is highway robbery
Honestly, it's very good, for a game the size of Hogwarts legacy, I confess that I'm very surprised
Honestly I think it looks horrible but tbf it's all the switch can pull off probably.
So imo a Switch version should have never existed as it lacks all the atmosphere and is completely lifeless (rarely any NPCs)
But yeah, for those who wanna play it on the go it's nice that it's there.
Its not very good. The "size" doesnt matter, when its all loadings
delusional
@@snakeeater4042only thing good in this game is the combat system
@@JacoBee93 size somewhat matter, i'm 200% certain Switch can run GTA V, but it's 120gb, literally a game targeted towards GT series Nvidia, 4+ GB of ram and literally a Core Duo, even phones has better specs than that.
Decent job preserving the game’s presentation.
Seeing how old the switch system is and belongs to the previous generation, graphics wise it looks great.
Yea other than water it’s not that bad of a downgrade for a 6 year old hardware
I mean ps4 looks better
@@raulbalarezos No shit, also PS4 isn't a mobile device
@@raulbalarezos They're both still 8th gen consoles, and only one of them is portable.
I know there are no 9th gen portable's, but given how current PC based portable systems are, I imagine a Switch 2 would run this better than a PS4.
@@raulbalarezos Switch although the same gen as ps4/x1, has only better specs than an xbox 360/ps3 but is significantly/much much slower than a ps4
1:05 Uhm I think you did an oopsie xD
The colors look so dull, it's almost depressing. Static lightning would've improved the visual quality so much, but instead they went the easy route and just turned off everything that eats performance. Just compare it to Witcher 3, it's like day and night.
The Witcher 3 is a different generation game.
Isn't Witcher 3 a PS4 game? Hogwarts legacy looks a lot better than Witcher 3.
@@Vyyc-m9g Sure, on PS5. But on the Switch, Witcher 3 looks way better imo.
It's not even the graphical fidelity, but the brightness and colors alone. Hogwarts Legacy on Switch just looks... dull. As if they forgot to increase the base brightness to compensate for the missing dynamic lighting.
i wish we can have that blue cold filter that the switch has, makes it more cinematic just how they are in the movies. ❤❤❤
Switch/PS5 mark is messed few times, but thank for the comparison! In some cases Switch version look bad, but in some scenes it hold surprisingly well!
Yeah for me just improve the water little bit aaaanndddd itss perfect
crazy some parts look better on the switch, i think its due to how they change the style to cover the limitations like they did in the old days, the dark lighting makes it feel like a dark fantasy game which actually fits the HP franchise well
Better? you must be joking 🤣🤣
The cope is real
14:40 for a moment I was like "damn the switch version looks pretty good in this one!"
Haha.
What am I missing cuz it looks amazing
@@jaxcasonmaximusthey must have got them the wrong way round because no way the switch version looks that clear and hd
It's the wrong way around 😂
00:15:26 lol bro's clipping through ground
I’ve got a ps4 and a switch and I’ve been indecisive which version to get. Watching this I think I’ll get the switch version. I’ve always just loved handheld, and it looks like the game really is all there with sacrifices I’m well used to by now
get a steam deck
I actually decided to get the ps4 haha but yeah esp that new oled seems perfect@@frozenduck74
I wish but too expensive @@frozenduck74
@@frozenduck74 yeah sure all of us stuck with switch will definitely move up to steam deck, defintely has nothing to do with budget
@@ejilock not my fault u got a switch Instead of saving up 100$ more
1:02 editing error. When transitioning to the ps5, it's actually showing the switch version and when it goes back to the switch version it shows the PS5 version
also 14:53 it shows the wrong one hahaha
Reminds me a bit of the HL2 Xbox port. The hardware is way below the specs to run the game, and it doesn't look pretty at all. But somehow it runs competently and retains the foundation of the visual presentation, against all odds. This might be one of the most impressive ports so far.
HL2 on the OG Xbox does not look that bad tho
Frame rate is still too low on switch (below 30)
In line with the power difference. It's in fact a very acceptable port.
Y’all are crazy for thinking this is acceptable. You’re basically saying it’s OK to pay the same price and get half the experience.
Delusional nintendrones
Well, that’s how we used to play games in early 2000s
@@solidsnivy5639half life 2 has better water than that, and the elder scrolls oblivion has better forests and water. So yeah mid 2000s, I’m with ya.
imagine paying full price for a game on less than low settings
-almost empty hallways
-loading when going inside the castle
-very long loading when going to hogsmeade
-2d water texture
-no grass
-blurred texture.
