Base M3 Pro 11/14 vs Top M3 Pro 12/18 - $400 Upgrade - Results will surprise you.
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 พ.ค. 2024
- Base M3 Pro 11/14 vs Top M3 Pro 12/18 - $400 Upgrade - Results will surprise you - Pro Photo Workflow Test & comparisons. This is a comprehensive test & comparison of Apple newest M3 SoC inside the 14" & 16" MacBook Pro. This review will also include results from previous generation M1, M2, M3, M1 Pro, M2 Pro, M1 Max, M2 Max, M3 Max, M1 Ultra and M2 Ultra. These tests includes Lightroom Classic, Lightroom, Capture One, Photoshop, Final Cut Pro and After Effects. These are tests done from a perspective of a pro photographers so you can choose the best machines that fits your workflow.
M3 vs M2 vs M1 | Pro Photo Workflow Test - Good improvement & "Pro" SoC wannabe
• M3 vs M2 vs M1 | Pro P...
M3 Pro vs M2 Pro vs M1 Pro | Pro Photo Workflow Test - Disappointing performance?
• M3 Pro vs M2 Pro vs M1...
M3 Max vs M2 Max vs M1 Max | Pro Photo Workflow Test - This Rival the Ultra!
• M3 Max vs M2 Max vs M1...
32GB on M1 PRO vs M1 MAX, Does memory bandwidth matters?
• 32GB on M1 PRO vs M1 M...
Should you buy the fastest SSD for Pro Photo + Video Workflow? Does internal vs external matters?
• Should you buy the fas...
Ultimate Calibration Guide for Apple 14" & 16" MacBook Pro XDR Display - This is the way!
• Ultimate Calibration G...
iStat Menu bjango.com/mac/istatmenus/
Diglloyd Photoshop Test macperformanceguide.com/Optim...
Looking back - Pre M3 release videos
My thoughts about the new M3 Macs, Overall configuration advise
• My thoughts about the ...
M3 Macs - A few additional thoughts before the official ship date!
• M3 Macs - A few additi...
00:00 Intro
00:17 Preface
01:19 Test System
02:26 Memory Bandwidth
03:49 Retest Everything
04:03 Battery
05:16 Color Calibration
05:29 Single App Test
05:44 Test Configs
06:08 Effect of SSD & RAM Is known
06:17 Reading the Spec
06:27 SSD
07:14 Internal vs External SSD
07:30 Memory - RAM
08:52 Intel Mac advise
09:18 32GB+ for Pro
09:44 Lightroom Classic Preview 1:1
10:55 LRC Export
12:24 LRC HDR
13:13 LRC Panorama Merge
14:43 LRC AI Noise Reduction
15:56 Lightroom CC - LR Export
17:11 Capture 1 - C1 Preview
18:47 C1 Export
20:18 Photoshop
23:28 Video Export FCP
24:21 AfterEffects
25:21 Analysis
26:42 14” Advice
27:54 16” Advice
28:41 SoC Recommendations
31:01 Upgrade Path
32:17 Conclusion
Art's Tip Jar
www.paypal.com/donate/?busine...
Full Disclosure:
ArtIsRight is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a way for websites to earn advertising revenues by advertising and linking to amazon.com
Some of the links below are affiliate links. This means that, at zero cost to you, I will earn an affiliate commission if you click through the link and finalize a purchase.
#M3Pro #macbookpro2023 - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Correction for one of the computer in the charts it is supposed to be 14MBP M3 8/10 16GB 512GB instead of 13MBP M3 8/10 16GB 512GB. It is a 14" MBP M3 not a 13" one. But you get the idea.
18:39 hi Art what do you mean here with tether capture on C1Pro? Unsure what you mean. Does the top spec M3Pro tether any faster than the base? Thank you!
my man dropped the best buyer guide for M3 pro and thought we wouldnt notice
:)
This review video was exactly I was searching for. Great work. Clearly explained with final recommendations. Now I know which one to upgrade to.
Glad it was helpful!
This was super comprehensive. Thank you!
You're so welcome!
Top notch review. All performance results and data laid out clearly, straightforward and no exaggeration, best to watch as buying guide when consider buying a mac.
Thanks!
I can't believe you made so many comparison videos... but I'm glad you did, this was the exact one that I needed. 11/14 w/ 36GB it is.
😀
Great video as always! Looking forward to the M3 Max comparisons Base vs Top end.
