Fight breaks out in Taiwanese parliament over chamber reforms
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 พ.ค. 2024
- A scuffle broke out in the Taiwanese parliament days before the president-elect, Lai Ching-te, takes office without a legislative majority.
Subscribe to Guardian News on TH-cam ► bit.ly/guardianwiressub
The opposition wants to give parliament greater scrutiny powers over the government, including a controversial proposal to criminalise officials who are deemed to make false statements in parliament. The ruling Democratic Progressive party has accused the opposition of improperly trying to force through the proposals without the customary consultation process in what they call 'an unconstitutional abuse of power'.
The Guardian publishes independent journalism, made possible by supporters. Contribute to The Guardian today ► bit.ly/3uhA7zg
Sign up to the Guardian's free new daily newsletter, First Edition ► theguardian.com/first-edition
Website ► www.theguardian.com
Facebook ► / theguardian
Twitter ► / guardian
Instagram ► / guardian
The Guardian on TH-cam:
The Guardian ► bit.ly/guardiannewssubs
Guardian Australia ► bit.ly/guardianaussubs
Guardian Football ► bit.ly/gdnfootballsubs
Guardian Sport ► bit.ly/gdnsportsubs
Guardian Live ► bit.ly/guardianlivesubs
#Taiwan #Politics #TaiwanNews #WorldNews
When Taiwanese politicians say 'we fight for you' to their constituents they really meant it.
Taiwan has a two-party system, so it is only a party struggle and has nothing to do with the truth of the incident.
Oh yeah
One of my Taiwanese friend told me that this fight that breaks up usually is preplanned. The constituents especially the older people felt that it meant the Assemblyman is fighting for you
@@christophers2937 i have an idea. There should be a Celebrity Deathmatch spinoff where its only politicians that would be featured.
骗别人可以，可是千万不要骗自己
Politicians playing WWE.
Still better than the actual WWE.
Former Prime Minister of Singapore, Mr. Lee “ democracy will only bring regression!”
They Are Fighting Like Indians So Much For Highest Developed Democracy...😂
@@22martinez1yea whatever u say matinez 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Please be informed:
The real game of expanding powers in the legislature should be to expose arms dealers, the US military, and US military aid programs in the Legislative Yuan. The construction projects in Eastern Taiwan are allowing Chinese funds and personnel to enter the hinterland of our national defense. All of this is paving the way for Xi Jinping's annexation of Taiwan by 2027. From the beginning, this has nothing to do with Taiwan's financial, livelihood, fairness, or justice. This marks the beginning of the second Cold War and a new axis of evil in the East Asian theater. Considering the joint statement issued by China and Russia yesterday, it seems that the activities of CPP around the world are intensifying.
That women on the left at 0:19 tried to hit a guy with a phone and midway realised this is not worth it.
Timing failed her 😂
Who does she think she is? Paul E. Dangerously?
😂😂
😂😂😂 thanks for your fastidious video screening
Lol
Elizabeth Swan:"this is madness "
Cap. Jack Sparrow : " no, this is Politics"
Holy moly I just rewatched it last night
Exactly what i was about to say. Just watched it though
No this is Patrick !
and it always resorts to fights lol
If my country were like this, I would never stop watching the sessions on the congress channel.
You'll be surprised to hear that Taiwan is deemed more democratic than your country.
Preach. If C-SPAN was like this, I'd have it on 24/7.
🤣 the TW news channels actually had live streaming all day for this event.
Well...we did have that whole Jan 6th thing, I guess that was pretty funny.
Ture
Bro took equal rights equal fights a little too seriously 💀💀
No he didn't.
@@travel4yourself yes he did
@@redmenacingbirb2492 No, he didn't.
@@travel4yourself ok ok you win
@@redmenacingbirb2492 Win what?
Just imagine this scene at the UK parliament Rishi Vs Starmer 😂😂
It’s right around the corner, once the truth comes out about Kate? They’re done!
I'd watch that on pay per view 😂😂
Go to Palestine
Where can i watch the full Movie?
Underrated comment 😂😂
porbhub you are welcome
Just look around.
True democracy
Thats why i like democracy and im not joking...
That's not democracy. This is barbaric.
