I love Home Free and totally respect your opinion. For me this song has never been one of my favorites. I did love Micahel Bolton and this song always makes me think of him., but it never made my Playlist until Home Free did this version. I could take or leave the song, but HF made me love something about it. I think their complimentary, no showboating way of singing a song is something I will always appreciate. Music doesn't always need vocal tricks, a lot of the time just a straight forward heartfelt, clean, passionate song is enough. That's what this is for me. Thank you for respectfully voicing your opinion.
That makes a lot of sense actually and I’m so glad you commented. Thank you for allowing me the space to share my feelings and for so respectfully expressing yours! It means so much especially on this platform. I LOVED their version of “man of constant sorrow” and I agree with you. Sometimes straight fwd and clean showcases aspects of a song and the beauty of it in a new way. No vocal tricks (tho his ability to sing so high and his runs are impressive), just heartfelt and clean. You said that well. That actually gives me a new perspective toward the song. Thank you, April. ❤️
I'm pretty sure this song was by Percy Sledge back in 1966....As far as bringing in the other members, on this song, I really can't see where they'd fit in.... Back to your preference for bassist, (my weakness too)....You'll get an earful in their cover of Dire Straits "Brothers in Arms"...a song in tribute to fallen soldiers.... For pure harmonies, it's a tough call but the cover of "Helplessly Hoping" orig by Crosby, Stills & Nash is ear candy....For pure fun, check on the "Butts Medley/Remix"....5 or 6 songs featuring the backside...(and you'll note, they NEVER feature a females butt in the video as they didn't want to objectify the female half of the planet)... Most Home Fries will give ya dozens of selections by this versatile group but most will suggest you hold off on a reaction to "Mayday" until you become completely familiar with each member and their typical lanes. Oh, I subbed due to this review...Good job..
I agree. This is a clean, purely passionate song sung purely and passionately. Listening to it, I can feel the intensity of the love the song describes.
You are entitled to your opinion and people like what they like. Congratulations. You are the first person I've ever seen react to this that wasn't completely blown away. My opinion. It's a gorgeously crafted song.
This is one of the few songs where one person sings the lead for the whole song. If you like bass, please listen to their version of Brothers In Arms. Other recent songs are Amazed, God Bless The Broken Road, The Driver, One Man Band. All of these songs the lead is done by more than one person.
@@rosalieelliottofficial I would second the Brothers In Arms recommendation. After you've become acquainted with all the different singers check out their cover of Mayday by country artist Cam. They will definitely surprise you with their versatility.
THIS IS A DEPARTURE for two reasons .... COVID made the pictorial segments and AN INSISTENT TIM FOUST .... always wanted to Hear Austin go off on this classic - AND FOR THE RECORD DONE AS ORIGINATED, DONE BETTER and that is syaing Something !!! Appreciate your opinion so very spot on. GBjj
Austin did a fabulous job of this classic song. Loved Percy Sledge's version, but this was taken to another level. I think it is also better than Michael Bolton's version. And remember this was done during quarantine, so the guys weren't even together. The backing harmonies are great, along with Tim's bass. And Adam's vocal percussion is outstanding. This is why these guys are my favorite a cappella group. I have watched hundreds of reactors to this song & most are blown away by this version. You are the first one ever who didn't care for it, but you are entitled to your opinion. For songs that are bass heavy where Tim Foust leads, check out "Brothers In Arms", "In The Blood", "What We Ain't Got", "Hillbilly Bone", "Misty Mountains" with Peter Hollens.
Your initial reaction is what you felt at the time. Respect for not just dishing all dessert to the fans. I think if you had seen half a dozen more of their songs before this one you might have felt differently. This is a single thread in the tapestry of their catalog and not to be overlooked: done in a pandemic lockdown where they could not all perform together in the same place.. They share lead roles in a ton of their songs.
Take Me Home,Country Roads has a fabulous rich sound in which there are different leads. I have never been a fan of this song, but Austin does really well with it. More than the song itself, what amazes me is how they did this during the quarantine. They were creative during that time with their videos. I think they released a new video every two weeks ( or something like that).
Their bass singer Tim Foust did a collaboration with fellow Acapella singer Peter Hollens on... "Misty Mountains", a song from the Hobbit Movie of The Lord Of The Rings. Just the two of them, but Peter is the master of layering voices so they sound more like a choir. Tim also gets in lots of bass notes! This is epic!
The part where it sounds like a Gregorian chant gives me chills every time. That and Tim's voice joining Peter's. Even when I expect it...chills every time.
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Sometimes "simple" emphasizes quality, which is what I think of this song. "Bells and whistles" aren't always necessary; paying homage to the original is a valid creative choice too. And their efforts to continuously put out videos for their fans throughout the pandemic and lockdown (thus the simplicity and separation in this one) speaks to the kind of people they are--yet another reason they are dearly loved by the Home Fries! 🏠 🍟 🥰
Everyone has their own opinion, and I respect that. But this is my favorite version of this song. They have many many song where you will hear that bass that you prefer. Thanks for the reaction, even though we dont agree. I have always loved a tenor with power and seeing him on stage is an experience you will never forget.
The critique is valid. Of course, in their catalog as a whole, everybody gets a turn. Some songs center on just one person, some spread the wealth around. This is one of many vids they did during COVID shutdown. They recorded their vocals in their separate homes, then someone did the final audio mix, and then they all mimed their parts on camera, again in their separate homes. In some of those vids, such as The Gambler, they created an illusion that they were all together in one room. Others, they did not.
When I first heard this song was going to be covered by HOME FREE, I knew it was going to be my favorite version. Everytime Austin looks into the camera, I smile and wink lol
I believe this song was made in the middle of covid isolation at the time hence the separation and complications of singing together and every now and then it's nice to hear a solo, to highlight individuals importance. The high range I agree with only because I'm jealous and never going to hit those high notes😂 and only a very few could sing this in that key range.
Home Free is the "BOMB!!!" I too love A Capella...With that said and with all due respect to all of the other great A Capella groups out there, Home Free (both individually & collectively) is the most versatile Vocal Band on the planet!!! Mic Drop!!! 🎤
This was recorded during a time of covid restrictions. Most of the members were recording their parts from home studios and they live in at least three different states. The recording was done online and I think it's amazing that they were able to get a video out at all.
