Novara REACTS To BBCQT Special w/ Nigel Farage & Adrian Ramsay
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- Novara Live broadcasts every weekday from 6PM on TH-cam and Twitch.
Episodes of Downstream are released Sundays at 3PM on TH-cam.
__________________________
Support our journalism by buying Novara Media merch:
shop.novaramed...
Donate one hour’s wage per month, or whatever you can afford:
novara.media/su...
Adrian Ramsey was excellent. Fiona Bruce was terrible.
I've been more impressed with Sian Berry than both co leaders, great policies but Greens should have a working class leader contrast with all major parties having very affluent leaders
Love to you
Can't bear entitlement ...Fiona whosehusband a isa Tory
The BBC is STUFFED TO THE GILLS with Tories and has been ever since Cameron came to power. Not sure what your point is?
Fiona should stick to Antiques Roadshow. Shes comes across as aggressive and biased.
I’ve never liked her reading of the news. She really doesn’t seem to be a journalist to me.
Doing exactly what her bosses want
She should be sacked.
She interfered every time farage spoke and found it amusing what seems to be hand picked racist accusers asking questions.
Voting reform for that reason.
@@andrewgleeson8862 what a ridiculous reason to vote reform
There's always the questions about what the climate measures are going to cost (electric vehicles etc.) but never any talk about the cost of the climate problems now and in the future.What is the cost of the sewerage in the rivers now and if this continues into the future? What is the cost of the increasing numbers of people having health problems due to high temperature levels, having to get treated by the health system? These neo-liberal budget wankers need to be grilled on these questions.
The cold is more of a problem than the heat for us.
Affordable, dependable and secure energy supplies are the bedrock of civilization
Our climate spending will make a negligible impact to these effects. It's a complete waste of money - money the country does not have.
@@benjiman_OBE definitely agree with all that. I just don't agree with net zero policy, it's just exporting manufacturing and putting too much pressure on energy when we have an energy crisis. Should have built nuclear power stations decades ago
hate that fiona
Considering we are the nation that invented the train, revolutionizing transportation, i would put a huge amount more emphasis on how we should have the best train services in the world. It should be a symbol of national pride. It is a cause that i believe every British person could rally around. Trains, and protecting our beautiful countryside and wildlife.
Protecting our poo and chemical filled rivers and coastlines and our abused farmland full of illegal or dubious pesticides and anti nature farming in general.
We are doing the exact opposite of protecting under the conservative government.
For that we'd need to build a modern railway not the Victorian obsolete HS2
@@thetruth6417will cost hundreds of billions
@@ShotsMerkzAll It is anyway. And the only reason these things cost so much is because everyone involved rips the government off to the extreme and they just sign it off. You could do it for a tenth of the price with proper management.
Bruce can't hide her hostility to Green party rep. Her gritted teeth speaking is appalling.
What are you smoking?
@@latest3dsgamesI'm 19 minutes in and she won't let him answer the questions she just keeps interrupting and making assumptive answers before he's finished talking. Barely 5 mins after saying she would let them talk uninterrupted.
@@swanchamp5136 I never saw him answer a single question, just rambling about what they want to do, not how they;'re going to do it.
Maybe watch it again and actually listen to his responses then you’ll hear what the rest of us heard
Omg the bias in that audience is blatantly obvious.
We are all voting Green in Norwich, just have by postal vote.❎❎❎❎❎
You’ve got one of the best progressive MPs in the country in Clive Lewis in Norwich South. Need to keep strong left MPs in the Labour Party. For Norwich North though, Green all the way!
Bbc plants . People need to look into the first two people
Fiona needs to go. 😡😡😡
I iniitally "liked" this, but then realised ... that would mean more Kuenssberg, which would be worse and the replacement in junior level would probably be even worse than even worse.
Farage never got one, clap what a joke.
@@bigkanuna That was all arranged, to make reform look bad but in fact, it just drew my attention to what is happening when it comes to elections. The program was a disgrace and everyone paying for a license should stop right now and get rid of the BBC altogether.
I bet most of the postal votes go AWOL too.
