Hijraah needs homework just like any project a person does for worldly matters. Become financially independent, use the power of the currency and use it in your favor in the land of Hijraah you are focussing. In sha Allaah He Subhana wa tala will make it easy. Surah Nisa verse 100 says: Whoever emigrates in the cause of Allah will find many safe havens and bountiful resources throughout the earth. Those who leave their homes and die while emigrating to Allah and His Messenger-their reward has already been secured with Allah. And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
Ibn Qudaamah (may Allah have mercy on him) said: With regard to Hijrah, people fall into three categories: 1. Those for whom Hijrah is obligatory: this applies to the one who is able to do it and is not able to practice his religion openly or establish the obligatory duties of his religion if he stays among the kuffaar. In this case, it is obligatory to migrate because Allah says (interpretation of the meaning): “Verily, as for those whom the angels take (in death) while they are wronging themselves (as they stayed among the disbelievers even though emigration was obligatory for them), they (angels) say (to them): ‘In what (condition) were you?’ They reply: ‘We were weak and oppressed on the earth.’ They (angels) say: ‘Was not the earth of Allaah spacious enough for you to emigrate therein?’ Such men will find their abode in Hell - what an evil destination!” [al-Nisa’ 4:97]. This is a stern warning which indicates that it is obligatory. Establishing the obligatory duties of Islam is obligatory for the one who is able to do that, and Hijrah is necessary for fulfilment of that obligation; whatever is essential to fulfilment of an obligation is also obligatory. 2. Those for whom hijrah is not obligatory. This applies to the one who is not able to do it, either because of sickness, or because he is forced to stay, or because of weakness in the case of women, children and so on. In this case Hijrah is not obligatory, because Allah says (interpretation of the meaning): “Except the weak ones among men, women and children who cannot devise a plan, nor are they able to direct their way. 99. These are they whom Allaah is likely to forgive them, and Allaah is Ever Oft-Pardoning, Oft-Forgiving” [al-Nisa’ 4:98-99]. And it is not mustahabb for them, because it is not possible for them. 3. Those for whom it is mustahabb but is not obligatory. This applies to the one who is able to do it, but he is able to practice his religion openly and establish it in the kaafir country. So it is mustahabb for him, so that he would be able to engage in jihad against them, increase the numbers of Muslims, and support them, and so that he can stop increasing the numbers of kuffaar, mixing with them and seeing evil among them. But it is not obligatory for him, because it is possible for him to establish the obligatory duties of his religion without migrating. End quote from al-Mughni, 9/236 Based on that, if you are able to practice your religion openly as you say, then Hijrah is not obligatory for you, but moving to one of the Muslim countries is better and more safe, so as to avoid increasing the numbers of kuffaar, mixing with them and witnessing their evils, and so as to move away from fitan (turmoils, temptations) and causes of deviation which are prevalent in those societies, as well as for the sake of the children who are born to the Muslims there, to save them from being lost and going astray in Western societies. This applies in general, but a person may be in a place in those countries where he lives among a Muslim majority and is able to play his role in da‘wah, teaching and explaining Islam to others, in which case it is better to him to stay and not migrate. So you should weigh up the pros and cons, and give priority to preservation of religious commitment over other interests, for religious commitment is the capital of the individual which must not be squandered. With regard to going back -- temporarily -- in order to obtain a better education, we hope that there is nothing wrong with you doing that, especially if it is an education that you need or there is some benefit to the Muslims in it, but you should keep trying to find an opportunity to settle permanently in a Muslim country. We ask Allah to guide and help us and you. And Allah knows best.
Jazakallahu Khaira for summing up the three categories. Hijraah needs homework just like any project a person does for worldly matters. Become financially independent, use the power of the currency and use it in your favor in the land of Hijraah you are focussing. In sha Allaah He Subhana wa tala will make it easy. Surah Nisa verse 100 says: Whoever emigrates in the cause of Allah will find many safe havens and bountiful resources throughout the earth. Those who leave their homes and die while emigrating to Allah and His Messenger-their reward has already been secured with Allah. And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
“Obligation is to be considered in matters of Jihad according to the opinion of upright men of religion who have experience in what people of this world do, rather than those who mainly look at a matter from the viewpoint of religion. Do not adopt their opinion - not the opinion of men of religion who have no experience in the world." - Ibn Taymiyah (May Allah have mercy on him)
I experienced the same in Egypt… they locked me up and deported me!! They asked me why I have a beard. Is it for religious purposes ?!? When I hear the word Egypt now I feel sick.
Assalamu alaykum. Brother great talk as usual. If you want to check out a beautiful Muslim country that is welcoming check out Albania. Easy to get residency and must Imams are graduates from Saudi or Jordan. I did it from US and it’s not the best but it’s better.
