China's Hidden Concentration Camps: How China Imprisoned Millions of Uighurs - TLDR News
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ต.ค. 2024
- TLDR Podcast TH-cam: / tldrpodcasts
Livestream: • Video
Hong Kong China Dispute: • Hong Kong's New Securi...
India China Border Conflict: • The India China Border...
UK Bans Huawei: • Britain Considers Bann...
Follow TLDR on Facebook: / tldrnewsuk
Follow TLDR on Twitter: / tldrnewsuk
Follow TLDR on Instagram: / tldrnewsuk
Discord: / discord
TLDR TeeSpring Store: teespring.com/...
Support TLDR on Patreon: / tldrnews
Donate by PayPal: tldrnews.co.uk...
TLDR is all about getting you up to date with the news of today, without bias and without filter. We want to give you the information you need, so you can make your own decision.
TLDR is a super small company, run by a few people with the help of some amazing volunteers. We are primarily fan sourced with most of our funding coming from donations and ad revenue. No shady corporations, no one telling us what to say. We can't wait to grow further and help more people get informed. Help support us by subscribing, following and backing on Patreon. Thanks!
////////////////////////////////////////
1 - web.archive.or...
2 - en.wikipedia.o...
3 - www.bbc.co.uk/...
4 - books.google.c...
5 - simple.wikiped....
6 - www.sscnet.ucla...
7 - www.refworld.o...
8 - www.cfr.org/ba...
9 - www.cecc.gov/pa...
10 - en.wikipedia.o...
11 - en.wikipedia.o...
12 - en.wikipedia.o...
13 - news.bbc.co.uk/...
14 - en.wikipedia.o...
15 - archive.vn/201...
16 - www.hrw.org/re...
17 - www.hrw.org/re...
18 - www.nytimes.co...
19 - www.foreign.se...
20 - www.cfr.org/ba...
21 - www.nytimes.co...
22 - www.cfr.org/ba...
23 - www.cfr.org/ba...
24 - www.foreign.se...
25 - www.aspi.org.a...
26 - www.hrw.org/re...
27 - www.nytimes.co...
28 - www.hrw.org/re...
29 - www.cfr.org/ba...
30 - jamestown.org/...
31 - archive.is/hfGL6
32 - www.un.org/en/...
33 - www.state.gov/...
34 - www.congress.g...
35 - www.cbc.ca/new...
36 - www.cfr.org/ba...
37 - ap.ohchr.org/D...
![[Full Episode] The Restaurant War Thailand ศึกพ่อค้าซ่าแม่ค้าแซ่บ Episode 3 | 6 ต.ค. 67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fTfIMFVjt_8/mqdefault.jpg)
At 3:32 I say that the Han Chinese population represented 67% of residents. As you might have guessed looking at the graph on screen, I meant to say 6.7%. Sorry for any confusion! - Jack
This is a significant error on top of which the province is pronounced sheen-gee-ang, not 'jin yang' and not 'zin yang'.
You always make a mistake in your videos. Always. Hire me to proof-watch/read your videos. I got an A* in Literature and an A in Language at GCSE. I love this channel and your niche on YT too much to see silly errors like this slip by.
@@commercio3564 "Give me money!" -Commercio
Tell me this, UK muslims wanna live by their own laws. And they do live, it's a hard female supression, female mutilation. It's illegal in UK, but it's happening. Especially supression part.
Now, law is written for everyone equally, but some wanna live by sharia law. How we gonna react on that, is it normal for our society? No!!!
At that point, UK laws starts to suppress muslims and their believes. In fact every government's job is suppress differently thinking people. That is their direct function. China is doing what every other country doing, making people follow the law.
@Masked Singer that province was east turkestan uyghuristan land of scitians saka uyghur is turkhis iranians saka,chinese dont desrve help of russia iran
“The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.”― Edmund Burke
The whole world should unite and do more to put an end to this tyranny and persecution.
Right. Pity for the Indians.
The US media then yes.
"If you enjoyed this video"
I am not sure I would say I enjoyed it.
But it is informative and well made.
conor you are idiot or what you enjoyed someone death in auswhitz
@@gcrecords1731 what you smoking?
He said the OPPOSITE of what you accuse.
@Bob Taylor i found a ccp lackie China will pay for it's crimes against humanity.
@Bob Taylor Only time will tell now the clock is ticking
The chinese bots are strong in this thread.
This is basically ethnic cleansing to make everyone identify as Han Chinese. They did the same with Tibet by moving lots of Han Chinese into Tibet to make sure it doesn't become independent. The Tibet leader for independence was forced into exile in India.
Heschewingonit probably connected to the silk road project
When Han Chinese move to another part of China for work that's not "ethnic cleansing", its "economic migration".