Wtf is the point of asking questions if she keeps interrupting the answers?! So annoying
What did she say at the beginning ' I am not going to interfere'. Which in plain English meant I AM !!!
The first chap wasnt answering them
The first lot of questions were pretty much the same too, joke
Im not sure the audience understand there is a difference between legal and illegal migration, its a bit baffling how much the two concepts are confused. Legal migrants are probably far more exercised by this than the average Uk voter it seems.
Irrelevant.
Feelings > Facts!
Nor, apparently, are they capable of understanding that numbers in any way matter.
Nor the colour of their skin
Nigel has been talking to Australia's opposition leader - Peter Potato Dutton 😢
Did he pull "Small nuclear reactors" from some other dark and musty place?
They have made it that there’s no way to get to Britain so it’s only illegal,what you know about migration can be written on the back of a postage stamp!
it says a lot about the overton window in the UK that a at best, socdem is paired with an actual, textbook, fash...
Or centre right is paired with communism- have a careful look at where the greens want us to go
I thought Andrew Ramsay was really impressive and could answer Fiona Bruce's irritating interruptions with confidence and clarity . I'm voting Green.
100% unbiased audience 😂
Nah, that's pretty representative of how most people feel that aren't terminally online closet racists living in the reform-bot echo chamber
This shit was stacked by starmer and rishi. So damn obvious, it bleeds guilt
@@CapoKabar Of course it was. They looked like a pair of muppets going head to head on their debate, so why would they want to do Nigel any favours. Just goes to show what is really going on in our Government and it does not boil down to honesty or helping the British Tax payers.
Reform gets my vote and will always get my vote where able.
@@sparrow_6177 Nigel needs to play dirtier too
I know I shouldn't be, but I'm actually surprised by how much Farage sounds like Trump.
@@lrshowreelare you implying that fart is a carbon copy of garbage & not the other way around??
They've worked with the same people (Bannon) and use the same playbook.
@@7dtdfil730as hominem attacks, wouldn’t expect anything less from a labour voter
@@cookieking1996 Your comment is so hypocritical it eats its own tail.
Big shout out to Aaron for doing this, makes it much more enjoyable than just watching it on TV
it is a joke the uk does not have any high speed rail france and japan can do it the uk rail mess will take 100 years before u get something
Funny thing is mate, most of the rail stock is owned by the french. 😂
@@jrlx86 You do realise you’re making his point for him? Thatcher started the decline in the UK, she sold everything off, killed manufacturing and now all we have is a few London spies gambling on DEBT, and High Streets full of Nailbars.
Fantastic commentary Aaron. You made Question Time enjoyable 👏👏👏
So fantastic, he chimes in whenever something hits too close to reality.
Give Adrian Ramsey his due, he never stalled once and his answers were crisp and to the point!...which is good cos I'm voting for him!
56:48 so many audience members and this woman gets to ask both leaders a question! Definitely a BBC plant!
how many actors in that audience ? they seemed well rehearsed in there questions ?
Are you suggesting if you went on question time to ask a question you would just pull it out your arse at the last minute?
Surely they would have been thinking about what they were going to say and rehearsing it over and over. I know I would, and have, having been in a question time audience many years ago. You just want to get it right.
Definite paid shills/activists there to boo Reform. They don't want a real populist party to have any power.
@@petejones3966 @petejones3966 as far as I know all bbc audiences are picked by releasing more tickets than they have seats and then doing first come first serve. It's possibly different for political stuff but an alternative explanation would be outside of his core base farage is seen as more of the same kind of nasty corrupt politics we've just put up with, what with him being the reason the country is totally fuck up and all
The media are so loathsome.
Adrian became much more articulate and impassioned after a while and therefore more interesting. Hey, Aaron put the debate on pause when you are speaking/commentating on it. It's annoying otherwise. Common practice nowadays to do just that. Cheers!
War of the Worlds sums up Gaza
There should be a buzzer or a gong that goes off whenever a fact-check is failed.
Thet tried a hatchet job but you can't barage the farage.
Adrian Ramsay performed very well!
no seemed like a automaton
@@bichonferret8488 how?
