Mulan is the Worst Disney Live-Action Remake So Far
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2020
- Go to BuyRaycon.com/schaffrillas for 15% off your order! Brought to you by Raycon.
Schaff is not happy, Bob. Not. Happy.
Patreon: / schaffrillas
Twitter: / schaffrillas
Redbubble: www.redbubble.com/people/scha...
Reddit: / schaffrillas
Esteemed $5+ Patrons:
Aamod Pant
BiGGE_Cheeze
Blaine Melvin
Bomfs, of Bomfscorp Ltd
BryceCold
Camille P
CG Lemonade
Charlotte M
Cole Jackson
Dan Vicarel
David Alejandro Moreno
Dig Dog
Dman990099
EpicEvan921
Flan
Gabi Christie
Genevieve Schoeberlein
Hadley Milano
InazumaFrost
Jacob LaBossiere
James Rodehaver
Jared Metzner
Jonatan Burgos
Kevin Tomato
King Goodra
Leporibae
Logan McQuaid
LuckyLightGamer
Maddy!
Milky
Nick G
NoneLovesMe
Noobuu
Nozerz
Peter Hollens
Put 9-Volt in Smash Bros. Please
Rina
Sara2
SeaJay Guzman
Seth Howell
Soalric Parker
Soloco
Tailored Muffin
Terry Maverick
That Guy Named Rai
The Right Opinion
TheClooch
Thomas Leeds
Tyson V
Uncultured Swine
Vellum Tony
Vintage
William Johnson
Zelda Cailin - บันเทิง
"now all of youtube knows this movie is terrible."
"Perfect"
Now it will bomb like it should
Alexandrian Tria I wish I could like this twice
"Shit"
How many youtuber it take to send a message
Pirated this movie and i still want a refund
Now I’m just imaging the guy who’s streaming it PayPal’s you some money with an “I’m sorry” note. 😂
Disney ought to pay you for the trauma of having watched it
Kudos to your for doing that. Legit. Disney wants people to pay 30 fucking bucks or something to get the movie early, instead of just releasing it to Disney+ when they plan to (which, needless to say, should be never).
Link please?
@@crunchy1547 gotcha dude
www.olevod.com/?m=vod-play-id-21158-src-1-num-1.html
if you can handle the hentai ads then you're good to go
Something else I hate is how the main villain dies.
In the animated version, he gets launched into a bunch of fireworks and exploding in a fire of colors. Cartoony, but somewhat realistic. You can absolutely die from fireworks.
In the live action version, the emperor catches an arrow flying at him at top speed like an anime character, throws it, and Not Mulan kicks it with enough power to pierce and kill him.
They absolutely butchered it. No other words for it.
"Butchered" is pretty appropriate in this context
@@isaywhateveriwantandyougot7421 Butchered is a strong word. It's the right word, but still.
I never seen the remake and hearing this version of the villain’s death just made me lose braincells
@@Aimi_Kanekous 🤝
exactly plus I think its symbolic I mean the fire works symbolis how an empire falling is a captavating yet scary site cause it could happen to yours
The actress for Mulan didn’t show ANY emotion, just had the same blank stare pinned on her face.
it's an independent woman from live-action-disney
what did we expect?
@@nikoskonstantinidis4069Oh yeah right! They DONT have souls GREAT! 🫠
Pokémon sun and moon
The best part of the animated Mulan was the fact that Mulan wasn't magical or special, beyond her tenacity and intelligence. She manages to succeed because she finds unconventional solutions and refuses to give up. Take that out and what the hell is even the point??
Plus that her unconventional solutions do not make her overpowered. Like how she fired at the mountain instead of shan yu to win the war, yet that made the guy survive in the end. It is a depiction of actual human decisions and not just what the plot wants for it to end.
Yea, she was like anyone else which stuck out to us growng up that even being like everyone else we can succeed at something but nah just make her magicial because only special people can do stuff
this is the most sexist movie I have ever seen instead of Mulan training to fight like the on others she just naturally gifted and instead of her using her intelligence to get out of problems just use your muscles oh what you want to be an empowered woman but your not as strong or as naturally gifted in fighting like a man I mean like Mulan well too bad just go get married like Mulan sister.
ikr
@@paulitopichipoothingi8573 what
I'm amazed, the animated version is the most realistic one. AND THAT ONE HAD A DRAGON.
Ironic
Reality is Unrealistic, to quote TV Tropes
Eddie-murphy-laugh.wav
a TALKING dragon!!
@@gix.y are you telling me that talking dragons that sound like Eddie Murphy aren't real?
honestly, a 1/10 is being nice.
I'd like to know whats the part of the movie that got the 1 point.
@@jugemujugemugokonosurikire4735 The movie got the 1 point for the end credits because it meant that the movie was finally over
@@jugemujugemugokonosurikire4735 No. I would say the live action Mulan would get a 2.5/10. (Just in my opinion)
I thought it was a 7-8/10.
Then there is something wrong with you
You can tell Schaff's angry when he doesn't use as many Tamatoa pictures in his review.
Not a SINGLE frame of his face is enough to truly express the anger within.
i'm so sick of "strong independent women" characters that have no personality or traits besides being a woman
Could you give some examples of well executed characters with the traits of ‘strong independent woman’ type?
@@dfquartzidn6151 Mulan in the original, for one
DFQuartz IDN Literally Mulan from the original
@@dfquartzidn6151 Ciri from Witcher series.
@@dfquartzidn6151 Kill Bill
“This Movie is supposed to be more realistic and mature”
Animated movie literally has more blood
Disney said no to a talking dragon to be realistic, okay fine i get it, BUT THEY PUT A WITCH THAT TURNS INTO A HAWK AND BATS AND OTHER PEOPLE? cmon now that's sum BS mushu was my favorite character
They really try hard to please Chinese market lol
your channel is even worse than clownfish tv!!!!!!
skye chor Funny because all the writers.... Weren’t Chinese.
