Mandir, Modi & Message for India I Devdutt Pattanaik on Ram Rajya I "Ram's Ayodhya..." I Barkha Dutt
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ม.ค. 2024
- Barkha Dutt speaks to author and mythologist Dedvutt Pattanaik on the inauguration of the Ram Mandir in Ayodhya, and what it means for Hinduism, india, and the world. He also speaks about the concept of Hindutva and Ram Rajya and what implications will the temple have on the Indian masses. We also discuss whether religious polarisation will overtake everything in the run-up to the 2024 elections where PM Modi will seek to return to power for his consecutive third term.
#ramayan #devduttpattanaik #rammandir
Become A Mojo Story Member Now: / @mojostory
Subscribe to us for more updates:
Follow us on Twitter: / themojostory
Like us on Facebook: / themojostory
Instagram: / mojostory.in
For more videos: / @mojostory
Disclaimer: The views of guests who appear on Mojo Story, as well as the views of interviewees or speeches by public figures or those in the news, are their personal opinions. At no point do they reflect the views of the organization.
![[ไฮไลต์] ฟุตบอลชาย ฝรั่งเศส vs อเมริกา รอบแบ่งกลุ่ม | โอลิมปิก 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oZ9aSS0NEEg/mqdefault.jpg)
I pulped all this joker's book, after watching his Famous Twitter Saga.... A fellow who cannot respect another person's view and getting all abusive and ridiculing everyone, is not the authority to have any say about the Ehics or Ram or put any commentary on Ram.
i cant belive Barkha you have turned into such a positive person!
first learn what an abusive asshole this devdutt is.
Yes, unbelievable
Really? Seems you are ignorant of this cunning scoundrel of an author. Listen to Nityanand Mishra's tearing apart this over smart author
Modi hai toh mumkin hai 😂😂
DHONGI person????
It is 'रामायण' as Dr Patnayaka is pronouncing and not 'रमायण'
Also at 26:12 he says भाष (Correct is भास), at 26:18 प्रतीम-नाटक (Correct is प्रतिमा-नाटक). Fella can't read a single Indian language, nikal pada h gyan dene.
It is so irritating
Need not to give him much of attention.
Right or wrong....'reclaiming' lost temples will erase a series of atrocities committed by invaders on Hindu civilization. This is the recentering of a nation's psyche and aid its journey towards its destiny - not with a troubled past but with a reassurance of newfound identity of itself.
Sometimes I think about so many forefront BJP leaders who fade into the background and allow the limelight only on Modiji, just to support the cause, through him, like Hanuman saying it's Ram's story.
We can excuse Burkha for not knowing anything that goes to make Indian ethos. She is totally ignorant about it. But Mr.Patnaik, on purpose, avoids the spiritual contents of Ramayana and Mahabharata. Spirituality is the soul of Indian Puranas and Itihasas. Social, ethical, moral, Dharmic, state craft contents etc., are only the shell of our epics. These things change with time and place. But the soul, which in this case is spirituality, is eternal.
That is the whole defect with Devdatt. He is interested only in the shell. Otherwise he has good knowledgeable of Itihasas and Puranas. That is why he becomes controversial.
He knows the core...
But he don't want to tell it here...
Bcoz then leftist propaganda will be hampered.
folk tales?!!
is it?!
Barkha discussing Hinduism!!!!???? Better late than never 😂
Ghar wapsi 😅
इस कुटिया पर कभी भरोसा नही ।😆
Devdutt Pattnaik reminds me of Yogendra Yadav. Trying to be the know it all - Duggal Saab.
Totally agree
What an amazing interview. Great job Barkha, you ask brilliant questions and gave him space and comfort to answer those questions.
These are not mere stories, It's the History of the land. It is Fact not Fiction. Our Veda's are very clear about it.
what else do you expect from a guy who says Mythology is just a myth, we are in that time where we really don't know our religion any guy who comes and speaks non-stop English with confidence just becomes an expert
Brothers, I think he is not saying these things in a wring sense. I think what he wants to imply is that, what the Bharat sages and rishis have accomplished is putting the events that have occurred in a very concise narrative, where the facts are not missed, but conveyed in a very clear manner. Unlike the news articles of today, where the actual message is misrepresented and leads to more confusion.
So one thing is clear from this debate that Ramayan/ Mahabharat are literary stories. Nothing true about it.
But u didn’t discuss how present day is compared with RamRajya under Modi who is more akin to Ravana. Modi has crossed all “Maryada “, very arrogant and still millions well educated/ poor follow him. He is master manipulator with money power/ muscle power ( through encouraging goonda elements) though born very poor.
