I always believed that the real reason for him to go back was to distract the Pinkertons and gang from going for John. It may be false but I’d like to believe he went down in a final stand.
@@egggamer1800 that doesn't mean shit, it could simply mean Arthur is telling himself he's going for the money but deep down wants to kill Micah. You can't take everything at face value
Surprised they didn’t have something like this happen also for the honorable decision. Like Arthur knock out teeth when smacking Micah with the gun or something like that
I honestly prefer the go back for the money. The run back is awesome with the music and the scene in the flaming camp just looks cool. It shows the end of the gang. However I’ve only ever done High honour - go back for the money. I’m currently midway through my first low honour run.
I'd done my second playthrough, and I was really tempted to do the go-back-for-the-money option. But I just couldn't bring myself to do it. I just didn't feel right.
I find it funny Micah says "your buddy Arthur did this to me I won" when Arthur was pretty much dead from TB already with most his strength gone like well done Micah you barely won against someone with almost no strength left dying from a disease
I know going back for the money isn't the right choice but the ending where Arthur gets stabbed, pulls the knife out and proceeded to cut Micahs eye, all while dying from TB. just an absolute beast in this ending
@@cb-9938 Well TB can cause a slow death, he does give a slight hoarse noise as he says 'Your buddy, Arthur! Did this to me! *Hic* I won! Maybe his time out in the cold has finally caught up with him
There's two go for the money ends High honor:you cut micah eye and die watching the sunset at camp And low honor, you don't cut micah eye and you get stabbed
Oh yes that is true and also notice how when arthur wasn't sick micah wasn't piping up to him at all but then when arthur does get sick micah starts having goes at him. Because micah even said that arthur can fight which makes me think to believe he truly knows arthur would absolutely snap him in half in a hand to hand fight.
@@Max-Muirhead Exactly. Even one foot in the grave Arthur was still holding his own against Micah. If he were healthy, Arthur would *destroy* that rat in a straight up fight.
TB doesn't destroy muscle until the final stages, and in the high honor go with john, he literally beat micah and only lost because dutch stepped on the gun. keep in mind, he was thrown off of a mountain and nearly choked out. arthur could've beat him when he was sick if it wasn't for dutch or being thrown off the cliff.
@@VegetaLF7 arthur is just built different man. Micah couldn't kill arthur even when he is minutes away from death. He even has a line where he says to micah can't even kill a dying man.
I think if you have high honour, it should say "Stop Micah" or "Save John". Only low honour should return for the money, but we all know high honour Arthur is canon
Making the choice called something like “Go after Dutch and Micah” could divide the players more and they could believe they’re still helping John by either escaping or fighting. And maybe low honour could still be “Go back for the money” despite Arthur on his deathbed and the money being useless. Honestly I never understood why Arthur would go back for the money if John didn’t care for it
I have completed the story four times, and I discovered new things every single time I played. You are right, the bar has been set. It is unlike Rockstar to create such beautiful characters ✨️ but they did an amazing job here
I wish I could replay the story mode compagne again but with all the challenges still saved from my previous gameplay and all the rare animal pelts that I saved for my clothing except the legendary animals I don’t mind hunting them again those are fun to hunt on a second replay. I wish Rockstar update there settings for story mode or inleast give you the option to wear any outfit you want on replay mission just like you have that option in GTA 5.
I kind of like that you can only scar Micah the dishonorable way, you cannot have it both ways, ties to john on American Venom, and how choosing revenge in the end, sealed his fate by letting Ross know he was still alive.
How would Ross know it was John, he didn't even know him. Ross still had to search for him, and likely found word of him in Blackwater. I mean he owns a ranch half a mile away under his real name, Ross would've found him eventually either way
@ClaytonTheCracker oh yeah,it wasnt really shown in credits but its pretty much clear they could check sisika records for validation.Question that's still left unanswered is when they finally bothered Marston's family or it was the beggining of 1911 and i worry too much...never know.
As much as I love the choice where you help John, this choice is so much more cinematic. A bloody knife fight, Dutch's hopeless way of pleading for them to stop fighting, Arthur's biting way of digging into Micah's betrayal. Also, Arthur's "Not Molly, Dutch. Him. Hiiim!" is just so fucking gut wrenching. And how Arthur can just barely position himself towards the rising sun. Jesus this ending does not get enough credit.