You could simply say, "Quran and hadith already said about Hijrah. So I can not add my or someone's opinion here. All you can say, find a suitable Muslim land to live. Bare in mind where ever you go there are difficulties. But you need to do your best to comply with Islam and then Allah will make it easy for us. And Allah knows best.
Tawakullallahla! He created the earth and will definitely give way to His sincere slaves. Some of us live these little comfortable life in the west and expected the same else where! The noble companions may Allah honour them did Hijrah and Allah grant them authorities and makes them leaders! So, it's clear! ALLAH is in control. May Allah aid all muslims who are striving and struggling in these Kufar and any other oppressed lands. May He ease the path, means for them to leave and may He replace, bless them with peaceful territories.
I agree. To many folks make excuses because the comfort level and the fact that not many ppl are practicing. However the overwhelming majority is always better
May Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala make it easier for the Muslims to return to the Muslim majority nations and bring about taqwa, trust, safety and prosperity.
The situation in Yemen is also western influence. The same western leaders that plenty of Muslims are paying taxes too! Important to be fair on matters of oppression.
Even if you say it's wajib, realistically speaking it's unrealistic until Muslim nations stop treating fellow Muslims from other lands as less than them,... I.e. immigration limitations, you can't enter without buying a visa, you can't stay more than 30 days on a visa, you can't work without buying a different kind of visa plus getting a company sponsorship, if you stay over the 30 day visa youre put in jail, deported then forbidden to return,...etc...etc This is no government system in favor of Hijrah, Muslim unity,...etc A single nation could literally become one of the most powerful nations over night by simply announcing and allowing Muslims from Darul kufar to make Hijrah to their nation, how many soldiers they will gain over night? Millions, how much material gains will they get over night $millions, educated men and women, doctors,....etc...etc they could become a power house and grow their economy massively just from a worldly perspective. And other nations would quickly follow in their footsteps. But untill then we're stuck in darulkufar
According to the latest released report there's a huge exodus of Muslims from France since that country's among the worst place for Muslims beside India, China and Burma. I have read on Islam Q&A it's obligatory to migrate from the lands of disbelief to Muslim LANDS.I have also watched an episode on Ask Zad saying the something. Mauritania, Morocco, Malaysia, Indonesia and there are many other suitable Muslim lands to migrate to.
Akhi, you should refer to a scholar who has accurate knowledge of where you live because alot of times, there are fatwas from scholars that are inaccurate because they have a rather "shallow" understanding in that regard (with all due respect to Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem from Ask Zad and IslamQA). Sheikh Haitham Al-Haddad for example is of the same opinion as Sheikh Abu Taymiyyah with regards to Hijrah because of the implications it carries. By saying that it is obligatory, every one is then sinful if he doesn't and the Deen was made easy in general (of course there are hardships but in general its easy) and where there is extraordinary difficulty, things are made easy in Islam. The thing is, with some fatwas, scholars have a "shallow" or "theoretical" understanding of things, one of which is bitcoin for example and the fatwas given sound quite silly to someone who somewhat understands how bitcoin works. Sheikh Haitham Al-Haddad for example only gives fatwas for Muslims in the west when he speaks in english because we have abnormal situations as he says and a normal fatwa is not going to work.
@@ebrahimi44 it's so ignorant to generalize all western scholars as orientalists and very ironic given how they study under the same scholars as the ones u mentioned and still follow the same methodology but western scholars are still orientalists according to u just because they differed on one issue...
@@rogersmith6813 I'm personally not a fan of the last sultan but he's a actual caliphate and no colonization Is much better than what the middle East finds itself In now. If only they didn't get involved in the European War WW1. And if only the Arabs in the Hijaz weren't stupid enough to believe the British would actually pull their end of the bargain in a deal. Just lots of poor choices in all parties in the caliphate
Every era had their ups and downs. A lot more lands are controlled by Muslims now, even before the Ottomans fell. In 1916, Egypt, Sudan, Yemen, Oman, East Arabia, Indian subcontinent, part of Somalia, and Malaysia were all under British control. Italy controlled Libya and the other half of Somalia. France controlled west Africa, Algeria, and Morocco. The Netherlands controlled Indonesia. Russia controlled the northern Turkic countries (Kazakhstan, etc.) Basically the only lands controlled by Muslims were Anatolia (Turkey), Iraq, Sham, Hejaz, and the central Arabian peninsula.
@@abcdef-xh3mk that’s very true, I’ve learned more since I first wrote that comment. Pre 1917 was already the waning years and in fact could be seen as worse than today
Can someone elaborate on the monopolizing of Hajj ? Is it allowed ? Is commercialisation of our Hajj expecience in any way beneficial ? Are pelgrims worshippers or tourists ??