@Heschewingonit I don't think its about getting rid of people. They force Uyghur women to marry to Chinese according to some reports. So it's not about a kind of genetic purity. Its all about toeing the party line. Join or leave. Contribute or leave etc.
@Heschewingonit It's not that simple. Companies are perfectly rational when they prefer people that speak their own language and that have been educated to the same standard as their other employees.
That's why libertarians and other anti-regulatory agitators are wrong: the government has a big role to play to protect minorities through necessarily invasive regulation.
I am not in defense of the chinese, but the US also has the same problem with the native indian situaiton, where they are striped of lands and sent to the far reaches of US, and most of them are in dire situations.. then there are the EU with the refugee problem.. the only one with clean slate are Japan.. there are so many problems countries needs to face.. people need help every where.. so instead of looking at it like a joke.. help those people in need.. that is all i could remind people to do.
Xi: "It is not illegal, if you make all the laws"
Reminds me of a certain German fellow with a funny moustache
@@StrangerOnTheWeb It's pretty much what Trump's defense was for his crimes: the president cannot do anything illegal.
@@dirkdeschepper735 laughs in Hillary
Reminds me of the pigs in Animal Farm by George Orwell. “All animals are equal, but some are more equal than others”
@@StrangerOnTheWeb Xi probably has a poster of that mustache guy on his wall in his room
This is genocide. No argument in my mind.
Nice. Regurgitate BS from western msm who wants to destablise China as China is getting stronger economically and financially.
Marvin Western Marine & Offshore Supplies, Okay Comrade
@@marvinwesternmarineoffshor8404 dude the ccp is literally nazis and your defending that
@David -01 your just denying the fact.. people are dying evryday
There is no true footage and facts that I have seen yet
Social credit point -3000
陳奕釩 at -5000 you’ll get sterilized
@@worldpeace1822 -7000 you get great opportunity to donate organs for benefit of China's social harmony.
At -10000 you get a free trip to meet the Tiananmen Square man in person. It's a trip to die for....
Kiri Seraph -"N", if u don't even have the f*king right to breath! And Black & native lives matter!
@pammens miss that's your opinion, but the BLM has had quite a positive impact on our society and many black people feel that they are finally being heard and can use the voices that their ancestors never had.
8:38 the highlighted line doesn't say "round up everyone who should be rounded up." It says "i think you would support it, it's for their own good, for your own good"
The fact that they will get away with this easily is actually more sickening than the genocide itself.
@Fail Zero ha-ha.
Fail Zero what you think that if they had guns (assuming they could afford them and ammo instead of buying you know food) everyone would just immediately start shooting the police.
Especially considering they probably aren’t really certain what is about to happen to them.
At best the police would start shooting back and end up killing everyone in the family.
I haven’t shot anyone (and neither have you) but from what I can tell it isn’t easy and people are very reluctant to resort to violence unless they are in immediate danger.
(unless you are American police)
Aint over yet, Hitler met his match , so will these cnnts.
@Fail Zero If they were bearing arms, this whole campaign would be a hell of a lot uglier.
Same thing happened to the Soviet Union. Mass purges but no one did anything
I liked how you were much more balanced that so called "news networks".
But quoting US financed self titled NGOs like the HRW, military financed "research" agengies like ASPI, and religious extremists who have never even been to China like Adrian Zenz (I wonder if you actually read his report and how he got his data before quoting him) kinda makes some of your arguments moot.
No it doesn't make them moot and Zenz collated of the data he used from Chinese Government sources. In addition, he used the three 2014 directives issued by Ci himself: pop. embedding, p. displacement, and pop. bith quota reduction to ask the question of other if this is calssed as Genocide.
I'm banging my head against the desk.
The quote "Round up everyone who should be rounded up" at 8:33 is totally wrong if you can read the original text at 8:36. I respect the channel and respect the right of free speech, but not the misinformation. I hope the channel can fix the problem.
As a quarter Uighur myself I would like to thank you for bringing awareness to the mad things that are happening there. I see endless talks about certain nations affected by injustice, but somehow no one ever mentions camps in China :(
but do you really want to talk about the camps knowing what they will do, it's just like hong kong... it's a taboo topic for anyone...
I'm sorry that happened to your people, it is unacceptable!!! Absolutely disgusting!
@@PrograError not sure what you mean, all world talks about Hong Kong :)
@@mukhammadmuratov5715 i meant in china, they can talk bout HK but it's often alien.
if you get me...
Racial supremacy - check
Military expansionism - check
Concentration camps - check
Dreams of global domination - check
Guess which country
Viruses spreader - check☑
Do you remember the propaganda "China Builds Hospital in 4 Days" Looks exactly the same as the camps
Ban Chang Bill you unraveled the mystery!