That is up coming :)
Thank you Art, once again, very professional presentation.
Thanks again!
Honestly: This is the best review I‘ve ever seen! Thanks pure quality content that you can use for years! Thank you so much for sharing your tests! I’m a software developer but your analysis helped me a lot decoding what’s best for me!
You're very welcome!
Thx for all your effort, amazing 🙏
Thank you!
Man, you're on fire! So many videos and tests in such short time. 🤯
Thank you
u answered all my questions. thank you legend
Thank You!
Awesome job, and thanks for diving into M3 Pro! One thought... not sure how you would do it, but an annotation on memory pressure (green/yellow/red) for each run would be very interesting... clearly you can't test every RAM configuration, but knowing where paging/swapping kicked in would be helpful. But even without this it was great... thank you!
The thing is that with single app testing you won't see much of the effect.
@@ArtIsRight Thank you for the clarification... looking back, I think I was confused by your comment for Photoshop Medium (at 22mins) that "once you increase the memory in the system things do run faster"... looking back I think you were referring to the "70%" and "90%" numbers(?), which I didn't understand (I'm not a photographer).
underrated video. and im happy that I went for the pro base with an ram upgrade. appreciate for this and keep up the good job !
Appreciate it!
Thanks for this review mate, you just saved me 200 bucks! Keep it up.
No problem 👍
My mannnnn - what is thisssss - PURE GOLD !!!
thank you!
Wow, so glad I ended up with M3 Pro (11core) in 14 inch body.... I must also add, the thermals are really great with this one, Cinebench CPU/GPU tests reach around 60 degrees celsius and only then can you hear the vents...
agreed
Your videos are very educational. Thank you.
You are welcome!
Excellent review. The 14" MBP M3pro is exactly the machine I was considering, so I appreciate how you clearly laid out in your analysis section the suggestion of depositing $200 dollars towards upgrading the memory to 36 GB instead of using it to upgrade the core from 11 to 12. This was exactly where I had uncertainty in my decision regarding the configurations. Your video nailed down exactly what I needed to know to select the perfect machine for my needs. You saved this gal some money. THANK YOU! ^_^
Glad to hear!
That's a great work!! Thanks
Thank you too!
Can’t wait for this channel to hit 1m subscribers. This is legit my go to channel for mac related benchmarks
Thank you, hopefully then I'll have a team to work on my charts and double check the annotations. So hard being a 1 person team.
@@ArtIsRight you’re welcome. For a 1 man team, you are doing an amazing job.
thanks for your work!!
😀
Again, great info for decision process on what MBP to purchase! During the Apple Scary event, they mentioned the GPU utilization with Dynamic Caching. What is your take on how that may effect LRC and PS performance if/when Adobe optimizes to take advantage of the GPU on the M3’s?
I would be interesting, that really just utilizes the memory, but the cores are already being used right now in the task. I don't think we'll see much by ways of improvements, may be, if anything, just a touch. But remember too that older machines that used to be really fast like the M1 Ultra is now a touch slower with the current OS and apps on the market.
bro.. why did it take me over 8 hours if listening and watching comparisons to find this INCREDIBLY thorough video. Thank you so much. Seems like if video is my thing I have to go max. Was really hoping you were going to give the base m3 pro with upgraded ram the thumbs up for the video editing as well! Thank you so much!
My pleasure!
Thank you for your thorough comparisons. Recently discovered your channel and it’s fantastic.
Just a note, from the description and at the start, I thought you were initially talking about the actual base/lowest spec and priced MacBook Pro 14” which doesn’t really have a pro chip and only has 8gb Ram. I know you wrote the cpu/ gpu specs but I didn’t even take note of them - just read ‘base’ and assumed you meant the 8gb Ram version. Perhaps it would be a good idea to write or say “not the m3 pro with 8 gb ram that costs $1599 usd”. I think some people may be completely unaware of all the different m3 machines & importance of all the specs- specifically the Ram.
ok
Amazing review 💯 🙌
Thank you 🙌
Great video.
Do you showcase your photographic work anywhere?
Not yet, I used to. :)
Art, thank you for all you do! I've watched all your comparison videos with the new M3 chips and I think this video in particular definitely will shape up my decision. For my workflow (schoolwork, media consumption, working on ad creatives/Shopify, light photo and video editing), would you say the base M3 Pro with 36GB/2TB be more than good enough for my use case?
