He looks like a normally well-kempt teenage boy whose parents go on vacation for two weeks and his one act of rebellion is to grow facial hair and show up to church with that on their first morning back with a nice suit and half a month's scruff
I forget which one it is, but there’s one I remember where it starts really soft saying “Eat this bread.” but by the end of the verse it’s practically shouting, then just has a jarring swap back to the refrain gently saying “Eat this bread”. It’s always been funny to me lol
Dont trust the Jesuits. Ever. They murdered the Pope that tried to disband them, and they are still large and in charge today. "The Civil War never could have been possible without the sinister influence of the Jesuits" - Abraham Lincoln "I learned much from the Order of the Jesuits. Until now, there has never been anything more grandiose, on the earth, than the hierarchical organization of the Catholic Church. I transferred much of this organization into my own party..." - Adolf Hitler
His impression was 100% accurate. My family still imitates one of the guys from our parish who sang like that ages ago only he had an accent we could never place (maybe Eastern European), so it was more like "Da bread of bread is breeeeeead." Oh and the suit were better in the 70s. Sportcoats, wide ties, with white belts and shoes.
Imagine this college student running the music at church, who only knows how to play in keys that are too high for anyone to reasonably sing and has an ear-piercing screech of a singing voice. It's worse than the dads
Around the ~6:00, when they're both talking about their Confirmation names, it's like they both forget they're on camera and it's just two guys having a conversation in a coffee shop or something.
flipian86 it also helps when they both had a brother named Peter who passed away whose name they took for confirmation?! - did that mind-boggling coincidence seem bizarrely unsurprising to them?
Those brought up Catholic have a deep connection - the only way to get thru growing up Catholic and still have some sort of sanity in their souls. Aaaaaaaaaamen.
Stephen needs invervewees who interview him. I think that's part of the reason this went so sell. John kind of takes over the interview ad holds his own. Colbert's interviews go poorly when his guests are passive and leave him to draw out the information or stories. Colbert isn't good at that yet. He'll often say things that leave no room for response or discussion. I think it's because he has done interviews for years, but as his character who existed TO make people uncomfortable and to dominate the conversation.
My fav is when John talks to someone and mentions a mutual friend they know and calls THEM the funniest person and you can always tell the other person is thinking "i mean sure but definitely you're the funniest john" i swear ive seen seth go thru that thought process lol
Seemed like Stephen got personal then found it hard to transition back to jokes. Kinda like those people you can't help but let your guard down around. I wonder if they caught up after the show and decided to become friends
It was super interesting. Stephen is a devout Catholic, and a Sunday school teacher, and the tragic deaths of his father and brothers when he was a child obviously deeply affected him. It was a little strange to see him get caught on his back foot a bit here -- John's just trying to be funny and irreverent, but they were clearly getting close to some stuff that makes Stephen emotional and it seems like neither knew what to do with that. I love them both.
I agree. I became quiet. Internally prosessing "what if", and I didn't know how to respond other than, "wow, now what.. You both loved, lost, chose to honor your brother, and I'm still unsure how to tell you.. I love you, I'm sorry, you're beautiful"! Nah.. But from someone raised roman Catholic.. Wow. This hit me. I'm the ugly duckling. I do not worship God in church. I'm devout in my multi spiritual dimensions. Carry the Catholic cross and guilt wherever I go, I have no prejudices towards beliefs/religions/spiritual endeavours. I know that what molds us from infancy, makes us separate. It's when we over come our beautiful differences we see one another with respect, and that's amazing. I honestly don't care about the physical scars from not being true, I just care about how I treat you, and you treat you. #findlove #worldpeace
They both had brothers names peter who died; John took his brother's middle name as his confirmation name, and Stephen took as kinda Peter-adjacent name (because Jesus renamed Peter, his original name was Simon). Stephen was definitely taken aback alright.
Wizard Suth Vaccines? I don’t know how Mulaney’s brother died but as for Colbert, his father & 2 of his brothers died in a car crash. Not sure what vaccines have to do with the topic.