Cheating, hatred and bigotry are his weapons.
Rajiv
Canada
U r saying talking monkeys ,bears, vulture,sea,10 headed man,flying monkey is part of history ?
@@suyash5244vanara doesn't mean monkey first learn meanings of words.
How i enjoyed this ❤. Thank you ❤
Why is Maryada Purushottam a tragic phrase. Rama never shirked … He was independent though performing his duties.
Barkha Dutt doing a show on the stories of Ram and Krishna. It truly is a new day😂
she called an asshole forr the show. Realize the intention
BUT.. Hindu Itihassa or true events is mythology for these leftists aka pseudo liberals or brown slaves of the European/Christians + Arabs but Christian & Islamic mythologies & lies are a gospel truth!!
This guy is overhyped.....I request EVERYONE to find out his credentials or education.... just a year of diploma n he has BECOME mythologist......too funny.
I agreee with you.......Or ye mythologist kya hota hein??? This guy is so full of STUPIDITY....It's like I start calling myself....FICTIONALIST.....
Hindu Itihassa or true events is mythology for these leftists aka pseudo liberals or brown slaves of the European/Christians + Arabs but Christian & Islamic mythologies & lies are a gospel truth!!
Just check video made by Rajiv Malhotra few years ago, he is attention seeker and twisting all scriptures for his benefits. Share the videos to more people to stop this guy
@@Wilmamag BS!! Rajeev Malhotra is a legend and he is almost always right!!
Ramayana & Mahabharat are mythologies ONLY for the brown/black eternally colonized slaves and their white masters!!
Among all the stories of our heritage, Ramayana is singular and unique. Just about every corner of the Subcontinent can relate to the story, geographically speaking. From the north-east to central to dakshin to the southern tip of India; even Sri Lanka.
The narrative connects everybody!
In contrast, while Mahabharata includes all the locations of the greater India, you need to go searching for it. Not readily obvious.
Amazing and deeply intellectual ❤❤❤
This was a really beautiful discussion. Thank you Ms. Dutt for this wonderful interview. To see you enjoying it as much was a delight to watch as well. Thanks 🙏🏻
Well said Sir, ' to admire Ram is easy, but to emulate is difficult', that's what Modiji also meant, 'Ram to Rastra', ie., conscious effort to reach, though not to that extent, in our own small way, will also make our lives sublime and peaceful.
BAKWASS kar di....
I absolutely enjoyed watching barkha and Devdutt together sharing their knowledge with, thank you Barkha 😊
Wonderful!! Stay blessed!!
श्री राम and श्री कृष्ण is our historical figures can't be called story.
Its the art of our ancestors thay history was told with philosophy i.e. दर्शन शास्त्र
Atrotious that this woke leftist "Hindu Pandit" Devdutt keep on mentioning Ramayan as a story. I wonder if he will have guts to say the same to Kuran and Mohammad literature.
1. The question that comes to mind after watching this podcase is - Is Barkha doing a U Turn now?!!! Why is she getting lessons on Hinduism, Ramyana, Dharma etc!!!! Devdutt can demolish any woke anytime anywhere!!! 2. Anyway, thanks Barkha for getting over Devdutt who was otherwise generally missing during the last week!! 3. Barkha- please remember- Devdutt may be talking of appealing stories from ancient India but this is nothing but about Hinduism and Hindutva!!!! And though he never mentioned Modi anytime, Modi is always around invisibly in the background.....he..he... 4. Thanks Devdutta for such a wonderful explanation on Ramayana in particular and Hinduism in general. Hope BJP communication department uses ideas to defend Ram and cultural /civilizational revival from this during next General Elections propaganda
Barkha was like an attentive student ! Like she was learning another the Ramayan for the first time
Good too see a more open mind Barkha
The millions of devout Hindus have this understanding in their D and A
Our joy is not one of triumph or mockery : it’s just closure of a very cruel past
It's DNA!!!! Not D and A
good to see open minded Barkha indeed
People either like or hate Devdutt, and I find myself feeling a bit of both.
I dislike him for being quite foul-mouthed, classless troll, especially on social media. While he possesses insightful knowledge about the epics, he fails to embody or live by the profound teachings he imparts. He comes across as opportunistic, Vile, crass and utterly uncouth. Much like many (not all) of our present day babas. Great pravachans but can walk the talk.