Well, those don't necessary go hand on hand, but animated Mulan would be just as mature with or without blood
1998: Mulan has to LEARN how to fight, but her major talent is the smart moves she makes. Brains over brawn
2020: MULAN BUILT DIFFERENT
Also, even her wits needed some refining, she was only using her talents to be a lazy loaf, which only lead to messy halfassed jobs and her getting very lost if she was not allowed to cheat her way out, the board game clip showed her untapped potential as a problem solver, and the training helped her strengthen that aspect of hers, while also greatly reducing her weaknesses, making her all the more balanced and capable
1998*
1998
YESSIR
I agree that this 2020 remake is so bad
Director/producers: “We wanted to make this film realistic”
Also the directors/producers: *Hits money blunt* “Witches, Phoenixes and Mulan Skywalker”
Also Mongol women being kept out of battle lmao like I’m not gonna go around and say they were feminists but the idea that women fighting was alien to them is ridiculous
1998: A girl worth fighting for
2020: A film worth not watching
I really hope they don't butcher Hunchback of Notre Dame. Out of all the live action remakes, this one needs to be good.
@@ausername8699 omg I didn’t know they were making that- I’m actually terrified they will fuck it up !!!! 🙈
@@xoshanland It's on their remake list, but it probably won't come out for a long time due to Covid. Hopefully they learn from Mulan because it lost a ton of money trying to be both Chinese and Westernized at the same time.
Hunchback should relatively easier to adapt since its more similar Les Miserables than Mulan.
@@ausername8699 it's a bad idea because scary big shoulder man would scare the toddlers that are watching because their grandma bought the wrong DVD instead of the real Hunchback of Notre Dame. All the Disney live-action remakes are just cash grabs
@@ausername8699 Oh god they are gonna ruin hellfire somehow aren't they.
A chinese woman made a twitter thread about how inaccurate the movie was culture wise so the argument that they cut out a bunch of stuff for culture just hurts much worse.
But hey, white libs got what they wanted
A link to the thread?
Twitter? Damn we are so down
Link please!
I would also want to see the tweet myself.
The editing in this movie makes Spy Kids look like the most amazing action movie
Spy Kids IS the best action movie
Um.... W O T
Spy Kids 3 and 4 were the best
Well technically at that time period it was but I can understand where your going here
No no clearly Shark Boy and Lava Girl are the best.
You know, I've been thinking about this for a long time. You mention that the cricket gets all the hate in the world for ruining Mulan's chances with the matchmaker and not Mulan herself. That is true and the cricket deserves it, but why was the cricket given to Mulan? It was given by her Grandmother based on the belief that crickets give good luck, and we clearly see this belief is false.
And with that understanding, a gong went off in my head. This theme, the idea of traditions being flawed or even counterintuitive is shown all the way throughout the film, not just in the human charecters, but in the story beats as well.
Going back to the grandma, her belief in the cricket's luck is almost hypocritical as her first line is her chiding the mother's worries.
("I should have prayed to the ancestors for luck."
"How much luck can they be? They're dead.")
It is true that she crossed the road, but that could have happened without the cricket.
Mushu is the only one of the guardians we see and from minute one, we are shown is unhelpful and pathetic at his job. (Rip Fa Zane) And when he tries to awaken The Great Stone Dragon, he does so with no reverence, no care to this being it is hinted is far above anything he could have been.
Speaking of The Great Stone Dragon, this thing is given such importance, such reverence by the family and ancestors. In the scene before Mulan's haircutting, we see her beside the statue, sitting in it's lap as a child would a comforting parent for guidance. And yet she makes her own decision after seeing the turmoil of her actual family. And the final nail in the coffin is that this great statue is just that, a statue, broken by what is reguarded as a failure of a spirit.
But the biggest thing that cements this all is how Mushu ensures the troop goes to war; not by magic trickery or spiritual divination, but by disguising as a human messenger with news.
In short the animated movie is the theme 'magic doesn't help you win' done right rather than treating it as a wink to the audience.
That’s actually a really intriguing analysis.
it could be argued that cricket ruining the meeting with the matchmaker *was* good luck as it set in motion the series of events that led to Mulan saving China, though I am quite a fan of your take on things too
what i believe made the original mulan so special was mulan herself. she didn’t get free passes, she trained with all the other men and still was able to prove herself a strong team mate. team mate, not person. she fought within a team, where she relied on her partners and they relied on her. she didn’t become ‘better’ than everyone because of some magical chi, she worked hard and it payed off. this remake just makes a mockery out of it.
zuko is a simp Disney be like: *we now copy overpowered anime protagonists*
EXACTLY. They take everything that I loved before but I said to my self let's give a chance. Well. I WAS WRONG! I love Mulan because she did battle in every part of the movie, she did her best, she never give up, even when it's world against her. Her family is far away, her friends are disappointed with her, the man she loves and admires it's felling betrayed, she lost everything, and yet she choose to get up and fight for her country and for the people that she love.
its almost like characters growing, needing to face actual challenges, and having depth make good characters.
Here we have someone who was a physical god from the start for bullshit reasons not being challenged or showing any particular prowess other than "im just good at it", not interacting with or deeply affecting other likeable characters, who shows next to no emotions, and faces few threats (like the baddies causing the avalanche themselves to prove their incompetence).
@@ee-td3ex except op anime protagonists usually have psychoemotional growth arcs to make up for it.
It's just not relatable. When I watch Mulan training in the original movie, I feel empowered because we watch her go from being one of the weakest, someone more at most regular girls' level, to being a strong warrior just like the guys. Giving her chi just tells us, "Yeah women can be strong, but only if they have magical powers."
Disney is trying so hard to show us they're feminists that they forget about writing an actual personality for their female lead
The worst part is they gave up actual entertainment for female empowerment here, but... *They failed that too.* Not every woman has chi running through their veins that magically makes them good at everything. So how the fuck is this supposed to inspire them?
Woman woman female female power yeah just go and make a good movie for once!!! Jesus Christ 🤦🏽
Disney teaching young girls, u r only worth if u r born prodigies or have super powers. 🤦♀️
@@sheenshah5253 more like a brainwash instead of teaching lol
The best thing about Mulan as a character was her determination and capacity to face challenges, but they took that away. They threw away what really made her a strong woman and gave her superhero powers instead.
