IS TAG GRADING WORTH IT? Comparing TAG to PSA & SGC!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ส.ค. 2024
- Is grading sports cards with TAG Grading worth it? We tested Technical Authentication Grading (TAG Grading) and compare it to PSA Grading, Beckett Grading Services (BGS) and SGC Grading. We sent 10 cards into TAG for grading and do a TAG Grading reveal of the 10 cards in the same way a PSA Reveal video would work. We discuss the TAG grading process, the time it took to turn the cards, the TAG Grading scale, the guidelines TAG has for its submission process and even the overall TAG Slab TAG uses for encapsulating cards. In the end, we ask, was it worth it or not?
Beck and Penny join me during the PSA Reveal Style video of the CSG cards. The final card of the CSG reveal will be Beck's first ever pack pulled card that he got graded. Will he be forever pleased with his CSG grade? Find out!
#TAG #TAGgrading #PSA
JOIN ONE OF THE HOBBY'S LARGEST PATREON COMMUNITIES!
All for as low as $2/month! JOIN TODAY! / 1centsportscards
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @1centsportscards
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subscribe: www.youtube.co...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WANT TO GET YOUR CARDS GRADED? CHECK OUT MY PATREON PAGE TO SEE HOW YOU CAN GET CARDS GRADED AT NO ADDITIONAL CHARGE! PLUS, GET 1ST ACCESS TO ALL BREAKS, RETAIL RESTOCK LINKS, DISCORD COMMUNITY ACCESS & MORE! JOIN TODAY! www.patreon.com/1CentSportsCards
TAS grading has the potential to be the most perfect grade you can possibly get out of all the grading companies. Im in!
Yeah - potential is huge. But I'm not sure the business strategy they currently have will maximize the potential. I'd love to see them become a player though. It really is a grading company for collectors which is refreshing.
Tag is trash twist the slabs and they will pop out
@@brianogrodnick1382why would you twist the tab? Nobody is doing that and risking damaging the card.
@@brianogrodnick1382 why would you twist the slab in the first place?
bewertungen die 9 oder 10 sind können nie perfekt sein ^^
TAG is superior to PSA. I'd much rather have a TAG 10 over a PSA 10. But a PSA 10 sells for like double what a TAG 10 does because the masses are slow to catch on and still haven't figured it out yet.
Wenn das Tag system halbwegs funktionieren würde, würdest du nie im leben eine 10 bekommen ^^
Based on how you define superior. Certainly, it can be stated TAG may be the most accurate based on their models input parameters.
Down with PSA and their human opinions that manipulate the market. Go TAG, I’m in!!!!
Love the enthusiasm! I do agree that the human error element is a big miss for PSA.
I think with the right management and capitalization that the sky is the limit for TAG grading. I'll definitely going to send them some cards just to see what the user experience is like. All the AI, tech stuff is cool, but the slabs alone could change the game just by the aesthetics.
Someone tested the ability to resubmit the same card and they spotted it, just reslabbed it with the same score and cert number and sent it back.
We’ve all been wondering about TAG, kind of strict grading, but isn’t that what we really want? Thanks for the great review and information. 🤘
I do think people want strict grading, but I also think what they really want more is their cards to be all 10s. I think if we're all honest, what we want is to know the exact condition a card is in when we go to buy it and I think the TAG grading g scale provides that with more transparency than the other grading companies. I appreciate you watching!
It’s actually non- subjective grading which is what collectors have been asking for ever. Also RIP to PSA artificially manipulating population counts. So these are the people you want to send your Brady’s and Jordan’s to.
@@user-xf2tl8ee3c, your 100% right.
From what I’ve searched and come across, best explanation by far. I’ve got cards heading into TAG, arriving today. I surely will share out this video
I appreciate you explaining TAG. I’ve been seeing TAG graded cards, but didn’t know anything about them. I like the idea and hope it catches on. I may grade some of my 1995-2005 cards with them. I feel most of these cards are graded harshly.
Also, being an Orioles fan, I loved that Gunnar Henderson card (probably AL ROY).
Hey David - thanks for watching. I'd be interested to see what 20 year old cards get. I bet you the grades would be tough, but I think for older cards this is exactly the type of grading scale you need to know exactly the condition. Like a 6 in PSA is so open for interpretation it's almost a useless grade. But imagine a 643 vs a 607.. that's the kind of detail you really want with older cards.
This is what we want...Beautiful Grading and Objective..Not depend on The grader mood.
I agree that it's very straightforward and I love that it avoids a grader just being super strict (or not strict enough).
I’m a fan! I was able to get into 2 drops so far. I received the results from my first and was happy overall. I’m waiting on my second submission to come back. All are PC Cards so the resell value isn’t as big of a deal to me. I’m glad to get some PC Cards in such awesome looking slabs. 😁
They’ve added an “anytime access” submission to their website too!!