I honestly thought he was faking his kindness to John, then really tuning into multiple clips between him and John I think ur right! Haha it's a great friendship!
I loved this whole video, as I do this two hilarious men, but I have to say towards the end I just got so mystified watching this. The fact they had nearly the same story for their confirmations and the same brothers names who passed away... that is remarkable. That those two people would have that similar story. Before Stephen said his story, you could see he was shocked in realizing that it was nearly the same story for him. Woah...
It was amazing but it also seems like it made them both uncomfortable. John's just there to be irreverent and funny -- earnestly discussing the tragic deaths of their siblings (and Stephen's father) didn't seem like something he was prepared to do.
And now he's divorced that Jewish woman, much to the surprise of all of his fans. I'm only 35 (so I've only been Jewish for 35 years) but in my experience it's NOT very "One of us" to fall off the drug-and-alcohol wagon, come out of rehab, & divorce the woman who stood by you through everything. That said, a second cousin of mine - also age 35 - was recently divorced by the husband she'd nursed through late-stage colon cancer. After years near-death going though experimental treatment, this guy was miraculously given a clean bill of health... and the first thing he did was leave his wife. So, abandoning the person who was there for you during the worst times is (I'm ashamed to say) something Jews apparently do to each other, too (it's not bad behavior reserved for Catholic men married to Jewish women).
this interview made me realize why i relate to mulaney more than colbert, as someone who was raised catholic...colbert leaned into the religion as a result of his major trauma, while mulaney drifted away from it
@@InverseAgonist I can't help but feel a little tension over that... even though I know steven is cool and he doesn't actually care I think he's still bummed out over how much john is joking about it
@@MattFyrm I know Stephen's feelings are valid but Cmon he knows John says those things with no ill intent. Plus hes a comedian. That's kind of what they do.
I love these interviews with people Colbert genuinely wants to spend time with. You see them go off on tangents and think “Oh do I need to let this brilliant person do an instant bit” so it becomes an English Politeness standoff until they remember “Oh crap you came here to test material” and then they have to cram in what was actually prepared. We love our tall child. We wish him all the best.
I don't think any guest could truly shine because John is so naturally funny that he'd be the funny one and the guest would just be. There. Facilitating John's humor. Instead of the other way around.
This show screwed Colbert's comedy... You should've seen the Colbert Report, what he made before they gave him this extra good paying job.. It was so funny.. I hope for our sake he stays away from this shit.
I picked Thomas More as my confirmation name. I recently discovered that the real St. Thomas More had one of my ancestors burned at the stake as a Lollard heretic. It's funny world, this.
my favorite John Mulaney interviews are the ones with Steven Colbert because they don’t feel as forced as some other hosts, and their energies together are just hilarious
Chris Fullington they all died you know. there's great living comedians like Louis CK, Doug Stanhope, Jimmy Carr. Mulaney is definitely among them though! His specials are insanely funny and very consistent.
Brian Sexton I think a lot of Jewish celebrities are atheist in their beliefs (Sarah Silverman and Seth Rogen, for example), but because "Jewish" is both a religious affiliation and an ethnicity, you can be an atheist Jew. So when they say they're Jewish, their referring to their ethnicity, heritage, or culture- not their beliefs.
Catholics traditionally, like Jews, say once you're Catholic you're Catholic for life(whether you want to be or not). That's often why its a ehhh who knows situation for lapsed Catholics. In fact the term "lapsed Catholics" is a term used by practicing Catholics to refer to those baptized and confirmed in the Church who no longer believe or have gone elsewhere for their religious life. For Jews it does seem to blur the line into ethnicity and paternal/maternal inheritance so they would have less of a problem just saying yes Im a Jew even if they don't believe in God or a Soul etc... There is another interesting factor, in America especially, the school of Judaism known as Reform Judaism in which a person practices as a Jew in many different ways; from a very traditional manner based on the most orthodox Rabbinic beliefs all the way to creating their own idea of what God is, whether or not an eternal soul exists or not, rejecting the idea bodily resurrection, the historicity of the bible, the messianic age vs the messiah, etc..., while still being able to practice(or not) their Jewish faith in a temple or synagogue with a congregation. In fact for many, Reform Judaism really most resembles a somewhat more deistic/religious humanism rather than what people normally associate with Judaism. A lot of interesting theology, philosophy, and history behind that question
Just to add on to what you said, as a Catholic we have to literally and formally request to not be Catholic in order for us to be considered non-Catholics, otherwise you're Catholic for life. So it's also probably like "ehhhh, well I haven't officially written to my Church to request that I not be considered a Catholic anymore... and I probably don't agree with certain aspects of the church, but I was raised as a cradle Catholic and still like some of the values and probably a lot of the social justice teachings, so... meh idk."
