Gujarati jains call it 'Santharo*' fast till death. It was manifested in second story of the film "Ship of Theseus", the maker Anand Gandhi himself is Gujju Jain. *In Jainism, santhara refers to a practice of fasting culminating into one's eventual demise
It is interesting to listen to these two. Each one of us is entitled to perceive and think about a particular issue. Each of us have our own beliefs and practices about religion and practices. None of us question the authenticity of history. Let us really think and analyse what,why,and when history or religion.
The anchor is very ignorant and is a bit condescending to the vegetarian people, Jainism says that the grass, plants are Ekindriya Jeev Plants literally doesnt have brain to feel the pain while we boil or roast them, but Animals are tortured for days for our consumption and they do have brain, they feel the pain, they feel emotions unlike plants. But Devdutt never mentions this fact that Jainism says coz he is hardcore Nonvegetarian guy.
both are dumb guys trying to play intellectual ...... mentioned all fake stories ........hindu history is not mythology .......they are anti hindus pretending to be intellectual........clearly on an agenda
Quick info on what Orthodox Christians ( St.Thomas Christians) are allowed to eat or not eat - "Any animal who has cloven hooves and chews its cud may be eaten; such animals as the camel, badger, hare and the pig then may not be eaten. Sheep, cattle, goats and deer are all kosher and may be eaten. From the water, anything that has fins and scales may be consumed; prohibiting all shellfish."
Who said that? That time even hindi wasnt there, in gita it is written diff he says zyada na khaye na kum khaye to live a healthy life but food is bhog so bhakti without it is pure one
Devdutt is a star. Sheer brilliance. In conversation with Krish, both shine complementarily. Kudos to the unsung heroes who brought these two stellar minds together.
One I know a Family who will not use electricity to heat water but coal or fire wood and they are Jain's in Mumbai. Two Fasting Menu means you have different types of Dishes than the regular ones.
Brinjal and ginger also not allowed in Jainism. Even raw turmeric is not allowed only the dried-up ginger is allowed and there are explanations for that. Just sharing......
Fasting to death or not eating roots is a super weird idea which only rich urban guys could have come up with... All food is violence...whether on plants or animals. Jain beliefs and their slow seepage into some parts of hinduism is extreme. Eating moderately and food for everyone as in Sikhism or Buddha's middle path is the sensible way....
It is very important to have deep understanding of animal and plant life cycle , pain , emotions and difference between uproot and underground plant, what happens to the whole plant when you uproot them, seeds within vegetables, life within them to understand food intake in Jainism.. in fact jainism explains existence of life in several forms around us in the best way. having minimal understanding on life form within animals and plants and their existence in air , water bodies or land discussion on food intake in Jainism is misleading for those who don’t practice Jainism. 99 percent people does not know many in Jain community does not even eat vegetables ( forget underground vegetable) on certain days every week ..
Showcase of Shallow knowledge about the science of Jain food. Hope you realize it. Many things lack real concept. Request to do in depth research and then showcase for better and real understanding. All the best.🙏
Both the host and Devdutt has not any understanding of base level and they are talking like they have in-depth knowledge about JAINISM. assuming things by thr limited knowledge and trying to look cool and intellectual.
Devdatta Patnaik is always glorifying things. He is too much . I don't know what he thinks of himself! He is irritating. I suspect that he has a Narcissistic personality. Very sad to see Krishashok with him. Ashok is very logical and rational. He does not glorify things. Devdatta seems a hypocrite. Ashok please don't be with this man! You are different from him. It's a request
There are still more South Indians who know quite a bit about North India - ratio and proportion wise..including speaking Hindi..cannot say the same for North Indians..
Omelet and troubling living creatures for food and selfish things is not the part of jain tradition,and we are proud of it. Though what non voilance means is very detailed idea which you will not understand and leaving nonveg is just screaming layer of becoming human being. Leaving troubling animals doesn't make you jain,it only makes you human being,animals don't understand what's right or wrong. So don't dare to insult jain concept of Ahinsa.