Hi Rosalie. It would have been interesting to see how your reaction would have gone if you had heard this much later in your HF journey. This is my favourite rendition of this song. I got really tired of listening to this song after the movie came out. It wasn't until Austin sang it that I was able to appreciate the belting AND follow every word of the story. I may be biased, but I feel that Home Free has the best diction in the industry. Another no frills performance that turned me into a fan is HF HOW GREAT THOU ART. Looking forward to your next HF reaction.
That’s a very valid point. Perhaps it would’ve felt different if I listened later on after hearing more of their work. I still want to hear how great thou art for sure. I love that song. Thank you for commenting :-)
@@rosalieelliottofficial Definitely review "How Great Thou Art." Not only is their harmony outstanding, but it was filmed in the Swiss Alps, so the setting is breathtaking.
@@rosalieelliottofficial Another couple of great faith songs (even though they are "Christmas" dongs are O Holy Night, Do You Hear What I Hear, and Mary Did You Know. They have such a wide collection of videos out there that they really do have something for just about everyone.
Love your reaction! Subjectivity is one of the many traits each of us have and to be credible, one need not be afraid to express such inherent feelings, especially for a music reactor such as yourself. Totally respect your comments.
Hearing your original history with a cappella music I highly recommend Home Free's cover of a song called Brother by a comtemporary christian group called needtobreathe (i think). Be prepared to be amazed by the wonderful music and to laugh to tears from their acting/storyline. (Note: the lead singer here is the elf in that video and the warrior lady is his actual girlfriend and partner. Also, she's in the sudio with him here; that's who he's looking at.)
No backlash. I think you hit on a lot of how I feel about this song AND what I think helps Home Free stand out (in an interesting way). Many of the other a cappella groups tend to lean on their vocalists and use a little shock value to sell their performance. Home Free tends to lean into the actual song. Some of their arraignments, because of this, can end up sounding a bit simple or straightforward (as you commented about this one). All I'd say about that is that they, to me, end up with more of a song one might hear on the radio than a nice group of singers. That also means that the different aspects of the group can almost disappear into a sort of background sound (especially the bass) and it really takes me a little extra concentration to hear the amazing bas lines that are building the extremely solid foundation. As for this song, I've always liked it but never been blown away by it, no matter who has sung it. That said, the props I will give to home free (and it goes for many of their covers/songs) is that they are all so crystal clear that I hear lyrics that I've never caught before. This song is no different. I always consider this a sappy love song, but if you listen to the lyrics it is a song about the darker side of love and how true love is walking that edge between oneself and another person. If the love received is not on the same level, it can become terribly destructive (ignoring friends, holding on by going bankrupt, giving up everything just to keep that person around). I'll let you know that Home Free switches up their lead very often. They approach it as trying to find the best voice to fit their vision for the song but sometimes it ends up being who arrived at the studio first that day .
Your comment is outstanding!! Thank you so much for taking the time to share. I’m learning and find what you said interesting. The part about who comes to the studio first, had me smiling. You make a lot of good points tho! Sometimes straight fwd really does showcase lyrics better and I love good lyrics. Your interpretation and thoughts on the meaning of the song is also very well said and true! Thank you very much for commenting
@@rosalieelliottofficial You should never worry about expressing your true impressions of anything you react to. It is an essential part of reacting and not just being a semi promoter. That said while I am a HF fan and consider myself a "Home Fry" I am also a fan of another a capella group that I would love to see you react to, Pentatonix. They are also a 5 member group and won the same TV show as HF on the previous season. In fact, it is their success and thrice Grammy Award-winning subsequent career that has prompted the rise of popularity of the art form. Pentatonix, or PTX for short, are more pop/R&B/soul oriented though like HF they do explore a wide variety of genres, especially known for their incredible Christmas catalog. THey have an 11 year, 200+ song catalog of both covers, affectionately referred to as "upgrades" by the Pentaholics, that provide a very diverse range of options. Being a dedicated fan of both groups I guess makes me a Pentafry.
Some of their arraignments? My gosh, was this performance so bad that they were arrested? LOLOL That's okay, we know what you meant, but I did have a big laugh at this word being used. In fact, your comments are extremely insightful.
Rosalie, yes I agree there are songs where a lower lead voice that resonates would be the perfect fit. This arrangement however, needed the higher lead vocals for clarity and as a distinct contrast to the bass and harmony vocals, which were perfectly together and smooth. The lead singer's voice was clear and delivered with full on emotion. You couldn't take anything away and that's the magic of great musicians and their arrangements. Everything they did "added." Home Free raised the bar with this cover. Exceptional.
This was done during quarantine. They were all in different places. The production was awesome. You need to listen to mor of their songs They all take turns doing the leads in in other songs they do.. They are awesome. Love your reaction.
You need to try VoicePlay next, to complete the “trifecta” of current A Capella groups. Pentatonix are the classic version, Home Free the country/folk version, and VoicePlay are the “theater” group. Each has their own unique style
The original recording sung by the great Percy Sledge was sung in a high tenor, as well as Michal Bolton's cover was sung in a high tenor, although he has a raspier voice. I know of no versions where multiple voices took the lead on this song. HF's version stayed true to the both the original and Michael Bolton's cover of having a single lead. Many, if no most of HF's songs feature multiple performances by the band members, but this particular song really does not call for it. Sorry to disagree with your take. Btw, after viewing dozens of female reactors to this video, you are the only one that did not clearly like this performance by Austin.
it's ok you disagree :) respectful dialogue and various perspectives and opinions is what makes for the opportunity to grow and learn. It's very valid that too many voices leading would not necessarily work for this song. Something I didn't consider. :) I guess I am not like other women ;) Nonetheless I would like to reiterate, they did do a good job, and it's valid most covers are probably sung higher anyways, but it just did not blow me away. The beauty of music is it will touch different people in different ways. I have a feeling the next HF video I watch will be right up my alley :)
Thank you sir ! I was actually ticked off that this foolish woman thought herself a critic and justified to deny THE BEST HIGH TENOR I EVER HEARD .... and I sang back when this was new - Percy did it this way .... and I did as close as I could .... but, NOT LIKE THIS !!! Great version, best ever ! GBjj
I believe this was also a Covid-19 release which is why they are all separated on their own tv. They had to send the recordings back and forth to do this. I think another one was their Sea Shanty video where they were still separated by the pandemic. Love this version and love this song. It’s almost always great to hear old songs either freshened up or simply sung again by current artists. Pentatonix has many songs that feature just one singer also. Could easily tell you weren’t to impressed but not all songs are gonna be the most amazing song we’ve ever heard. There are many songs by my favorite artists that I don’t really care for. It just makes the ones that hit it out of the park that much better.