they also shut down the "count me out" website in 2013, where you could formally request to leave the catholic church so they count many of us as lapsed who are in fact aggressively anti-catholic
Has anyone picked up that John had a little brother that died called Peter and now when people see him and Pete Davidson together they see him as Pete’s older brother ?
This didn't feel like an interview. This felt like I was at a restaurant and the two people in the booth behind me were having an in depth conversation and it was so fascinating that I couldn't help but enjoy.
Love, look at the two of them, strangers in many ways. got a lifetime to share So much to say and as we go from day to day I'll feel you close to me But time alone will tell Let's take a lifetime to say I knew you well For only time will tell us so And love may grow for all we know
They're two of my favorite comics, but they were oddly awkward talking to each other. I thought the same thing when I watched (beardless) John on another one of Colbert's shows. I don't think it's purposely competitive, but instead I think that John so often surprised Stephen with things that he said that Stephen (usually very quick) had to really think to respond. I think it will be a better interview in the future as they get to know each other's humor better.
It was almost awkward but then I realized it's because they were very similar and so is their timing ..so they were kind of talking over each other a few times
QuizMaster Hanzo now that you’ve brought that up yes he absolutely is. He looks like the type of man that would try to take me to a secondary location as well. Terrifying.
I wish John didn’t use his bits during interviews. He’s already naturally funny but then there’s always a chunk of interviews where i’m like “I’ve heard this before” It’s funny, but he doesn’t need to
John Mulaney's easily one of the funniest comedians in the English-speaking world. But who does he think he's fooling with that beard from Hair and Make-up?
I didn't think it was possible for someone to look younger with a beard than without one, but John Mullaney pulled it off
Deedeedee137 I think its because it carves his chin out, making the top of his face look bigger (including his eyes) evoking a childs big eyed face.
Deedeedee137 He looks so familiar and yet SO different. It's strange, but I adore it. What a precious man.
He looks like a normally well-kempt teenage boy whose parents go on vacation for two weeks and his one act of rebellion is to grow facial hair and show up to church with that on their first morning back with a nice suit and half a month's scruff
That was startlingly but refreshingly specific
I've never seen this before, either! It's quite amazing! He DOES look younger with facial hair! HOW does he DO that??
Stephen: "Are you still Catholic?"
John: "Uh..."
God that is the most relatable mood for kids raised Catholic and are kinda not anymore
YUP.
Omg yesss
"My Parents Are Watching"
I am, I just don’t go to church
Meeeeeeeee
That's so beautiful they both had a brother named Peter who passed away and they both took their confirmation name to honor the brother.
also kinda a crazy coincidence!
Yeah really shocking coincidence, so sad!
Stephen lost two brothers and their father in a plane crash. It's a deeply sad story.
Is that how you get into comedy?
I was beginning to think it's a Catholic line/figure of speech of sorts, but I guess not... :(
"You can't be married to everyone nice, because then you'd be married to too many people"
-John Mulaney, 2016
you'd be married to no one*
Big mood.
Oh, they're the same person. That's cool I guess.
There needs to be a really well presented coffee table book full of John Mulaney quotes. Haha
Every church song ever: "The bread of bread is bread!"