Yes
Amazing video. I was already leaning towards 11c/14g Pro with 36gb 1 TB before this video. Thanks!
Good choice!
@@ArtIsRight Hey Art! Your channel is the best for comparisons by far. Should have 200k+ subs in no time. Can I ask your advice? I’m going to start a youtube channel myself and will do some video editing. Mostly 1080p and probably 30 min max videos, but some will be 4k. Right now my machine is an M1 Mini 16gb. Will this machine do ok with Adobe Premiere Pro? I was debating keeping it or upgrading to either: 14” Macbook Pro M3 Pro 11/14, 14” Macbook Pro M3 Pro 12/18, 14” Macbook Pro M3 Max 14/30 (all of these would be 36GB 1TB), Mac Studio M2 Max 12/30 64 GB Ram 2TB (same price as most of the macbooks due to no screen, keyboard, etc).
Out of those 5 options, what do you recommend?
Thank you for this video!!
You are so welcome!
Thanks. You are doing yeoman's work with these M chips.
You bet
Best testing video I've seen so far would've loved to see more about the Max. And graphics performance on games but I realize that probably isn't what you focus on
You are right. I don't really game
Great review. Really detailed. Maybe 14 inch M3 pro is better value in a way but I wanted a 16" M3 pro because of screen size and space black finish. I didn't then consider 14 inch M3 Pro. The M2 pro was a very good model for my Mac mini so that highlighted the value proposition of the pro chips for me. I so some light photoshop and graphic layout work.
I hear you
I really appreciate the video. Wanted to make sure which version of the pro would be best for me. Coming from an m1 air base model 😅.
Either, I would not update the GPU, it does make sense for the money. Conclusion to this video said as much, better use money on RAM
great review!
Thanks!
Great video. One suggestion. You should include code compilation test also for programmers.
Some one need to send me a benchmark sample
Just wow what a review, great work. I was using my mbp late 2015 until 2023, upgraded to m2 air with 8gb ram but just wasnt doing it for me with my workload. I have just ordered the mbp 14 inch with 11 core 18gb ram (Silver its just the best colour) THANK you once again for the review.
Enjoy!
Very thorough job. I'd be interested to see this comparison with DxO PureRaw.
😀
Hey, there. A very much appreciate your approach on reviewing/testing. Quick question: Will you include tests in Davinci in the future?
have been looking into it, if I do it won't be generational testing
That would be totally fine, kerp up the good work!
Thanks for the video. I was really wondering if those 4 extra gpu cores make a difference
😀
Art as always we HIGHLY Appreciate everything
Will you ever be testing the M3 pro 32 GB versus the M3 Max base that’s the next jump up between the two levels and we need to be able to see if it’s worth the extra money to jump up to
With real world testing with LRC and Photoshop?
Levels between previous model, and next model with allow us to decide whether it’s worth the price jump
Probably not. The routine now is to stick with Stock, unless someone want to lend me their machine for about 4 hours
Understand
how about the base 16 inch M3 Pro versus the base M3 max head to head with LRC and Photoshop?
Did you show that in your last video with charts and if so, head to head what benefits?
Is the m3 max on the 14” mbp and overkill? Previous editions were throttled in the smaller chassis. Should any Max chip be bought on the 16” mbp?
Thank u for this. Only thing i would say is i wish it was the same size as battery and performance could vary because of thermals etc. but still a great video
marginal at best, I would say don't over think it. I also made the argument that the bigger one that's supposed to be better is not performing that much better at all. That is pretty much telling you everything that you need to know.
Perfect video thanks
You're welcome!
great stuff
Incredible and comprehensive review I ever need after spending almost 2 weeks figuring out what to upgrade to!!! I'm using MBP 13" 2019 Corei5 and thinking about upgrading to M3 pro. However, I cannot decide whether I should pay extra $200 for 12/18 + 36Gb ram/ 512Gb or not. As a pro photographer who has to reach deadline as soon as possible and have watched this video, I think I will go for M3 pro 11/14 + 36Gb ram 1TB to use for 4-5 years and I think it will definitely pay of itself. Thank you so much, you literally save my day!
Awesome
Nice analysis. I have the M3 Max base 14 more or less for the reasons you mentioned…
the best one this round
awesome! thank you
You bet!
Hi Art, another great video! I have a question I work in event photograpy with a sony a7 iv maybe a sony A1 for later, I wanted to know if the MBP 16 M3 max 14cpu 30 gpu 36gb 1to would be suitable for Lr and Ps use?