The green party made the most important comment re migration: If Climate change kicks in the number of people needing to migrate will increase massively. We have to take responsibility for actions that culmatively are making parts of the world unlivable.
Can I suggest pausing when you interupt, made it difficult to follow what you or they were saying.
I usually struggle with that, but as it was just Aaron, without someone else then adding on and causing back and forth, I was alright this time.
I did end up placing a piece of cardboard over the subtitles though. I can't cope with subtitles for English.
Greens won hands down 🌿first answer = first applause & Ramsey was good at addressing question authentically. He even kept Bruce's nit-picking on track to broader national relevance. Was much more in tune with what people care about. Food security, warmer homes, cheaper energy, infrastructure, realistic affordability etc. Farage wasted too much time defended himself and his new political company, harking back to bygone era and the usually othering of pointing the blame elsewhere. He even blamed the NHS for medical shortages & not Brexit. Unlike Reform, the Green have been steadily building base over a number of years.
No NHS dentist in where i live in Norfolk cant find one in or around Norwich. The bus service is diabolical. Infrequent, limited routes, don't run late, regularly services are cut out and the buses are second hand, decrepit and routinely break down. The railway station was closed in the 1960s.
I thought Adrian Richards gradually improved, he came across too nervous initially. Considering he would have had considerably less TV experience than Farage, he was okay.
Actors can't be racists, can they Lawrence? Moreover, Farage and Tice are VERY litigious, do you really think if Farage etc thought for one second that they'd been setup that they wouldn't sue?
If you cant pause to interject could you put the subtitles on the bbc feed so we dont miss anything - i really like the commentary but cant be arsed to watch these twice if i miss something
I really hate subtitles.
Just as I can't process a voice, if I can clearly hear two, I also can't read and listen at the same time and I can't avoid reading subtitles for some reason.
Can never please everyone.
how biased this presenter is... unfeckingbeliveble!
He's right about nuclear energy.m give him that much
Biggest winner was Nigel Farage.
No its not
Not at all he wasn’t as high energy as he normally is
What is a rightoid doing watching novara?
Why? He’s got no policies and no way of paying for his BS ideas!🤡
@@orionnebula1136Being a Nause
Why is Fiona just interuptting the Green guy, what an idiotic host
Great work from the green candidate, he's almost as good as Aaron.
😂😂😂 Just wow
😂😂😂😂 Just wow
Yes, I think he speaks quite well, and is honest about what we need to do in order to improve services, etc….. whereas the main leaders just HIDE from the reality of it all.
I live in an area that is 99'9% white British. My wife had to attend the nearest hospital (Furness General) for emergency treatment. The ambulance waiting time was estimated to be 3 hours so I took my wife in our car. Every one of the 7 different medical personnel that my wife had been treated and received advice from was dark-skinned and English was not their first language. Each one of those individuals provided a very caring and professional service. I can't imagine what state the NHS in that hospital would be in without those particular migrants.
Yeah cheaper to import them than train out own people bollox
Nobody is asking for those migrants to disappear. If every migrant was an NHS doctor or nurse then we wouldn't have a waiting list problem, would we? Those vacancies aren't available, nor is there accommodation enough to house an additional 1.2 million people per year. Immigration at *this* scale is unsustainable. That's the argument. It's a matter of scale.
When you have 10 loaves of bread for 10 people you get peace. When you have 20 people fighting over 10 loaves of bread you get anarchy. We may need more foreign doctors soon.
Isn't it rather colonial to take the best qualified from poorer countries instead of training our own? Then we can send ours out to do charitable medicine in third world countries so they can feel good about themselves.
We need nurses and doctors so we should have an open door immigration policy for deliveroo drivers. Makes perfect sense.
The greens seem to be the party of common sense and I hope they get more seats in parliament
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂 fool
Electric cars will not be cheaper than ice cars .show me your evidence .regards
Many planted actors
That’s just silly. Why would they do that..