@@adamdaniel8909Same. People get so passionate about their country.
@@adamdaniel8909democracy is a show for people
@@adlerzweiIt is not about their country, it is about their political career.
The lady with a helmet is a lawmaker too. She certainly came prepared.
She is crazy
@@jennychuang808他是我國離中共最近的離島（距離）選出的立法委員，家中有這些東西很正常吧(笑)😅😂😅
😄😅😆
why u call your people crazy...lol
😂😂😂😂
Kids in school : fight fight fight !!
i believe this is what is referred to as "robust debate".
Ну не в Грузии жоще! 🤔👌
"This is MADNESS!"
"This is politics."
This is the system that they desperately sell to mainland China and the rest of the world.
Pirates
Madness? THIS IS SPARTA!
"Politics? THIS. IS. TAIWAAAAANNN!!!"
It's another US backed democracy in actionQ
Politicians in our country are either too old too lazy to do this
😂😂😂
Or, hear me out.....
Maybe they are too mature to try that.
Nah@@beegreen249
@@beegreen249 what bs fairytale world do you live in?
@@beegreen249have u ever seen a mature politician anywhere? 😂...
Governments = corporations no matter what country
👍👍👍
You guys can also watch the Japanese version of this.
Indonesian too
You can't deny that they're passionate
Literally 😂👏👏
They are so corrupt ‘
@@bulldogfightingforfreedom Atleast they are not poor country, mine is is not only corrupt but also poor
@@jonlaurenzreyes1902 Mine too!
high five bro! ✋😂
@@jonlaurenzreyes1902what is your country? Indonesia? 😂
this is one of the calmer ones
😂😂😂😂
Yep, at least no chairs were thrown this time
Well... that's embarrassing.
It is never embarrassing for a country to have legislators who fight for the rights and interests of its people. The male legislator's party is striving to prevent the pro-China party, represented by the female legislator, from forcibly passing a bill that infringes on human rights and jeopardizes national security. He is fighting for Taiwan's democracy and freedom. If you prefer a parliament without dissenting opinions, please refer to China's National People's Congress, where people's rights perish in the peaceful and unanimous votes of the assembly.
@@fredchen2763 Fred, it was escalation to physical confrontation that was embarrassing, in a chamber that should be far more sober and professional. That said, we sincerely hope the pro-China party loses their political influence entirely in that parliament.
Say the American
@@ThepursuitofHappiness-fb8iy Or anyone who cares for freedom and independence.
Where to watch the full fight?
For Taiwanese parliament this is pretty common, just another day at the office 😊
But this is not what democracy is. If anyone resorts to violence in parliament, they can do much worse outside the parliament. This is why there is no hope in Taiwan.
@@Strawberryknight It's bourgeois democracy, that's why it doesn't actually work.
Not common in these days until DPP becomes minority in the parliament. They always resort to violence when they can't win.
@@Strawberryknight No, you are wrong! they could have dinner together later on pretending nothing had happened.
Please be informed:
The real game of expanding powers in the legislature should be to expose arms dealers, the US military, and US military aid programs in the Legislative Yuan. The construction projects in Eastern Taiwan are allowing Chinese funds and personnel to enter the hinterland of our national defense. All of this is paving the way for Xi Jinping's annexation of Taiwan by 2027. From the beginning, this has nothing to do with Taiwan's financial, livelihood, fairness, or justice. This marks the beginning of the second Cold War and a new axis of evil in the East Asian theater. Considering the joint statement issued by China and Russia yesterday, it seems that the activities of CPP around the world are intensifying.
its a normal day in taiwanese politics
Bringing shame to china
是的！這在台灣很常發生，是超級擂台賽😅
@@warsonggulch6998 lol, this would never go down in China, only in a democracy with opposing parties.
Free entertainment with politics as intermissions? Count me in.
Everybody was Kung Fu Fighting!
i love how they are just wrestling instead of serving punches here and there.
That is very democractic.
就差沒有帶炸彈！帶槍了
@@gazacao2007 我覺得應該標配武士刀
@@gazacao2007 seeing youtube in VN great
❤❤👍
Everybody was kung fu fighting
"Those cats were fast as lightning."🤣
@@22martinez1 in fact it was a little bit fright’ning 😅
LITTLE BIT FRIGHTENING!!!!