Prices are cheaper now and Saudi make no money from hajj. Only issue I can think of is cultural issues when explaining hajj to different groups from diff backgrounds. May allah bring Khalid from what happened
@@suleman5965 well of course. They provide a product/service for hujaj. without those services peopled would be here complaining “why does saudi not make it easy for us when it comes to AC food transport etc” sometime the people want to be upset with no valid reason. At the end of the day Saudi is losing money trying to make hajj as effective and well managed as possible, they are not perfect of course. We should make dua that Allah gives them tawfeeq and aids them in doing so. Before this hajj companies were making so much money but no one ever complained about those external companies subhanallah. Saudi made it cheaper for everyone else.
@@Zzzzxx-qg6cs ameen. I mean it’s debatable wether you think prices from companies have gone down but even expats try rent homes due to the amount they can actually make but Yh the country itself for them just an expense but may Allah make it easy for us and those wanting to do hajj or umrah and free us from the commercialisation of the deen insha’Allah
@@suleman5965 There's no commercialisation of the Deen by the government. Hajj and Umrah has been made much easier by the government of SA. If individuals are taking advantage of you then deal with that but please let's refrain from blaming on things we don't know or understand. I'm not a defender of SA by any stretch of the imagination. I left there ... no I ran from there 6 years ago when MBS came to power and may Allah Guide us all. I know a lot of things about SA but when it comes to the Hajj and Umrah, the government has my respect. They looked after everyone.
Regardless about giving fatwa etc, the brother just mentioned his own personal experiences (which I might add is not the experienced of thousands of others who have done the same journeys.). So what? I know brothers who have lived in Egypt/Morroco etc for years with no issues, yes there are some who encountered issues but not everyone. And hijrah isn’t meant to be easy. Did the prophet want to leave his home in Makkah and go to Madinah? Was those that left everything behind overjoyed and found it easy? And yes I agree there are a lot of issues in our lands, but just saying it was down to ‘revolutions’ ya akhi be just. It was the west that destroyed most of our lands. But you don’t want to mention that. If you’re going to go off on emotional tangents atleast speak the haqq
I lived in Egypt benefitted greatly for over a year without any problem I was without paperwork and yes it was a problem but far from being threatened sexually and whatever else nonsense.
He only is mentioning that he can’t give a fatwa on it, and he is stating that the issue isn’t black and white in todays age. Either way, Throughout his entire talk, he still recommended that we make Hijra, and he stated that this is his goal to make Hijra with his family.. And it’s good that he brought these points so that people aren’t naive when they intend to migrate and seek knowledge in the Muslim lands. May Allah guide us and increase us in beneficial knowledge, Ameen
@@truthseeker2095 are you a woman? Egypt is an amazing place that I pray Allah allows me to continue going back to, but its astonishingly high in r*pe cases and violence towards women subhanAllah just the other week there was a 15 yr old girl that killed her assaulter
Assalamou Alaykoum brother/sister, Jazzakoum Lahu khairan for the video first of all. I just wanted to point out that the thumbnail is barely readable. Perhaps you could change it or take it into account for future videos. Baraka Lahu feekoum.
Subhana Rabbi al.A'laa. If Oppression is Great to the point death may occur than as directed in Qu'ran Hijrah will be obligatory to a category of people. Hijrah to where is thr issuem
Everyone has a different situation. For some it is not possible, for some it is. If someone has the possibility of moving to a place that has less fitnah and more freedom to practice Islam and be able to sustain oneself and ones family then i dont see how and why one can stay in the place they are at. Its not the same for everyone. But i really think the west is not a place to expect any good, islamically. Just look at how our youth and misguided. I will never raise my two sons here when they reach school age i will be off. Most likely even before that.
Don’t try to justify staying in Kafir lands making excuses the prophet our prophet says he washes his hands of any Muslim who migrates or lives in kafir lands very scary Hadith
Am confused, am leaving here in the UK, with my wife and daughter , I kind of rely on some of these dayee to benefit from,majority of whom have left the country for dubai, the one abu tayimiya we got said he is gonna sort something out for his family....meaning leaving who do we turn now to and benefit from? Where do we go?
@@zayn6725 come on bro!!! You are in a Muslim country in Qatar Mosques everywhere call of prayers out loud and all that Your practice of Islam is down to you after that nothing to do with the country itself But Qatar is a great Muslim country to live with your family if you can afford it May Allah make it easy for you to find a Muslim country suitable for you and your family Ameen
Any lace in the uk is safer and more peaceful than the muslim lands except for khaleeji nations... And you not getting to live there on a permanent basis
murji madkhali reject. Our beloved Prophet[PBUH] prohibited rebellion against rulers, 'Unless you see a flagrant disbelief on which you have clear proof from Allah.’” [Narrated by Muslim] Now the flagrant disbelief here is, the ruler ruling by a Law other than the Shari'ah of Allah. Also, abolishing part or some islamic laws and substituting it kuffar law & values also counts.