I am a straight man. Mulan is one of my favorite Disney movies of all time. 1998 one. In that version she had something called character growth. She starts out as bumbling somewhat of a disappointment to her parents who doubts her worth in the family. Yet she deeply loves her family enough to the point of going her fathers place where impersonating a man would mean death. She is weak physically at first bad at anything martial and yet with time and training she grows stronger and earns the respect from her fellow soldiers. She leads by example and puts her life on the line to save China her friends and most importantly her family by going to shoot the cannon by herself. She is revealed to be a woman and banished. She again saves China well at least the emperor. When she gets home she is accepted well more so haha and she’s confident to approach li Shang for dinner. The songs are awesome the set up etc. it’s funny it shows mass death wounds war fighting. It also shows the amount of sexism that has existed historically in which women have been oppressed and how she overcame stereotypes and earned respect of men to show the strength all women possess. Yet this movie screwed that up. She’s a Mary sue who is the quote unquote the secret weapon from the start. The whole shell die is not there. There is no character growth cuz there’s almost no character. Obviously I was very very disappointed with the remake haha.
Mulan (1998) is my favorite Disney movie of all time.
Mulan (2020) is my inner demons in the form of film.
When I watched this for the first, only, and last time I seriously felt the urge to pull out my eyes.
And ears
And nose
And all other sensory organs
"We cut Mushu out of the movie because we wanted to be more realistic"......
The movie starts with a little girl doing parkour across rooftops, we have a witch that transform into a dozen birds and Mulan doesn't prove to everyone that no matter your gender you can push yourself forward and improve upon yourself and prove everyone that even in a toxic male environment a woman can also shine....but instead she just born with magic powers...
This movie says it wants to be realistic, but in the opening scene when she was the powers, the concept of realistic goes to shit
They mean the 'cool' type of 'realistic', as in super in your face gritty and dark and absolutely no humour or whimsy or colour in any way so you know this is the 'grown up's' version of Mulan.
Exactly this is so bad. Like seriously 😒 Mulan animated was amazing 😉. Comparing the movies. Animated Mulan 😄 Live Action☹️😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Also the phoenix
@Chin Wing LIU Because they never tried to be realistic with those ones,they said they wanted this to be “realistic” but it ended up as a waste of money
Why does white Hollywood think a movie about China cannot exist without mentioning chi
OR MAKING CHINA LOOK LIKE JAPAN OMFG
Uh, Kung Fu Panda 1 and 2 don't mention chi
@@stormdoesgaming8919 dreamworks kinda has its own vibe
@@lulin2546 yes that is is the definition if a good company
Bless you :)
Biggest pet peeve with this movie. In the original the whole thing was “women can do what men can do, but because of the world you have to work harder, and constantly have to prove yourself”, in the new one its “woman can’t do what men can do, but some can, if they have ~magic~, but only if they have ~magic~” 🤦♀️
Me: I just remember. Walt Disney founded Disney studio as a ANIMATION studio NOT A LIVE ACTION FILM STUDIO!(my old Disney soul is raging)
This movie is just an act of dishonor to everyone's cows
Eddie R what if I don’t have a cow though
@@IcyDiamond your faviorite speck on the surface of the sidewalk
Darth Kizr ?
NOT MY COW!
The Fat Piranha Plant your next burger or steak
“Mulan is the worst live action remake so far.”
...So far...
either 2021 or 2022's gonna have a worse one i assure you
Anyone know what, aside from Little Mermaid, they’re remaking next...?
I'm scared to see what they'd do with Hercules or Hunchback of Notre Dame.
Yup, just wait for black Ariel kissing white Eric. I have a feeling i see what message they are trying to force there.
The way things have gone i even joked that they're going to make Quasimodo transgender.
Hopefully they won't remake Emperor's New Groove
This movie is basically saying: 'girls, you don't have to grow, change, and learn from your mistakes as long as you're badass. And just to be clear, only badass women can be heroines.'
Congrats! You successfully described the Disney version of brainrot!
This reminds me of that time someone tried to make an airplane after the Wright Brothers did it, but got rid of everything that made the plane fly. It was in the air for two seconds before dropping at least 60 feet.
Wait that happened? Now you've got me curious dear fellow
@@skygard49 I don't remember much, but I do know that for the moment it was in the air, it became the world's first plane to be on a postcard.
I pirated this movie and still want a refund.
......ooof that burnactually made me audibly say..... oof
gotta claim that refund for the amount of time wasted of watching this movie
If you get yours tell me how do I can get my refund too.
Literally the best comment ever
Where did u watch it
“I hope she’s a better person than she is an actress...OH WAIT.”
I’m literally crying.
That actually shocked me.
@Winifred Eghrudje you know shes an american citizen right?
@@robespierre2837 and even as an american citizen, actors, singers etc were expressing their 'support' through weibo only, those who went to twitter, instagram and beyond are the ones people are criticizing
@@lookatthat2438 yh
@@robespierre2837 she still has property and family in China. If u think the ccp won't hurt them ur delusional.
Animated Mulan: you can be strong no matter who you are.
Live action "Mulan": woman good men bad and stinky
Woman stronk with superpowers
basically it
I find it so funny that Disney took out elements like Mushu for being " unrealistic and disrespectful to Chinese culture" but one of chinese people's favorite western (animated) movies is Kung Fu Panda, a movie about kung-fu fighting anthropomorphic animals with several stereotypes about chinese culture.
and the fact that kung fu panda portrayed Chinese culture better than actual china at the time really says something,
@@user-nx8ce9hk1b Japan has made better representations of Sun Wukong than China ever did, and that's surprising considering the Anti-Chinese sentiments in Japan.
@@gamerstheater1187 did not know that
@@gamerstheater1187 I mean, they made Dynasty Warriors, like, 9 entries already.
the message from this movie is women can only be strong if they were born special and "not like other girls"
My brother owns a sword but he might as well give it to me cuz I take over it.
oh shit this really is just the "not like other girls" thing but literally
@@chinesedramafan4787 good for you?
@@inanakatheboss3001 lol, i said this because nobody is born special, but we can earn our own unique talents.
She’s not like other girls, she’s a robot.
Most of these terrible live action movies wouldn't be created if people just acknowledged that animation isn't inferior to live action. Animation is its own medium with which you can tell amazing stories! It isn't something to be avoided.
So true, but sadly people have already being brainwashed, especially by tv, to think that animation is always, ALWAYS, for kids.
My parents can't watch animation, or if they do, they will think is childish, I can give them something like Castlevania and, just seeing a frame, will say child stuff.