Buildings look similar so
The issue is that these so-called hospitals were absolutely unfit for the purpose that they were built for: to treat COVID-19 patients. The media swallowed the whole story without questioning it. Just like many others about how well the Chinese economy is really doing and how perhaps a comunist management style is sometimes preferred to the capitalist system. Who needs fact checking and critical thinking skills when these are low hanging fruits that are easy to pick and report on.
From above lots of things look about the same.
But prefab buildings isn't some amazing new thing. I don't think it's meaningful to associate these two in any way.
@@0xCAFEF00D Do you think that the "Patients" in the "Hospital" were there by choice? The 3 Metre Razor Wire fence was there for a reason.
8:38 It's not 'round up whoever need to be rounded up' in that highlighted part of document. The highlighted part is saying 'I think u will understand, it's for their benefit, and also for yours.'
Yeah... they need someone who knows Chinese as a correspondent... :)
IKR they can’t even translate it properly
Thank you for clarifying
Two million people is almost the size of entire population of Houston, around one fifth of entire Uighur population, and around 8% of entire Xinjiang Province. I wonder how is that logistically and economically possible to detain that many people, let alone remaining social stability?
because they aren't being detained for long periods of time. it's a rotation system. you stay in the camps for a while, complete the education program, and leave. once you leave, if you don't complete gov sanctioned political education quizzes, you get caught and sent back
@@hwong1776 and you know this how??
@@hwong1776 sounds like if you were once in "camps"
@@hwong1776 Don't forget the voluntary jobs which the Uighors are not paid for... slavery is not employment
How is the world allowing CHINA to get away with this???? 🌈☝️✝️☝️🌈
It's Islam
easy the muslim countries are not complaining
Same way all powerful countries get away with their varied crimes against humanity.
@Ashley I can tell by that statement u know fk all about Muslims, other than what u hear on the news. They don't hate them. Their belief tells them that its wrong; their belief also tells them to accept and not to judge. You going to tell me Christians don't judge or discriminate? I was raised christian, and i'm ngl i think its wrong. Doesn't mean i hate them or would do anything to them.
It would be racist to criticize China
I swear he pronounces Xinjiang differently every time lol
Ikr
Really? Is that your focusing on?
That's because he hasn't much learning about it even the initial pronunciation
Somehow nobody cared for a long time... and suddenly now everyone cares... wtf...
Nobody knew now with video erything changes
That's not fully true. So many news reports and documentaries have repeatedly highlighted this issue in the past years. But the selfish governments of the world decided to ignore it, fearful of losing China's cheap manufacturing. But the only thing that has surprised me so far is, how the UN has been ignoring this issue for so many years. This leaves us with the question, why does the UN even exist?
It's political. There is a separatist group of Uyghur nationalists, many of whom are in exile, who brought these camps to the attention of the NED and anyone else who would listen to them. It appears that they extrapolated a number of detainees based on tiny group of colleagues and the general population, most likely a highly inflated extrapolation. With the current rogue's gallery of western leaders looking to abuse China in order to distract their constituents from their own failures, issues worthy of thoughtful questioning are instead targeted for knee-jerk accusation.
The camps were put in place in response to terrorist activities within China perpetrated by Uighur separatists over the last decade. China admits that they are reeducation camps. If you are an optimist, that means vocational training. If you are a pessimist, it means torture. China's opacity certainly fuels the pessimism, but nobody reliable knows for certain where on that spectrum the truth actually lies. Most in positions of power are more interested in condemnation than they are in truth anyway, after all, there are elections to be won.
They haven’t built camps until 2017 the video says, 2 year delay isn’t much of a delay with how hermetic Chinese institutions are
@@alanfriesen9837 If you want to go by the Chinese propaganda, you can call them as Uyghur terrorists. But the free people of the world would call them as Uyghur Freedom Fighters fighting against the atrocities of the CCP. If you do some more research on the so called 'Uyghur terrorists', you would even see a 11 year old girl and a 75 year old woman in there too. Now if you still want to call them terrorists, go further and call Tibetans, Hong Kongese, Taiwanese as terrorists too. If you still haven't realised, then go and settle in China.
You can hear Jack almost laugh as he reads the words "boarding schools" in reference to concentrstion camps. Thats how ridiculous the premise of that characterisation is...
those poor children taken away from their families. Ive seen kindergarten boarding schools in another video about XinJiang's camps. Those children are only 3-4 years old, they need their mothers love! It is completely heartbreaking, and it is NEVER on the news!!!!!
You left out the worst part.