On the other hand, I appreciate him for making sense to those undecided, left-of-center agnostic Hindus exploring religiousness. He helps them see the depth in their scriptures. His appeal lies in connecting with English-speaking, agnostic Hindus who might otherwise lean towards Instagram anti-hindu activism. I could have been one of those individuals myself if not for Devdutt. And i suspect many in the comments section below.
Yeah, one can start with him if that’s what catches one’s attention but one needs to quickly move on before the vile man can poison you. I thought his Twitter might have been hacked the first time I went there - first and last.
He has also been called out for lack of basic Sanskrit knowledge.
Fantastic to hear Devdutt throughout
well done Barkha for bringing this beautiful message. Those people who are commenting here are ignorant about the essence of the existence.
Enjoyed, enlightened!
Congratulations to both Devdutt and Barkha.
These aren't stories but incidents told in an effective way like the puranas, not like history text book.
Wow ! ❤ change of heart..even barkha n pattnaik r touched by Ram
What an amazing articulate person is devdutt
Devdutt Patnaik is unduly given importance. He is not an authority on mythology, but a genuine Fraud.
Ramayan & Mahabharata are Itahaasa, NOT Mythology at all!! As for Patnaik, he is a congressi/communist crook!!
Braka sold people are surprised that you deal with all subjects like a true journalist. You are what a journalist should be and not keep asking nation wants to know but actually provide answers
Thanks for the interview with Patnailk.Discussion on Ramayana was interesting.
Excellent conversation.. thanks for bringing the essence of Ram..
Amazed, Digvijay enlightening how to do pran an, Brakha praising Ramayan 😊
Glory Glory of India Revived after 500 years.
Propodanda dimaang mein ghus gaya hein tumhaare...
It was extremely delightful to hear you both. I am surprised that even Barkha can be genuine sometimes.
Barkha dutt in her real shurpnakha avatar as usual.Had it been for any other religion,she wouldn’t have dared to even talk
Ramayan is such a beautiful EPIC. And its amazing that Ram Mandir has been built. This magic could have been used to unite people of all faith. Just doing lip service that "Ram belongs to all" is not enough. Govt proxies & media have been guilty of chest-thumping Hinduism. We are such a diverse group of people in India. We should recognize this as our strength and not our weakness !
Kaaba is a shiva temple. Hindu supremacy.
This is open to everyone.No one stopped anyone to come forward and participate.I am surprised as to why only Hindus are preached to be liberal which they have been doing for decades but others can do anything,say anything?
@@rinkiiphone444 Bak Bak....
Jai Shree Ram ❤❤❤❤❤❤
sanatan dharma is called eternal so as it changes with time and is inclusive. I also think to give new angle to things.
Wonderful session. Hats off to his knowledge and understanding
Fascinating
They r facts of our history ….;
Ram sriram ji is dharma personified embodiment of dharma. Ie his choiceless awareness is dharma.
Whether follow or not words belongs ordinary ppl.... when he himself is dharma then there is no other way..... he is that...which is bramhan.
For ex : even in ppl now
what some one of us do effortless same thing we cant do it .. with same easy just at a perticular worldly act.. why? Is so?
What else is left to bring healing but these stories. Good effort.
Nice to see Barkha talking about Ramayan…
What super knowledge & truth
Whats with the pronunciation of word RAMAYAN? Indian languages are phonetic and its clear to pronunciation it as RAMAYAN and not as RUM-AAYAN. Do you see westerens speaking hindi say english words in Indian Accent?
😅 Barkha is obviously new to all this Rama and spirituality...
This guy distorts our history. Basically a liberal who's a supporter of khangress preaching us religion
He is opportunistic
@@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386 yes, he will speak for a religion against a religion based on what benefits him
@@Fukranhm Dharma is not Religion
@@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386 please don't go into the details, you got what I've said
Tum to mythology mantein ho....tumko history se kya lena....
Amazing content. Thanks Barkha and Devdutt!
RAM RAM 🙏🏻
Very interesting ❤
Its seems Barkha listening like a student frm Prof Pattnaik
Yes it is great Utsav. I agree, Indians love utsavas. Why not?. Bhakti one side. Temple economy is to support farmers on another side. One shld study this economy. Jai sreeram.