Awesome ! Laughed so much ! Two of the best ! And yet so informative! Thank you!
One hour of pure entertainment. Both host and guest wonderful. Never knew how the time passed. Thank you!
Wow, very delightful.
Gujarati jains call it 'Santharo*' fast till death. It was manifested in second story of the film "Ship of Theseus", the maker Anand Gandhi himself is Gujju Jain.
*In Jainism, santhara refers to a practice of fasting culminating into one's eventual demise
Girls are forced to do fast so that they cannot have many babies. Jainism is an anti-human sadistic idea.
It is interesting to listen to these two.
Each one of us is entitled to perceive and think about a particular issue.
Each of us have our own beliefs and practices about religion and practices. None of us question the authenticity of history. Let us really think and analyse what,why,and when history or religion.
Jai Jai Jinendra.
The anchor is very ignorant and is a bit condescending to the vegetarian people, Jainism says that the grass, plants are Ekindriya Jeev Plants literally doesnt have brain to feel the pain while we boil or roast them, but Animals are tortured for days for our consumption and they do have brain, they feel the pain, they feel emotions unlike plants. But Devdutt never mentions this fact that Jainism says coz he is hardcore Nonvegetarian guy.
both are dumb guys trying to play intellectual ...... mentioned all fake stories ........hindu history is not mythology .......they are anti hindus pretending to be intellectual........clearly on an agenda
Plants do respond to touch..Ekindiya..but since they have only 1 sensory organ to feel pain, they feel less pain compared to beindiya, treindiya, etc
Wow I enjoyed it like anything
Quick info on what Orthodox Christians ( St.Thomas Christians) are allowed to eat or not eat - "Any animal who has cloven hooves and chews its cud may be eaten; such animals as the camel, badger, hare and the pig then may not be eaten. Sheep, cattle, goats and deer are all kosher and may be eaten. From the water, anything that has fins and scales may be consumed; prohibiting all shellfish."
Very nice speech & voice........
In Gujarati we say 'Bhukhe bhajan na hoy gopala" Meaning "God, I can't pray with empty stomach"
Who said that? That time even hindi wasnt there, in gita it is written diff he says zyada na khaye na kum khaye to live a healthy life but food is bhog so bhakti without it is pure one
If it's true then spiritualism is decreasing...
@@eyeopenerselfrealise5515 abey teri hindi gai tel lene, meri Gujarati me yehi hai.
@@krupadave1975 gujrati pan na hati ben
@@krupadave1975 gujrati pan na hati ben
Delightful
I really enjoyed it
Very informative and thought provoking .
Eye opener on jainsim
He is mostly wrong at places.
Both of them doesn't know anything about jainism..they just copy paste and use good english.
Devdutt is a star. Sheer brilliance. In conversation with Krish, both shine complementarily. Kudos to the unsung heroes who brought these two stellar minds together.
They know nothing.... spreading falsehood in name of Jainism
Devdutt is the biggest seller of bullshit in English in India....
One I know a Family who will not use electricity to heat water but coal or fire wood and they are Jain's in Mumbai.
Two Fasting Menu means you have different types of Dishes than the regular ones.
So that family increasing the pollution...
You are either lying,or ignorant,or both
This is the most democratic conversation I've witnessed in the last 10 years😂
Very intriguing. Thank you for sharing it.
🌞
We expect discussion on
Adhyatmic Gyaan
w.r.t.
Shrimad Ramchandra Mission
Shrimad Rajchandra Mission
🪔
Interesting to listen to two experts
Wow 😂 Superb Krish
Brinjal and ginger also not allowed in Jainism. Even raw turmeric is not allowed only the dried-up ginger is allowed and there are explanations for that. Just sharing......
Fasting to death or not eating roots is a super weird idea which only rich urban guys could have come up with... All food is violence...whether on plants or animals. Jain beliefs and their slow seepage into some parts of hinduism is extreme. Eating moderately and food for everyone as in Sikhism or Buddha's middle path is the sensible way....