Not song, psalm 🤣
it’s either about bread, or it’s about (any replaceable adjective insert here: ex. leaning on, standing on, walking with) God
Sounds like a Lenin quote
I forget which one it is, but there’s one I remember where it starts really soft saying “Eat this bread.” but by the end of the verse it’s practically shouting, then just has a jarring swap back to the refrain gently saying “Eat this bread”. It’s always been funny to me lol
Dont trust the Jesuits. Ever. They murdered the Pope that tried to disband them, and they are still large and in charge today.
"The Civil War never could have been possible without the sinister influence of the Jesuits" - Abraham Lincoln
"I learned much from the Order of the Jesuits. Until now, there has never been anything more grandiose, on the earth, than the hierarchical organization of the Catholic Church. I transferred much of this organization into my own party..." - Adolf Hitler
John: my dad grabbed me and said "God can't hear you"
Stephen: *thoughtfully* wow
Stephen is 100% the Catholic Dad in this scenario. I know the look.
t12478 agreed. I often wonder about how much Stephen’s in camera persona reflects his real character. Intriguing guy.
meanwhile that was the mic drop for kid gorgeous
@@cryspbacon i was looking for this comment
The eye contact following that was intense
"The bread of bread is breeeaaaadd" lmao 😂
His impression was 100% accurate. My family still imitates one of the guys from our parish who sang like that ages ago only he had an accent we could never place (maybe Eastern European), so it was more like "Da bread of bread is breeeeeead." Oh and the suit were better in the 70s. Sportcoats, wide ties, with white belts and shoes.
Imagine this college student running the music at church, who only knows how to play in keys that are too high for anyone to reasonably sing and has an ear-piercing screech of a singing voice. It's worse than the dads
"Bread is breead, there issss BRead."
It's pronounced "screaming"
"GOD CANT HEAR YOU"
Around the ~6:00, when they're both talking about their Confirmation names, it's like they both forget they're on camera and it's just two guys having a conversation in a coffee shop or something.
I live for these moments in life.
The synergy between John and Stephen is amazing. Their interview went so smoothly.
In my opinion it helps when both are relatively intelligent.
flipian86 it also helps when they both had a brother named Peter who passed away whose name they took for confirmation?! - did that mind-boggling coincidence seem bizarrely unsurprising to them?
Those brought up Catholic have a deep connection - the only way to get thru growing up Catholic and still have some sort of sanity in their souls. Aaaaaaaaaamen.
Stephen needs invervewees who interview him. I think that's part of the reason this went so sell. John kind of takes over the interview ad holds his own. Colbert's interviews go poorly when his guests are passive and leave him to draw out the information or stories. Colbert isn't good at that yet. He'll often say things that leave no room for response or discussion. I think it's because he has done interviews for years, but as his character who existed TO make people uncomfortable and to dominate the conversation.
It was a little rocky to start off, but it felt real.
Bearded John Mulaney is the third property brother
4th they have a brother
@@orphanedhanyou exactly! And it’s John Mulaney
I'd love to just hangout with John Mulaney, he's such a naturally funny guy
He's a great conversationalist.
TheDizzyBadger hang out*
yeah, he should become a stand up comedian
people aren't wrong when they say he's the funniest man in the world. bill hader's said it, nick kroll's said it
who would give kroll that much credit...?
@@fenecofeneco19 me.
So has Seth Meyers
My fav is when John talks to someone and mentions a mutual friend they know and calls THEM the funniest person and you can always tell the other person is thinking "i mean sure but definitely you're the funniest john" i swear ive seen seth go thru that thought process lol
i have also said it
Seeing them speak to each other, it's become increasingly clear that John Mulaney is just a younger Stephen Colbert
Jack Ding o.o That's what it is! XD That makes so much sense!
The Late Show with Mulaney 2030, I'm down.
I feel like this is why the interview felt a little clunky. It's like someone interviewing themselves.
God I hope not.
John is actually funny though
I think I have a crush on bearded John Mulaney
Mia I think I just have a crush on John Mulaney, the beard is just a nice bonus.
I think I just have a crush in him at all times.
who doesnt tbh
Makes him look like a slightly older tall child.
Me too! Sexy!
Why does that tall child have a beard? Shave your beard, tall child!