@@alboorts If it isn't canon, why is it a fully programmed, scripted and mo-capped scene created by the devs? If it's a valid option provided by the game, it's canon ... unless literally half of all moral options and every evil deed you're allowed to commit in RDR2 somehow isn't canon either.
@@alboorts I mean, up until the GTAO Franklin mission where he references a "movie producer friend" of his (which more or less confirmed Option C), each of the three endings were equally legitimate outcomes. I mean, if the devs went through the trouble of adding them in as options, why wouldn't it be? And even at that, the endings in GTA5 result in different people being alive, whereas the choices at the end of Arthur's story results in the same overall outcome, so there's genuinely no reason why going back for the money isn't canonically possible. You know, kinda fitting you've taken yourself after John Marston, because it does seem like some of the wolves ate part-a yer brain! 😜👍
@@alboorts Tuberculosis isn’t transmitted through bodily fluids, just from respiratory droplets. I’m honestly surprised that he didn’t transmit it to anyone else seeing as each time an infected person exhales, they spread the bacteria everywhere in front of them.
I’m going through a dishonorable path, but I don’t know if I can bring myself to miss the Arthur ending on top of the mountain 💔 it’s just so satisfying.
I can’t watch him die I have to look away until it’s over every time I have to do it. The game makes you grow to love him so much and then rips him away like that. Dropped my controller and started crying the first time I had to do it. I thought it broke my heart enough when he said thank you to his dying horse but then I had to see him die too.
I like this ending going back to get the money to try and give John, Abigail, and Jack a life none of them ever could've dreamed of. I've never understood why people hate it so much.
Exactly, like what was Arthur going to do with the money at that point? He was too far gone then- He just wanted everyone to be fine after he was gone. Even if he did act like a psychopath in that route I like to think that taking the money to give John was a way to soften the blow. He was bad and knew his actions affected everyone-
Aside from not being able to scar Micah in any other ending the one thing I hate about the endings is that no matter what you do it's a final confrontation with Micah and Dutch as Arthur. Because it's just odd that they both come back to camp and chase Arthur and John at the same time depending on what ending you choose. In my opinion it probably would have been better for Arthur to die from TB fending off the Pinkertons in the ending where you help John and then die to Micah in the get the money ending
well, dutch and micha wmey back for the miwny and then got up the hill. it would take longer for arthur and john to get up because they had no horse, and it’s only a few minutes walk away to go back to beaver hollow, weirdly enough
holy shit I just noticed that in the beginning of the game it's only arthur & dutch & micah and in the near ending of the game it's also arthur & dutch & micah lol.
I don't like that you have to do dishonored action to scar Micah,but I like to think that high honor Arthur goes there either to kill Micah,or to get the money for John and his family.Since getting the money for himself would be pointless he was already dying.
4:46 I had not think about it and you're right, that scar could make him remember Arthur everyday for all those 8 years. It's curious that Micah calls Jonh "Scarface" when he even lost his eye with that scar
Exactly, that was my thinking. Everytime he can’t see in that side of his face or looks at himself in the mirror he thinks of Arthur. That’s why now in most of my recent Playthroughs I always go back for the money on high honor.
@@RDBTheRedDeath I literally just chose this ending with high honor about an hour ago. This is my second playthrough and on my first I chose the mountain with high honor as well. It was so satisfying to get that bastard's eye. And this ending isn't as sad as the mountain one so I didn't weep like a child, so that was a bonus lol. Although the horse dying always gets me.
Micah: "Hello scarface" "John: You can't be talking Micah not anymore" Micah: "Yeah your right. Black lung got one good hit in before i left him to die" John: "By the end of this, your eye ain't gonna be the last thing you lost Micah" Micah: "Very scary scar face. I wonder if your family will have the same attitude" John: "You wont live to find out"
Seeing the "you ain't better" and "arthur came for the money" is funny. In the end i guess micah declared everyone as awful as him because they were all outlaws, kinda why he got captivated by dutch so much.