You are someone with music knowledge,most people that love music don't have your kind of knowledge about music and in my opinion that is where the beauty lies,they say beauty is in the eye of the beholder and I think the same is true for the ear and since I can't hear all the faults or hear how it could be better I just enjoy it.
thank you for sharing your thoughts. to me it's not either or, but both, and. Both knowledge and preference can work together. there is a lot I don't know, but those with knowledge and those without are allowed to prefer one style over another in my opinion. yes, sometimes it helps knowing less and looking at things from a simple point of view (so i think that's an interesting point on your part), but I don't think I dove deep into music here, but more so expressed a personal preference (i.e. my thoughts as a beholder :) ) what is more interesting to me is how some (not saying you did), got so defensive in regards to my personal preferences that they attack, as if their identity is so closely tied to this song/singer and to others opinions thereof. quite interesting how humans operate :) I think it's nice you are able to enjoy the music :)
Austin and Adam (beatboxer) did a great job. He really has a great singing voice. This was during Covid so they weren’t even together. I thought the use of tv’s was clever. I respect your opinion. If you like bass try Brothers in Arms, I Can’t Outrun You, In the Blood, Hillbilly Bone, Helplessly Hoping to hear more incredible bass and harmonies.
You will find they vary a lot as to whether they allow one or two members to carry the song to up through four and occasionally five (although the songs where Adam Rupp: Vocal Percussionist has significant singing lines are rare). One of the things many enjoy about them is the variety in their arrangements.
According to Percy Sledge, the original and the songwriter, the inspiration for the song came when his girlfriend left him for a modelling career after he was laid off from a construction job in late 1965. Released in 1966
I appreciated your honest reaction. The Home Fries (me included) are pretty passionate about these guys, but reactors who bob their heads and say nothing are boring :) I think Austin did a great job, but this isn't one that calls me back often. Some of those are Take Me Home Country Roads, Colder Weather, In the Blood, Woman, Amen/Female . . there are many! Sold! is amazing too, and Tim's bass is mind blowing :) It's a rewarding journey!
Finally someone who recommends Woman Amen/Female. IMHO, one of their most underrated songs. I agree, those who really react like The Charismatic Voice get the best responses and HF actually does interviews with them and sends personal messages.
It was originally sung by Percy Sledge. His girlfriend had just broken up with him and he walked on stage, told his band to play some music and he sang this.
I grew up with the Percy Sledge version, and that's still my favorite. Anything else just feels like an imitation, no matter the vocal extremes the covers work in that maybe Percy couldn't have done. But I believe that this is one of the quarantine productions, each recording their own part at home. I appreciate the effort required, and the quality of the result. Home free has many videos that will make you think, and maybe bring a tear to your eye. But this wasn't one of them.
I felt the same way about this being an Austin Brown feat. Home Free song. I do think some of this was because it was they put together in isolation. Each part was recorded separately. It was also a love song from Austin to his gf... so there is that. Lol. If you want to hear pure a cappella from HomeFree you should listen to Helplessly Hoping. If you need some bass... and want to hear something different... check out Peter Hollens and Tim Foust doing "Misty Mountains" from the Hobbit.
You might as well add Voice Play to your playlist, as I believe they were runners up to Home Free on Sing-Off Season 4. Their latest two covers of "Enemy" and "Running Up That Hill" are outstanding.
Great reaction ! I love these guys ! Please be aware that the first two songs that you chose feature Austin Brown in the lead - this is not the case for the majority of their work. You should check more of their catalog. I would suggest 'Brothers in Arms', 'In the Blood', 'End of the Road'. You will be pleased with what you find.
I totally accept your opinion of this song. We all have our personal preferences. This is one of the few songs of this group where one vocalist is showcased thru the whole song. Although you perhaps were not totally thrilled with this one song please don't stop reviewing them. They have a very large variety of music and I'm sure that you'll find other songs that you do like. Cheers!
Thank you for allowing me to speak freely and for your comment :-) I definitely will not stop listening to them because I do like what I am hearing and I’m excited to explore more. Stay tuned for more
Try Ring of Fire, Folsom Prison Blues, I Can’t Outrun You, Brothers in Arms, Folsom Prison Blues, Hillbilly Bone, Champagne Taste on a Beer Budget for more bass. HF usually features multiple leads on each song.
Home Free is my favorite vocal band, tho I do really like the others. They make a wide range of songs and different people like different songs of theirs more than others. I tend to fall into moods and like to listen to different leads. I think Austin is an amazing singer. His voice is just golden. But each of the members of Home Free and great in their own right. Rob has a real soulful voice and when he does "Go Rest High On That Mountain" is can make you cry. Chance singing "Cover Me Up" just moves me a lot. Tim, the bass, well, I have so many of his leads I love. "Brothers in Arms" or "Ring of Fire" shows a good depth of his voice. And Adam Rupp's drum solo's will get you dancing. So, I do understand your opinion, and it is valid. Music is one of those things like wine, not everyone likes the expensive stuff, sometimes the lower shelf stuff just has better flavor. (the wine thing is because of a disagreement a friend of mine had with me about corked wine vs twist top. I liked the twist top flavor better) For more bassy sound, I'd try, "Ring of Fire" or "Brothers in Arms" those are two popular bass songs they have. Keep up the good work!
"This song is timeless, it came before me, and will be here long after I am gone, we men, love you, get that through your thick heads ladies". Qoute by Michael the Archangel #BookofMichael #Bookofnow #Bookoflife
Most reactors to this song noticed the way Austin was singing with such passion ...like he was singing into the eyes of the woman he loves...well he was....his girlfriend was standing right beside the camera...this version would have lost something if they were switching leads like the usually do..My opinion , some songs are meant to be sung by one I think this was one of them. Listen to " How great thou art" let's you hear all of them sing even the beat boxer. Most of there songs have multiple leads.