-2d trees
-no screenspace reflection
-no fog
Switch version: depression mode on. :-D
How many watthours of energy did you use during the test? PS5 / Switch / Switch handheld?
About 1.21 gigawatts judging from the video
As impressive as it is, this looks like a PC game from 2010 at times, especially in the first shot with the Farming Simulator 9 water. But it's good that those who want to play it but only have a Switch are also able to play it now.
Love that switch bring back ps2 textures to games.
The difference is astronomical. Bigger than the pre release material suggested. Which was all carefully selected and none of it was open world stuff.
09:10 Castle layout in Switch has been changed to include a tunnel-enclosed space and towers in the background removed. Weird choice
It’s rendering less polygons to help boost performance. Given the hardware they’re working with, it’s an interesting way to tackle the problem
Looking closely you can only see minor changes to architecture, apart from that big change you mentioned lol
Weird choice? They did their best optimising the game for a trash console.
The tunnel-enclosed space was originally used in the PS4/Xbox version actually. not sure about the missing towers tho
The switch version reminds me of the OG Harry Potter games on PS2. I’m mighty impressed they were able to do something like this, but I think that the Switch version should only be played if a switch is your only option. 😬
Yeah I agree really shows with the water effects very poor lighting on the switch version
Switch is my only option, and I got the game on sale for less than $20. I wouldn't have paid full price for it.
My favorite console is the PlayStation 5 mostly because of the exclusive games but I believe if the Nintendo switch had the same hardware as the PS five Sony will definitely have their work cut out for them. can you imagine a Zelda game with the graphics of Final Fantasy seven that would definitely be 90% of the gamers dream.
Is that the switch oled or v1 or v2? Which is it and if it is V1 then does the oled have any improvements at all? Cause I was planning to get an oled just to play HL on the go. Please reply, thanks.
Hi, I know is late but in any case I will answer for other people, the hardware is just the same as the previous nintendo switch so the oled version just have a better screen not better graphics, you will no notice improvements. pd: I got the nintendo switch oled.
とてもわかりやすく参考になりました！
ありがとうございます！
おそらく
14:40の映像がSwitchとPS5が逆になっています！
I remember when the comparison videos between Nintendo and the others made me like, "There ain't no way I'm playing that on Nintendo." But where we are now with graphical power, its really not that bad.
Wow - switch version looks very respectable for the hardware it’s on! Goodjob devs!!!
Wow, just wow. They better not be selling this full price.
Why not? They did a lot of work to make it work on the Switch. They basically made the game from cratch again just for switch owners.
Yeah but it kinda falls short compared to what others get for their money. So selling it for 50$ would be fine instead of 70$ like the PS5 version costs.
Edit: and it wasn't made from scratch, it's mostly de-make to fit the power of the switch graphic wise.
@@CDumkeThis is mostly aimed for the people who only have a Switch as a mean of playing this game, so the price tag won't matter much. The same thing happened with the RDR1 port from Rockstar, they charged $50 and it sold wonders on the Switch.
Oh, they will be. Be prepared to be pist af 😂
when you take seeing glasses off vs when you have them on
That’s what I thought the switch version is like the screen is dirty then when you wipe it that is the ps5 version
EXACTLY. I swear switch has made my eyes worse from straining to make out what certain things are for some games.
The switch version looks like a PS2 game.
This is like a retro port, it's like taking red dead redemption 2 look like the first game and run on xbox 360
It's like a whole other game. The difference is immense.
Yeah, but it's pretty impressive for the switch to even run it tbh
14:46 I think that they are the wrong way around
Great video though, getting this on switch and a great side to side comparison
Yeah must be no way the switch version looks that sharp
ps2 graphics
The first lake reminded me of GTASA
It's looks more like assassin creed
Ps3
no way ps2 can handle Switch Graphics, Graphics on Switch look exactly like PS3
I’m not expecting much graphics wise, still could be better in some cases and it’s good that more people can play it. But you can’t be asking 60€ for this…
I would say it is one of the best pors I have seen on Nintendo switch
You made a mistake at 14:42.
Your video is really cool, I found it very entertaining and informative but at 14:42 you swapped the PS5 version with the Switch version.
Or I finally have to get glasses.
Am I stupid now or does anyone else see this?
And that's why we need a Switch 2.