Well done Nigel, vote reform. Another bbc hit job
It’s always someone else’s fault
I Agree Nigel never got one clap in the So called BBC debate. Well thats ok ,all that does is show how biased and ignorant they are to Nigel Farage REFORM which inturn makes us want to VOTE REFORM even more. As for the audience well ..... I think they were on another planet, i felt sheer embarrassment by them for their calculated ignorance. Wouldnt want them standing beside you going into battle. VOTE REFORM FOR POSITIVE CHANGE!
Well said
They were obviously selected before being put there.
@@sparrow_6177of course the BBC are part of the establishment and they would not want to have someone like Farage getting lots of claps and support on tv it would destabilise their cushty number
Where does the BBC find those ill-informed weirdos. You ask questions and debate, not slander with hate. BBC would have been better off accepting a random audience, first in, first served.
I’m sick and tired of hearing poli saying that we are more likely to be treated by immigrants working in the nhs than meeting them in the queue for services. The whole world is experiencing a shortage of health care workers and we need to stop this continual poaching from each other which is out of control. What NEVER seems to get to considered is that not all overseas health qualifications are actually comparable. Competencies need careful cross referencing with uk equivalent to ensure standards are met. The standards are different countries. Given that it’s not essential to have any qualifications to work in social care and training is up the employer the sit-ups ares the life out of me. There is high incidence of abuse in both aged care and disability . The elderly and people with disabilities deserve to be supported by workers with the relevant skills and knowledge which are completely underestimated especially given people are living with more complex conditions and needs.
A number you will never see. How much the NHS pays out in medical negligence commited by foreign Doctors.
@@StoatLoxley I hear you. Funny how that never gets a mention. Now retired I was a RGN on 2 registers having trained in the nhs. Sadly I have saved more than a few doctors bacon , all were overseas qualified. At the same overseas qualified nurses are the same. While many are competent there are just as many whose demonstration of duty of care is questionable. Sad but true and scary.
Oops I posted this without checking. I meant to say the situation in social care scares the life out of me mainly because of lack of relevant and quality training.
And yet its TRUE. What you FAIL to mention though through your frothing cakehole is why the sixth richest nation on earth cant train and pay our own people to become Doctors/Nurses…… Thats the REAL crime.
The money exists in this country, or rather the Crown dependencies where they’ve locked it up, we just need to tax it correctly and scale all taxes and services according to requirements, all else is simply BS and degradation of our quality of life.
Plus the language barrier. People are dying. One person died as someone on the emergency line couldn't understand the caller saying they were not breathing. It's a crime what concessive governments have done to us.
Fiona Bruce the Tory girl!
The guy is an actor and was using a fake voice , so why ? Seems very odd
Why is this comment section full of right wing racists? I thought Novara was a left wing platform?
It's almost as thought things aren't as black-and-white as a fringe-outlet like this one claims.
Bots and reform ltd activists are spamming the comments of every single video that features 'ol snake oil and his party.
At least you can be confident Novara are not moderating their comments and only allowing opinions aligned with their own - unlike some...
Aaron this has to be the funniest show I've ever witnessed on your channel.
This clown Adrian Ramsay first claimed he didnt have an electric car as when he bought his "council house" £240, 000 they didnt have a home EV charger, you can charge your car at work and where he works I'm betting my bottom dollar they have EV chargers in Paiament Sq or just off it, he then tried to imlply "poor me , I had to "buy my council house" well so do thousands of others but they dont try to use it as a political statement if they had a IQ in double figures, then you defended China on CO2 omissions claiming its the wests fault for giving them so much work to do, you literally couldnt make this up, keep this coming Aaron it really is good tv.
It's not a theory.
Nigel CAN answer anything thrown at him...
But won't.
@@pauln6803
He does, but trust the more tribal party to ruffle its feathers over anything he says.
Yes we all know what a CON - tract is.
Can't deliver if he's not in power and in opposition. This contract is about the election in 2029, when you've had enough of 5 years of Labour.
It’s so funny, every time Nigel is on a panel it’s very clear that the audience have been carefully selected to hold intense animosity towards him, yet he very calmly brushes off their attacks and dismantles their “gotchas” - Nigel is a very intelligent man you love him or loathe home, his ability as an orator and debater is second to none. Why else do you think he’s the most popular British politician of the 21st century by a long shot?