These concentration camps have become the largest source of "volunteered" organ donations for China. Detainees are subjected to frequent blood tests, and many healthy youth, disappear in the camp networks(which have their own crematoriums).
An airport in the region, even briefly had a dedicated fast line for organs...
I thought organ was taking mainly falun gong practitioners
@@gokulbalagopalpayyanur8080
It was, put simply, they started running low. Most of them they have left in the system are getting too old. Healthy, young adult organs around age 28 are ideal.
I Hope the TLDR Team never goto China lol
Arguably Hong Kong is the real danger zone now, as you can be deported to mainland China to stand trial just for any criticisms you may have publically made anywhere in the world.
And of course, the Chinese Court system has a 99% conviction rate, and VERY harsh sentences for dissidents
@Heschewingonit Layovers? REALLY?
No good reason to go at this point.
@@djoakeydoakey1076 yes, the new security law in Hong Kong can criminalise people outside of Hong Kong who are not Hong Kong citizens. That's why Canada has stopped it's extradition agreement with HK. Same is being discussed in US, Australia and the UK.
I always wanted to visit Hong Kong some day, I fell enamored with the city after seeing Ghost In The Shell (1995) and read from the source material that the city look is based on Hong Kong... I always wanted to see it...
But now I can't since I've been vocal and public critic of CCP with my own name and I don't want to go to prison...
So fuck you CCP!
It seems odd that you didn't cover the organ harvesting which has now spread to the Uighurs from the Falun Gong. I know it's not easy to cover that level of genocide but I think it's important.
I've read about the organ harvesting stuff it's insane
It's a hard one to get accurate information on. There's too many poor sources around that hinder any investigation.
you are gullible! hahaha
This was a kind of softened review for people bew to thr subject or semi denialists I suppose.
A kind of sugar coated version of the events
The Hui are mainly from Ningxia, not where you pointed on that map
thanks for opening this Topic
This is why Huawei UK has to be phased out
nah
Wow i feel like those terrorist attacks happening in china before the whole camp stuff where hardly reported where i live. In generel this video mentioned a lot of things i feel were too scarcely covered in the media before.
Terrorist ETIM doesn’t fit US media narrative.
This is how the media brainwash people
In 1953, Uyghur population was 3.6 million. While in 2010, this figure was more than 10 million. You call this a genercide? Have you asked the opinion of the remaing 9+ million Xinjiang Uyghurs who enjoy China's development and want to live their happy and fuitful lives in Xinjiang without fearing for extremism and terrorism?
Xinjiang is much more stable now, not because of the reeducation measures but because that the majority of Uyghur people support such measures. They know what happens if you don't put extreme ideas and terrorism in check and they are also not blind to what happens when the West successfully destablize your hometown!
This made me remember the episode '2010' of Stargate SG-1. Dang, it's scary.
3:30 ‘grew from representing 67% of residents in 1949, to 40% in 2008’ - not sure that is what you meant to say.
probably 6.7% but ya that was confusing as all hell
You're absolutely, right. I meant to say that the Han Chinese population went from being 6.7% to 40%. Sorry for the confusion - Jack
I think they meant to day 6.7% XD
From China. Start watching your channel when I was in the UK and got totally confused by the Brexit. Thank you for all the detailed videos (including this one), and wish that you won't be targeted by Chinese trolls (many of them are funded by the gov and they can be very damaging).
The propaganda in China is also very strong and so I bet a lot of Chinese are willingly defending their homeland. So, I'd not dismiss everyone defending China just as trolls.
This issue doesn't get enough attention. Thank you for making this very informative video!
I think it’s because so many companies around the world are owned or get the products from China and on cheap labour. So they’re not gonna talk about it if them company’s are making big bucks from stuff like this. Also a lot of countries have trades with China.
@@felicityrose29 Very true. If we didn't have so many products produced from cheap labour then many Americans and Europeans wouldn't be able to afford the quality of life that they do. It's a pretty sad situation.
W Hodge exactly but also we wouldn’t be sat here on our smartphones talking about this topic and opening up peoples minds on what’s actually going on in the world. The sad this is we have all these goods but nearly no one what’s to do good things with them. 💖
At first I was afraid it was Anti-Chinese Propaganda, British News Agencies are notorious for this...
Then I saw not only is it accurate, but Justified.
We've become soft as a world. Evil prevails when good men do nothing.