I laughed too long at this reference
I read this in his voice and died
Valentina Fangirling SAME
Hahah I use his references for so many situations 😂😂😂
He probably "blacked out" when he grew that beard
"Then you are asked to reject Satan, just as high school is beginning, when you need him the most."😂
Seemed like Stephen got personal then found it hard to transition back to jokes. Kinda like those people you can't help but let your guard down around. I wonder if they caught up after the show and decided to become friends
It was super interesting. Stephen is a devout Catholic, and a Sunday school teacher, and the tragic deaths of his father and brothers when he was a child obviously deeply affected him. It was a little strange to see him get caught on his back foot a bit here -- John's just trying to be funny and irreverent, but they were clearly getting close to some stuff that makes Stephen emotional and it seems like neither knew what to do with that. I love them both.
Yeah I was about to say, this was an unexpectedly personal interview
I agree. I became quiet. Internally prosessing "what if", and I didn't know how to respond other than, "wow, now what.. You both loved, lost, chose to honor your brother, and I'm still unsure how to tell you.. I love you, I'm sorry, you're beautiful"!
Nah.. But from someone raised roman Catholic.. Wow. This hit me. I'm the ugly duckling. I do not worship God in church. I'm devout in my multi spiritual dimensions. Carry the Catholic cross and guilt wherever I go, I have no prejudices towards beliefs/religions/spiritual endeavours. I know that what molds us from infancy, makes us separate. It's when we over come our beautiful differences we see one another with respect, and that's amazing.
I honestly don't care about the physical scars from not being true, I just care about how I treat you, and you treat you. #findlove #worldpeace
3 years have passed and based on their many interviews after this, they're probably great mates now. (Special mention: that Anxiety talk clip)
Wait I am so confused they both had brothers named peter that died and they both took their middle names and their not freaking out about this??
They both had brothers names peter who died; John took his brother's middle name as his confirmation name, and Stephen took as kinda Peter-adjacent name (because Jesus renamed Peter, his original name was Simon).
Stephen was definitely taken aback alright.
Peter is a fairly common name among Catholics. It is odd that both of them had a brother who died. That happens a lot less now thanks to vaccines.
Wizard Suth Vaccines? I don’t know how Mulaney’s brother died but as for Colbert, his father & 2 of his brothers died in a car crash. Not sure what vaccines have to do with the topic.
@@wizardsuth vaccines have been a thing since the late 1700s but okay...
@@sarahabc4557 eastern airlines plane crash
I think I just watched John and Stephen become best friends.
I honestly thought he was faking his kindness to John, then really tuning into multiple clips between him and John I think ur right! Haha it's a great friendship!
they were hardly getting along
MultiDragola exactly, like best friends
i think i just watched john slowly dissociate as he realized stephen is future him after he goes back in time
Yes... this was so sweet.
This is the truest thing ever. My grandma knows she can't sing but she said to me, "God gave me this voice so he's going to hear it." 😂
"Yeah, you know." That is the most Catholic answer he could've given. :-)
Michael Stearne 7:00
I loved this whole video, as I do this two hilarious men, but I have to say towards the end I just got so mystified watching this. The fact they had nearly the same story for their confirmations and the same brothers names who passed away... that is remarkable. That those two people would have that similar story. Before Stephen said his story, you could see he was shocked in realizing that it was nearly the same story for him. Woah...
It was amazing but it also seems like it made them both uncomfortable. John's just there to be irreverent and funny -- earnestly discussing the tragic deaths of their siblings (and Stephen's father) didn't seem like something he was prepared to do.
I know this is a serious comment but.....
69 likes, ayyyyy
they both were trying to out-comedy each other, but it kinda works.
@@kcblachere152 yes
John: *Is married to a Jewish woman, wishes he had a Bar Mitzvah, and has Chinese on Christmas*
Me: One of us! One of us! One of us!