When the Switch 2 arrives and you'll will see that it is not as powerful as a PS5 everyone will start saying "And that's why we need the Switch 3" and so on.
Yeah in this switch version it looks like there’s a constant cloudiness over the castle and the water looks very bad
The Switch really is “the system that could.”
5:55 if you want more pumpkins then get the switch version
lol
It’s like they went hmmmm idk just put more pumpkins that will do
i think theres no other open world game in switch that look as good as this for an old portable hardware its well made, and i know we older gamers feel kinda nostalgic with the style i would love to try it out
The witcher 3 is really good on switch
yes! i meant new games for switch@@Jk-sw9lj
The Switch version just looks like a really ambitious PS2 game
Loving how people who have probably never played a PS2 calls this PS2 graphics. The Switch graphics would’ve been wild to see back in the PS2 days.
For me it's more like a PS3 game
No, more like PS3. There is still a decent amount of detail and the movements are fluid overall. A lot of characters in PS2 games had stiff and rigid movements.
@@Photo0021I grew up with a PS2, and in my experience most of the time someone says this they’re right on the money.
But I agree with you here. I’d say this is closer to an early PS3 game visually.
There’s no way even the more powerful Xbox would be able to pull something off on this scale, even with massive shader and HDD cache abuse
Wow at 1:05 the Graphics of Ps5 and switch changed🤣. No Problem dude.
Was a nice Video and thanks for Upload .
Even the frame rate is decent on the switch.
XD
@@celphalonred1999A copin 🧢 fr 😂
Wow. Just within the first couple of seconds comparing PS5 vs Switch, feels like one of those Titanic sad flute memes for expectation vs reality.
Yeah in the switch version there seems to be a constant cloud over the castle and the water looks really bad but hey the switch version s totally portable
Looks like a 2013 PS3 game but at least it runs
That’s actually a much more accurate observation compared to the previous comment.
More like an early 2013 ps3 game, no way this looks anything like the last of us, uncharted 2 and GTA V did on the PS3
Se ve como un juego de 2010 o 2011 de esa generación, para el 2012 ya habían juegos con mejores gráficos que estos
Considering that Switch is on par with PS3/X360 hardware, I say you made a quite accurate take
@@hugocastilla3102Switch is more powerful than both of those
As a switch player for life it’s crazy to see the difference!!! The amount of details in ps5.. almost makes me wanna buy one too
Well at least it works, Shame they still charge full price for it.
do you know how much effort it took to get it to run this good switch? if anything they should charge more
Right! Like I get the hardwork and all, but they should've went down a little on the price to like maybe $40.
Those at Nintendo will say that investing in graphical power is not necessary but in the Nintendo Switch version everything feels like a completely dead world, lifeless without color, on PS5 it feels like a more real and alive world, watching the leaves go by, the saturation of the sun in the clouds, etc.
Si el gameplay es fluido, es una conversión muy digna y demuestra una vez más que con un buen trabajo, la mayoría de juegos actuales pueden jugarse en Nintendo Switch.
Es que es muy subestimada, ve como está ahora mk1 con esos parches que le han ido metiendo es solo dedicarle una buena optimización antes de lanzar el juego 😏
@@somacruz508 El problema es que hacer esos ajustes para que puedan correr en algo tan anticuado en hardware como lo es switch requiere una cantidad de esfuerzo considerable para un juego que la mayoria de usuarios de switch ni comprarán
Como de ese juego específico, no he visto o jugado la versión PS5 y tampoco la del Switch, si alguien me hiciera la broma de mostrar esa comparación invirtiendo la colocación de los letreros de una consola y otra, No me daría cuenta si el de imágen de Switch le pusieran letrero de otra consola, no le encontraría modo de saber si los letreros estuvieran colocados en la versión correcta de consola o No, por ejemplo vi la parte que compara el vuelo del personaje y la izquierda muestra piedra en gris sin musgo verde y el de la derecha piedra también gris y ese sí con musgo verde, (minuto 2 con 8 segundos) Si No tuviera los letreros de consola correspondiente ya puestos No le distinguiría cual es la del PS5 y cuál No es
The Switch Version kinda reminds me of the game we would wish for in the ps2 era or Nintendo DS era of Harry Potter Games.
However, it lacks the charm of the HP characters and story.
Those graohics reminds me of the first Xbox, it's nostalgic and it has its charm to see new games with the old look.
