Publicly Advising Muslim Rulers: An Answer backed by 12 Narrations
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 มิ.ย. 2024
- Timestamps:
0:00 Introduction
0:26 Building the foundation
2:19 An ayah
2:52 Our ummah
3:19 Ruling on advising rulers publicly
4:06 A hadith
5:05 A hadith
6:50 Imam Ahmed said
8:29 A hadith
10:14 On the authority of Abi Wael, he said
11:15 ibn Hajar
13:59 Sa'eed Ibn Jubair
14:50 On the authority of Anas ibn Malik
16:19 Ibn Al-Nahhas said
18:15 Ibn Abdul Al Bar, what did he say?
19:03 Ibn Al-Jawzi, what did he say?
21:06 Ibn Baz, what did he say?
23:33 a beautiful narration
24:33 first person to do khurooj
26:21 Public criticism
27:24 another beautiful narration
31:43 The Khawarij
33:12 Public criticism of rulers, what does it do?
34:04 Who appointed you to be a spokesman of the ummah?
35:23 That's their weapon today, their weapon is social media and fake news
36:13 Conclusion
#farishammadi #salaf #hadith #madkhali #islam #salafi
![ขายสมบัติ Ferrari 488 ลูกรักก!! l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pwF1Il1Uevw/mqdefault.jpg)
That's it, crystal clear ! Baarak Allahu feek
_“Leave me with what I have left for you. When I narrate a saying to you, take it from me. Verily, those before you were only ruined because they excessively interrogated and disputed their prophets.”_
[Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2679]
May Allah protect you sheikh Faris. Barak Allah fik. I am learning a lot.
جزاك الله خيرا
To anyone who will be quick to insult, remember that these are narrations of the prophet peace be upon him.
If you cannot answer without providing clear cut evidences from the Quran and Sunnah in its entirety in regard to the topic then stay quiet and don’t let your tongue be a regret for you on that day.
@@Richest_Person_in_the_WorldWorry about your own income of deeds. Spreading lies against your Muslim brother might end up making you bankrupt on the day of judgment.
Abu Hurairah narrated that the Messenger of Allah (s.a.w) said: "Do you know who the bankrupt is?" They said: "O Messenger of Allah SAW! The bankrupt among us is the one who has no Dirham nor property." The Messenger of Allah (s.a.w) said: "The bankrupt in my Ummah is the one who comes with Salat and fasting and Zakat on the Day of Judgement, but he comes having abused this one, falsely accusing that one, wrongfully consuming the wealth of this one, spilling the blood of that one, and beating this one. So he is seated, and this one is requited from his rewards. If his rewards are exhausted before the sins that he committed are requited, then some of their sins will be taken and cast upon him, then he will be cast into the Fire." [Abu 'Eisa said: ] This Hadith is Hasan Sahih.
Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2418
جزاكَ اللهُ خيرًا أخي الكريم
Always using evidence اللهم بارك
I’m really enjoying you displaying evidences on video ❤
Ya sheikh I live in the west and your videos have been such a blessing for me alhamdulilah! I hope to meet you in real life one day inshallah. الله يبارك قيك
Always welcome dear brother
@@Farishammadiالسلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته.
Ustad, How long did it take for your side burns to grow out?
بارك الله فيك
And I recommend (as always) to watch the series "Replying Crystal Clear to the People of Takfeer" at @Gardenofilm. Baarak Allahu feekum, may Allah guide us all !
Al-Fuḍayl b. ʿAyyāḍ (رحمه الله) Said :
“If I had one supplication that was going to be answered I would make it for the ruler (imām), for the wellbeing and righteousness of the imām means wellbeing for the land and its people.”
Source - Al-Dhahabī, Siyar A’lām Al-Nubalā` in his biography of Al-Fuḍayl b. ʿAyyāḍ.
JAK. Much needed clarification
BaarakAllahu feek,
Its crazy some people will still takfir you just because you are saying Allah said… and His Messenger Peace be upon Him said..