Please be informed:
The real game of expanding powers in the legislature should be to expose arms dealers, the US military, and US military aid programs in the Legislative Yuan. The construction projects in Eastern Taiwan are allowing Chinese funds and personnel to enter the hinterland of our national defense. All of this is paving the way for Xi Jinping's annexation of Taiwan by 2027. From the beginning, this has nothing to do with Taiwan's financial, livelihood, fairness, or justice. This marks the beginning of the second Cold War and a new axis of evil in the East Asian theater. Considering the joint statement issued by China and Russia yesterday, it seems that the activities of CPP around the world are intensifying.
🤣
why did this happen?
In the 21 second mark, the hot girl took out her cellphone and tried to hit someone with it but missed. This could be a felony?
She swung but missed, so attempted misdemeanor
All’s fair in politics and war…
I'm Taiwanese. I promise you it's completely fine. I've never seen a fight in Congress or been sentenced to criminal law.
It's almost midnight now & they're all still in the parliament trying to pass the law (& trying to stop it passing)
(Except the ones who got injured during the fight)
filibuster....
Shame on DDP!
xiami law?
DPP ones were sent to ER, then went home right after, but KMT one who was former prosecutor, went back to fight with his teammate.
Shame on KMT and TPP
A parliamentary tradition here, for some reason.
After this fight and the law passing, these will become history
What's the reason for the fighting please I really want to know
Because Taiwan's opposition parties, the Kuomintang and the People's Party (which are not in power but hold a majority in parliament), are pushing Congress to expand its power in an attempt to check and balance the power of the president (Lai Ching-te of the Democratic Progressive Party).
i have time for this
And I thought American politics was wild!
Because they are serving the same master !
@@simonsimon1814but guns aren’t that rare in Taiwan. Lots of Taiwanese do have guns. If I remember correctly a store got shot over 50 shots yesterday.
@@user-bi8ko7kc6h Of course people have guns illegally anywhere. Compared to US, situation is not as bad . You cited a single incident in Taiwan, I can cite a 100 cases which happen everyday in the US.
same
@@simonsimon1814我不知你們國家是否也像台灣這樣貪污很嚴重，甚至我們民間有個說法「貪污沒關係，有作點事情就好」😅😅
Misleading. They weren’t fight for chamber reform but the discussion of the reforms before approval, their rights.
The majority went straight to approval before the legislation was finalized, distributed, reviewed, and discussed.
thank you for context.
Actually that reform was base on the DPP old reform back in the day , and when the opposition party made the new reform and DPP goes nuts and try whether they can to stop it happening as everyone seeing now.
If DPP being serious they can complete that reform during the past 8 years already , they are the party who has the most vote back then.
Plus : the DPP even try to rob the staff of Legislature for the reform official documents
@@leetony5162Im sorry, but can you explain it more about the detail of this reform? The opposition is KMT, right?
I saw some furniture moving 😂
Dude hit a double leg on that lady
She had zero takedown defense she’s gotta work on that
Equal Right - Equal Fight
@@fajarkurniawan9434damn right! hahaha
@@MythowarsTDD stat is on zero 😂
@@fajarkurniawan9434how ? He did that unprovoked
I think this is like the 3rd time in my life where I've seen a video of a Taiwanese Chamber brawl. Well in a way, you can clearly see that everybody(deeply) cares about what's going on within the country, especially with a potential war breaking out from the Mainland just over the horizon.
you spoke like a eight-year-old. They don't fight when there was no camera, don't you know?
他们只关心自己的选票
Chinese*
We are tangled
MMA is for amateurs. Taiwanese parliament is for the pros.
In the voice of Jim Ross, its STONE COLD ITS STONE COLD 😂
And a guy tackled a woman. Yes, it's just like WWE
Randy Orton slithering....WATCH OUT! WATCH OUT!!!
😂😂😂
@@fabr1cated Spear! Spear! Spear!
Lol
Democracy??
that's what they say.
Demo crazy 😂😅😢
The western one, yes.
Says who CCP supporters 😂
US backed "super democracy"!!!
did that woman try to bash a person w/ her phone!??