It's sad, but it seems is the direction we are going :c
Yes, or thought of as a inferior replacement until so-called lifelike fx can be reproduced as justification for using real humans in remakes. (See every superhero cartoon being remade in the last few decades.) Animation is its own unique art form created by myriad artists deserving respect unconnected to any other medium by comparison.
And that voice actors are better for animated films. It's literally their job. Part of the reason these remakes bomb is celebrity casting. They're casting people who can't voice act to save their lives.
They just want to make money, not a statement. I guess
Carter Watts Agreed.
This remaking process by Disney is starting to feel insulting. I image them sitting in chairs around a table talking about their plans to make the next billion dollars they don’t need and it goes like
“So we haven’t made a Mulan remake yet? What do y’all think?” And the next guy goes, “Yea but I’m bored of that let’s see how much we can get away with before there is an actual outcry!” And another rich dude is like
“Yea let’s not give it music!”
“Let’s not even bother to give it heart,”
“Let’s not care really about cast or performance!”
“Let’s take as many characters out as possible while still being able to pass it off as a remake!”
And they did and we got this and it’s a mockery
"This crosses the line from bad to insulting." Could not have said it any better myself, this is a slap in the face to all the original movie stood for.
“This movie has the worst editing ever”
Me : it can’t be that bad
“I literally did not edit anything you’re seeing on screen rn”
Me : ...oh
yeah, that got me.
Yeah I watched the movie, he’s not lying the action scenes were pretty bad.
i literally started zoning out bc it hurt my eyes so bad
I felt like I was in a whirlpool lol
@@cornboi4217 sorry you paid 30 dollars to watch this
This movie sucks
Disney: So you want Phineas & Ferb 2d dimension live action without perry?
I'm going to get violently ill in my bathroom now.
Don't dare you do that, I swear if they do I will go to disney headquarters and put six bombs per square inch and make them sxplode with everyone inside.
DINOEXTREME Origin of a Serial Killer right here
I was not fine without Mushu, where's my homeboy
MIAU :3
Hey, where's Perry? The movie
Actual reactions of me during the movie
Before I watched: Omg Im so excited...I wanna see how Mushu will look in cgi!
During: - who is this lady?
- Where is mushu? Im sure he will come
- who the hell is this guy? Where is shang..is shang the old guy?
- finally we are getting mushu...wait...its a crusty paper pheonix
- where the hell is shang?!!
- no further comments cuz i couldn't complete the film....
I had the same reactions XD
OG Disney Mulan: Emotion, heart, soul, good characters, was dark, had the greatest songs, and the greatest message that made Disney a beacon to all young girls like me who saw ourselves in Mulan
2020 Trash Mulan: lmao eff all that, let’s take all of that out and offend the Chinese by showing how woke we are, also let’s include chi as an excuse why Mulan can overpower everyone
Wasn’t the point of Mulan was that she was training all her life to be a perfect wife/woman and failing miserably, but excelled above all the older men at being a warrior/man in a few weeks?
and the main reason she was so good at being a soldier was because she was forced to think outside of the box / work even harder than the men bc of her desperation to be respected and to keep her gender a secret. also she was super smart and good at finding other solutions to things.
Ah, screw all that character development. Let's just give her powers without any point of her training for no particular reason except that she's a girl.
But nah fuck that, now Mary Sue Rey, I mean Mulan has super powers and can do anything since she was a baby
But In the army it was more strict and she had to think more becuase when you fight there isn’t much plan
@@AnnoyingMystery I loved that about the original Mulan. She was a good soldier, but not by brute force. She wasn't a superhero, and was actually weaker phisically than the men. BUT she was clever and outsmarted the rest of the soldiers.
She climbed the pole not because she was the strongest, but because she was the smartest.
She beat the villain (who seemed to have superhuman strenght) not by beating him up, but by being smarter.
Disney forgot that "strong, independent woman" isn't a personality
Except in this mulan they pretty much remove everything making her strong and independent woman anyway and replace it with ***super powers***.
True. She was so bland I wanted to cry.
I wish Obama was still here
Also, Mulan is not "strong" at all, she is just the chosen one.
Thank YOU
Original movie: if you work hard, you can achieve anything. Stay determined to reach your goal!
Remake: sorry u need special powers to be as strong as others
3:58 So, basically Mulan's Girl Goku and the Witch is discount Bayonetta?
Oh my god you're right
Hold up, Goku trained for the power he had (Mostly, and even than he admitted to everyone around him that he wishes to train and fight with his own power and hates shortcuts.), has an actual character in the original Dragon Ball and Dragon Ball Z and barely wins any of his fights by himself in Dragon Ball, Z or Super. Meanwhile, Live action Mulan has no character, wins every single fight and Is a complete Marry Sue.
Also the fact that she rips off her armor in battle to "be true to herself"...GIRL YOU CAN STILL BE YOURSELF AND WEAR ARMOR!!! ARMOR KEEPS YOU SAFE!!!
and took her hair out of her bun? Like I know they where try to do a girl power thing or something but I'm pretty sure hair in your face during battle is a sure way to get killed.
@@LisaAnne1998 there's a reason soldiers shave their hair off bruh
bruh idiot
THATS THE EXACT SAME THOUGHT I HAD
Ah but you see, this doesn't take place in china. It takes place in the china region of catachan, because you'd have to be living in Warhammer 40k for that to make sense.
Seeing how Mulan is like, one of, if not, the strongest Disney princess, this really dulls down that fact.
Giving her chi just makes her overpowered. What really made her a great woman was the fact that she trained hard to protect those she loved and her home. All of the original princesses are better for empowering woman than what is current on screens today. Even the more girly girl ones have better messages.
i agree, with the whole her being born with powers gives me a "i wish i can be her" not a "if i work hard like her, i will be her"
Back then being strong meant overcoming hurdles you previously couldn't, nowadays it means getting everything handed to you on a silver platter and make it look like you earned it.
Celeste CC i agree. I had high hopes. Mulan is my favourite disney movie, And it crumbled and died. But also GOD I WANT A BLACK COFFEE
I bet u didnt watch till the end haha but i wonder why so many likes. Truth is 85% who hates this movie havenot yet watched it
@@Sebastian-ig3lt i haven't watched the movie, but I know that she has chi and I have seen some clips of Mulan, and my point still stands (I don't "hate" it because i haven't seen it, but i know I wont like it because I only like a select few of the live action remakes). But no for once I watched the entire video before commenting lol
The two scenes I feel they failed the most are training scene and the village scene.