The Sheikh you're talking about probably gave a fatwa according to the evidences and the situation at the time, and as you said Yemen was the best place etc. So you can't knock him for how things turned out. He didn't know what would happen in the future. Also, those that got sent back can't be sinful, because it was out of their control. So what's the issue Sheikh?
Sorry to say, Brother , first of all you are not qualified to give a fatawa. We know that. People asking you about the Deen of Allah not how you feel, or about your experience. You made it unnecessary long. Just say, if you are desperate then do hijrah and if you are not , stay here....no worries..I came from Madinah...i got knowledge.....Forgot about what classical Ulamah said about hijrah. We can interpret quran and hadith differently now.... like Yasir Qadi or Omer Sulyman etc... Don't worry brother the world will be witness for you in the day of judgement InshaAllah. You made us wrong in front of others. Now, many will say, .....see you took too much burden.... You could easily stay here.... May Allah be enough for you and the people like you who give their opinion over Deen of Allah and make difficult other Muslims life by this type of talk.....
L video fr only opinion + egypt no laws from quran best place to go is qatar or saudi if u are an arabic speaker, english works there too, also egypt legit has bans on hijab lol
Don’t try to justify staying in Kafir lands making excuses the prophet our prophet says he washes his hands of any Muslim who migrates or lives in kafir lands very scary Hadith
There are valid excuses such as the revert one - people born here without means to migrate and many Muslims lands don’t want other Muslims from other nations in their lands
@@Samialexchak thats a lie are you saying your mother land will reject you if go back no they wont but we are use to the luxury life in west back home at least we hear adan and our kids we can control and no lgtb etc so many benefits
@@ahmedsalah5364 if you are a revert born in a European country for example, no Muslim nation will take you without meeting some strict criteria - these Muslim nations won’t want millions of Muslims around the world coming to their countries. Many are racist towards African Muslims for example
No Fatwa needed. Use common sense. Land of fhe Kuffar in todays time is not better then Muslim land. The reality is Hijrah is hard who wants to come out of their comfort zone and self inflict hardship? It takes a strong minded soul who desires Allah more then themselves. Plenty of Muslim land to choose from. Go on Holiday first and then decide which land you want to make Hijrah too. Assalamualaykum
Our elders came here with nothing, we have more then them!!!!! Secondly you've gone against Qur'an and sunnah.... Thirdly most people love the kuffar, even if you have given the fatwa they wouldn't care, due to the love of the kuffar
Ha ha these madkhalis like abu taymiah abdulrahman hassan living in the west preaching hijrah but they haven't made hijrah themselves surely you should practice what you preach
Hijraah needs homework just like any project a person does for worldly matters. Become financially independent, use the power of the currency and use it in your favor in the land of Hijraah you are focussing. In sha Allaah He Subhana wa tala will make it easy.
Surah Nisa verse 100 says:
Whoever emigrates in the cause of Allah will find many safe havens and bountiful resources throughout the earth. Those who leave their homes and die while emigrating to Allah and His Messenger-their reward has already been secured with Allah. And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
Y’all are all welcome to The Gambia, we’re regarded as the smiling coast of Africa with a muslim population of 95%.
Gambia is the place to be for real!!!
Mashaa Allah
May Allah protect you
💯
Allahumma barik, i really want to visit one day!
Get me there
I suggest you guys watch the podcast of Abdulrahman Hassan where he provided a lot of evidences on the obligation or not of the hijrah. الله المستعان
Link please
@@saajiddaya2152 th-cam.com/video/3H9rroUZUKI/w-d-xo.html
@@saajiddaya2152 th-cam.com/video/3H9rroUZUKI/w-d-xo.html
@@saajiddaya2152 th-cam.com/video/3H9rroUZUKI/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/3H9rroUZUKI/w-d-xo.html
Allah عز وجل connected Hijra to Jihad. Hijra isn’t meant to be easy Hijra it’s hard, it was hard back then and it still is.
Ibn Qudaamah (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
With regard to Hijrah, people fall into three categories:
1.
Those for whom Hijrah is obligatory: this applies to the one who is able to do it and is not able to practice his religion openly or establish the obligatory duties of his religion if he stays among the kuffaar. In this case, it is obligatory to migrate because Allah says (interpretation of the meaning):
“Verily, as for those whom the angels take (in death) while they are wronging themselves (as they stayed among the disbelievers even though emigration was obligatory for them), they (angels) say (to them): ‘In what (condition) were you?’ They reply: ‘We were weak and oppressed on the earth.’ They (angels) say: ‘Was not the earth of Allaah spacious enough for you to emigrate therein?’ Such men will find their abode in Hell - what an evil destination!”
[al-Nisa’ 4:97].
This is a stern warning which indicates that it is obligatory. Establishing the obligatory duties of Islam is obligatory for the one who is able to do that, and Hijrah is necessary for fulfilment of that obligation; whatever is essential to fulfilment of an obligation is also obligatory.