Yes will be perfect. Maybe a bit more RAM if you are a heavy tab collector.
@@nwwy I wanted to go for the 16/40 48gb RAM but the price in Europe (+600€) doesn't really justify it, especially to save a few seconds on export. I don't really care, on my MBP 16 M1 pro 32gb 1to I haven't had any slowdowns due to the ram or the beach ball, so that should do it.
Fly to an American state with zero sales tax, like Alaska, and try to get an Education discount. It's like a free holiday, and you will save more even on top of the price of the flights. M3 Max can be £1000-1500 cheaper than the UK / EU that way. @@mathieuceccarini1841
Totally!
Hey art, idk if u can but can you do a blender sample scene render time comparison on the macbooks ?
Need a sample file
28:24 Do you think the 4 extra GPU cores on the top spec M3P chip would make a bigger difference if you were to play more intensive AAA games (I plan to install virtual windows and install AAA games in it)?
I don't think you'll see much variations
@ArtIsRight Dear Sir, is there any difference of internal structure between 14”MBP equipped 11/14 SOC and 12/18 SOC?
just the SoC
Hey, great video. What’s better? A 14” 11/14 M3 Pro with 36gb ram, or a 14” M2 Max with 32GB ram.
My main concern is temps. I want the fan running as little as possible
then 16" would be the way to go, but still unless you are working it hard then the 14" does not ramp up as much
Hi ArtIsRight - I have seen lot of TH-cam channels but your approach to analyze multiple configurations is awesome. My needs are pretty simple - I do financial modeling using excel with data tables, macros and formulas which are volatile like - offset, lookups etc. I don't multitask..just safari with 2-3 tabs, Apple Music and teams for calls and pdf. I intend to buy MBP-M2Pro-12C (8C+4E) with 16GB or MBP-M3Pro-12C (6C+6E). Not sure which one is good..I think having more P-cores will help. Can you please advise ? Thanks a lot. Manoj
if you can save a good amount of money, M2 Pro. Either will do just fine really
ai summary: Recommend base 14" M3 Pro upgraded to 32GB RAM as the price/performance sweet spot around $2300
😀
Ya, but 512GB is kinda unusable.
@@rene.s.sadd external Thunderbolt ssd, problem solved.
@@rene.s.swhy is 512GB unusable?… especially if I have hard drives for photo/video work? Feel like 512 is plenty of space
Agree and if you would often use 512gb, you'd also often use 1TB anyhow. Need external unless you have 2TB.
exactly what i searched for!
Nice!
So I have a pro question I’d like to get your thoughts on:
For those of us working with many high res images in Lightroom Classic, the most critical speed bottlenecks are the executional ones: e.g., instantaneous viewing of the high res image as you flip from one image to the next, followed probably by instantaneous execution of brush masking etc. These are operations that involve a lot of rapid back and forth interaction between the human and the machine.
Exports and imports where the computer is working on its own are less of an issue, as we can organize our paperclips or argue with our spouses about the price of a new wildlife lens while the computer works. 😀
What would you say is the order of importance on which spec to ramp up for those interactive executional functions?
Cheers and thanks. 👍
I would always choose making your time as efficient as possible, since the computer can do what it does while as you say, do something more constructive with your time. Whether that’s possible who knows, I think that’s where AI comes in. I’m a canon DPP user and beginning to use Lightroom, Photoshop and Premiere and the M series chips really do smoke the previous i5 MBP 2014 13 inch I used
I'd also be curious to know how much the configs differ in this regard as this is where I noticed limitations on my 2020 M1 16gb the most. Using the clone stamp tool can be painfully slow on high res images. Click an area to remove a spec of dust, wait several seconds for it to clone out, click the next spec, wait several seconds, etc. Same thing with brushing/masking it can begin to lag significantly.
@@mvp_kryptonitehe's saying these are the tasks where you wouldn't be doing anything else. You're just working on an image, you click the next image in lightroom, it takes a few seconds to render the full res, then click to zoom to 100%, wait several seconds for the image to re-render, then use the clone stamp tool, wait several seconds for it to clone, etc. If going from the Pro at ~$2700 to the Max at ~$3900 makes a significant difference in these tasks, it may be worth spending the extra money.
Yes.
The key for my work is avoiding a delay when examining images (the pause between showing the preview and the full res image as I move from shot to shot) and avoiding the spinning ball when I’m inputting edits via mouse or tablet.