So...where was the fight?
This is pretty shameful tbh
They've been doing this many times...
do you even realise what the context is? being ignorant is whats shameful. being emotional over an authoritarian regime crippling your nation's democracy is the least shameful thing i can imagine
Have a look at south african parliament... that is shameful.
@@thelaststraw1467explain me, what is happening?
@@dalexisfantasy lol nothing im messing with everyone
Anyone know where I can watch the full fight?
I want to know what the reforms were
What was this scuffle over?
The entire world has gone nuts 😂
I think the slime from Ghostbusters is oozing up everywhere
Welcome to the circus
It already did, from the very beginning
They have been doing this for more than 40years.
Welcome To Roman Politics.
Why can't Americam congress be this exciting?
Old men cannot fight.
We have Jerry Springer and Maury Pulvich for that 😆
a bunch of old people with alzheimers forgot how to fight and just roll over when conflict happens
Lol, the old run American.
@@willywonka4340 biden: Let's ready to mumble!!!
As a tourist I thought Taiwan of being very peaceful. Seeing this now is a bit shocking 😳
If there is supposed to be a legitimate government in that room I don't see one.
What is even more shameful is that the police officers responsible for security were assaulted by these Legislative Council Members, who claimed that it was the police officers who were blocking their way
DPP should feel ashamed of themselves. Police is there for their duty.
The police were blocking the DPP members. If you are a Taiwanese and really watch live streaming feed in the chamber you would know. The KMT members are some of the worst politicians who share ties with the mafia and they were trying to pass an unconstitutional bill. It wasn’t chamber reform it was corruption.
甚至是媒體和議事人員也被DPP攻擊，不說還以為回到70年前
呵 幫北京做事的能當台灣國會議員 也算人類的奇蹟了。
Actually is not, the KMT party have much more power in police system. They ask the media take the picture maked the news, and named it liked the DDP party are offence.
It's not easy to said what happened cause the KMT party have the resource in school system, police system, media company (which used be own by KMT goverment during 1953~ 2005). Not metion about that CHINA goverment use their dirty hand to block down our Diplomacy and Economic with the world.
No one talks about a man attacking a woman almost using wrestling techniques. Shameful!
They were aiming for true equality 😅
They also hit security guards, slapping another guy’s face, attacked a 70+ old man , that’s how far DPP can go just to stop the other two parties from reforming which the reform were promised by DPP themselves 8 years ago
Conservative endorsed attacks on woman. They mask it as equality
He apologized several times afterwards.
@@turingcs2001 you think an apology for that kind of behavior is enough?
Imagine trying to catch Jackie Chan in that?
And they say our politicians are crazy
2024 TAIWAN parliament edition is little boring tbh !
always they act like kids, very immature
They're premature adults 😂 !
Nah, this is what happens when words fail. Produces better results.
At least they didn't use walking cannes like in the old days in U.S. House.
他們好像在玩戰略遊戲一樣，執政黨攻佔主席台，反對黨保護主席台讓程序進行
@@_Aeon_ ill do you one better, At least they didn't get on all 4s like in the old days during imperial china
Do you not have a formal way of expressing concern?
Everybody was kung fu fighting.
Absolutely embarrassing.
They have been doing this for the last 10 years.
No, the Taiwanese are proud of it. They think it's an expression of democracy. You can see their justification in the comments.
@@luisgabrieldelmo772thank you DPP hahahahah
The president doesn't care and doesn't know what to do.... 60% is pro China hahahahahhaha
Actually it’s not! They are fighting with their life to protect Taiwan’s democracy!
The reforms, proposed by the Kuomintang (KMT) and the Taiwan People's Party (TPP), "exceed the bounds of those found in constitutional democracies around the world, subvert the rule of law and parliamentary procedures," the statement said.
Quoted by Ex-AIT directorand two dozen academics!
“Everybody was kung fu fighting”
What happened
Some real fight
AH this is how true democracy should look like.🤣
Make sure it dose not spread out.
我懷疑你在諷刺我們但我沒有證據😂😂（笑）
@@c-h-c-c4944 不然學習包子：有沒有人反對？ "沒有!" "沒有!" "沒有!"