2.
Those for whom hijrah is not obligatory. This applies to the one who is not able to do it, either because of sickness, or because he is forced to stay, or because of weakness in the case of women, children and so on. In this case Hijrah is not obligatory, because Allah says (interpretation of the meaning):
“Except the weak ones among men, women and children who cannot devise a plan, nor are they able to direct their way.
99. These are they whom Allaah is likely to forgive them, and Allaah is Ever Oft-Pardoning, Oft-Forgiving”
[al-Nisa’ 4:98-99].
And it is not mustahabb for them, because it is not possible for them.
3.
Those for whom it is mustahabb but is not obligatory. This applies to the one who is able to do it, but he is able to practice his religion openly and establish it in the kaafir country. So it is mustahabb for him, so that he would be able to engage in jihad against them, increase the numbers of Muslims, and support them, and so that he can stop increasing the numbers of kuffaar, mixing with them and seeing evil among them. But it is not obligatory for him, because it is possible for him to establish the obligatory duties of his religion without migrating.
End quote from al-Mughni, 9/236
Based on that, if you are able to practice your religion openly as you say, then Hijrah is not obligatory for you, but moving to one of the Muslim countries is better and more safe, so as to avoid increasing the numbers of kuffaar, mixing with them and witnessing their evils, and so as to move away from fitan (turmoils, temptations) and causes of deviation which are prevalent in those societies, as well as for the sake of the children who are born to the Muslims there, to save them from being lost and going astray in Western societies. This applies in general, but a person may be in a place in those countries where he lives among a Muslim majority and is able to play his role in da‘wah, teaching and explaining Islam to others, in which case it is better to him to stay and not migrate.
So you should weigh up the pros and cons, and give priority to preservation of religious commitment over other interests, for religious commitment is the capital of the individual which must not be squandered.
With regard to going back -- temporarily -- in order to obtain a better education, we hope that there is nothing wrong with you doing that, especially if it is an education that you need or there is some benefit to the Muslims in it, but you should keep trying to find an opportunity to settle permanently in a Muslim country.
We ask Allah to guide and help us and you.
And Allah knows best.
Such a good reply, perfectly summed up this topic.
Jazakallahu khairan for that explanation
Where is the source in Arabic and book
Jazakallahu Khaira for summing up the three categories.
Hijraah needs homework just like any project a person does for worldly matters. Become financially independent, use the power of the currency and use it in your favor in the land of Hijraah you are focussing. In sha Allaah He Subhana wa tala will make it easy.
Surah Nisa verse 100 says:
Whoever emigrates in the cause of Allah will find many safe havens and bountiful resources throughout the earth. Those who leave their homes and die while emigrating to Allah and His Messenger-their reward has already been secured with Allah. And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
“Obligation is to be considered in matters of Jihad according to the opinion of upright men of religion who have experience in what people of this world do, rather than those who mainly look at a matter from the viewpoint of religion. Do not adopt their opinion - not the opinion of men of religion who have no experience in the world."
- Ibn Taymiyah (May Allah have mercy on him)
I experienced the same in Egypt… they locked me up and deported me!!
They asked me why I have a beard. Is it for religious purposes ?!? When I hear the word Egypt now I feel sick.
Assalamu alaykum. Brother great talk as usual. If you want to check out a beautiful Muslim country that is welcoming check out Albania. Easy to get residency and must Imams are graduates from Saudi or Jordan. I did it from US and it’s not the best but it’s better.
Could you write your experience down brother? Detailed if you can.
@@rvist1 My friend I think you are wrong. But that’s your opinion.
@@rvist1 You do realize it’s 2023 now? Maybe you should update your information.
@@rvist1 thanks already do. I wish you the best.
This is a very accurate, real and down to earth explanation.
You could simply say, "Quran and hadith already said about Hijrah. So I can not add my or someone's opinion here. All you can say, find a suitable Muslim land to live. Bare in mind where ever you go there are difficulties. But you need to do your best to comply with Islam and then Allah will make it easy for us. And Allah knows best.
JazakAllah
Tawakullallahla! He created the earth and will definitely give way to His sincere slaves. Some of us live these little comfortable life in the west and expected the same else where! The noble companions may Allah honour them did Hijrah and Allah grant them authorities and makes them leaders! So, it's clear! ALLAH is in control. May Allah aid all muslims who are striving and struggling in these Kufar and any other oppressed lands. May He ease the path, means for them to leave and may He replace, bless them with peaceful territories.
Ameen
I agree. To many folks make excuses because the comfort level and the fact that not many ppl are practicing. However the overwhelming majority is always better
May Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala make it easier for the Muslims to return to the Muslim majority nations and bring about taqwa, trust, safety and prosperity.