He says he won - against a man who was at the end stages of tb, and had been through so much already. and he *still* barely beat him. That wasn't winning. If Arthur were even a month back in the progression of TB, Micah wouldn't have even stood a chance. He has a lot a guts sayin he won
Exactly. To proudly say he won against Arthur in his late stages of TB is like saying that you won a fight against 10 guys, except they were all 7 year olds. That's really nothing to boast about lmao. Micah was such a piece of shit.
@@UnchainedMelodie92 He's right. Nothing matters to Micah, he just needs to be able to claim he "won". Micah doesn't care that he "won" because Arthur is weakened, he only cared that he "won"
"your buddy Arthur did this to me... I won" Micah bragging about barely beating a dying man who had almost nothing left and yet still got his ass kicked lol. The final mission reveals that Micah pulls the sneaky, backstabbing moves that he does because he's very clearly not a fighter or badass. Healthy Arthur wrecks Micah with zero difficulty lol
My first playthrough was Low Honor! I was the worst Arthur you could imagine killing and robbing anyone with no remorse! But I plan on playing again with high honor!
Rich he says “Arthur gave this to me…I won” when he was having a hell of a time trying to stay alive knife-fighting a man seconds away from dying of TB.
@@goodboi1725 nah in the bad honor ending you don’t even cut out his eye, micah just dodged arthur’s knife shots and laughs at him and tackles him and shoved a knife in his chest
I mean john can run away from the pinkertons by himself, he's no push over so arthur could choose to go for the money (and not worry) to either get it for johns family or to get dutch ad micah away from john as a sort of distraction so it does make sense and makes arthur slash micahs eye as a bonus (and if you say "john is wounded, he can't do shit" Arthur could shoot straigth being almost dead by tb so john can handle a shoulder wound)
You know something I dont think anyone realized. Arthur cuts Micah's eye with his knife, Micah stabbed Arthur with his own knife. When Downes spat blood into Arthur's face he got TB. Micah shouldve gotten it from Arthur's blood being on the knife
This is the canon ending Micah would of killed John and Dutch if he saw him draw but Micah didn’t see Dutch draw on him because he didn’t have his eye Dutch might not of been there to kill Micah but to recruit him again but was reminded about Arthur from John and seeing the scar on Micah’s face
When arthur died on my game play his right hand did not fall it went the other direction and i said so many times fall hand fall hand fall hand FALLL JUST HAND FALL but than i transformed into john
I wish you could fuck him up like that without going back for the money. It’s nice knowing Arthur made Micah’s life just a bit more unpleasant post mortem, but not worth missing the proper good ending for
How do you actually take his eye cause if you play as the good guy then go back for the money you just fuck up his eye real bad so how do you actually take his eye out ?
![Red Dead Redemption 2 & 1 - All Gang Members' Deaths (from Davey to Abigail) [PC, 4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5gjVpYQ9DWQ/mqdefault.jpg)
See all of John’s HIDDEN DIALOGUE With Micah on the mountain th-cam.com/video/MLJ2JTfFhbM/w-d-xo.html
Thank you
Honestly, I like to think in the dishonorable ending, Arthur isn’t really trying to get the money, rather trying to kill Micah out of hatred.
As shocking as it seems I kinda think he was also there to kill Dutch although I'm not sure he'd go through with it.
I always believed that the real reason for him to go back was to distract the Pinkertons and gang from going for John. It may be false but I’d like to believe he went down in a final stand.
That's absolutely the reason! He even curses them out after picking the decision.
The decision is called “go for the money” not go for micah
@@egggamer1800 that doesn't mean shit, it could simply mean Arthur is telling himself he's going for the money but deep down wants to kill Micah. You can't take everything at face value
It’s quite unfortunate that the only way to scar Micah is to choose the dishonourable decision
Surprised they didn’t have something like this happen also for the honorable decision. Like Arthur knock out teeth when smacking Micah with the gun or something like that
I honestly prefer the go back for the money. The run back is awesome with the music and the scene in the flaming camp just looks cool. It shows the end of the gang. However I’ve only ever done High honour - go back for the money. I’m currently midway through my first low honour run.
I'd done my second playthrough, and I was really tempted to do the go-back-for-the-money option. But I just couldn't bring myself to do it. I just didn't feel right.