Bruce needs to go she should be sacked.
Interfering while farage spoke and found it funny while the racist accusing audience asked questions.they certainly were not a mixed audience.i will vote reform.bruce wont sway that.
Adrian Ramsay answered questions and responded thoughtfully and intellectually. Farage simply tried to talk all over people and blew a lot of hot air
Long serving nurses on band6 with overtime may be higher rate tax payers. Aron
I dont really understand your love for chinese auto industry, its a joke, the electronic cars are dreg cars. Brittle and often malfunctioning. i do not want them on british roads, far too likely to cause hazards.
You want to get rid of Trident, our only big stick in a time of heightened international tension. Sorry Aaron but that's such a dumb take it's hard to take you seriously after that.
Arron your comments on electric cars are nonsense. They will never be cheaper, electric cars will cost more and the investment in the national grid will be crippling.
I'd like to see how they're going to cope with a totality of electric cars AND the base power needed for AI.
Not entirely sure what point you were trying to make when farage was talking about getting migration back to how it used to be and you said he's only been in politics since the late 90's. What relevance does the time he's been in politics have to do with commenting on taking it back to how it used to be?
It was pretty simple, mate. He said that Farage has been saying "we need to get back to how we used to be" ever since the late 90s. When exactly is he referring to when he says "like it used to be"?
It is obvious to be fair.
What's the point of a far left organisation like yours 'reacting' to this. We don't even need to watch it to understand what stance you will have on it!
BBC 😂😂
Am glad I don't have a BBC licence since 1993
Peaceful ❤
Unbelievable BBC still here 2024
Shame the greens weren’t given the chance to talk more about health and social care. Adrian did a reasonable job, could do with a bit more zippy concise reposes and quick responses on the “always asked” questions & green put downs,. He generally successfully managed to put across a positive vision.
Your comment about Nigel farage saying he does not want to let people in, in answer to someone asking for asylum is very misleading. Nigel Farage has said many times that he want to reduce legal migration for long enough to let our infrastructure catch up. His actual answer was he wanted to be treated the same as 500,000 people have been treated in recent years that have applied for asylum the lawful way and been accepted. People crossing the sea in boats throwing away their papers and anything to identify them simply put is not legal migration or a lawful attempt to seek asylum.
Spot on but they forget to mention THAT part of migration what with it being 'illegal' and all.
Are you slow? The conservatives have made it so there aren’t any legal routes to claim asylum
@@fs6688
I'm sorry, I didn't know Farage was still a conservative.
@@WAEVOICEReform UK are the only Conservative party standing in the next election!
That was the most biased audience that I’ve ever seen, shame on the bbc.
Where is the workers party
Not relevant enough
Way too much truth for the BBC.
They don't even poll regularly at 1% so don't justify a place here at that level of support.
Fiona’s Questions Time
BBCQT Special "Ask Fiona Bruce her opinionated and bigoted views."
If work is so good for you, why are most people on benefits IN-WORK?
More plants in this audience than in the Amazon rainforest.
Did he really say "get back our own sovereignty" AGAIN?? I thought we already had.
I retired early after many years of ill health, I have no intention of becoming economically active for Fartgarbage or Sunak. Retirement has improved my health immensely, I've never been happier.
Fasinating that they put Farage the idiot last, as he will then be most rememebered
Well done Nigel . People should vote even more for Reform now after that so bias program . Makes me voting for Reform even more justified. He does not duck questions like the main parties. Hes passionate about is country and tells it as it is truthfully
biased audience, biased youtube channel
Now I know what it must be like for e primary school teacher trying to tell toddlers why they shouldn't stick their fingers in a plug socket. That audience was unteachable, stuck in their mindset. Shame, they are losing out.
Aaron, quite annoying you speaking over the commentary with your bias smug comments.
Won't be watching your material again.
Let the viewer decide, not you trying to influence the viewer. It insults our intelligence.