First the training scene, in the original, we see our cast of characters be really bad and them struggling. They're trying to improve, but Mulan is pretty much told to leave because she's falling behind everyone else's progress. So she decides to go for the arrow, realizing the proper technique is important not just pure determination. And by using her smarts, she gets the arrow. This marks a turning point and we see everyone actually becoming good!
What did the live action do? Mulan walks up a hill with water and succeeds on her first try. She doesn't struggle, she uses her fucking magic powers. This is also very similar a task they did while training in the animated one, where everyone else was going just fine. BUT NOPE! This time Mulan is the one who succeeds while everyone else struggles. I don't think there's a single scene in this movie where she gets better at anything, everything just comes easy to her thanks to her chi powers. How do you expect me to root for her when she stays pretty much the same the entire movie???
Second, the village scene. In the original they're singing a happy song for fun, just for the song to cut when they find the village. We go from a bright cheery song, into a dark awful event. You see everyone taking it in, the destruction and loss of life. You feel the shock, the grief, you feel what the characters feel. And after this scene, they don't sing anymore. Things have changed and they need to take the war seriously. They found a girl worth fighting for when they were too late and found the lost doll of a girl who has lost her life.
I'll be honest, I can't even remember the live action one beside from what was showm in the video. That's how lazy and boring it was. *How* do you go from a scene that sticks with you for years into a scene that is so worthless and not important you can't remember it at all?
I hate this movie with a passion.
I love how he just stops censoring the swearing halfway through
pretty in-character to the last movie, going from humorous and kiddy to dark and adult
2017: Beauty & The Beast is the worst live-action Disney remake
2019: Lion King is the worst live-action Disney remake
2020: Mulan is the worst live-action Disney remake
I'm starting to see a cycle here
They keep one upping themselves lol
I liked it-
To go above and BEYOND!
Little Mermaid going to be next?
Me stanning the Aladdin remake and only the Aladdin remake and that is the hill I choose to die on.
"I don't care about the children! I just care about their parent's money!"
-Mr. Krabs
This quote perfectly represents modern Disney.
"What inspired you to create these live action remakes to your classic films?"
"Money."
Disney: "Am I really gonna remake my classic movies for money?"
"OF COURSE I AM!"
At least Mr. Krabs has a heart...
Walt Disney is turning over in his grave and screaming his head off😭😭😭😭
@@sunshineholtzlander5593 Nah, dude made pretty racist characters in his old movies.
When I was little, I learned from the original Mulan that ANYONE could succeed if they worked hard. Watching this, I learned that only people born with talents can succeed and the rest of us can never be as good.
The mulan in the animated movie worked hard and became respected like a princess. And the live action was like fuck that use random super powers that you have.
Disney is creatively dead. The management killed it, basically slaughtered it.
I always expected changed the good 2d movies would be making them smooth and in 3d
I think that's just today's movies period. Creativity is dead, everything is remade or rebooted. It's truly sad.
@@natayleegivens1046 Ik ☹️
Yup every Disney movie after Moana is shit
@@sherreoz5399 but beauty and the beast (live action)
Is fine
Actually, you’re wrong. This movie isn’t worthless.
It is a example on how not to make a movie.
Have your own opinion but you guys treat it as a fact!!!!😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
@@marshall5620 Chill bro. It is just a plain old joke.
@@potatofive8711 It's prolly just one of those kids who gets angry at people for not liking this movie.
Just ignore em' they don't know what kind of movie we grew up with.
@@potatofive8711 I think that was also a joke because no sane person unironically uses that many emojis
Matthew Collins Get out
As a Vietnamese, I would prefer they hadn't turned a great cartoon masterpiece like Mulan into an emulation of Chinese films like "Romance of the Three Kingdom". I feel surprisingly nostalgic of my childhood watching these films but without all the good elements that make these Chinese films better than the live-action.
Live-action Mulan in a nutshell: Hi i’m Mulan and I was born with a special power that makes me stronger than literally any other character in the movie but I can’t use it because *gEnDeR rOlEs*
but I use it anyway and go not train for war because i’m technically already stronger than the men… AND Speaking of men look at that! A dude that definitely doesn’t look like a K-pop star and we have some sexual tension here and there but because he’s not a human with female reproductive organs the movie glosses him over and there’s this witch lady that is a feminist but nobody cares about her and I end up saving the empire and whatever dynasty I’m in thanks to my female-girl-lady-women-ness. The end.
This was Rlly long so don’t read it if you don’t want to
Disney: We removed Mushu to make the movie more serious and real.
Also Disney: PAPER PHOENIX
Also also Disney: Mulan has magic chi powers now woop woop
Also also also also Disney: BIRD LADY
Um ok imma be real, I did not expect this to reach 200 thumbs up in an hour.
ThAnks FOR tHe rEddit GolD Kind StRangers.
I will just move this to the bottom if anyone wants to continue the chain BTW
@@benjaminhaines7145 wholesome chungus
Paper Phoenix go whoooosh
This is like comparing Ratatoing to Ratatouille
ratatoing 😂😂😂 that scarred me
Precisely
@@IcyDiamond Oh hey! I did not know you watch his videos. Hiiiii
There was a sequel?!
@@jpHasABadHandle No,it's a shitty rip off
Except it's actually probably not a rip off and it's probably juat trying to trick people into buying it cause they it's Ratatouille.
I’m mad that they didn’t include Mushu the dragon, that was what made the animated one so special to me as a kid
Thank the lord that he pointed out all of those “good reviews” from the movie. I honestly wonder if the people who had written the reviews even saw this disgrace😤
Disney: This should please the Chinese audience.
Me, a Chinese: No.
My chinese friend also says it feels more racist than appeal to chinese audience
A Chinese, you say? Well I have some words for you.