It shows they are not satisfied with evidences.
Jazakallah khairan. Well received. In shaa Allah, i will focus on reforming myself and my family based on quran and sunnah.
جزاك الله خيرا و ثبتك الله
❤❤❤❤ nice work
JazakAllah Khair
جزاك الله خيرا وبارك فيكم
بارك الله فيكم أستاذنا
Baraqallahu feekum. May Allah reward you. jazakallahu khairan.
السلام عليكم
كيف ممكن اتواصل معك
Khair Insha’Allah
The Jew (and founder of shi'ism) Abdullah ibn Saba used to say:
"Begin by criticizing your leaders. And appear to enjoin good and forbid evil so the people incline towards you."
[Tareekh at-Tabari (4/341))]
SubhanAllaah. It seems the emotional people are following this jew instead of Rasulullah ﷺ
@@dralchemy8459 at the same time they claim to boycott jews hhhhhhh the irony😂
Wow thanks for this bro
Imam Al-Barbahari (رحمه الله) Said :
“If you see a man supplicating against the ruler, know that he is a heretic (ṣaḥib hawā), and if you see a man supplicating for the ruler, know that he is a Sunni - inshā Allāh.”
Source - Sharḥ Al-Sunnah p113, 114
@@Richest_Person_in_the_World he is a ruler but he is not muslim !
@@Richest_Person_in_the_World this statement of The imam is about a muslim ruler
BarakAllaahu feek
God bless u shaikh
important question ya faris allah yahfadkhak they say that khurooj bi lisan is mas'ala fiqhiyyah and not aqadiyyah unlike khurooj bi sayf is this true? and they bring narrations of salaf that they did publicly criticised their leaders like hajjaj ibn yusef or abdil malik ibn marwan
Brother Faris , May Allah guide you and me and all the Muslim.
SOME IMPORTANT POINTS
What you are saying is not incorrect, but it’s not the full story
It’s very one sided
First you must istablish akhi what is a Muslim leader , you gave the eg of so as long as they isablish the salah fast zakat ect ,
This is correct
But if they do that AND Also make allowed to the public RIBA , alcohol , and other things that Allah has made haram , then that leader falls into major kufr as a IJma of all scholars, apart from those that have irjah ofc.
There is a way to deal with a Muslim leader
And there is another way to deal with a non Muslim leader ,
If you look into the history of Islam, Many of them made khurooj on the leaders that displayed clear kufr, no one calls them khawarij. You wouldn’t dare to
the people who mention names, mention names as they say he is kafir, so that’s okay
If the leader is Muslim and sinful then you can mention the generic and warn the people to stay away from the wrongdoing without mentioning the name.
I hope one day we can talk to reason and have a good understanding as I see you as a brother but unfortunately I see you to be someone who is famous, and someone who doesn’t know how to implement the Knowlage he has,
It’s from the wisdoms to understand the Knowlage and apply it.
May Allah guide you to the correct creed, wa barakAllau feek
The basic ruling is as follows
If someone changes , replaces the sharia with man made law then he is a kafir that takes him out the fold of the religion
However , if he only judges without on a one off, or here and there, then this is kufr less of kuffr
When the khawarij came to ibn abas to cause fitnah and make takfeer of them and told him about what the people of Ali and mawiah are doing , that they are not judging but what Allah has revealed in some matters here and there, ibn abas told them this is kufr Duna kufr , so this falls into fasiq and thalim
You can’t take ibn abbas statement to give a translation for that verse when allah has made it specific, what about all the other Sahaba that gave tafseer and also ibn abas him self when he said this is Kufr, major kufr!?
Why are you not teaching the people this part , why have you left it out akhi, it’s very distorting
Please ignore all the juhaal in the comments. Any average aqeedah book mentions this topic. It’s a well known principle and people are just emotional today with regards to rulers.
21:20 The dumb Khawaarij said the Shaykh was a corrupt scholar for dollars... Shaykh Ibn Baz was blind, so there's not a lot you can do to corrupt or bribe a pious Muslim scholar who can't even see the riches you're trying to bribe him with.