Moderate path can't be the ultimate path.. Truth doesn't always mean to satisfy everyone
@@Ajain5521 And what is that committing suicide.
It is very important to have deep understanding of animal and plant life cycle , pain , emotions and difference between uproot and underground plant, what happens to the whole plant when you uproot them, seeds within vegetables, life within them to understand food intake in Jainism.. in fact jainism explains existence of life in several forms around us in the best way. having minimal understanding on life form within animals and plants and their existence in air , water bodies or land discussion on food intake in Jainism is misleading for those who don’t practice Jainism. 99 percent people does not know many in Jain community does not even eat vegetables ( forget underground vegetable) on certain days every week ..
These two gentlemen just slayed with pure vegetarian spoon. 😂
Not all lives are equal in jainism. There are five categories.
4.51 even it is very funny to say it actually correct North India doesn't know the south India.😄😄😄
Showcase of Shallow knowledge about the science of Jain food. Hope you realize it. Many things lack real concept. Request to do in depth research and then showcase for better and real understanding. All the best.🙏
Absolutely best conversations ❤🎉
They have just no understanding of philosophy, principles and practices of Jainism and then talking with authority on Jainism..
They do. Otherwise you explain.
Completely agree with you.@dbya13
@@vinsin328He is also big zero..
Just two atheists talking about theism, belief and people 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
The confidence of both talking about religion and food habits without having prior knowledge behind it.😂
This is internet bro. Anybody can have a discussion on anything and upload a video of it!!
Daat chiharo
What about you?
I agree , its like "kehta bhi deewana , sunta bhi deewana" neither of them knows anything about Jain Philosophy but yes they are good a oratory
The confidence of speaking nonsense fluently in English is something else...
Totall rong and false information in Jainism
I could not watch the full video. They are so ignorant and full of false information..
If you have not watched fully how could you conclude that they were ignorant..?
Both the host and Devdutt has not any understanding of base level and they are talking like they have in-depth knowledge about JAINISM. assuming things by thr limited knowledge and trying to look cool and intellectual.
Devdatta Patnaik is always glorifying things. He is too much . I don't know what he thinks of himself! He is irritating. I suspect that he has a Narcissistic personality. Very sad to see Krishashok with him. Ashok is very logical and rational. He does not glorify things. Devdatta seems a hypocrite. Ashok please don't be with this man! You are different from him. It's a request
too false thoughts or i can say both of them have bad assumption about jainism
Why don’t you clarify if you are a practicing Jain
Please clarify.
@@krshmrthyHe is a namesake jain..
God the food sounds vile 😢
Likewise, there are zillion South Indians who know squat about North India. Enough with this aggravated victim hood.
There are still more South Indians who know quite a bit about North India - ratio and proportion wise..including speaking Hindi..cannot say the same for North Indians..
Too much false information
Yup, Jains eat Meat....
He's liberals and atheist 😂😂😂
Yes, there is a anti hindu agenda
@@Tonysparkt1507 Just like Jains.
Which one?
A very honest opinion - Absolutely no depth in the conversation. Its an absolute hodge podge with half baked truth. And a sly mockery on vegetarians.
It is not mockery of vegetarianism but hypocrisy of it..
We’ll have to let it go as it’s their cooked up mental mythology. (Sad to see misuse of intellect).
@@AtmaRuchiI wouldn't let it go. I cannot let people spread wrong information about Jainism and also make a mockery of it.
JAIN OMLET CONSISTS OF EGG MINUS ONION.
😂
Sorry to say it's not a culture of ours but it's shameful commented
Omelet and troubling living creatures for food and selfish things is not the part of jain tradition,and we are proud of it.
Though what non voilance means is very detailed idea which you will not understand and leaving nonveg is just screaming layer of becoming human being.
Leaving troubling animals doesn't make you jain,it only makes you human being,animals don't understand what's right or wrong.
So don't dare to insult jain concept of Ahinsa.
No Mr Dave pls don't comment something false in this comments section
@@S111-c8vIf you drink milk then you are not better than meat eaters.. step down from your moral high ground..