Me parece admirable que el juego vaya bien y sea así de bien para lo que es switch, esperaba que se repitiera lo de MK1 y nos dieran gráficos sin expresiones sacadas de la ps1, en cambio tenemos un juego que parece de la gamecube pero obviamente se debe a que es la Switch
Yo no diría tanto que se vea de Gamecube, vale que Switch no sea un portento en graficazos y eso se debe a que usa componentes creados en 2014/2015, para lo que es, es un resultado sorprendente, se puede comparar por ejemplo con el port de The Witcher III para el mismo sistema y eso que este último es más grande que Hogwarts Legacy. Yo pensaba comprarme la versión de Switch dado que de momento es la única consola que tengo pero, me voy a esperar al posible lanzamiento de Switch 2 y con eso quizá lleguen los parches "next gen" para que dichos juegos se vean mejor, que ojo, que a mi me vale con que el juego sea estable y pueda al menos ir a 30fps sin tantas caídas.
Como dije, el port es más que admirable y el trabajo que hay detrás, es muy meritorio, lo van a disfrutar muchos por el hecho de la portabilidad y algunos dirán que es mejor la steam deck, si ya, pero muchos no tienen la solvencia económica para permitirse una steam deck y aun si la tienen, es una consola que literalmente es una PC portátil y por tanto también tiene sus contras.
Para una persona que no lo haya jugado en PC o consolas de nueva generación seguramente disfrutara la experiencia, pero para alguien que ya lo ha jugado con gráficos a tope se nota el bajonazo en todos los niveles, gráficos más opacos y sin luces, ni hablar del agua que se ve como cortada, en fin, el hardware del switch a estas alturas simplemente ya debería ser actualizado.
@@David-gb8brswitch no puede ni correr sus zeldas sin tener bajones
Have say some places looking better in Nintendo Switch that dark colornes. I'm very impressed this port. :)
i think it's a good port, due the limitations of switch, in portable mode maybe this low graphics don't make such difference!!!
Did anyone really expect PlayStation 5 graphics on the Switch? My daughters play this game on the Switch and they love it despite of any restrictions. That's all that matters
The Switch version really shows how busy the visuals are on PS5. Developers have gone all-in on throwing as much detail and effects at you as possible without really considering the visual readability you have when you're actually playing the game. I wonder if the gaming industry will ever get over this obsession with attaining photorealism and realize simpler easy to read visuals are actually better for gameplay.
Agreed!! I actuality remembered an argument over the Crash N-Sane Trilogy port for the Nintendo Switch, "One looks like Cheetos Puffs, and the other looks like Crunchy Cheetos" Where I said, "Yup and the Crunchy ones are the best!!" It's not surprising how many people agreed with that.
Wrong. Simple sometimes get in the way when you can't make out what something is in order to react to it. If you're going to have details, it has to be clear enough for a gamer to read what it is, or else stick to simple boring graphics like you said, and have boring gameplay.
I love Nintendo, but they definitely need to amp their future consoles to stay conpetitive in today's market
I’m quite excited for a new Nintendo console, the Zelda games will be amazing
Stay competitive? It’s the highest selling console out of Gen9 and 10
Good graphics do not mean a winning console
Looking forward to the year 2040 when nintendo consoles can handle 1080p 60fps.
Cool but I really wish you would have show other key locations, like the 4 common rooms, the map chamber, the room of requirement and its biomes, maybe even the house elf kitchen.
There's a house elf kitchen? I had this game on the switch and I never saw that
@@jordanmccahan335 I’m not sure about the Switch, I got the PS5 version.
Hogwarts Legacy 2023 vs Hogwarts Legacy 2008
Its okay, way better than mk1
Apart from the water, they did an incredible job on the switch
After watching this video I'm quite sure that Nintendo would port GTA 5 to Switch if they wanted to
ps3 runs gtav, and switch is like 2x more powerful, so yes, they can do it
@@solidsnivy5639Probably because of GTA Online. It's huge, I wonder if the Switch and Nintendo's online can handle it.
They already did that test in an article. Needless to say, it wasn't good--much like this comparison. That's exactly why the switch 2 (if and when it comes) will not be getting GTA 6. But yes, they plan to port GTA 5 to the switch in the future...to most likely their successor. Just, it will look and perform weaker than a ps4 pro by comparison and it has been stated, cost near or same as when the original PS5 came out.