I love Home Frees rendition of this song, i love Boltons as well. But I like that they give everyone a chance to shine in a solo song once in a while. I feel like it keeps tension from building in a group if there is respect and freedom to do things like this. Too many times we see big groups like this fall apart cause there is too many egos or tension. This group has been together a long time and probably will for years to come. They are more than a band they are great friends that let each other do solo pieces or have a say in what they do. And that is part of what I like about them. When I watch them i get the feeling like they are just a bunch of buddies having a great time that are very talented. But that is just my opinion so take what you want from it. Thank you.
Especially such a slow paced piece is suitable to show off their marvelous teamwork and skills. Everyone knows, that a glitch will be heard and judged, and yet they perform ever so very well together. Lots of songs they did featured one or two of them alone, then somtimes each of them gets a turn, there is just no designated leader, Austin is technically an amazing singer, not every cover shows that off as much as this one. "End Of The Road" features Rob the most, "Mayday" must get counted out of this for mostly showing off Tims highest range while Adam Chance pulls an incredibly sturdy and powerful bass. Just do not judge "When A Man Loves A Woman" too simple, compare this a cappella approach of five men to a singer with just his effort supported by numerous instruments and it is apples and oranges. Wow, just check out THIS ORANGES!
Please remember, this was done during quarantine,, so they were all at their own homes. They kept a lot of us sane by putting out a new song every other Friday!!
Rosalie, I just discovered this. I think you will find that as long as you are being respectful (like you were here), Homefries will respect your opinion and listen to what you say. My favorite thing about Home Free is that they seem to have no ego's. I love that they take their music seriously, but not themselves. If you continue to approach them with an open mind, you will be blown away by their versatility and their range (and their sense of humor).
Listen to the key change section of the song again. Start a couple bars before the switch. Pay attention to the beat box. Now, please someone explain to me how a human voice can do that up trill that sounds like a sci-fi special effect.
You have a lot to learn. Kudos for your honesty, and everyone is entitled to their opinions - but with only two Home Free songs that you have heard, your perspective will grow if you let it. This one was a showcase for Austin, yes - but sometimes bands do that. Try "Brothers in Arms" or "Everybody Walkin' This Land" if you like bass.
If you'd like to check out the range of music they cover check out the Butts Remix, Country Fried Pop Medley and All About That Bass!! Tim Foust is an amazing bass! For a shock check out him and Austin singing My Maria then Tim's cover of Will You Still Love Me/Stay!!!
I love Home Free and totally respect your opinion. For me this song has never been one of my favorites. I did love Micahel Bolton and this song always makes me think of him., but it never made my Playlist until Home Free did this version. I could take or leave the song, but HF made me love something about it. I think their complimentary, no showboating way of singing a song is something I will always appreciate. Music doesn't always need vocal tricks, a lot of the time just a straight forward heartfelt, clean, passionate song is enough. That's what this is for me. Thank you for respectfully voicing your opinion.
That makes a lot of sense actually and I’m so glad you commented. Thank you for allowing me the space to share my feelings and for so respectfully expressing yours! It means so much especially on this platform. I LOVED their version of “man of constant sorrow” and I agree with you. Sometimes straight fwd and clean showcases aspects of a song and the beauty of it in a new way. No vocal tricks (tho his ability to sing so high and his runs are impressive), just heartfelt and clean. You said that well. That actually gives me a new perspective toward the song. Thank you, April. ❤️
💯💯
I loved it I prefer this version
I'm pretty sure this song was by Percy Sledge back in 1966....As far as bringing in the other members, on this song, I really can't see where they'd fit in....
Back to your preference for bassist, (my weakness too)....You'll get an earful in their cover of Dire Straits "Brothers in Arms"...a song in tribute to fallen soldiers....
For pure harmonies, it's a tough call but the cover of "Helplessly Hoping" orig by Crosby, Stills & Nash is ear candy....For pure fun, check on the "Butts Medley/Remix"....5 or 6 songs featuring the backside...(and you'll note, they NEVER feature a females butt in the video as they didn't want to objectify the female half of the planet)...
Most Home Fries will give ya dozens of selections by this versatile group but most will suggest you hold off on a reaction to "Mayday" until you become completely familiar with each member and their typical lanes.
Oh, I subbed due to this review...Good job..
I agree. This is a clean, purely passionate song sung purely and passionately. Listening to it, I can feel the intensity of the love the song describes.
You are entitled to your opinion and people like what they like. Congratulations. You are the first person I've ever seen react to this that wasn't completely blown away. My opinion. It's a gorgeously crafted song.
Ya shez an idiot
agreed :) everyone has a different taste. Your opinion is valid :)
This is the best version of this song. I love Michael Bolton version but this tops it. Adam the beatboxer was awesome and Austin killed this song 😍
This is one of the few songs where one person sings the lead for the whole song. If you like bass, please listen to their version of Brothers In Arms. Other recent songs are Amazed, God Bless The Broken Road, The Driver, One Man Band. All of these songs the lead is done by more than one person.
Brothers in arms is gonna be one of my next videos of theirs. Very intrigued even by the title alone. Thank you for the suggestions
@@rosalieelliottofficial I would second the Brothers In Arms recommendation. After you've become acquainted with all the different singers check out their cover of Mayday by country artist Cam. They will definitely surprise you with their versatility.
Agree… this is a powerful and moving song…. Cover of Dire Straits….. listen to theirs first for reference.
THIS IS A DEPARTURE for two reasons .... COVID made the pictorial segments and AN INSISTENT TIM FOUST .... always wanted to Hear Austin go off on this classic - AND FOR THE RECORD DONE AS ORIGINATED, DONE BETTER and that is syaing Something !!! Appreciate your opinion so very spot on. GBjj
Austin did a fabulous job of this classic song. Loved Percy Sledge's version, but this was taken to another level. I think it is also better than Michael Bolton's version. And remember this was done during quarantine, so the guys weren't even together. The backing harmonies are great, along with Tim's bass. And Adam's vocal percussion is outstanding. This is why these guys are my favorite a cappella group. I have watched hundreds of reactors to this song & most are blown away by this version. You are the first one ever who didn't care for it, but you are entitled to your opinion. For songs that are bass heavy where Tim Foust leads, check out "Brothers In Arms", "In The Blood", "What We Ain't Got", "Hillbilly Bone", "Misty Mountains" with Peter Hollens.