習包子：好，沒有反對，通過！
有比較民主嗎？
@@user-oz7ik6xs8x 所以你的认知只有这些。在TG，所有分歧都在会前得到解决，会议是统一思想执行决定，不是探讨问题。
🤣👉🤡，整天喊民主喊的。对对对，全世界就你最民主了，继续打，全世界当猴看。
everybody look here, a Taiwanese said, "Nevertheless, our democracy is still superior. It's no problem for our members to fight in the parliament, because this is our democracy, and it's still much better than everyone else."
*Now you know where Jerry Springer got his idea for a TV show...*
These people were furious wow
I was waiting for a "Hadouken!"
This is what the UK parliament is missing. The childish insults are the wildest you will see anywhere in the world.
Well, this is different...
quite surprised, Rishi can last so long
@@aloyd6157 AS LONG AS IS NEEDED...
The UK parliament has moved past the childish phase. There are more than one way to resolve conflicting ideas and physical fights are the lowest form. Besides, words cut deep, even after the meeting. They tend to stick with you for a long time and influence your behaviour at a later time. This benefits the ones who insults you. They actually changed you from the inside to fit their image. Fighting you physically doesn't produce the same effect.
@@MrDosonhai INDEED... VERY OLD MEDIEVAL INSTITUTION... AGREE WITH YOU ON THIS MATTER... CAN NOT COMPARE TAIWAN WITH UK... THOW BOTH ARE ISLANDS...
Taiwan government is more funny than the professional entertainment show.
What’s this about?
A lady hitting with her phone 😂
As a Taiwanese, this is insane to see. People are standing up against violence in congress. Besides, this also happened because the party with more people(KMT) and TPP are trying to pass a law that we don’t even know what it is about! However, this law is trying to oppress our freedom of speech and put people in jail if you are considered “contempt of congress” which includes talking back to the congress man and refusing to go to the congress as a person(not limited to citizens). The penalty and definitions are all unclear and whenever DPP( the party with less people) what to open a stage for debate and exchanging ideas. They end the discussion!!! This is insane and we as Taiwanese have to stand up to this to protect our freedom of speech and democracy!!!!
preach
If you can read, then you will know about it.
Why do you sound like a helldiver 2 character
they just want to return to their original roots ie dictatorship
U need to with China.
U guys are not different same skin same religion same language.
B together b stronger.
Not even a single punch? What kind of a fight is this?
Per US standards: Very heart warming American democratic showing
I wish. US never has this happen. Ever. I’ve never seen it once inside.
No, your ignorance is showing. The last proper fight in Congress was in 1902, so more than a century ago.
*Therefore, the Taiwanese people are eager to return to Chinese rule and are extremely disgusted with the existing pseudo-democratic system. They fight every day and cannot pass bills.*
@@peabase yep I just read it and it sounded like a decent fight not this its a pantomime for the cameras. if you mean it you fight for it
@@blackout07blue I guess that means US is not democratic enough. Taiwan is leading now. 😂
Why is this a thing now? Seems to be happening every week
It's a tradition of Taiwanese parliament. It's partly for their own amusement
These scenes were quite common in the 80s…can’t believe it’s still happening today
Don’t like the KMT either but over the last eight years, the Democratic DPP has committed numerous disgraceful acts, and they've tried everything to prevent the bill from being passed. Those who have closely followed recent party negotiations know that DPP legislators never seriously read the provisions but merely delayed proceedings with the aim of obstructing the bill's passage. They even proposed 80 different versions of the bill, with each version differing only in punctuation and a few words. Despite their majority in Congress, the DPP failed to deliver on the reforms promised over the past eight years. It's clear that there's no bill that can't be passed, only those that the DPP doesn't want to pass. Holding all the power, they have allowed Taiwan's wealth gap to reach 66 times while deceiving the international community with claims that only the DPP can protect Taiwan's sovereignty, resulting in severe hardship for the people of Taiwan.
I'm not surprised. Most DPP voters aren't very bright. Most DPP voters think that Trump is a protector of Taiwan's democracy (after he tried to end America's democracy). Most DPP voters are pro-lgbt rights & pro-vaccine but keep on trying to court Republican politicians from America.