This brother's got stories
Jazaka Allahu Xayran ♥️
The situation in Yemen is also western influence. The same western leaders that plenty of Muslims are paying taxes too! Important to be fair on matters of oppression.
Even if you say it's wajib, realistically speaking it's unrealistic until Muslim nations stop treating fellow Muslims from other lands as less than them,... I.e. immigration limitations, you can't enter without buying a visa, you can't stay more than 30 days on a visa, you can't work without buying a different kind of visa plus getting a company sponsorship, if you stay over the 30 day visa youre put in jail, deported then forbidden to return,...etc...etc
This is no government system in favor of Hijrah, Muslim unity,...etc
A single nation could literally become one of the most powerful nations over night by simply announcing and allowing Muslims from Darul kufar to make Hijrah to their nation, how many soldiers they will gain over night? Millions, how much material gains will they get over night $millions, educated men and women, doctors,....etc...etc they could become a power house and grow their economy massively just from a worldly perspective.
And other nations would quickly follow in their footsteps.
But untill then we're stuck in darulkufar
بارك الله فيك
Jazaakumullaahu khayran
Brother Abu taymiyah come to the gambia in sha Allah
According to the latest released report there's a huge exodus of Muslims from France since that country's among the worst place for Muslims beside India, China and Burma. I have read on Islam Q&A it's obligatory to migrate from the lands of disbelief to Muslim LANDS.I have also watched an episode on Ask Zad saying the something. Mauritania, Morocco, Malaysia, Indonesia and there are many other suitable Muslim lands to migrate to.
Akhi, you should refer to a scholar who has accurate knowledge of where you live because alot of times, there are fatwas from scholars that are inaccurate because they have a rather "shallow" understanding in that regard (with all due respect to Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem from Ask Zad and IslamQA). Sheikh Haitham Al-Haddad for example is of the same opinion as Sheikh Abu Taymiyyah with regards to Hijrah because of the implications it carries. By saying that it is obligatory, every one is then sinful if he doesn't and the Deen was made easy in general (of course there are hardships but in general its easy) and where there is extraordinary difficulty, things are made easy in Islam. The thing is, with some fatwas, scholars have a "shallow" or "theoretical" understanding of things, one of which is bitcoin for example and the fatwas given sound quite silly to someone who somewhat understands how bitcoin works. Sheikh Haitham Al-Haddad for example only gives fatwas for Muslims in the west when he speaks in english because we have abnormal situations as he says and a normal fatwa is not going to work.
@@s.adnansami5106Western scholars are orientalists.
@@ebrahimi44 ehm excuse me?
@@ebrahimi44 it's so ignorant to generalize all western scholars as orientalists and very ironic given how they study under the same scholars as the ones u mentioned and still follow the same methodology but western scholars are still orientalists according to u just because they differed on one issue...
@@s.adnansami5106 Name one scholar
The Muslim world pre 1917 was amazing. It's sad what's happened to the middle East today
You mean when the Ottoman Empire was ruled by a real Caliph Abdulhamid the II?
Heck ye it was
@@rogersmith6813 I'm personally not a fan of the last sultan but he's a actual caliphate and no colonization Is much better than what the middle East finds itself In now. If only they didn't get involved in the European War WW1. And if only the Arabs in the Hijaz weren't stupid enough to believe the British would actually pull their end of the bargain in a deal. Just lots of poor choices in all parties in the caliphate
Every era had their ups and downs. A lot more lands are controlled by Muslims now, even before the Ottomans fell. In 1916, Egypt, Sudan, Yemen, Oman, East Arabia, Indian subcontinent, part of Somalia, and Malaysia were all under British control.
Italy controlled Libya and the other half of Somalia.
France controlled west Africa, Algeria, and Morocco.
The Netherlands controlled Indonesia.
Russia controlled the northern Turkic countries (Kazakhstan, etc.)
Basically the only lands controlled by Muslims were Anatolia (Turkey), Iraq, Sham, Hejaz, and the central Arabian peninsula.
Forgot: Afghanistan was also under Muslim rule
@@abcdef-xh3mk that’s very true, I’ve learned more since I first wrote that comment. Pre 1917 was already the waning years and in fact could be seen as worse than today
Can someone elaborate on the monopolizing of Hajj ? Is it allowed ?
Is commercialisation of our Hajj expecience in any way beneficial ? Are pelgrims worshippers or tourists ??
Prices are cheaper now and Saudi make no money from hajj. Only issue I can think of is cultural issues when explaining hajj to different groups from diff backgrounds. May allah bring Khalid from what happened
@@Zzzzxx-qg6cs the government don’t make profits the Saudi companies do though
@@suleman5965 well of course. They provide a product/service for hujaj. without those services peopled would be here complaining “why does saudi not make it easy for us when it comes to AC food transport etc” sometime the people want to be upset with no valid reason. At the end of the day Saudi is losing money trying to make hajj as effective and well managed as possible, they are not perfect of course. We should make dua that Allah gives them tawfeeq and aids them in doing so. Before this hajj companies were making so much money but no one ever complained about those external companies subhanallah. Saudi made it cheaper for everyone else.