Yeah anytime is pretty expensive. Congrats on getting in a drop. I e struck out 3 times now. But you're right. It's the best looking slab on the market right now.
Really enjoyed this video! I am a PSA guy but this has me intrigued....
I think this is the future of card grading & they did it at the perfect time with fanatics coming in the mix. We'll see how the LCS thing works out though.Like everything new it's hard accept new ways of doing things so i love how you gave your detailed opinion.
Thanks Matt. I'll be interesting to see how they grow over the next few months. I really think market penetration will be key for their success and I think having kiosks for on demand grading is a good idea, but I see it being a card show feature vs an LCS feature. Either way, it's a promising concept.
PSA will eventually steal all of what TAG is doing or more likely just buy the company.
Only problem is tag is for collectors. People who care if a cards over/under graded. Psa is for flippers and resellers, who dont care if its properly graded, its all about the number on the front. They seem to be the majority of the hobby at the moment. Untill people care why it got the grade, instead of just what the grade is, things wont change.
You're not wrong at all. I think there are still more collectors than flippers/investors but PSA was first to market so long ago that most people simply know the brand and assume it to be "the standard" - that's a big hurdle for every other company to get over.
Well put. Im really digging tag as a collector
I have to agree, PSA is big du to big collectors and resellers making it the standard and not wanting their card values to decrease. I stayed away from grading for a long time. Tried a few companies and just didn’t think it was worth it but tag is the first I’m finally highly considering making my PC Cards are tag…. It’s not some dudes opinion of my card. Seem way too many terrible grades on psa cards…..
Slabs quality ranked for me is
1) TAG
2) CSG
3) BGS
4) PSA
5) SGC
I agree with everything, but I would take PSA over BGS.
@@1CentSportsCards fair enough I just like the sturdiness of BGS. Sometimes I feel like the PSA slabs could snap in my hands. Which is actually great if I want to crack and resubmit.
sgc is dead to me
Great video! I found this company a few weeks ago and I’m super intrigued in their product and process. I cracked 10 from my PC to submit to them to see how BCG and TAG compare grade wise.
I am curious to see how they stack up against Beckett as well.
Howd it go??
Love TAG! Awaiting my first order to come back. Great review!
Thanks and good luck on your submission!
I’m gonna have to check em out
On paper, I LOVE how crystal clear the slabs are, the weight, the 1000 pt scale, the ability to see exactly why it got the grade it did, and the philosophy of taking subjectiveness out of grading. Do you get any sense on how others are reacting to TAG, and if they have what it takes to last the test of time and actually grab significant market share away from PSA and the other big hitters since you made this video 8 months ago?!?
Hey 1 cent sports cards thank you for the video. This was very interesting. I definitely would love to try them out when I can afford to
I appreciate you watching. It's a very promising grading company for sure and I'd recommend them for PC cards and for cards under $500... In the future maybe even more expensive cards. But take a wait and see approach for sure.
I just saw these guys on instagram and the technology is pretty sweet. They can view the topography and blemishes really well. What im a little hesitant of is the shift thats happened in grading toward not just a preserved pack fresh card but obsession with perfect printing. Is that really what grading cards is really about? There seems to be this double goal of putting a card in a slab, one to preserve it but also to determine perfection in printing. When I look at a Babe Ruth graded card there is no printing quality in the conversation. We are looking for a well preserved card. i think the print perfection takes away from it a little bit as a collector even though I do still want that lol
Great video. Honest review. TAG already catches resubmitted cards. If any cards are cracked and resubmitted their system catches it and gives the card the same grade or lower (if new defects are present). Basically you can’t get a higher score on a resubmission.
As for comps brother, I beat PSA comps 100% of the time.
Yeah I feel like it would be very easy for TAG to catch a crack and sub based on prior imaging so, great to hear they're using it. As for comps, I may have to do a random sampling of 10 cards on eBay to see, but it wouldn't surprise me if TAG is close and even beating some PSA 10s. That said, I am confident that over a large sample size, the PSA 10 is still king, especially at the high end. Now to go look at some TAG 9 Trout RCs vs PSA 9s... It's the perfect card to comp. Thanks for watching!
I was always a BGS guy. However that has changed over the last few years to PSA. However I have to say I really like the idea of taking out the "Objective" aspect of grading. We've all gotten a card back and were disappointed in the grade. We look on Ebay and think "mine is better than that and it's a higher grade!"
Exactly. If TAG can get the traction, I can see this really helping buyers know exactly what they're buying and really help people grading cards know that they aren't just getting snubbed by a grader having a bad day (or a company that only cares about ensuring those who spend big bucks get big grades).