And now he's divorced that Jewish woman, much to the surprise of all of his fans. I'm only 35 (so I've only been Jewish for 35 years) but in my experience it's NOT very "One of us" to fall off the drug-and-alcohol wagon, come out of rehab, & divorce the woman who stood by you through everything. That said, a second cousin of mine - also age 35 - was recently divorced by the husband she'd nursed through late-stage colon cancer. After years near-death going though experimental treatment, this guy was miraculously given a clean bill of health... and the first thing he did was leave his wife.
So, abandoning the person who was there for you during the worst times is (I'm ashamed to say) something Jews apparently do to each other, too (it's not bad behavior reserved for Catholic men married to Jewish women).
God John is so sharp, he's the classic comedian on the surface, then his own beautiful beast beneath
I read “his own beautiful breast underneath” the first time.
I still think it works better actually, not that I disagree with you. He’s super.
this interview made me realize why i relate to mulaney more than colbert, as someone who was raised catholic...colbert leaned into the religion as a result of his major trauma, while mulaney drifted away from it
Interesting thoughts
Drifted away or saw the light of sanity? The church does not equate with goodness.
John Mulaney's Netflix comedy specials are actually really funny
Thanks John
YOU SWITCHED THE SAMPLES!
I could have watched HOURS of this. This needs to be a show :'D just the two of them telling stories
I am a proud Asian-American woman and you will treat me with respect! I am a Tiger mom.
"John, it was lovely to see you."
"...I've still got 2 minutes of material."
Oh, they're the same person. That's cool I guess.
Linnamonroll Stephen still takes Catholicism seriously, though. John is very clearly over it.
@@InverseAgonist I can't help but feel a little tension over that... even though I know steven is cool and he doesn't actually care I think he's still bummed out over how much john is joking about it
@@MattFyrm I know Stephen's feelings are valid but Cmon he knows John says those things with no ill intent. Plus hes a comedian. That's kind of what they do.
I love these interviews with people Colbert genuinely wants to spend time with. You see them go off on tangents and think “Oh do I need to let this brilliant person do an instant bit” so it becomes an English Politeness standoff until they remember “Oh crap you came here to test material” and then they have to cram in what was actually prepared.
We love our tall child. We wish him all the best.
Their banter is phenomenal.
My God, they're the same person.
It's like frasier and niles
He is the best stand up comedian... a genius of comedy
nah
DD yes! Love his style, very fresh!
this is the best possible interview combo, they work so well together
So we all can agree John get the late show after Stephen right?
I don't think any guest could truly shine because John is so naturally funny that he'd be the funny one and the guest would just be. There. Facilitating John's humor. Instead of the other way around.
This show screwed Colbert's comedy... You should've seen the Colbert Report, what he made before they gave him this extra good paying job.. It was so funny.. I hope for our sake he stays away from this shit.
Mulaney makes everyone who interviews him laugh. What a charming son of a mother
John Mulaney's father is a savage lol When he talks about him I lmfao
Gabriela M "GoD cAn'T hEaR yOu"
One black coffee.
you have the moral backbone of a chocolate eclair
I love John. The guy is hilarious, but he's so underrated. His standup routines leave me in stitches 😂
I picked Thomas More as my confirmation name. I recently discovered that the real St. Thomas More had one of my ancestors burned at the stake as a Lollard heretic. It's funny world, this.
Lord Cottington - this comment should have gotten more likes and replies 😂
I would choose Martin Luther
Oh my god
@@plushpuppy32 😄
I also picked Thomas More, only to find out I'm a descendant of Henry VIII 😂
my favorite John Mulaney interviews are the ones with Steven Colbert because they don’t feel as forced as some other hosts, and their energies together are just hilarious
john mulaney is the greatest comedian
Easy now!! Lets let him become a house hold name before we put him with the likes of Pryor, Carlin, Hicks... ok? ok!
+Chris Fullington ew
Chris Fullington they all died you know. there's great living comedians like Louis CK, Doug Stanhope, Jimmy Carr. Mulaney is definitely among them though! His specials are insanely funny and very consistent.
Dennis Struijcken yes! Someone recognizing Jimmy Carr! Well I mean wait if you're a British person then never mind lol
I see all these comedians listed and no one mentions the rage machine, Bill Burr, come on now
that was the most former-catholic response to being asked if you're still a catholic
I love John Mulaney and I'm glad to see him again. haven't seen since he's been busy with Broadway.