Exactly ! Thank You. GBjj
They have done many Christian songs too, their version of "How Great Thou Art" is a must!
They are simply the best
Your initial reaction is what you felt at the time. Respect for not just dishing all dessert to the fans. I think if you had seen half a dozen more of their songs before this one you might have felt differently. This is a single thread in the tapestry of their catalog and not to be overlooked: done in a pandemic lockdown where they could not all perform together in the same place.. They share lead roles in a ton of their songs.
Thank you :) good point. I’m excited to check out more.
Take Me Home,Country Roads has a fabulous rich sound in which there are different leads. I have never been a fan of this song, but Austin does really well with it. More than the song itself, what amazes me is how they did this during the quarantine. They were creative during that time with their videos. I think they released a new video every two weeks ( or something like that).
I have tickets to see “Home Free” on October 20. Can’t. Wait.
Nice. :) enjoy. I’m sure it’ll be wonderful
Beatboxer phenomenal on this track.
Their bass singer Tim Foust did a collaboration with fellow Acapella singer Peter Hollens on...
"Misty Mountains", a song from the Hobbit Movie of The Lord Of The Rings.
Just the two of them, but Peter is the master of layering voices so they sound more like a choir.
Tim also gets in lots of bass notes! This is epic!
If you wanna hear a low note, that definitely the song.
Sending her on a trip huh? That is definitely a good choice for her to critique. Lots of complexity, juxtaposition and straight up awesome layering.
The part where it sounds like a Gregorian chant gives me chills every time. That and Tim's voice joining Peter's. Even when I expect it...chills every time.
@@lisaseverance6785
Have you heard VoicePlay doing "The Dragonborn Comes"? Geoff hits some nice growls there.
@@bobr4987 yes I have and it's quite impressive.
great singing Austin.
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Sometimes "simple" emphasizes quality, which is what I think of this song. "Bells and whistles" aren't always necessary; paying homage to the original is a valid creative choice too.
And their efforts to continuously put out videos for their fans throughout the pandemic and lockdown (thus the simplicity and separation in this one) speaks to the kind of people they are--yet another reason they are dearly loved by the Home Fries! 🏠 🍟 🥰
Agreed :) and yes that’s wonderful. That they kept putting out music and working hard.
Everyone has their own opinion, and I respect that. But this is my favorite version of this song. They have many many song where you will hear that bass that you prefer. Thanks for the reaction, even though we dont agree. I have always loved a tenor with power and seeing him on stage is an experience you will never forget.
I can imagine it's a great experience in person. Your opinion is def. valid
The critique is valid. Of course, in their catalog as a whole, everybody gets a turn. Some songs center on just one person, some spread the wealth around.
This is one of many vids they did during COVID shutdown. They recorded their vocals in their separate homes, then someone did the final audio mix, and then they all mimed their parts on camera, again in their separate homes. In some of those vids, such as The Gambler, they created an illusion that they were all together in one room. Others, they did not.
Interesting. I didn’t know. That is impressive. They def sound wonderful nonetheless. Thank you for commenting :)
When I first heard this song was going to be covered by HOME FREE, I knew it was going to be my favorite version. Everytime Austin looks into the camera, I smile and wink lol
I believe this song was made in the middle of covid isolation at the time hence the separation and complications of singing together and every now and then it's nice to hear a solo, to highlight individuals importance. The high range I agree with only because I'm jealous and never going to hit those high notes😂 and only a very few could sing this in that key range.
Home Free is the "BOMB!!!" I too love A Capella...With that said and with all due respect to all of the other great A Capella groups out there, Home Free (both individually & collectively) is the most versatile Vocal Band on the planet!!! Mic Drop!!! 🎤
This was recorded during a time of covid restrictions. Most of the members were recording their parts from home studios and they live in at least three different states. The recording was done online and I think it's amazing that they were able to get a video out at all.
Hi Rosalie. It would have been interesting to see how your reaction would have gone if you had heard this much later in your HF journey. This is my favourite rendition of this song. I got really tired of listening to this song after the movie came out. It wasn't until Austin sang it that I was able to appreciate the belting AND follow every word of the story. I may be biased, but I feel that Home Free has the best diction in the industry. Another no frills performance that turned me into a fan is HF HOW GREAT THOU ART. Looking forward to your next HF reaction.
That’s a very valid point. Perhaps it would’ve felt different if I listened later on after hearing more of their work. I still want to hear how great thou art for sure. I love that song. Thank you for commenting :-)
@@rosalieelliottofficial Definitely review "How Great Thou Art." Not only is their harmony outstanding, but it was filmed in the Swiss Alps, so the setting is breathtaking.
@@rosalieelliottofficial Another couple of great faith songs (even though they are "Christmas" dongs are O Holy Night, Do You Hear What I Hear, and Mary Did You Know. They have such a wide collection of videos out there that they really do have something for just about everyone.
Love your reaction! Subjectivity is one of the many traits each of us have and to be credible, one need not be afraid to express such inherent feelings, especially for a music reactor such as yourself. Totally respect your comments.
Hearing your original history with a cappella music I highly recommend Home Free's cover of a song called Brother by a comtemporary christian group called needtobreathe (i think). Be prepared to be amazed by the wonderful music and to laugh to tears from their acting/storyline. (Note: the lead singer here is the elf in that video and the warrior lady is his actual girlfriend and partner. Also, she's in the sudio with him here; that's who he's looking at.)
thank you for the suggestion :)
adding it to my list and will look into it as I'm able to
You will be amazed when you hear their cover of How Great Thou Art.... A MUST listen to for one of their gospel songs....
looking fwd to listening to more
Love what they did with this. Can't wait for the next one. Thank you ^_^
This song was made for Austin. Love these guys. CK out Listen to the Music. CK out End of the Road.