We always been soft 50 years from now they gone say millennials were a bunch of badasses who protested errthang🤣🤣🤣🤣
The most common reason for detainment as having too many children is a little out of context. The video has failed to mention the one child policy which was only lifted at the end of 2015
Uighurs and all minorities were not subjected to the One Child Policy though..?
good catch! this might be the reason why China needs a lot of camps, but US only needs Guantánamo. lol
One child policy were not targeted at ethnic minorities tho
This video will mysteriously disappear soon
The province is roughly pronounced "Shin Jang," with the "ang" part pronounced like the Ang in Angela Merkel
Duh, it's on the first page of the Vocational Education Camp Newcomer Guide
Our host did a reasonable good job, not jang, it's Jiang, emphasis on the I.
Yeah I know it sounds like nitpicking, but they've done a lot of videos on China at this point and by now should have invested the hour or two it takes to learn how to read out pinyin names.
@@R4x0 Well there are 3 pronunciations of Xinjiang in this video, maybe they'll get it right at least once by chance.
TLDR doesn't know what they are talking about at all on this topic
did you record this over several days? your pronunciation of xinjiang slowly morphs throughout the video lol you had it more or less correct in the beginning!
The whole report goes down the drain the moment you mentioned Adrian Zenz.
Why called them militant when they are fighting for independence?
@- i did, and I still question the reason of calling them militant. The video said that they were resistance against an occupying force, not trying to implement an extremist ideology
Well done for covering this, though this has been going on for over 3 decades.
Not really. The detention and reeducation camps for Uyghurs are only 3 years old. Other reeducation camps (e.g. for Falun Gong members) are only a few years older.
The radicalisation of the Chinese government's response isn't all that different from what happened in the West after a few successful terrorist attacks. At least China hasn't invaded any muslim countries, causing the deaths of hundreds of thousands. Yet.
By all means, attack China for its despicable behaviour. But don't ignore that we've been doing similar things in the West.
@@lacdirk
China's hundreds of thousands are dying within their own borders. We don't know how many people have died in these camps, but we can be confident that many won't make it out alive unless something drastic changes.
@@OriginalPiMan We know that that hasn't happened, at least not in large numbers. The point of the camps is to "reeducate" the prisoners into more docile workers. It also locks them into menial jobs, even if they were educated.
The Chinese idea of reeducation camps is quintessentially anti-intellectual, and as such not that different from the "moral majority" type movements in the west. It's not about genocide.
The genocide accusation rests on the forced sterilisation of women that have had "too many" children. This is not just the case in Xinjian, it is just a remnant of the one-child policy, which was relaxed but not entirely removed. There are reports that this sterilisation is done for other reasons, and/or done earlier (after fewer children).
If true, that would make the Xinjian situation similar to the Australian genocide of its aboriginal population.
@@lacdirk
Evidence shows that more sterilizations were done in 2019 in Xinjiang than were done in the rest of the decade combined, even reaching before the One Child Policy was relaxed. (Graph shown in the video)
And the number of IUDs given annually to Uigher women rose by 40% between 2014 and 2018, just when the number of children allowed was supposed to have gone up.
@@lacdirk I was referring to the general standoff between Uyghurs and CCP post Mao.
citing ASPI at 9:20 + adrian zentz... this is just 5eyez propaganda
Genocide is the mass killing of ones own citizens. I believe china are not murdering these individuals.
It's important to use the correct terminology.
It seems history is repeating itself; Just around 2 decades early.
Ho ho ho. Nooooo. No no no.
During the Second Boer War (1899-1902), the British rounded up around a sixth of the Boer population - mainly women and children - and detained them in camps, which were overcrowded and prone to outbreaks of disease , with scant food rations
Of the 107,000 people interned in the camps, 27,927 Boers died
Amritsar, India, on 13 April 1919
11 000 British troops invaded North Russia 1918-1919 and shoot 4000 people directly and made concentration camps where 28 000 people died from hunger and epidemics, not mention stealing food supply from majority of population.
I'll say history bang on time
@@yannikoloff7659 Yes that is really sad and has been happening for ages in human history. But all the people who did those things are now dead. We can't change nore does it justify anything CCP is currently doing. So take your whataboutism and leave.
@@jokuvaan5175 well played bro. HAHAHA
Its anachronistic to use the PRC flag to represent China in the 1930s
jhe3903 In the 30s, XZ was controlled by Soviet supported warlord, Shen ShiCai with the yellow banner
This was really good to know, I had no idea all this was started by a terrorist insurrection. It definitely changes the subject from black and white to grey. Dark grey mind you but still.
Edit: by which I mean there was a motive besides, because hatred, despite the fact that it appears to have massively overcompensated by this point.
Yes my thoughts exactly
There's no act of some members of the people for which the whole population deserves destruction. And their descendants, and their descendants....
Genoside is wrong, for any act.
