Well, the nickname PsychoOctopus is already taken by Aquiles Priester… maybe Manic Octopus? Also, didn’t Portnoy have animation of him as an octopus? Trying to remember the exact song but I think it was on the Train of Thought tour (oddly enough I was at the show in Boston where Portnoy/Mangini had the infamous drum duet).
My fav song on the entire scenes from a memory Love how they use the phrygian mode to create the tension vibe the storytelling needs at this point of the album Well balanced virtuosity, composing and execution through all the tracks
You have only referenced the Phrygian mode as a means of demonstrating to others how much you know, which is likely not very much. I pity the future of your family tree, as well as weep for the future of a world that contains people like you. Good day, sir.
i think you actually intend to mention "Arabic Scale" rather than "phrygian mode". Some people say it is "harmonic minor scale" but i don't know if thats correct. I know it by "Arabic scale"
i was expecting LaBrie to sound bad but his voice was pleasantly surprising on the distance over time tour. much better than 2015-2017, he seemed to have got back his stage aura.
damn, mangini played 6:01 part in a more difficult way. that the transitional coordination between the right and left hands is not easy to copy by ordinary drummers (who have a dominant right hand)
People have free will. It is their will not to agree or hate. There must be balance. It cannot be all sunshine and rainbows. Having said that I respect Mangini’s talent. He is a fine clinical player and has feeling just not what Portnoy added to DT. No hate. Just preference.
It's neither. They have playback tracks in the background, namely including percussion and background vocals (all JP singing is fake). They can because they only play to a click. It's a shame because they are finally getting tighter as a band, but they feel the need to include these ridiculous things that have nothing to do with a live show. Just do what you can with the people on stage, and don't press a freaking play button... It doesn't take away from the fun they're having there (esp. Mangini, who really came out of his shell) and the great show.
The intonation of La Brie sounds very wrong at the beginning of his singing and again and again wrong throughout the song. Nevertheless: DT - the best there are, there were and there ever will be in progressive metal!
Verdade, ele melhorou sim! Mas as músicas continuam vazias (robô) e vc percebe também nos caras no palco, não há o sentimento que havia entre os músicos, vc percebe muito isso em Jordan (tecladista)...
O que eu não consigo gostar do Mangini, é o timbre que ele usa no estúdio, Isso me irrita demais kkkkkkkkkkkk, mas tocando não tem o que falar do cara, é um monstro, vi eles em sp semana passada 07/12 e fiquei boquiaberto tamanha precisão e pegada, porém faço coro de suas palavras, também prefiro e sempre vou preferir o Portnoy.
Too dumb to bring Portnoy back and let go this amazing drummer, Mangini is way better than portnoy. Mangini improved the original version of this song, Portnoy will never perform this song live as perfect in timing and skill like this drum monster did, freaking amazing!
Drop D, Phrygian Dominant sound, you sure this isn't a Tool song? Lol This is an amazing song. One of my favorites from SFAM but I can't help but feel this is Dream Theater trying to be Tool 😂
@@jameskostov9353 meh, not really a fair comparison. They take very different approaches to music and thus come out with (mostly) very different results. Which one is "better" per se is up to personal preference.
@@qaisalfaris22 He's one of the best. He along with Mangini, Peart, Danny Carey etc. are in fact some of my favorites. Personally I think Mangini is better than Portnoy but Portnoy is one of my favorites. Why would I not want to admit it? Give me a break.
@@qaisalfaris22, the other members of DT thought he's a talented-enough drummer to play with DT. As for you, more than likely, not so much. DT didn't fire Portnoy. He quit.
![Dream Theater - Enigma Machine [Breaking The Fourth Wall]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qRFcLHo58eQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Dream Theater - Enigma Machine [Breaking The Fourth Wall]](/img/tr.png)
![Dream Theater - Breaking All Illusions [LIVE] [Breaking the Fourth Wall]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rFkPPokCL6E/mqdefault.jpg)
That hand move at 1:01 hahah amazing
2:41 Mangini is having fun 😁
Wtf... Having fun lk Mike Machine!
What a crazy Super Mangini. He's an Octopus in his drum kitchen. Awesome.
Well, the nickname PsychoOctopus is already taken by Aquiles Priester… maybe Manic Octopus?