I’m about to move from Intel to M series, and am looking to maximize the bang for the buck.
In every other major platform change since the original Mac (yes, I’’ve been at this for that long), RAM has always been the first priority, with processing speed coming after.
So far, the testing shows what I would expect: adequate head room in RAM and SSD storage are important in this iteration too.
But I’d like to get the thoughts of someone who has had hands on experience testing the new platform to confirm.
Cheers!
T.
RAM and then SoC and then SSD. Upgrade them in that order / priority
Thanks. Another excellent review. It seems quite clear that for intense/pro users what matters is good amount of memory and fast SSD. I think a very good machine to think about is the new Imac M3 with 24 GB and 1TB SSD. This configuration is the best value for money and it can handle intense tasks if required.
Still only 8+10 cores though. Needs Pro and Max versions, 27", SD card slot, etc.
@@_Chris390, this would be my ideal and desired machine.
if you won't hit the limit of the M3 then sure
As always pretty impressive demo & content explanation 👍🏻
I‘d like to see DxO Photolab (7) in your comparisons, if possible.
😁
Firstly, thank you Art! What a deeply considered, useful analysis and presentation. I’ll be getting the M3P 14” 36GB 1 TB.
My question is about 11 vs. 12 cores vis a vis future-proofing: the difference doesn’t seem worthwhile now, but for those of us who want to keep this machine for 5+ years, might we see a more tangible benefit to 12 cores later? Or is the difference in speed for tasks likely to be essentially the same as now? (Also, will the fan be any more or less likely to kick on depending on number of cores?)
Once again - huge thanks, and really appreciate your presentational ways and the kind intention with which you offer your work!
I would say that the 1 extra cores will do you very little down the road.
Thank you! Do you see any downside to upgrading to 12 core besides money?
no downside like I said for the money spend you are better off upgrading your RAM, you'll see more performance jump, for the price significantly more.
Thank you again 🙏🏽 subscribing and will do what I can to help your channel succeed!
thank you!
Danke!
Welcome!
Dude your voice is so friggin young. Leave some egg yokes for the rest of us. Love the vid. thank you
thanks
You might have sold me on getting the $2k machine tomorrow…. Was debating it vs refurbished M2 Pro
That is a great value as well!
Amazing job what you did with your videos! Can you help me to decide please, if I should go with 14" M2 Max 12/38, 32GB, 2TB SSD or pay 300 extra for 14" M3 Pro 12/18, 36GB, 1TB SSD? Im doing mostly photo editing simultaneously in Lightroom and Photoshop for retouching (portraits, weddings, product photos), some music playing in background and Google chrome opened too. Im curious if I should go for newer generation for more battery life and less heat since its 14" size, or go for more powerful chip. Is it the same perfomance for my type of use? Or M2 Max will be more powerful? Because I would love to have less heat, less noise from the fans and better battery life but if its less power and better deal overall, I guess I would go with MAX.
Thank you very much for your help!
I would probably choose M2 Max in this case over the M3 Pro
Thank you very much for this detailed review. My situation is this:
I'm considering to buy either MBP 16", 12/18, 36GB, 512GB SSD OR MBP 14", 11/14, 36GB, 1TB.
Which one do you think I should get when we take in account the additional screen size, bigger battery and cooling capabilities of 16" as well as the unbinned chip. The only that worries me is the 512GB SSD on 16", do you think that would cause a bottleneck effect since 1TB SSD's seem to be faster? Do you think that 512GB SSD would in any way hurt better performance on the 16" as opposed to 1TB on 14"? Difference in price is minimal, cca 150 USD
Thank you in advance.
choose the size that works best for what you need. never mind the SSD size to speed ratio, they are on par, and even if they are not, which they are, you'll be hard press to see any variation on the daily. 16 has bigger battery but then you are carrying that around as well. Better thermo sure, but the performance between 14 and 16 of the same SoC are identical. All SoC are binned, just how much, either way variation between the two is null at best. Like I said, I would choose the size that you need.