@@Mtaalas Have you considered the fact that you're being LIED TO? There's literally 0 signs of a genocide. Just another developing countries the west would like to destroy
@@TheMinimumPC "developing country"... yeah sure... with NUCLEAR WEAPONS, SPACE PROGRAM, BALLISTIC MISSILES... and thin skin. Sure... ;D
Thank you for this explanation. The kind of investigation that we used to get from the BBC 30 years or so ago. I cannot imagine the BBC covering this today as it is implicitly critical of China.
There are a few video on Uyghur Concentrate camps by the BBC. You should probably watch it, it shows the detainees talking to reporters but clearly cannot say what they want to say...
@@jessicahwlo Thank you Jennifer. I have just watched the one in December 2019. A useful insight but not as much information as TLDR reveals.
Also a little known fact: Historically, Uighurs have favored the "Southpole" brand of clothing over other cultural garb.
And Definitely love eminem
Another excellent video that sheds light on a barbaric state. Keep up the great work 👍
Lmao love how they take picture of houses from above and make all these speculations… it’s like how some people try to decipher cave painting without any concrete evidence
Well Xinjiang wasn’t necessarily “historically Uighur”. Han Chinese first gain control of the territory more than 2000 years ago during Han dynasty, way before the Islamic prophet Mohammad is even born. Uighur just migrated there much later on.
They were less Chinese than Parthia/Persia was Roman. The Chinese could (with a lot of effort) send punitive missions into the area for brief periods (with long breaks in between). Those punitive missions caused a lot destruction. That doesn't make those areas Chinese. It also doesn't mean they were under Chinese control in any meaningful sense. Steppe nomads could (and did) send plundering expeditions to Chinese areas again and again long before the Mongols conquered China -- and they did not need as long recuperation periods in between as the Chinese did for Xinjiang.
The Romans could do the same with Parthia/Persia (and did). That does not mean Parthia/Persia was Roman in any meaningful way.
The modern Uighurs are mixed population consisting of Indo-Europeans who were there first and Turkic peoples who showed up later. The Han had historically nothing to do with the area. The old writing from the area is neither Sinitic nor Turkic... it is Indo-European. Their entire material culture was Indo-European. They even *looked* Indo-European, as evidenced by the Tarim mummies.
Peter Lund That is not true. China had effective control of the region during the height both Han and the Tang Dynasty. The reason they are able to control the area is because both of the dynast managed to dominate the surrounding nomads: Han defeated the Xiongnu and Tang defeated the Goturks. Both of the dynasty managed to defeat the major nomadic power and drive them westward and then made the remaining surrounding nomads submissive tributary states to China, so what u say about nomads could just plundering expeditions aren’t true, at least not during the height of those two empires. Historically China seek to control the region for the purpose of bringing stability and protection to the trade route that is the Silk Road, so I don’t get how u could call Chinese missions “punitive and cause destruction“, those areas are definitely better of with Chinese control compare to the uncivilized nomads that simply raids wherever they go.
What I’m trying to point out is that Chinese controlled the land way before Uighurs do, and before Islam this region was also Buddhist, and also Uighur migrated from the north nomadic region too. Therefore calling the region “historically Uighur” isn’t necessarily accurate. Whoever controls it currently has the rightful claim.
What would other countries do if in one of their country's regions there was an act of terrorism like in Xinjiang?
They definitely wouldn't use it as an excuse to invade Muslim countries for oil. Oh wait
Well there's the IRA that you can look into in Britain
Would you mind doing one of your excellent videos on Tibet?
So this is basically China's Stalinist version of Manifest Destiny
i mean that is kind of true
especially given how many people on the chinese internet are talking about the parallel between the xinjiang situation to what happen in past territorial conquest and assimilation into the han race during china' dynastic era, like with taiwan, Manchuria(which is of particular interest as it is incorporated into china about the same time xinjiang did ) and tibet
More like Hitlers vision of a one race superpower
Only much worse.
I am a Chinese and I am very curious on the concentration camps in China. I was doing some research about this, but I barely find any first handed sources. All I find is a 16 pages file from Newyork time (they claim they have 400pages but they never show it to the public) and some screenshot from google earth. That is hardly convincing. Is it possible if TLDR may show the citation?
@- yeah right, let's see which Politician lie more? Trump or Chi？ What a great excuse
@- u cliam it, u prove it. Still waiting.
These are in US, Australia and Canada as well. "Quarantine facilities" governments are hiring to staff them now.
Attendants facility staff
Security
And "other"- not sure what job is so bad that it has to be labeled as other. Possibly morgue or disposal... creepy as hell
"How many border disputes do you want with your neighbours?"
China: *YES*
Finally a video about the Uyghur oppression that even mentions the Hui muslims for one
"There's a link --"
*David Starkey would disagree this is not genocide*
Chinese bots defending the Grand Pooh coming in 3 ... 2 ... 1 ...