动态网自由门 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Free Tibet 六四天安門事件 The Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 天安門大屠殺 The Tiananmen Square Massacre 反右派鬥爭 The Anti-Rightist Struggle 大躍進政策 The Great Leap Forward 文化大革命 The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution 人權 Human Rights 民運 Democratization 自由 Freedom 獨立 Independence 多黨制 Multi-party system 台灣 臺灣 Taiwan Formosa 中華民國 Republic of China 西藏 土伯特 唐古特 Tibet 達賴喇嘛 Dalai Lama 法輪功 Falun Dafa 新疆維吾爾自治區 The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region 諾貝爾和平獎 Nobel Peace Prize 劉暁波 Liu Xiaobo 民主 言論 思想 反共 反革命 抗議 運動 騷亂 暴亂 騷擾 擾亂 抗暴 平反 維權 示威游行 李洪志 法輪大法 大法弟子 強制斷種 強制堕胎 民族淨化 人體實驗 肅清 胡耀邦 趙紫陽 魏京生 王丹 還政於民 和平演變 激流中國 北京之春 大紀元時報 九評論共産黨 獨裁 專制 壓制 統一 監視 鎮壓 迫害 侵略 掠奪 破壞 拷問 屠殺 活摘器官 誘拐 買賣人口 遊進 走私 毒品 賣淫 春畫 賭博 六合彩 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Winnie the Pooh 劉曉波动态网自由门
@@simj202 ı highly agree
Yiding Liu I imagined you to say no in the Simon cowell
It seems funny to speak English in Chinese ancient costume movies
Original movie: Hard work and determination will make you succeed
Live action: Fuck hard work, I have the power of God and anime on my side!
AHHHHHHH-
1998 : Hard working, butt kicking female who trains along men and who starts off her training experience making mistakes but keeps working and trying and uses her smarts and self discipline to get better and improve.... Never gives up!
2020 : M A G I C
Underrated comment.
Plot armor
i love these comments
Thank Christ that this movie didn’t win an Oscar. I was genuinely terrified that it would have when I watched the Oscars earlier this year.
Why Disney keeps doing these live action remakes?! They are aways inferior than the originals
The funniest part out of all of this:
The whole point of the changes, was because they wanted the movie to do really well in China, and they felt that they should make the movie more loyal to the original legend Mulan was based of.
Not only apparently it's not more loyal to the source, but seemingly Disney didn't think of including any Chinese person on the creative team of the movie they made to appeal to the Chinese market. And the movie is bombing and getting panned in China.
Edit: To be entirely fair, I don't think my dumb ass can make that much fun of Disney executives for bad decisions when, just one day after watching videos tell me how useful it can be to leave comments that get lots of likes in the videos of bigger creators, I post a comment like this using my personal-use channel instead of the one I want to become a youtuber with.
Wh--so their solution to making it more based on the original legend was to be even more inaccurate about Chinese culture?
"they wanted the movie to do really well in China" lol well disney is heavily funded by chinese...
F in the chat
Good
"The Harder You Try, The Harder You Fail'
-Common Daoist Teachings
Hello, I work for Disney, and I'm proud to announce that we're remaking The Princess and The Frog.
We're getting rid of all the magic, because we want the movie to be as realistic as possible.
Also, we're getting rid of Prince Naveen.
And we're getting rid of all the references to racism, since we want this to be a family friendly movie.
We're also getting rid of all the music. And literally any sound.
There's now a brand new character who can transform into an army of frogs, and she's also the main villain.
ngl the last idea would be great
@@justasmltwngir1732 Oh, ok. Thanks for telling me. :)
I'll get rid of that idea. We can't have anything interesting in our movie
@@justasmltwngir1732 Seriously though, now I wanna make a movie about a lady who can turn into an army of frogs
Memento mori
@@genericname2747 lol
Mulan [1998] : "Anyone Can Be a Hero !"
Mulan [2020] : _(Closes Book and Fixes Glasses)_
"No, I don't think, **Anyone** Can Be a Hero..."
_(Gives Their Mulan bullshit "Chi" Powers to somehow make her more relatable to women)_
Disney should've stopped at making live action remakes in 2016 when they made Jungle Book and Cinderella.
“The Lion King 2019 is no longer the worst Live Action Disney Remake”
Was it even Live-Action to begin with?
I don't care.
Technically, no
Lion king 2019 is the worst disney animated movie
lol no it's just an alternate animation of a movie that was already amazing with performances that have no soul (i literally watched 2 mins of the remake and could not get watch anymore without considering it torture)
What's worse is that it's considered the highest grossing animated movie,yet it's a complete rehash.
The animated Mulan had the theme “Anyone can be a hero” but the live action had the theme that “You have to be born special to be a hero”
As Zuko stated, in the best of my memory, "I was lucky to be born; she (Azula) was born lucky."
Literally what live-action Mulan said. You gotta be fuckin' born lucky just to be a hero.
Thank you Mike Wazowski
She needs superpowers to be a worthy opponent to male villains
I was the like 420
I’m special ed so I’m a hero
Thank you very much for giving this movie exactly what it deserves.
This movie was not good. To make the witch a better villain, I would let it be that the witch is Mulan’s sister. The live-action remake replaced the grandmother with her sister. The reason why her sister, aka the witch would attack Mulan is that she felt rejected by her own family. Because of Mulan’s chi powers, her family gave all of the love and attention to Mulan instead of her. The family would look down to the sister because they believed that she wasn’t and never will be as good as Mulan. This would at the VERY LEAST make the villain a little bit better.
I feel like the animated Mulan movie feels more realistic than the real life movie.🧐
🤔
😯
Yeah I definitely agree with you
😬
Ironic isn't it
Dragons are too unrealistic, but a phoenix and witch-sorceress aren’t?
Ikr? Look at what Game of Thrones did with their dragons and tell me multiBILLION dollar Disney can't do better. They just... It just... No.
I guess maybe it’s either because:
A. They thought Eastern dragons would be confusing since many Eastern countries adopted the same design of the dragon (only country I can think of would be Japan).
Or
B. This production team couldn’t animate or incorporate the small dragon (forgot his name). Where they weren’t able to (or didn’t bother to) animate the dragon climbing over things or having him interact things in the real world.
Either way, it’s pretty disappointing and nonsensical that the dragon from the original isn’t in the remake, yet add a witch and a Phoenix despite the two being unrealistic.
Edit: apparently it’s because the animated mulan movie depicted dragon(s) as dumb and clumsy instead of wise. Which is ‘offensive’ to the culture. Even though the remake could have easily made the dragon much more wise instead of it being clumsy in the original.
EXACTLY!!!