And I’d never choose the dishonourable decision. Never. High honour Arthur is a must.
If they had replaced the decision from “return for the money” to “get revenge on Micah and Dutch” then I feel like a lot more people would pick it
I find it funny Micah says "your buddy Arthur did this to me I won" when Arthur was pretty much dead from TB already with most his strength gone like well done Micah you barely won against someone with almost no strength left dying from a disease
on god
micah did not actually win, pretty sure that arthur had the upper hand before old dutch turned up again to save his ass.
And hes still acting like a tough guy
"can't even kill a dying man"
@@whocaresidontfuckoff In both endings, Dutch saves Micah
Arthur dying with a hat is so cursed and I genuinely don't know why.
Lol
dying with style my friends
well because Micah knocks it off in the high honor scene during their fight but that doesn't happen in knife fights
@@potatoman7594no Arthur gives his hat to John
@@TheChosennn oh yeah
I know going back for the money isn't the right choice but the ending where Arthur gets stabbed, pulls the knife out and proceeded to cut Micahs eye, all while dying from TB.
just an absolute beast in this ending
If you think about it, there’s a chance that Arthur could have given Micah tuberculosis from slashing him with that same knife
@@igneousrock654 I thought that too, but sadly no. Atleast Micah had a permanent reminder that he lost a fight to a dying man
@@cb-9938 Well TB can cause a slow death, he does give a slight hoarse noise as he says 'Your buddy, Arthur! Did this to me! *Hic* I won! Maybe his time out in the cold has finally caught up with him
@@igneousrock654 from what I heard tb is in 9/10 people it just doesn’t do anything most times unless regular drinking/smoking
There's two go for the money ends
High honor:you cut micah eye and die watching the sunset at camp
And low honor, you don't cut micah eye and you get stabbed
we all can agree that if Arthur wasn't sick he would absolutely destroy Micah
Oh yes that is true and also notice how when arthur wasn't sick micah wasn't piping up to him at all but then when arthur does get sick micah starts having goes at him. Because micah even said that arthur can fight which makes me think to believe he truly knows arthur would absolutely snap him in half in a hand to hand fight.
And especially arthur would destroy micah in a duel.
@@Max-Muirhead Exactly. Even one foot in the grave Arthur was still holding his own against Micah. If he were healthy, Arthur would *destroy* that rat in a straight up fight.
TB doesn't destroy muscle until the final stages, and in the high honor go with john, he literally beat micah and only lost because dutch stepped on the gun. keep in mind, he was thrown off of a mountain and nearly choked out. arthur could've beat him when he was sick if it wasn't for dutch or being thrown off the cliff.
@@VegetaLF7 arthur is just built different man. Micah couldn't kill arthur even when he is minutes away from death. He even has a line where he says to micah can't even kill a dying man.
The option should’ve never been “go back for the money”
It should’ve been “go after Micah” so many people would’ve been fine picking that ending
only if you had high honour
Wait just a minute you got mentioned in gxk the new empire
I would have made it "stop Micah" to contrast with "save John"
I think if you have high honour, it should say "Stop Micah" or "Save John". Only low honour should return for the money, but we all know high honour Arthur is canon
Making the choice called something like “Go after Dutch and Micah” could divide the players more and they could believe they’re still helping John by either escaping or fighting. And maybe low honour could still be “Go back for the money” despite Arthur on his deathbed and the money being useless. Honestly I never understood why Arthur would go back for the money if John didn’t care for it
This game is just beautiful. It needs to be put in a museum
It has set the standard in gaming for me.
I have completed the story four times, and I discovered new things every single time I played. You are right, the bar has been set. It is unlike Rockstar to create such beautiful characters ✨️ but they did an amazing job here
I wish I could replay the story mode compagne again but with all the challenges still saved from my previous gameplay and all the rare animal pelts that I saved for my clothing except the legendary animals I don’t mind hunting them again those are fun to hunt on a second replay. I wish Rockstar update there settings for story mode or inleast give you the option to wear any outfit you want on replay mission just like you have that option in GTA 5.
9.9/10.