China also has African and Asian countries under it's control by way of its "Belt and Road Initiative". Theyve become Colonies indebted massively to China
6:35 I doubt the hundreds of murders and dozens of attacks did much for community stability ether.
I think you forgot how China has the most mosques in the world and how poverty has greatly reduced in XinJiang
Most mosques in the world? Really, 五毛?
Wow, so much lies in one video. It really is incredible. Seems like it is from a fiction book rather than from facts. Shocking.
China map at 2:42 is wrong, do your research
What I want to know is why has it taken so long for the media and governments to start talking about this in the mainstream? This has been happening to Christians in the country for a lot linger that to the Muslims, and across a wider area, but calls to act have been completely ignored. Even now that this is being talked about, all people seem to care about is the Muslim population and the Christians are still being ignored.
It is almost as if there is a narrative certain groups want to maintain about the 2 faiths.
"Okay, well here's $5 million dollars and a grant to open a company in China, now all you have to do is not mention what we're doing in Xinjang and every once in a while help us out, sound like a deal?"
"....Deal!" - most politicians / people in power
I believe that even though the Muslim stories get more 'media attention' thn the Christian stories, not enough action is being taken. The Bosnian and Chechen wars in Europe, for example, are almost completely forgotten nowadays, as are the never-ending crimes against humanity that Afghanis, Kashmirians, Yemenis, Syrians, Iraqis, Somalians and Ghanian and Nigerian muslims suffer from.
Did any of you bother to read the so-called UN report on this?
You should try to especially the part about how they gathered the evidence and the sole writer, who happened to be the only American in the group, amonst the group of multinational who investigated it.
This was never reported on any news I have ever seen...thank you so much for this well done video.
Organ harvesting? Oriental education and china construction banks funding this?
During the time line around 1933 and 1944 you showed the CCP flag. That is incorrect because the CCP didnt take total power until 1949. And CCP wasnt a big territorial power until the soviets took manchuria and gave it to the CCP
7:35 Speaking like a true European. You don't know how their culture works. Have you forgotten how they promise to respect intellectual property? Hongkong autonomy? WTO agreements? Their territorial claim in the sea? Peace on India border? It is NOT what they say. It is what they do. Yeah, some report that Hui mosques have been closed but they said it was not about Islam, yeah?
Informative
This video started objective but ended subjective.
Ah yes! *I love this civil comment section.*
The Chinese trolls on here are rather entertaining .
Should you not have used the flag of the Soviet Union when dealing with the interventions by the Soviet Union in 1934 and 1944 rather than the modern flag of the Russian Republic. It is misleading for those not familiar with the symbols of the Soviet Union and, despite Putin, Russia and the Soviet Union are not synonymous.
There are many XinJiang travel vlog on youtube, I wonder ever this TLDR have been to XinJiang in person. Just showing some Google Earth picture? LOL
Cheng Si
EXACTLY there’s this youtuber called 安妮古丽
Seems like the complete opposite of what this video says lol
No, there aren't. It is impossible to get permission to go there unless one is already 100% in the pocket of the CCP.
@@peterfireflylund 💩🐕👎
@@peterfireflylund funny, if it's impossible to get there, how could anyone know the truth? And you even believe that?😁
are you allowed to report this?
I was watching a video similar to this moments ago. My phone spazzed out and crashed. I tried to find it but it was removed.
Great work no doubt this took a lot of time to put together
As an American all I care about is being able to buy my T-shirt for $5.
No mention of the more than 6,000 hardcore Uighurs who Turkey let into Syria who have been fighting there since 2015 against Assad. The Chinese have special forces troops in the city of Tarsus in Syria pursuing them and have said that none of them will be allowed to return to China under any circumstances. None of this however excuses what China is doing to these people.
you didn't mention the Turkistan Islamic Party Jihadists currently in Syria.
like these islamis exremist only have 20 active members for past 30 years，im a ethnic mongol from xinjiang（east turkistan） i can confirm uyghur people are not religous freak，they are way secular than any arab countries out there
It feels like a global war is more of a when not if
I was mostly happy about the content of this video. However some points where presented without proper context.
For instance, at 11:05 it talks of sterilization of Uighur woman who have too many children, but no mention of the One-Child policy which puts limits on ALL people in China.
Or at 11:49 start talking about China's actions - supposedly - meeting the criteria of genocide. Yet fails to mention that ZERO COUNTRIES have claimed as such. Only activist groups.
Nonsense. There's mountainous evidence to refutd your points.