Bring my man Jackie Chan, and it'll become a movie scene!
Is Jackie Chan Taiwanese...m
Nah bring Jet LI, Donnie Yen, and Michelle Yeoh into this brawl.
There is even a legislator playing a recorder on site.
@@adamdaniel8909His wife is Taiwanese
Jackie Chan is a CPP shill.
A truer form of democracy than we get.
Can you Imagine the amount of Chinese laughter that erupted to this clip?
china smiling watching this 😂😂😂
China：This is your said democracy??? We won't fighting in the parliament. We have civilization.
Chinese smiling/laughing watching this here...lol
...jealously. China's National People's Congress is just a rubber stamp.
Taiwan should learn from CCP, 不同意的请举手
No, this is TAIWAN show. It has nothing to do with CCP. Taiwanese always like to talk about things outside the topic.
You have to wear a helmet to work.
他是金門縣的立法委員，也是台灣抵抗中國第一線的地方，家裡放個頭盔很正常吧（笑😂😂）
@@c-h-c-c4944 不是喔 她有動過腦手術
Not the first time.
So no be only Nigeria
What a passion
A all out brawl 😂
"And that is how the inning will end"
Is this common?
It's about congress reform. Guess the ruling party doesn't like it.
The reform was promised by the ruling party 8 years ago , now 8 years has passed they did nothing but lies ,and yes they trying very hard to stop the other two parties fulfilling promises which made by the ruling party
Yes,Our Taiwan congress If there is a bill to be passed, it needs more than half of the votes, but this time, no political party has more than half of the parliament. Furthermore, Taiwanese officials are currently not subject to jail for lying. All the opposition parties will try their best to get the bill passed, and the ruling party will find ways to block it.
@@Ohwowwoewhat is the bill about?
@@championred3619 Contempt of Congress
@@championred3619主要是立法規定公務員被立法委員質詢時不可隱瞞或欺騙（國防和外交機密除外），否則會有刑責
Shameful. Disgraceful. Uncivilised.
So I guess making "under the table" deals and rampant corruption is considered civilized, I suppose.
politics, basically.
@@demigodgamezThey do both. Why do you think they locked up their ex president Chen Shui Bian?😂😂
@@sigerlion8608
I'm not saying that the Taiwanese government does not have any corruption.
I'm saying that since OP considered the fights as "uncivilized", then "under the table" deals are then considered "civilized".
@@demigodgamez Yes, and I'm saying the Taiwanese government has both. They have that extra spicy brawl "incivility" that other most gov don't have.
Its just royal rumble, wait for the wrestlemania
The name of the movie?
In case you guys do not know, while our officials are questioned, they are allowed to:
1. Leave freely.
2. Fight back.(Talk back, sorry for the wrong wording)
3. Lie.
4. Take nap.
5. Deny answering or providing file, even it is hardly about national security.
Would not be fired or punished, and some people want to keep it that way. Guess if it is the same party that tackle guy belongs to.😏
If fight can really solve political differences..use punches to settle..whose punches strongest who had right take charge.. what a shame for Taiwan.. behaviour is outrageous..no anger management..
thank you
@@glentok1977 Sorry for my wrong wording, normally it's "talk back", officials would answer like "在那叫什麼?" which close to "who do you think you are?" or “不必去查”(no need to investigate that further).
they even won't answer directly to the question always talking about ideal or history
Feeling ashamed...
They better need hold together.
Before china does.
Why? We are defending our democratic freedoms. what have you done? Nothing at all
Things like this also happen in Japan regularly. Watch the Japan version.
This is real democracy.
Por um momento, achei que era aqui no Brasil.
As a Taiwanese I’ve never been this embarrassed before
Why sounds like it’s the first time…
At least Nymphia Wind got to perform for President Tsai.
Actually Ive never been prouder
@@federiconiedpp chimp out whenever they lose a vote
You guys had to know your time was coming up, we Americans couldn't be the laughing stock forever.
A war is going to break out in this tiny island
Malaysian parliament: *the loudest mockery and yelling in malls screaming*
Taiwanese parliament: 💪🏋️♂️🤜🤕🤬
What....the..... Sharmful!