Layla Abdush-Shaheed you mean Brdway
This is such a nice, fluid interview to watch! Colbert and John really get along so well.
I can recite all his stuff by heart hes so funny
Much love to you both for sharing this meaningful conversation. I adore the both of you.
It's odd how a lot of Jewish celebrities always refer to themselves as Jewish but most Catholic raised celebrities have become atheists.
Brian Sexton wish there was a simple explanation it's very interesting.
Brian Sexton I think a lot of Jewish celebrities are atheist in their beliefs (Sarah Silverman and Seth Rogen, for example), but because "Jewish" is both a religious affiliation and an ethnicity, you can be an atheist Jew. So when they say they're Jewish, their referring to their ethnicity, heritage, or culture- not their beliefs.
Catholics traditionally, like Jews, say once you're Catholic you're Catholic for life(whether you want to be or not). That's often why its a ehhh who knows situation for lapsed Catholics. In fact the term "lapsed Catholics" is a term used by practicing Catholics to refer to those baptized and confirmed in the Church who no longer believe or have gone elsewhere for their religious life. For Jews it does seem to blur the line into ethnicity and paternal/maternal inheritance so they would have less of a problem just saying yes Im a Jew even if they don't believe in God or a Soul etc... There is another interesting factor, in America especially, the school of Judaism known as Reform Judaism in which a person practices as a Jew in many different ways; from a very traditional manner based on the most orthodox Rabbinic beliefs all the way to creating their own idea of what God is, whether or not an eternal soul exists or not, rejecting the idea bodily resurrection, the historicity of the bible, the messianic age vs the messiah, etc..., while still being able to practice(or not) their Jewish faith in a temple or synagogue with a congregation. In fact for many, Reform Judaism really most resembles a somewhat more deistic/religious humanism rather than what people normally associate with Judaism. A lot of interesting theology, philosophy, and history behind that question
Just to add on to what you said, as a Catholic we have to literally and formally request to not be Catholic in order for us to be considered non-Catholics, otherwise you're Catholic for life. So it's also probably like "ehhhh, well I haven't officially written to my Church to request that I not be considered a Catholic anymore... and I probably don't agree with certain aspects of the church, but I was raised as a cradle Catholic and still like some of the values and probably a lot of the social justice teachings, so... meh idk."
they also shut down the "count me out" website in 2013, where you could formally request to leave the catholic church so they count many of us as lapsed who are in fact aggressively anti-catholic
i laughed way too hard at the 'god cant hear you' bit
Jackie Perez I started screeching
i think its so funny and interesting how john held onto that memory of seeing stephen that one day at 9am when he was hungover
Get some rest, tall child! You can't keep burning the candle at both ends!
this is such a genuine & pure interaction
two of the best humans in the world in one room.
#bless
What I love about Stephan is that he has genuine conversations with the interviewees on his show.
THIS WAS A GREAT CATHOLIC NERD-OUT FOR ME
André Crema totally 😄
Gotta love the Jesuit school shout-outs! St. Ignatius (Chicago) and Georgetown!!
Has anyone picked up that John had a little brother that died called Peter and now when people see him and Pete Davidson together they see him as Pete’s older brother ?
lol to when they started playing the electric slide on the outro!
I love how it closed with the electric slide playing 🎶🎶
I could see the regret in Stephen's eyes xD He'll never bring up the Catholic church with John Mulaney again
I have never seen a more genuine interview in all of late night
I love John's father.
"You were there for "The Daily Show", which was a show you did on Comedy Central" LMAO
Holy shait that was an emotional roller coaster.
This didn't feel like an interview. This felt like I was at a restaurant and the two people in the booth behind me were having an in depth conversation and it was so fascinating that I couldn't help but enjoy.
god i can not wait for his next comedy special
AnIrresponsibleOaktree me neither!
this is like the two nicest people meeting and being too nice to each other
This was such a beautiful interview.