Welcome to the rabbit hole. Enjoy the ride.
❤️❤️
No backlash. I think you hit on a lot of how I feel about this song AND what I think helps Home Free stand out (in an interesting way). Many of the other a cappella groups tend to lean on their vocalists and use a little shock value to sell their performance. Home Free tends to lean into the actual song. Some of their arraignments, because of this, can end up sounding a bit simple or straightforward (as you commented about this one). All I'd say about that is that they, to me, end up with more of a song one might hear on the radio than a nice group of singers. That also means that the different aspects of the group can almost disappear into a sort of background sound (especially the bass) and it really takes me a little extra concentration to hear the amazing bas lines that are building the extremely solid foundation.
As for this song, I've always liked it but never been blown away by it, no matter who has sung it. That said, the props I will give to home free (and it goes for many of their covers/songs) is that they are all so crystal clear that I hear lyrics that I've never caught before. This song is no different. I always consider this a sappy love song, but if you listen to the lyrics it is a song about the darker side of love and how true love is walking that edge between oneself and another person. If the love received is not on the same level, it can become terribly destructive (ignoring friends, holding on by going bankrupt, giving up everything just to keep that person around).
I'll let you know that Home Free switches up their lead very often. They approach it as trying to find the best voice to fit their vision for the song but sometimes it ends up being who arrived at the studio first that day .
Your comment is outstanding!! Thank you so much for taking the time to share. I’m learning and find what you said interesting. The part about who comes to the studio first, had me smiling. You make a lot of good points tho! Sometimes straight fwd really does showcase lyrics better and I love good lyrics. Your interpretation and thoughts on the meaning of the song is also very well said and true! Thank you very much for commenting
@@rosalieelliottofficial You should never worry about expressing your true impressions of anything you react to. It is an essential part of reacting and not just being a semi promoter. That said while I am a HF fan and consider myself a "Home Fry" I am also a fan of another a capella group that I would love to see you react to, Pentatonix. They are also a 5 member group and won the same TV show as HF on the previous season. In fact, it is their success and thrice Grammy Award-winning subsequent career that has prompted the rise of popularity of the art form. Pentatonix, or PTX for short, are more pop/R&B/soul oriented though like HF they do explore a wide variety of genres, especially known for their incredible Christmas catalog. THey have an 11 year, 200+ song catalog of both covers, affectionately referred to as "upgrades" by the Pentaholics, that provide a very diverse range of options. Being a dedicated fan of both groups I guess makes me a Pentafry.
Some of their arraignments? My gosh, was this performance so bad that they were arrested? LOLOL That's okay, we know what you meant, but I did have a big laugh at this word being used. In fact, your comments are extremely insightful.
@@theloneranger8725 hehe need a less efficient spell check. This one KNEW what I wanted to say so corrected me....
Quarantine song, done during lockdown. They have several other quarantine songs, some very funny.
Rosalie, yes I agree there are songs where a lower lead voice that resonates would be the perfect fit. This arrangement however, needed the higher lead vocals for clarity and as a distinct contrast to the bass and harmony vocals, which were perfectly together and smooth. The lead singer's voice was clear and delivered with full on emotion. You couldn't take anything away and that's the magic of great musicians and their arrangements. Everything they did "added." Home Free raised the bar with this cover. Exceptional.
That’s a very fair perspective and well said :) thank you for sharing
This was done during quarantine. They were all in different places. The production was awesome. You need to listen to mor of their songs They all take turns doing the leads in in other songs they do.. They are awesome. Love your reaction.
more coming very soon :)
Much ❤..... ✌👍🙏🇺🇸🇩🇰🏴☠️
Home Free, Brothers In Arms is the song you are looking for. No regrets with this one.
:) stay tuned. Thank you for commenting
You need to try VoicePlay next, to complete the “trifecta” of current A Capella groups. Pentatonix are the classic version, Home Free the country/folk version, and VoicePlay are the “theater” group. Each has their own unique style
Wow, Acapella. George Pendergrass,Duane Adams,Gary Moyers,Wayburn Dean .I saw them many times and glad to hear you mention them.
The original recording sung by the great Percy Sledge was sung in a high tenor, as well as Michal Bolton's cover was sung in a high tenor, although he has a raspier voice. I know of no versions where multiple voices took the lead on this song. HF's version stayed true to the both the original and Michael Bolton's cover of having a single lead. Many, if no most of HF's songs feature multiple performances by the band members, but this particular song really does not call for it. Sorry to disagree with your take. Btw, after viewing dozens of female reactors to this video, you are the only one that did not clearly like this performance by Austin.
it's ok you disagree :) respectful dialogue and various perspectives and opinions is what makes for the opportunity to grow and learn. It's very valid that too many voices leading would not necessarily work for this song. Something I didn't consider. :) I guess I am not like other women ;) Nonetheless I would like to reiterate, they did do a good job, and it's valid most covers are probably sung higher anyways, but it just did not blow me away. The beauty of music is it will touch different people in different ways. I have a feeling the next HF video I watch will be right up my alley :)
Thank you sir ! I was actually ticked off that this foolish woman thought herself a critic and justified to deny THE BEST HIGH TENOR I EVER HEARD .... and I sang back when this was new - Percy did it this way .... and I did as close as I could .... but, NOT LIKE THIS !!! Great version, best ever ! GBjj
I believe this was also a Covid-19 release which is why they are all separated on their own tv. They had to send the recordings back and forth to do this. I think another one was their Sea Shanty video where they were still separated by the pandemic.
Love this version and love this song. It’s almost always great to hear old songs either freshened up or simply sung again by current artists.
Pentatonix has many songs that feature just one singer also.
Could easily tell you weren’t to impressed but not all songs are gonna be the most amazing song we’ve ever heard. There are many songs by my favorite artists that I don’t really care for. It just makes the ones that hit it out of the park that much better.
This was filmed during quarantine so they did this (and many others) from their own closets.