That's exactly what I'm thinking!! ._.
From what I've heard about this movie, they didn't have dragons because the way the animation depicted dragons was dumb and offensive to the culture. Not because it was unrealistic
Mulan is my favorite Disney movie and I could watch it 7 hounded billion times and not get bored. The characters are great, the scenes are great, the songs are amazing, the be a man scene and Mulan’s “transformation” are on the list of my favorite movie scenes ever. This movie took away everything I loved about Mulan. Instead of having a dramatic scene with her dressing up as a man to go to war with a great score, lets just have her immediately get in armor and leave. Instead of making Mulan train to become a warrior and seeing her struggle, the more realistic path, they just made her have superpowers. Instead of the scene seeing Mulan combine brain and muscle, the scene that makes more sense since biologically, the men there would be stronger than her, nah fuck that, let’s just make her stronger than them and ignore biology. Instead of having charming side characters, let’s make bland characters with no depth or personality at all. Instead of the amazing songs, let’s take bad instrumental versions of them.
This movie makes me so fucking mad
You know what I absolutely DESPISE about this movie?
THERE’S NO MUSHU
How, and I mean HOW, can you get rid of probably the GREATEST side character I have seen in all of fiction and expect me to LIKE it?
This movie gets a -100000000/10 on the White Hat meter
say it with me kids: not everything needs to be live action, animation is WONDERFUL
I mean some things need to be live action but remaking something that was originally in animation, in live action probably won’t work.
One word: money.
The only thing that needs to be in live action is Pokemon.
And I do mean no CGI and no puppetry or robotics.
Aye aye captain.
There is already a live action movie for mulan before this and it's waaayy better
Disney Live action: “Mushu wont be in it, its not realistic”
Also Disney: *Has Mulan fight a sorceress*
Also also disney: mulan has butterfly wings and kicks an arrow or somethin back to the big bad like its KUNG FU HUSTLE
Starting to suspect that mushu was cut more because he is comic relief and his very nature is comic relief rather then it being because of that. Considering they got rid of practically everything else relating to comedy.
@@Thastormable or just pure laziness
@@Thastormable this!
@@Thastormable Not to mention the cultural can of worms with a black man voicing an ancient Chinese dragon... can I have my 90s back please? They weren't perfect but they were far more tolerant.
Fun fact: "Witches" in China were actually fairly respected by the public, and not at all treated like their western counterparts. Well, that is, if they didn't do anything to harm people using their magic. Cuz we all know that's a big no-no.
It hurts that they tried to make this movie more feminist by completely removing the actual feminism. In the original Mulan trained hard and proved she was intelligent, an excellent leader, and team player. In this movie it’s basically telling women that you are incapable of breaking gender roles unless you are literally magic
Feminism is about dismantling the patriarchy.
1998: A girl worth fighting for
2020: A film not worth paying for
1998 actually.
*UPDATE* . I saw you corrected it.
copy and pasted from another comment?
I did not copy and paste we both had similar comments
Lol
*The viewers to Disney after the remakes:* "Are they blind?.. Suffering from some form of brain damage?"
( I just did a reference to your profile pic, but it fits. )
I was at my dad's house on Labor Day, and he said "hey why don't we watch Mulan?" And hey, the original might be my favorite Disney movie ever made, and I may have been religiously avoiding everything about the live action version since its announcement, but HEY: it can't be that bad right?
Watching the live action movie felt akin to having my soul sucked out in real-time. I couldn't agree more with EVERYTHING said in this. Bravo.
My dad did the same thing
Wait, you watch this channel? It's always fun to see a youtuber you like watching another youtuber you like
Mulan was better represented in KH2 and saying that hurts my soul
@UCi_WHT-mh8aRI9FsKnF8cdQ wait you do know he doesn't actually mean he may even like other movies and irrelevanttly saying it to make it sell more because that's marketing is it not
@@Logan-th9is um its marketing his not actually meaning it
Having a women character just be special without having to start of weaker and show growth is the definition of insulting writing.
Bart: Mulan is the worst Disney live-action remake.
Homer: The worst Disney live-action remake so far.
Mulan original was great not because she was strong, feminist or independent. But because of her growth. We got to see how she was the worst soldier, but she became better with her iconic friends who they butchered. I really hoped they brought that out.
What I saw was the Women could be just as successful as men. Live action Mulan just took that message and threw it away, making that no everyone could keep up with men, but just a few select individuals.
Original Mulan was an awesome character. She had a motivation, she was a regular person who showed us that we could get better, she had a personality, she wasn't 100% invencible, she showed little girls that a woman fighting for a good reason was awesome, but 2019 Mulan? Oh yeah she has chi. That's it
@@mariajosefinasaporito5189 This is a prime example of flanderization.
Yep, the original mulan's message is that women can be as good as men. The original mulan, she wasn't invisible, or gifted with magical, supernatural powers or something. The 2020 remake was just, well... all the opposite.
not to mention the three male friends dressing up as women with no problems towards the end. the original was ironically more subversive of gender roles than most modern movies today
My local movie theater literally has “WILL NOT BE SHOWING MULAN” on its billboard lmfao
damn was the film really THAT shit?
Are you serious??!!?
@@games_on_phone89 yes
Federico Arrojo its alright.. it didn’t flow good at all and it should be watched as a film on its own and not like the original cartoon movie at all since its more based on the original poem from China
That's hilarious
The original was my third favorite Disney renaissance movie after lion king and beauty and the beast, and seeing this... it just hurts my soul.
Original: "Mulan is a powerful woman who overcame the most difficult challenges that one can face and empowers the idea that someone can accomplish the impossible not on your own, but by trusting family, friends, and determination."
modern Disney: "She born with superpowers. She so tuff tuff, nobody can stop her, she better den you- she doesn't need to try like you have to. She has plot protection and solves problems on her lonesome cuz she don't need anyone. money money money money" God- what were they thinking?
Disney: We will remake Mulan with a realistic tone
Also Disney: Here's a magical witch!
Also ALSO Disney: Hey moltres exists here :D
The witch was the best character lmaoooo
also also ALSO disney:
WITH thE HElP Of HeR magiCALL PHeoNIx PoKeMoN
I mean a witch existing in the time isn't dumb but adding her to the story and making her a bird was very retarded
@@essejay7952 also why a witch isn't that a very western thing? There has to be an equivalent of some sort?