Also, didn’t Portnoy have animation of him as an octopus? Trying to remember the exact song but I think it was on the Train of Thought tour (oddly enough I was at the show in Boston where Portnoy/Mangini had the infamous drum duet).
@@AJNystrom was it filmed?
a very good decision to choose a drummer .... crazy magini
2:43 When the drummer has to both drum and punch evil spirits... Talent
Love the best band of the world
My fav song on the entire scenes from a memory
Love how they use the phrygian mode to create the tension vibe the storytelling needs at this point of the album
Well balanced virtuosity, composing and execution through all the tracks
You have only referenced the Phrygian mode as a means of demonstrating to others how much you know, which is likely not very much. I pity the future of your family tree, as well as weep for the future of a world that contains people like you. Good day, sir.
@@benjones6865 ultralocrian
Ben Jones chill dude. You sounds like such a pretentious jerk.
i think you actually intend to mention "Arabic Scale" rather than "phrygian mode". Some people say it is "harmonic minor scale" but i don't know if thats correct. I know it by "Arabic scale"
@@yuribatera9233yeah because it has both the minor 2nd, typical of the Phrygian mode, and the major 7th, typical of the harmonic minor scale
Mangini having fun at 2:44 :)
11:48 Ultra Instinct in practice. Attack and defense, all in one. Instant kill in every note. Human intelligence at it's best. Period.
i was there, amazing show.
i was expecting LaBrie to sound bad but his voice was pleasantly surprising on the distance over time tour. much better than 2015-2017, he seemed to have got back his stage aura.
yeah i think acctually worked on his pitch
watching Mangini playing is so much fun!!!
what hand off Mangini has???? perfectoooo
Mangini..... Perfect
love this video,one of my fav songs i learned about this song on dbz history of trunks and i love this song
Bikin meringding.....
Mangini 👍👍👏
I will always hear... "Can't have it, HEY ABBOTT!!.. it's calling me back to my home." IYKYK.
Mangini asik bngt main nya... 😀
damn, mangini played 6:01 part in a more difficult way.
that the transitional coordination between the right and left hands is not easy to copy by ordinary drummers (who have a dominant right hand)
11:19
Mangini just nutzo...like he’s just toying around.
Mike is better then Mike 😎
To all the fucks who praise Mangini for his drumming here, Portnoy composed the drums to this song.
And wrote the lyrics too
Those cymbals are distracting😂
2023 - 12 - 14 😊
The hate for Mangini is stupid, as well as the ones hating.
And I love Portnoy but come on, grow up... Pfff
People have free will. It is their will not to agree or hate. There must be balance. It cannot be all sunshine and rainbows. Having said that I respect Mangini’s talent. He is a fine clinical player and has feeling just not what Portnoy added to DT. No hate. Just preference.
i'm hiring is fals not in the begining intro,, who mistake ? keyborad or drummer ?
why is the vocal like that...?
we've all been asking that same question for years lol
10:25 is it only me hearing tambourine somewhere by Mangini? Usually Labrie did it, but he's not.
It's neither. They have playback tracks in the background, namely including percussion and background vocals (all JP singing is fake). They can because they only play to a click. It's a shame because they are finally getting tighter as a band, but they feel the need to include these ridiculous things that have nothing to do with a live show. Just do what you can with the people on stage, and don't press a freaking play button...
It doesn't take away from the fun they're having there (esp. Mangini, who really came out of his shell) and the great show.
Amplificador fisico cada vez menos presente nos palcos .
LABRIE voice a little high
especially 3:15
Mangini mellong panigoanna masarru...
Very insane drummer😅
Great music they are playing Indian classical music.
The intonation of La Brie sounds very wrong at the beginning of his singing and again and again wrong throughout the song. Nevertheless: DT - the best there are, there were and there ever will be in progressive metal!
La Brie did sound very wrong.
And Tool !!
His pitch was off throughout most of this tune by a lot which tells me he could not hear himself.
@3:14 it almost sounds good, he's so far off pitch that he hits the 4th instead of the major 3rd. Not sure if it's intentional or not...
Fanofquo i noticed that too, haha. it stuck in a weird way, on a “wrong” harmony :]
Yes, Haken is a very, very good prog band, I‘ve got one CD, called „Mountain“, but I know the rest of their music from Apple music.