@Connor Fry 60fps on console. Core game is 10/10 though. Dlc would make it like a 15/10
Bro you got Arthur dressed up like Charlie Chaplin wtf
Lmfao, I just got excited when I was heading back to beaver hollow and discovered I could pick up a hat for the final battle
Drip$
@@RDBTheRedDeath that looks like what hosea wore when he died
@@Nobody_In_Particular He Beith Of The Rodentia Dutch! Rodentia!
He went out with style
Something about the transition from crash of worlds to American venom, is beautiful.
Thanks, I thought so as well so I really wanted to play around with the idea. Glad you like that lol
@@RDBTheRedDeath well done.
It’s unspoken by d’angelo not crash of worlds
@@gossipmongersaunt774 Crash of Worlds is the Arthur's Death version, and its not "Unspoken" its Unshaken.
@@laitesuit Virgin
I kind of like that you can only scar Micah the dishonorable way, you cannot have it both ways, ties to john on American Venom, and how choosing revenge in the end, sealed his fate by letting Ross know he was still alive.
How would Ross know it was John, he didn't even know him. Ross still had to search for him, and likely found word of him in Blackwater. I mean he owns a ranch half a mile away under his real name, Ross would've found him eventually either way
@ClaytonTheCracker oh yeah,it wasnt really shown in credits but its pretty much clear they could check sisika records for validation.Question that's still left unanswered is when they finally bothered Marston's family or it was the beggining of 1911 and i worry too much...never know.
As much as I love the choice where you help John, this choice is so much more cinematic. A bloody knife fight, Dutch's hopeless way of pleading for them to stop fighting, Arthur's biting way of digging into Micah's betrayal. Also, Arthur's "Not Molly, Dutch. Him. Hiiim!" is just so fucking gut wrenching. And how Arthur can just barely position himself towards the rising sun. Jesus this ending does not get enough credit.
It's just a shame that going back for the money genuinely doesn't feel like it should be canon, given how Arthur's story plays out.
@@arandompasserby7940 it isnt canon its called redemption also arthur would never go back for money
@@alboorts If it isn't canon, why is it a fully programmed, scripted and mo-capped scene created by the devs?
If it's a valid option provided by the game, it's canon ... unless literally half of all moral options and every evil deed you're allowed to commit in RDR2 somehow isn't canon either.
@@arandompasserby7940 so in that logic gta vs bad endings are canon since they were mocapped
@@alboorts I mean, up until the GTAO Franklin mission where he references a "movie producer friend" of his (which more or less confirmed Option C), each of the three endings were equally legitimate outcomes. I mean, if the devs went through the trouble of adding them in as options, why wouldn't it be?
And even at that, the endings in GTA5 result in different people being alive, whereas the choices at the end of Arthur's story results in the same overall outcome, so there's genuinely no reason why going back for the money isn't canonically possible.
You know, kinda fitting you've taken yourself after John Marston, because it does seem like some of the wolves ate part-a yer brain! 😜👍
Man, imagine nearly losing a knife fight to a guy that's been run ragged and is dying of a stab wound AND Tuberculosis.
Not really dishonorable if you still get the deer spirit lol, good to see your Arthur was still a good man at the end
If you have low honor Micah stabs Arthur in the neck and him and Dutch watch as he slowly chokes on his own blood
@@ardademir7054 Plus. You cant stab the rat in the eye in the low honor one
Go with John = Micah chases Arthur
Go back for the money = Arthur chases Micah
Amazing transition from arthur to marston
Thx :)
@@RDBTheRedDeath can I ask for the song because the american venom one doesn’t have those trumpets and drums
@@impossibleduck3681 it's the original American venom from the 1st one
If only Arthur coughed in that knife.
Micah kills Arthur with his own knife soooo
but his infected blood was on the knife🤨
If I was Arthur after I found out I had TB Id have spent the last few weeks coughing in Micahs face everytime I got close to him.
@@stevepalpatine2828 “Revenge is a fools game”
@@alboorts Tuberculosis isn’t transmitted through bodily fluids, just from respiratory droplets. I’m honestly surprised that he didn’t transmit it to anyone else seeing as each time an infected person exhales, they spread the bacteria everywhere in front of them.
I’m going through a dishonorable path, but I don’t know if I can bring myself to miss the Arthur ending on top of the mountain 💔 it’s just so satisfying.