You are someone with music knowledge,most people that love music don't have your kind of knowledge about music and in my opinion that is where the beauty lies,they say beauty is in the eye of the beholder and I think the same is true for the ear and since I can't hear all the faults or hear how it could be better I just enjoy it.
thank you for sharing your thoughts. to me it's not either or, but both, and. Both knowledge and preference can work together. there is a lot I don't know, but those with knowledge and those without are allowed to prefer one style over another in my opinion. yes, sometimes it helps knowing less and looking at things from a simple point of view (so i think that's an interesting point on your part), but I don't think I dove deep into music here, but more so expressed a personal preference (i.e. my thoughts as a beholder :) ) what is more interesting to me is how some (not saying you did), got so defensive in regards to my personal preferences that they attack, as if their identity is so closely tied to this song/singer and to others opinions thereof. quite interesting how humans operate :) I think it's nice you are able to enjoy the music :)
Austin and Adam (beatboxer) did a great job. He really has a great singing voice. This was during Covid so they weren’t even together. I thought the use of tv’s was clever. I respect your opinion. If you like bass try Brothers in Arms, I Can’t Outrun You, In the Blood, Hillbilly Bone, Helplessly Hoping to hear more incredible bass and harmonies.
it's impressive they did this apart. I didn't know that. Excited to check out more very soon :)
This was during the COVID pandemic. They were following COVID rules.
Wow, I always thought that guy was black. Blue eyed Soul I guess. Beautiful.
❤HOMEFREE❤
Tim the bass has broken speakers on live shows from going so low. His lowest was A0 and he also sings tenor.
You will find they vary a lot as to whether they allow one or two members to carry the song to up through four and occasionally five (although the songs where Adam Rupp: Vocal Percussionist has significant singing lines are rare). One of the things many enjoy about them is the variety in their arrangements.
Their rendition of Helplessly Hoping has all five of them singing and no beatboxing. A stunning and moving piece.
According to Percy Sledge, the original and the songwriter, the inspiration for the song came when his girlfriend left him for a modelling career after he was laid off from a construction job in late 1965. Released in 1966
I appreciated your honest reaction. The Home Fries (me included) are pretty passionate about these guys, but reactors who bob their heads and say nothing are boring :) I think Austin did a great job, but this isn't one that calls me back often. Some of those are Take Me Home Country Roads, Colder Weather, In the Blood, Woman, Amen/Female . . there are many! Sold! is amazing too, and Tim's bass is mind blowing :) It's a rewarding journey!
I'm grateful I can be honest and real here. I am excited to check out more and I'm adding your suggestions to my list now.
Finally someone who recommends Woman Amen/Female. IMHO, one of their most underrated songs. I agree, those who really react like The Charismatic Voice get the best responses and HF actually does interviews with them and sends personal messages.
Haha I saw the group Acapella do a show in my town years ago. They were really good
He actually sang the song pretty much actually the way it was sung to begin with and other singers.
This song was done during covid so it was done in separate studios and then mixed. He's great!
that is indeed impressive
It was originally sung by Percy Sledge. His girlfriend had just broken up with him and he walked on stage, told his band to play some music and he sang this.
Wow. That’s crazy. Talk about a spontaneous hit
Adam Rupp is a beatboxer. He does vocals every now and then
Yes, I would love to see more of HF!! Subscribed because of them!!
more coming soon
I grew up with the Percy Sledge version, and that's still my favorite. Anything else just feels like an imitation, no matter the vocal extremes the covers work in that maybe Percy couldn't have done.
But I believe that this is one of the quarantine productions, each recording their own part at home. I appreciate the effort required, and the quality of the result.
Home free has many videos that will make you think, and maybe bring a tear to your eye. But this wasn't one of them.
We home fry's love our home free ❤️❤️❤️
I felt the same way about this being an Austin Brown feat. Home Free song.
I do think some of this was because it was they put together in isolation. Each part was recorded separately.
It was also a love song from Austin to his gf... so there is that. Lol.
If you want to hear pure a cappella from HomeFree you should listen to Helplessly Hoping.
If you need some bass... and want to hear something different... check out Peter Hollens and Tim Foust doing "Misty Mountains" from the Hobbit.
Thank you for your comment and the suggestions :) it’s impressive they put that together in spite of isolation. Stay tuned for more soon
You might as well add Voice Play to your playlist, as I believe they were runners up to Home Free on Sing-Off Season 4. Their latest two covers of "Enemy" and "Running Up That Hill" are outstanding.
They actually placed 6th.
good to know :) thank you for the suggestions. more coming very soon
Great reaction ! I love these guys ! Please be aware that the first two songs that you chose feature Austin Brown in the lead - this is not the case for the majority of their work. You should check more of their catalog. I would suggest 'Brothers in Arms', 'In the Blood', 'End of the Road'. You will be pleased with what you find.
Thank you :) I def plan to listen to and react to more very soon
@@rosalieelliottofficial Don't watch Mayday until you get a good feel for each of the guys and their roll in the group. You will be surprised.
I totally accept your opinion of this song. We all have our personal preferences. This is one of the few songs of this group where one vocalist is showcased thru the whole song. Although you perhaps were not totally thrilled with this one song please don't stop reviewing them. They have a very large variety of music and I'm sure that you'll find other songs that you do like. Cheers!
Thank you for allowing me to speak freely and for your comment :-) I definitely will not stop listening to them because I do like what I am hearing and I’m excited to explore more. Stay tuned for more
❤️❤️
Now that you know Home Free and PTX, VoicePlay is a must do...
I love Voice Play. I would recommend their rendition of Dream On.
Try Ring of Fire, Folsom Prison Blues, I Can’t Outrun You, Brothers in Arms, Folsom Prison Blues, Hillbilly Bone, Champagne Taste on a Beer Budget for more bass. HF usually features multiple leads on each song.
Please follow up with Mayday, Folsom Prison Blues and End Of The Road. You will see so much versatility in all of them!
more coming soon :) just got done recording 2 more videos for HF today. stay tuned :)
🖤🍟
respect your honesty and well expressed! Try Home Free "Listen to the Music"
adding it to the list now :) thank you.
To hear some lower notes, check out their Folsum Prison Blues.