Why come on this platform then? Just watch the actual BBC broadcast
Great idea. UK navy head to head against a fellow NATO navy in the French. We couldn't win in a cod wars years ago. Nonsensical.
So what just be pushovers and accept it?
What are you laughing at IMMIGRANT?
QT socialist audience?
NF is NF
re trident - the idea that China doesn't know where those submarines is ludicrous due to a combination of intelligence, habits and likelihood of locations, and modern satellite surveillance. Plus they are like bringing a pea shooter to a gunfight.
If you're that keen on Trident, stick it in a waterway in england, rather than next to Scotland's second largest city? Don't fancy it sitting in the Thames? Nah, thought not.
Another hand picked audience with irrelevant questions!
I hear Birmingham is quite a diverse place. Maybe not the best place for Fürage.
Hahah Typical Reform Reichman popping up
@@alex_n8863 Shows how brave he is!
@@harrynewman211 Proud of it!
Farage got some tough questions today. Quite right.
About time, the media have softsoaped him for months until he announced he was standing. Only right and proper he now receives the same grilling as other leaders. Given that some of his views are so extreme, its inevitable his drones feel he’s being singled out.
No question is too tough for Farage. He's brilliant. Go and watch some of his speeches during his campaign. Terrific
@@jackieisseri2967 😂😂😂🤡😂😂😂
@@jackieisseri2967
You mean no question is too tough for Farage to dodge or twist the truth with his answer.
Someone needs to ask him about his video claiming he might have to leave the UK due to being unable to access banking services, despite the fact that he'd only fallen below the minimum threshold (£3 million?) for banking with Coutts and had been offered another account within the NatWest group due to it being illegal to refuse basic banking services to UK citizens.
Go and watch some of his speeches. I'm serious. He is absolutely brilliant. We want our country back evem if you don't.
Another biased audience. Got to say nigel is handling this very well. Vote Reform
Yeah, if you’re delusional
Every audience is biased, and what would the point be of having audience members that are already planning to vote Reform?
@@joellemm9229 seems like a lot of effort is made to discredit Reform and Nigel
@@stevemills2941 He wasn't the only aspiring MP being questioned on that stage. A lot of effort is made to discredit every political party. Journalism's purpose is to question those that might otherwise abuse power. It benefits potential Reform voters too, because each question forces answers that they'll surely want to hear, rather than blindly following the words of man whose only intention is to convince. If those questions are answered ineffectually, or Reform is in fact discredited, then it's proven they're not worth voting for.
@@joellemm9229
Being questioned wasn't the only thing happening to Farage; he was and continues to be smeared.
Awesome watch 👍
Do your research. There is plenty of proof stacked up that the guy was an actor, was paid by a production company and Channel 4 just 'happened' to be there. Go and look at what Mayhar Tousi and others are saying about it.
Not proof at all. Proof is a receipt- suspicion is not proof.
Regardless, his staffer from ukip days in his inner circle was featured- the actor nonsense is a distraction he’s using as his normal manipulative way, to add smoke and mirrors.
Like Mayhar Tousi is to be taken as gospel!
🤣🤣
Go and look at the actor's website then. Andrew Parker.
Disgusting show, all the questions attacking Farage as a person, yet not interested in the Polices of Reform UK. Typical hand picked BBC audience, this can only
make more people vote for Reform UK, Bruce was shameful. People have had enough of listening to this rubbish over the last couple of decades.
LOL crying because he’s being scrutinised is pathetic
I think the sort of person we have in charge of running the country is rather important. The fact that we are even questioning it speaks volumes
Wow changed my mind about greens vision
which way?
@@autumn4142 think is good
@@dudley0007 yeah they’re pretty good
he uis a grofter i i i i i was was was the first 1 bog off farage
I can tell that Farage getting affected by this questioning.
In turn, his responses are affecting the audience.
Vote Reform!
Farage triggers my gag reflex
He must have a large appendage then
@@tezkennedy132 Disgusting
@@orionnebula1136
Hey, you sent the invitation.
What does Farage mean by ‘friendly countries ‚
Let’s hear the answers stop chirping in why he’s talking
Why did you watch this and not the BBC broadcast then?