You'll miss it by being shot in the face by micah
wtf it's satisfying to see Arthur get a gap in his cap
@@angiekootenay335 bro got the low honor ending
I had a low honor last ride but a high honor ending. I expected to get a hole in my head but was gifted the most emotional death. I’m still confused.
@@varietyvince6583 you get a big honour boost when you pick the mountain end. Could've put you in the green?
I guess Arthur gave Micah something to remember him by. Micah took the gang from him, so Arthur took his eye
I can’t watch him die I have to look away until it’s over every time I have to do it. The game makes you grow to love him so much and then rips him away like that. Dropped my controller and started crying the first time I had to do it. I thought it broke my heart enough when he said thank you to his dying horse but then I had to see him die too.
2:30 that music hits so hard. it alone can bring me to tears.
4:21 I just noticed Micah does that to keep the high ground on John 😭
"it's over John, I have the high ground,!"
@@arthurmorganofthevanderlin6737 John: "You underestimate my power"
(and Micah does actually underestimate)
@@KikomochiMendoza"Heh. All manner of folk paying social calls... *tsk"*
I like this ending going back to get the money to try and give John, Abigail, and Jack a life none of them ever could've dreamed of. I've never understood why people hate it so much.
Exactly, like what was Arthur going to do with the money at that point? He was too far gone then- He just wanted everyone to be fine after he was gone. Even if he did act like a psychopath in that route I like to think that taking the money to give John was a way to soften the blow. He was bad and knew his actions affected everyone-
It should have been:
Micah: Hello, Scarface.
John: Hello, Scarhead.
I would pay 500 dollars just to see Arthur live that fight
It is quite cinamatic to see Arthur's final resting place be that final camp.
Aside from not being able to scar Micah in any other ending the one thing I hate about the endings is that no matter what you do it's a final confrontation with Micah and Dutch as Arthur. Because it's just odd that they both come back to camp and chase Arthur and John at the same time depending on what ending you choose. In my opinion it probably would have been better for Arthur to die from TB fending off the Pinkertons in the ending where you help John and then die to Micah in the get the money ending
Agreed
I wish it let you kill at pinkertons in beaver hollow. I fought them for like 15 minutes but they just kept coming
well, dutch and micha wmey back for the miwny and then got up the hill. it would take longer for arthur and john to get up because they had no horse, and it’s only a few minutes walk away to go back to beaver hollow, weirdly enough
holy shit I just noticed that in the beginning of the game it's only arthur & dutch & micah and in the near ending of the game it's also arthur & dutch & micah lol.
@@William11987finally someone else aside from me noticing this
Played the story already 4 times and every time I see rdr2 content I want to play it again.
I don't like that you have to do dishonored action to scar Micah,but I like to think that high honor Arthur goes there either to kill Micah,or to get the money for John and his family.Since getting the money for himself would be pointless he was already dying.
Yeah, I agree. It doesn't make much sense for for him to keep the money. This is unfinished business for him and unfortunately it stays unfinished.
@@TomFoolery350 Yes
Late but I always saw it as Arthur distracting the Pinkertons.
I always thought it was an all above thing. He knew he was a dead man so he said fuck it and decided to gamble the last bit of life he had.
"And you're dead , inside your dead"
Arthur knew John would revenge him.
4:46 I had not think about it and you're right, that scar could make him remember Arthur everyday for all those 8 years. It's curious that Micah calls Jonh "Scarface" when he even lost his eye with that scar
Exactly, that was my thinking. Everytime he can’t see in that side of his face or looks at himself in the mirror he thinks of Arthur. That’s why now in most of my recent Playthroughs I always go back for the money on high honor.
John comments on it.
"KINDA RICH CALLIN *ME* SCARFACE!"
"YOUR BUDDY, ARTHUR, DID THIS TO ME! *evil giggle* I WON!"
@@RDBTheRedDeath I literally just chose this ending with high honor about an hour ago. This is my second playthrough and on my first I chose the mountain with high honor as well. It was so satisfying to get that bastard's eye. And this ending isn't as sad as the mountain one so I didn't weep like a child, so that was a bonus lol. Although the horse dying always gets me.