That last bit was also from his Netflix special and I love hearing it again and again 😂😂
Is it just me or was there a strangely competitive vibe between those two?
It was beautiful. They're perfect together
Nathan Ware Colbert is just trying to be conscientious of offending religious people - primarily Catholics.
"strangely competitive vibe" Stephen takes Catholicism seriously and John doesn't, so there was a built-in awkwardness that they both handled well.
Love,
look at the two of them,
strangers in many ways.
got a lifetime to share
So much to say
and as we go from day to day
I'll feel you close to me
But time alone will tell
Let's take a lifetime to say
I knew you well
For only time will tell us so
And love may grow for all we know
They're two of my favorite comics, but they were oddly awkward talking to each other. I thought the same thing when I watched (beardless) John on another one of Colbert's shows. I don't think it's purposely competitive, but instead I think that John so often surprised Stephen with things that he said that Stephen (usually very quick) had to really think to respond. I think it will be a better interview in the future as they get to know each other's humor better.
It is very interesting seeing two comedians talk about their respective brothers who have passed away
Salt and Pepper Diner
WHAT'S NEW PUSSYCAT!
I prefer The Xanax Story but that one is a close second!
Erasmo Garcia How about Delta airlines? :-)
It's not unusual....
Liston Pepper owned the Pepper Shaker in Burlington, PA. It was great.
John is infinitely more attractive with a beard. I never thought such a thing was possible.
this is such an odd interview. i love it.
This was a really awesome interview! I feel like these two riffed off each other really well, and they connected nicely.
My son has a beard now I'm screaming
I like how they always find a very interesting similarity between them
These guys should be bros. I want to see more of John coming to Steven’s show more often. They bond rly well. Very interesting conversations.
Love how they played the electric slide at the end... Never too late for a Bar Mitzvah
I never knew John had a brother who passed :(
It was almost awkward but then I realized it's because they were very similar and so is their timing ..so they were kind of talking over each other a few times
John without a beard: *funny stand up guy wow he seems nice*
John with a beard: *that man makes me uncomfortable*
but is he a man that would make you run away from him at 2 AM on a train station?
QuizMaster Hanzo now that you’ve brought that up yes he absolutely is. He looks like the type of man that would try to take me to a secondary location as well. Terrifying.
I wish John didn’t use his bits during interviews. He’s already naturally funny but then there’s always a chunk of interviews where i’m like “I’ve heard this before”
It’s funny, but he doesn’t need to
Yes, his bits are awesome but once you already watched his shows it loses its shine. And his way of telling stories is funny enough!
Lots of people like rehearing or are new to him.
Nice, Stay Human played Electric Slide as the outro! 😂💃🏻
I love watching the two of them. It almost always gets deep or insightful
he blew up so fast. saw him as a club opener a few years ago
It's because of the Netflix special.
Yup. Love his specials on Netflix...... "I'm a little fat girl!!!" :)
Lol still laughing! Some priceless replies in this exchange particularly his Dad's comment on his singing thank you
They're just shootin the shit. I love it.
1:07 the "Oh thank you..." melts my heartttttt
When you realize the whole bit at the end was just a test for his new stand up🧐
I like how john always smoothly brings in parts from his shows during interviews
John Mulany has a direct line to my funny bone...
he looks like hugh jackman if he starved himself for 2 months
Brandon Curry he looks like a tall baby with facial hair
@@laurenhatter6824 That tall Child looks terrible!! Get some rest tall Child!!!
You can’t keep burning the candle at both ends
Mulaney is one of the best comics ever! 💜
The band going into the electric slide as they cut to commercial is fantastic!
Every time John tells a story about his dad, I love him more. His dad, I mean.
I just love watching these two talk.
the best part of this story is that he knows the name Farnsworth Bentley off the top of his head
I love that the band started playing The Electric Slide at the end of the segment! Hahaha!
John Mulaney's easily one of the funniest comedians in the English-speaking world.
But who does he think he's fooling with that beard from Hair and Make-up?
Hahaha! That tall child can't grow a beard!