Hello.. Can you compare the M1 Pro 16 inch vs the M3 Max base model 16"
Results are in the charts or you can check this video out as well th-cam.com/video/5r2D7EG4M38/w-d-xo.html
Is it possible that the 16” screen has an effect on performance that makes the comparison not quite apples to apples (I.e., has a speed drain for the larger screen real estate?)
no, all of them has display engine that does not load the GPU
28:24 excellent analysis Art! I’ve been using the early-2015 base MacBook Pro for the past 8 years, but I think you’ve just convinced me to upgrade to the base 14” M3P MacBook Pro with 32GB ram and base storage (rather than the top spec M3P chip with 18GB ram). Question for you though: do you think the 4 extra GPU cores on the top spec M3P chip would make a bigger difference if you were to play more intensive AAA games (I plan to install virtual windows and install Windows compatible AAA games into it) compared to other base M3P chip?
Thanks
I would also love a take on this situation as i just downgraded from 18c gpu to the 14c gpu, I keep going back and forth on the decision in case I start doing more 3d renderings and playing more games on my mac...
is the base M3 Pro good enough for smooth 4K playback and unreal engine? (No raytracing or high resolution textures, developing a cartoon 3D game)
probably
For AI/computer vision do you recommend the 14in 11 core cpu or the 12 core cpu, both would have 18gb ram
very little to no variation, still the same 16 NPU regardless of CPU variations.
Do we really need to upgrade the unified memory to 36gb in the M3 Pro14" base model, incase we use it for running tensorflow and machine learning algorithms most of the time ?
Please help me decide.
probably not, but it does not hurt to have more
Hey brother, love your channel can't wait to see what's more to come!
i am about to purchase a Macbook fore Premiere video editing. but i can't decide on:
MacBook M3 Pro 36GB RAM 512GB SSD 14-core 14.2 = 2.750 US
or
MacBook M3 Pro 18GB RAM 512GB SSD 14-core 14.2 = 2.140 US
WHAT DO YOU THINK?
I would choose 36GB if you can stretch it. Also price should jump by $400 US, not sure what ma I missing here, seems like all of the specs are the same beside RAM
Interesting comparison. What about M2 air 24gb vs M3 14 24gb? If I can't afford the preferred 36gb on M3 Pro. Which one is better? I mostly do coding and not video editing and have one ultrawide monitor. My current machine is 2015 MBP. Thanks!
Get the M3 Pro, forego the regular M3 that is all I can say
@@ArtIsRight Thank you! 🙌
The "slower" 512 SSD (fewer chips, less bandwidth) has some effect on export tests with M2P. Pretty sure the 1TB will give results closer to M3P.
M3 : nice upgrade for M1 systems.
M3 pro : to expensive versus M2P
ok
THANK YOU.
You're welcome!
@@ArtIsRight i bought the 14 inch m3 pro with the upgraded 36gb ram yesterday by the way :) now just anxiously waiting for it lol thanks again for this video!
Same with the video yesterday, your charts have "13MBP M3", and should they not read "14MBP M3"? I get for the older laptops the "13" was applicable, but the M3 does not come in a 13".
Yup didn't catch that. Thanks for pointing that out.
Excellent analysis. These system configurations Apple stipulate are so leading for spending more. $400 just to move up the ram from base is nuts
Yup, it happens many times that are engineering reason behind that as well
I'd really be interested in a comparison between the M3 Max with 14 core vs 16 core.
Coming Tuesday 11/14 - the date not CPU/GPU in the M3 Pro base ;)
Great! This will definitely be interesting, also in comparison to the M3 Pro and maybe even the good old M2 Pro. That being said, take your time, not sure how healthy your pace of pumping out those videos is. ❤ @@ArtIsRight
What would you recommend for PTGui Pro in the line up?
used that a long time ago, have too look at the app again
@@ArtIsRight Thank you! And a whole heap of virtual tour photographers will love you for that. There are over 15,000 registered Google Trusted photographers around the world who probably would love to see PTGui Pro in the testing line up as is stuck in the world of OpenCL and generally used by power users only who do large batches. And if you need any source files to standardise your testing, feel free to reach out to me. I'd be happy to provide you a file set.
Thanks again!
I makefull hd editing videos,doing zoom meeings, using Canva, after effects, premire/final Cut while using the web and want a good battery. Do you recommand the 11/14 and 18GB for me?
You should be fine with that, a good base line machine
Great comparison like to know about the fan noise with the 14 inch High End 12/18 M3 Pro compared with the 14 inch Basic M3 Max
Don't have the 14 Max base, so it would be difficult to tell.
Ok thank's I enjoyed your review
hi, is fan noise a problem with this 14" model? Thanks!