Me: Damn, I'm not digging this new editing style Schaf is experimenting with. It's too jumpy and makes my eyes hurt.
Schaf: I did not edit any of the shit you're seeing on the screen right now. This is all how it looks in the movie.
Me: Oh... Oh no.
I never expected to get motion sickness from a video on such a small screen
Lmao Chinese action scene goes BRRRRRR
*my dad watched a lot of kung fu movie. At least the old ones. And it's basically **-swish swoosh cling cling cling-** I do not love you mother, you killed my sister - flies then swoosh - then you are not my father*
Exactly xD I was so annoyed till he says that’s not edited
I actually started to feel nauseous when he started complaining about the editing, watching the scenes back-to-back. This is attrocious, holy crap.
YUP
I love how brutally honest this guy is
I know you touched a bit on this, but just wanted to point a bit more out:
A big part of the original Mulan is where she joins the military. She stands out, and trying to blend in is really difficult for her. However, after sheer determination to protect her home, she learns how to fight smarter, and actually improves in her training. The song Be A Man is my favorite song, and it shows Mulan struggling WITH the new recruits. But thanks to Mulan’s inspiration, they also improved. All of them work hard, and improve.
And that’s the big part. BOTH Mulan and the recruits struggle, but they get better. They work hard to get as strong as they are. And that is truly inspiring
However, in this live action trash remake, the writers just take the idea of Mulan working hard to get stronger, and burn it to the ground. They give her all the strength, skill and power she needs without her having to even work hard for it. And their only explanation is that she has “A lot of Chi.” It’s not at all inspiring for any audience, despite Disney’s efforts to make a “good female character”, they instead inadvertently wrote a character that pretty much tells you “you need to be born special to be badass and cool and strong”. They make Mulan an unnecessary girlboss all for the sake of “inspiring female audiences”. And they executed it so badly. Even now, their newer films are all completely discarding the original movie, and making it all about the girls and how badass they are🤦
OG Mulan: Had to push herself and prove to everyone that she was just as capable a warrior as the men were.
Nu-Mulan: hA Ha, ChI giVEs mE UlTRa inStiNCt PowErS!
So all that character growth and determination Mulan had was gone and they made her into a "Chosen One". Does Disney ever watch their movies? Or at least understands why they're so beloved??
Michael Strong They basically turned her into Wendy Wu: Homecoming Warrior. Except I’d rather watch that movie than this boring husk of a movie.
Mulan:HaHa InFinITe PoweR BecAusE dEterMinaTiOn AnD cHi.
Thank God it wasn't friendship power too because I would've thrown up.
@@kingbash6466 I was thinking more like Neo from The Matrix, but he at least had to train to become the One.
That detail *really* irks me...
I originally thought this was going to be a historically accurate version of Mulan and that reason they removed mushu and the songs was to allow for a more accurate and serious movie. After watching it I realized no this is just Disney’s mulan but striped of everything that made it great. It, like all the other live action remakes, is nostalgia bait nothing more.
Nostalgia isn't the only purpose. It's also to let the kids in this new generation know about the movies. I was upset when my youngest sister watched Aladdin AND Beauty and the Beast (animated) the first time and said "isn't this like the movie with the real people?" (Live action remake). But although the live actions are nothing more than for nostalgia, the thing I mentioned and mainly money, not all of them are bad. I personally enjoyed beauty and the beast and Aladdin.
Sad, truly
Yes exactly! I’ve honestly hoped for a less racist version of it that would’ve still allowed all the heartwarming relationships and jokes and ideas shine through and maybe the original soundtrack too! So far I havn’t watched it nor read any reviews, but I do trust schraffilla and was shocked by the scenes he showed on screen :///
The ironic thing...
is that I would be 100% fine with it if they made a 100% real life non- magical non fantastical Mulan film.
An epic story of a woman in an army...
But nah... lets make it even LESS realistic than the animated version.
If it would be an historical accurate movie I would watch the hell out of it. Like I love historical dramas and having one with a strong female who goes secretly to the army? Yeah golden.
One thing I get, from the over-the-top fight scenes, is that the director actually just wanted to make a goofy, fun kung-fu movie, but had to mishmash that with Mulan.
I honestly hope whoever the director is, manages to escape long enough to make that kung-fu movie.
Petition to boycot all live action remakes Disney does
⬇️
Honestly it’s kind of sad they gave Mulan powers and stuff in the remake. She definitely seemed more human and stuff in the animated one.
Freeswine07 pretty much yeah.
Especially since one of the biggest messages in the original was that strict gender roles are damaging and that Mulan was just as capable as the men and that not giving her equal opportunities and respect just because she has bobs and vagene is stupid. But now it's like, "she literally needs superpowers to hold her own against an ordinary man" which is Yikes and Shitty.
Gwendolyn Stata we got to see her grow into a strong warrior, and now she doesn’t have to train because she has some powers? Sounds like bull, but alright.
they changed literally everything, including her traits! mulan was clumsy, yet smart, kind and funny
Fe Jung and now she’s some almost superhero with perfect abilities?
Now all of China knows you hate this movie.
Schaffrillas: Perfect
*all of China hates this movie too
@@emily-bg8cb if that's true; then thank God for that
@@mr.kevin1209 Chinese people watched mulan too.
Honk Kong is boycotting it 👁️👄👁️
@@hansenyan6217 darn it
This has GOT to be the worst of Disney's live-action remakes EVER! First of all, everything that was FUN was taken out of this film -- no talking animals, no songs, not even any really funny moments. It was basically a drama/action flick, with no real attempts at humor. Also, in the original film, Mulan was just an ordinary girl who knew what she needed to do, and she went out and did it. She worked hard to gain the respect of her fellow soldiers, and put her life on the line more than once. But this new version of Mulan was totally unrelatable because she was born with ninja powers, didn't really have to struggle that much in the army, and she won every single battle she got involved in. Who was this movie made for, anyway? Sounds like it was made much for Chinese audiences than American ones, and certainly not for children. Most kids would probably be bored out of their minds within five minutes with THIS film!
Even though I haven’t seen it yet, all I can is…
“DISHONOUR! DISHONOUR ON YOU! DISHONOUR ON YOUR COW!!!” 🐲🐮🐴