NS: ☁️ PS5: 🌤️. NS version looks very empty 😭
The fact people waited to get it on switch instead of any other platform😭😂
Some people don’t have any other platform.
@@blueflare3848that’s depressing
When seeing the Nintendo switch version it gave me ps3/Xbox 360 Harry Potter vibes from this
La primer comparativa con el agua te puede dar una muy mala impresión de este port xd, pero por las demas la verdad es un trabajo muy decente, considerando que la switch no tiene ni 1/10 del poder de una PS5 creo que han captado la escencia del juego bastante bien
HERMANO ni que tuviera potencia de Xbox 360 por ahí tiene un 5/6/4 de potencia pero tampoco tan bajo
@@carnitas679de hecho la switch es 4 veces más potente que la play 3 y la play 3 era la consola más potente de su generación.
@@apue9849 Ush si hablaramos así entonces la WiiU era dos veces más potente que una play 3🧠
@@carnitas679 de hecho la Wii u si es más potente pero por poco
@@apue9849 Hablando de potencia si, nintendo no es un representante de eso pero yo compro sus consolas por qué sus juegos son demasiado divertidos y buenos (no pago los 60 pavos compro cuentas secundarias)
I only have the Nintendo Switch but I'm not complaining, I'm a big Potterhead and I really really really want to play it so I'm still excited even though there's difference with the quality. I don't have money to buy PS5 yet. But someday maybe.. I am currently playing it and I just had a break typing this comment after a 10-hour playthrough, I need to eat.. and while watching this. 🤣
tbh with y’all as an only switch owner, I’m used to this graphic LMAO so ig it’ll be fine 😭
Same bro, at least we can play the game now lol
Same. Lol
Its so crazy how developers have to absolutely destroy their own game artstyle and details just so their can game can run on the switch.
Main thing that bothers me is the loading when going into all the shops in hogsmead, but graphic wise I’m impressed with the switch
If only Switch didn't need SD cards, loading times would be way better.
As far as speed goes we have, eMMC < SD card < HDD < Flash storage < SSD < M.2
So it's no wonder it takes so long.
Hopefully Nintendo give the next system an SSD at least.
Switchバージョンをやった後PS5でやれば感動がまた味わえるってことだ！！！
やったね！！！
The switch has produced far better ports even with its limitations, even Red Dead Redemption from ps3 looks waaaaayyyyyy better and graphically it is quite similiar to the Legacy port, but it has gorgeous sunsets and nice sharp clean visuals. Main issues I have are the lack of any kind of dynamic lighting which would have greatly improved the texture details, they could have increased the contrast also to hide alot of the messy looking textures too, and the draw distance being so foggy is a huge eyesore, looks like Silent Hill 1 on ps1 lol. Will I buy the switch port? Yes, because performance wise I will agree it looks like it's running well and I'd love to play the game on the go, but I think they could have done a better job and I hope some patches come out down the road like GTA trilogy and Witcher 3 that can improve the graphics. The switch is more than capable of handling way better graphics, just look at Doom! Easily outperforms this visually and gameplay speed. I'm definitely holding on to my ps4 copy of it lol
Most PS3 era games ported to Switch will look better than this. They get to keep sharp textures and consistently higher resolutions. The problem here is that poor image quality ruins what would otherwise be an artistically stunning game. So, older games get to preserve their visual identity or even enhance it.
It's also a completely different engine. The standard of the Unreal 4 engine is much higher.
The port is very good. Especially when you see how terribly Mortal Kombat 1 was realised.
RDR is a PS3 game. Hogwarts is two generations past that.
Going to follow up and say I picked up the game today and I am actually more impressed with it than what footage on TH-cam has shown. Reduce the brightness a bit to improve the contrast like I was suggesting and man, while it’s still a shadow of it’s next gen self and not the best port I’ve played to date, it’s still very very impressive and holds its own :)
This reminds me of when new games used to get launched in the Nintendo DS. The difference is that in the of Switch they have the exact same gameplay
If the visual downgrade were the only thing, it would have been fine. But there is a lot of loading screens that wasn't there before.
and what did you expect? the switch storage is not an SSD
I swear this generation is the most ungrateful lot ever. Just be thankful that they even managed to port such an immense game to Switch
@@hassanshareef6794 they are for sure… I could still play ps1 games no problem lol.
@@hassanshareef6794Yeah guys, be grateful that a company wants your money! Consume product, don’t have standards! This generation sucks.
@@CaptainEffort you can say the same thing about the steam deck