With the M3 Max, the 14" will be the loudest and warmest with the worst battery life. Better to get the 16" M3 Max or 14" M3 Pro.
relative, just get what you need.
I want to upgrade from my 2019 13” base model mbp. And hearing u recommend at least 32gb of ram. I’m considering buying the m3pro 14” with 36gb of ram and 1tb of storage. Would you recommend that configuration for someone who mostly uses it school work, coding, video/movie viewing and who uses After Effects for personal matters like editing short videos (normally within 10-20min) in 1080p and every now and then 4k. Idk my mbp now can barely run After Effects and that’s mainly why I want to upgrade and also SSD of course like 128gb is trash 😂 I can’t keep anything on it everything has to be kept in an external 🙃. Or is it overkill? I’d like to be able to use it for as along as I can too.
If you are not using the machine for intense photo work you might be able to get away with the base 14" model. Something to consider. But the Base M3 Pro in the 14" is a sweet machine
What did u choose?
@@marcOandrz I went for the m3pro 14” with the 36gb ram and 1tb storage . I hadn’t upgraded since 2019. And if I was gonna spend money on a MacBook I might as well spend it on the one I know would do the job and more. I’ve been using it for a little over a month and it’s light years better than my previous MacBook. It runs everything I need so nicely and I don’t have to worry about storage.
wow nice to hear. I'm still considering whether to go for 36 ram base or 1 TB as I'm also looking at my budget. I have similar usecases, but I'm not sure if 512 will be enough for me. But I think I'll go for the ram as I have alternatives (external or cloud storage). Thanks for the quick reply ;)@@eeveefromwall-e8459
wow nice to hear. I'm still considering whether to go for 36 ram base or 1 TB as I'm also looking at my budget. I have similar usecases, but I'm not sure if 512 will be enough for me. But I think I'll go for the ram as I have alternatives (external or cloud storage). Thanks for the quick reply ;)@@eeveefromwall-e8459
Could you compare the base M2 pro MacBook Pro and the base M3 pro MacBook Pro ?
don't have that machine in the studio
I just bought a refurbished M3 macbook with 24gb of ram and 1tb of storage (8core CPU, 10core GPU) using it for some (not super intense) video editing and for school. I had the option of getting the m3 pro for the same price but with less ram (18gb) but with more cores (11core cpu, 14core gpu).
I decided in the end the ram was more important than the cores. I’d love to know ur thoughts!!
This is an interesting one. Pro will benefit in overall speed and also when tasks run in long duration because of the fan. Personally I would choose Pro over Air
I generally prefer the Pro over air, but that depends on how intense your workflow is./\
@@ArtIsRight sorry I forgot to specify! I was deciding between TWO macbook pros. The base M3 with more storage and memory, or the M3 pro chip with less memory. Sorry if that was confusing!!
No worries, to my point I still prefer the "Pro" or higher SoC than just the plain one
When you show all the graphs, it's hard to see the two reference systems your testing amongst all the other systems. I would do something to highlight those so they're more quickly obvious at a glance.
I'll consider that, thanks
Sir could you please make a video comparison between macbook air 15 16gb/512gb vs macbook pro m3 base
not for this cycle
Right now macbooks are sale. And the 14 m3 pro 11/14 36+512 and 14 m3 pro 12/18 18+1024 are the same price. Which one should I choose? Could you give me some advice? Thanks!
I would go for more RAM
Useful info, thank you. Considering either the 12/18 core M3 Pro 14", or the 16/40 core M3 Max 16". These comparisons are helpful. Near the end you called the 16 inch a "12 inch" and then again the "16GB model" ha, but never mind. Great info still. Much, much better than nearly all other Mac videos on TH-cam, which are rushed out for views, and effectively just recite the press releases with no meaningful testing - "Oooh Space Black has less fingerprints - Hype!" - I really do not care... Silver will always be the best anyway :)
nice!
I didn't see benchmark of M3P 32G memory vs M3P 18G memory, but you recommended to upgrade to 32G memory instead of upgrading the M3P SoC, why?
for the money, better performance
Sir, what would you recommend
14MBP M3P 11/14 32 GB 512 GB OR 14MBP M3P 12/18 18 GB 512 GB ?
Main usage for video editing with premier pro, Da Vinchi and after effects.