Ya Sheikh, I can see the wisdom regarding this as it affects the ummah as a whole and can lead to worse situation for ALL people like the Arab Spring.
I was watching a video from Dan and he called you Rabbi Faris and that youre paid by the government. Could you make a video on this please?
If he has to refute every drama youtuber with a false aqeedah then he will not have time for lessons😅
@@030Ayoub i agree but some of them have such a huge following that a video should be made to protect his image. The layman follow many celebrity daee
@@giovannioro1642Daniel said any scholar in arab countries who is not jailed is automatically being paid by goverments
That itself shows how ignorant he is
@@muslimresponses9731 so he must agree with Farhan al Maliki then despite not following all Sahih hadiths since he too was jailed.
All of this talk and evidence does not address the majority of Muslims who do not live in Muslim countries. They don't have an ameer. Those who speak badly about and critize Muslim rulers while living in non Muslim countries are indeed spreading fitna and should stop and be warned against.
However, what rights to obedience do Muslim rulers have over Muslims living in outside of their jurisdiction? Should Muslims living in UAE obea the leader of Saudi?
Should Muslims living in Canada (for example) obey the leaders of Saudi or the UAE or Qatar?
What rights do the Muslims in Canada have on the leader or UAE? or Saudi, or Qatar?
If they have no rights on each other for obedience then that means that the Muslims living in non muslim countries are free to decide for themselves how to help the Palestineans or Uyghurs, etc via boycotts or other means.
In the modern times, after tawheed, this subject (matters related to muslim ruler) is the main subject which differentiates between ahlussunnah [salafiyyah] and ahlul bidah. May Allaah make as steadfast upon sunnah.
*_Living is a blessing in the UAE_*
100% agree, may Allah preserve the UAE and it's rulers and it's people
mashallah i can see the nour on your face Sheikh may Allah protect and bless you, thank you for the education
he is Madkhali..............
You mean Muhammad ibn Abdillah ﷺ is a madkhali?
He is Hammadi
Everything to you guys is Madkhali or Wahhabi, you will be the first to follow dajjal just out of spite for us.
@@VexLooterTypical sufi behavior: we give you narrations, you call us Wahabis 😂 The ones upon clarity and sunnah will follow Dajjal, and fools who dance in the masaajid, call upon other than Allah, and have nothing with them but name-calling will be safe? Shut your mouth, honestly.
Sheikh muqbil disagrees with you and sheikh alalbani. Many muhadditheen class that hadith as daeef
Which hadith you're talking about?
Bring the specific statements of muqbil and Albani rahimahullah and which hadith is daif.
Why can't you agree with the prophet and his companion?
Can you show us the proof?
@@nalali5730 ignore him he is just yapping
There are 12 narrations mentioned in the video he can't prove all weak
I agree with the evidences about not publicly criticizing Muslim rulers about their sins. This is clear and I accept it as from Quran and Sunnah.
Sheikh does this still apply if they openly betray the Ummah in battle and aid the disbelievers that are killing the muslims? Would this just be counted as sin or would it be major kufr? Do we rebel in this particular case or do we let them continue aiding the enemies killing muslims and just remain silent and patient? I am not being sarcastic or argumentative I would like a serious answer please as I am at my limit seeing muslims being killed and nothing being done. Little children with their hands tied behind their backs by zionist cowards being shot and dumped in mass graves. I am a retired crippled soldier, not an armchair keyboard coward. I need a clear answer please if this applies even in this case.
You can make the affair very easy upon yourself: leave issues of takfeer to the scholars. The scholars have made takfeer on some of the rulers, such as Qathafi, Bashar, and Khomeini. Other than that, we need not delve into such matters that laymen are not qualified to deal with.
Be patient, make dua', and call people to repent and purify their hearts of kaafir ideologies and to unite upon the brotherhood of Islam and sunnah. This is what we can do, so let us busy ourselves with it.