Home Free is my favorite vocal band, tho I do really like the others. They make a wide range of songs and different people like different songs of theirs more than others. I tend to fall into moods and like to listen to different leads. I think Austin is an amazing singer. His voice is just golden. But each of the members of Home Free and great in their own right. Rob has a real soulful voice and when he does "Go Rest High On That Mountain" is can make you cry. Chance singing "Cover Me Up" just moves me a lot. Tim, the bass, well, I have so many of his leads I love. "Brothers in Arms" or "Ring of Fire" shows a good depth of his voice. And Adam Rupp's drum solo's will get you dancing.
So, I do understand your opinion, and it is valid. Music is one of those things like wine, not everyone likes the expensive stuff, sometimes the lower shelf stuff just has better flavor. (the wine thing is because of a disagreement a friend of mine had with me about corked wine vs twist top. I liked the twist top flavor better)
For more bassy sound, I'd try, "Ring of Fire" or "Brothers in Arms" those are two popular bass songs they have.
Keep up the good work!
Thank you so much for your candid honesty, great reaction.
FWIW, Percy Sledge "hammered" this song long before Michael Bolton did.
Your crazy!
*you're
🙂❤❤❤ ...They are so incredibly good this group!
"This song is timeless, it came before me, and will be here long after I am gone, we men, love you, get that through your thick heads ladies". Qoute by Michael the Archangel #BookofMichael #Bookofnow #Bookoflife
Most reactors to this song noticed the way Austin was singing with such passion ...like he was singing into the eyes of the woman he loves...well he was....his girlfriend was standing right beside the camera...this version would have lost something if they were switching leads like the usually do..My opinion , some songs are meant to be sung by one I think this was one of them.
Listen to " How great thou art" let's you hear all of them sing even the beat boxer. Most of there songs have multiple leads.
that's a very valid point :) It's a sweet thought to think he was singing it to her. More HF coming very soon. :)
Love your reactions, get to learn a lot 😊
Thanks so much :)
If you want the lower tones check out their covers of Brothers in Arms, Folsom Prison Blues, the Driver has then all taking lead.
All I can say is you have so much to learn about this group. Please listen to some more. Stay well.
happy to learn :) more coming soon
Great, honest reaction Rosalie. You're doing a good job!
thank you, Mike. Your kind comment and feedback is very appreciated!
This song was a best hit for Percy Sledge in 1966.
I think it’s a fabulous rendition, but, of course, music and many other things are subjective. Appreciate the honesty. Always. Greetings from Florida.
well said!! :) the world is a big place. There's something for everyone. I look fwd to exploring more of their work tho. They are very talented!
A lot of nice comments here. ❤️❤️
agreed! :) thankful for it.
I love Home Frees rendition of this song, i love Boltons as well. But I like that they give everyone a chance to shine in a solo song once in a while. I feel like it keeps tension from building in a group if there is respect and freedom to do things like this. Too many times we see big groups like this fall apart cause there is too many egos or tension. This group has been together a long time and probably will for years to come. They are more than a band they are great friends that let each other do solo pieces or have a say in what they do. And that is part of what I like about them. When I watch them i get the feeling like they are just a bunch of buddies having a great time that are very talented. But that is just my opinion so take what you want from it. Thank you.
I personally LOVED it.
Let's not forget the original singer Percy Tyrone Sledge(11/25/1940-4/14/2015)
Especially such a slow paced piece is suitable to show off their marvelous teamwork and skills. Everyone knows, that a glitch will be heard and judged, and yet they perform ever so very well together. Lots of songs they did featured one or two of them alone, then somtimes each of them gets a turn, there is just no designated leader, Austin is technically an amazing singer, not every cover shows that off as much as this one. "End Of The Road" features Rob the most, "Mayday" must get counted out of this for mostly showing off Tims highest range while Adam Chance pulls an incredibly sturdy and powerful bass. Just do not judge "When A Man Loves A Woman" too simple, compare this a cappella approach of five men to a singer with just his effort supported by numerous instruments and it is apples and oranges. Wow, just check out THIS ORANGES!
Fun fact: Austin's then fiance' and now wife, was off camera here. It was Valentine's Day and he was singing it to her.
Austin and Amberly are not married - I think you meant Adam Chance who recently married
@@Ingrid_Haendel Im wrong, thought they married last year. Great couple regardless,
A lotta love going on there!
that's very sweet
Keep exploring Home Free. The variety of their creations is extraordinary and they all take the lead at times, aside from the beat boxer.
You bet! I promise I will
Please remember, this was done during quarantine,, so they were all at their own homes. They kept a lot of us sane by putting out a new song every other Friday!!
that's understandable :)
I look forward to your future reactions to Home Free's performances! I don't think you'll be disappointed!
I don't think so either :) looking fwd to more too. thank you :)
Austin's beautiful girlfriend was in the studio while he recorded this, he was singing to her.
Rosalie, I just discovered this. I think you will find that as long as you are being respectful (like you were here), Homefries will respect your opinion and listen to what you say.
My favorite thing about Home Free is that they seem to have no ego's. I love that they take their music seriously, but not themselves. If you continue to approach them with an open mind, you will be blown away by their versatility and their range (and their sense of humor).
i agree :) most have been respectful and kind :) I look fwd to exploring more very soon
Listen to the key change section of the song again. Start a couple bars before the switch. Pay attention to the beat box. Now, please someone explain to me how a human voice can do that up trill that sounds like a sci-fi special effect.
You have a lot to learn. Kudos for your honesty, and everyone is entitled to their opinions - but with only two Home Free songs that you have heard, your perspective will grow if you let it. This one was a showcase for Austin, yes - but sometimes bands do that. Try "Brothers in Arms" or "Everybody Walkin' This Land" if you like bass.
excited to explore more soon.
Please react to home free-can’t stop the feeling
You might like their version of "In the Blood "...
They did amazing in this cover. But, since you like bass so well, I would like to suggest Home Free covering Dire Straits Brothers in Arms.
If you'd like to check out the range of music they cover check out the Butts Remix, Country Fried Pop Medley and All About That Bass!! Tim Foust is an amazing bass! For a shock check out him and Austin singing My Maria then Tim's cover of Will You Still Love Me/Stay!!!
Austin brought his girlfriend along for inspiration. He is actually singing and pointing to her.
that's sweet
his hit was originally by Percy Sledge , Thanks
Check out their version of the MAYDAY cover by Cam.