When someone says stories, we immediately think that this is imagination, it is not REAL, its just some values and morals being taught through stories. However myhtological stories everywhere, are about TRUTH, but not always the truth that we know as material historical truth. Ok, sure some historical events are recorded as story, for example the matsya avataar and Manu, or the Noah's Art do signify an ancient flood which may have ended one age. Before another began. Or the dashavataras may signify evolution in a symbolic manner. But more importantly the truth and history that these 'stories' tell us are about the history of the human spirit, psyche, the higher consciousness evolving on this Earth and in the universe. Thats why we say that the mythology comes from a higher state of being, because there is a deeper consciousness (for all religions) which knows this past intuitively or via spiritual states. As history notes, stone age civilisations tended to have some forms of human sacrifice and even cannibalism. Then bronze ages did away with that, but sacrifice in general continued. And as iron age civilisations came religions became more complex. We also have a shift from overt sacrifice to the inner sacrifice and devotion to the divine, from Gods that are to be feared or pleased by offerings we have later a more personal and affectionate relation with God. Then we even have a more abstract idea of divine consciousness. These shifts are global. Our 'stories' are telling anout these true transformations and reflections also. So both those who dismiss them as mere imaginations of a culture and those who insist that they are historical fact as such, could instead note this third aspect. It is a more subtle kind of fact that myhtologies everywhere tell us. And this is why often cross cultural readings also reveal related (though not always similar) themes and truths.
Its also a fact that these stories or histories were written in their social times, and so are often also carrying values of the past, such as hierarchy and inequalities of certain kinds that were normal for a monarchy or agrarian-fuedal society, but will not suit our goals today. And thus even as we value and keep alive our traditional wisdom, it is best read with a free and open mind, very much aware of a world where everyone has equal dignity.
Thanks for your analysis doctor Patnaik. Yes Social Sciences or reading of mythology argues for being in the shoes of the other to eliminate inequality and otherness but increasingly what I realise have you pointed out the people have become egocentric. Science and development has a has a dark shade to it as well I agree. Look at old age homes old parents are made to live there young generation has no time for their parents. Sorry for generalization. For me you are a post Modern Academic
Barkaajee,many political commentators unfoundedly believe, that forthcoming Modi Regime Iii would ne puntuated with highhandedness, even tyranny. But I believe that this may not really forthcoming. He has Mellowed over a decade of rule, and may become a GOD-King, who is guided by the heavens to govern the right way and usher RAMRAJYA in divisive India
,
A GLOBAL VILLAGE WITH VIRTUOS RAJA,S
The "Ramayana" and the "Mahabharata" are the greatest mind-experiments in the history of human-kind.They raise 2 questions you have to answer for yourself: [1.] What would you do if your wife is abducted and you are monogamous? [2.] What would you do if your wife was sought to be abducted and she was polyandrous? In the first instance the hero is consumed by the fire 🔥 of suspicion. In the second case the heroes are devoured by the fire 🔥 of revenge. That these have been facts of life since time immemorial make them facts of history since the origin of man!
I think the central thought is ‘locus standi’ what is the standing of any character in the story are they aggrieved do they need justice? Only the aggrieved can ask for justice/ fight. It was not Hanumanji’s fight or any other character because only Ram and Sita were aggrieved with the sita apaharan. So only Ram can fight. The same is true even in Mahabharata. Krishna doesn’t fight because it is not his fight but Pandavs.
Ram is not myth, country is having lot many proofs, just think how they quoted names of cities and places
What proofs?
Where is the proof?.
Extraordinary! Kudos Barkha. Deva Dutt is no less than a Maharishi! This is one of your best videos and certainly the best in terms of adding value to the children of India and indeed the World!. I hv downloaded this video so I can hear this from time to time as well as forward them to other kindreds! Hearing this vlog is no less than undertaking a serious spiritual practice!
By the way, the word Yagna….
Ya means ‘to be a boon to others’. Gya means ‘knowing something that was always present’. Hence Yagna is 27:30 the spontaneous act of helping other beings without pride, prejudice or profit! This is the essence of sanatana dharma.
Devdutt Patnaik has to be celebrated for airing this extraordinary insight and you Barkha have made your best offering before Lord Rama Himself! God bless!
It is not only utsav it is a beginning of new era. It is not storys but it is based on facts for which still there are thousands of proofs available. Please do not mislead and misguide the people. JAI SHREE RAM!
In that context Rajiv Gandhi never wanted the PM post. Yet he gets denegeaded as pariwar vadi
However erudite Mr. Dutta may be, but calling Dharma religion again and again is very wrong.
Barkha is smiling because Devdutt is playing on her fingers, the game , she wanted him to do
Yes it is waiting for all prodigals into its fold.
Awesome, brilliant, superb can't find more words sir ,A perfect person who understand what religion actually is .across the world all the same , we human being can't understand that these are our stories. Just need to correct interpretation like Pattnaik sir. Then there will be no quarrel over so called religion. Religion is really mundane
Showing mirror to present regime. The most heinous thing to divide people in the name of religion. India just not the name of a country but an experiment. This experiment is failed by some extremely useless ,power & money hungry beasts.
he seems to infer fairy tales>> don't have time to waste,
Send this person to me and I will tell him how both Rama and Krishna are for dharma. Both are not dharma breaker.