Same…what I loved about BGS was their transparency and the sturdiness of their slabs. Unfortunately their operations has completely shyt the bed over the past 3 years.
One thing I did not like about TAG was how long it takes them to ship the box and sleeves out to the customer for us to ship back. For me it took them a week.
I plan to use TAG for my new cards, but will keep the PSAs I have and will still grade older cards through PSA.
Thank you for doing this…I’ve been wondering about this company. I may try them but they’re a little pricey. Keep up the great work.
Try and get in a drop. For $14, I feel like it's totally worth it. But at $20, ehh... Yeah a bit pricey.
I looked today the base is $25 so not sure what’s happening there.
I want to get cards graded but was put off from PSA being so dang expensive and having to join a club to get reduced pricing and a minimum submission. TAG is a godsend.
Was kind of interested so I checked it out. Double the cost to get the 1-1000 score. Yet it requires ZERO extra work on their part. Saw that and it made my decision for me.
I love TAG. I think given the money involved this should be required. However, since it’s not PSA will rule. A TAG 10 is so hard to get, but if you get a 10, a 10 is a 10 is a 10 with them…bit extremely hard to get a 10 when PSA just randomly hands them out.
I plan to grade my pc for sure a rainbow set in those cases would be dope
I think TAG is perfect for a PC collection. Could t agree more about the rianbow
I like most of what they're doing. It's definitely new and pretty cool eye appeal upon delivery. Too bad it's gonna take forever to even sniff SGC.
It all depends on how they scale. SGC really is t grading all that many cards (about 10% of what PSA does). Their pricing model is going to hold them back though. But even since this video went live they've become more competitive on price.
Wow very nice slabs….
What is the price per card? Do they grade the autograph?
It depends on the speed in which you want it delivered. Normal is $14 on a drop. They do not do auto grading.
Love it
TAG 10'a are harder to get than PSA 10's - Should Sell For More - ONE DAY ?
The future imo and should go 95.2 so it’s a 95 basically and I look forward to seeing this work with older cards
I would love to add some TAG graded cards into my PC. I only see one listed for my PC player and it's $120 overpriced to comps. I guess I need to cherry pick some gems and see if i can send in some. I love the look over any grading companies. But I would only want to do it at $14 per card.
Yeah, good luck getting in a drop. They really need to expand that side. It's limited to about 5-7K cards per drop. I've tried getting in 3 times and keep missing. But at $14, it'd totally be worth it.
Forget getting set up at local LCS….Fanatics will try to take it over. Imagine if they made these available at local Targets and Walmarts instead 🥳
That would be awesome if they could get into Walmart. I love the kiosk idea at a card show all day. I think that'd be a perfect opportunity to grab market share.
Only thing I dislike about TAG is they do drops have to catch it perfectly to send a big order.
Great breakdown on TAG. fully agree with that business model, it's a great concept but probably not something that will come to fruition. I really like the look of the slabs and feedback you get so will definitely be sending some of my PC items to them.
Yeah, the little touches they're doing - Beautiful slabs, grade transparency, the set registry, the packaging - all exactly what collectors have been asking for. I really feel they'd benefit from simply focusing and grabbing market share and generating awareness of the grading breakdown. The costs to get I to LCSs is just not feasible to generate profits when you're only grading around 10-20K cards a month.
They do have the mechanism in place so that you can’t regrade it
Even though a TAG 10 with a 980 might be a more perfect card than a pSA 10, people might actually not like the 980 score. People just want to see the 10.
Whoa! PSA is $25/card unless they are having a special. Then it's $18/card for Club Members. And then, you can only submit the Style, era, or game cards they specify.
Yeah, overall I think TAG is still a little expensive when compared to SGC, but I really like a lot of what they're doing. It's all about scaling for TAG right now and if they can pull it off, it feels like they could become a serious player in the grading market.
Their slabs look nice
I may be incorrect, but I think there longer term play may be to sell or license their grading tech.
I wouldn't be surprised to see them sell at all.
So what if the slab is a gem mint 10 and on the QR code it says tag instead of a number? Also, this slab looks to have a black background with white lettering
Does TAG grade authenticate & grade autographs along with the autographed card?
… just an additional thought. If a company like Fanatics were to acquire TAG with Fanatics’ massive industry influence and brand power, it could give more credibility to the AI model and rival PSA’s antiquated grading approach. Would be interesting…
Do you pay up front when submitting the order or do they charge once cards are sent back like PSA ?
You need to pay up front.
So why didn’t the Baty 878 not round up to a 9 ? Price point is too high.
Because a 9 is 900-950. An 8.5 is 850-899. It's weird, I know. It's because the 10 has to be 950+. It effects the rest of the grading scale.