Plus, you don't understand international law. Until recently the 1948 UN convention to which China was a signatory forbade the laws controlling ethnic minorities birth rates. China in more recent years has completely violated this agreement ( should at least be suspended from thr UN for doing so) and imposed an 80 % policy of sterilization on the Uighor population regardless of whether they've had children or not.
Denial is part of every Genocide.
@@morejoy5188
A mountain of evidence to refute my points?
My points being that the one child policy exists. I'd very much like to see this "mountain of evidence" refuting this.
Or perhaps you mean my 2nd point. That zero countries have called China's actions "Genocide". Again, I'm looking forward to seeing this "mountain of evidence" you speak of.
Assuming this "mountain of evidence refuting my points" even exists. Which I doubt. But who knows, there's a slim chance you're not just spouting hot air. I'll be pleasantly surprised if you actually follow through.
We should stop trading with china. The cost of cheap goods is not worth it and continuing to trade with them is not making them more open. It is also not even remotely fair trade. Their companies can operate in western countries but western companies can not operate even close to as freely in china as Chinese companies do. If companies or people say bad things about China anywhere in the world they can still be punished for it if they have any assets, relatives, friends etc in China. You may not like the western countries but that does not happen with them.
this is a comment to help the algorithm
It would be relevant to analyse China's appointments in the UN's councils, reasoning and support behind each appointment and contrasting the description of each seat with their actions.
china uncensored has covered this in more detail from the start 😅
Yeah like half a year ago
@Lutz Bammer the good thing is majority of people did not believe you
rather than genocide isnt this more like forced assimilation? kinda like what happened in japan with their indigenous tribes, the crusades by the romans and ottoman
Forced sterilisation is genocide my guy, you dont have future generations if you cant have children, thats genocide.
China has the one child policy.
Sterilization of people who have too many kids isn't a Uighur exclusive this. Thus is not a targeted genocide of a group of people.
The only reason the numbers are higher for this group of people is because they break the laws more often.
@@shanerooney7288 One child policy was abolished and replaced, it also wasnt applied to the regional locations like this IIRC. China is under a massive demographics crisis in terms of aging population and lack of young people. Sterilisation of women in the region (some not having children yet iirc) effectively is self harming.
Funny enough IIRC these forced strelisations you say happen across the nation happen in the more independent zones with historical roots in seperatism...
Not to mention it never mandated sterilisation camps.
TLDR you should really Research into flags 2:11 otherwise people will laugh at you guys!
Freedom Loving Loyalist agreed, no real excuses for that
@@nonah60 Also the map is Inaccurate.
@@nonah60 That's just lazy.
the flags seem alright and where is the map wrong? (beside propably not a good solution to show every detail or disbuted region when its not the main point of the video)
In the 30s, XZ was controlled by Soviet supported warlord, Shen ShiCai with the yellow banner
Jonathan Richards from the University of Queensland.[4][3][1] Criteria such as defining a massacre as the killing of six or more people are used and an interactive map as an online resource is included.[5][6][2] As of 3 January 2020, at least 311 frontier massacres over a period of about 140 years had been documented, revealing "a state-sanctioned and organised attempt to eradicate Aboriginal people".[2]
You're not biased, yet you only base all your findings on the likes of CNN and BBC. Funny!
China is criticized for its one child per family policy because it is such a human right violation and China is also criticized for its persecution of Uyghurs and Tibetan. But we never ask ourselves why even China’s president Xi Jinping can only have one daughter due to this strictly enforced one child per family policy while the persecuted Uyghurs and Tibetan families can have as many as they want. Isn’t Chinese government that stupid that he doesn’t know the best way to persecute a minority group is to curb its growth of population?
In Gaza, with the complicity of the US and Britain, there exists a virtual concentration camp.
The US Government has built several hundred FEMA camps, with barbed wire fences and railway tracks leading to their gates, and each are designed to house thousands of families in what are in effect highly-secured units.
And the US imprisonment of blacks for non violent crimes, is the same. What China is doing is terrible, We are the same.
@@andrewfrancis3591 - exactly.
@@andrewfrancis3591 clearly you know nothing of China if you think the usa is that same :)
@@Mrfizzly clearly you're a brainwashed moron if you think they're different. No one is good, the world isn't unicorn and rainbows
10:49 "campaign of pressuRRRe" bro what happened to your accent lol
Xinjiang birkenau
i mean for now its more like Japanese internment camp, let hope it does not reach there
and the American Mainstream Media is COMPLETELY QUIET
China will have TH-cam demonetize this so I hope it still gets tons of views
Great video guys
China actually banned youtube
Another reason why the 2022 Winter Olympics and 2023 Asian Cup ⚽️ Tournament need to be either boycotted and/or forced to relocate out of China.