@@Zzzzxx-qg6cs ameen. I mean it’s debatable wether you think prices from companies have gone down but even expats try rent homes due to the amount they can actually make but Yh the country itself for them just an expense but may Allah make it easy for us and those wanting to do hajj or umrah and free us from the commercialisation of the deen insha’Allah
@@suleman5965 There's no commercialisation of the Deen by the government. Hajj and Umrah has been made much easier by the government of SA. If individuals are taking advantage of you then deal with that but please let's refrain from blaming on things we don't know or understand.
I'm not a defender of SA by any stretch of the imagination. I left there ... no I ran from there 6 years ago when MBS came to power and may Allah Guide us all. I know a lot of things about SA but when it comes to the Hajj and Umrah, the government has my respect. They looked after everyone.
I bet when you look into ibn taymiyyah quote he is talking about a Muslim ruler
Regardless about giving fatwa etc, the brother just mentioned his own personal experiences (which I might add is not the experienced of thousands of others who have done the same journeys.). So what? I know brothers who have lived in Egypt/Morroco etc for years with no issues, yes there are some who encountered issues but not everyone. And hijrah isn’t meant to be easy. Did the prophet want to leave his home in Makkah and go to Madinah? Was those that left everything behind overjoyed and found it easy? And yes I agree there are a lot of issues in our lands, but just saying it was down to ‘revolutions’ ya akhi be just. It was the west that destroyed most of our lands. But you don’t want to mention that. If you’re going to go off on emotional tangents atleast speak the haqq
I lived in Egypt benefitted greatly for over a year without any problem I was without paperwork and yes it was a problem but far from being threatened sexually and whatever else nonsense.
He only is mentioning that he can’t give a fatwa on it, and he is stating that the issue isn’t black and white in todays age. Either way, Throughout his entire talk, he still recommended that we make Hijra, and he stated that this is his goal to make Hijra with his family.. And it’s good that he brought these points so that people aren’t naive when they intend to migrate and seek knowledge in the Muslim lands. May Allah guide us and increase us in beneficial knowledge, Ameen
@@EliteLaith123 Ameen!
Can you tell us which Western country told you to rebel against your leaders?
@@truthseeker2095 are you a woman? Egypt is an amazing place that I pray Allah allows me to continue going back to, but its astonishingly high in r*pe cases and violence towards women subhanAllah just the other week there was a 15 yr old girl that killed her assaulter
Alhamdulillah. 50K!!!
Come to Mauritius Respected Ustadh!
Mauritius is not a Muslim country
@@muzza9467 better then Uk still
Assalamou Alaykoum brother/sister, Jazzakoum Lahu khairan for the video first of all.
I just wanted to point out that the thumbnail is barely readable. Perhaps you could change it or take it into account for future videos.
Baraka Lahu feekoum.
Subhana Rabbi al.A'laa. If Oppression is Great to the point death may occur than as directed in Qu'ran Hijrah will be obligatory to a category of people. Hijrah to where is thr issuem
Everyone has a different situation. For some it is not possible, for some it is. If someone has the possibility of moving to a place that has less fitnah and more freedom to practice Islam and be able to sustain oneself and ones family then i dont see how and why one can stay in the place they are at.
Its not the same for everyone. But i really think the west is not a place to expect any good, islamically. Just look at how our youth and misguided. I will never raise my two sons here when they reach school age i will be off. Most likely even before that.
Don’t try to justify staying in Kafir lands making excuses the prophet our prophet says he washes his hands of any Muslim who migrates or lives in kafir lands very scary Hadith
Am confused, am leaving here in the UK, with my wife and daughter , I kind of rely on some of these dayee to benefit from,majority of whom have left the country for dubai, the one abu tayimiya we got said he is gonna sort something out for his family....meaning leaving
who do we turn now to and benefit from? Where do we go?
I’ve been to Qatar, it’s worse than living in the U.K. in terms of the deen.
@@zayn6725 so what are you saying don't move?
@@zayn6725 come on bro!!!
You are in a Muslim country in Qatar
Mosques everywhere call of prayers out loud and all that
Your practice of Islam is down to you after that
nothing to do with the country itself
But Qatar is a great Muslim country to live with your family if you can afford it
May Allah make it easy for you to find a Muslim country suitable for you and your family
Ameen
@@WandererinAqaba thanks
For hijra to the a peaceful Muslim land come to Somaliland its open and very peaceful. Research it.
Any lace in the uk is safer and more peaceful than the muslim lands except for khaleeji nations... And you not getting to live there on a permanent basis
Haaa wallahi. Somaliland is very beautiful and peaceful! Come to Somaliland.