Waiting on your Bowman Chrome set review….
So the reviews are on hiatus... I'm reinventing the whole concept to be more about "what's good, what's not, what's interesting and should you get in"
Just trying to figure out how to present that info in an entertaining way that stays informative.
@@1CentSportsCards I will say I really enjoyed your review videos and how you broke down each team.
Whats the turnaround times?
2:00 yeah odd because Dan the Card Man swears the hobby doesnt want it. Just had this conversation about it. I said grading is dumb because the number is a mystery. I said if they included reports then maybe it would be different. He said no nobody wants that lol
Dan the Card Man is nothing but a click bait channel. Never trust a channel that talks about cards yet never shows a card. He doesn't even have his own stories, he just regurgitates stuff from X and Sports Cards Radio, makes a 12 minute video for something that could be said in 2 minutes and acts like he's doing the Lord's work for the hobby.
@@1CentSportsCards I clipped it and replied to him with it. I think its ridiculous to think people dont want the report. Hell ya we want it
All my PC cards are going to TAG when I can snag a drop
They are beautiful slabs. I'd totally recommend them for a PC collection. Good luck getting in the drop!
@@1CentSportsCards I have 1 submission in currently
Im never impressed with new grading companies especially HGH garbage slabs. Tag blew my mind.
The only bad thing its going to take a while for the prices to can any value. Old school PSA collectors aren't going to buy TAG graded cards and have the inconsistency in their collection. Which sucks the hobby needs a grading company like TAG and its nice that you can look at the grade and nit question anything on why it was graded. Psa and their pop control on key cards should be considered fraud
If TAG wants to be taken seriously they need to be able to grade RPA’s. Grading to scale has been challenging for TAG
I’d like to see a Tag order crack & submitted tO PSA to compare.
I'm sure down the YT rabbit hole there's a video of this idea. There's got to be, right?
@@1CentSportsCards I found some but in reverse. Cracked PSA and Beckett to tag. This one video the guy couldn’t believe he got a Beckett 7.5 on a card and he sent it to tag, it came back a 10. All of the others were pretty close. I think one PSA went from a PSA 8 to a Tag 9
I really hope Tag catches on…I really dig this way of grading.
Flipper = Loathes TAG as they only want 10s not an actual grading. Crack and resubmit is part for the course.
Hobby enthusiast = Loves TAG as they want accurate grading.
Hobby Collector = 1/2 & 1/2 They prefer higher grades than accurate grades. Overall, MORE probable more accuracy with TAG.
If you Pump and Dump.......Any grading house that gives 10's like "Carter's has Liver Pills!"
Save you $$, Grading is the biggest Con/Grift. Use that $$ and purchase vintage HOF players. Imagine the collection you can actually have over time.
You guys remember taxis?
🔥👌🔥🤘💯🤘
A ten is a ten big dogg why else would it be a ten then maybe should have got another grade
Well a 10 is a 10, but a 978 10 would be considered less flawed than a 951 10. And with so many 10s in ultra modern cards, differentiating between them is probably a good idea... Or at least the idea behind TAGs grading scale. I appreciate you watching!
I agree with many in the comments. I did not read all the comments though. The one thing i did not see in the comments though is money. Most of the big spenders to PSA and other grading companies will never make the switch. Simply because they would be losing money. When TAG grades a card 8 (or maybe lower) And PSA gives it a 10. That is a lot of money left on the table that the big spender will be losing. There is one card. You can go look at sportscard investor and look at the 1952 topps Mickey Mantel. "The Holy Grail of sports cards. The PSA 10 the nicest one ever known to mankind. Then look at the SGC i think was graded 9 or 9.5. It is a much nicer card. But there is like $40,000,00.00 dollar price difference in the card. The PSA has a surface problem on the card. All down thru the bat near his neck. How this graded a 10 is beyond me. So the biggest people in the market will never let something like TAG take over. As it takes away the power they have.
'Promo sm'
To sell a TAG 10 lower than a PSA 10 is insane, PSA gives out 10's like candy, PSA is for the scammer side of the hobby.
We all want perfect grades but sounds to anal to me
Thanks for sharing your opinion
People that care about a red psa bamner are also the weirdos thats care about blue texts.
Spoiler alert: no
Explain your concerns...
@@1CentSportsCards No dealer takes them seriously. They are 30 years behind the big boys (PSA, SGC, BGS) CSG is WAY ahead of them. Nothing against them, but spending money on the smaller grading houses is a waste.
New subscriber here! Thank you for this valuable information! My friend and I make videos opening different sport packs. We just started and it would mean the world if you would 🎉th us ;) Thank you for your content!!