@KrustyToast That's awesome! But just be aware that it's way more work getting through the Pinkertons and all that!
@KrustyToast No problem! But judging from your picture, you look like a pro at this game so it'll be a walk in the park for you lol 😀
Yeah of course I sliced his face I'm Arthur Morgan!
Nicely done, cowpoke!
You're alive arthur?
@@sukunafromwalmartmaybe.....
good uncle arthur
@@LewisEstudios9754 you done getting revenge jack?
Micah: "Hello scarface"
"John: You can't be talking Micah not anymore"
Micah: "Yeah your right. Black lung got one good hit in before i left him to die"
John: "By the end of this, your eye ain't gonna be the last thing you lost Micah"
Micah: "Very scary scar face. I wonder if your family will have the same attitude"
John: "You wont live to find out"
Seeing the "you ain't better" and "arthur came for the money" is funny. In the end i guess micah declared everyone as awful as him because they were all outlaws, kinda why he got captivated by dutch so much.
the hard transition from Unshaken to America Venom goes beyond hard
it took arthur dying for dutch to realize he was telling the truth
Nah, I don't think he realized.
All that for Dutch to know it was Micah all along
I have to say, the transition from arthur dying to john riding to kill micah like a movie is pretty damn cool.
i like how they are in the snow in the ending just like the beginning of the game
“Hello Scarface”
“You’re one to talk…”
He says he won - against a man who was at the end stages of tb, and had been through so much already. and he *still* barely beat him.
That wasn't winning. If Arthur were even a month back in the progression of TB, Micah wouldn't have even stood a chance.
He has a lot a guts sayin he won
Exactly. To proudly say he won against Arthur in his late stages of TB is like saying that you won a fight against 10 guys, except they were all 7 year olds. That's really nothing to boast about lmao. Micah was such a piece of shit.
You don't get Micah's character. None of what you said matters. What matters is that he won. Micah is the man that killed Arthur Morgan.
@@mr.jameson218 Lmao quit your trolling
@@UnchainedMelodie92 I mean, I'm literally not wrong. Lol
@@UnchainedMelodie92 He's right. Nothing matters to Micah, he just needs to be able to claim he "won".
Micah doesn't care that he "won" because Arthur is weakened, he only cared that he "won"
All them years and I didn't see the other ending until this video
If only Arthur coughed or spited in Micah’s face
John actually has bars after that
"your buddy Arthur did this to me... I won"
Micah bragging about barely beating a dying man who had almost nothing left and yet still got his ass kicked lol. The final mission reveals that Micah pulls the sneaky, backstabbing moves that he does because he's very clearly not a fighter or badass. Healthy Arthur wrecks Micah with zero difficulty lol
I like how John grew a beard a couple of minutes after he was talking to Micah after 8 years
0:46 it's the first time i laugh so hard from a long time 😂😂
Start playing for the 9th time…though I would play as dishonourable arthur but couldn’t do it 😅
It’s kinda fun. I used to think the same but it’s just so easy to lose honor so I’ve just embraced it now
I play from chapter 2 to 5 on neutral honor and then from begining of chapter 6 i upgrade honor to max
I can I'm a psychopath
@@DeadX2 🤣
Bros got Arthur dressed like a dandy
My first playthrough was Low Honor! I was the worst Arthur you could imagine killing and robbing anyone with no remorse! But I plan on playing again with high honor!
Low honor all day eryday
I feel like low honor arthur is canon imo
Lmao y'all crazy if you think Arthur deserves low honor. It's literally called red dead REDEMPTION
Bruh I cried when Arthur died bro. One of the few games that really had me emotional
when micah giggles at 4:23 its so funny with his lil ahh chuckle, i always laugh at his laugh
i've never heard of those lines before, kind of refreshing
Song at 3:32?
American venom, it's from the game's soundtrack
if arthur wasnt sick, micah would lose in seconds
I like the music where John ride his horse with Charles and Sadie
Gentleman Arthur vs micah, niche
I wanted to hear the "you vant even kill a dying man" line.
Micah got under everyones skin,
In my opinión going for the money Is better than helping john
I only go for the money to scar Micah feels like more of a victory against him
Imagine you just started hearing John Marstons theme while fighting Micah and he just runs down there and shoots Micah
I always saw the go after the money with high honor as the real ending.