As long as you give me banana for breakfast, i am in.
Swear? I’m British kashmiri would I be accepted? Genuine question I love my somali brothers.
No jobs plus there are a lot of hardships it’s not practical
You don't have to revolt - just acknowledge they are taaghoot. That is enough. That is Jihad of the tongue.❤️☝️
Can you say something about Anwar al-Awlaki?
He was a Kharriji, many of the duat in America refuted him years ago.
@@daywalker0988what made him a khariji
@@daywalker0988 Yea right, many duats "in America". You murji rejects will surely call the sahabas khawarij if they're alive today.
@@daywalker0988 lol many of the duats in America, yea right haha
whats wrong with Jordan or Turkey?
Forgive me for asking this do you your salf write "ustad"
The channel is run by his Imad and Samir not him
@@Kardu3 جزاك الله خيرا
murji madkhali reject.
Our beloved Prophet[PBUH] prohibited rebellion against rulers, 'Unless you see a flagrant disbelief on which you have clear proof from Allah.’” [Narrated by Muslim]
Now the flagrant disbelief here is, the ruler ruling by a Law other than the Shari'ah of Allah. Also, abolishing part or some islamic laws and substituting it kuffar law & values also counts.
theres music in the beginning.
Salam That’s just the intro for TH-cam premiere it’s not apart of the video 🥰
@@Lightmylove oh really thank you sister, learned something new🤗☺️
Dont watch the video then and get off youtube...
@@stadiamak692 bro , calm down
Make the hijra for sins by deleting this youtube app.
Where are these lectures from?
السلام عليكم
Masjid name ⬇️
Alfurqan Education Trust
Post code TW3 2AD
It’s a question and answer
The Sheikh you're talking about probably gave a fatwa according to the evidences and the situation at the time, and as you said Yemen was the best place etc. So you can't knock him for how things turned out. He didn't know what would happen in the future. Also, those that got sent back can't be sinful, because it was out of their control. So what's the issue Sheikh?
Hijrah to turkey is good?
Maybe your friend Dawah Man should listen to this after he gave the public fatwa that making Hijrah is obligatory
Sad that you spoke with emotions instead of speaking with evidences. الله المستعان
Sorry to say, Brother , first of all you are not qualified to give a fatawa. We know that.
People asking you about the Deen of Allah not how you feel, or about your experience. You made it unnecessary long.
Just say, if you are desperate then do hijrah and if you are not , stay here....no worries..I came from Madinah...i got knowledge.....Forgot about what classical Ulamah said about hijrah. We can interpret quran and hadith differently now.... like Yasir Qadi or Omer Sulyman etc...
Don't worry brother the world will be witness for you in the day of judgement InshaAllah. You made us wrong in front of others. Now, many will say, .....see you took too much burden.... You could easily stay here....
May Allah be enough for you and the people like you who give their opinion over Deen of Allah and make difficult other Muslims life by this type of talk.....
L video fr only opinion + egypt no laws from quran best place to go is qatar or saudi if u are an arabic speaker, english works there too, also egypt legit has bans on hijab lol
Nonsense I live in Egypt and there are tons of women in niqab let alone hijab.
Don’t try to justify staying in Kafir lands making excuses the prophet our prophet says he washes his hands of any Muslim who migrates or lives in kafir lands very scary Hadith
There are valid excuses such as the revert one - people born here without means to migrate and many Muslims lands don’t want other Muslims from other nations in their lands
@@Samialexchak thats a lie are you saying your mother land will reject you if go back no they wont but we are use to the luxury life in west back home at least we hear adan and our kids we can control and no lgtb etc so many benefits
@@ahmedsalah5364 if you are a revert born in a European country for example, no Muslim nation will take you without meeting some strict criteria - these Muslim nations won’t want millions of Muslims around the world coming to their countries. Many are racist towards African Muslims for example
No Fatwa needed. Use common sense. Land of fhe Kuffar in todays time is not better then Muslim land. The reality is Hijrah is hard who wants to come out of their comfort zone and self inflict hardship? It takes a strong minded soul who desires Allah more then themselves. Plenty of Muslim land to choose from. Go on Holiday first and then decide which land you want to make Hijrah too. Assalamualaykum
Our elders came here with nothing, we have more then them!!!!! Secondly you've gone against Qur'an and sunnah.... Thirdly most people love the kuffar, even if you have given the fatwa they wouldn't care, due to the love of the kuffar
Not the love of kuffar but the love of good luxury life and dollar mate.
Ha ha these madkhalis like abu taymiah abdulrahman hassan living in the west preaching hijrah but they haven't made hijrah themselves surely you should practice what you preach
Clearly you don’t understand the Mas’alah also ustadh ARH is in Sharjah
modi not a muslim