14MBP M3P 11/14 32 GB 512 GB
Correction: That config has 36GB, not 32GB
Finally, your stats help me decide. I was half hearted between MBP 14" 12/18 - 18gb / 1TB vesus MBP 14" 11/14 - 36GB / 1TB
I've been researching for days now and the numbers you showed doesn't really justify the SoC difference of 12/18 vs 11/14
I'm gonna get more ram then :)
Awesome!
@@ArtIsRight by the way, hope you can do another video for these two again that will benchmark the gpu alone. Or can i get your insights if they are not too far off as well.
not going to see much change, marginal at best
Yeah So I bought the m3 14" pro with 24 gb or Ram. I am moving from having a 15" air. I miss the form factor of the air and the size. the 14" feels small on my lap I find myself leaning in looking at it. The screen is beautiful but I'm struggling to adjust. That being said, I'm considering returning it and getting the base 16 MBP, my concern is going from 24 gb of ram to 18gb of ram, I do see my 14" get up to 20gb of used memory in the activity monitor some times. It seems like the CPU/GPU and SSD will all be quicker on the 16" m3pro but I'll lose 6gb of ram, Should I be worried about this? Or do you think I'll be ok with the 18gb of Ram if I make the switch? (I am mainly running lots of browser tabs, apps and Canva)
side note even though I do see 16-18gb of ram used alot of the time it is always in the green on my current 14" with 24 gb
If you can get the 16MBP and upped the RAM
Please don’t forget the Logic Pro benchmarks!! Not all of us do video or photos
I don't use that pap
Which would be better to go with m2 pro MacBook Pro 14 vs MacBook Pro 14 m3 16 gb also is it worth spending more money for the m3 pro vs the m2 pro.
If you can save money on the M2 Pro which you can somewhat do that now. or even better yet get the 14 M2 Max from Costco for about 2K right now that is a great deal. But in general I would go with Pro SoC vs non Pro. And regarding M3 Pro vs M2 Pro, the variation is small, so If you can get a better spec M2 Pro, i.e. more memory/RAM, SSD then I would go with that
Will 11 core cpu wifh 36gb ram be a good configuration?
excellent
Possible to have comparison between 18GB ram vs 36GB in Pro model?
we'll have to see
Can anyone explain how the 11 core outperforms the 12 core on several tests?
better, surprisingly, not much about it. the software as we have time works better on the 11 than the 12 at this point
I'm Logic User: Logic use the P-Cores and with 6 P-Cores vs 5 P-Cores Logic use more Tracks
thanks
My wife in not a creator but she is using MS office apps daily and statistics analysis apps like Stata and Spss. And normally she works with 10+ tabs open and pdfs. Is 18gb of ram enough for her or should she upgrade as I rarely see anyone benchmarks with such apps if not never.
Yes 18GB will be more than enough for what she needs.
Art thank you again
I have a direct question for you, and if you could answer this with a fine point that would allow me to make my decision to buy my computer finally
I’ve asked this multiple times, but you’re different tests and chart results are still making me hesitate.
LRC, Adobe Photoshop some of the times with plug-ins, and also special effects software Nik etc.
I understand about your point about the 14 inch versus a 16 inch I am not traveling nor will I be traveling
Just to my house upstairs and downstairs or in the backyard that’s it
I need the real estate visually because of eyesight I like the larger screen
QUESTION: Please- Your Answer will allow me to finally finally buy the Laptop this week
16” 36gb (upgrade reason only for Ram)
M3Pro
VS.
Next jump up
16” M3 Max Base model
On your chart you show GOOD for LRC in the M3 pro where best or better would be the max
WHY? what major differences are we gaining to go to the max for LRC?
What is driving me crazy from seeing your tests the max base 16 inch is that much better in LRC versus the M3 pro 16 inch?
What lets it warrant a Better vs Good in chart
Could you please address those two Models versus each other what you gain speed wise to justify the jump in price to the base max in the 16 inch laptop? PLEASE
Art
This is the ONLY thing keeping me from deciding
M3 Max base
And here’s where I go crazy originally you said the
“MP3 Pro Would be be fine”
Now you’re saying the base max for what reasons the base max versus the M3 pro 32 GB please that’s what I need to know
In a couple of comments, your observations of what I would gain from the M3 base max over the M3, pro 32 GB?
I absolutely trust and respect you aren’t. I’m just trying to see from you observations of why? Why the M3 Max base versus the M3 pro 32 GB? What am I getting so I can justify the price jump
Ignore the Siri typos, lol my deepest respect to you, sir