Rich he says “Arthur gave this to me…I won” when he was having a hell of a time trying to stay alive knife-fighting a man seconds away from dying of TB.
The only game that has made me cry.
i picked this ending the first playthrough because i heard you got to knife fight Micah.
I didn’t even know this ending existed. That said, I never went back for the money.
It was at this moment that Dutch knew he fucked up.
Dying of TB and has a hole in his side from Micah getting the jump on him. And he still almost won!!
Things like this give you a valid reason to choose bad honor. Also, the bad honor ending is much more badass.
You'd think the tactically viable choice to take the money for John's family or at the very least, distract Dutch and Micah wouldn't be dishonorable
@@goodboi1725 that’s why i chose to go back for the money
arthur gets destroyed in the go for the money bad honor ending
@@eruptttttt he has fucking tuberculosis and still manages to give micah a big ass scar, thats a win in my book
@@goodboi1725 nah in the bad honor ending you don’t even cut out his eye, micah just dodged arthur’s knife shots and laughs at him and tackles him and shoved a knife in his chest
Which ending should I pick in red dead low honour or high honour because I could be nice until chapter 6
finally after 5 minutes of waiting
Well come on, its better like this rather than unedited 13 second long clip
"Hello Scarface.. Did you Miss me?"
"Not Much, Looks like Arthur didn't either!"
I never knew Arthur actually bit micahs hand when Arthur gives him a scar on the face 💯
1:05 wait arthur just bit micah is that why he died he just caught the plauge from the rat
How tf did ur hat stay on the whole time
you went back for the money. i went back to give micah that scar, so he can never forget me.
I mean john can run away from the pinkertons by himself, he's no push over so arthur could choose to go for the money (and not worry) to either get it for johns family or to get dutch ad micah away from john as a sort of distraction so it does make sense and makes arthur slash micahs eye as a bonus (and if you say "john is wounded, he can't do shit" Arthur could shoot straigth being almost dead by tb so john can handle a shoulder wound)
My evades were so good I was in the fight for 10 minutes before it ended
You know something I dont think anyone realized. Arthur cuts Micah's eye with his knife, Micah stabbed Arthur with his own knife. When Downes spat blood into Arthur's face he got TB. Micah shouldve gotten it from Arthur's blood being on the knife
1:02 even I felt that bite, it definitely might have hurted a lot ngl, lol
I've never done that I did not know you could cut Micah's face like that I've beat the story mode more times than I can remember
I want alternative cutscenes where dutch kills micah then and there and kneels down to arthur while crying uncontrollably.
I felt so bad for Arthur, I kinda felt like he was the one who did everything to keep the gang together and no one even cares about him once
This is the canon ending Micah would of killed John and Dutch if he saw him draw but Micah didn’t see Dutch draw on him because he didn’t have his eye Dutch might not of been there to kill Micah but to recruit him again but was reminded about Arthur from John and seeing the scar on Micah’s face
I never even saw this part of the game because I could never go for this ending
Man the money I would give to make a live action series of red dead redemption 2 or red dead redemption as a whole
They would undoubtedly ruin it
I didn't slash micah eye somehow and the scene was a bit different from getting very low honor
now i want to play this game again
I will try dishonorable ending on next playthrough. Tbh john is fine on his own
In 4 years I never watched that ending lol
If Micah make fun of Arthur's death body, then John retaliated with Micah's scar.
When arthur died on my game play his right hand did not fall it went the other direction and i said so many times fall hand fall hand fall hand FALLL JUST HAND FALL but than i transformed into john
That voice acting in point
The only good thing about going back for the money with high honor is that Arthur gives Micah a scar and also bites his hand
who else did American venom with the cattleman which is technically arthurs and johns only?
I wish you could fuck him up like that without going back for the money. It’s nice knowing Arthur made Micah’s life just a bit more unpleasant post mortem, but not worth missing the proper good ending for
How do you actually take his eye cause if you play as the good guy then go back for the money you just fuck up his eye real bad so how do you actually take his eye out ?
I DIDN'T KNOOOOW!!!🤯
🥺 beautifully done