People are emotionally charged about the Ram Temple, because we love "Utsavas" !! (He lost me right in the beginning). He has his own woke agenda. Doesnt speak the truth.
He is psycho! It’s not story or mythology! It’s our history which happened in real !
Yes..talking monkeys,bears,vulture,sea was part of history 🤡
@@suyash5244seriously man I don't understand what's up with people these days....they are mythologies and that does not reduce their importance
Sir, you seem to have a hole in your knowledge of Mahabharata. Duryodhana and his mama were deceitful. They took Indraprastha from Pandavas by deceit. Promised to return it back after Pndavas completed vanabas and guptabas, just to break it. This is the very thing that started the war. Did Duryodhana break rule or not?
Wow very informative indeed, thanks
Devadutta for Bharat Ratna, Barkha for Padma. What an enlightening and uplifting interview! Woh Bharat desh hai mera…aur yeh Bharat desh bhi!
Really! SITA is lucky, she is free, because she is deserted in the forest when she is pregnant. What is he saying!!
He is saying you are too far gone to understand m
Krishna was mischievous as a young boy and Machiavellian as an adult per pre-written fate of the Mahabharata.
It's a love story. Nonsense he is talking.
No one invited him in TV
To you these may seem unimportant fictional stories, but to the vast Indian masses it is a part of life. Pure itihasa, if not history in the Western perspective. Your propaganda market is down, so nothing will be swayed by your false narrative & misleading. May Bhagwan Ram bless you with wisdom.
Values ? Where are they
You are on wrong channel
Dev dutt is very clever in still trying to tell that Ramayan and Mahabharat are stories even after proving in Supreme Court. He is intelligent anti Hindu anti India anti government anti Modi anti BJP. He is exposed.
First of all ramayan is not myth 😡😡
Story! Scrap your talk. Jesus and Allah are stories. Minuscule thought process!!
So Devdutt Pattanaik can't read sanskrit but is somehow an expert on Hinduism? Imagine an Islamic scholar who cant read or write arabic 🤡
Absolute poetry hope devdutt has his own podcast
This guy has completely misunderstood the Ramayan and Mahabharata,, Not sure who is he but he needs to unlearn many things to come to the reality!
So called expert doesn't know that the Pancham Veda is Mahabharata , not Ramayana. So much bullshit being peddled as expert analysis, how can he say Krishna broke rules, while Duryodhana followed them. Is he for real, the whole deal with Duryopdhana was to manipulate and bend rules to suit his outcomes. Countless examples such as Lakshagriha, poisoning Bheema, Gambling with loaded dice, not honoring the rules of war etc.
As a prime minister, is it proper for modiji to endorse a particular religion. He is the pm of not only hindus, but of all religion
Ma'am, Plz take pride in Indian & Hindu culture.
Hinduism says all r equal. Others doesn't think so. Why is that?
Are you sure everyone is equal in Hinduism?
@@Amuipe4786 all are equal except assholes 🤣🤣
@@Amuipe4786 Yes every one is equal period
@@easwaransanthakumar297one let’s see from today onwards nobody look at caste when marrying
He talked good this time..
But be careful he is a manipulator 🤷
Wonderful Devdutt, super.
Behen ji.. Spit the gutkha out and pronounce properly.. It's not RIMayann or Rumayann.. It is RAMAYAN.. The sound is AAA and not IH or UH..
Good God such fake accent.. Trying to impress whom nobody knows..
This is a Buddhist temple..
Bharka Dutt is irrelevant, nobody really cares what she has to say. I am waiting when she will be held accountable for her actions and help she has provided to bad actors
Let’s first start with this- it’s not just stories OR mythology. Ithihasa is the word. Please choose your words carefully
Ram Naam Jappo khudi emulate hone lagega.
Devdutt is one of my go-to folks to understand the intricacies of these stories and the purpose behind them.
Sadly totally a wrong choice!
@divyadhriti14 Well, for scholarly translation of literations, nithyanand misra is the best... but the modern correlation of such concepts are best understood by folks like Devdutt since he understands the intricacies on both ends of the spectrum.
BS!! He is SHAME to his own Sanatani Hindu name!! After such Dharmic & ideological injustice, he perpetrated against his own name, this congressi, pseudo liberal & communist should drown in chulu bhar paani!!