I bet labrie doesn't miss the camal behide him spitting ...
What?
@@marinhrabric6162 Mike Portnoy spits a lot when playing live.
Indiscutível a técnica de mangini, o cara é um ET, mas pra DT prefiro Mike Portnoy, (minha opinião)!
Verdade, ele melhorou sim! Mas as músicas continuam vazias (robô) e vc percebe também nos caras no palco, não há o sentimento que havia entre os músicos, vc percebe muito isso em Jordan (tecladista)...
O que eu não consigo gostar do Mangini, é o timbre que ele usa no estúdio, Isso me irrita demais kkkkkkkkkkkk, mas tocando não tem o que falar do cara, é um monstro, vi eles em sp semana passada 07/12 e fiquei boquiaberto tamanha precisão e pegada, porém faço coro de suas palavras, também prefiro e sempre vou preferir o Portnoy.
Dude that looks uncomfortable to have the cymballs so high up
He confirmed it isn't
Too dumb to bring Portnoy back and let go this amazing drummer, Mangini is way better than portnoy.
Mangini improved the original version of this song, Portnoy will never perform this song live as perfect in timing and skill like this drum monster did, freaking amazing!
I can't really handle Labrie's yodeling. They get him to sound decent in the studio but his weird falcetto yodeling needs professional help.
He needs a Miracle, because his vocal chords are the Sleeper. I don't care how terrible that joke was.
God James is so bad man.
Hot take - portnoy agreed to rejoin on condition that they let james go after one more album
Laurie sounded awful in the beginning
RIP Laurie
Labrie desafinando tudo! Hshaha
The Wizard X problema seu
Até q eu gostei da performance dele rs
listen to this song on scenes from new york... Portnoy is exponentially better and has so much more synergy with Petrucci
Plus his singing voice is so important for songs off this album.
pfft found the video with the wrong drummer again.
which one?
to me right one is not mangini.
@@efeozturk5253 move on kid.. nobody care about your right drummer anymore..
@@meshuggahman3225 almost 40 and won’t take advices from little nobodies like you baby.
@@efeozturk5253 40? then act like 40.. stop acting like butthurt 18yrs.. dont go to dt video with MM and talking shit.. easy?
geezus LaCheese sounds like a dying cat. someone please take that mic away from him
depois que o portnoy saiu isso ai virou banda cover, principalmente esse baterista robô com a bateria xoxa
Ok viuvinha do portnoy
Portnoy is dream theater
Aditio Akbar Well this is Dream Theater rocking like bosses and I don’t see Portnoy so 🤷🏼♂️
Shut up deal with the loss Mangini can do everything portnoy does
In that case, I don't like the ego of Dream Theater, nor its backing vocals.
Udah gausah dengerin DT lagi.. ganti band aja mas
Portnoy is a man.. I'm a right ?
Drop D, Phrygian Dominant sound, you sure this isn't a Tool song? Lol
This is an amazing song. One of my favorites from SFAM but I can't help but feel this is Dream Theater trying to be Tool 😂
Project-awesome customs and music Dream Theater always was and is better than tool
@@jameskostov9353 meh, not really a fair comparison. They take very different approaches to music and thus come out with (mostly) very different results. Which one is "better" per se is up to personal preference.
I always hear "The Matrix" when I hear the "wow-wow" of the guitar.
Mangini is perfect for Dream Theater. Much better than Portnoy
Leandro Zavarez really? event song portnoy write?
Mike Portnoy the best
Ninink Oktavia Then go watch him 🤷🏼♂️
Sky Quest Music Official you know he’s the best but you just don’t want to show it
@@qaisalfaris22 He's one of the best. He along with Mangini, Peart, Danny Carey etc. are in fact some of my favorites. Personally I think Mangini is better than Portnoy but Portnoy is one of my favorites. Why would I not want to admit it? Give me a break.
@@qaisalfaris22, the other members of DT thought he's a talented-enough drummer to play with DT. As for you, more than likely, not so much. DT didn't fire Portnoy. He quit.
Sky Quest Music Official you’re just hating on Portnoy that’s my point
Mangini not a good choice